ERROR LOADING HTML FROM SOURCE (http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu//design/skins/UFDC/html/header_item.html)

Progressive Bullying

Permanent Link: http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu/NCFE004294/00001

Material Information

Title: Progressive Bullying How Unilateral Actions Could Help International Fisheries
Physical Description: Book
Language: English
Creator: Mewhirter, Jack
Publisher: New College of Florida
Place of Publication: Sarasota, Fla.
Creation Date: 2010
Publication Date: 2010

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords: Fisheries
Regional Fisheries Management Organizations
International
Unilateralism
Genre: bibliography   ( marcgt )
theses   ( marcgt )
government publication (state, provincial, terriorial, dependent)   ( marcgt )
born-digital   ( sobekcm )
Electronic Thesis or Dissertation

Notes

Abstract: As the governing bodies of international fisheries, Regional Fisheries Management Organizations have largely failed to protect key stocks. This failure has led to unsustainable harvests that threaten the future of several key fisheries. Although many studies have focused on alleviating their inadequacy through institutional or policy changes, they have often ignored the underlying problem: cooperation among member states. Through an examination of the key variables for cooperation as applied to international fisheries, this thesis demonstrates that attaining legitimate cooperation between member states may not be possible through multilateral governance. Because multilateral governance may not be possible, unilateral actions by key states could offer the only hope for successful management. Under specific conditions, powerful states can achieve sustainability through unilateral action. By using their leverage in the fishery, these states can promote compliance from those who may not prefer regulation. Although this dynamic may not sound equitable, it may be the only hope for preserving fish stocks.
Statement of Responsibility: by Jack Mewhirter
Thesis: Thesis (B.A.) -- New College of Florida, 2010
Electronic Access: RESTRICTED TO NCF STUDENTS, STAFF, FACULTY, AND ON-CAMPUS USE
Bibliography: Includes bibliographical references.
Source of Description: This bibliographic record is available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication. The New College of Florida, as creator of this bibliographic record, has waived all rights to it worldwide under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights, to the extent allowed by law.
Local: Faculty Sponsor: Alcock, Frank

Record Information

Source Institution: New College of Florida
Holding Location: New College of Florida
Rights Management: Applicable rights reserved.
Classification: local - S.T. 2010 M5
System ID: NCFE004294:00001

Permanent Link: http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu/NCFE004294/00001

Material Information

Title: Progressive Bullying How Unilateral Actions Could Help International Fisheries
Physical Description: Book
Language: English
Creator: Mewhirter, Jack
Publisher: New College of Florida
Place of Publication: Sarasota, Fla.
Creation Date: 2010
Publication Date: 2010

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords: Fisheries
Regional Fisheries Management Organizations
International
Unilateralism
Genre: bibliography   ( marcgt )
theses   ( marcgt )
government publication (state, provincial, terriorial, dependent)   ( marcgt )
born-digital   ( sobekcm )
Electronic Thesis or Dissertation

Notes

Abstract: As the governing bodies of international fisheries, Regional Fisheries Management Organizations have largely failed to protect key stocks. This failure has led to unsustainable harvests that threaten the future of several key fisheries. Although many studies have focused on alleviating their inadequacy through institutional or policy changes, they have often ignored the underlying problem: cooperation among member states. Through an examination of the key variables for cooperation as applied to international fisheries, this thesis demonstrates that attaining legitimate cooperation between member states may not be possible through multilateral governance. Because multilateral governance may not be possible, unilateral actions by key states could offer the only hope for successful management. Under specific conditions, powerful states can achieve sustainability through unilateral action. By using their leverage in the fishery, these states can promote compliance from those who may not prefer regulation. Although this dynamic may not sound equitable, it may be the only hope for preserving fish stocks.
Statement of Responsibility: by Jack Mewhirter
Thesis: Thesis (B.A.) -- New College of Florida, 2010
Electronic Access: RESTRICTED TO NCF STUDENTS, STAFF, FACULTY, AND ON-CAMPUS USE
Bibliography: Includes bibliographical references.
Source of Description: This bibliographic record is available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication. The New College of Florida, as creator of this bibliographic record, has waived all rights to it worldwide under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights, to the extent allowed by law.
Local: Faculty Sponsor: Alcock, Frank

Record Information

Source Institution: New College of Florida
Holding Location: New College of Florida
Rights Management: Applicable rights reserved.
Classification: local - S.T. 2010 M5
System ID: NCFE004294:00001


This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

! ! "#$%#&''()&!*+,,-(.%/! 0$1!+.(,23,!243($.'! !"#$%& 0&," !(.3&#.23($.2,!5('0&#(&' ! *! 6247!8&10(#3&# ! 2!39:;<; ! '=>?<@@:A!@B!@9:!C
PAGE 2

ii !"!#$%&#'( ) 39<;!@9:;<;!<;!A:A><:!0HKK:L@RQ!J9B!
PAGE 3

iii %$*('+,"!-"."(&/ ) 39HEP!RB=!@B!HII! BF!?R!FL<:EA;! J9B ;=MMBL@:A!?:!@9LB=K9B=@!@9<;!HLH!0::E!HE!H?HYR!?R!;
PAGE 4

iv $'(&"(&/ ) 247.$1,&C%&8&.3'ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ O< <
PAGE 5

v %$0'(1./ ) ) ) ) *53 WWW !*I=:FI:!c=B@H (++ WWW (II:KHIQ!+EL:MBL@:AQ!+EL:K=IH@:A 8'WWW 8HXI:!-<:IA .25$ WWW .BL@9J:;@!2@IHE@I:!4H@G9 +.4,$' WWW +E<@:A!.H@
PAGE 6

vi ,#/&)'2) 2#-30" /)%(!)&%4,"/ ) ) 5R!'@ H@:ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZOO_T ! 3H>I:;/ [OU! ($34!8:?>:L;!H;!4B?MI I:;Z ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZO_S ^OS! ,:D:LHK:!)HLI:;ZZZZZZZ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ O__ ^O\!$@9:L!)HLI:;ZZZZZZZOO ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZO`T

PAGE 7

vii "#$%#&''()&!*+,,-(.%/! 0$1!+.(,23,!243($.'! !"#$%& 0&," !(.3&#.23($.2,! 5('0&#(&' 6HGP!8:J9BA <:; !BF!I:!9HLD:;@; !@9H@ !@9L:H@:E!@9:!F=@=L:!BF!;:D:LHI !P:R!F<;9:L<:;O!! 2I@ 9B=K9! ?HER!;@=A<:;!9HD:!FBG=;:A!BE!HII:DI:?/!GBBM:LH@:L!;@H@:;O!!39LB=K9!HE!:X H?I:;!FBL!GBBM:LH@:@J::E!?:?>:L!;@H@:;!?HR !EB@! >:! MB;;<>I:!@9LB=K9!?=I@:!MB;;<>I:Q!=ER!P:R! ;@H@:;!GB=IA !BFF:L!@9:!BEIR!9BM:!FBL!;=GG:;;F=I!?HEHK:?:E@O!! + EA:L!;M:GI:Q!<@!?HR!>:!@9:! BEIR! 9BM:!FBL!ML:;:LD
PAGE 8

1 $56789:);< ) #=8:>?@A8B>= ) & 'HI!GH@G9!BF!F<;9!;@BGP;!::E !:L!BF!F<;9HI!GH@G9!L:ML:;:E@;!H!A:GII:!9HLD:;@;!@9H@!@9L:H@:E!@9:!F=@= L:!BF!P:R!;@BGP;O! U !39:! KIB>HI!GH@G9!BF!:D?)$68A59E)>F)'A96=BA)/79AB9E)'AA@::B=G)H:B=AB76DDI)B=)JBG5)/96E)% :96E ) & Food and Agricultural Organization. The State of World F isheries and Aquaculture (Rome 2009 ): 14 & ) 1 Food and Agricultural Organization. The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture (Rome 2009) : 14

PAGE 9

2 ?=;@!>:!::E!H>I:!@B!I:!MBIR !?:?>:L!;@H@:;O!! 3B!AH@:Q!?HER!GL<@I:!MBI:L!;@H@:!GBBM:LH@::E!H>I:!@B!L:HG9!?=@=HIIR! >:E:F:L!;@H@:;!@9:?;:ID:;! HEA!@9:!GL:A<>I:!MBI:L!;@H@:;!?=;@!HKL::!BE!J9H@!MBI:!:!HAAL:;;:A!BL!F::I!H;! @9B=K9!@9:R!9HD:!EB@9I:!MBIR!?:?>:L!;@H@:;!<;!=EI:L;!L:ML:;:E@!KL:H@IR!A
PAGE 10

3 @9:!#58$!;R;@:?!>=@!BE:!@9H@!<;!:!ABB?:A!@B!FHI:! MLHG@:!FB=EA! B=@!+EI:Q!<@! ?HR!>:!@9:!BEIR!JHR!@B!HII:DI:?!:X9<><@:A!I:!9HLD:;@;!R!H! L:KI:?O 2 Bodansky, Daniel. "What's so Bad about Unilateral Actio n to P rotect the Environment?" European Journal of International Law 11.2 (2000) : 339

PAGE 11

4 49HM@:L!]!:XMIBL:;! @9:!HG@R!@9:!(E@:LEH@I=:F::E!:EHG@:A Q HEA! @9: !L:;=I@; O!!'::E!I:;!@9H@!?HR!9HD:!HFF:G@:A!L:;=I@;O!!(@!HI;B!HEHIRY:;!@9:!
PAGE 12

5 $5678 9:)K<) ) #=89:=68B>=6D)09D68B>=E)6=?)$>>79:68B>=)&59>:I ) #:KB@9! LI: O!!39<;!?:HE;!@ 9 H@!;@H@:;!GB?M:@:!BD:L!H!FB@9!LI:Q!;@H@:;!HL:!FBLG:A!@B!JBLP!@BK:@9:L!:@J::E!I:! MBII:!GBEA<@I:!GBEA<@:L!BF!;@H@:;!:L!BF!;@H@:;!:L!BF!HG@BL;!L<;:Q!GBEKL=:EGR! >:@J::E!;@H@:! :GB?:;!@9:L!BF!HG@BL;!L<;:;Q!@9:!G9HEG:;!BF! 3 Barkin, J. S. "Time Horizons and Multilateral Enforcement in International Cooperation." International Studies Quarterly (2004) : 336

PAGE 13

6 ;HEG@:L!BF!HG@BL;!HFF:G@;!GBBM:LH@R! GB?MI R! A:GL:H;I:!HI@:LEH@:! L:HG9:A!@9LB=K9!GBBM:LH@:GB?:;Q!@9:!?BL:!I:L!BF!HG@BL;!f:G@
PAGE 14

7 39:!FR!$R:!<;!@ 9:!;9HABJ!BF!@9:!F=@ =L:O!39:!;9HABJ!BF! @9:!F=@=L: !GHE !>:!;::E!H;!@9:!F:HL!BF!J9H@!H!;@H@: !?HR!IB;:!BL!@9:!GBE;:N=:EG:;!@9H@!H! ;@H@:!?HR!;=FF:L!FLB?!L:F=;:GB?:!?BL:!F:HLF=I!BF!@9:!F=@=L:Q!@9:R!HL:!?BL:!I

:L!BF!HG@BL; Q !HEA!L:;B=LG:!@RM:!HFF:G@;!GBBM:LH@I:!:
PAGE 15

8 39<;!MLB>I:?!<;!:XHG:L>H@:A!>R!@9:!FHG@!@9H@!GB??BE!MBBI!L:;B=LG:;!HL: !EBE W :XGI=AH>I:Q!?:HER!EB@!HA9:L:L;! BF!! HG@BL;!L<;:Q!;B!AB !@9:!G9HEG: ; !BF!A:F:G@I:?;Q!*HLPR!H!9:K:?BE!?HR!>:!@9:!BEIR!JHR!@B!MLB?B@:!?:HE:9:L!BF!HG@BL;O!19:E!@9:!E=?>:L!BF!HG@BL;!:GB?:!I:;;!GI:HL Q !J9I:?H@:L!BF!HG@BL;O!!39<;! AREH?:;@! L:ML:;:E@:A!>R! #kKEDHIA=L 0H EE:;;BE h;!A:D:IBM?:E@!BF!H!g;=M:LKH?:j!H;!L:IH@:A!@B! :L;!BF!HG@BL; !L<;:Q!;B!AB!@9:!G9HEG:;!BF!EBE W GBBM:LH@R!@9:!IHGP!B F!HGGB=E@H>:!>=@!J9
PAGE 16

9 >R!IHLK:!E=?>:L;Oj U\ !!*:GH=;:!#58$;!HL:!;B!I HLK:Q!L:GBKEI:!MBI:L!;@H@:!A:F:G@:L!;@H@:;!<;!A:E:F<@!FLB?!@9:!MBII:?!<;! :XHG:L>H@:A!H;!;B?:!;@H@:;!MIHG:!I<@@I:!DHI=:!BE!@9:!HG@=HI!;@H@=;!BF!@9:!;@BGPO!!39:! A<@ !;@H@:! GBBM:LH@:!9I:O!!*:GH=;:!:!?BD:A!HEA!K: HL!GHE!>:! G9HEK:AQ!:E:F
PAGE 17

10 ?BD:!BE @B!@9:!E:X@Q!E: D:L!>:R!MBII:! GH@G9!I:!M=@!BE! F<;9!;@BGP;O!! *:GH=;:!@9:;:!If:G@! @B!?=G9!A:>H@:O !!2;!I:!@B!HGG:M@!BL!HA9:L:!@B! MBIH;:A!BE!9<;@BLR Q!GBBM:LH@;@HGI:!FBL! 4BE@LHG@I:!L=I:;!MLBD;@HGI: !FBL!?=I@:!HGG:M@:A!>R!HII!;@H@:;Q!@9B;:!J9B!MIHG:!@9:!I:H;@!DHI=:!BE!@9:!F=@=L:!BF!@9:! ;@BGP!d@9B;:!J<@9!@9:!9HLKHI:O !39:;:!H;R??:@L<:;!KHLKH
PAGE 18

11 :XMIB<@H@B=@!:ED:!?BL:!J:!=EGBBM:LH@:!B=@J:R!MB@:E@R!IB;;:;O!(E!@:L?;!BF!IB;@!L:D:E=:! FLB?!F=@=L:!KH:!@L=:!@9H@!;B?:!;@H@:;! F:HL!L:M=@H@:!MLBF<@H>I:O!!'@H@:;!J<@9!gBM:E!L:K<;@L<:;j! GBII:G@!F::;!@B! HIIBJ!D:;;:I;!@B!L:K<;@:L! =EA:L!@9::L!BF!9:@:LBK:E:B=;!HG@BL;!KLHE@;!I<@@I:!9BM:! 16 The High Seas Task Force (Governments of Australia, Canada, Chile, Namibia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom, World Wildlife Fund, World Conservation Un ion, and the Earth Ins titute at Columbia University. Closing the Net: Stopping Illegal Fishing on the High Seas (2006) : 36

PAGE 19

12 FBL!I:K<@:@J::E!;@H@:;O !2;!R! @9:;:!FHG@BL;Q!#58$;!?HR!>:!=EH>I:!@B!BD:LGB?: !@9:!B>;@HGI:;!BF!?:?>:L!;@H@:! GBBM:LH@=@!FLB? !=I@:L:!?BL:!MHIH@H>I:!@B!@9:!I:!MBI I:Q !<@!GB=IA!;R!;@L::E!MH;;:AQ!=E:9HD:!@9:!F:LK !A:?BE;@LH@:;!9BJ!=EI:?;!BF!?=I@H@@I:!FBL!:!HII:DR! @JB!?:HE;/!GBE@LHG@
PAGE 20

13 ;@H@:;!>R !?HPR!=;:GB?:!:XM:E;: L!BF!HG@BL;! L<;:Q!<@!<;!BF@:E!?BL:!:FF:G@:L!;@H@:;O!!(E!@9:!GH;:!BF!#58$;Q!@9:!P:R!;@H@:!?R!G=@@HGP!AB?:;@:! :FF:!H>I:!@B!L:A=G:!@B@HI!GH@G9!@B! 20 Steinberg, R. H. "Power and Cooperation in International Environmental Law." Inter national Economic Law (UCLA School of Law 2007) : 488 21 Steinberg, 488 22 Steinberg 528

PAGE 21

14 ;=;@HI:!IR!;=>;@HE@R!>HEE:! L:A=G:A! I:!9HLD:;@;O !! 5HL!FBL! :!:XMHEA:A!I<;9:A!>:@J::E!@9:!@JB!P:R!;@H@:;!I:!BL!@9H@!=EI:!BM@I:Q!@9:!BEIR!9BM:!FBL!;=;@HI:!MLHG@:!@9:!HG@
PAGE 22

15 ) $56789:)L<) ) &59)!9M9D>7N9=8)>F)#=89:=68B> =6D)2BE59:B9E).6=6G9N9=8 ) 4()+&.()&/539)&/3:/;&<'()&/)3&-/&7)1.3-+5:&7*==*+&.*&355&2)1/*+/>?&.()&0-/()1=3+&3@1))/A& BC.&D()+&.()&/539)&3,,/;&'()+&D(3.&-/&0*C+,&-+&.()&7*==*+&/)3&-/&7*==*+&21*2)1.:8?&()& 1-@(.5:&*BE)7./>&/3:-+@;&&-/&3B/*5C.)5:&=:&*D+8? HI & W 0=KB!%LB@<=;Q!U^\\ & & (E!9<;!JBLP! J31)&$-B)1C=& d5L::AB?!BF!@9:!':H;eQ!f=L<;@!HEA!M9:! BM:E!@B!HIIQ!<@!JH;!HE!=@:!KLHE@:A!f=L<;A:!MLB@:G@:A!FLB?!GHEEBE!;@LB=EAHL<:;!BE!IHEA!GB=IA!>:!L< K9@F=IIR!ALHJEQ!@9:!GBEG:M@!BF!BJE
PAGE 23

16 L:ML:;:E@:AO!!5HL!FLB?!>:::E!HE!:FF:G@:GB?:! MLB >I:?H@B=EAI:;;O!!$D:L!@:!FB=EAO!!$L
PAGE 24

17 @=LEI:!L:;B=LG:!I:! L:;B=L G:!@9H@!L:N=DR!%LB@<=; !9H;!L: ?HI:?H@BA<:A!< E!%HLL:@! 0HLA:RBEA!@9:!IHEAh;!GHLLR::E:F<@!@9:!9:LA;?HEQ!J9:!; ML:HA!H?BEK;@!@9:! B@9:L! 9:LA;?:EO!7EBJI:?!<;!A:;GL<>:A!H;!@9:!gLHG:!FBL!F<;9 Oj 19
PAGE 25

18 39:!F=EG@:!A<;?<;;:A!A=:!@B!@9:! GB?MHL<;BE!BF!@9:!U^Ta!F<;9:Q! HKKL:KH@:!A:?HEA!FBL!F<;9!;@BGP;!9H;!L<;:E!HEA!I:O!!39<;!gGIB;::E!F=:I:A!>R! @9:!L:DBI=@=@:A!@B!KIB>HII:!@:G9EBIBKRO!! %IB>HI:!;::E!H;!@9:!gJHI!HI:K:GB?:;!I:;;!BF!H!>HLL<:LO!! *:GH=;:!@9:!L:?BDHI!BF!@9<;!>HLL<:L!AL::E!G=@!B=@!BF!@9:!?HLP:@O!!5=L@9:L?BL:Q!@9:!:RBEA!@LHA<@R!F<;9:L?:E! BF!H!;M:G=R:LO! 29 Held, McGrew, Goldblatt, and Perraton. "Rethinking Globalization." The Global Transformations Reader: An Introducti on to the Globalization Debate Oxford: Black well Publishing Ltd. (2000) : 67

PAGE 26

19 39:!:FF:G@;!BF!@:G9EBIBKHI!BD:LF<;9BHLA!FL::Y::E!A:D:IBM:AQ!MLB?B@H<@:A!I:!@HLK:@:A! >R!F<;9:L?:EO!!(E!@=LEQ!@9:;:!?HLP:@;!?HR!>:!FIBBA:A!J<@9!F<;9O!!(F!;BQ!?HLP:@!ML:!GH=K9@!@B!K:E:LH@:!:N=HI!L:D:E=:O!!39<;!GRGI:! J:GB?:; !II:jO!! 0 <;@BL=@!GB?:!H;!H!L:;=I@ BF!g:N=
PAGE 27

20 I;HI!F<;9:L<:;!;9B=IA!>:! ;::E!H;!BD:LGHM<@HIF)2BE59:B9E ) Grinning Planet. "Pretty Mermaids are Always Over Fishing for Compliments: The Causes and Effects of Overfishing." 7 May. 2005. < http://www.grinningp lanet.com/2005/06 07/fishing cycle.gif > (accessed 4 Jan. 2010) 39:!
PAGE 28

21 JBLIAh;!F<;9:L<:;!GB=IA! >:!:X9H=;@:A!HEA!@9H@!L:;B=LG:!?HEHK:?:E@! JH; !E:G:;;HLR!@B! ML:;:LD:!@9:!JBLIA h ;!F<;9!;@BGP;O!!39:!BEIR!JHR!@B!KBD:LE!@9:!BG:HE;! JH; !@B!KLHE@!@9:! f=L<;A:RBEA!<@;!GBH;@I!@9:!HI!;@BGP;O!!(E! @9:! Ua_T;Q!@9:!JBLIA!F:KHE!J<@E:;;R! Ua_^O \S !!*R!STT^Q!KIB>HI!F<;9!:XMBL@;!LB;:!@B!H!L:MBL@:A!+'C!`[Oa!>:L;!HL:! BEIR!HMMLBX
PAGE 29

22 d@9B;:!BD:L!UT?!HI!F<;9I:O #=E8B8@8B>=6D)$56=G9E ) 2@!@9:!:EA!BF!11((Q!?HER!EH@:KHE!@B!:X@:EA!@9:!@:LL<@BLH;:A!BE !@9:!A:; :KHE!:X@:EAH@:!BD:L!@9:!I:KHI<@R! BF!@9:;:!GIHI:!A:KHE!=;H;:Q!@B!=ER!GBH;@HI!;@H@:; O \_ (E!@:GH?:!HE! I<;9:A!EBL?!J9 (accessed 8 Apr. 2010 ) 36 Alcock, 252 37 Steinberg, 497

PAGE 30

23 Ua`SO!!!39: !2KL::?:E@!KLHE@:A!;@H@:;!H!STT W ?B=EAHL<:; O \` 2I @9B=K9 !@9:!+.4,$'!(((!HKL::?:E@!FBG=;:A!GB?MHLH@I:!MLHG@I:O!!39<;!G9HEK:!JH;!;: :E!B=@ !;@BGP!;@H@=;!J<@9HI!GB??BE;!HEA!GL:H@:!H! ;R;@:?!?BL:!;=;G:M@<>I:! @B!L:K=IH@HI! GB??BE;Q!@9:!2KL::?:E@!;9B=IA!9HD:!HDBI:?;!FBL:;::E!>R!0HLA.

PAGE 31

24 2I@9B=K9!@9:!2KL::?:E@!;@L:;;:A!@9:!IRO!!*:GH=;:!GBH;@HI!;@H@:;!EB!IBEK:L!FHG:A!GB?M:@<@=:GH ?:! IHLK:L!HEA!A:D:IBM:A!?BL :!:FF:E:F
PAGE 32

25 ;=;@HI:!MLHG@HI! g LHG:!FBL!F<;9 j !B=K9@!F<;9I:!MLHG@f:G@:A!@B!;=>;@HE@:L! ;@H@:;!A:D:IBM:A!H! ;@LBEK:L Q!?BL:!GB9:;:@J::E!;@H@:;! F<;9
PAGE 33

26 LHEK:!BF!;@LHAAI=@R!#58$;!?=;@!fB:L;!GHEEB@!>IBGP! E:J!:E@LHE@; Q! EBL!GHE!@9:R!A<;GL:L;Q!#58$;!?=;@!HGGB=E@!FBL! @9:!G=LL:E@!;@BGP!I:D:I;!HEA!G=LL:E@!F<;9e!@9:!L:HI!:L;!HEA!E:J!?:?>:L;O ]\ !'=G9!?:H;=L:;!HL:!A:;R!HII!;@H@:;!F<;9I:! A:D:IBM?:E@O!2@!<;;=:!<;!@9H@!@9:!F=EG@R!@9:!:L;O!(F!;@H@:;!L:F=;:!@B!GB?MIR!@9:E!@9:!#58$! ;@L=G@=L:!<;!I:@J::E! G=LL:E@!?:?>:L;!HEA!E:J!?:?>:L;O!(F!#58$;!GL:H@:!H!;=;@HI:!324!FBL!H!K
PAGE 34

27 HL:HQ!@9:!:L!;@H@:!:L;O!(E!BLA:L!@B!?H:L!;@H@:;!?HR!H@@:?M@!@B! LH<;:!@9:!324!BL!;B@9!GH;:;Q!@9:!+.5'2!;@L=G@=L:!BFF:L;! I<@@I:!;BI=@I:!FBL!L:K=IH@eQ!?HP:;!FIHK!;@H@:;!L:;MBE;<>I:!FBL!H;;=LR! D:;;:I;!F<;9R!#58$;!;R!@9::L;! @B!HG@!HGGBLA:E:F<@;!FLB?!EB@! fBB=EA!>R!@9:!+.5'2Q!@9:R!AB!EB@!:EFBLG:!#58$!MBI
PAGE 35

28 I:!FBL!@9:!?HEHK:?:E@!BF!F<;9!;@BGP;!BE! @9:!9BA<:;Q!@9:!2KL::?:E@;! BFF:L:A!F:J!;@L=G@=LHI!K=::E!HG@B@9!?:?>:L;!HEA!KBD:LEBA<:;Q! L:;MBE;<>I:!FBL!@9:!F=EG@I:!MBIIR!;=;@HI:!MBII:?H@BA<:;!9H;!BF@:E!I:A!@B! =E;=;@HI:!9HLD:;@;!@9H@!A:KLHA:!F<;9!;@BGP;O!! 2;!:L!;@H@:;!HL:!G9HLK:A!J<@9!FBL?I:!@B!BD:L:XMIB<@H@:!:EHG@:AQ!;@H@:;!?=;@!;::P!@B!?HP:!;=;@HI:!MBI:L!;@H@:O!!3B!:EHG@!;=G9!MBI:!HLKHI:O!!39:R!?=;@!HI; B!>:! :@J::E!;@H@:;!<;!MB;;<>I:O!!*:GH=;:!#58$;!HL:!:E@
PAGE 36

29 ?HEAH@:;Q!MBII:!@B!HII!?:?>:L;!HL:!L:N=:L;Q!<@!<;!=EI:GB?:;!ML:DHI:E@Q!@9:!#58$!J:L!;@H@:!L:G::L;Q!EH?:IR!B IA:L!?:?>:L;O!2 ;!324;!HL:! BF @:E!A:IR!9<;@BL:L; !HL:!BF@:E! HI<:EH@:AO ]^ !! *:GH=;: !MHL@R!HII!HG@BL;!<;!ML:F:LL:AQ!?HER!#58$;!9HD:!::E!
PAGE 37

30 @9H@Q!::E!GBE;<;@:E@IR!MIHK=:A!>R!BD:LF<;9R!E BEGB?MI:L;!E::A;!HL:!EB@!?:@Q!@9HE!EBEGB?MIH@!@9:!GBBM:LH@f:G@:L!@B!HDB:L!?HR!EB@!>:!A:@L: f:G@!@B!@9:f:G@:E:F<@;!BF!@9:!MBI:RBEA! @9::f:G@=@!=@:GB?:;!@9:L! BF!;9HL:;!@9H@!GHE!>:!A<;M:E;:AO!3 9:L:FBL:Q! :L!;@H@:;!HL:!HIL:HAR!GBEFR!@9::L;!FLB?!MHL@I:!N=B@HQ!@9:R!J
PAGE 38

31 #58$!GBE;@LHR!GH@G9!I:L;!HG@!H;!gFL::! L=@! L:HM:E:F<@;e!J9:GB?:;! ML:DHI:E@!HEA!E:KH@:;!#58$!GBE;@LH:L;!?HR!EB!IBEK:L!F::I!@9H@! <@!<;!IRO!!(E!:<@9:L!GH;:Q! #58$!I:K<@HIHEG:!@9H@!#58$;! 9HD:!@B!?H<@:GH=;:!@9:R!A:L;O!3B!AH@:Q!?B;@! #58$!HIIBGH@H;:A!BE!;@BGP!;@H@=;Q!9<;@BLI<;9!9BJ!#58$;!;9B=IA!AB!;BO!! (E;@:HAQ !@9:!+.5'2!HIIBJ;!@9:!?:?>:L;!BF! @9:!
PAGE 39

32 9HD:!HAB M@:A!MBI:L;O!!#58$!L:II:GH=;:!<@!L:JHLA; !@9B;:!J9B!9HD:!:XMIB<@:A!@9:!HL:H!@9:! ?B;@!HEA!GL:H@:;!H!;@H@=;!N=B!BF!:!A:E<:A!?:?>:L;9:!H>I:!@B!fBI:O!!3B!HGGB??BAH@:!E:J!?:?>:L;! J<@9B=@!LH<;:L;!BL!HIIBGH@::E!HMMI<:A!:L;!HL:!HGG:M@:AQ!@9:=@:A!HEA!J:!G9HEK:AO [] !!#58$;!BF@:E!f=;@R!GIH:L;!9HD:! >BLE !@9:!ML:D
PAGE 40

33 HEA!;9B=IA!EB@!9HD:!@B!;9HL:!@9:R!G9HL@:L!?:?>:L;!d:L;!:L;!BF@:E!gA<;GL:!<@!I:KHI!BL!MLHG@:L;Q!#58$;!HL:!MLB?B@B=EA !@B!HER!2KL::?:E@!@B!J9I:!324;Q!@9:!E:J!:E@LHE@;!JR!#5 8$!IHJO [_ !4BED:L;:IRQ!:!GB?MLB?<;I:!MBI:! H@@H
PAGE 41

34 $ 56789:)P<) ) &59)#=89:=68B>=6D)$>NNBEEB>=)F>:)859)$>=E9:M68B>=)>F)%8D6=8BA)&@=6E ) ) +EA:L!@9:!+.5'2!HEA!@9:!+.4,$'!(((!2KL::?:E@;Q!#58$;!9HD:!>:GB?:!@9:! B=EAHL<:;Q! <@!<;!I:KHIIR!:;@H>I<;9:A!@9H@!;@H@:;!JBLP!@BK:@9:L!=EA:L!HE!#58$!@B!A<;@L<>=@:!;@BGP;! H?BEK!;@H@:;!J<@9!gL:HI!I:!?HEE:LO!(E!HE!:FFBL@!@B! ;@=AR!#58$! M:LF BL?HEG:Q!@9<;!G9HM@:L!JI=:FIR!@9:!?B;@!:L!BF!?:?>:L;Q!@9:!DHI=:!BF!<@;!F<;9:L<:; Q !HEA!@9:!;:L;!J9I:! A:D:IBM?:E@O!! C:;M<@:!; @HEAI=:F
PAGE 42

35 2@IHE@:!I<;9:A!H@!H!4BEF:L:EG:!BF!"I:E:L;!d@9:!+E<@:A!'@H@:;Q!4HEHAHQ!6HMHEQ!%9HEHQ! *LHY:L;Q! ?HPI:!FBL!?HEHK:! L:KHLA:A!H;!@9:!JH@:L;!>:@J::E!_T r1 !HEA!ST r!1 O! !39:I:!FBL!@9:!?HEHK:?: E@!BF! HE!HLLHR!BF!@=EH!HEA!@=EH W II=:FHGBL:Q!R:IIBJF (accessed 8 Feb. 2010) 59 ICCAT. "Introduction" 60 International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas. "Organization." < http://www.iccat.int/en/organization.htm > (accessed 10 Feb. 201 0)

PAGE 43

36 (4423!GHE!BEIR!F=EG@:L; O!!39<;! MLBD<;:L!;@H@: Q!:HG9!;@H@:!L:ML:;:E@H;:A!BE!H! @JB W @9HGBL:!HEA!2@IHE@I=:FHGBL:!HEA!;B=@9:LE!>I=:F:!@HP:E!:L;Q!@9:!;@H@=;!BF!@9:!;@BGP!>:?<;;I:! 61 International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas. Basic Texts: 5th Revision ( Madrid 2007) : 5 62 ICCAT. Basic Texts, 14 63 International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas. Report of the Independent Review International Co mmission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas By G.D. Hurry, H. Ha yashi, and J.J. Maguire. (2008) 64 ICCAT. "Organization"

PAGE 44

37 GBE;R!@9 :!4B??<;;:L!BF!HG@BL; !HEA! @9:! 9:@:LBK:E:<@R!BF!@9: !?:?>:L;Q!@9:!HGG:M@HEG:!BF!HIIBGH@I:!MBII:! GH@G9O!!(4423!@L<:;!@B!?=;@!>HIHE G:!H!MLBF=;R!@9:!4B??<;;R!@9:!;G<:E@GB ??<@@::;Q!@:E!;M:G<:;!KLB=M;!d>HGBL:Q!>I=:FI=:FI<;9:A!>R!@9:!'4#'!<;!A:M:EA:E@!BE!L:;:HLG9!ABE:!>R!@9:! ;G<:E@<;@;!BF!(4423!?:?>:L!;@H@:;O!!39<;!HMMLBHG9Q!PEBJE!H;!@9:!gEH@:R!@9:!'4#'O!! 65 ICCAT. Report of the Independent Review International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas 18 66 ICCAT. Report o f the Independent Review International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas 37 67 Willock, 22

PAGE 45

38 & K!!L'& 3+, &F5C)0-+&'C+3 & *I=:FI=:FIR!;I:!@B!BD:L:XMIB<@H@I:!FBL!@9:!L:K=IH@I=:F:L!;@H@:;O!! '=>;:N=:E@IRQ!(4423;!?HEHK:?: E@!BF!@9<;!;@BGP!9H;!>::E!<@;!KL:H@:;@!FHI:!HIIBGH@I=:FI=:F:!;::E!H;!H!LH@R!@9:!JBLIA h ;!F<;9HI
PAGE 46

39 @:G9EBIBKR!HIIBJ:A!F< ;9H@:A!@9LB=K9B=@!@9:!Ua^T;!HEA!Ua_T;O!!C=LI<;9:A!H!?I=:F:!;=;M:EA:A!H;! ;BBE!H;!MB;;<>I:O!!5BL!@9:!FI=:FI:!I:D:I;Q! 1:;@:LE!>I=:F::E!H>I:!@B!F=IIR!L:GBD:L!FLB?!I=:F
PAGE 47

40 ) 2#-30")PC;<) 097>:89?)$ 68A59E)>F)+ Q 4 2&)$ >N76:9?)8>)&%$E ) International Commission on the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas Report of the Standing Committee on Research and Stati stics ( Madrid 2009 ) : 134. (@!JH;!EB@!=E@;@HE@L::AR!HE!H;@BE<;9 R![Ts!>:@J::E!UaaS!HE A!Uaa[Q >L::A
PAGE 48

41 ;@BGP;!JB=IA!A:GIR!HE!:;@:!EB?I=:FI=:F:L O!!39:!'J:A<;9!KBD:LE?:E@! HI;B!L:GB??:EA:A !2MM:EAI=:F::!HGGB?MHE<:A!>R!H!* I=:F:!H=@9BLR!@9:!:XMBL@
PAGE 49

42 MBL@O _\ !!39:!* 3 'C"!;B=K9@!@B!:L;! F<;9< EK!::@@:L! =EA:L;@HEAR!=EA:L;@HEA:L;Q!(4423!GB=IA!A:@:L?:! :EGB=LHK:A!@B!fBI=:FR!EBE W 4"4;!=@I=:FBA<:;!HIHEG:!BF!@9:!4B??<;;R!GL:H@:L;9=@:L;O!!5BIIBJ:L;!@B!@9:!(4423!GBED:E@:GB?:!?:?>:L; O *R !STT`Q!@9:L:!J:L:!H!@B@HI!BF!]`!?:?>:L;!HEA! 73 De Stefano, V., and P. G. M. Van Der Heijden. "Bluefin Tuna Fishing and Ranching: A Difficult Management Problem." NEW MEDIT 6.2 (2007): 62 74 Eilperin, Juliet "Global Conference Rejects Bans on Trade in Bluefin Tuna, Polar Bear." Washington Post. 19 Mar. 2010. . ( accessed 10 Apr. 2010 )

PAGE 50

43 @9L::!GBBM:LH@:L;O _[ !!39:!;=LK:!:L;9R!@9:!STT\! N)7*==)+,3.-*+&*+&!1-.)1-3&0*1&L..3-+-+@&.()&O.3.C/&*0&!**2)13.-+@& P*+ Q !*+.137.-+@&631.:>&R+.-.:&*1&M-/(-+@&R+.-.:&-+&K!!L' Q!J9:L;!HEA!MLB?B@:L;O _^ (4423;!L:;MBE;:!@B!@9:!gE:J!?:?>:L!A:@J::E!:FF:G@::E!FBLG:A!@B!F:K:!9HLD:;@:A!;=;@HIRQ!(4423!?=;@!G9BB;:!J9:@9:L!@B! ::E!H! g A<;@=L>:L;!J<@9B=@!L:A=GI=:F:L;9:!:;@H>I<;9:A !FBL! 75 International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas. "Contracting Parties" (accessed 13 Jan. 2010 ) 76 ICCAT. Report of the Independent Review International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas, 31 77 Willock, 26

PAGE 51

44 &H;@:LE!2@IHE@RH!dUQSTT?@eQ! 8BLBG GB !dUQT[]?@eQ!3=LP:R!daU`?@eQ!@9:!+E<@:A!'@H@:;! d`[`?@eQ!4LBH@R!@9:!GBE;<;@:E@IR!9I=:FIR!;@H@:;!J<@9!gBM:E!L:K<;@L<:; O j!!39:!:XMBL@;!>R!D:;;:I;!L:K<;@:L:A!=EA:L!gFIHK;!BF! GBED:E<:EG:j!>:GH?:!;B!@LB=>IHE;!BE! >I=:F<@:L;! @B!@9:!(4423!GBED:E@R!IHGPj!HEA!gJ9<@:j!I<;@!MLBKLH?O!!(E<@:I:A!@9:?!H;!g>IHGPj! d. 79 The High Seas Task For ce 79

PAGE 52

45 dD:;;:I;!FBIIBJI<;9:A!IHGPj!D:;;:I;!HGG:;;!@B!@9:IHGP!D:;;:I; O j!!39:;:!I<;@;! ;B=K9@!@B!?HP:!@9:!GBEA<@I:!H;:A!;@LH@:KR!9HD:! GB?M:II:A!H!;= >;@HE@:L !BF!F<;9R!4"4;!9HD: !L:?HR!@9:!?:?>:L!;@H@:;!@9:?;:ID:;O!2;!HE! (E@:LEH@:FBL:!<@!<;!HIIBJ:A! @B!F<;9!L:HP!(4423!L:K=IH@B@9!H
PAGE 53

46 HII!>BH@;!BD:L!ST!?:@:L;!R!?HP::E!H>I:!@B!A:@:G@!H! IHGP!B F!GB?MII:A !F<;9:L<:;!?HEHK:L;!@B!P::M!@LHGP!BF!:D:LR!D:;;:IO! 19I=:FI:!BE:;O!!39:R!9HD:!L:M:H@:AIR!L:F=;:A!@B!H;I:!-<:IA!d8 'e !@B!F<@!@9:::E!=E@ I=:FI:!HA:!@9:!H@ W ;:H!@LHE;;9I=:FI=:F
PAGE 54

47 GB=IA!>:!IHEA:AO!!5=L@9:L?BL:Q!@9:!@LHE;MHL:EGR!BF!GH@G9:;!>R!@9:!I=:FR!@9:!MLBM:L!H=@9BL<@<:;!HEA!I=:FR!8BEHGB!HEA!>HGP:A!>R !@9: !+'!HEA!&+Q!@9:!2KL::?:E@!JB=IA! 9HD:!>HEE:A!HII!I=:F:LH@R!@9:!&+!@B!J:HP:E!@9:!L:;@LR!6HMHE!HEA!?HER!A:D:IBMHEA!J:L:!EB@!:D:E!H>I:!@B!KHHE!L:N=I=:F:IBJO!! 2#-30")PCK<)$68A5)&:9=?E)>F)"6E89:=)%8D6=8BA)6=?).9?B89::6=96=)4D@9FB=)&@=6C ) 84 ICCAT Report for Biennial Period, 2006 07, 138 85 Stokstad, E. "Trade Trumps Science for Marine Species at International Meeting." Science (2010)

PAGE 55

48 Intern ational Commission on the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas. Report of the Standing Committee on Research and Statistics ( Madrid 2009 ) 130. & K!!L';&P*1.(&L.53+.-7&OD*1,0-/( & 'I=:F:@J::E!@LHA<@B=EAHL<:;!HEA!9;O!! 39B=K9 !@9:R!9HD:!H!I
PAGE 56

49 9H;:A!F<;9:L<:;Q! @9:!.BL@9!2@IHE@I:!MBI:!H>I:!@B!>LHGP!@B!HE!BM@B@9!f=D:E:IBJe!HEA!;:X=HIIR!?H@=L:!;@BGP;O `` !!39<;! FB@9! E=L;:L<:;!HEA!IHLK:L!;@BGP;O!!39:!UaaU! 4BED:E@R! J9:L!BF!F<;9!M:L!IHEA (accessed 14 Feb. 2010 ) 87 International Commission on the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas. Report of the Standing Committee on Research and Statist ics (Madrid 2009) : 112 88 International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas. Report for Biennial Period, 1990 91 PART I. (Madrid 1991) : 191

PAGE 57

50 GB?M :II:A!@B!L:A=G:!BD:LHII!F<;9R! U[s!BF!Ua``!I:D:I;O!!2@!@9<;!MB=@! @9:!Uaa\!HEA!Uaa[!F<;9R!'MH:!;9HL:A!H?BEK!4"4;O!! 39:! Uaa^!?::@:!KLHA=HIIR!L:A=G:A! @B!MLB?B@:! ;@BGP!L:GBD:LR/!!39:!4B??<;;:! ;::E!H;!FH:!EB@:A!@9H@! @9:!324 !<;!D:LR!;R!@9:!'4#'!BF!L:A=GR!BD:L![TsO!! 39B=K9!H!FH R!(4423Q!@9:!Uaaa!'4#'!;@BGP! H;;:;;?:E@!A:?BE;@LH@:A!@9H@!;@BGP;!J:L:!;@
PAGE 58

51 ;JBLAF<;9!JB=IA!A:GI=R!A<;GHLA::E!A:@L:!A<;GHLA:A!:;@B J:A!]aO`[s!BF!GH@G9!@B!@9:!&4! J<@9!`Ts!BF!@9H@!KB:!A<;@L<>=@:A!;BI:IR!@B!@9:!+E<@:A! '@H@:;!d`Tse!HEA!4HEHAH!dSTseO!!39:!R!@9:!HAB;Q!):E:Y=:IHQ!49HKBQ! 92 International Commi ssion for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas. Recommendation by ICCAT t o Establish a Rebuilding Program for North Atlantic Swordfish. ( Madrid 2000 ) : 1 93 ICCAT. Recommendation by ICCAT To Establish a Rebuilding Program for North Atlantic Swordfish 1

PAGE 59

52 @9:! +7!dBD:L;:H;!@:LL<@BL<:;eQ!5LHEG:!d'@O!"<:LL:!:@!8R!FHG@BL;!B=@;R!@9:!MH;;R!@9:!g%:KHE!ML:;;=;R!;: D:E!@BM!G9:F;!>:HE!4L=<;:;Q!4:I:>L<@R!4L=<;:;Q! "LBAR !0B@:I!%LB=M Q HEA!STT!HAA<@R!@9:!:EA!BF!@9:!R:HLO!!!1<@9!M=>IHE!@9:!;O a[ !!2F @:L!;B?:!A:I<>:LH@:!M=II:A!J<@9 (accessed 5 Mar. 2010.) 96 United States. Cong. House. H. CON. RES. 344: To Express the Sense of the Congress Regarding North Atlantic Swordfi sh and Other Highly Migratory Species of Fish. 105 Cong., 2 sess., 4

PAGE 60

53 GH@G9O!39:;:!HG@:KHE!:XM:LI:!c=B@H!d( 3c e !;R;@:?! HF@:L!@9:!R!D:RBEA! (4423!;@HEAHLA;! >R !HIIBJ ::E!9<;@BLR!(4423Q!+E<@:A!'@H@:; Q !HEA!'MH< E!9HD:!K:E:LH@:A! ;::E!L:A=G:A!@B!U\Q_\T@!BF!J9:IBJO!! 19:!GBE; (accessed 6 Mar. 2010 )

PAGE 61

54 ?HE:!HMMII:!@B!B@9:L! ?HEHK:?:E@!;G9:?:;O!! ) 2#-30")PCL<)&>86D)(>:85)%8D6=8BA)/R>:?FBE5)4B>N6EE)6= ?),6=?B=GE ) National Marine Fisheries Service "FishWatch North Atlantic Swordfish.". Web. (accessed 15 Feb. 2010 )

PAGE 62

55 $56789:)S<) ) &59)#=?B6=)'A96=)&@=6)$>NNBEEB>= & +EI<@;!;:K=E!@B!E:KH@<@:KHE!@B!I<;9:A!= EA:L!2L@=AK:@O!! 39:!($34! ABG@L
PAGE 63

56 JH;!F I=:FI:! A:D:IBM?:E@Oj! aa 39:!GB?MB;<@:L;O!(F!HE !HMMI:L!BF!@9:!52$!>=@!<;!H!+.! ?:?>:LQ!@9:R! HL:!H>I:!@B!KH:L;9BAR!@9H@! L:ML:;:E@;!H!DHL<:@R!BF!R !H!@JB W @ 9:I<:D:;!H!MBI:!A:@L (accessed 16 Mar. 2010 )

PAGE 64

57 ;=>?<@!H!GB?MIH?<;;:L;9I:L;!BF!@9<;!>BAR!9HD:!FH:L ;!?HR!9HD:!9R!IHGP!BF!?:?>:L;9:L; Q!J9< E:AQ!?HR!9HD:!H!;I:![OU!I<;@;!HII!?:?>:L;!BF! @9:!($34!J<@9!@9:N7DB6=A9)%G:99N9=8)/BG=68>:B9E ) Indian Ocean Tuna Commission. Report of the IOTC Performance Review Panel (2009), 16 102 Willock, 34 103 Willock, 7

PAGE 65

58 39:!4B??<;;I<;9:A!H@!@9:!5I<;9BAR Q!<@!9H;!EB!L:HI!MBJ:L!B@9:L!@9HE!@9:!MBJ:L!@9H@!@9:!4 B??<;;R!H!':GL:@HLR!HEA!;=>;I:! FBL!R!@9:! 4 B??<;;:@J::E!?:?>:L;Q! L:@HR!JBLP::E! L:IH@R!L:G:E@!>
PAGE 66

59 R:IIBJFI=:FI<;9!HER!:FF:G@H@:AO!! J3+3@)=)+. &L221*37( & 39:! ($34!?HEHK:?:E@!HMMLBHG9 !MLB?B@:; !gBM@I:! A:D:IBM?:E@j!>R!ILBHA!?HEHK:?:E@!MLBG:A=L:;!@9H@!LHL:IR!@HLK:@!;M:GR!:;@H>I<;9I<;9I<;9IHGP!HEA!J9<@:!I<;@;Oj (E!HE!H@@:?M@!@B!KH@9:L!AH@H!HEA!KHLE:L!;B?:!;:?>IHEG:!BF! GBE@LBI!BD:L!@9:R!#:;BI=@R!#:;BI=@?<@! EB?H;<;!dEB?R!;M:G<:;!>R!K:HL!J9:L:H;! GH@G9!HEA!:FFBL@!AH@H!<;!@9:!EB?B@9!;:@;!BF! AH@H Q!@9:!'G<:E@B@9!;:@;Q!@9:!4B??<@@::!9BM:A !@B!>:@@:L! 108 Indian Ocean Tuna Commission. Collection of Resolutions and Recommendations by the Indian Ocean Tuna Commission ( 2009 ) : 123

PAGE 67

60 =EA:L;@HEA!;@BGP!I:D:I;!d@9<;!<;!?HR!@9:!GH@G9!M:L!=E<@! :FFBL@!AH@HeO!! 5=L@9:L?BL:Q!>R!=EA:L;@HEAR!4"4;Q!@9:!($34! 9BM:A!@B!A:@:L?I<;9::E!H>I:!@B!GBII:G@!HGG=LH@:!AH@H O!!39<;!I::E A:?BE;@LH@:A!>R!@9:!?<;L:MBL@R!4"4;!H;!J:II!H;!GH@G9:;! >R!EBE!4"4;O!!#:G:E@IRQ!@9:!':GL:@HLI:?H@<@:A!IHGP! HEA!J9<@:!I<;@j!;R;@:?Q!J9:@J::E! D:;;:I;!@9H@!HL:!I<;9:A!& #:;BI=@& K+75C,-+@&M53@&*0&!*+9)+-)+7)&S)//)5/>&M-/(-+@&0*1&'1*2-735&'C+3/&3+,&OD*1,0-/ (&-+&.()& K"'!&31)3&*0&!*+0-,)+7) !HEA!#:;BI=@&#+1)@C53.),>&#+1)2*1.),&M-/(-+@&-+&.()&K"'!&31)38 !!2;!;::E!IHGP!HEA!J9<@:!I<;@;j!G HE!>:!=;:A!@B! 109 Indian Ocean Tuna Commission. Indian Ocean Tuna Fisheries Data Summary, 1994 2003 Vol. 25 2006.

PAGE 68

61 A<;GB=LHK:!F<;9R!?HP:n!?<@!@9:I<;9:A!::E!EB@H;:A!HMMLBHG9:;!@B!A:@:L! EBEGB?MII:Q! #:GB??:EAH@R!HER!
PAGE 69

62 (E!BLA:L!@B!MIHG:!L:;@L:!?HA: Q !HEA!@9:!4B??<;;:;@O!! 39B; !9H;!E:D:L!>::E!F=IIR!R !#:;BI=@:L; !@B!?<@!@9<;! :R!?:?>:L;!HEA!L:;=I@;!HL:!EB@!R:@!PEBJEO UU] !! 2I@9B=K9 !@9:!($34!9H;!?HA:!;R!4"4; O!!39=;!FHLQ!@9:!($34!AB:;!EB@!9HD:!@9:!H=@9BL<@R!@B!I
PAGE 70

63 & X)55*D0-+&'C+3 & '::E! :GBEB?I:?!@9H@!9H;!HIIBJ:A!;@BGP!:XMIB<@H@;@L=G@:AO!!39<;!MLB>I:?!<;!:XHG:L> H@:A!>R!@9:!FHG@!@9H@!BD:L!\Ts!BF! 9HLD:;@;!HL:!@HP:E!>R!HL@<;HEHI!F<;9:L<:;!@9H@!?HR!EB@!>:!MLBM:LIR!HGGB=E@:A!FBL!=EA:L! @9:!($34!;@L=G@=L:!dFLB?!>B@9!4"4 ; !HEA!EBE?:?>:L;eO UU[ !!39B=K9!;@BGP;!HL:!EB@! G=LL:E@IR! H@!H!GL<@R!@9 :!($34!HEA!@9:!:@J::E!@LHA<@I=:F=@!GHE!L:HG9!I:EK@9;!BF!U`TG?!HEA!J:R!HK:!;I=:F
PAGE 71

64 < ?MLBM:L!?HEHK:?:E@!HEA!I:KHG<:;!BF!BD:L9HLD:;@!9HD:!@9:!MB@:E@::E!H!P:R!MBI<;9 !H!DI:!MLBKLH?!>R!STT\O!!39:!L:MBL@!;@ H@:A!@9H@!>B@9! R:IIBJF:L!BF!FIHKK:A!D:;;:I;!BF!S]?!?<@!A:D:IBM?:E@!MIHE;!@B! @9:!($34!GB??<;;
PAGE 72

65 GH@G9:;!@9H@!@9:!4B??<;;;@HE@R!FI::@;!@B!\U_QTTT@!:L;!HL:!:D:E!?BL:!@LB=>II:!HL@<;HEHI!FI::@;!!@9:!BD:LF<;9R!:;@H>I<;9& :HG9!4"4!<;!@B!A<;@L<>=@:!FBL?;!@B!HII!D:;;:I;!H=@9BL?<@! ABG=?:E@H@:!;=>?<@@:A!@B!@9:!4"4! HEA!DHIR!@9:!MLBM:L!H=@9BL<@<:;O!!39<;!ABG=?:E@H@:!;:E@!@B!@9:!':GL:@HL< H@O!!'@BGP;!@9H@!AB!EB@!9HD:!@9:! MLBM:L!ABG=?:E@H@:!@LHA:A!J<@9R!(++!D:;;:I;O!!39:!;= GG:;;!BF!@9:!MLBKLH?!<;!:E@
PAGE 73

66 2#-30")SC;<)19DD>RFB=)&@=6)$68A5)B=)#'&$)%:96 ) 1 Food and Agricultural Organization Corporate Document Repository "Development of the Indian Ocean Tuna Fisheries." (accessed 17 Mar. 2010 ) !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 3B!AH@:Q!?HER!BF!@9:!($34h;!4"4;!9HD:!EB@!F=IIR!:! A=:!@B!H!IHGP!BF!GBEG:LE!FBL !G=LL:E@!;@BGP!I:D:I;Q!<@!<;!?BL:! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IR!M=L;:!;:R!M=L;:!;:R!IB EKIR!KR!M=L;:!;:R!K:L;!HL:!HEE=HI! HD:LHK:;!FLB?!Ua_T W STT`!HEA!HL:!I
PAGE 74

67 R:IIBJFI:!;=GG:;;O!! K+,-3+&"7)3+&OD*1,0-/(; & 6=;@!H;!<@;!2@IHE@:@J::E!@LHA<@B=EAHL<:;!HEA!@9:!9I:!@B!BD:L9HLD:;@!:L;O US] 3LHA<@RGH@G9Q! 3H:KHE!@HLK:@
PAGE 75

68 39:!L<;:!R!F<;9R!HE!::E!:XMBL@:A!@B!A:D:IBM:A!EH@R!@9:!+'!dH;!;::E!R!3H:!
PAGE 76

69 @B!STT\!I:D:I; O USa !!2EX<:@R!BD:L!;@BGP;!I:D:I;!JH;!HKH J9L<:F;!HEA! #:;BI=@I:?!=E@R! N)/*5C.-*+&[_\[T > &!*+7)1+-+@&.()& N)@ -/.13.-*+&3+,&RV7(3+@)&*0&K+0*1=3.-*+&*+&S)//)5/>&K+75C,-+@&M53@&*0&!*+9)+-)+7)& S)//)5/>&M-/(-+@&0*1&'1*2-735&'C+3/&3+,&OD*1,0-/(&-+&.()&K"'!&L1)3&*0&!*=2).)+7)8&& 39:! #:;BI=@ ?<@!AH@H!FLB? !HII!D:;;:I;!F<;9I<;9!H !gJ9<@:!HEA!>IHGPj!I<;@!;R;@:?!I:?O!!(E!FHG@Q!@9:!($34! 9H;!EB@!L :I:H;:A!H!;I:!9HLD:;@;Q!:FF:G@H@:AO!!"HL@I:?H@:!@9:!;@HEG:!BF!G:L@H:!AR!@9:!L:;MBE;:!BF!3H?<@!GL:A<>I:!AH@H!@B!($34! 129 IOTC. Report of the IOTC Performance Review Panel 57

PAGE 77

70 H=@9BL<@<:;Q! <;!EB@!II:!I:?FBE5)$68A5)4I)/8689 ) Food and Agr icultural Organization Corporate Document Repository "Development of the Indian Ocean Tuna Fisheries ." < http://www.fao.org/docrep/007/y5428e/y5428e05.htm > (accessed 17 Mar. 2010 ) 130 Govender et al. 15

PAGE 78

71 $5678 9:)U< ) %=6DIEBE ) $F!@9:!FB=L!GH;:;!:XH?IHEG:!BF!;=GG:;;O!!2@!BE:!@::E!L:A=G:A!@B!H!FHI:!I:D:I!@9H@!AB:;!E B@! G=LL:E@IR!@9L:H@:E!@9:!F=@=L:!9:HI@9!BF!@9:!;@BGP;O!!39H@!;HR!@9:!+E<@:A!'@H@:; Q !J9B! 9HA!H!IHLK:!A:KL::!BF!I:D:LHK:!I=:F::E!?BL:!MLB>I:?H@:!I:O!!39:!($3 4! ?HEHK:?:E@!BF!@9:!R:IIBJF!F<;9H@:AQ! ;9BJB@9!4"4;!HEA !(++!F<;9:L?:EO!! *:GH=;:!BF!@9:;:!FHI:!I:D:I!

PAGE 79

72 @9H@!@9L:H@:E;!@9:!F=@=L:!BF!P:R!F<;9!;@BGP;O!!19::E!ABE:!BE 9BJ!#58$;!GHE!>:!:@J::E!;@H@:;!@9H@!<;!I:!HI!GB??BE;Q! #58$!FH:!;::E!H;!H!IR!HEHIRYR!$R:/! @9:!E=?>:L!BF!HG@BL;Q!@9:!MHRBFF! H;R??:@LR!HEA!@9:!;9HABJ!BF!@9:!F=@=L:O!!! 39<;!<;!A:?BE;@LH@:A!I:!^OUO &%4,")UC;<) $>>79:68B>=)V6:B6TD9E ) 2;!;::E!B=@! (4423/!*53 (4423/!'1$ ($34/!-53 ($34/!'1$ .=?>:L!BF! 2G@BL; 8HER/! 2@!I:H;@!U_ 5:J/!2@!I:H;@!^O!! S!8HfBL!2G@BL; 8HER/! 2@!I:H;@!U`O! 5:J/!2@!I:H;@!`O! U!8HfBL!2G@BL "HRBFF! 2;R??:@LR 2;R??:@L
PAGE 80

73 @9:!F=@=L:O!!(F!@9:;:!GBEA<@I:!FBL!GBBM:LH@I:!GBEA<@I:!MBII:!=E@R! @9:!+E<@:A!'@H@:;O!2II!B@9:L!GH;:;!;@=A<:;!L:ML:;:E@!I<@@I:!9BM:!FBL!GBBM:LH@H;:L!BF!HG@B L;! :L!BF!HG@BL;!:GB?:;!@9I:! MBI:L!BF!H G@BL;! I:?H@I=:F:L!BF!HG@BL;!J9B !HL:!LB=K9@!;=GG:;;!@B!@9:!($34 W L:K=IH@:A!;JBLAF<;9 Q J9:L:!3H::E!L:I=G@HE@!@B!KLHE@!@9:!($34!HER! ?HEHK:?:E@!MBJ:LO!39:!ML:;:EG:!BF!L:IH@:@J::E! @9:! ?H
PAGE 81

74 &N=HIIR!:!H@@H< E:A!@9LB=K9!GBBM:LH@I=:F:L;!BF!@9:!F<;9:LR!A:?BE;@LH@:!H!IHLK:!A:KL::!BF! 9:@:LBK:E:<@R!@9H@!?HR!?HP:!MBIB@9!F<;9:@J::E!&+!;@H@:;!HEA!A: D:IBMI:!@B!GB:LG:!;@H@:;!I:!MBII:?H@
PAGE 82

75 HEA!KBHI;O!!19:@J::E!@9:!;@H@:;!HEA!@9:!;?HII!E=?>:L! BF!P:R!HG@BL;Q!?HEHK:?:E@!;=GG:;;!JH;!?BL:!I::E! 9<;@BLI:!MBI:!K:E:LH@:AO!! 39:!F:!IB;@!BL!BF!J9H@!GBE;:N=:EG:;!H!;@H@:!GB=IA!:EA=L:! :E:FLI:!HEA!>:GH=;:!L:M=@H@
PAGE 83

76 FBL!;@LI:Q!I:HAI:!GB??<@?:E@;O!! (E!@9:!GH;:!BF!@9:!&H;@:LE!2@IHE@I=:FB@ 9!GH;:;!HL:!A:?BE;@LH@I:A!F<;9:L<:;Q!;GHE@!GBEG:LE!9H;!>::E! :XML:;;:A O!!*:GH=;:!;B?:!;@H@:;!::E!J:HPO!!'::E!:!F:HLF=I!BF!@9:R!B@9:L!;@H@:;Q!@9:R!9HD:!IHLK:L!>HLKH::E!H>I:!@B!MH;;! HER!GL:A<>I:!L:K=IH@I:;!A:?BE;@LH@:;Q!@9:!?HEHK:?:E@!BF! I:!A:D:IBM?:E@O!!39B=K9!@9<; !HEHIR;<; !?HR!ML:;:E@!H!>I:HP!B=@IBBP!FBL !F=@=L:!

PAGE 84

77 BF!@9:!9:!FB=EA!@9LB=K9!@9:!=;:!BF!=E:!=EI:O!!39H@!;H:!H>I :!@B!;I:!@B!MLB@:G@!D=IE:LH>I:!;@BGP;Q!HIIBJR!(4423!HEA!JH;!:KHE!@B!L:;@L
PAGE 85

78 '@H@:;! F<;9:A!>:E:H@9!<@;!(4423! N=B@HQ!L:A=G:KHE!@B!@:!A:!AR!@9:!+'!JH;!?HA:!?BL:!F:H;<>I:!>R!@9:!L:IH@I:!GBEA<@:!H@@HR!@9:!+'!AI:!GBBM:LH@::E !=;:A !I=:FL::A HE!BL!II=:F
PAGE 86

79 6HMHE:;:!?HLP:@!@9H@!ALI=:FI=:FIBGPI:!>I=:F:!=;:A!H;!I:D:LHK:!:!D:LR!AI=:FHEE:AO !!*:GH=;:!BF!@9<;Q! @9:!?HLP:@!I:D:LHK:!<;!AI:!FBL!=E::E!9<;@BL
PAGE 87

80 19I:;!MLBDI:;!?HR!9HD:!MB@:E@I:;!@9H@!?HR!HFF:G@!@9:!;@=AR!I:;!HL:!A:?BE;@LH@:A!H;I:;!@9H@!?HR!HFF:G@!@9:!HEHIR;<;!BF!F<;9:L<:;!GB=IA!>:! @9:!L:MLBA=G@ I:!@B!BD:L F<;9::E!HEHIRY:AQ!HII!>=@!@9:!(EA
PAGE 88

81 @9:?!:X@L:?:IR!D=IE:LH>I:!@B!BD:LF<;9I=:F:!@LB=>IH@:AO!!! 2;!HIHEGI:!MBII:!AH@H!FLB?!<@;!;G<:E@::E!D:LR!MLBHG@:!=;:A!>R!@9:!4B??<;;I:!@B!HG@!:FF:G@:!=EI:GH=;: !@9:!L<;P!JB=IA!>:!@BB!KL:H@O!!2;!;::E!I=:FR!@9:!4B??<;;I:O!! 39:!'G<:E@::E!I:;;!HM@!H@!K:E:LH@I:!@B!A:I:!?HEHK:AO!!5=L@9:L?BL:Q!J< @9B=@!DHI:!A=:!@B!@9:!FHG@!@9H@!<@!<;!H!L:IH@
PAGE 89

82 ($34h; !FHI:!MLHG@:L;9R!=I@:LI:!MBII=:FR!:;@H>I<;9R!KL:H@IR!L:A=GI=:F!<@;!BD:LF<;9I:!@9L:H@O!!#H@9:LQ!@9:!4(3&'!G9HII:EK:!;HEAHK:!@9:!;<@=H@I:?O!!39<;!;HI:!G9HII:EK:;!?HR!HG@=HIIR!HI@:L!@9:!>:9HD:L!;@H@:;Q!I:HAI:!MLHG@I:!@9H@!?HR!HFF:G@!MHL@
PAGE 90

83 J:!?BL:! JI:HP:L!MLB;M:G@!FBL!@9:!9I=:F::!H;;=?:A!@9H@!@9:R!;9B=IA!9HD:!;B?:!::E!@L=:O!!39<;!AREH?R!@9:!L:IH@;@<@=@:;Q!;=G9!H;!(EA:!MIHG:A!BE!H!L:MIHG:?:E@!;@BGPQ!GH=;I:!DHI=:Q!EB! ;@H@:;!J:L:!A::MIR!R! @9:!+' !ALBD:!=M!I:EK@9!BF!'MHI:!H;!@9:!;M:G<:;!JH;!BF!I<@@I:!DHI=:Q!@9:!F:HL!BF!L:@HI
PAGE 91

84 (E!@9:!GH;:;!BF!@9:!($34Q!?HLP:@!DHI=:!?HR!I:9HDH;:!ABE:!@B!R! P:R!;@H@:;!?HR!>:!@9:!BEIR!G9HEG:!H@!;=GG:;;O!!39B=K9!<@!<;!EB@ !G=LL:E@IR!MB;;<>I:!I:!?HEHK:?:E@O!! 39:!=;:!BF!=E:!?:@!J<@9! 9B;@:E:F<@!FLB?!@9:!FIHJ;!BF!@9:!G=LL:E@!;R;@:?O!!C=:!@B!@9:;:! ;@H@:;Q!@9:!BAR!<;!=EI:!FB=EA!@9LB=K9!4(3&'!?HEHK:?:E@O!!39=;!FHLQ!4(3&'!9H;!MLBD:E!H;!HE! :FF:G@:E:F<@!GL<@:L;9
PAGE 92

85 ) $56789:)W< $>=AD@EB>= ) ) ) 2F@:L!HEHIRYI:;!@9H@!<@!;@H@:!GBBM:LH@I:!I:!?HEHK:?:E@!?HR!>:!FB=EA! @9LB=K9 !=ER!MBJ:LF=I !;@H@:; O!! +EHEEBD:!@9:I<;9!9@I:!FBL?!BF!GB:LG
PAGE 93

86 2;!;9BJE!:! D:LR!:FF:G@::E!HR!H!;:I<:D:!?BL:!>IH@HE@!GB:LGR!H!MBJ:LF=I!;H@:!JB=IA! K:E:LH@:!HER!I:; ;!;=GG:;;O!! +ER!3HHE!BE! HEE:!L:FI:G@:A!I:!MBIR!6HMHEQ!@9<;!;@LH@:KR!GB=IA!HII:DI=:F
PAGE 94

87 F=:I:A!KIB>HI!BD:LF<;9:!H>I:!@B!L:GBD:LO!19:!;B?: !?HLP:@!FBL!>I=:FI:! L:;=I@;Q!6HMHE!9H;!;9BJE!EB!I=:FR!EH@:!FB=EA!R!@9:!+'Q!&+!HEA!6HMHEQ!H!fB:L;! GB=IA!>:!=;:A!@B!ALI:! :@J::E!@9:!+'!HEA!@9:!&+!GB=IA!MLBD:!@B!>:!>:E:FIHEG:!BF!9BM:!FBL!@9:!ML:;:LDH@:L ;9:!IR! A:L;9:!H@@H:!H>I:!@B!:FF:G@:!@9:!BEIR! BM@:!;=GG:;;F=IQ!MLBKL:;;:!J:!J@;!PEBJL
PAGE 95

88 ?HR!EB@!JBLPO! *=@!J9
PAGE 96

89 4BTDB>G:675I ) 2IGBGPQ!5LHEPO!g"LB;M:G@;!FBL!+;:!#;>HJEO!STT`O! *HLPHI! ":L;M:G@B=@!+EI:?Oq! PR4&JR%K' !^OS!dSTT_e C:'B?>L:Q!&I:@9O!q5<;9HI!4BEF:L:EG:!#:f: G@;!*HE;!BE!3LHA:!
PAGE 97

90 5BBA!HEA!2KLO!STUTe %HLL:@@Q!2EK=;Q!HEA!2AH?!*LBJEO!g-:IIBJFHI!HEA!+7!'=MMIR!49HHI!,:;;BE;Oq!dSTT\e %LHF@ BEQ!#O!cOQ!:@!HIO!q39:!&GBEB?IH@@Q!HEA!":LLH@BEO!q#:@9HII<;9
PAGE 98

91 (EA&]eeT Q & & H[[I O!)BIO!S[O! d STT^ e (EAIHEPoGFIHKyHIIoIK:HLy>IHEPoGK:HLyHIIoIBLA:Ly'M:G<:;4BA:oIL:K< BEy>IHEPo>@;:HLG9y':HLG9xO (E@:LEH@O! STUT e (E@:LEH@&]eef>&3+,& & ]eee O! d 8HAL
PAGE 99

92 ( E@:LEH@&]efg Q f_&6LN'&KK O! d 8HAL&H[[H Q [I&631.&KK O!)BIO!UO!8HAL&H[[g Q [_&6LN'&K O! d 8HALO! STUT e 7:B9HE:Q!#B>:L@O!q(E@:LEH@I:!5<;9!3LHA:!HEA!5BBA!':G=L<@ROj!! ML"&M-/()1-)/&')7(+-735&632)18& & P*8&T^g8 !#B?:O!dSTT[e! BAK:Q!8HG9Q! N)7*==)+,),&F)/.&6137.-7)/&0*1& & N)@-*+35&M-/()1-)/&J3+3@)=)+.&"1@3+-W3.-*+/;&N)2*1.&*0&3+&K+,)2)+,)+.&63+)5& & .*&%)9)5*2&3&J*,)5&0*1&K=21*9),&b*9)1+3+7)&B:&N)@-*+35&M-/()1-)/&J3+3@)=)+.& & "1@3+-W3.-*+/ Q!d,B EABE/!#BRHI!(E;@<@=@:!B F!(E@:LEH@
PAGE 100

93 .H@. (accessed U[!5:>O! 2010 ) $R:Q!7:EE:@9!2O!q&XMIHHI!3L:EA;! (accessed 5 Mar. 2010 ) '@::LKQ!#O!0O!q"BJ:L!HEA!4BBM:LH@
PAGE 101

94 +E<@:A!'@H@:;O!4BEKO!0B=;: 8&U8&!"P8&NRO8&ITT;&'*&RV21)//&.()&O)+/)&*0&.()&!*+@1)//& & N)@31,-+@&P*1.(&L.53+.-7&OD*1,0-/(&3+,&".()1&U-@(5:&J-@13.*1:&O2)7-)/&* 0&M-/(8 UT[!4BEKOQ!S!;:;;O )HE!CRP:Q!6BE!8O!g'9HL

ERROR LOADING HTML FROM SOURCE (http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu//design/skins/UFDC/html/footer_item.html)