Material Information |
Title: |
Public Lies and Private Truths Images of Dictatorial Power in La Fiesta del Chivo and El Oto�o del Chivo. |
Physical Description: |
Book |
Language: |
English |
Creator: |
Thompson, Sarah |
Publisher: |
New College of Florida |
Place of Publication: |
Sarasota, Fla. |
Creation Date: |
2011 |
Publication Date: |
2011 |
Subjects |
Subjects / Keywords: |
Latin American Literature Masculinity Dictators |
Genre: |
bibliography ( marcgt ) theses ( marcgt ) government publication (state, provincial, terriorial, dependent) ( marcgt ) born-digital ( sobekcm ) Electronic Thesis or Dissertation |
Notes |
Abstract: |
This thesis is concerned with how a community could allow and even participate in its own subjection by a brutal dictator. I examine the representations of dictatorial power in two Latin American novels: El oto�o del patriarca by Gabriel Garc�a M�rquez and La fiesta del chivo by Mario Vargas Llosa. I present an examination of the creation and dissemination of a public image that the dictator uses to affirm his power and to subject his people. I believe this to be the key mechanism that contributes to the public's belief that the dictator has either a right to rule, or else is so intimidating that the public is paralyzed to overthrow him. I then articulate the manner in which the novels expose the contradictions of the public image in the presentation of the dictator's private truths, which appear in intimate spaces often inhabited only by the dictator and the reader. This exposure of the falsities of the dictator presents a criticism of the dictator and perhaps provides a clue for the public's ability to empower and protect itself from future manifestations of authoritarian figures. |
Statement of Responsibility: |
by Sarah Thompson |
Thesis: |
Thesis (B.A.) -- New College of Florida, 2011 |
Electronic Access: |
RESTRICTED TO NCF STUDENTS, STAFF, FACULTY, AND ON-CAMPUS USE |
Bibliography: |
Includes bibliographical references. |
Source of Description: |
This bibliographic record is available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication. The New College of Florida, as creator of this bibliographic record, has waived all rights to it worldwide under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights, to the extent allowed by law. |
Local: |
Faculty Sponsor: Portugal, Jose Alberto |
Record Information |
Source Institution: |
New College of Florida |
Holding Location: |
New College of Florida |
Rights Management: |
Applicable rights reserved. |
Classification: |
local - S.T. 2011 T4 |
System ID: |
NCFE004461:00001 |
|
Material Information |
Title: |
Public Lies and Private Truths Images of Dictatorial Power in La Fiesta del Chivo and El Oto�o del Chivo. |
Physical Description: |
Book |
Language: |
English |
Creator: |
Thompson, Sarah |
Publisher: |
New College of Florida |
Place of Publication: |
Sarasota, Fla. |
Creation Date: |
2011 |
Publication Date: |
2011 |
Subjects |
Subjects / Keywords: |
Latin American Literature Masculinity Dictators |
Genre: |
bibliography ( marcgt ) theses ( marcgt ) government publication (state, provincial, terriorial, dependent) ( marcgt ) born-digital ( sobekcm ) Electronic Thesis or Dissertation |
Notes |
Abstract: |
This thesis is concerned with how a community could allow and even participate in its own subjection by a brutal dictator. I examine the representations of dictatorial power in two Latin American novels: El oto�o del patriarca by Gabriel Garc�a M�rquez and La fiesta del chivo by Mario Vargas Llosa. I present an examination of the creation and dissemination of a public image that the dictator uses to affirm his power and to subject his people. I believe this to be the key mechanism that contributes to the public's belief that the dictator has either a right to rule, or else is so intimidating that the public is paralyzed to overthrow him. I then articulate the manner in which the novels expose the contradictions of the public image in the presentation of the dictator's private truths, which appear in intimate spaces often inhabited only by the dictator and the reader. This exposure of the falsities of the dictator presents a criticism of the dictator and perhaps provides a clue for the public's ability to empower and protect itself from future manifestations of authoritarian figures. |
Statement of Responsibility: |
by Sarah Thompson |
Thesis: |
Thesis (B.A.) -- New College of Florida, 2011 |
Electronic Access: |
RESTRICTED TO NCF STUDENTS, STAFF, FACULTY, AND ON-CAMPUS USE |
Bibliography: |
Includes bibliographical references. |
Source of Description: |
This bibliographic record is available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication. The New College of Florida, as creator of this bibliographic record, has waived all rights to it worldwide under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights, to the extent allowed by law. |
Local: |
Faculty Sponsor: Portugal, Jose Alberto |
Record Information |
Source Institution: |
New College of Florida |
Holding Location: |
New College of Florida |
Rights Management: |
Applicable rights reserved. |
Classification: |
local - S.T. 2011 T4 |
System ID: |
NCFE004461:00001 |
|
PAGE 1
!"#$%&'$%()'*+,'!-%.*/('/-"/0)1'%2*3()'45',%&/*/4-%*$'!46(-'%+ !"# $%&'("#)&!#*+%,# *+,' &!#-(-. -#)&!#/"(0%"0*" ' #7 )*-*0'&*)(7'/042!)4+ ! *'/0()%) ' )89:;<<=>''<@=',;A;B;?C'?D'08:EC;<;=B +=F'&?GG=H='?D'5G?I;>E ;C'JEI<;EG'D8GD;GG:=C<'?D'<@='I=K8; I=:=C<'D?I'<@='>=HI== #EL@=G?I'?D'*I=I'<@='BJ?CB?IB@;J'?D'M?B='*G9=I'!?I<8HEG ' )EIEB?E MEC8EIO'PQRR
PAGE 2
' ; "#$%&'(%)* /@;B'<@=B;B';B'>=>;LE<=>'':O'<=EL@=IB SSS !E:=GE'-=B=C>;TN'#I;EC')8?I S -?>I;H8=TN'EC>'M8EC'V&E9EGG=I?V' -E:WC'&@EA=B SSS F@?';CBJ;I= >'EC>'=CL?8IEH=>'E'C=EIGO'B=A=C S O=EI'G?CH'JEBB;?C'D?I' $E<;C'*:=I;LEC'G;<=IE<8I=N'L8G<8I=N'@;B'J?G;<;LBU'6;<@?8<'=EL@'?C='?D'O?8 N '<@;B' <@=B;B'F?8G>'C?<'@EA='9==C'J?BB;9G=U ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '
PAGE 3
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
PAGE 4
' ;;; 2'3.#!)4!5)*(#*(1 ,=>;LE<;?CUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUU'; *LXC?FG=>H=:=C8L<;?CUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU 'R /@='!89G;L'%:EH=UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'] /@='!I;AE<='%:EH=UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU U UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU '^ &@EJ<=I'4C=1' /I8_;GG?ZB'!89G;L'%:EH='EC>'!I;AE<='/I8<@BUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU RQ /@='!89G;L'%:EH='?D'/I8_;GG?UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'R` 3?>'EC>'/I8_;GG?UUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'R` ' /@='2=BB;EC;L'2O<@UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'R] ' )8J=IB<;<;?C'EC>'<@=')8J=ICE<8IEG'#?>OUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUU'R[ ' /@='3ET=UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'PR ' &G=ECG;C=BBUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'Pa 2EBL8G;C;'2EL@;B:?UUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'P] ' (:EBL8GE<;?CUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'P] ' )=Y8EG',?:;CE<;?C'?D'6?:=CUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUU'`Q .;?G= CL=1'/?I<8I=N'3=C?L;>='EC>'*BBEBB;CE<;?CUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUU'`a /@='!I;AE<='%:EH='?D'/I8_;GG?UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'`^ &@EJ<=I'/F?1' 2O<@?G?H;T;CH'EC>',;BEDD;I:;CH'<@='!E1')8J=IB<;<;?CB'EC>'<@=')8J=ICE<8IEG UUUUUUU']^
PAGE 5
' ;A 2EBL8G;C;'2EL@;B:?UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUU']^ ' /@='!EOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUU'][' ' 2EG=')=Y8EG;',?:;CE<;?C'?D'6?:=CUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU U'][' .;?G=CL=1'/?I<8I=N'3=C?L;>=N'EC>'*BBEBB;CE <;?CUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU U'b` /@='!I;AE<='%:EH='?D'<@='!E';C' %C<;:E<=' )JEL=BUUU'b[ &?CLG8B;?CUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'^] #;9G;?HIEJ@OUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU'^[ ! ! !
PAGE 6
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
PAGE 7
' R 6*(7)$8&(%)* /@='>;L=D;C=>';C' "#):;3:2@89A#2<#B2569@#/21:3:;= 'EB'V?C='J=IB?C'F@?' @EB'B?G='EC>'L?:JG=<='J?G;<;LEG'J?F=IU'%C'EC<;K8;;L'EB'EC'=:=IH=CLO':=EB8I='9O'B';C' B?:='?<@=I'DEB@;?CUUU;C'<@=':?>=IC'F?IG>N':ECO'>;L=IB'?D':EBB':?A=:=C'@EA='I8G=>'<@I?8H@'<@=;I'L?C'E':?C?J?GO'?D'J?F=IV' eRa]fU'*C?<@=I'J ?G;<;LEG'BL;=CL='>;L<;?CEIO'EGB?'C?<=B'<@E<'>;L'@EA='G;<'D?I'@8:EC'I;H@');LF;>=' J@=C?:=C?C'FI;<<=C'E9?8<'=Y<=C B;A=GO';C'F?IXB'?D'G;<=IE<8I='?I'?<@=IF;B='>=J;L<=>' ;C'AEI;?8B'EI<'D?I:BN'<@=I='@EB'9==C'E'JEI<;L8GEI'DEBL;CE<;?C'F;<@'<@='I=JI=B=C;L';C'$E<;C'*:=I;LE';C' <@=' ;8C5:112 ?D'<@=' C;C=<==C<@ S L=C<8IOU'/@=B='D;H8I=B'LGE;:=>'J?F=I';C'<@='AEL88:'LI=E<=>'9O'<@=' ;C>=J=C>=CL='FEIB N 'B?:=<;:=B'=C>?F;CH'<@=:B=GA=B'F;<@'E9B?G8<='E8<@?I;'J?F=I'<@I?8H@'E'L?:9;CE<;?C'?D':;G;' J=I B?CEG'L@EI;B:E1'V<@='LE8>;GG?'g@E>h'E'JI?J=CB;':EHC;DO'@;B' J=IB?CEG;'EGG'G;:;';<;?C'g:E>=h'@;:'9=G;=A=';C'<@='C=L=BB;=C'=YL=J<;?CE G'L@EIEL<=I'?D'@;B'?FC'J=IB?CV'e&@=AEG;=I'`ifU''/@=' ;8C5:112D= 'J?F=I'FEB'?D<=C'JI=>;LE<=>'?C'@;B'E9;G;U'-?9=I'3?CTdG=T'(L@=AEIIcE'C?<=B'<@E<'<@=B='D?I:B'?D'
PAGE 8
' P >;L=IB'VAEIO'G;<G =BB'?D'<@='J?G;<;LEG'>?L'F;=G>'EG:?B<'E9B?G8<='J?F=IV'eRfU'/@;B' ;8C5:112 ':?>=G'?D' >;L'<@=';:J?I;A;>8EG'G=E>=IN'L?C<;C8=>' ?DD'EC>'?C'<@I?8H@?8<'B=A=IEG'L?8C'R[[QB'@?F=A=IN':EIX=>'E'L@ECH=';C' >;L=A=G?J=>';C')?8<@' *:=I;LEU',;A=IH;CH'DI?:'<@='?G>'D?I:B'?D' ;8C5:112 '>?:;CE<;?CN':?>=IC'>;L'C?<'9O'EC';C>;A;>8EG'F;<@':;G;?B?'`bfU'6@;G='>;LB' B?:=<;:=B'=:=IH=>'?8<'?D'<@;B'I8G=N'V<@='EJJ=EIECL='?D'E'B;L=C<;EG;B :'B?:=<;:=B'@;>'<@='=DD=L<;A='L?C'?A=I'<@?B=';C'H?A=IC:=C?B?'aPfU' !=I@EJB';C'EC'E<<=:J<''8C>=IB'<@;B'C=F';CLEICE<;?C'?D'>;L8I;CH'<@;B'<;:='J=I;?>'eR[bQ S R[ [QfN';CLG8>;CH' 3E9I;=G'3EILcE'2dIK8=T'EC>'2EI;?'.EIHEB'$G?BEN'L@?B=''I= S =YE:;C='<@='?G>' ;<;?CB'?D'>;L'F@E<';B'C?F'XC?FC'EB'<@=' >;L=D;C=>'9O'B''9=H;C'F;<@',?:;CH?'5E8B<;C?')EIE:;=C=I=>'<@='D;IB<'F?IX'<@E<'D;=D;C;<;?CN'EB';<'JI?A;>=B'EC' ;C>;I=L<'LI;<;L;B:'?D'<@='>;L='-?BEB'<@I?8H@';?'j8;I?HEU'3=IEG>'2EI<;C N'
PAGE 9
' ` @?F=A=IN';C'@;B 'ECEGOB;B'?D'$E<;C'*:=I;LEC'G;<=IEIO'B N 'C?<=B'<@E<'2;H8=G'kCH=G' *B<8I;EBZB' &1#=6429#796=:56@36 'e (>6#/96=:56@3 f'eR[abf'FEB'V<@='D;IB<'I=EG'>;L'<@='>;LG=>'J?F=IU'/@='>;L IEFC';C'<@=B='F?IXB'F;<@' G;<''@;B':?<;AE<;?CB'?I'F=EXC=BB=BU'%C'B?:='LEB=BN'B8L@'EB';C'*B<8I;EBZ B C?A=GN'<@='>;L;L=C<';B'B;:JGO'E'VI= S L?CB ;L8#IC6932 'e (>6#H:M#HC9C5K@#H69C@5L#+8=#):65 f'eR[]Pf'F=I='J89G;B@=>' ED<=I'<@='LGEBB;L'C?A=G'?D'*B<8I;EBN'L?C <; C8;CH'<@='>;LU'/ @='H=CI=' I=L=;A=>'I=GE<;A=GO'G;<'<@= 'R[^QBU'*<'<@;B'<;:=N' <@='>;L';C'<@='J89G;LE<;?C'?D'<@I=='B=:;CEG'F?IXB1' &1# 96;C9=2#561#IN3252# e-=EB?CB'?D')='=YJGE;CB'<@E<' <@=B='C?A=GB'?D'<@='R[^QB'>;DD =I=>'DI?:' <@=;I'JI=>= L=BB?IBU'/@ =O':EIX=>'E''>=D;C;CH'EBJ=L<'?D'<@=' J?B<:?>=IC '$E<;C'*:=I;LEC'>;L=I'A;=FB' <@='L@EIEL<=I'DI?:'E'D;IB<'J=IB?C'AEC;L'D==G;CH BU'/@='>;L;:=CB;?CEG' D;H8I=N'BO:9?G;L'?D'<@='=A;GB'?D'=YL=BB;A='J?F=IN'98<'E'L?:JG;LE<=>'@8:EC'9=;CHV' e`b[fU' %C'?<@=I'F?I>BN'<@=B='C?A=GB'F=I='8C;K8=';C'JGEL;CH'<@='>;L
PAGE 10
' a @8:EC;T=>'JI?;CH''-?9 =I'3?CTdG=T'(L@=AEIIcEN'<@='>;L;L?:'?D'E'G;:;6#J6@6981#:@#>:= #!8GA9:@3> f'eR[i[fN'EC>'<@=':?B<'I=L=C<' EC>'L8II=C;L:?2 'e (>6#$68=3#2<#3>6#J283 f'ePQQQf' L?C<;C8='<@;B';<;?CU'6@;G=' (>6#J6@6981#:@#>:=#!8GA9:@3> '>?=B'C?<'B;L=D;C;<;?CN'EB';<'>=J;LO'G?B<'J?G;<;LEG'J?F=IN ;<'B@EI=B'C8:=I?8B'B;:;GEI;<;=B';C';O'?D');:?C'#?Gc AEIU /@='EG<=I=>'D?L8B'DI?:'<@='>;L;L'ECY;=>=C':EC'>=:?CB;B<;CL<;?C':E>='9=;L'<@='>;L'EIH8='<@E<'<@;B' >;B<;CL<;?C'EGG?F=>'D?I'E'>=:OB<;D;LE<;?C'?D'<@='>;L=J;L<;CH'@;B'9?>;GO'E;G:=C;L''@8:EC'@8:;G;E<;?CB'B8L@' EB'>=D=LE<;CH'@;:B=GDU'0;B'9?>OZB'F=EXC=BB=B'@;H@G;H@<'<@='L?::?CEG;<;=B'9='<@='L?::?C';C>;A;>8EGB'?D'<@='I=H;:='?A=I' F@?:'<@='>;LU'*B'-?BEGcE'&?IC=_? S !EII;=H?'C ?<=B';C'EC'=BBEO' ?C'F@E<'B@='LEGGB'<@='V>=:O<@;D;LE<;?CV'?D'3EILcE'2dIK8=TZB'!E;L;GO'DE;G;CHB'EGB?'B=IA=''@8:;G;E<='@;:N'>=G=H;<;:;T;CH'@;B'E8<@?I;;:=CB;?C'ELK8;I=B'E'>=G=H;<;:;T;CH'D8CL<;?CN';CAEG;>E<;CH'E8<@? I;6#J6@6981#:@#>:=# !8GA9:@3> h'I=L?HC;T=B'<@E<'<@='HI=E<=B<'@8:;G;E<;?C'?D'EGG'D?I'E':EC';B''@EA='@;B' 9?>O'DE;G'@;:V'ebPfU'
PAGE 11
' ] %<';B'<@;B'>= S :OB<;DO;CH'JI?L=BB';C'<@='I=JI=B=C;L'@;B' J?F=I'F@;L@'D?I:B'<@='9EB;B'?D':O'<@=B;BU'%C'<@;B'<@=B;B'%'F;GG'JI=B=C<'E'LG?B='I=E>;CH' ?D';L6# "C3CI@#2<#3>6#/839:89;> f'EC>'2EI;?'.EIHEB'$G?BEZB' !8#<:6=38#561# ;>:?2 'e (>6#$68=3#2<# 3>6#J283 fN'F@;L@'9?<@'JI?A;>='EC'ELL?8C<'?D'<@='>?FCDEGG'EC>'>=:;B='?D';L;L';C' G;X='?I' B8J=ICE<8IEG'E9;G;<;=B'EC>'Pf'<@I?8H@' @;B '=:JG?O:=C<'?D';C<;:;>E<;?C';C'<@='D?I:'?D' @8:;G;E<;?C'?I'A;?G=CL= ''@;B'B89_=L=J;L<;?C B'?D'=EL@ '>;L=I:;C=B'@;B'J89G;L'?C='D?I'<@='I=E>=I' 9O'8C:EBX;CH';<'D?I';;L=I''B89_=L<'<@=:B=GA=B''@;B'I8G=U'%'E:';C<=I=B<=>';C'@?F' E' L?::8C;'L?:=' '9=G;=A=';C'@;B';:EH=N'E<'<;:=B'B?'B'<@8B'DEL;G;=D;C='<@='>;L' J=IB?CEG;;L';C'<@='C?A=GB N 'EB'L?::?CGO'XC?FC'9O' <@='J?J8GE<;?C'?A=I' F@;L@'<@='>;L;L
PAGE 12
' b LEB='L?8G>'9=B<'9='>=D;C=>'<@I?8H@'EC'E:EGHE:E<;?C'?D',EA;>'$?LXF??>'EC>'2EY' 6=9=IZB'>=D;C;<;?CBU'%<';B' 9?<@'V<@='JI?9E9;G;'9O'?<@=IBV'EC>'V<@='LEJEL;6#*2@;:=6#-Q<295#):;3:2@89A#2<#'2;:212MA N'aRP S aR`f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n?I'E':EG='B8JI=:EL;B<';>=?G?HOV'e &@EC<'EC>'&IEBX= 'Y;fU'*G <@?8H@ 'B?:=' BL@?GEIBN'B8L@'EB'*GDI=>?'2;IEC>o N ':=I2 N'LGE;:;CH';<';B' ?D<=C'=:JG?O=>''>=C;H IE<='EC>'B< =I=?';<'9='<@=':?B<' ELL8IE<='I=JI=B=C;L>;<;?C''<@='>;LE<;?C'<@I?8H@'@8:;G;E<;?C'?I' =:EBL8GE<;?CN'<@='>;L;I=L=I''L?C;=B'<@I?8H@'IEJ=N'=U'4A=IEGGN'<@='>;L'?A=I<@I?F'@;:'
PAGE 13
' ^ EI='?'DI;H@<=C=>''EL <'?C'<@=;I'>=B;I=B'9=LE8B='?D'E' D=EI' ?D' I= EG;;LG;X='?I'B8J=ICE<8IEG'B=D;C=B'L@EI;B:E'EB'V<@= 'L=I;A;>8EG' J=IB?CEG;;CEIO':=C'EC>''EB' =C>?F=>'F;<@'B8J=ICE<8IEGN'B8J=I@8:ECN'?I'E<'G=EB<'BJ=L;D;LEGGO'=YL=J<;?CEG'J?F=IB' ?I'K8EG;<;=Bp'e6=9=I'`]ifU'/@=B='L@EIEL<=I;B<;LB'EI='=;<@=I '''<@=' J?J8GE<;?C'?A=I'F@;L@'<@='>;L;BL8IB;A=':=ECB'B8L@'EB'J?G;<;LEG' JI?JEHEC>Eq'?I'=GB='<@=O'EI='L@EIEL<=I;B<;LB'E<''<@='>;L=:?CB'?C' ;;L;L'<@I?8H@'@;B'L@EIEL<=I;TE<;?C'EB'B8J=I@8:EC'?I'3?>G;X=U'0=';B' B8J=I;?I''?<@=I'@8:EC'9=;C HB'9=LE8B='@='@EB'BJ=L;EG'J?F=IB'<@E<'?<@=IB'>?'C?<' J?BB=BBN'B8L@'EB'<@='>;A;C= S G;X='E9;G;'<;:='?I'<@=':?I='9EB;L'E9;G;'VI;H@ V 'J=IB?CB'F@?:'@= 'I8G=BU' %C'<@='3EILcE'2dIK8=T'<=Y:=38 'B<=I=?G;X=';L:=38# K8EG;<;=B'EI='B?'@ OJ=I9 ?G;T=>'<@=O'EJJ=EI'B8J=ICE<8IEGN'B8L@'EB'@;B' 9=G;=A=>' E9;G; I=CU
PAGE 14
' i 29#!:7%;'(#!60'/# %C'L?C;L'B=LI=>=C'DI?:'J89G;L'A;=FN'EC>'<@E<'JI=B=C<'E' <@I=E<''<@='>;L;BL?A=I=>U'/@=B='L@EIEL<=I;B<;LB' EI='EG:?B<'=YLG8B;A=GO'I=GE<=>''9?>;GO'DE;G;CHBN'98<':EO';CLG8>='?<@=I'DEL;L;I=L;L<'<@='J?J8GEI':O<@BU'%C'<@;B'FEON'<@='C?A=G'=YEL=I9E<=B'<@=' DEGB=@??>'?D'<@=';:EH='?D'J?F=I'<@I?8H@';;L;DD=I=C<' I=JI=B=C;L'ELL?8C<'?D'<@='@;B;L;L'F@E<'.EIHEB'$G?BE'@;:B=GD'>=BLI;9=B' ;C'EC';C<=IA;=F'EB'<@='V=G'<=:E'eI=EG;B<';L ?=B' C?<'EGG?F'<@='I=E>=I''B'EC>'>;B<8I9;CH'I=EG;=J;L<=>U'%C'L?C'LEIC;AEG=BK8='CE<8I='?D'<@='3EILcE' 2dIK8=T'C?A=G'EGG?FB'D?I'E':?I='@8:?I?8B'EC>'BE<;I;LEG'=YE:;CE<;?C'?D'J?F=I'EC>' >;L< E=I''A;=F';;:?2 N'%'@EA='L@?B=C''>;BL8BB'<@='GE<=I'C?A=G'D;IB=I;CH' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' r *G 'U
PAGE 15
' [ FEB'9EB=>'?C'EC'E<<=:J<''EGG?F'D? I'=EB;=I'I=E>=I'L?:JI=@=CB;?CU'%'9=G;=A='<@E<' -EDE=G'/I8_;GG?':EX=B'D?I'E'B=G'?D'<@=';L;BL8BB';C'<@;B'<@=B;BU'+E:=GON'@=';B'E'>;L'?C'<@='JI?_=L<;?C'?D'E' JEI<;L8GEI';:EH='<@E<';B'L=C'?C'@ ;B'EJJ=EIECL='EC>'B=Y8EG;;L=GN'%'D?8C>';<'JI8>=C<''JI=B=C<'<@=' :?I='B<=I=?;L>;<;?CN'3EILcE'2dIK8=TZB'8C8B8EG' C?A=G;B<;L'B;DD;L8G<'I=E>'< @E<'I=K8;I=B'HI=E<=I' =YJGECE<;?CU'%'D?8C>';<'B=CB;9G=''9=H;C'<@='<@=B;B'F;<@'E'C?A=G'<@E<'FEB'B;:JG=I'D?I' <@='I=E>=I''D?GG?FU' ' ' '
PAGE 16
' RQ 59'<(#7!=>!278?%..)@1!:83.%&!60'/#!'*$!:7%;'(#!278(9 R"=#12@M#8=#(9CS:112#1:?65P#>6#8@5#I8@A#23>69#)2I:@:;8@=#T 2C15#G6#;2@56I@65#32#3>:=# 8T8?:@M#32#1:6#32#3>6I=61?6=#8@5#56;6:?6#6?69A2@6# 61=6P#2<#>8?:@M#32#G6#3T2#762716#:@#2@6 W #8#7CG1:;#1:6#8@5#8#79:?836#39C3>#3>83#;2C15#@23# G6#6Q796==65R XXX ,89M8=#!12=8#<92I# !8#<:6=38#561#;>:?2 # %C'E'I=L=C<'>;BL8BB;?C'L?C>8L<=>'ED<=I' .EIHEB'$G?BE'I=L=;A=> '<@='+?9=G'!I;T=' D?I'G;<=IE<8I=N'+=FBF==X'I=J?I<=I')=<@'&?G<=I'6EGGB'K8?<=B' <@='E8<@?I 1's%'<@;CX'$E<;C' *:=I;LEC'G;<=IE<8I='>=EGB'F;<@'J?F=I'EC>'J?G;<;LBN'EC>'%'F?8G>'BEO'<@;B';B' ;C=A;'8B'<@;B'E;<;?C'?D'E8<@?I;' 9I8;DD;L8G<'D?I'E'$E<;C'*:=I;LEC'FI;<=I''EA?;>'J?G;<;LB' EC>'<@=B='JI?9G=:B'<@E<'EI='GEIH=I'<@EC'J?G;<;LBUV'/@=';C=BLEJE9GO';C<=I' CE<8I='?D'$E<;C'* :=I;LEC'J?G;<;LB'EC>'G;<=IE<8I='<@E<'.EIHEB'$G?BE'>=BLI;9=B';B' I=JI=B=C<=>';C'?C='?D'@;B':?B<'GE8>=>'C?A=GB'I=HEI>;CH'J?F=I'EC>'>;L:?2 'e (>6#$68=3#2<#3>6#J283 fU' /@='C?A=G'EI<;L8GE<=B'<@I==':E;C'CEIIE<;A=' G;C=B '<@E<'=EL@'JI;A;G=H= ?C='JEI<;L8GEI'L@EIEL<=I'?I'B=<'?D'L@EIEL<=IBU'/@='CEIIE<;A=' G;C=B';CLG8>='"IEC;EZB'B'<@=;I'JG?<''EBBEBB;CE<='/I8 ;GG?N'EC>' E'LG?B='A;B;?C'?D'<@='>;L '?C'<@='D;H8I='?D'/I8_;GG?'@;:B=GD'EC>' @;B';CC=I'L;ILG=U' /@='D;IB<'CEIIE<;A='G;C='D?L8B=B'?C'"IEC;E'&E9IEGU'/@;B'=C<;I=GO'D;L<;?CEG' L@EIEL<=I'I=<8ICB''<@=',?:;C;LEC'-=J89G;LN'@=I'CE<;A='@?:=GEC>N'`]'O=EIB'ED<=I' @=I'=BLEJ='EC>'E'G? CH'J=I;?>'?D'B=GD S ;:J?B=>'=Y;G=U'/@='I=<8IC'?D'<@='E>8G<'"IEC;E'' L?CDI?C<'@=I'B;LX'DE<@=I'eE'A;L<;:'?D'E'B'A;IH;C N 'JI?A;>=B'E'<=:J?IEG'9I;>H='9= S
PAGE 17
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e5E<@=IB'HEA='/I8_;GG?'<@=;I'>E8H@<=IBN';?L8:=C<=>UUU'%<'FEB'E'FEO'D?I' <@=:''=YJI=BB'<@=;I'E>:;IE<;?CVf'e*GE:=>EN'PfU' %C'<@='B=L?C>'CEIIE<;A='G;C=N'D?8I'L?CBJ;IEIEFC'DI?:'@;BN'FE;<';C'EC'E 8'<@=;I'8C;K8='I?G=B';C'<@='JG?<'EHE;CB<' /I8_;GG?U'*GG'D?8I'?D'<@='L?CBJ;IE='<@='I=E>=I'ELL=BB''<@='>;L';C<=ICEG;TE<;?C'?D' <@=' J89G;L';:EH= EB'F=GG'EB'< @E<'?D '<@?B='EI?8C>'<@=:U 4CL='EFEX=C=>''<@='>=J<@B'?D' <@='>;LN'EC>'GEBL;A;?8BC=BB'@?F=A=IN'<@=O'C?'G?CH=I'B' D?I' <@=;I'?FC'B89_=L<;?C 'EC>'I=;B<;L'I8G=IU' |