ERROR LOADING HTML FROM SOURCE (http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu//design/skins/UFDC/html/header_item.html)

The Enduring Landscape the Archaeology of Seminole Ethnogenesis in West-Central Florida

Permanent Link: http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu/NCFE004685/00001

Material Information

Title: The Enduring Landscape the Archaeology of Seminole Ethnogenesis in West-Central Florida
Physical Description: Book
Language: English
Creator: Wass, Michael
Publisher: New College of Florida
Place of Publication: Sarasota, Fla.
Creation Date: 2012
Publication Date: 2012

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords: Seminole
Myakka River
Peace River
Charlotte Harbor
Archaeology
Ethnogenisis
Genre: bibliography   ( marcgt )
theses   ( marcgt )
government publication (state, provincial, terriorial, dependent)   ( marcgt )
born-digital   ( sobekcm )
Electronic Thesis or Dissertation

Notes

Abstract: The Seminole Tribe of Florida, the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida, and the Independent Traditional Seminole Nation of Florida are the descendants of the people who were not sent to the Indian Territory along the Gulf Coast route of the Trail of Tears. The origins of the Unconquered Seminoles are contested with popular, scholarly, and indigenous understandings offering differing perspectives. As a result of the confusions created by the colonial encounter in the American Southeast, the historical record has impacted earlier understandings of the origins of the Seminoles. This thesis contributes to uncovering its 19th-century history by focusing on the West-Central Florida landscape, specifically the Myakka River, the Peace River, and Charlotte Harbor. By examining the historic maps of Florida, the historical record, and the archaeological record, this thesis argues for the significance of Southwest Florida for the ethnogenesis of the Seminoles.
Statement of Responsibility: by Michael Wass
Thesis: Thesis (B.A.) -- New College of Florida, 2012
Electronic Access: RESTRICTED TO NCF STUDENTS, STAFF, FACULTY, AND ON-CAMPUS USE
Bibliography: Includes bibliographical references.
Source of Description: This bibliographic record is available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication. The New College of Florida, as creator of this bibliographic record, has waived all rights to it worldwide under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights, to the extent allowed by law.
Local: Faculty Sponsor: Baram, Uzi

Record Information

Source Institution: New College of Florida
Holding Location: New College of Florida
Rights Management: Applicable rights reserved.
Classification: local - S.T 2012 W1
System ID: NCFE004685:00001

Permanent Link: http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu/NCFE004685/00001

Material Information

Title: The Enduring Landscape the Archaeology of Seminole Ethnogenesis in West-Central Florida
Physical Description: Book
Language: English
Creator: Wass, Michael
Publisher: New College of Florida
Place of Publication: Sarasota, Fla.
Creation Date: 2012
Publication Date: 2012

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords: Seminole
Myakka River
Peace River
Charlotte Harbor
Archaeology
Ethnogenisis
Genre: bibliography   ( marcgt )
theses   ( marcgt )
government publication (state, provincial, terriorial, dependent)   ( marcgt )
born-digital   ( sobekcm )
Electronic Thesis or Dissertation

Notes

Abstract: The Seminole Tribe of Florida, the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida, and the Independent Traditional Seminole Nation of Florida are the descendants of the people who were not sent to the Indian Territory along the Gulf Coast route of the Trail of Tears. The origins of the Unconquered Seminoles are contested with popular, scholarly, and indigenous understandings offering differing perspectives. As a result of the confusions created by the colonial encounter in the American Southeast, the historical record has impacted earlier understandings of the origins of the Seminoles. This thesis contributes to uncovering its 19th-century history by focusing on the West-Central Florida landscape, specifically the Myakka River, the Peace River, and Charlotte Harbor. By examining the historic maps of Florida, the historical record, and the archaeological record, this thesis argues for the significance of Southwest Florida for the ethnogenesis of the Seminoles.
Statement of Responsibility: by Michael Wass
Thesis: Thesis (B.A.) -- New College of Florida, 2012
Electronic Access: RESTRICTED TO NCF STUDENTS, STAFF, FACULTY, AND ON-CAMPUS USE
Bibliography: Includes bibliographical references.
Source of Description: This bibliographic record is available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication. The New College of Florida, as creator of this bibliographic record, has waived all rights to it worldwide under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights, to the extent allowed by law.
Local: Faculty Sponsor: Baram, Uzi

Record Information

Source Institution: New College of Florida
Holding Location: New College of Florida
Rights Management: Applicable rights reserved.
Classification: local - S.T 2012 W1
System ID: NCFE004685:00001


This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

! "#$!$%&'()%*!+,%&-. / $ "#$!,(.#,$0+0*1!02!-$3)%0+$!$"#%0*$%$-)-!)%!4$-" 5 .$%"(,+!2+0()&, ! 61 3).#,$+!4,,! ! ,!"789:9 ! -;<=:>>8?!>@!>78!&:A:9:@B!@C!-@D:EF!-D:8BD89 %8G!.@FF8H8!@C!2F@I:?E : B!JEI>:EF!C;FC:FF=8B>!@C!>78!I8K;:I8=8B>9!C@I!E! 6ED78F@I!@C!,I>9! :B ,B>7I@J@F@HL 'B?8I!>78!9J@B9@I97:J!@C!&IM!'N:!6EIE= -EIE9@>EO!2F@I:?E 3EL!PQRP

PAGE 2

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

PAGE 3

! ::: "@!=L!CI:8B?9!E>!%8G!.@FF8H8O!,F8W:9!V-J:?8IX!-EB>@9O!-8B98:!3EIT!4:FD@!\EB?!<89>! 8B?8I!E>!*I@GF8I9!/;<]O!6E:F8L!#@GEI?O!.E>78I:B8!`ET@9T8O!&@=:B:K;8!*7:IEI?:O! S8CC!*;8I>:BO!$AEB!&EII@GO!3@IHEB!3@F:BE 5 3EI:BO!-E=EB>7E!-8=8B>:FF:!\8A8B!>7@;H7! H@E>9!EI8! ,6$"#612)-+$#(3# >@!DE=8F9]O!3@IHEB!&@FEBO!+:N!'978IG@@?O!(@N!.I8G9O! -E=:!#EBBE7O!"@==L!/FE>aO!3@FFL!3DD@I=:DT O! 6I8B?EB!(:A8I9O! -;9EBBE!/ELB8 5 /E99=@I8O!$I:D!b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`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

PAGE 4

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c^R,] '9:BH!JI@C:>9 CI@=!>78:I DE9:B@9O! >78!-8=:B@F89! 7EA8!<;:F>!9>E>8!@C!>78!EI>! CED:F:>:89!C@I!>78!D@B98IAE>:@B!EB?!9>@IEH8!@C!EI>:CED>9M! 4:>7!>7898!CED:F:>:89!> 78! -8=:B@F89!EI8!9EC8H;EI?:BH! >78:I!:==8?:E>8!78I:>EH8!EB?!EID7E8@F@HLO! E9!G8FF!E9! 8B9;I:BH!>78:I!I@F8 E9! 9>8GEI?9!@C!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!>78!EBD89>IEF!2F@I:?E!J8@JF89!F8C>! <87:B?M!"78!D@B>89>!@A8I!>78!"I:<8U9!7:9>@IL!EB?!78I:>EH8!7E9!<88B!9F@GFL!F8EB:BH! >@GEI?9!>78!-8=:B@F89O!<;>!>78!C@FF@G :BH!A:HB8>>8!8=J7E9:N89!>78!:99;89!>7E>!9>:FF! JFEH;8!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!2F@I:?EU9!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9M! 23456776! 8 9,:;56;?!@A>!B:6!7A6!.6C35>D6;EF "@==L!:9!E!d >7 HIE?8IO!E>>8B?:BH!9D7@@F!:B!-EIE9@>E!.@;B>L O!2F@I:?E M!#:9! >8ED78IO!3I9M!S@B89!:9! >8ED7:BH E<@;>!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9 C@I!>78:I!C:I9>!>:=8M!-78! >8ED789 >78=!E<@;>!G:HGE=9O!>88J889O!<;CCEF@9O!EB?!C8E>78I8?!78E??I89989M! -78! :BDF;?89!<@>7!>78 -8=:B@F89!EB?!3:DD@9;T889O!89J8D:EFFL!.7:8C!09D8@FE!EB?!7:9! <8>IELEF!;B?8I!>78!G7:>8!CFEHM!"@==L!:9!8B>7IEFF8? G:>7!>78!9>@IL!@C!09D8@FE!EB?! GEB>9!>@!TB@G!8A8B!=@I8M!#8!E9T9O!V3I9M!S@B89O!G7@!EI8!>78!-8=:B@F89_X!

PAGE 5

! A 7:9!:9!E!JI@EIL!9D7@@F9!EI@;B?!>78!9>E>8M!2@;I>7! EB?!C:C>7!HIE?8 9!:B9>I;D>:@B9!8=J7E9:N8!2F@I:?E!7:9>@IL M!/@J;FEIFLO!>78!-8=:B@ F89! 7EA8!F@BH!<88B!;B?8I9>@@?!>@!<8! ,(4"##3/$) O!@I!VI;BEGEL9X!@I!VG:F?!@B89X!\3@@I8 5 4:F9@B!Recfg!6:ID7C:8F?!PQQhg!#:9>@IL3:E=:!PQRR]M!&M!+M!6:ID7C:8F?!JI@A:?89!E! >LJ:DEF!D@B>8=J@IEIL!J@J;FEI!A:8G!@C!G7@!>78!-8=:B@F89!EI8^ ,C>8I!>78!-JEB:97!DFE:=8?!2F@I:?E! :B!RdedO!$;I@J8EB!?:98E989!EB?!GEI! <8>G88B!-JE:B!EB?!$BHFEB?!G:J8?!@;>!>78!@I:H:BEF!)B?:EB!J8@JF8!@C! 2F@I:?EM!&;I:BH!>78!RiQQ9O!3;9D@H889!CI@=!JI898B> 5 ?EL!*8@IH:E!EB?! ,FE@!>7E>!8=J>L!FEB?!:B!B@I>78IB!2F@I:?EO!G7:D7! GE9!9>:FF!-JEB:97!>8II :>@ILM!6L!RiidO!>78L!7E?!C@I=8?!E!98JEIE>8!>I:<8! :B!B@I>78IB!2F@I:?EO!TB@GB!E9!-8=:B@F89M!\PQQh^f] 6:ID7C:8F?!I8JI898B>9!>78!-8=:B@F89!E9!8=:HIEB>9!:B>@!2F@I:?E!CI@=!>78!.I88T!BE>:@B! :B!*8@IH:E!EB?!,FE@!2F@I:?EM!"7:9!A:8G!I8JI898B>9!9@=8!@C!>78!D@BC ;9:@B9! DI8E>8?!78!,=8I:DEB!-@;>78E9>!<8DE;98!:>!?@89!B@>!I8D@HB:N8!>78! 9;IA:AEF!@C!BE>:A8!2F@I:?E!J8@JF89!E9!>78L!I8@IHEB:N8?!>78=98FA89!:B!I89J@B98!>@! D@F@B:EF!8BD@;B>8I9M! 478B!)!GE9!:B!8F8=8B>EIL!9D7@@FO!>7:9!:9!G7E>!G8!G8I8!>E;H7>M! #@ G8A8IO!>78I8!EI8!CEI!=@I8!:B9:?:@;9!EB?!?EBH8I@;9!J@J;FEI!J@I>IELEF9!@C!>78! -8=:B@F89!7:9>@ILM!"78!C@FF@G:BH!:9!CI@=!>78!2F@I:?E!&8JEI>=8B>!@C!3:F:>EIL!,CCE:I9! \2&3,]^ )C!>78I8!GE9!E!D@B9>EB>!>78=8!:B!>78!C:I9>!>7I88!7;B?I8?!L8EI9!@C! $;I@J8EB!98>>F8=8B>!:B %@I>7!,=8I:DEj:>!7E?!>@!<8!>78!)B?:EB! JI@!:B!,=8I:DEB!7:9>@IL!7E9!<88B!9@!DF@98FL! 9DI;>:B:N8?O!?88?O!EB?!I8D@I?8?M!2F@I:?E!7E?!:>9!@GB!)B?:EB! JI@78!8EIF:89>!?EL9!@C!-JEB:97!D@F@B:NE>:@BM!3@9>! =8=@IE78!-8D@B?O!@I!*I8E>! -8=:B@F8!4EIO!Rehd 5 RekPM!"G@!>7:I?9!@C!>78!8B>:I8!,=8I:DEB!,I=L! G@;F?!C:H7>!>78I8O!JEI>9!@C!>78!%EAL!EB?!3EI:B8!.@IJ9O!JF;9!>7@;9EB?9! @C!D:>:N8B!A@F;B>88I9!CI@=!2F@I:?E!EB?!9>E>89!E9!CEI!EGEL!E9!3:99@;I:M! )>!GE9!>78!-8D@B ?!-8=:B@F8!4EI!>7E>!H@>!2F@I:?E!:B>@!>78!7:9>@IL! <@@T9!@C!)B?:EB!4EI9O!EB?!9@=8!@C!:>9!D@B98K;8BD89!I8=E:B!>@!JFEH;8! 9>E>8!J@F:>:D9!8A8B!>@?ELM

PAGE 6

! A: "78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EI!7E?!8A8IL>7:BH^!>F89O!=E99EDI89O!CE=@;9! =8BO!78I@:9=O!9>;J:?:>LO!C@I>:>;?8O!EB?!>I8E D78ILM!+:T8!=@9>!)B?:EB! GEI9O!:>!:BA@FA8?!@BFL!E!C8G!7;B?I8?!@I!E!C8G!>7@;9EB?!D@=EB>9!@B! 8:>78I!9:?8!E>!EBL!H:A8B!>:=8O!EB?!GE9!C@;H7>!:B!EB!8B@I=@;9!BE>;IEF! EB?!JI:=:>:A8!E=J7:>78E>8IM!"78I8!G8I8!I8=EITE>F8! ?8E>79O!EF>7@;H7!?8E>79!CI@=!?:98 E98!:B!2F@I:?EU9!;B78EF>7L!DF:=E>8O! E??8?!=EBL!7;B?I8?9!@C!BE=89!>@!>78!DE9;EF>L!F:9>9M!"7:9!GEI!GE9! C@;H7>!CI@=!@B8!8B?!@C!>78!98>>F8=8B>!>@!>78!@>78Ig!B8EI!>@GB9!EB?! 98>>F8=8B>9O!:B!>78!C@I89>9!EB?!:B!>78!HI8E>!9GE=J9!>7E>!D@A8I8?!FEIH8! JEI>9!@C!>78!J8B: B9;FEM!,C>8I!98A8B!L8EI9!:>!8B?8?!G:>7!=@9>!@C!>78! )B?:EB9!F:A:BH!J8ED8C;FFL!:B!>@?ELU9!0TFE7@=E!@B!>78!DE97!<@;B>:89! H:A8B!>78=!78!'M-M!*@A8IB=8B>M!\-@=8!@C!>7898!>IEB9J@I>8?! -8=:B@F89!C@;H7>!:B!>78!.@BC8?8IE>8!,I=L!EB?!@>78I9!:B!>78!'B:@B! ,I=L!?;I:BH >78!.:A:F!4EIg!@B8!2F@I:?E!<@IB!78!.@BHI899:@BEF!38?EF!@C!#@B@I!E9!EB!)B?:EB!9D@;>!@B!>78! ->ET8?!/FE:B9!@C!"8WE9!:B!Reif]M 7*$28$4(/36$)2"#$2/3%2(/9(.$/3-)2%32:63#(9";27*$12"#$2"2,366$,%(3/2352 83-%*$#/2<#$$=2>/9("/2?"/9)2%*"%2?$. "/24(.#"%(/.2(/%32:63#(9"@25#342 %39"1A)2)%"%$)2352B$3#.("2"/92C6"?"4"@2(/2%*$2$"#612DE%*2,$/%-#1; "78L! 9:?8?!G:>7!>78!-JEB:97!EHE:B9>!>78!$BHF:97!D@F@B:9>9!>@!>78!B@I>7O!EB?! G:>7!>78!6I:>:97!EHE:B9>!>7@98!9E=8!J8@JF8O!DEFF8?!,=8I:DEB9!9:BD8! RiifM!&;I:BH!>7 8!-8D@B?!-JEB:97!/8I:@?!:B!2F@I:?EO!>78!-8=:B@F89!7E?! 98A8IEF!E>:@B9!G:>7!>78!,=8I:DEB9O!=@9>!B@>E!>78!EI=L!@C!,B?I8G!SEDT9@B!:B!ReReO!@CC:D:EFFL!>78!2:I9>! -8=:B@F8!4EIM!)>!GE9!B@!HI8E>!=@=8B>!@C!JF8E9;I8!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89! G78B!>7 8L!F8EIB8?!>7E>!-JE:B!7E?!9@F?!2F@I:?E!>@!>78!,=8I:DEB9M! \2&3,!PQRRg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

PAGE 7

! A:: 3:DD@9;T889!7EA8!<88B!9@!9;DD899C;F!:B!98D;I:BH! 8D@B@=:D9!H;EIEB>889 CI@=!>78! ->E>8!@C!2F@I:?E!E9!G8FF!E9!8WJEB?:BH!>78:I!FEB?!7@F?:BH9!G:>7:B!>78!9>E>8! EB?! <8D@=:BH!G8EF>7L!>7I@;H7 HE=:BHM

PAGE 8

! A::: -BGD6!>H!#>57657; ,DTB@GF8?H8=8B>9 llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll llllllllllllllllllllllllllllll!! JM!:: /I8CED8 lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll!!JM! :A +:9>!@C! 2:H;I89llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!:W ,<9>IED>lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll lllllllllllllllllllllllllll!JM!! W! .7EJ>8I!)^!) B>I@?;D>:@B!EB?!"78!#:9>@I:DEF!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I :DE lllllll!! JM R .7EJ>8I!))^!"78!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!+EB?9DEJ8^!/FED8!@C!/F8B>L lllllllllllllllll!!JM!Ri .7EJ>8I!)))^!/8@JF8!@B!>78!(;B^!#:9>@I:DEF!.@B>8W>!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89 lllllllllllll!!JM!hf .7EJ>8I!)b^!,ID7E8@F@H:DEF!-:>89 llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!fc .7EJ>8I!b^!V,!G:F?!7@I98O!E!CI88!=EB[X^!$>7B@H8B89:9!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89 lllllllllll!JM!ed .7EJ>8I!b)^!"78!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!-8=:B@F8!$>7B@H8B89:9 llllllllllllllllllllllllll!JM!RRR .7EJ>8I!b))^!"78!'BD@B K;8I8?!/8@JF8 lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllJMRPQ ,JJ8B?:W!,M 3EJ9 lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll!JMRPe ,JJ8B?:W!6M "I8E>L!@C!3@;F>I:8!.I88T llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll!JM!Rhe ,JJ8B?:W!.M &:9D;99:@B!@C! 09D8@FE llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!Rkf ,JJ8B?:W!&M 3LETTE!(:A8I!2E;BE llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!Rkc ,JJ8B?:W!$M )=EH8 llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll!JM!Rdd ,JJ8B?:W!2M 6:
PAGE 9

! :W (3;7!>H!134I:6; 134I:6!J ^!"78!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!GE>8I978?O!>@?EL!\$BA:I@B=8B>EF!/I@ >8D>:@B! ,H8BDL!PQRP]lllll llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!Re 134I:6!K ^!"78!3LETTE!(:A8I! GE>8I978?O!>@?EL!\-@;>7G89>!2F@I:?E!4E>8I! 3EBEH8=8B>!&:9>I:D>!PQRP]!lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!PP 134I:6!L ^!"78!/8ED8!(:A8I!GE>8I978?O!>@? EL!\CI@=!-4243&]lllllllllllllll lllllJM!Pc 134I:6!M ^!S@7B!+88!4:FF:E=9! '"+2352:63# (9" \Rehi]M!"78!>IE:F!:9!?@>>8?!@B!>78!=EJM!)>! :9!:=J@I>EB>!>@!B@>8!>7E>!>78!3LETTE!:9!I8D@I?8?!E9!>78!,9>8IBEF!(:A8I!@B!>7:9!=EJM! lllllllllllllllllllllllllll lll llllllllllllllllllllllllll lllllllllll lllllllllllllllllllllll!JM!hh 134I:6!N ^!V6:FF:8!09D8@FEU9 C:8F?O!6:H!.LJI899!SEB!UdhO!J;=JT:B9O!>EI@O!DEB8O!?8E?! D@IBX!\*@HH:B!.@FF8D>:@B!6@W!f!2@F?8I!-8=:B@F8!/7@>@9!m!R]! llllllllllllllllllllllJM!kf 134I:6!O ^!6:FFL!6@GF8H9O!,78I!-8=:B@F8!+8E?8I9!:B!4E97:BH>@B!&M!.MO! RedRlllllllllllllllllllllllllll llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll llllllllllllllllJM!de 134I:6!P ^!.7E>>E7@@D788!6I;978?!/@>!D@;I>89L!@C!*8@IH8!)B?:EB!/@>>8IL!48<9:>8O! 'B:A8I9:>L!@C!*8@IH:Ellllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll lllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!iR 134I:6!Q ^!0D=;FH8 8!2:8F?9!)BD:98?!<@GF!D@;I>89L!@C!*8@IH8!)B?:EB!/@>>8IL!48<9:>8O! 'B:A8I9:>L!@C!*8@IH:Ellllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll lllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!iR 134I:6!R ^! C4$#(,"2)$+%$/%#(3/"6()2(/2)-")2+#"$,(+-")2+"#%$29(F()"@2"92-)-42)$#$/())(4(2 G-#.-/9(" $29-,() O!Rfcklllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll llllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!RQk 134I:6!JS ^! <"#%$29$26"2H3-()("/$2,3-#)29-2'())())(+(2$%2+"()2F3()(/) O!Rikk llllllll!JM!RQd 134I:6!JJ ^! C#%$2.$/$#"629$2%3-%$26"2,I%$29$26"2H3-()("//$2J-)K-L"26"2G"1$28%;2G$# /"#9@2 ,3)%$29$26"2:63#(9$@2G"1$29$26"2'3?(66$@2G$;29$2M"/)",36$@2G"1$29$28%;2>3)$+*@28%;2'"#,2 9$)2C+"6",*$);29"/)26LC4$#(K-$2)$+%$/%6$ O!Riki lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!RQf 134I:6!JK ^! 2I@= 2 7*$2!()%3#12"/9273+3.#"+*12352%*$2N/(%$928%"%$) 2 \+@B?@B O!^!#:B>@BO! )M!"M!-:=JT:BO!3EI97EFF!EB?!.@MO!RehP]M!"78!(898IAE>:@B!:9!=EIT8?!:B!>78!78!->E>8M! llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllJM!RRR

PAGE 10

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c>7 5 D8B>;IL!7:9>@IL!78!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!FEB?9DEJ8O!9J8D:C:DEFFL!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IO!>78! /8ED8!(:A8IO!EB?!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IM!6L!8WE=:B:BH!>78!7:9>@I:D!=EJ9!@C!2F@I:?EO!>78! 7:9>@I:DEF!I8D@I?O!EB?!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?O!>7:9!>789:9!EIH;89!C@I!>78! 9:HB:C:DEBD8!@C!-@;>7G89>! 2F@I:?E!C@I!>78!8>7B@H8B89:9!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89M llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll &IM!'N:!6EIE= &:A:9:@B!@C!-@D:EF!-D:8BD89

PAGE 11

! R #ABT76:!&56! 8 U57:>VIW73>5 "78!2F@I:?E!FEB?9DEJ8!:9!7E;B>8?!78!H7@9>9!@C!E!9:F8BD8?!JE9>M!2@I!=@I8! >7 EB!RQOQQQ!L8EI9O!2F@I:?E!7E9!<88B!E!7@=8!C@I!:>9!7;=EB!:B7E<:>EB>9M!2F@I:?EU9! JIE:I:89!EB?!J:B8FEB?9O!9GE=J9!EB?!9F@;H79O!EB?!I:A8I9!EB?!89>;EI:89!7EA8!JI@A:?8?! 9;9>8BEBD8!EB?!9EC8!7EA8B!C@I!:>9!J8@JF89M!"7:9!GE9!B@!?:CC8I8B>!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89! EB?!>78:I!EB D89>@I9M! 2F@I:?EU9 -8=:B@F89!EB?!3:DD@9;T889!EI8!>78!?89D8B?EB>9!@C!>78 EJJI@W:=E>8FL!PQQ! -8=:B@F89!G7@!I8=E:B8?!:B!2F@I:?E!EC>8I!>7I88!GEI9!:B!>78! B:B8>88B>7!D8B>;ILM!"78!9GE=J9!@C!D8B>IEF!EB?!9@;>7!2F@I:?E!JI@A:?8?!9EC8!7EA8B!>@! >78!-8=:B@F89 g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c]O!6I8B>!48:9=EB!\Rcecg!Rccc]O!SE=89!&88>N!\Rccf]O!6EI>F8!\PQQi]O!.7EIF89!$M!0I98I!\PQQi]O!EB?! -:nB!S@B89!\Rcci]! >@!JI@A:?8 E!>78@I8>:DEF! CIE=8G@IT!EB?!E!=8>7@?@F@H:DEF!EJJI@ED7!>@!>78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!9@;>7G89>!2F@I:?EM

PAGE 12

! P )B!>7:9!D7EJ>8IO!)!G:FF!8WJF@I8!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!EB?!FEL >78!:B>8FF8D>;EF!C@;B?E>:@B!C@I!>7:9!>789:9M X3;7>:3WBD!":WAB6>D>4Y!>H!%B73Z6!"C6:3WB #:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!DEB!<8!E!I898EID7!JEIE?:H=!C@I!D@=<:B:BH! EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I898EID7!G:>7!I898EID7!:B>@!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!I8D@I?M!#@G8A8IO!7:9>@I:DEF! EID7E8@F@HL!:9!=@I8!>7EB!E!CIE=8G@IT!C@I!J;I9;:BH!I898EID7g!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL! :9!E!CIE=8G@IT!>@!9;JJF 8=8B>!EB?!>@!D7EFF8BH8!V>78!7:9>@IL!G8!TB@G!>7I@;H7! ?@D;=8B>9jo>@!I8D@B9>I;D>p!J8@JF8U9!GEL9!@C!F:C8jo>@!:=JI@A8p!EID7E8@F@H:DEF! =8>7@?9O!EB?jo>@!;B?8I9>EB?p!=@?8IB:NE>:@B!EB?!HF@:@BX!\+:>>F8!PQQi^PP]M! 6EI>F8!:B! !()%3#(,"62C#,*"$363.1O2P*12% *$2M")%2'"%%$#)2 \PQQi]!JI@A:?89!E! !@C!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HLM!-78! @;>F:B89 >78!H@EF9!EB?!E=<:>:@B9!@C! 7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!:B!>78!C:I9>!98D>:@B!@C!>78!<@@T!EB?!JI@A:?89!:B! >78 98D@B?! 98D>:@BO!E!98I:89!@C!EIH;=8B>9!C@I!G7E>!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7 E8@F@HL!C@D;989!@B!EB?!>78! 8>7:D9!@C!>78!C:8F?M! "78 >7:I?!98D>:@BO!EJJI@JI:E>8FL!>:>F8?!V,!4:B?97:8F?!-;IA8L!@C! #:9>@I:DEF!,ID7E8@F@HLXO!JI@A:?89!E!98I:89!@C!DE98!9>;?:89!:B!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL! G7:F8!E>!>78!9E=8!>:=8O!=ET:BH!E!G:>>L!J;B!@B!EB!EDD8J>8?!9 ;IA8L:BH!>8D7B:K;8!:B! EID7E8@F@HLM!#8I!C:BEF!98D>:@B!?8EF9!G:>7!>78!8>7:D9!@C!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!E9!E! J;78!C:8F?!97@;F?!8BHEH8!G:>7!>78!J;!>78!9E=8!>:=8O! J;I9;8!D:A:D!EB?!9@D:EF!Z;9>:D8M #:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!E9!9@D:EF!Z;9 >:D8!7E9!>I8=8B?@;9!J@>8B>:EFM!#8FJ:BH!>@! 8F;D:?E>8!EB?!DI8E>8!B;EBD8?!7:9>@I:89!:9!Z;9>!@B8!E9J8D>!@C!>78!J@99:<:F:>:89!CI@=! 7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HLM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!+:>>F8!\PQQi^Rkc]O!V)BD@=JF8>8!EB?!8WDF;9:@BEIL! 7:9>@I:89!98IA8!>@!D@BD8EF!>78!>I;>7!E<@;>!>7 8!JE9> q >I;>7!>7E>!:9!B88?8?!:C!G8!EI8!

PAGE 13

! h :B?88?!>@!F8EIB!CI@=!>78!8WJ8I:8BD89!@C!@;I!JI8?8D899@I9!EB?!>@!E>>8=J>!>@!78EF! F@BH 5 9>EB?:BH!G@;B?9XM!!)B!,=8I:DEO!9@=8!@C!>78!<89>!8WE=JF89!@C!>7898!>LJ8!@C! 8WDF;9:@BEIL!7:9>@I:89!EI8!;B?8I9>EB?:BH9!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DE B!7:9>@IL!E9!G8FF!E9! ,CI:DEB!,=8I:DEB!7:9>@ILM!!3EIT!+8@B8!:B! 7*$2C#,*"$363.12352H(?$#%12(/2"/2C4$#(,"/2 <"+(%"6O2QR,"F"%(3/)2(/2C//"+36()2 \PQQd]!EBEFLN89!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!@C! 98A8IEF!9:>89!:B!,BBEJ@F:9O!:BDF;?:BH!>78!7@=8!@C!4:FF:E=!/EDE!EB?!>78!3 EILFEB?! ->E>8!#@;98M!'B?8I!>78!CIE=8G@IT!@C!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HLO!78!=ET89!98A8IEF! :=J@I>EB>!:B9:H7>9!>7E>!I8A8EF!>78!7:??8B!7:9>@I:89!@C!,CI:DEB!I89:9>EBD8!EB?!EH8BDL! :B!E!G@IF?!G78I8!8A8IL!E>>8=J>!GE9!=E?8!>@!@JJI899!EB?! >@! 9>:CF8 >78:I!7;=EB:>LM #:9!G @IT!I8JI898B>9!>78!J@>8B>:EF!:B!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!>@!ED>!C@I!9@D:EF!Z;9>:D8!E9! +:>>F8!9>E>89!\PQQi^Rkc]O!V,ID7E8@F@HL!DEB!D@B>I:<;>8!>@!>I;>7 5 >8FF:BH!:BH!7:??8B!@I!?8B:8?!JEI>9!@C!>78!JE9>XM "7:9!F:>8IE>;I8!I8A:8GO!7@G8A8IO!: 9!B@>!E!H8B8IEF!I8A:8G!@C!7: 9>@I:DEF! EID7E8@F@HL!:B!,=8I:DEg!: >!:9!E!:@B!@C!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!%E>:A8! ,=8I:DEB9!:B!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!@C!,=8I:DEM!)!G:FF!?:9D;99!/E>I:D:E!(;<8I>@B8U9!\PQQQ]! V"78!#:9>@I:DEF!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9 X!EB?!8F;D:?E>8!78I!EIH;=8B>!E<@;>! 7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!;9:BH!6I;D8!"I:HH8IU9!\RceQ]!V,ID7E8@F@HL!EB?!>78!)=EH8!@C! >78!,=8I:DEB!)B?:EBXO!(;998FF!*M!#EB?9=EB!EB?!"I;?:8!+E=:BH!.@F@B:EF:9=^!"78!3E7:DEB!EB?!-D7EH7>:D@T8!/8@JF89! EB?!'9XO!EB?! ->8J78B!4M!-:FF:=EBU9!\PQQd]!V.;F>;I8!.@B>ED>!@I!.@F@B:EF:9=_!.7EFF8BH89!:B!>78! ,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!%E>:A8!%@I>7!,=8I:DEXM /E>I:D:E!(;<8I>@B8!\PQQQ]!I8A:8G9!>78!9>E>8!@C!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL! >@GEI?9!J@9> 5 D@B>ED>!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!(; <8I>@B8 \PQQQ^kPf] O!

PAGE 14

! k Vj7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HLU9!E<:F:>L!>@!9>;?L!J@9>D@B>ED>!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!:B!E! D@BD8I>8?!GEL!7E9!<88B!7E=J8I8?!78!;B?8C:B8?!I@F8!@C!EID7E8@F@H:DEF! C:B?:BH9joEB?p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ceQ^fiQ] -:BD8!6I;D8!"I:HH8I!GI@>8!>7:9!9DE>7:BH!DI:>:K;8!@C! >78!7:9>@IL!@C!EID7E8@F@HLU9! E>>:>;?8!>@GEI?9!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9O!B8G!:?8E9!EB?!@JJ@I>;B:>:89!7EA8!78FJ8?! 89>E78!CIE=8G@IT!C@I!<@>7!B8G!8>7:DEF!;B?8I9>EB?:BH9!:B!EID7E8@F@HL!EB?! @J8B8? ?@@I 9 C@I!:B?:H8B@;9!J8@JF89!>@!8B>8I!>78!C:8F?!EB?!>@!78FJ!>IEB9C @I=!:>M! ,ID7E8@F@H:9>!S@8!4E>T:B9O!E!.7@D>EGO!GI:>89!E<@;>!<8:BH!EB!:B?:H8B@;9! EID7E8@F@H:9>!:B!E!D@FF8D>:@B!@C!899EL9!8B>:>F8?! G$(/.2"/92G$,34(/.2>/9(.$/3-)2 C#,*"$363.()%) \PQRQ]M!4E>T:B9!\PQRQ^hPP]!GI:>89!>7E>!7:9!HIEB?=@>78IU9!G@I?9!F8C>! EB!:B?8F:78I!=E?8!:>!TB@GB!>7E>O!:B!78I!@J:B:@BO!:>!GE9!:=J@I>EB>! >7E>!>78!JI8 5 D@B>ED>!7:9>@IL!@C!>7@98!@I:H:BEF!J8@JF8!o>78!.E??@EB! J8@JF8p!B@>!H8>!F@9>j6;>!)!B8A8I!C@IH8>!=L!HIEB?=@>78IU9!G@I?9!EB?! :?8E9M!

PAGE 15

! d 4E>T:B9! E9!<@>7!E!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB EB?!EB!EID7E8@F@H:9>! GE9!F8C>!D@BCF:D>8?! C@FF@G:BH!>78!JE99EH8!@C!>78!,=8I:DEB!)B?:EB!(8F:H:@;9!2I88?@=!,D>!:B!RcieM! +:9>8B:BH!>@!@>78I!%E>:A8!J8I9J8D>:A89!@B!EID7E8@F@HLO!78!9>I;HHF8?!>@!I8ED7!E! =:??F8!HI@;B?!<8>G88B!7:9!HIEB?=@>78IU9!G@I?9!@C!JI898IA:BH >78!=8=@IL!@C! >7@98!G7@!DE=8!<8C@I8!>7I@;H7!9>;?L :BH!>78!EID7E8@F@HL O!EB?!>78!G@I?9!@C!>7898! %E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!G7@!JI8C8II8?!>7E>!B@!9:>8!<8!?:9>;I<8?O!8A8B!E>!>78!D@9>!@C!F@9:BH! >78!A@:D89!@C!>7@98!=;>8?!@ILM!"7:9!9@!D@BCF:D>8?!7:=!E9!EB!)B?:H8B@;9 ,=8I:DEB!EB?!E9!EB!EID7E8@F@H:9>!>7E>!78!F8C>!>78!?:9D:JF:B8!:B!RcehM! )B!RcefO!78!I8>;IB8?!>@!>78!9>;?L!@C!EID7E8@F@HLM!-7@I>FL!EC>8I!78!I8>;IB8?! CI@=!7:9!7:E>;9O!>78!$E9>!48BE>D788!.F@A:9!.ED78!GE9!?:9D@A8I8?!:B!4E97:BH>@B! ->E>8M!6E98?!@B!7:9!@<98IAE>:@ B9!@C!>78! :B>8IED>:@B <8>G88B!EID7E 8@F@H:9>9!EB?! %E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!7 8! 8WJ@989 >78!78EI>!@C!>78! D@BCF:D> @A8I!8>7:D9!@C!EID7E8@F@HL!:B!E! D@B>8=J@IEIL!G@IF? ^ "78L!o>78!.F@A:9!.ED78p!:B>I:H;8?!=8O!<;>!=@I8!9@!>78!9@D:EF!9:>;E>:@B! >7E>!?8A8F@J8?!E9!>78!9:>;E>:@ B!JFEL8?!@;>M!"78!D@BCF:D>!<8>G88B!@B8! EID7E8@F@H:9>!EB?!>78!F@DEF!,=8I:DEB!)B?:EB!HI@;J9!=E?8!=8!9>@J!EB?! >7:BT!E<@;>!>78!I:H7>9!@C!<@>7!HI@;J9!>@!:BCF;8BD8!>78!I898EID7!EB?!>78! 8>7:D9!@C!>78!?:9D:JF:B8!:B!I8FE>:@B!B@>!@BFL!>@!>78!C:8F?G@ITO!<; >!>@!>78! ?: 9D:JF:B8!E9!G8FFj )!<8HEB!8WE=:B:BH!>78!I8FE>:@B97:J9!<8>G88B! EID7E8@F@H:9>9!EB?!,=8I:DEB!)B?:EB9O!:>!<8DE=8!?:CC:D;F>!>@!D@B>:B;8! JIED>:D:BH!<;9:B899!E9!;9;EFM!)>!<8DE=8!@7E>!EID7E8@F@HL!D@;F?! B@!F@BH8I!JI8>8B?!>@!8W:9>!@;>9:?8!@C!>78!D@B>8=J@IEIL! 9@D:EF!=:F:8;! G:>7:B!G:>7!I8JE>I:E>:@B!8W:9>8?O!EB?!I8JE>I:E>:@B!GE9!E!=@A8=8B>! >7E>O!:C!L@;!F:9>8B8?!>@!,=8I:DEB!EID7E8@F@H:9>9O!>7I8E>8B8?!>@! ?:9=EB>F8!>78!?:9D:JF:B8M!\PQRQ^hPd] "7:9!D@BCF:D>!I8ED78?!E!>;IB:BH!J@:B>!:B!RccQ!G78B!>78!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB!*IE A89! /I@>8D>:@B!EB?!(8JE>I:E>:@B!,D>!\%,*/(,]!JE998?!.@BHI899!EB?!GE9!9:HB8?!:B>@! FEGM!%,*/(,!89>E7!JI@>8D>:BH!EB?!9>;?L:BH!%E>:A8!

PAGE 16

! f ,=8I:DEB!9:>89!E9!G8FF!E9!I8JE>I:E>:BH!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB!EI>:CED>9!>@!8:>78I!>78!?:I8D>! ?89D8B?EB>9!@ I!>@!>78!%E>:A8!J8@JF89!G7@!JI@>8D>!>78!JE9>!@C!>78!FEB?9DEJ89!K;:8>8?! A@:D89M!,C>8I!=;D7!D@B9>8IBE>:@B!@B!>78!JEI>!@C!EID7E8@F@H:9>9!EB?!=;98;=9O! %,*/(,!7E9!<8D@=8!9;DD899C;F!:B!DI8E>:BH!D@FFE<@IE>:A8!I898EID7!>7E>!:BD@IJ@IE>89! ?89D8B?EB>9!E9!=;D7!E9!:>!J I@>8D>9!>7@98!G:>7!=;>8?!A@:D89M!#:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL! :B!%@I>7!,=8I:DE!:9!H8EI8?!>@GEI?9!;BD@A8I:BH!>7@98!=;>8?!A@:D89!C@FF@G:BH! $;I@J8EB!D@F@B:NE>:@BM! 0B8!@C!>78!C:I9>!E>>8=J>9!E>! 7:9>@I:DEF EID7E8@F@HL! @C! %E>:A8!,=8I:DEB 9! GE9! ?;I:BH!>78!RciQ9!G78B!V7 :9>@I:D!9:>89!EID7E8@F@HLX! C@D;98?!>78!C:8F? M! #:9>@I:D!9:>89! EID7E8@F@HL!C@D;98?!>78!C:8F?!>7I@;H7!8BHEH:BH!EID7E8@F@H:9>9!>@!9>;?L!9:HB:C:DEB>! 9:>89!CI@=!J@9> 5 9:W>88B>7!D8B>;IL!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!%@I>7!,=8I:DEM! #@G8A8IO!>7:9!GE9! B@>!>@GEI?9!J@9:>:A8!8B?9!>IL: BH!>@!IE:98!>78!9;8IB!>7I@;H7!>78!EID7E8@F@HLO!<;>! IE>78I!>7:9!GE9!>@!I8:BC@ID8!$;I@D8B>I:D!:?8E9!E<@;>!%@I>7!,=8I:DEM!,DD@I?:BH!>@! (;<8I>@B8^ ,F>7@;H7!>78!JI@J@9EF!8B?@I98?!>78!9>;?L!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB!9:>89!@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@H:9>9O!9:>8!>LJ89!G8 I8! ,3/,$+%-"6(&$92"/92 )%#-,%-#$923/2"))-4+%(3/)2"?3-%2%*$2"))(4(6"%(3/2"/92$R%(/,%(3/2352 /"%(F$2,-6%-#$)@2"/92"?3-%2%*$2#$6"%(3/)2352+30$#2"/92934(/"/,$2%*$)$2 (4+612(/2,363/("62,3/%$R%); "78!DE>8H@I:89!98H=8B>8?!>78!7:9>@IL!@C! %E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!EC>8I!RkcP!: B!GEL9!>7E>!EJJF:8?!@BFL!>8B;@;9FL!>@! >78!D@=JF8W!I8EF:>:89!@C!>78:I!F:A89!EB?!8WJ8I:8BD89j'9:BH!>7:9! I8H:9>8I!@C!9:HB:C:DEBD8O!>78!=@I8!I8D8B>!8J:9@?89!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB! 7:9>@IL!G8I8!I8?;D8?!>@!>78!C:BEF!9>EH89!@C!E!>IEH:D!?IE=E!:B!G7:D7! 7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E 8@F@H:DEF!I898EID7!<8DE=8!EB!8W8ID:98!:B!?@D;=8B>:BH! >78!?:99@F;>:@B!@C!BE>:A8!D;F>;I89!:BH!JI@J@I>:@B9!@C! :=J@I>8?O!7LIE?:>:@BEF!@9!:B!EI>:CED>!E998=:CL:BH!>78!F@DE>:@B9!@C!9:>89!@C!D@F@B:EF!8BD@;B>8I9!=8B>:@B8?! :B! GI:>>8B!>8W>9M!\(;<8I>@B8!PQQQ^kPcO!8=J7E9:9!E??8?]

PAGE 17

! i 6L!I8:BC@ID:BH!>78!?@=:BEB>!:?8@F@HL!EB?!J@G8I!9>I;D>;I8O!EID7E8@F@HL O ;B>:F! I8D8B>FL O 7E9!98IA8?!E9 E!>@@F!@C!>78!?@=:BEB>!9@D:8>L IE>78I!>7EB!E!A87:DF8!>@!78FJ! :FF;=:BE>8!>78!9>@IL!@C!>78!@JJI8998?M ,9!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!?8A8F@J8?!E9!E!9;78 RceQ9! EB?!>78!RccQ9O!E99;=J>:@B9!I8HEI?:BH!>78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!J@9> 5 D@B>ED>!%E>:A8! ,=8I:DEB9!<8HEB!>@!97:C>M!)B9>8E?!@C!988:BH!Vj%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!E9!BErA8!D@B9;=8I9! @C!D@==@?:>:N8?!$;I @J8EB!.;F>;I8X!\(;<8I>@B8!PQQQ^khQ]O!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL! <8HEB!>@!;B?8I9>EB?!>7:9!B@>!E9!>78!?8E>7!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB!D;F>;I8!>7I@;H7! E99:=:FE>:@BO!<;>!IE>78I!>78!EH8BDL!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!E9!>78L!9@;H7>!>@! EJJI@JI:E>8!EB?!;B?8I9>EB?!B8G!=E>8I:EF!D;F>; I8!EB?!:?8@F@H:89!:B>I@?;D8?! >7I@;H7!$;I@J8EB!D@B>ED>M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!(;<8I>@B8 \PQQQ^khQ 5 khR] O!V (E>78I!>7EB! D@BCFE>:BH!$;I@J8EB!\EB?!7L:CED>9!G:>7!EDD;F>;IE>:@BO!>78:I!G@IT! 8=J7E9:N89!>78!:=J@I>EBD8!@C!BE>:A8!D;F>;IEFO!7:9>@I:DEFO!EB?!=E>8I:EF!D@B> 8W>9!:B! :B>8IJI8>:BH!D7EBH89!:B!=E>8I:EF!E998=@B8 \PQQQ^khR 5 khP] =ET89! >78!:=J@I>EB>!J@:B>!>7E>!>78!EI>:CED>9!7@F?!>IEB9C@I=E>:A8!J@99:<:F:>:89 EB?! B8G! GEL9!@C!;B?8I9>EB?:BH! >78!97:C>:BH!:?8B>:>L!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!@J8IE>:BH!G:>7:B!E! J@9> 5 @B>ED>!$;I@J8EB!FEB?9DEJ8^ jI8D8B>!9>;?:89!:B!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9! ?8=@B9>IE>8!>7E>!7@G!J8@JF8!E>>ED7!>78=98FA89!>@!=E>8I:EF!>7:BH9! EB?!D@==@?:CL!:?8B>:>:89!:9!:BDI8?:7EB!7E9!<88B! 9;JJ@98?!;IE>:@B!=@?8F 9M!*I@;J9O!<;>!E??:>:@BEFFL! :B?:A:?;EF9!EB?!8A8B!=E>8I:EF!@9!>78=98FA89O!7EA8!7:9>@I:89!>7E>! 98IA8!E9!9@;ID89!@C!AEI:E<:F:>L!I8F8AEB>!>@!D@=JI878B?:BH!D7EBH8!\@I! J8I9:9>8BD8]!:B!EI>:CED>!E998=:@B!@C!>7898!7:9>@I:89! =ET89!9EF:8B>!>7 E>!G7E>!:9!9:HB:C:DEB>!E<@;>!>78!E?@J>:@B!@C!EF:8B! @9!:A8!,=8I:DEB9!EI8!>78!GEL9!:B!G7:D7!>78L!EI8!D;F>;IEFFL! I8?8C:B8?!EB?!J;>!>@!;98M!6L!8=J7E9:N:BH!>IEB9C@I=E>:A8!J@99:<:F:>:89O! >7898!C:B?:BH9!J@98!I8EF!D7EFF8BH89!>@!I898EID7!E9!;9;EF!@B!7:9> @I:D 5 J8I:@?!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9M!

PAGE 18

! e (8>;IB:BH!>@!>78!:?8E!@C!:?8B>:CL:BH!7:9>@I:D!9:>89O!(;<8I>@B8!DI:>:K;89!>7:9! >LJ8!@C!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!8WE=:B:BH!>78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C! ,3/K-()%"93#$) O! 9J8D:C:DEFFL!>78!>IE:F!@C!#8IBEB?@!?8!-@>@!:B!9@;>78E9>8IB!%@I>7!,=8I :DEM!-78! D@II8D>FL!JI@:N89!>78!7:9>@IL!@C!EID7E8@F@HL!=ET:BH!?:I8D>!>8=J@IEF! D@BB8D>:@B9!>@!9J8D:C:D!9:>89!EB?!?E>89M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!(;<8I>@B8!\PQQQ^khh]^ "78!I@F8!@C!EID7E8@F@HL!:B!?8!-@>@!I@;>8!9>;?:89O!E9!:B!@>78I!7:9>@I:DEF! I8D@B9>I;D>:@B9O!:9!B@>! ;BJI@:DMMMo<8DE;98p!EID7E8@F@H:DEF! 8A:?8BD8!=EL!B@>!EFGEL9!JI@A:?8!>78!JI8D:9:@B!B88?8?!>@!EB9G8I! 9;D7!K;89>:@B9!;BE=<:H;@;9FLM!2@I!:B9>EBD8O!=E>8I:EF!I8=E:B9!;98?!:B! ?E>:BH!EB!@DD;JE>:@B!=EL!B@>!JI@A:?8!>78!I89@F;>:@B!B88?8?!>@! J:BJ@:B>!E!9:>8!>@!E! JEI>:D;FEI!?8DE?8!@I!8A8B!D8B>;ILM -78!C;I>78I!JI@:N89!>78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!9;D7!7:9>@I:D!9:>89!>7I@;H7!8BD@;B>8I9! G:>7!>78!D@F@B:EF!GI:>>8B!I8D@I?M!-;D7!EID7E8@F@HL!8WE=:B89!Rf >7 EB?!Ri >7 D8B>;IL! %@I>7!,=8I:DE!>7I@;H7!>78!F8B9!@C!>78!D@F@B:N8IO!IE>78I!>7EB!>78!I89J@B989!@C!%E>:A8! ,=8I:DEB9!>@GEI?9!>7898!8BD@;B>8I9M!(;<8I>@B8!9>E>89!\PQQQ^khk]^!V"78!;BDI:>:DEF! EDD8J>EBD8!@C!GI:>>8B!9@;ID89!<8F:89!E!JI:A:F8H:BH!@C!>7:9!I8D@I?!@A8I!EID7E8@F@H :DEF! 8A:?8BD8!8A8B!G78B!>78!@JJ@9:>8!:9!89J@;98?XM! 68C@I8!)!D@B>:B;8!G:>7!8WE=:B:BH!(;<8I>@B8U9!G@ITO!E!DI:>:DEF!8WE=:BE>:@B!@C! D@B>ED>!EB?!D@F@B:EF:9=!:B!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!:9!B88?8?M! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!->8J78B!-:FF:=EB!\PQQd^de]O! V.@B>ED>O!@I!D;F>;I8!D@B>ED>O!9>EB?9!E9!E! H8B8IEF!>8I=!;98?!9!>@!I8C8I!>@!HI@;J9!@C!J8@JF8!D@=:BH!:B>@!@I! 9>EL:BH!:B!D@B>ED>!C@I!?EL9O!L8EI9O!?8DE?89O!D8B>;I:89O!@I!8A8B!=:FF8BB:EXM!)B!>7:9! >789:9O!)!G:FF!<8!;9:BH!>78!>8I=!J@9> 5 D@B>ED>!E9!E >8=J@IEF!;B?8I9>EB?:BHO!>@!H:A8!EB! :?8E!@C!>78!>:=8!EB?!JFED8!@C!G7:D7!)!E=!?:9D;99:BHO!IE>78I!>7EB!E9!>78!JEIE?:H=! ;B?8I!G7:D7!>78!EID7E8@F@HL!EB?!7:9>@IL!97@;F?!<8!A:8G8?M!-:FF:=EB!I:H7>FL!

PAGE 19

! c DI:>:K;89!>78!:?8E!@C!D@B>ED>!:B!%@I>7!,=8I:DEB!EID7E8@F@HL!C@FF @G:BH!>78!EII:AEF!@C! >78!-JEB:97!:B!>78!Rf >7 D8B>;IL^ )B!G7E>!C@FF@G9O!=L!DI:>:K;8!@C!D;F>;I8!D@B>ED>!EID7E8@F@HL!:B!%@I>7! ,=8I:DE!?@89!B@>!E>>8=J>!>@!;B?8I=:B8!>78!AEF;8!@C!D;F>;I8!D@B>ED>! 9>;?:89!@B!E!O!IE>78IO!>@!:FF;9>IE>8!>78!:B8CC8D> :A8B899! @C!>7:9!>8I=!C@I!9>;?:89!@C!D@F@B:EF:9=M!,9!E!I89;F>!@C!D;F>;I8!D@B>ED>! <8:BH!E!sOs!>78!>8I=:B@F@HL!IEJ:?FL!<8D@=89!AED;@;9! EB?!;B:BC@I=E>:A8O!JEI>:D;FEIFL!:B!>78!DE98!@C!%@I>7!,=8I:DE! D@F@B:EF:9=M!\PQQd^de] -:FF:=EB!H:A89!E!H8B8IE F!?8C:B:>:@B!@C!D@F@B:EF:9=O!9>E>:BHM!V.@F@B:EF:9=!:9!H8B8IEFFL! ?8C:B8?!E9!>78!JI@D899!L 5 @I!BE>:@B 5 9>E>8!8W8I>9!D@B>I@F!@A8I!J8@JF8 q >8I=8?!:B?:H8B@;9 q EB?!>8II:>@I:89!@;>9:?8!@C!:>9!H8@HIEJ7:DEF!<@;B?EI:89X! \PQQd^de]M!#8!CF89789!@;>!7:9!9J8D: C:D!D@BD8J>;EF:NE>:@B!@C!G7E>!D@F@B:EF:9=!97@;F?! <8!;B?8I9>@@?!E9!78I8O!K;@>:BH!<@>7!.7EIF89!0I98I!\Rccf]!EB?!.7I:9!*@9?8B!\PQQk]^ .@F@B:NE>:@B!;9;EFFL!>ET89!JFED8!:B!>78!D@B>8W>!@C!:=J8I:EF:9=O! G78>78IO!C@I!8WE=JF8O!8WJEB9:@B!78!,N>8D!EB?!)BDE!:B!EBD: 8B>! >:=89!@I!$;I@J8EB9!:B!>78!FE9>!dQQ!L8EI9M!#@G8A8IO!E9!?8A8F@J8?! C;I>78I!<8F@GO!DEI8!=;9>!<8!>ET8B!B@>!>@!D@BCFE>8!D@F@B:NE>:@BO!E! A87:DF8!@I!=EB:C89>E>:@B!@C!D@F@B:EF:9=O!G:>7!D@F@B:EF:9=O!E!JI@D899M! .@F@B:EF:9=!:B!>78!=@?8IB!G@IF?O!EF>7@;H7!97EI:BH!8F 8=8B>9!G:>7! @>78I!D@F@B:EF!>:=89O!@J8IE>8?!@B!sC:W8?!@I?8I9!@C!IED:EF!EB?!D;F>;IEF! ?:CC8I8BD8s!\*@9?8B!PQQk^PP]!EB?!I89;F>8?!CI@=!>78!>IEZ8D>@I:89!@C! H8@HIEJ7:D!8WJEB9:@BO!=8IDEB>:F:9=O!EB?!DEJ:>EF:9=!\0I98I!Rccf]M! "7:9!D@F@B:EF:9=!:9!>78!C@D;9!@C!=L!EI>:D F8M!\-:FF:=EB!PQQd^de] 'B?8I9>EB?:BH!= @?8IB!$;I@J8EB!D@F@B:EF:9=!:9!?8C:B8?!E 9!E!98I:89!@C!9>IE>:C:8?! J@G8I!9>I;D>;I89!:B!G7:D7!I89@;ID89!EB?!:?8@F@H:89!EI8!I898IA8?!C@I!>78!8F:>8!EB?! I8=@A8?!CI@=!>78 D@F@B:N8?O :9!;98C;F!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!EID7E8 @F@HL!@C! J@9> 5 D@B>ED>!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9M!47:F8!D@B>ED>!:9!;98C;F!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78! (/(%("62$/,3-/%$#) O!:>!:9!JI@:D!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!G7E>!C@FF@G8?!?;I:BH! $;I@J8EB!8WJEB9:@B:9=M!-:FF:=EB!9>E>89!\PQQd^fP]^ .@F@B:EF:9=!:9!B@>!E<@;>!EB!8A8B>!< ;>O!IE>78IO!E<@;>!JI@D89989!@C!

PAGE 20

! RQ D;F>;IEF!8B>EBHF8=8B>O!G78>78I!A@F;B>EIL!@I!B@>O!:B!E!8=!@C!FE<@IO!I8F:H:@;9!D@BA8I9:@BO!8WJF@:>E>:@BO! =E>8I:EF!AEF;8O!98>>F8=8B>O!EB?!9@=8>:=89!:=J8I:EF:9=M!48!C:B?!:>! =;D7!7EI?8I!>@!J:BJ@:B>!G7 8B!D@F@B:EF:9=O!IE>78I!>7EB!>78!s.@B>ED>! /8I:@?Os!8B?8?M!.@F@B:EF:9=!:9!EB!;BC:B:978?O!?:A8I98!JI@Z8D>!>7E>! DEBB@>!<8!:HB@I8?!:B!>@?ELt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khd]! 9>E>89^ 68DE;98!E99;=J>:@B9!@C!D;F>;IEF!D@B>:B;:>L!>LJ:DEFFL!7EA8!EJJF:8?!>@! %E>:A8!,=8I:DE B9!<8C@I8!IE>78I!>7EB!EC>8I!$;I@J8EB!8BD@;B>8I9O! 7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@H:9>9!:B>8I89>8?!:B!8WJF@I:BH!>78!J8I9:9>8BD8!@C! BE>:A8!HI@;J9!:B!>78!?8DE?89!EB?!D8B>;I:89!C@FF@G:BH!:B:>:EF!D@B>ED>! =;9>!I88AEF;E>8!=8>7@?@F@H:89!C@I!89>E:A8!JI898BD8M! (E>78 I!>7EB!I8FL:BH!@B!>78!:?8B>:C:DE>:@B!@C!8>7B:D!@I!s>I:!<8!7:H7FL!JI@:D!:B!=E>8I:EF!E998=7!,=8I:DEO!>78L!B88?!>@!>ET8!@B!>78!?E;B>:BH!D7EFF8BH8! J@98?!7E>!J8I9:9>8BD8!9@=8>:=89!\EB?!J8 I7EJ9! =@I8!@C>8B]!=8EB9!D7EBH8!\IE>78I!>7EB!E!7@F?:BH!@B>@]M!.@B98K;8B>FLO! EBL!98I:@;9!E>>8=J>!@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@H:9>9!>@!:BA89>:HE>8!7@G! ?:CC8I8B>!HI@;J9!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!=E:B>E:B8?!>78:I!sI@E?9!@C!F:C8s! \Y87@8!Rcck^PQkg!988!EF9@!.F:CC@I?!Rcee]!=; 9>!I8D@HB:N8!>7E>!F@DE>:BH! D@==;B:>L!=8EB9!F@@T:BH!<8L@B?!EI>:CED>9!EB?!9:>89!>@!>78!JFED89! EB?O!>7;9O!>78 FEB?9DEJ89!>7E>!9;9>E:B8?!:>M M "78!D@BB8D>:@B9!>@!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!EI8!8W>IE@I?:BEI:FL!:=J@I>EB>!>@GEI?9! ;B?8I9>EB?:BH!97:C>:BH!:?8B>:>:89!EB?!>78!J8I9 :9>8BD8!@C!TB@GF8?H8!:B!?89D8B?8B>! HI@;J9!>@?ELM!#:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!:9!;B:K;8FL!9:>;E>8?!:B!>78!JEIE?:H=E>:D! 9>I;D>;I8O!G:>7!:>9!C@D;9!@B!9;8IB!7:9>@I:89!EB?!8F;D:?E>:BH!>78!7:9>@IL!CI@=!

PAGE 21

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e >7 D8B>;ILO!>78!3E7:DEB!EB?!-D7EH7>:D@T8!J8@JF89!7E?!<88B! C@ID:78!7@=8FEB?9O!C:I9>!78!)I@K;@:9!.@BC8?8IEDL!E B?!FE>8I!M!"78L!G8I8!I8=@A8?!D@B>:B;@;9FL!G89>GEI? 8B?:BH!:B! 4:9D@B9:BM! $A8B!>7@;H7!>78!3E7:DEB!EB?!-D7EH7 >:D@T8!J8@JF89!7E?!<88B!I8=@A8? O! >78!J8@JF89! D@B>:B;8?!>@!=E:B>E:B E!D@BB8D>:@B!>@!>78:I!7:9>@I:D!7@=8FEB?!EF@BH!>78! .@BB8D>:D;>O!%8G!1@ITO!EB?!3E99ED7;98>>9!<@I?8IM!'9:BH!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?! EB?!>78!7:9>@I:D!I8D@I?!=E:B>E:B8?!78!<:8?!>@ >78!3E7:DEB9O!>78! ?89D8B?EB>!D@==;B:>:89!G8I8!E@!I889>E78:I!DFE:=9!>@!G7E>!GE9! JI8A:@;9FL!D@B9:?8I8?!V8=J>L!G:F?8IB899XM!18>O!>78!I8>;IB!@C!>78!<::F!>78!RciQ9O!GE9!JI@:D!:B!:>9!@GB! I: H7>M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!#EB?9=EB!EB?!+E=! GE9!@@!>78=!o>78!3E7:DEB9p!>7E>!>78:I!<:I:E>8?! 3/612 ?$,"-)$2%*$(#2,6"(4)235230/$#)*(+20")2)-++3#%$92?12,6$"#612(/,3/%$)%"?6$2"/926$."6612 ,34+$66(/.2$F(9$/ ,$ MX!68DE;98!@C!>78!AEHEI:89!@C!,=8I:DEB!FEGO!:>!D@;F?!Z;9>!E9!8E9:FL! >;IB8?!:B>@!EB@>78I!DE98!@C!CE:F8?!I8JE>I:E>:@B!?;8!>@!EB!;BDF8EI!7:9>@I:D!I8D@I?M

PAGE 22

! RP .@=<:B:BH!@IEF!>IE?:>:@B9!G:>7!>78!7:9>@I:D!EB?!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?9!:9!E! J@G8IC;F!>@@F!C@I!8=J@G8I: BH!%E>:A8!D@==;B:>:89!>@!78FJ!>ET8!>78:I!7:9>@IL!:>F8!C@I!>78!C@;I>7!98D>:@B!@C!>78:I!EI>:DF8! V)FF;=:BE>:BH!>78!#:??8B!#:9>@I:89!@C!#@=8FEB?9X!\Rccd^cd]!:9!?89DI:J>:A8!@C!G7E>! 7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!DEB!?@!C@I!8B9;I:BH!> 7E>!>78!7:9>@I:89!@C!>78!J8@JF8!G7@!DE=8! <8C@I8!EB?!97EI8!E!D@BB8D>:@B!>@!>78!FEB?!:9!B@>!?8B:8?!EB?!@JJI8998?M!,9! #EB?9=EB!EB?!+E=E>8!\Rccd^cd]^! ,F>7@;H7!>78!D@F@B:EF:9>!:=EH8!@C!EB!@DD;J:8?!EB?!;B>E=8?! G:F?8IB899!J8I9:9>!>@?ELO!:B!I8EF:>L!> 78I8!G8I8!E!98I:89!@C!EBD89>IEF! 3E7:DEB!7@=8FEB?9!9JI8E?!EF@BH!>78!8B>:I8!F8BH>7!@C!>78!#@;9E>@B:D! (:A8I!AEFF8L!:B!>78!98A8B>88B>7!D8B>;ILM!"78!B;=8I@;9!<;I:EF9!EB?! D@==;BEF!D8=8>8I:89!CI8K;8B>FL!?:9>;I<8?!88B>7 5 D8B>;IL! CEI=8I9!EB?!7@;98!<;:F?8I9j: B?:DE>8!>7E>!>78!D@I8!@C!@B8!9;D7! 7@=8FEB?!GE9!F@DE>8?!EF@BH!>78!I:A8I!<8>G88B!>7E>!o*I8E>! 6EII:BH>@Bp!>@GBU9!D8B>8I!EB?!->@DT:@BEF!7@=8FEB?! D@I89O!:BDF;?:BH!>7E>!E99@D:E>8?!G:>7!>78!48EB>:B@DT!)B?:EB!7@=8FEB?! :B!%8G!3:FC@I?O!EI8!9:>;E>8?!EF@B H!>78!I:A8I!:B!B@I>7G89>8IB! .@BB8D>:D;>!EB?!G8I8!>78!C@D;9!@C!>78!2@I>!7:FF!JI@Z8D>j! "78!.@BB8D>:D;> 5 3E99ED7;98>>9 5 %8G!1@IT!<@I?8I!JI@A:?89!EB!:=J@I>EB>!9JED8!:B! G7:D7!%E>:A8!J8@JF89!7EA8!9;DD899C;FFL!I8HE:B8?!9@=8!D@B>I@F!@A8I!>78:I!78I:>EH8! CI@=!>78!?@ =:BEB>!J@G8I!\:B!>7:9!DE98O!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!H@A8IB=8B>]M!"78!7:9>@I:D! FEB?9DEJ89!EJJI@ED7!:9!AEF;E@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!D@BB8D>:@B9!>7E>! J8@JF89!97EI8?!>@!>78!FEB?!:B!<@>7!>78!EBD89>IEF!EB?!>78!D@B>8=J@IEIL!D@B>8W>9M! (;<8I>@B8!9;=9!:>!;J!B:D8FL!G 78B!978!9>E>89 \PQQQ^khi] ^ "7898!>78@I8>:DEFFL!EBD7@I8?!@<98IAE>:@B9!E<@;>!9JED8!:BA@FA:BH!>78! I8;98!@C!EBD89>IEF!9:>89!EB?!>78!I8@DD;JE>:@B!@C!JFED89!EJJI@JI:E>8?! C@I!$;I@J8EB!D@F@B:EF!98>>F8=8B>jJI@A:?8!D@BDI8>8!EID7E8@F@H:DEF! >89>:=@BL!C@I!?:9J8FF:BH!E9 9;=J>:@B9!@C!E<98BD8O!<;>!EF9@!C@I!I8A8EF:BH! 98B989!@C!JFED8!E=@BH!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!>7E>!EI8!8B?;I:BHO!;BC@F?:BHO! EB?O!>7;9O!9>@;>FL!I89:9>EB>M!)B!9;=O!>7:9!EJJI8D:E>:@B!@C!>78!JI@=:B8B>! EB?!ED>:A8!I@F8!@C!FEB?9DEJ8!:B!9;9>E:B:BH!D@==;B:>L!=EL!@CC8I!>78! =@ 9>!J8I9;E9:A8!EIH;=8B>!EHE:B9>!AEI:@;9!C@I=9!@C!DE>8H@I:DEF!

PAGE 23

! Rh >7:BT:BH!>7E>!7EA8!@<9D;I8?!>78!I:D7B899!EB?!D@=JF8W:>:89!@C!%E>:A8! ,=8I:DEB9t!F:A89!:B!D@F@B:EF!,=8I:DEM "78!FEB?9DEJ8!:9!E!J@G8IC;F!EBD7@I!C@I!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!%E>:A8!J8@JF89!8B?;I:BH! D@BB8D>:@B! >@!>78:I!7@=8FEB?9!:B!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HLM!)>!:9!8=J@G8I:BH!>@!988! @IEF!>IE?:>:@B9!E9!E!HE>8GEL!:B>@!>78!F:A:BHO!7:BH!JE9> O E9!:>!:9!I8=8=<8I8?!@B! >78!FEB?9DEJ8!\-88!%E<@T@A!Rccf]M )B!>78!FE9>!98D>:@B!@C!78I!EI>:DF8O!(;<8I>@B8!8WJF@I89!>78!?:A8I9: >L!C@;B?!:B! J@9> 5 D@B>ED>!%E>:A8!,=8I:DE!>7I@;H7!V.I8@F:NE>:@BO!3;F>:D;F>;IEF:9=O!EB?! .@=JF8W:>LXM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!(;<8I>@B8!\PQQQ^khi 5 khe]O!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HLU9! I8D@HB:>:@B!@C!JF;IEF:9=!E9!E!I898EID7!JEIE?:H=!:9!E!I8D8B>!J78B@=8BEM! 'B?8I9>EB?:BH!J@9> 5 D@B> ED>!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!E9!B@>!@BFL!E!HI@;J!@J8IE>:BH!G:>7:B! EH8BDLO!E9!B@>!@BFL!E!HI@;J!D@B9>EB>FL!I8:=EH:B:BH!>78!D7EBH:BH!FEB?9DEJ8!G7:F8! =E:B>E:B:BH!D@BB8D>:@B9!>@!>78!EBD89>@I9O!<;>!EF9@!E9!E!HI@;J!:B!D@B9>EB>!:B>8IED>:@B! G:>7!>78:I!9;II@;B?:BH9O!I8:=EH: B:BH!:?8B>:>:89!E9!E!=:W>;I8!@C!%E>:A8!HI@;J9O! $;I@J8EB9O!EB?!,CI:DEB9!DE=8!>@H8>78I!>@!<;:F?!B8G!=;F>:D;F>;IEF!:?8B>:>:89M! #:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!DEB!JI@A:?8!>78!I:D7B899!C@;B?!:B!>78!7:9>@I:D!I8D@I?!G:>7!>78! EI>:CED>!E998= 5 D@B>ED>!9:> 89M!(;<8I>@B8!9>E>89^ (8JI898B>:BH!>78!I:D7B899!EB?!?:A8I9:>L!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB!F:A89!:B! J@9>D@B>ED>!%@I>7!,=8I:DE!B8D899:>E>89!E!I8EJJIE:9EF!@C!I8D8B>! D@BD8J>;EF!EJJI@ED789!>7E>!7EA8!:BC@I=8?!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@H:DEF! I898EID7O!89J8D:EFFL!>7@98!>7E>!988= ?@@=8?!>@!I8J8E>!@A8I 5 9:=JF:C:DE>:@B9!EB?!I8:BC@ID8!?:D7@>@=@;9!>7:BT:BH!E<@;>!s=:W8?! 8?!\@I!sJIEL:BH!)B?:EB9s]! A8I9;9!>IE?:>:@BEF!@B89O!EB?!BE>:A8!=8B!A8I9;9!G@=8BM!"78I8C@I8O!>78! D7EFF8BH8!C@I!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL :9!>@!;B?8I9>EB?!>78!?:CC8I8B>! 8WJ8I:8BD89!@C!>7@98!G7@!9;IA:A8?!B@>!@BFL!$;I@J8EB!D@B>ED>!<;>!EF9@! JI@DFE=E>:@B9!E<@;>!EDD;F>;IE>:@BO!E99:=:FE>:@BO!7L:@BO!EB?! I89:9>EBD8M!4:>7!:>9!EDD899!>@!=;F>:JF8!9@;ID89!@C!8A:?8BD8O!7:9>@I:DEF! EID7E8@F@HL!JI8 98B>9!>78!J@99:<:F:>L!@C!?@:BH!=@I8!>7EB!E??:BH! )B?:EB9!>@!>78!JF;IEF!=:W!@C!J@9>D@B>ED>!%@I>7!,=8I:DEM!(E>78IO!:>!

PAGE 24

! Rk J@989!>78!@JJ@I>;B:>L!>@!8WE=:B8!:99;89!@C!:B>8IED>:@B!EB?!:?8B>:>L!:B! =@I8!?8>E:FM!6L!D@=JEI:BH!EB?!D@B>IE9>:BH!?:CC8I8B>!9>IEB?9!@C! 8A:?8BD 8!:B!I:H@I@;9!EB?!:=EH:BE>:A8!GEL9O!E=<:H;:>:89!=EL!<8! I8A8EF8?!>7E>!=@I8!DF@98FLO!:C!B@>!=@I8!EDD;IE>8FLO!I8CF8D>!>78!9J8D:C:D! E=<:AEF8BD89!@C!BE>:A8!F:C8M!"7;9O!@<98IAE>:@B9!@B!=E>8I:EF!D;F>;I8! >7E>!=:H7>!H:A8!>78!:=JI899:@B!@C!E99:=:FE>:@B!@I!D;F>;IEF!9 LBDI8>:9=! D@;F?!<8!I8:B>8IJI8>8?!:B!GEL9!>7E>!DEJ>;I8!E!?:A8I9:>L!@C!8WJ8I:8BD89! EB?!>7E>!D7EFF8BH8!EDD@;B>9!:B!G7:D7!>78!AEI:E>:@B9!EI8!C:B:>8!EB?! JI8?:D>E@B8!D@BDF;?89!>7E>!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!7E9!EB!:=J@I>EB>!I@F8!>@!JFEL!:B! 78 FJ:BH!>@!8=J@G8I!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9! "/9 >@!I8C;>8!>7@98!G7@!G@;F?!?8BL!>78! 8W>8B9:A8!D;F>;IEF!D@BB8D>:@B9!>@!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!@C!>78!C:I9>!J8@JF89!@C!%@I>7! ,=8I:DE^ (8D8B>!9>;?:89!7EA8!<8H;B!>@!I8A8EF!E!I:D78I!?:A8I9:>L!@C!8WJ8I:8BD89! E=@BH!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!C@F F@G:BH!D@B>ED>!>7EB!>7@98!J@I>IEL8?!:B! DE>8H@I:89!9;D7!E9!s>I:9Os!sEDD;F>;IE>8?!)B?:EB9Os!EB?! s=:W8?!@I:89!I8JI898B>!98I:@;9!EB?!@BH@:BH! D7EFF8BH89!>@!F@BH 5 78F?!D@BA:D>:@B9!>7E>!>8=J@IEFFL!EB?!9JE>:EFFL! ?:9>EBD8!%E>:A8!J8@JF89M! "8FF:BH!@C!D@=JF:DE>8?!9@D:EF!:B>8IED>:@B9O! ED>:A:9=O!J8I9:9>8BD8O!>8B9:@B9O!EB?!D@B>IE?:D>:@B9!7E9!=E?8! 9:HB:C:DEB>!9>I:?89!:B!?8=@B9>IE>:BH!>7E>!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!:B?88?! :9!E!JEI>!@C!>78!=EBL!9>@I:89!@C!%E>:A8!J8@JF89t!8WJ8I:8BD89M! 7*-)@2(%2 *")2%*$2 +3%$/%("62%32+6"12"2,#-,("62#36$2(/2%*$2+#3,$))2352#$4$4?$#(/.2 "/92+#39-,(/.2=/306$9.$2"?3-%2%*$2+")%2%*"%2)*30)20*"%20")23#2 "643)%20");22 \(;<8I>@B8!PQQQ^kk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
PAGE 25

! Rd ?:A8I98!I8H:@B!E9!G8FF!E9!E!?:9D;99:@B!@C!>78!7:9>@IL!@C!>78!I8H:@B!>7I@;H7!=EJ9!EB?! EID7E8@F@HLM "78!>7:I?!D7EJ>8I!:B>I@?;D89!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!>78:I!7:9>@ILM!'9:BH!E AEI:8>L! @C!7:9>@I:DEF!9@;ID89O!)!JI@A:?8!E!C@D;98?!7:9>@IL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89O!<8H:BB:BH!G:>7! >78!JI8 5 .@B>ED>!J8@JF89!@C!2F@I:?EM!"7:9!D7EJ>8I!:9!D8B>8I8?!@B!C@;I!=E:B!C8E>;I89^! >78!8CC8D>!@C!D@B>ED>!EB?!D@F@B:EF:9=!@B!>78!F@G8I!-@;>78E9>!EB?!2F@I:?Eg!9;<9: 9>8BD8! EB?!EHI:D;F>;I8!9>IE>8H:89!E=@BH!>78!-8=:B@F89g!,=8I:DEB!8BDI@ED7=8B>!EB?! JI899;I8!@B!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!GEIg!EB?!>78!D@B>8=J@IEIL!-8=:B@F8!8CC@I>9!>@! I8DFE:=!>78:I!7:9>@ILM "78!C@;I>7!D7EJ>8I!FEL9!@;>!>78!EID7E8@F@HL!EB?!7:9>@I:D!9:>89!>7E>!EI8! :=J @I>EB>!:B!>78!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!I8H:@B!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!-8=:B@F8! 8>7B@H8B89:9!\G7:D7!)!G:FF!?8C:B8!:B!D7EJ>8I!C:A8]M!"78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89! :9!B@>!G8FF!;B?8I9>@@?!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!JEI>:EFFL!?;8!>@!:>9!F:H7>!EB?!9DE>>8I8?! BE>;I8M!'9 :BH!<@>7!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!EB?!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?9!)!?89DI:<8!>78! EID7E8@F@H:DEF!8A:?8BD8!EB?!9J8D:C:D!7:9>@I:89!>7E>!97@G!-8=:B@F8!@DD;JE>:@B!EB?! ;>:F:NE>:@B! @C! EB!;B?8I9>;?:8?!I8H:@BM!! "78!C:C>7!D7EJ>8I!<8H:B9!78!D@ BD8J>!@C!8>7B@H8B89:9!EB?! DI:>:K;89!J@J;FEI!;B?8I9>EB?:BH9!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89M!)!JI898B>!D@=J8>:BH!>78@I:89!@C! -8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!EB?!C@D;9!@B!>78!D@BB8D>:@B!>@!JFED8!:B!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!I8D@I?M! )B!D7EJ>8I!9:WO!)!JI898B>!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!8A:?8BD8!C@I!-8=: B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9M!)B! =L!C:BEF!D7EJ>8IO!)!9LB>789:N8!>78!:BC@I=E>:@B!:B!>78!7:9>@I:D!EB?!EID7E8@F@H:DEF! I8D@I?9!D@=<:B8?!G:>7!8>7B@H8B89:9!>78@IL!>@!JI898B>!=L!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!@C!

PAGE 26

! Rf -8=:B@F8!7:9>@I:DEF!?8A8F@J=8B>!>7E>!D@B>I:<;>89!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>7:9!@C> 8B! =:9I8JI898B>8?!J8@JF8!:B!>7:9!A8IL!=:9;B?8I9>@@?!9>E>8M

PAGE 27

! Ri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cc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dRh O!>78!.EF;9E!

PAGE 28

! Re G8I 8!>78!=@9>!J@G8IC;F!J@F:>L!:B!J8B:B9;FEI!2F@I:?EO!?8=EB?:BH!>I:<;>8!CI@=!E9!CEI! EGEL!E9!>78!"8K;89>E!:B!3:E=:M! )B!RdPRO ?8!+8@B! I8>;IB8? >@!+E!2F@I:?E! EB?! GE9! 97@>!78!A:D:B:>L!@C!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!EB?! FE>8I! ?:8?!@C!7:9! G@;B?9!:B!#EAEBEM! .7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!7E9!<88B!TB@GB!!GE9!C:I9>!=EJJ8? :B!>78!9:W>88B>7!D8B>;ILM! "EE:B9 98A8IEF!8WE=JF89!@C!=EJ9!@C!.7EIF@>>8! #EI<@I!EB?!>78!BE=89!>78!DEI>@HIEJ78I9!HEA8!>@!>78!7EI<@I!\-88!EJJ8B?:W!E!C@I! :=EH89!@C!>78!=EJ9]M 134I:6! J -A6!#AB:D>776!XB:G>:!@B76:;A6V?!7>VBY!]H:>C!7A6!)5Z3:>5C657BD!/:>76W73>5!"465WY^

PAGE 29

! Rc -BGD6!J! 8 ,BT;!B5V!%BC6;!>H!#AB:D>776!XB:G>:! 18EI ,;>7@I 3EJ!%E=8 %E=8!@C .7EIF@>>8! #EI<@I RdfP! &:8H@!*;:>:8II8N C4$#(,"$2)(F$2 KF"#%"$23#?()2+"#%()2 /3F"2$%2$R",%())(4"2 9$),#(+%(3 2 2 6Eo7:Ep!?8!);EoBp! J@BD8 Rdfk SEDK;89!+8!3@LB8! ?8!3@IH;89 :63#(9"$ -:B;9!)@EB!B:9! /@BD8 Rdek *8I@B:=@!?8! .7EA8N H"2:63#(9";2C-,%3#$2 !($#3/S2 <*("F$) );EB!?8!/@B>8 Rdci .@IB8:FF8!4LICF:8> :HTU>VC2$%2 CMCHC :63#(9"2$%2U$.(3/$)2 W(,(/"$ 2 6E7:E!?8!.EIF@9 Rii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ceh^RQ]M!2@FF@G:BH!>78!$BHF:97!EDK;:9:>:@B!@C!-JEB:97!+E!2F@I:?EO!-;IA8L! *8B8IEF!@C!9@;>78IB!%@I>7!,=8I:DE O S@7B!*8IEI?!4:FF:E=!&8!6IE7= O D7@98!(@=EB9! >@!<8!7:9!E99:9>EB>!:B!RifcM!!"78!8E9>!EB?!G89>!D@E9>9!@C!2F@I:?E!G8I8!8WJF@I8?!
PAGE 30

! PQ (@=EB9!:B!>78!L 8EI9!RiiQ!EB?!RiiRM!)B!7:9!<@@T! C2<3/,()$2X"%-#"62!()%3#12352Q")%2 "/92P$)%2:63#(9" O!J;78!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!EI8EM! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!(@=EB9!\Riif^P]^ "78!@>78IO!@I!-@;>78IB!DF:=E>8O!<8H:BB:BH!E>!>78!FE>:>;?8!Pi!^!kQ!^!EB?! 8W>8B?:BH!@;>7GEI?!>@!>78!FE>:>;?8!@C!PdO!@B!>78!=E:BO!@I!>@!Pk!^!Ri!^! :BDF;?:BH!>78!T8L9g!>7:9!D@B>E:B9!E!FEIH8!I:A8IO!G7:D7!8=J>:89!:>98FC!:B>@! >78!B8G!7EI<@IO!@C!G7:D7!)!E=!>78!C:I9>!8WJF@I8IO!G8!7EA8!H:A8B!:>!>78! BE=8!@C!.7EIF@>>8!7EI<@IO!<;>!B8:>78I!7EI<@I!B@I! I:A8I!7EA8!<88B! ?89DI:<8?!78!-JEB:EI?9!:B!>78:I!=EJ9O!EB?!>78!-JEB:97!C:978I=EB! ?:9>:BH;:97!>78!JFED8!78!BE=89!@C!:>9!:BF8>9O!G7:D7!EI8!C:A8!EB?!G:FF! 78I8EC>8I!<8!?89DI:<8?g (@=EB9!\Riif^Pee]!E?A@DE>8?!>7E>! .7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!EB?!"E=JE!6EL!EI8!JI:=8 EI8E9!>@!89>E@!>78!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!%E>:@BEF!$9>;EIL!JI@HIE=!\.#%$/]O! V.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!D@A8I9!EJJI@W:=E>8FL!PiQ!9K;EI8!=:F89!EF>7@;H7!GE>8I!D@=:BH!>@! >78!89>;EIL!:9!D@FF8D>8?!CI@=!EB!EI8E!@C!kOkQQ!9K;EI8!=:F89X!\.#%$/!#EI?88!. @;B>L! .;II:D;F;=!*;:?8!PQRR^R]M!3@9>!@C!>78!PiQ!9K;EI8!=:F89!:9!K;:>8!97EFF@GO!EF>7@;H7! ?88J!7EI<@I!GE>8I9!?@!8W:9>!B8EI!>78!=@;>79!@C!>78!3LETTE!EB?!/8ED8!(:A8I9! \.#%$/!PQQQ^hQ]M!2;I>78I=@I8O!V"78!GE>8I978?!8W>8B?9!EJJI@W:=E>8FL!RhQ!=:F89O! CI@=!>78!B@I>78 IB!78E?GE>8I9!@C!>78!/8ED8!(:A8Ij>@!9@;>78IB!$9>8I@!6ELX! \PQQQ^Ri]M!"78!>7I88!I:A8I9!?@=:BE>8!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IU9!GE>8I978?O!G7:D7!78FJ9! DI8E>8!@B8!@C!>78!FEIH89>!EB?!=@9>!98B9:>:A8!89>;EI:B8!GE>8I978?9!:B!2F@I:?EM! "78!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!89>;EIL!7E9!E!;B:K;8 CI897!GE>8I!9@;ID8M!!'BF:T8! @>78I!89>;EI:89!:B!9@;>7G89>!2F@I:?E!>7E>!EI8!=@9>FL!:BCF;8BD8?!78! *;FC!@C!38W:D@O!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IU9!FEIH8!I:A8I9O!9;D7!E9!>78!/8ED8O!H:A8! :>!9J8D:EF!D7EIED>8I:9>:D9M!!+EIH8!CF;D>;E>:@B9!@C!I:A8I!CF@G9!<8>G88B! G8>!EB?!?IL! 98E9@B9!9>I@BHFL!ECC8D>!>78!GE>8IU9!9EF:B:>L!EB?!?:99@FA8?! @WLH8BM!!)B!D@B>IE9>O!B8EI;EI:89!:B!"E=JE!EB?!-EIE9@>E!EI8!=@I8! :BCF;8BD8?!78!*;FC!EB?!EI8!;9;EFFL!G8FF!=:W8?M!\PQQQ^Re]

PAGE 31

! PR "78!I:D7B899!@C!>78!89>;EIL!DEBB@>!<8!;B?8I9>E>8? EB?!>7E>!:9!EB! :=J@I>EB>! D@B9:?8IE>:@B!C@I!>7:9!>789:9 g!EDD@I?:BH!>@!>78!.#%$/O!V3@I8!>7EB!Pid!9J8D:89!@C! 978FFC:97!EI8!C@;B?!>7I@;H7@;>!>78!GE>8I9!@C!>78!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!89>;EI:89X! \PQQQ^he]M!!"78I8!EI8!EF9@!=EBL!?:CC8I8B>!9J8D:89!@C!C:97!:BDF;?:BH!>78!C@FF@G:BHO! :?8B> :C:8?!E9!>78!=E:B!9J8D:89!78!.#%$/^ jO!9J@>>8?!98E!>I@;>O!I8?!?I;=O!:BHO! CF@;B?8IO!@B8!DIEEIJ@BO! HI@;J8IO!98E!I@;>O! -JE B:97!EB?!T:BH!=EDT8I8FO!9788J978E?O!EB?!98A8IEF!9J8D:89!@C!97EIT9M! \PQQQ^hi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g! G7E>!:9!TB@GB!:9!>7E>!>78I8!GE9!E!HI@;J!@C!:B?:H8B@;9!J8@JF8!F:A:BH!:B!>78!"E=JE! 6EL!EI8E!G 7@98!D7:8C!GE9!8:>78I!BE=8?!3ED@ D@!@I!>78!BE=8! @C!>78!>@GB!@I! JI@A:BD8! GE9!3ED@ D@O!?;I:BH!>78!>:=8!@C!#8IBEB?@!?8!-@>@U9!Rdhc!8WJ8?:>:@B \(EBH8F!>IEB9M! 4@I>7!Rcch^!Pkc 5 hQf]M! "78!BE=8!3LETTE!EB?!:>9!AEI:EB>9!:BDF;?:BH!3:EIDEO!3:EDDEO! 3EDED@O!EB?!3ELED@!7EA8!<88B!C@;B?!EI@;B?!>78!9>E>8!@C!2F@I:?EM!2@I!8WE=JF8O!+ET8! 0T8 8D7@<88!GE9!@BD8!TB@GB!E9!+ET8!3ELED@M!)B!E??:>:@BO!>78I8!:9!E!A:FFEH8!@C! 3ELEIDE!@B!SEDK;89!+8!3@LB8U9!Rdfk!=EJ!B8EI!.EJ8!.EBEA8IEFM!"78!CED>!>7E>!>78!

PAGE 32

! PP BE=8!97@G9!;J!EI@;B?!>78!9>E>8!@A8I!98A8IEF!7;B?I8?!L8EI9!D8B>8I9!>78!BE=8!E9!EB! :=J@I>EB>!JFED8!@B!>78! FEB?9DEJ8M! )>!:9!F:T8FL!>7E>!>78! BE=8!@C!>78!I:A8I!3LETTE! D@=89!CI@=!>78!-8=:B@F89g! 7@G8A8IO!:>!:9!F:T8FL!>78!BE=8! =EL<8 @F?8I!@G:BH!>@!98A8IEF! CED>@I9!:BDF;?:BH!98A8IEF! =EJ9!G:>7!>78!BE=8!3LETTE! @I!:>9!AEI:EB>9!>7E>!JI8?E>8! >78!-8=:B@F8!98>>F8=8B>!@C! >78!9>E>8!;IL! EB?!>7;9!=EL!<8!E! VI8=8=<8I8?!BE=8X!E9! @JJ@98?!>@!E!DI8E>8?!BE=8M! ,9!S@7B!3D.EI>7L!GI:>89! \Rceh^ d]!V,9!>7898!8EIFL!J8@JF89!oJI8 5 -8=:B@F8p!F8C>!B@!GI:>>8B!7:9>@ILO!G8!7EA8!B@! EDD@;B>9!@C!>78!=EBL!F8H8B?9!>7E>!=EL!7EA8!I8A@FA8?!EI@;B?!>78!I:A8I!>7E>!G8! TB@G!>@?EL!E9!>78!3LETTEMX!,9!)!G:FF!EIH;8!:B!D7EJ>8I!C:A8O!>7:9!A:8G!?@89!B@>!>ET8! :B>@!EDD@;B>!>78! F:T8F:7@@?!>7E>!>78!J8@JF89!G7@!<8DE=8!>78!-8=:B@F89!G8I8!F:T8FL! 2F@I:?E!J8@JF89!G7@!7E?!=8IH8?!G:>7!@>78I!-@;>78E9>8IB!J8@JF89!9;D7!E9!>78!.I88TM! 2@I!E!J8I:@?!@C!>:=8O!>78!I:A8I!EF9@!GE9!TB@GB!E9!>78!,9>8IBEF!(:A8IM!"78!"EBB8I! =EJ!@C!RePh \988!,JJ8B?:W!, O 2:H;I8!i ] :9!>78!C:I9>!=EJ!>@!E9DI:<8!>78!BE=8!>78! 134I:6! K -A6!,YB__B!03Z6:!@B76:;A6V?!7>VBY!]H:>C!.>I7A@6;7! 1D>:3VB!'B76:!,B5B46C657!*3;7:3W7!`.'1',*a^

PAGE 33

! Ph ,9>8IBEF!(:A8I!>@!>78!3LETTEM!"7:9!=@B:T8I!D@B>:B;8?!>@!EJJ8EI!@B!2F@I:?E!=EJ9! ;B>:F!E9!FE>8!E9!>78!RekQ9M!3D.EI>7L!J@9>;FE>89!>7E>!>78!BE=8!,9>8IBEFO!G7:D7!:9! ?8C:B8?!E9!V7EA:BH!B@!9>8IB;=O!E9!:B!9BET89! EB?!>;I>F89OX!D@=89!CI@=!>78!I:A8IU9! E<;B?EB>!I8J>:F:EB!:B7E<:>EB>9!\Rceh^Rk]M "78!3LETTE!(:A8I!7E9!E!F@BH!7:9>@IL!@C! 7;=EB!7E<:>E>:@B O!?E>:BH!@!>78! /EF8@ 5 )B?:EB!J8I:@?M!-8A8IEF!9:>89!EI8!C@;B?!G:>7:B!>78!A:D:B:>L!@C!>78!I:A8IO!:BDF;?:BH! >78!.I@GF8L! 9:>89!\.I@GF8L!3@;B?!,!e-0iRO!.I@GF8L!#@=89>8E?!3@;B?!e-0iPO! .I@GF8L!)B?:EB!2:8F?!e-0RhhhO!.I@GF8L!(:D8!2:8F?!e-0RhhkO!EB?!.I@GF8L!.I88T! eU-0PhiQ]O!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!3@;B?!-:>8!\e-0hci]O!+:>>F8!-EF>!-JI:BH!\e-0Re]O!EB?! 4EI=!3:B8IEF!-JI:BH9!\e-0Rc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o"E>;=!-EGHIE99!3EI97p!kOhQQ 5 EDI8!=EI97!:9!>78!98D@B?!@C!>78!C@;I! BE>;IEF!?8JI899:@B9!G:>7:B!>78!3LETTE!GE>8I978?X!\3(3..!PQRR^d]M!

PAGE 34

! Pk 3LETTE!(:A8I ->E>8!/E IT!D@B>E:B9!RP!=:F89!@C!>78!I:A8IO!:BDF;?:BH!>78!'JJ8I! +ET8!EB?!>78!+@G8I!+ET8!@C!>78!I:A8IM!2I@=!>78!'JJ8I!3LETTE!+ET8O!>78!I:A8I!VCF@G9! >7I@;H7!E!FEIH8!=EI97!EI8E!TB@GB!E9!6:H!2FE>9X!\PQRR^d]!@B!:>9!GEL!>@!>78!F@G8I! FET8M!68C@I8!>78!RchQ9!EB?!RckQ9O!G78B E!?:T8!GE9!D@B9>I;D>8?!G7:D7!98A8I8?!>78! CF@GO!VE!98D@B?EIL!GE>8I!D@;I98!CI@=!>78!'JJ8I!3LETTE!+ET8!JE998?!>7I@;H7! bEB?8I:J8!-F@;H7X!\PQRR^d]!@B!>78!GEL!>@!>78!+@G8I!+ET8M!!,!9:BT7@F8!C8E>;I8! TB@GB!E9!&88J!#@F8!8W>8B?9!>@!E!?8J>7!@C!@A8I!RQQ!C88>!E>!>78!+ @G8I!+ET8M!! #@G8A8IO!>78!ED>;EF!?8J>7!:9!B@>!TB@GB!E>!>7:9!>:=8O!>7@;H7!:>!:9!D8I>E:B!>7E>!>78! &88J!#@F8!:9!@B8!@C!>78!?88J89>!JEI>9!@C!>78!I:A8IM! $W:>:BH!>78!+@G8I!+ET8O!>78!I:A8I!>@?EL!D@=89!>@!E!?E=!TB@GB!E9!&@GB9U! &E=O!Z;9>!@;>9:?8!@C!>78!9>E>8!JEITU9 <@;B?EILM!,C>8I!8W:>:BH!&@GBU9!&E=^! j>78!I:A8I!D7EBB8F!:9!?88JFL!:BD:98?O!=8EB?8I:BHO!EB?!<@I?8I8?!!98A8IEF!F@DE>:@B9O!>78!I:A8I!CF@G9!>7I@;H7! 7:H78I!EB?!?I:8I!FEB?O!G:>7!J:B8 5 JEF=8>>@!CFE>G@@?9!8W>8B?:BH!>@!>78! I:A8IU9!8?H8O!DI8E >:BH!E!B;=<8I!@C!78!I:A8I! 98H=8B>j3;D7!@C!>78!I:A8I!<@>>@=!<8F@G!&@GB9U!&E=!D@B9:9>9!@C! 7EI?!F:=89>@B8O!EB?!F:=89>@B8!@;>DI@J9!EF@BH!>78!I:A8I!>@=!EB?!>8!#EI<@IO!>G@!=EZ@I!>I:<;>EI:89!D@=<:B8!G:>7!>78!I:A8IM! "7898!EI8!>78!&88I!/IE:I:8!-F@;H7!EB?!>78!6:H!-F@;H7O!@>78IG:98!TB@GB!E9! 3LETTE7E>D788!.I88TM!,>!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IO!>78!I:A8I!G:?8B9!>@!:>9!G:?89>!J@:B>! <8C@I8!8 =J>L:BH!:>9!D@B>8B>9!:B>@!>78!*;FC!@C!38W:D@M! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!S@7B!2M!3D.EI>7LO!>78!H8@F@HL!@C!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!bEFF8L!?E>89! !F8E9>!@B8!=:FF:@B!L8EI9O!G:>7!:B?:DE>:@B9!>7E>!:>!=EL!<8!98A8IEF!=:FF:@B!L8EI9! @F?8IM!"78!?E>:BH!@C!>78!I:A8I!AEFF8L!>@!@B8! =:FF:@B!L8EI9!D@=89!CI@=!9E=JF89!@C!E! I@DT!>LJ8!TB@GB!E9!V.EF@@9E7E>D788!3EIFOX!G7:D7!?E>8!@!>78!/F:@D8B8!$J@D7M!

PAGE 35

! Pd 68B8E>7!>78!3EIF!:9!I@DT!TB@GB!E9!>78!V#EG>7@IB!2@I=E>:@BX!G7:D7!?E>89!>@!>78! 3:@D8B8!$J@D7!<8>G88B!98A8B!EB?!>G8B>L!=:FF:@B!L8EI9!EH@M!" 78!#EG>7@IB! 2@I=E>:@B!8W:9>9!EDI@99!>78!-@;>7!2F@I:?E!I8H:@BO!G78I8!:>!V7E9!I8A8EF8?!AEI:@;9! =EI:B8!<:AEFA89!:B?:DE>:BH!>78!D7EBH89!:B!98E!F8A8F!?;I:BH!>78!3:@D8B8X!\3D.EI>7L! Rceh^P]M!,DD @I?:BH!>@!3D.EI>7LO!>78I8!GE9!B@> EBL!8A:?8BD8!E>!>78!>:=8!oRcehp!>@! 9;JJ@I>!>78!:?8E!>7E>!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!bEFF8L!8W:9>8?!E9!9@=8!C@I=!@C!GE>8IGEL! ?;I:BH!>78!3:@D8B8g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i 5 e]M!3@9>!@C!>7898!9@:F9!D@B>E:B!3LETTE!C:B8!9EB?!@I!@>78I!9EB?L!9@:F9O!EB?!EI8! J@@IFL!?IE:B8? M!,9!E!I89;F>O!CF@@?:BH!:9!E!I8H;FEI!@DD;IEBD8M "78!I:A8I!:9!EF=@9>!F:T8!@B8!H:EB>!FET8O!IE>78I!>7EB!E!I:A8IM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78! 3(3..O!V,>!:>9!9@;ID8!>78!I:A8I!:9!E<@;>!RRd!C88>!E<@A8!=9F!o=8EB!98E!F8A8FpX! \PQRR^c]M!)>!:9!A8IL!CFE>O!8WD8J>!C@I!>78!EI8E!EI@ ;B?!>78!'JJ8I!3LETTE!4E>8I978?O! G78I8!>78!9F@J8!:9!E<@;>!C:A8!C88>!J8I!=:F8O!G78I8E9!=@9>!@C!>78!I89>!@C!>78!I:A8I!:9!

PAGE 36

! Pf F899!>7EB!@B8!C88>!J8I!=:F8M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!3(3..!V-F@J89!G:>7:B!>78!3LETTE! (:A8I!GE>8I978?!IEI8FL!8WD88?!P!J8ID8B>O! 0*(,*2()2,3/)(9$#$9 2 56"% X!\PQRR^cO!8=J7E9:9! E??8?]M "78!3LETTE!GE>8I978?!D@B>E:B9!E!G:?8!AEI:8>L!@C!FEB?9DEJ89M!-GE=J9!EB?! 9F@;H79!E9!G8FF!E9!J:B8FEB?!EB?!JIE:I:8!?@=:BE>8!=;D7!@C!>78!I:A8I9!J7L9:DEF! FEB?9DEJ8M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!3(3..O!>78!8BA:I@B=8B>!D7EBH89!E9!C@FF@G9^ )B! >78!;JJ8I!I8ED789!@C!>78!I:A8I!B8EI!3LETTE!#8E?j389:D!CFE>G@@?9! :9!>78!?@=:BEB>!7E<:>E>!>LJ8j"78!G8>FEB?9!E?ZED8B>!>@!>78!I:A8I!EI8! =:W8?!7EI?G@@?9O!?@=:BE>8?!7!E!C8IB! ;B?8I9>@ILj2FE>C@I?U9!-GE=J!:9!F@DE>8?!<8F@G!I:A8I!=:F8! dc j)==8?:E>8FL!<8F@G!2FE>C@I?U9!-GE=JO!>78!I:A8I!I;B9!>7I@;H7! J@JE97!9GE=J!EB?!=EI97!7E<:>E>9j68F@G!3LETTE!.:>Lj>78I8!:9!E! >IEB9:>:@B!CI@=!=EI97!EB?!7EI?G@@?!9GE=J!>@!DE<E>:@B!I8=E:B9!>78!?@=:BEB>! E99@D: E>:@B!C@I!>78!I8=E:B?8I!@C!>78!?89:HBE>8?!98H=8B>!o2F@I:?EU9! 4:F?!EB?!-D8B:D!(:A8Ip!@C!>78!I:A8IO!8WD8J>!C@I!>78!9EF>!=EI97!7E<:>E>!E>! >78!8W>8I8=8!9@;>78IB!8B?!B8EI!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!\3(3..!PQRR^k] "7898!8BA:I@B=8B>9!JI@A:?8!E!FEIH8!EB?!I:D7!7E<:>E>!C@I!< @>7!JFEB>9!EB?!EB:=EF9M! "78!BE>;I8!@C!>78!I:A8I!E9!E!9F@G 5 =@A:BHO!?EIT!GE>8I!I:A8I!=8EB9!>7E>!G78B!>78! I:A8I!7E9!CF@@?8?!J8I:@?:DEFFL!>7I@;H7@;>!:>9!F:C8>:=8O!>78!GE>8I9!7EA8!?8J@9:>8?! B;>I:8B>!I:D7!@IHEB:D!=E>>8IO!G7:D7!ED>9!E9!E!C8I>:F:N8I!C@I!>78!I:A8IU 9!CF@@?JFE:BM!"78! ?EITB899!@C!>78!GE>8I!D@=89!CI@=!>78!>EBB:B9!:B!>78!@IHEB:D!=E>>8I!>7E>!:9! ?8J@9:>8?!:B!>78!I:A8IM! "78!3(3..!?:A:?89!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IU9!8BA:I@B=8B>EF!EB?!CF@IEF! D@=J@9:>:@B!:B>@!>7I88!JEI>9^!'JFEB?9O!48>FEB?9O!EB?!-;<=8IH8?!,K;E>:D! b8H8> E>:@B!\3(3..!RccQ^P 5 hPg!-88!,JJ8B?:W!6!C@I!C;FF!?89DI:J>:@B!@C!JFEB>!F:C8]M! "78!;JFEB?9!8BA:I@B=8B>9!D@B9:9>!@C!>78!C@FF@G:BH^!V'JFEB?9!EF@BH!>78!3LETTE! (:A8I!D@B9:9>!@C!JIE:I:8!oW8I:Dp!7E==@DTO!=89:D!7E==@DTO!J:B8!CFE>G@@?O!?I L!

PAGE 37

! Pi JIE:I:8O!EB?!9DI;<G@ @?X \3(3..!PQRR^Re]M!"78!8BA:I@B =8B>!@C!>78!;JFEB?9! :9!AEI:8?M!# EI?G@@?9!:B!>78!=89:D!7E==@DT9!@C!>78!3LETTE!GE>8I978?!VJI@A:?8! D@A8I!EB?u@I!=E9>!C@I!B;=8I@;9!=E==EF!EB?!<:I?!9J8D:89!9;D7!E9!>78!HIEL!9K;:II8FO! C@W!9K;:II8FO!D@>>@B!=@;98O!G@@?!?;DTO!8E9>8IB =@F8O!IEDD@@BO!HI88B!>I88CI@HO! 9K;:II8F!>I88CI@HO!L8FF@G!IE>!9BET8O!DI@GO!HIEDTF8O!EB?!I8? 5 8L8?!A:I8@X!\3(3..! PQRR^Re]M!"78!;JFEB?9!EF9@!D@B>E:B!EF>8I8?!FEB?!D@A8I!9;D7!E9!CEI=FEB?!EB?!IEBD7! FEB?M!"78!J:B8!CFE>G@@?9!EB?!J:B8!JIE:I:89!@C!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!E I8!G:?8FL! ?:9>I:<;>8?!>7I@;H7@;>!>78!GE>8I978?M!"7898!>G@!>LJ89!@C!7E<:>E>9!EI8!:=J@I>EB>!C@I! ;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!I8E9@B!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!D@B>:B;8?!>@!JFEL!EB!:=J@I>EB>!I@F8!@B! >78!FEB?9DEJ8!E9!E!JFED8!@C!I8>;IB!EB?!@C!I8C;H8M!"78!C8IEF!7@H9!EB?!DE>>F8!>7E>! >7898! 7E<:>E>9!9;JJ@I>!78FJ8?!>@!JI@A:?8!C@@?!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?! >78! DE>>F8 9J8D:C:DEFFL 98IA8?!E9!E!J@:B>!@C!D@BCF:D>!<8>G88B!8BDI@ED7:BH!,=8I:DEB!98>>F8I9!EB?!>78! -8=:B@F89M 48>FEB?9 D@B9:9>!@C!>78!C@FF@G:BH^!V48>FEB?9!:BDF;?8!7L?I:D!7E==@DTO! <@>>@=FEB?!C@I89>O!G8>!JIE:I:8O!CF@@?JFE:B!=EI97O!8I!9>I8E=O!=EBHI@A8! 9GE=JO!EB?!9EF>GE>8I!=EI97X!\PQRR^Re]M!2@I!9;<=8IH8?!EDK;E>:D!A8H8>E>:@BO!>78! 3(3..!9>E>89!>7E>!V-;<=8IH8?!EK;E>:D!A8 H8>E>:@B!>LJ:DEFFL!D@B9:9>9!@C!=@B@>LJ:D! J@J;FE>:@B9!>7E>!J8I9:9>!;B?8IGE>8I!G:>7:B!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!EB?!:>9!E99@D:E>8?! >I:<;>EI:89X!\3(3..!RccQ 5 P 5 hP 5 hh]M "78!EK;E>:D!8BA:I@B=8B>9!@C!>78!3LETTE!EI8! E9!?:A8I98!E9!>78!FEB?!8BA:I@B=8B>9M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!3(3. \RccQ^P 5 kf] O! V2I897GE>8I!G8>FEB?9!:BDF;?8!G@@?8?!7E<:>E>!9;D7!E9!9GE=J9!EB?!CF@@?JFE:B! C@I89>9g!78IFEB?9!9;D7!E9!G8>!JIE:I:89!EB?!=EI9789g!EB?!EK;E>:D!7E<:>E>9! 9;D7!E9!FET89O!J@B?9O!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IO!EB?!:>9!E99@D:E>8?!GE>8I9 MX

PAGE 38

! Pe 47L!:9!>78!3L ETTE!EB!:=J@I>EB >!JFED8!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89_!2 8IEF!7@H9!EB?! DE>>F8!E9!G8FF!E9!>78!?88I!JI@A:?8?!E!9>8E?L!9;JJFL!@C!FEB?!=E==EF9!C@I!>78! -8=:B@F89!>@!7;B>M!"78!-8=:B@F89!J@>8B>:EFFL!;>:F:N8?!>78!GE>8I9!C@I!C@@?!E9!G8FFO! J@99::BH!EFF:HE>@I9!EB?!C:97:BH M!"78!?89DI:J>:@B!@C!>78!CF@IEF!EB?!CE;BEF! FEB?9DEJ8!<@>7!@B!FEB?!EB?!:B!>78!GE>8I \988!EJJ8B?:W!? ]!JI@A:?89!E!98B98!@C!>78! I:D7B899!@C!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!AEFF8L!EB?!G7L! :>!G@;F?!<8!E!JFED8!>@!I8>;IB M!"78! I8H:@B!:9!A8IL!C8I>:F8!JI@A:?:BH!H@@?!CEI=FEB?!E9!G8F F!E9!9;JJ@I>:BH!FEIH8I! =E==EF9M!)B! >78 B8W>!98D>:@B O )!?:9D;99!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IO!<;>!C@D;9!@B!>78!J7L9:DEF! FEB?9DEJ8!IE>78I!>7EB!>78!CF@IEF!EB?!CE;BEFM!"7:9!:9!<8DE;98!=EBL!@C!>78!CF@IE!EB?! CE;BE!>7E>!;>:F:N8!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!EF9@!;>:F:N8!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IM / 6BW6!03Z6: "78!/8ED8!(:A8I \2:H;I8!h] O!@B8!@C!2F@I:?EU9!FEIH89>!EB?!F@BH89>!I:A8I9O! 8W>8B?9!@A8I!RQd!=:F89!CI@=!>78!78EI>!@C!>78!9>E>8!;B>:F!:>9!8W:>!:B>@!.7EIF@>>8! #EI<@IM!"78!GE>8I978?!<8H:B9!:B!/@FT!.@;B>L!>@!>78!B@I>7!EB?!8BD@=JE9989!JEI>9!@C 3EBE>88O!-EIE9@>EO! /@FTO!#:FF9<@I@;H7O! #:H7FEB?9O!*FE?89O!.7EIF@>>8O!EB?!+88! D@;B>:89O!E9!G8FF!E9!EFF!@C!#EI?88!EB?!&8!-@>@!D@;B>:89M!"78!8B>:I8!GE>8I978?!D@A8I9! EB!EI8E!@C!EJJI@W:=E>8FL!POhdQ!9K;EI8!=:F89!\RMd!=:FF:@B!EDI89]!\2F@I:?E! &8JEI>=8B>!@C!$BA:I@B =8B>EF!/I@>8D>:@B!PQQi^d]M!!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!2&$/ \PQQi^d] O! V"78!I:A8I!?I@J9!@A8I!PQQ!C88>!:B!8F8AE>:@B!CI@=!:>9!78E?GE>8I9!>@!?:9D7EIH8XM!"78! /8ED8!(:A8I!8WJ8I:8BD89!E!=;D7!HI8E>8I!?:A8I9:>L!@C!8F8AE>:@B!>7EB!>78!3LETTE!EB?! 8A8B!D@B>E:B9!@B8!@C!2F@I:?EU9! 9@;>78IB=@9>!8W>EB>!GE>8ICEFF9O!F@DE>8?!B8EI!/ELB89! .I88TM

PAGE 39

! Pc +:T8!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IO!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!7E9!E!F@BH!7:9>@IL!@C!7E<:>E>:@B!EB?! ;9EH8!7!:B?:H8B@;9!J8@JF89!E9! G8FF!E9!8I!J8@JF89M!,F9@!F:T8!>78!3LETTEO! >78!@I:H:BEF!BE=8!C@I!>78!I:A8I!7E9!F@BH!9:BD8!<88B!F@9>!>@!>78!9EB?9!@C!>:=8M!"78! 8EIF:89>!BE=8!G8!7EA8!C@I!>78!I:A8I!D@=89!CI@=!>78!-8=:B@F89!G78B!:>!GE9!TB@GB!E9! >78! 7"6"=,*3+,3*"%,*$$ @I!>78!(:A8I!@C!>78! /8E9M!)>!:9!BE=8?!C@I!>78!G:F?!J8E9!>7E>! 134I:6! L -A6!/6BW6!03Z6:!@B76:;A6V?!7>VBY!]H:>C!.'1 ,*^

PAGE 40

! hQ HI@G!EF@BH!:>9!78!I:A8I!GE9!I8D@I?8?!CI@=!>78!2F@I:?E! J:@B88I9!G7@!TB8G!>78!-8=:B@F8!BE=8!@C!>78!I:A8IO!>78!F:9>8B8I!F:T8FL!>IEB9DI:<8?! VJ8E9X!E9!VJ8ED8XM!"7I@;H7!E!9:=JF8!D@II;J>:@B!@C!>78!G@I ?!J8E9O!:>!<8DE=8!>78! /8ED8!(:A8IO!I8=@A:BH!>78!:B?:H8B@;9!TB@GF8?H8!@C!>78!8D@F@HL!:B!@B8!C8FF!9G@@JM!)>! :9!:=J@I>EB>!>@!B@>8!>7E>!:>!:9!EFI8E?L!E!98D@B? 5 7EB?!>IEB9FE>:@B!EB?!B@>!>78!JI:=EIL! 9@;ID8!G78I8!>78!D@II;J>:@B!@C!>78!BE=8!:9!C@;B?M!3:FI@L!EB?!3:F I@L \RccR^fi] 9J8ET!>@!>78!?:CC8I8BD89!:B78I8B>!<8>G88B!9J@T8B!EB?!GI:>>8B!FEBH;EH8^ "78!EDD8J>8?!@I>7@HIEJ7L!:9!;F>:=E>8FL!EI<:>IEIL!EB?!C:W8?!:@BM!)>!:9!B@>!J8I=:99:@!9J8FF!@I?:BEIL!G@I?9!F:T8! )3"+@2$"%2 3062 E9!v9@EJUO!v88>UO!v@;FO!8A8B!>7@ ;H7!I7L=:BH!G@I?9!=EL!8=JF@L!>7898! FE>>8I!D@BA8B>:@B9O!8MHM! *3+$@25$$%@253-6 M! !! S;9>!<8DE;98!9@EJ!9@;B?9!8WED>FL!>78!9E=8 E9!9@J8O!?@89!B@>!=8EB!9@J8!:9! D@II8D>! EDD@I?:BH!>@!EDD8J>8?!@I>7@HIEJ7LM!478B!>78!DEI>@HIEJ78I!G7@!I8D@I?8?!>78!BE=8! /8ED8! (:A8IO!78!F:T8FL!78EI?!/8E9!E9!uJ:9u!E9!@JJ@98?!>@!uJ:NuM!68DE;98!J8E9!EB?! J8ED8!9@;B?!9:=:FEIO!>78!:99;89!@C!@I>7@HIEJ7L!;F>:=E>8FL!?8>8I=:B8?!7@G!>7:9! D@II;J>:@B!<8DE=8!>78!BE=8M!3:FI@L!EB?!3:FI@L \RccR^fk] 9;=!;J!7@G!>78! ?:CC8I8BD8!<8>G88B!@IEF!EB?!GI:> >8B!D@==;B:DE>:@B!DEB!?:I8D>FL!@I!:B?:I8D>FL!F8E?! >@!>78!8BC@ID8=8B>!@C!>78!?@=:BEB>!D;F>;I8!@A8I!>78!9;8IB^ ,F>7@;H7!9J@T8B!FEBH;EH8!:9!?:A8I98j>78!B@I=9!@C!GI:>>8B!HIE==EIO! 9J8FF:BH!EB?!A@DE<;FEIL!EI8!=;D7!=@I8!;B:C@I=M!,-!G8!7EA8!988BO!>78! EJJ8EF!>@ >78!E;>7@I:>L!@C!GI:>>8B!;9EH8!:9!@B8!GEL!:B!G7:D7! 9>EB?EI?:9E>:@B!@C!9J88D7!:9!JI@=@>8?j"78!=@9>!@G88B!9J88D7!EB?!GI:>:BH!EI8!C@I=EFM!-J88D7!:9!EB!E;?:>@IL! =8?:;=jGI:>:BH!:9!E!A:9;EF!=8?:;=j P*(6$2)+$$,*2",%(F(%12,"/2#$6123/2 "2/-4?$# 2 352)(%-"%(3/"625",%3#)2%32*$6+2,3/F$124$"/(/.2"/92(/%$/%(3/@2 %*$2",%23520#(%(/.2()29$+#(F$92352"/2(44$9("%$2,3/%$R%2352 ,344-/(,"%(3/; \ 8=J7E9:9!E??8?]M )B!>78!DE98!@C!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IO!>78!BE=8!GE9!JE998?!@IEFFL!CI@=!>IEB9FE>:@B!E9!>78! /8E9!(:A8I!>@!:>9!G I:>>8B!D@II;J>:@B!E9!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IM!"7:9!D@II;J>:@B!<8DE=8!>78!

PAGE 41

! hR EDD8J>8?!BE=8!@C!>78!I:A8Ig!9@=8!E>>8=J>9!7EA8!<88B!=E?8!>@!D@BB8D>!>78!D;II8B>! BE=8!@C!>78!(:A8I!>@!E!BE=8!H:A8B!>@!:>!78!=:?!Rf >7 D8B>;ILO! G7@!DEFF8?!:>! U(329$26"2M "& \(:A8I!@C!/8ED8]!\2F@I:?E!0;>?@@I9!PQRP]g! 7@G8A8IO E9!)! 8WJFE:B8?!E<@A8O!>78!BE=8!@C!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!D@=89!CI@=!>78!G:F?!J8E9!G7:D7!HI@G! EF@BH!>78!!EBL!D@BB8D>:@B!>@!>78!G@I?!VJ8ED8XM "78!I:A8I!:9!?:A:?8?!:B>@!>7I88!:@ BO!G7:D7!EI8!C;I>78I! ?:A:?8?!:B>@!B:B8!9;< 5 @!>7I88!9;< 5 @G!-;< 5 6E9:BO!`@FC@!-JI:BH9!-;< 5 6E9:BO!EB?!/ELB8!.I88T!-;< 5 6E9:BM!"78!H8@F@HL!@C!>78!;JJ8I!/8ED8!(:A8I!:9!;B:K;8!:B!>78!GE>8I978?^ "78! ;JJ8I!/8ED8!(:A8I!7E9!E!H8@F@HL!>7E>!:9!;B:K;8!CI@=!>78! I8=E:B?8I!@C!>78!GE>8I978?M!68>G88B!6EI>@G!EB?!2@I>!38E?8!:B!/@FT! .@;B>LO!E!B;=<8I!@C!TEI9>:D!C8E>;I89!@DD;I!:B!>78!F:=89>@B8!<8?9!>7E>! C@I=!>78!I:A8I!D7EBB8F!EB?!E99@D:E>8?!CF@@?JFE:BM!+:=89>@B8O!G:> 7!:>9! 7:H7!DEFD:;=!DEI<@BE>8!D@B>8B>O!:9!8E9:FL!?:99@FA8?!78!G8ET! 9@F;>:@B!@C!DEI<@B:D!ED:?!:B!IE:BGE>8I!EB?!=@9>!BE>;IEF!2F@I:?E! 9;ICED8!9>I8E=9M!\2&$/!PQQi^RR] "78!6EI>@G!-;< 5 6E9:B!:9!F@DE>8?!:B!>78!B@I>78IB=@9>!JEI>!@C!>78!GE>8I978?!EB?!:>!:9! EF9@!> 78!FEIH89>!9;< 5 8FL!Riw!@C!>78!>@>EF!GE>8I978?! \2&$/!PQQi^RR]M!"78!78E?GE>8I9!@C!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!EI8!F@DE>8?!G:>7:B!>78!*I88B! -GE=JM!"I:<;>EI:89!:B!>7:9!7@;H7!EFF!@C!>7898! 7EA8!<88B!98A8I8FL!ECC8D>8?!! \PQQi^RR]M!"78!`@FC@!-JI:BH9!-;< 5 6E9:B!8W>8B?9!CI@=!>78!9@;>78IB!8B?!@C!6EI>@G!>@! `@FC@!-JI:BH9!:B!#EI?88!.@;B>LM!%@>E78!/8ED8!(:A8I!G:>7:B! >78!9;< 5 >F8!.7EIF:8O!47:?? 8BO!EB?!6@GF8H9!DI88T9!EB?!-:BT!6IEBD7M! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!2&$/O!V-:W!3:F8!.I88TO!C@I=8IFL!@B8!@C!>78!FEIH8I!/8ED8!(:A8I! >I:<;>EI:89!:B!>7:9!9;< 5 @>EFFL!8F:=:BE>8?!E9!E!BE>;IEF!9L9>8=!
PAGE 42

! hP J7@9J7E>8!=:B:BHX!EB?!@BFL!+:>>F8!.7EIF:8!EB?!6@GF8H9!DI88T9 I8=E:B!EF=@9>! 8B>:I8FL!:B>ED>!\PQQi^RR]M!)>9!BE=89ET8O!/ELB8!.I88TO!EB?!:>9!>I:<;>EILO!+:>>F8!/ELB8! .I88TO!?@=:BE>8!/ELB8!.I88T!9;< 5 8?!B8EI!6@GF:BH! *I88B!EB?!:9!;J9>I8E=!CI@=!4E;D7;FEM!)>!:9!>78!98D@B?!9=EFF89>!9;< 5 7 8! GE>8I978?M "78!3:??F8!/8ED8!(:A8I!6E9:B!<8H:B9!:B!>78!,IDE?:E!9;< 5 8B?9!CI@=!`@FC@!-JI:BH9!9@;>7!:B>@!>78!D8B>8I!@C!&8!-@>@!.@;B>LM!"78! =E:B!>I:<;>EI:89!@C!>7:9!9;< 5 78!"I@;!9;< 5 78!.7EIF:8!.I88T!9;< 5 8?!JI:=EI:FL!:B! #EI?88!.@;B>LO!G:>7!JEI>9!@C!:>!G:>7:B!/@FTO!#:H7FEB?9O!EB?!&8!-@>@!D@;B>:89M!"78! .7EIF:8!.I88T!:9!>78!FEIH89>!>I:<;>EIL!:B!>7:9!9;< 5 !:9!>78!FEIH89>!>I:<;>EIL! 78!GE>8I978?!\PQQi^Rh]M!"78!>7:I?!9;< 5 78!=:??F8! /8ED8!(:A8I!:9!>78!#@I98!.I88T!9;< 5 U9!FEIH89>!>I:<;>EIL!:9!>78!#@I98!.I88TM! #@I98!.I88T!:9!98D@B?!@BFL!>@!.7EIF:8!.I88T!:B!>8I=9!@C!9:N8!@C!?:9D7EIH8!A@F;=8!@C! >78!/8ED8!(:A 8IU9!>I:<;>EI:89M!)>!:9!A8IL!:=J@I>EB>!>@!B@>8!>7E>!>78!#@I98!.I88T!9;< 5 8I978?!:9!A8IL!DF@98!:B!JI@W:=:>L!>@!>78!3LETTE!EB?!98A8IEF!@C!>78!DI88T9! F@DE>8?!:B!>78!#@I98!.I88T!9;< 5 8I978?!EI8!G:>7:B!J@I>EH8!?:9>EBD8!@C!>78! 'JJ8I!3LETTE!(:A8I! GE>8I978?!EB?!=@9>!:=J@I>EB>FLO!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IM!$A8B! >7@;H7!>@?ELO!>78!?IE:BEH8!;I8!EB?!?8A8F@J=8B>!@C!>78!FEB?!:B!>7E>!EI8E! 7E9!I8?;D8?!>78!9D@J8!@C!>78! I:A8I!EB?!>78!.I88TM!6 8C@I8!?IE:BEH8O!>7898!G8I8!FEIH8I! EB?!>7;9!J@I>EH89!EF9@!D@B98K;8B> FL!=E?8!98B98M!)B!>7:9!EI8E!GE9!E!TB@GB!-8=:B@F8! >IE:F!CI@=!>78!Rc >7 D8B>;IL! >7E>!S@7B!+88!4:FF:E=9!\Rehi]! I8D@I?9 \C:H;I8!k ]! >7E>! G8B>!<8>G88B!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IO!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IO!EB?!F@G8I!"E=JE!6EL!

PAGE 43

! hh "78!C:BEF!I8H:@B!:9!>78!+@G8I! /8ED8!(:A8IM!!"78!FEIH89>!9;< 5 78!I8H:@B!:9!>78!-78FF!.I88T!9;< 5 78!98D @B?!FEIH89>!:B!>78! GE>8I978?!\PQQi^Rk]M!"78!-78FF!.I88T! 9;< 5 8?!JI:=EI:FL!:B &8-@>@!EB?!.7EIF@>>8!D@;B>:89!G:>7! =:B@I!J@I>:@B9!:B!#:H7FEB?9!EB?! *FE?89!D@;B>:89!@B!>78!8E9>8IB!8W>8B>X! \PQQi^Rk]M!-78FF!.I88T!EB?!/IE:I:8! .I88T!EI8!>78!>G@!JI:=EI L!>I:<;>EI:89! @C!>7:9!9;< 5 !9;< 5 7:9!I8H:@B!EB?!>78!8B>:I8!GE>8I978?!:9! >78!S@97;E!.I88T!9;< 5 !>I:<;>EI:89!EI8! #EG>7@IB8!.I88T!EB?!S@97;E!.I88TM!6@>7!V#EG>7@IB8!.I88T!EB?!#@H!6EL!CF@G!:B>@! >7 8!F@G8I!I8ED789!@C!S@97;E!.I88T!:==8?:E>8FL!;J9>I8E=!@C!:>9!D@BCF;8BD8!G:>7!>78! /8ED8!(:A8IO!?@GB9>I8E=!@C!,IDE?:EX!\PQQi^Rk]M!"78!FE9>!9;< 5 7:9!I8H:@B!:9! EF9@!G78I8!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!8=J>:89!:B>@!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IM!"78!.@E9>EF!+@G8I!/8ED8! (:A8I!9;< 5 8?!:B!.7EIF@>>8O!&8-@>@O!EB?!-EIE9@>E!D@;B>:89M!#@I98!.I88TO! -78FF!.I88TO!EB?!S@97;E!.I88T!EFF!=88>!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!:B!>7:9!9;< 5 E:B9!>78!>IEB9:>:@B!EI8E!@C!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!CI@=!E!CI897GE>8I!9L9>8=!>@!EB! 89>;EI:B8!9L9>8= X!\PQQi^Rk]M 134I:6!M!=>A5!(66!'3DD3BC;! !"#$%&$'(%)*+" ]JQLP^776V!>5!7A6!CBT:7B57!7>! 5>76!7AB7!7A6!,YB__B!3;!:6W>:V6V!B;!7A6!";76:5BD! 03Z6:!>5!7A3;!CBT<

PAGE 44

! hk ,B7DBWAB!/B;;!B5V!(>@6:!#AB:D>776!XB:G>: 3E>FED7E!/E99!:9!F@DE>8?!<8>G88B!/:B8!)9FEB?!EB?!>78!2F@I:?E!=E:BFEB?!:B! .7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IM!"78!BE=8!3E>FED7E!7E9!<88B!E>>I:<;>8?!>@!E!-8=:B@F8!G@I?!@C! ;BTB@GB!@I:H:B!\*8@IH8!+;8I!PQRRO!J8I9@BEF! D@==;B:DE>:@B]M!"78!JE99!:9!I8FE>:A8FL! BEII@G!<;>!@CC8I9!K;:DT!JE99EH8!CI@=!>78!;JJ8 I!7EI<@I!>@!>78!.EF@@9E7E>D788!( :A8I! EB?!:9!EJJI@W:=E>8FL!Pd!9K;EI8!=:F89M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!2&$/O!>78!=@9>!D@==@B! 7E<:>E>9!:B!3E>FED7E!/E99!EI8!=EBHI@A8!\D@B>E:B:BH!I8?!=EB HI@A8O!8!=EBHI@A8O!EB?!<;>>@BG@@?!>I889]O!98EHIE99!\D@B>E:B:BH!>;I>F8O!=EBE>88O!EB?! .;!=EI97!\D@B>E:B:BH!9EF>!=EI97!HIE99O!B88?F8I;97O!EB?! D@I?HIE99]O!EB?!>:?EF!CFE>9M!"78!CF@IE!EB?!CE;BE!EI8!9:=:FEI!>@!>78!I8 9>!@C!.7EIF@>>8! #EI<@IM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!2&$/^!V3E>FED7E!/E99jC@I=9!E!F@BHO!BEII@G!7! C8G!DEBEF9!&;I:BH!>78!/F8:9>@D8B8!J8I:@?O!9EB?!EB?!DFEL!=E>8I:EF9!G8I8!>IEB9J@I>8?! EB?!?8J@9:>8?!8I9!=ET:BH!;J!>78!JEI8B>!=E>8I:EF!;B?8IFL:BH!>78!:9FEB? 9! EB?!D@E9>EF!=E:BFEB?!@C!>78!/:B8!)9FEB?!-@;B?!u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

PAGE 45

! hd J8@JF89M!)B!>78 B8W>!D7EJ>8IO!)!G:FF!JI@A:?8!E!C@D;98?!?:9D;99:@B!@C!>78!7:9>@IL!@C!>78! -8=:B@F89O!C@D;9:BH!@B!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!E9!EB!:=J@I>EB>!D8B>8I:BH!J@:B>!:B!EHI:D;F>;I8O! E9!E!JFED8!@C!I8C;H8!EB?!89DEJ8!CI@=!>78!GEI9!EB?!D@BCF:D>O!EB?!7@G!>78!-8=:B@F89! 7EA8!<8H;B!>@!I8 9>@I8!>78:I!9>@F8B!78I:>EH8!>7I@;H7!>78:I!@GB!:=JED>9!@B!>78! FEB?9DEJ8M

PAGE 46

! hf #X"/-)0!-X0))!! [ /6>TD6!>5!7A6!0I5\! X3;7>:3WBD!#>576b7!H>:!7A6!.6C35>D6; "78!7:9>@IL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!:9!:B!=EBL!GEL9!@<9D;I8?!78!97E?@G9!@C! 7:9>@ILM!,!J8@JF8!G7@98!8>7B:D!EB?!9@ D:EF!:?8B>:>L!:9!JI8?:DE>8?!@B!>78:I!D@FF8D>:A8! I89:9>EBD8!>@GEI?9!>78!9>E>8!\:B!>7:9!DE98O!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!@C!,=8I:DE]O!F8EA89!E! ?:9Z@:B>8?!EB?!@C>8B!>:=89!9DEB>!7:9>@I:DEF!I8D@I?M!"@!;B?8I9>EB?!>7:9!JI@D899!:>!:9! ;98C;F!>@!;>:F:N8!=@?8F9!JI898B>8?!>!\PQQc]O! EB?! .7EIF89!$M!0I98I!\PQQi] C@I!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!7@G!>78!7:9>@I:D!EB?!EID7E8@F@H:DEF! I8D@I?!@C!E!J8@JF8!@B!>78!=EIH:B9!DEB!<8!E>!<89>!<8!=:9F8E?:BH!EB?!E>!G@I9>O! D7E;A:B:9>:DM!"78!=8>EJ7@I!@C!>78!VJ8@JF8!G:>7@;>!7:9 >@ILX!@I!VJ8@JF8!@;>9:?8!@C! 7:9>@ILX!>7E>!4@FC \Rcci] EB?!-D@>> \PQQc] ;>:F:N8!:9!JEI>:D;FEIFL!:=J@I>EB>!C@I! ;B?8I9>EB?:BH!7@G!>@!EJJI@ED7!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!D@B>8W>!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89M! )B! >78! JI8A:@;9!D7EJ>8IO!)!FE:?!@;>!>78!CF@IEFO!CE;BEFO!EB?!H8@F@H:DEF! 78!3LETTE!(:A8IO!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IO!EB?!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IO!E9! G8FF!E9!E!78!7:9>@I:DEF!D@B>8W>!C@I!8ED7M!)B!>7:9!D7EJ>8IO!)! G:FF!<8!9:>;E>:BH!>78 -8=:B@F89!G:>7:B!>78:I!7:9>@I:D!D@B>8W>M!2@I! >7:9! 7:9>@I:DEF! ?89DI:J>:@B!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89O!)!G:FF!<8!8=JF@L:BH!E!=8>7@?@F@HL!>7E>!:9!9J:IEFM!)>!:9! 9J:IEF! :B!BE>;I8!<8DE;98!)!E=!B@>!E>>8=J>:BH!>@!J@I>IEL!E!F:B8EI!7:9>@IL!@C!>78! -8=:B@F89O!<;>!IE>78I!<8DE;9 8!)!E=!E>>8=J>:BH!>@!:FF;9>IE>8!E!J8@JF8!G7@98!:?8B>:>L! :9!C@I=8?!;B?8I!?;I899M!)>!:9!?:CC:D;F>!>@!;B?8I9>EB?!>78!EID!@C!-8=:B@F8!7:9>@IL! G:>7@;>!F@@T:BH!E>!?:CC8I8B>!E9J8D>9!@C!:>9!?LBE=:D9!:B!E!7@F:9>:D!=EBB8IM!"7:9!:9!B@>! EB!E>>8=J>!>@!EJJI@JI:E>8!E!D@B D8J>!@C!G7E>!7:9>@IL!=8EB9!EB?!G7E>!7:9>@IL!:9!CI@=! %E>:A8!,=8I:DEB!HI@;J9!:B!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89g!IE>78IO!:>!:9!E!;98C;F!EJJI@ED7!C@I! ;B?8I9>EB?:BH9!>78!D@=JF8W:>:89!@C!E!7:9>@IL!>7E>!GE9!B@>!GI:>>8B!78!-8=:B@F89!

PAGE 47

! hi EB?!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89!<;>!C@I!$;I@J8EB!, =8I:DEB9O!!:9! EF9@!9EF:8B>!>@!I8=8=<8I!>7E>!F:B8EI!D@BD8J>9!@C!7:9>@IL!EI8!E! 489>8IB! D@B9>I;D>:@B! >7E>!E99;=89!>78!:B8A:>E@ILM -8=:B@F8!7:9>@I L 7E9!<88B!GI:>>8B!=@9>FL!IE?8I9O!DEJ> E:B9!EB?!H8B8IEF9O!EB?!9;IA8L@I9M!,B! ;B;9;EF!8WE=JF8 GE9!,=8I:DEB! BE>;IEF:9>!4:FF:E=!6EI>IE=!\Ric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c]!8=JF@L9!I8HEI?:BH!F:BH;:9>:D!9>IE>8H:89!@C!J8@JF8!@B!>78! =EIH:B9M! -D@>>!\PQQc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

PAGE 48

! he )!DEBB@>!<8H:B!E!?:9D;99:@B!@C!>78!7:9>@IL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!G:>7@;>!C:I9>! ?:9D;99:BH!>78!@B>@F@HL!@C!>78!G@I?!-8=:B@F8M! "78!>8I=!-8=:B@F8!:9!@C! :B?8>8I=:BE>8!@I:H:B!EB?!H8B8IEFFL!;B?8I9>@@?!>@!I8C8I!>@!VI;B!EGELX!@I! ,(4"##3/2 :B! -JEB:97M!"78!ED>!@C!I;BB:BH!EGEL!CEFF9!:B!F:B8!G:>7!SE=89!.M!-D@>>U9!\PQQc]!>78@I8>:DEF! CIE=8G@ITM!,B!@J>:@B!;B>:F!>78!FE9>!7EFC 5 D8B>;IL!@I!9@!C@I! J8@JF8!G7@!G:97!>@!9>EL! @;>9:?8!@C!>78!J;IA:8G!@C!>78!9>E>8!GE9!>@!9:=JFL!I;B!@CC!:B>@!7EI97!>8IIE:BM!2@I! -D@>>O!:>!:9!>78!7:H7FEB?9!@C!-@;>78E9>!,9:Eg!C@I!>78!J8@JF89!G7@!<8DE=8!>78! -8=:B@F89O!:>!GE9!>78!9GE=J9!EB?!7E==@DT9!@C!2F@I:?EM! 18>O!>78!>8I=!V-8= :B@F8X!:9!D@B>89>8?!>8II:>@ILM!,9!)!G:FF!8WJ@;B?!;J@B!FE>8I! :B!>7:9!D7EJ>8IO!>78!>8I=!-8=:B@F8!:B!>78!$;I@J8EB 5 ,=8I:DEB!D@B>8W>!I8C8I9!>@! I;BEGELM!!#@G8A8IO! F@BH>:=8!3:E=:!Z@;IBEF:9>! SEB8!(8B@!I8D@I?8?!>78!C@FF@G:BH! EB8D?@>8!:B!78I!<@@T! 7*$2!$6620(%*2M36(% (,) \Rcck]^ j=@9>!<@@T9!9EL!:>t9!sI;B!EGELMs!6;>!)!E9T8?!#@GEI?!09D8@FE! @BD8^ s47E>!?@89!-8=:B@F8!38EB_s ,B?!78!9E:?^ s48FFO!=L!?E??L!>@F?! =8!>7E>!78L!G8I8!D7E9:BH!>78=!EFFO!G78B!>78L! G8I8!D7E9:BH!EFF!>78!)B?:EB9O!9@=8!G7:>8!9@F?:8I9!9E: ?!>@!@B8!@C!@;I! C8FFE9O!@B8!@C!>78!3:DD@9;T889O!s47@!EI8!>7@98!)B?:EB9!G8!988!@;>! >78I8!GEL!EGELO!@;>!@B!>78!7@I:N@B_ 48!DEB!B8A8I!DE>D7!;J!G:>7! >78=O!>78!@B89!>7E>!EI8!EFGEL9!I;BB:BH!EGELO 47@!EI8!>78L_s s,B?! @;I!C8FF@G!9E:?! L8$4(/36"1Y t )>t9!E!G@I?!@C! @;I!FEBH;EH8O!>78! 3:DD@9;T88!FEBH;EH8O!>7E>!=8EB9!G:F?O!E!98=:B@FEL!J:HO!E!98=:B@FEL! 7@I98O!G:F?O!B@>!C8BD8?!:BO!C8IEFM )>!I8EFFL!?@89Bt>!=8EB!I;B!EGELO!:>! =8EB9!E!G:F?!7@HO!E!G:F?!7@I98! 5 E!CI88!=EB[s!\Rcck^RQe] "78!:=EH8!@C!VE!CI88!=EBX!IE>78I!>7EB!E!VI;B!EGELX!:9!@B8!>7E>!:9!=;D7!=@I8!C:>>:BH! >7EB!>78!D@F@B:EF:9>!:?8E!@C!VI;B!EGELXM!!)B!>78!-8=:B@F8!"I:<8!@C!2F@I:?EU9!@GB! G@I?9O!>7:9!:9!EF9@!>78:I!D@BD8J>:@B!@C!G7E>!:>!=8EB9!>@!<8!-8=:B@F8^! .I88TO!#:>D7:>:O!,JE FED788O!3:T:9xTyO!1E=E9988O!1;D7:O!"8K;89>EO! ,JEFED7:D@FEO!.7@D>EGO!EB?!0D@B88!G8I8!Z@:B8?!78I9!:B!>78!J;I9;:>!@C!<8>>8I!F:A89!E=@BH!>78!>7:DT!A:IH:B!C@I89>9O! G:?8!HIE99!JIE:I:89!EB?!9JI:BH 5 C8?!I:A8I9!@C!:B>8I:@I!2F@I:?EM!"78L!

PAGE 49

! hc 97EI8 ?!EB!:B9>:BD>!C@I!9;IA:AEF!EB?!E!D@==@BEF>L!@C!J;IJ@98^! #$5-)"62 %32?$2934(/"%$92?12%*$20*(%$24"/S o8=J7E9:9!E??8?pM!\-"02!PQRR] "78!D@==@B!7:9>@I:DEF!A:8G!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!?:A8I>9!CI@=!>7:9!:?8EO!D7@@9:BH!>@! C@D;9!@B!>78!.I88T!78I:>EH8!E9!?@=:BEB>!>@!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!IE>78I!>7EB!>7:9!=E99! @C!-@;>78E9>8IB!EB?!2F@I:?E!J8@JF89O!9;:BH!:B>@!>78!-8=:B@F8!EB?!3:DD@9;T88! J8@JF89!G8! 988!>@?ELM! U5!7A6!.ABV>@;!>H!X3;7>:Y "78!9>@IL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!?@89!B@>!<8H:B!G:>7!>78!EII:AEF!@C!+@G8I!.I88T9! :B>@!2F@I:?Eg!:>!<8H:B9!G:>7!>78!EII:AEF!@C!>78!-JEB:97!:B>@!2F@I:?EM!!"78!EII:AEF!@C!>78! -JEB:97!:B>@!2F@I:?E!78FJ8?!DE>EFLN8!<@>7!>78!?8D:=E >:@B!@C!>78!J8@JF89!@C!2F@I:?E! >7I@;H7!8J:?8=:D9!EB?!>78!<8H:BB:BH9!@C!9@D:EF!I8:=EH:B:BH!E9!>78!J8@JF89! I8@IHEB:N8?!>78=98FA89!EF@BH!B8G!9@D:EF!I8EF:>:89M!2:I9>!.@B>ED>!ECC8D>8?!>78! J@G8IC;F!J@F:>:89!@C!2F@I:?E O F:T8!>78!.EF;9E!EB?!>78:I!>I:<;>EIL!>I:<89 O EB? O @>78I! J8@JF89!F:T8!>78!,JEFED788O!E!HI8E>!?8EFM!68C@I8!$;I@J8EB!.@B>ED>O!>78!.EF;9E!G8I8! >78!=@9>!J@G8IC;F!J@F:>L!:B!9@;>78IB!J8B:B9;FEI!2F@I:?EO!:BCF;8BD:BH!EB?!D@B>I@FF:BH! E!FEIH8!EI8E!@C!>78!J8B:B9;FEM!,9!EB!:B?:I8D>!I89;F>!@C!D@B>ED>9!<8>G88B!$;I @J8EB9! EB?!>78!BE>:A8!J8@JF89O!?:98E98!?8D:=E>8?!>78!.EF;9E!EB?!>78:I!>I:<;>EIL!>I:<89O! I8?;D:BH!>78!J8@JF8!>@!E!>IED8!@C!>78:I!C@I=8I!98FA89!!@C!$;I@J8EB!D@F@B:EF:9=! G8I8!9JF:B>8I8? E9!9@D:EF!:?8B>:>:89!97:C>8?!CI@=!>78! 3 :99:99:JJ:EB!-@;>78E9>8IB!.8I8=@B:EF!.@=JF8W!>@!.E>7@F:D:9=!E9!8A:?8BD8?!78!.EF;9EO!>78!,JEFED788!G8I8!G8FF! 8B>I8BD78?!:B!>78:I!B8G!9@D:EF!:?8B>:>L!EB?!>78!9D7:9=!@C!>78!@F?!,JEFED788!J@F:>L! 7E?!F@BH!9:BD8!< 88B!8B>I8BD78?M!

PAGE 50

! kQ "78!.EF;9E!EB?!,JEFED788!EI8!<;>!>G@!@C!>78!=EBL!J8@JF89!@C!2F@I:?E!>7E>! DEFF8?!2F@I:?E!7@=8!E>!>78!>:=8!@C!.@B>ED>M!)B!>78!2F@I:?E!Y8L9O!>78!3E>8D;=<8!=E?8! >78:I!7@=8M!"78!.EF;9EU9!FE9>!I8C;H8!@B!>78!J8B:B9;FE!GE9!:B!>78!2F@I:?E!Y8L9M!"7 8! "8K;89>EO!G7@!G8I8!D8B>8I8?!EI@;B?!>@?ELU9!6I:DT8FF!Y8L!@B!>78!=@;>7!@C!>78! 3:E=:!(:A8IO!G8I8!I8FE>8?!>@!.EF;9E!EB?!HEA8!>I:<;>8M!"78!,:9O!SE8HEO!EB?!3ELE:=:! EF9@!DEFF8?!9@;>78IB!2F@I:?E!>78:I!7@=8M!"78!":=;D;E!:B!>78!EI8E!@C!=@?8IB 5 ?EL! SEDT9@BA:FF8!G8I8 EB@>78I!J@G8IC;F!J@F:>L!:B!2F@I:?EM!"78!/@>EB@!EB?!*;EF8! :B>8IED>8?!G:>7!>78!":=;D;E!J@F:>L!EB?!:B!>78!DE98!@C!>78!/@>EB@O!HEA8!>I:<;>8M!"78! "@D@78!<@I?8I!I8H:@B!<8>G88B!>78!":=;D;E!EB?!.EF;9E! J@F:>:89M!2:BEFFLO!:B!E??:>:@B!>@!>78 ,JEFED788O!>78!/8B9ED@FE!DEFF8?!>78!JEB7EB?F8! >78:I!7@=8M!0>78I!9@;>78E9>8IB!J8@JF89!>7E>!:B>8IED>8?!G:>7!>7:9!D@=JF8W!I8H:@B! :BDF;?8!>78!.7@D>EGO!,JEFED7:D@FEO!EB?!>78!EBD89>IEF!.I88T9M 47L!:9!:>!:=J@I>EB>!>@!?:9D;99!@F?!9@D:EF!:?8B>:>:89!>7E>! I8>D7!@C!>78! :=EH:BE>:@B!7E?!E>!F8E9>!E!D8B>;IL!:B!<8>G88B!>78:I!V?8DELX!EB?!>78!I:98!@C!>78! -8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L_!)>!:9!:=J@I>EB>!<8DE;98!@C!G7E>!7EJJ8B8?!<8>G88B!RiQP!EB?! RiQk!\48:9=EB!Rcec]M!)B!>7@98!L8EI9O!>78!$BHF:97!EB?!>78:I!.I88T!EFF:89!9G8J>!:B!>@! 2F @I:?E!?;I:BH!z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

PAGE 51

! kR (@=EB9!\Riif^Pec]O!Z;9>!9@;>7!@C!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!GE9!TB@GB!>@!<8!>78!FE9>!I8C;H8! @C!>78!.EF;9E!;B>:F!>78!.I88T!9G8J>!>78=!9@;>7GEI?!EB?!;F>:=E>8FL!>@!.;78!78!G89>!9:?8!@C!>78!FEB?O!G8!=88>! G:>7!:BB;=8IEI8E=9j0B!>78! 7898!9>I8E=9!G8!=88>!G:>7!9@=8!7:FF9!@C!I:D7!9@:FO!EB?!@B! 8A8IL!@B8!@C!>7@98!>78!8A:?8B>!=EIT9!@C!>78:I!7EA:BH!<88B!C@I=8IFL! D;F>:AE>8?!78!9 EAEH89j "7898!7:FF9O!E=@BH!>7:9!?I8EIL!=EBHI@A8!FEB?O!7EA8!EJJEI8B>FL!<88B! >78!FE9>!I8>I8E>9O!EB?!9T;FT:BH!JFED89O!@C!>78! <3633)" o )(, p!9EAEH89O! 0*$/2%*$(#243#$2+3%$/%2/$(.*?3-#)@2%*$2<#$$=)@29#3F$2%*$423552%*$2 ,3/%(/$/% M!\8=J7E9:9!E??8?] )B!Rifh!G78B! >78!-JEB:97!>IEB9C8II8?!D@B>I@F!@C!2F@I:?E!>@!$BHFEB?O!>78!=EZ@I:>L!@C! >78!-JEB:97!)B?:EB9O!G7:D7!:BDF;?8?!>78!.EF;9EO!F8C>!G:>7 >78!-JE B :97!>@! .;89!>7E>!8:H7>L!CE=:F:89!G8B>!>@!#EAEBE!G78B!>78!$BHF:97!HE:B8?! D@B>I@F!@C!2F@I:?EM!6L!>7: 9!>:=8!>78!I8=BEB>9!@C!>78!.EF;9E!7E?!<88B!?I:A8B!>@ >78 F@G8I!2F@I:?E!Y8L9!78!.I88T9O!G7@!(@=EB9!I8=EIT9!>7E>!VjE>! <"13)2W",3) EB?! .EL@! !-()3 oY8L!489>pO!G8!988!>78!I8=E:B9!@C!9@=8!9EAEH8!7E<:>E>:@B9j>7898!G8I8! >78!FE9>!I8C;H89!@C!>78! <"633)"2 BE>:@Bg! <;>!8A8B!78I8!>78!GE>8I!?:?!B@>!JI@>8D>!>78=! EHE:B9>!>78!:BI@E?9!CI@=!>78!.I88T9X!\Riif^PcR]M 6I8B>!48:9=EB \Rcec] JFED89!>78!<8H:BB:BH!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8!7:9>@IL!:B!RikQ! G78B!.@GT88J8I!78FJ8?!SE=89!0HF8>7@IJ8!E>>EDT!->M!,;H;9>:B8M!.@GT88J8IO!>78! $BHF:97!BE= 8!C@I!,7ELE!\4ETEJ;D7E9:]O!GE9!E!=8=<8I!@C!>78!0D@B88!J8@JF8!@C! G7E>!:9!>@?EL!-@;>78E9>8IB!*8@IH:EM!!48:9=EB!9>E>89!>7E>!>7:9!:9!>78!<8H:BB:BH!@C!>78! ,FED7;E!78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!RikQ!:9!I8E9@BE8!>@! -8=:B@F8!7:9>@IL!\48:9=E B!Rcec^h]M!!,9!8EIFL!E9!RiRQO!.I88T9!G8I8!;9:BH!2F@I:?E!E9! E!7;B>:BH!HI@;B?!EB?!C@I!9FEA8!IE:?9M

PAGE 52

! k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cec^hi]!D:>89!*@HH:B!\Rcfh^dh]!!V"78!C:I9>!I8D@I?8?!;98!@C!>78! >8I=!o-8=:B@F8p!EJJ8EI9!:B!C:8F?!B@>89!EDD@=JEBL:BH!>78!9;IA8L@I!&86IE7= U9!=EJ! @C!2F@I:?E!:B!RifdMX!!48:9=EB!\Rcec]!;989!>78!;<:K;:>@;9!>8I=!V.I88TX!>@!?89DI:<8! >78!J8@JF89!98>>F:BH!:B!-JEB:97!2F@I:?E!<8>G88B!RiRf!EB?!Rifi!>@!J;I9;8!<@> 7! 8D@B@=:D!H@EF9!EB?!JEI>:D:JE>:@B :B!E!HF@ IE?8!E9!G8FF!E9!>ET:BH E?AEB>EH89!@C >78!I8FE>:A8!CI88?@=9!-JEB:97!2F@I:?E!ECC@I?8?!>@!>78=!E9!D@=JEI8?! >@!$BHF:97!D@F@B:NE>:@BM!#@G8A8IO!>@!?89DI:<8!>78!J8@JF8!E9!V.I88TX!:9!JI@:D!E9! .I88T!:?8B>:>L!:9!@BFL!@B8!E9J8D>!:B!>78!7:9>@IL!@C!>78!97:C>:BH!9@D:EF!:?8B>:>:89!@C!>78! J8@JF89!@C!> 78!-@ ;>78E9>M!!-8A8IEF!E;>7@I9!\*E>9D 78>!Reekg!.IEB8!RcReg!-GEB>@B! RcPPg!$>7I:?H8!PQQh]!?:9D;99!>78!@I:H:B9!@C!>78!.I88T!J8@JF89O!=EBL!@C!G7@=!E>>89>! >@!>78!CED>!>7E>!>78!.I88T!:?8B>:>L!G8!;B?8I9>EB?!>@?ELO!ED>;EFFL!?8A8F@J9! D@BD;II8B>FL!G:>7!>78!-8=:B@F89 M!,9!)!=8B>:@B!E<@A8O!.@GT88J8IO!>78!CE=@;9! -8=:B@F8!EBD89>IEF!C:H;I8O!:9!0D@B88O!B@>!.I88TM!2;I>78I=@I8O!.@GT88J8I!EB?!7:9! !988!>78=98FA89!E9!.I88T!8:>78I!\-E>>F8I!Rccf]M!)!G:FF!EIH;8!>7E>!>78! -8=:B@F89!G8I8!B@>!:==:HIE>:BH!>@!2F@I:?EO!<;>!G8I 8!I8>;IB:BH!>@!2F@I:?E!\988!EF9@! ->@ZEB@G9T:!PQQc]M!2@I!>78!I89>!@C!>7:9!D7EJ>8IO!)!G:FF!?89DI:<8!>78!D@B>:BH8BD:89!@C!

PAGE 53

! kh 7:9>@IL!>7E>!EFF@G8?!>78!'BD@BK;8I8?!/8@JF8!>@!<8D@=8!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?! 3:DD@9;T889!G8!TB@G!>@?ELM!)!G:FF!B@>!?89DI:<8!>78!8B>:I8!7:9>@IL @C!>78!-8=:B@F89O! <;>!)!G:FF!<8!C@D;9:BH!@B!>7I88!>78=89^!DE>>F8!EB?!DI@J9O!GEI!EB?!D@BCF:D>O!EB?! I89>@I:BH!E!9>@F8B!78I:>EH8M .TB53;A!#B77D6!B5V!);WBT6!"4:3WID7I:6!BC>54!7A6!.6C35>D6; .E>>F8!78I?:BH!E=@BH!>78!-8=:B@F89!>@?EL!:9!I8HEI?8?!E9!EB!:=J@I>EB>! JEI>! @C!>78:I!78I:>EH8M!,>! ,7 5 "E7 5 "7: 5 Y: =;98;=O!E9!@C!,;H;9>!@C!PQQcO!@B8!@C!>78!8W7:<:>! 7EFF9!GE9!?8A@>8?!>@!DE>>F8!78I?:BH!E=@BH!>78!-8=:B@F89O!89J8D:EFFL!:B!>78!=@?8IB! 8IEM!+:T8!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>LO!DE>>F8!78I?:BH!:9!E!J@9> 5 .@B>ED>!J78B@=8BE!>7E>!<8HEB! G 78B!DE>>F8O!!E?@I9!9;D7!E9!S;EB!/@BD8!?8!+8@B!EB?!#8IBEB?@!?8! -@>@!C@I!C@@?O!G8I8!F8C>!<87:B?!G78B!>78!-JEB:97!=@A8?!@BM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!48:9=EB! \Rcec^hk]O!Vj>78!AE9>!:B>8I:@I!9EAEBBE9!o@C!2F@I:?Ep!@CC8I8?!>78!D@F@B:EF!-8=:B@F89! EB@>78I!E?AE B>EH8 q BE>;IEF!C@IEH8!C@I!78I?9!@C!?@=89>:DE>8?!DE>>F8XM!#8!=ET89!EB! 89J8D:EFFL!9EF:8B>!J@:B>!>7E>!>78!-8=:B@F89!F:T8FL!7E?!8WJ8I:8BD8!G:>7!DE>>F8!EB?! DE>>F8!78I?:BH!JI:@I!>@!>78:I!EII:AEF!@I!I8>;IB!:B>@!2F@I:?EM!68DE;98!DE>>F8!7E?!<88B! EI@;B?!9:BD8!>78!9:W >88B>7!D8B>;ILO!:>!:9!EF=@9>!JI@7E>!>78!EBD89>@I9!@C!>78! -8=:B@F89!?:?!7EA8!9@=8!8WJ8I:8BD8!:B!DE>>F8!78I?:BHO!G78>78I!:>!GE9!:B!E!-JEB:97! 2F@I:?E!@I!;B?8I!.I88T!78H8=@BL!:B!F@G8I!*8@IH:E!EB?!,FE!?89DI:J>:@B!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!F:A:BH! :B!>78!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!I8H:@B!E9!G8FF!E9!>78!-JEB:97!.E>>F8!@C!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I! AEFF8LM!"78!DE>>F8!@C!2F@I:?E!G8I8!I8B@GB8?!C@I!>78:I!I@<;9>B899M!"7898!DE>>F8!G8I8! VE!FEIH8!7!@!4:FF:E=9! \Rehi^fP]M!)B!E??:>:@BO! 7*$283-%*$#/2<-6%(F"%3# \E!Z@;IBEF!J;78!-@;>7!

PAGE 54

! kk ?;I:BH!>78!B:B8>88B>7!D8B>;ILO!H8EI8?!>@GEI?9!-@;>78IB!47:>8!JFEB>8I9]!I8D@I?9! >78!C@FF@G:BH!E<@;>!>78!DE>>F8!:B!2F@I:?E^ 48!7EA8! 9E:?!9@=8>7:BH!@C!>78!>:=<8I8?!FEB?9!@C!>78!/8B:B9;FEO!<;>! F:>>F8!@C!>78!9DI;7898!L@;!G:FF!B@>!988!V %*$2 ,"%%6$2352"2%*3-)"/92*(66)@ X!<;>!8=J7E>:DEFFL!V %*$2,"%%6$2352"2%*3-)"/92 +#"(#($)@2+6"(/)@2"/92+6"%$"-) MX!,9!E!HIEN:BH!D@;B>IL O!:>!:9!;B8K;EFF8?!7E>!)!7EA8!8A8I!988Bg!@B!>78!J@@I!J:B8!JFE:B9!>78!HIE99!HI@G9! =@9>!F;W;I:EB>FLg!@B!>78!JIE:I:89O!=EHB:C:D8B>FL q E>!EFF!98E9@B9!@C!>78! L8EI!>78!DE>>F8!EI8!E=JFL!9;JJF:8?!EB?!CE>M!->@DT!IE:9:BH!:9!E>>8B?8?! G:>7!F899!FE<@I!EB?!8WJ8B9 8!>7EB!:B!EBL!@>78I!D@;B>IL q B@!C88?:BH!@I! 9EF>:BHM!"78!E>=@9J78I8!:9!9@!7:H7FL!:=JI8HBE>8?!G:>7!9EF>!CI@=!>78! 98E!7:9!?89D8B?:BH!E>!B:H7> 5 CEFF!;J@B!>78!HIE99O!:B!>78!97EJ8! @C!?8GO!ECC@I?9!EB!E=JF8!9;JJFL!@C!9EF>!C@I!9>@DT q DE>>F8!EI8!B8:>78I! C8?!B@ I!9EF>8?O!E>!EBL!98E9@B!@C!>78!L8EIM!,FF!>78!FE<@I!EB?!8WJ8B98!:B! 9>@DT!IE:9:BH!:9O!>@!?I:A8!;JO!J8BO!=EIT!EB?!!>78:I!DE>>F8!CI88!IEBH8!>7I@;H7@;>!>78!3LETTEO! C@I >78!AEFF8LU9! JIE:I:89!EB?!J:B8FEB?9 EI 8!A8IL!C8I>:F8!EB?!JI@?;D>:A8 O!G7:D7!)!?89DI:<8!:B!D7EJ>8I! >G@!\3D.EI>7L!Rceh^hf]M!'F>:=E>8FLO!>78!,BHF@ 5 ,=8I:DEB!J:@B88I9!GEB>8?!>7898! DE>>F8!C@I!>78=98FA89O!G7:D7!GE9!@B8!@C!>78!CED>@I9!F8E?:BH!>@!>78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8! 4EIM!$A8B!>7@;H7!>7:9!8WE=JF8!:9!: B!48 9> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?EO!:>!:9!B@> ;BI8E9@BE@! D@BDF;?8!>7E>!9:=:FEI!JI899;I89!8W:9>8?!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89!>7I@;H7@;>!>78!J8B:B9;FE! E9! 7*$283-%*$#/2<-6%(F"%3#2 I8D@I?8?!7@G!I:D7!J8B:B9;FEI!2F@I:?E!GE9!C@I!IE:9:BH! DE>>F8M! SE=89!.M!-D@>>!\PQQc^Rie 5 Phe]! ?:9D;9989!>78!:?8E!@C!V89DEJ8!DI@J9X!E9!E! =8D7EB:9=!C@I!J8@JF8!EA@:?:BH!>78!I8ED7!@C!>78!H@A8IB:BH!J@G8I!@I!>78!D@BK;8I:BH! J@G8IM!$9DEJ8!DI@J9!EI8!EBL!>LJ8!@C!DI@J!>7E>!:9!F@G 5 =E:B>8BEBD8!EB?!;9;EFFL!F@G 5 A:9:<:F:>LM!$WE=JF89!>7E>!-D@>>!JI@A:?89!:BDF;?8!>;< 8I9!EB?!9G88>!J@>E>@89! \PQQc^Rcd]M!47:F8!-D@>>U9!G@IT!?8EF9!G:>7!>78!7:H7FEB?9!@C!-@;>78E9>!,9:EO!7:9! 98D>:@B!@B!89DEJ8!EHI:D;F>;I8!:BDF;?89!98A8IEF!8WE=JF89!CI@=!>78!%8G!4@IF?M!!2@I!

PAGE 55

! kd >78!-8=:B@F89O!7:9!=@9>!EJI@J@9!8WE=JF8!:9!@C!3EI@@B!D@==;B:>:89!:B!%@I>7 ,=8I:DE^ (;BEGEL!9FEA89!DF;9>8I8?!:B!JI8D:98FL!>7@98!@;> 5 @C 5 >78 5 GEL!JFED89!o:M8M! /EF=EI89!:B!6IEN:FO!&;>D7!*;:EBE!\-;I:BE=]O!SE=E:DEO!.; 5 &@=:BH;8O!E9!G8FF!E9!:B!2F@I:?E!EB?!@B!>78!b:IH:B:E 5 %@I>7! .EI@F:BE!<@I?8I!:B!>78!*I8E>!&:9=EF!-GE=JMp !! G78I8!>78L!D@;F?!B@>! 8E9:FL!<8!C@;B?^!9GE=J9O!I@;H7!=@;B>E:B!D@;B>ILO!?88J!C@I89>9O! >IEDTF899!GE9>89M!"78L!D7@98O!G78B!J@99::@B9! EDD899:IE:F!>7E>!D@;F?!<8!7! >7@IB9!EB?!>IEJ9!EB?!@<98IA8?!8E9:F LM!+:T8!9O!>78L!JI8JEI8?! 89DEJ8!I@;>89!:B!DE98!>78L!G8I8!C@;B?!EB?!>78:I!?8C8B989!CE:F8?M! -7:C>:BH!D;F>:AE>:@BO!9;JJF8=8B>8?!IE?8O!EB?!>78C>O!GE9! >78!D@==@B89>!=EI@@B!JIED>:D8M!"78L!JI8C8II8?!>@!JFEB>!I@@>!DI@J9!!! \C@I!8WE=JF8O!=EB:@DuD E99EAEO!LE=9O!EB?!9G88>!J@>E>@89]O!G7:D7!G8I8! ;B@<>I;9:A8!EB?!D@;F?!<8!F8C>!:B!>78!HI@;B?!>@!<8!7EIA89>8?!E>!F8:9;I8M! &8J8B?:BH!@B!7@G!98D;I8!>78!9:>8!GE9O!>78L!=:H7>!JFEB>!=@I8! J8I=EB8B>!DI@J9O!9;D7!E9!E:B9O!?IL!I:D8O!=E:N8O! HI@;B?B;>9O!9K;E 97O!EB?!A8H8>E!9;D7!DI@J9!D@;F?!=@I8!8E9:FL! <8!98:N8?!@I!?89>I@L8?M!-@=8!@C!>7898!D@==;B:>:89!G8I8!97@I> 5 F:A8?O! @>78I9!9;IA:A8?!C@I!H8B8IE>:@B9M!!\PQQc^RcQ]! +:T8!>78!3EI@@B!D@==;B:>:89!-D@>>!?89DI:<89O!>78!-8=:B@F89!;>:F:N8?!>7:9!>LJ8!@C! EHI:D;F >;I8!E9!G8FFM!SE=89!,M!#8B97EFF!\Reek]!I8J@I>9!>7E>!>78!-8=:B@F89!G8I8! D;F>:AE>:BH!89DEJ8!DI@J9!E9!FE>8!E9!Reek!EB?!8BHEH:BH!:B!7;B>:BH!EB?!HE>78I:BH^ "7898!)B?:EB9!F8E?!E!K;:8>O!J8ED8E@IEF!F:C8O! D;F>:AE>:BH!C:8F?9!@C!D@IBO! +-4+=(/)@2)0$$ %2+3%"%3$)@2?$"/) O!DM!:B!>78!I:D7!7E=ET9!o )(, p!@B!>78!E?ZED8B>!:9FEB?9O!>78:I!A:FFEH89! <8:BH!:B!>78!J:B89!@B!>78!<@I?8I!@C!>78!=E:BFEB?M!"78L!EF9@!=ET8! 9>EID7!CI@=!>78! Z=34+%($ OX!@I!G:F?!EII@GI@@>O!G7:D7!HI@G9! E<;B?EB>FL!:B!>78!J:B8!G@@?9O!EB?!: B!>78!G:B>8I!>78L!7;B>!?88I!EB?! <8EI9M!!\Reek^RdcO!8=J7E9:9!E??8?] /;=JT:B9O!<8EB9O!EB?!9G88>!J@>E>@89!EI8!F@G!=E:B>8BEBD8O!F@G!A:9:<:F:>L!C@@?M! "78I8!EI8!:B?:DE>:@B9!:B!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!EB?!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?9 >7E>!EFF!>7I88! 9>EJF8!DI@J9 G8I8!:=J@I>EB> >@!-8=:B@F8!EB?!3EI@@B!D@==;B:>:89!:B!2F@I:?E!9;D7! E9!E>!,BH@FE!EF@BH!>78!3EBE>88!(:A8I!\6EIE=!PQRP]!EB?!E>!>78!%8HI@!2@I>!@B!>78! ,JEFED7:D@FE!(:A8I!\'978IG@@?!PQRRg!6EIE=!PQRP]M!"78!-8=:B@F89!DF8EI8?!FEB?!@B!

PAGE 56

! kf >78!8E9>8IB!8?H8!@C!>78!$A8IHFE?8!C@I!EII@GI@@ >!D;F>:AE>:@B!EDD@I?:BH!>@!(@<8I>!,M! "ELF@I!\RccR^hQR]O!9@;ID:BH!>78!9E=8! 83-%*$#/2<-6%(F"%3#2 EI>:DF8!CI@=!E<@A8!CI@=! 97@I>FL!EC>8I!>78!D@BDF;9:@B!@C!>78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EIO!9>E>:BH!V"7898!C;H:>:A89!T8J>! >@!>78=98FA89!EB?!G@IT8?!E>!DF8EI:BH!FEB?!:B!>78!8E9 >8IB!JEI>!@C!>78!$A8IHFE?89!C@I! >78!D;F>:AE>:@B!@C!EII@GI@@>XM!68DE;98!EII@GI@@>!:9!E!9=EFF!JFEB>O!:>!:9!F:T8FL!>7E>!>78! -8=:B@F89!8BHEH8?!:B!E!C@I=!@C!9G:??8B!EHI:D;F>;I8O!G7:D7!SE=89!.M!-D@>>! \PQQc^Red]!9>E>89!:9!EB!E?EJ>E>:@B!:B!F:B8!G:>7!89DEJ8!DI@J9M! "7:9!=@?8F!JI@A:?8?!>!>@GEI ?9!89DEJ8!EHI:D;F>;I8!C:>9! G:>7!-8=:B@F8!EHI:D;F>;I8O!G7:D7!D@B>:B;8?!>@! E>!F8E9>!>78!8EIFL!RcdQ9!I:H7>!<8C@I8!>78!"I:<8!GE9!I8D@HB:N8?!78!28?8IEF! *@A8I B=8B>!:B!Rcdi! \ 2:H;I8! d ]M .@IB!EB?! EB>!:B! -8=:B@F8! EHI:D;F>;I8!8A8B! >7@;H7!<@>7!EI8! ?8D:?8?FL!=@I8! :B>8B9:A8!>@! D;F>:AE>8!EB?!=;D7! =@I8!A:9:! :9!H E:B8?!:B! 134I:6!N!9c3DD36!&;W6>DBd;!H36DV!c34 #YT:6;;!=B5!dNL!TICT_35;?!7B:>?!WB56?!V6BV! W>:5F!]+>4435!#>DD6W73>5!c>b!O!1>DV6:!9.6C35>D6!/A>7>;!eJF^

PAGE 57

! ki D;F>;IEF!:?8B>:>L!EB?!JI89>:H8!@;>G8:H79!>78!E?AEB>EH89!>7E>!89DEJ8!DI@J9!JI@A:?8M! )B!D@IBO!>78!-8=:B@F8!C@;B?!E!D@BB8D>:@B!>@!>78:I!JE9>!:B!>78!*I88B!.@IB!&EBD8!EB?! 6;9T!D8I8=@B:89!\48:9=EB!RcecO!Rccc]M!"78!*I88B!.@IB!&EBD8!EB?!6;9T! D8I8=@B:89!EI 8!>78!F:A:BH!?89D8B?EB>9!@C!>78!-@;>78E9>8IB!.8I8=@B:EF!.@=JF8WO! G7:D7!HI8G!@;>!@C!>78!3:99:99:JJ:EB!J8I:@?!EB?!J@>8B>:EFFLO!#@J8G8FF:EB!>IE?:>:@B9M! )B>I:H;:BH!EI>:CED>9!CI@=!>78!.IL9>EF!(:A8I!=@;B?9!\3:FEB:D7!Rccc]!J@:B>!>@GEI?9!E! #@J8G8FF:EB!EB?!>78B!3:9 9:99:JJ:EB!:B>8IED>:A8!9J78I8O!:B!G7:D7!H@@?9!CI@=!2F@I:?E! 9;D7!E9!978FF!G8I8!>IE?8?!EF@BH!FEIH8!>IE?8!B8>G@IT9O!EF@BH!G7:D7!>78!3:99:99:JJ:EB! EB?!;F>:=E>8FL!-@;>78E9>8IB!.8I8=@B:EF!.@=JF8W89!G8I8!8WJ@I>8?!CI@=!2F@I:?EM! 6EBEBE9!EI8!EF9@!9:HB:C:DEB>!E9!JI89 >:H8!:>8=9M!"78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EIO!EDD@I?:BH!>@! F@I8!EB?!9@=8!EID7:AEF!I8D@I?9!\.EB@AE!RcQf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

PAGE 58

! ke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i] M!&;I:BH!>7:9!J8I:@?O!E!9>I@BH!%E>:A:9>!=@A8=8B>! <8HEB!E9!G8FFO!F8?!78!JI@J78>!"8D;=987O!:BCF;8BD:BH!=EBL!?:CC8I8B>!J8@JF89!>@! A:@F8B>FL!I89 :9>!,=8I:DEB!8BDI@ED7=8B>!@B!>78:I!FEB?9M!3EBL!@C!>7898!D@BCF:D>9!>@@T! JFED8!:B!>78!<@I?8IFEB?9O!G78I8!>8II:>@I:EF!D@B>I@F!GE9!@C>8B!97:C>:BHM!"78!%E>:A:9>! =@A8=8B>!:B9J:I8?!7!6I:>:97!8BD@;IEH8=8B>O!9JEIT8?!D@BCF:D>9!:B! >78!<@I?8IFEB?9!@C!E L@;BH!'B:>8?!->E>89!@C!,=8I:DE!\.FEA:B!PQRR^Reh]M!"78!.I88T! 4EI!GE9!@B8!9;D7!<@I?8IFEB?!D@BCF:D>M!"78!.I88T!4EI!GE9!C:I9>!EB?!C@I8=@9>O!E!D:A:F! GEI!<8>G88B!>78!%E>:A:9>!(8?!->:DT!.I88T9!EB?!>78:I!EFF:89!:B!>78!.I88T!BE>:@B! EHE:B9>!>78!+@G8I!.I88T9!G7@!G8I 8!B@=:BEFFL!EFF:89!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89M!"78!?8C8E>! @C!>78!(8?!->:DT!.I88T9!78!+@G8I!.I88T9!F8?!>@!>78!:BCF;W!@C!(8?!->:DT!.I88T! I8C;H889!:B>@!-JEB:97!+E!2F@I:?EO!:BDF;?:BH!>78!L@;BH!09D8@FEM "78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8!4EI!<8HEB!:B!ReRk!@B!>78!788F9!@C!>78!.I8 8T!4EIO!G7:D7! IEH8?!CI@=!ReRh!>:FF!ReRkM!"7:9!GEIO!F:T8!>78!.I88T!4EIO!>@@T!JFED8!:B!>78! :B>8IBE>:@BEF!D@B>8W>!@C!>78!4EI!@C!ReRPM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!4:FF:E=!-M!68FT@!\PQRR^dk]O! V0B!E!D@F?!EB?!G8>!=@IB:BH!:B!8EIFL!3EID7!ReReO!E!9:N8E:BH8B>!@C!'M-M!

PAGE 59

! kc I8H;FE I9O!=:F:>:EO!A@F;B>88I9O!EB?!.I88T!GEII:@I9!;B?8I!>78!?:I8D>!D@==EB?!@C!3EZ@I! *8B8IEF!,B?I8G!SEDT9@B!?8JEI>8?!2@I>!-D@>>!:B!*8@IH:E!EB?!DI@998?!:B>@!-JEB:97! 2F@I:?EM!"78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8!4EI!7E?!D@==8BD8?MX! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!68FT@^ "7:9!988=:BHFL!78!A@FE>:F8!EB?!CE@IL!@C!'M-M! 8WJEB9:@B!GE9!EBL>7:BH!<;>!EB!:9@FE>8?!:BD:?8B>M!)>!JI@A8?!=@I8!>7EB! E!9:=JF8!8WJ8?:>:@B!@;>C:>>8?!9@F8FL!>@!J;B:97!7@9>:F8!)B?:EB9g!:>!GE9!E9! =;D7O!:C!B@>!=@I8O!E!DE=JE:HB!>@!J;IH8!>78!6I:>:97!CI@=!>78!*;FC!-@;>7! < @I?8IFEB?9O!EB!@:A8!FE;BD78?!98A8IEF!L8EI9!JI:@I q :>!GE9O!:B! 97@I>O! "/2$+(63.-$2%32%*$2P"#2352DED[ M!"78!CE>8!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!:B! ReReO!>78I8C@I8O!7E?!E9!=;D7O!EB?!:B!9@=8!DE989!=@I8O!>@!?@!G:>7! G:?89JI8E?!,=8I:DEB!,BHF@J7@<:EO!G:>7!>78!:B>8B98!C8EI9!@C 6I:>:97! :BCF;8BD8!EB?!ED>:A:>L!:B!-JEB:97!2F@I:?EM!\PQRR^dk 5 ddO!8=J7E9:9! E??8?] "7898!C8EI9!G8I8!I8EF!E9!68FT@!J@:B>9!@;>!E9!>78!:B>I:H;89!@C!6I:>:97!@CC:D8I9!EB?! C:F:<;9>8I9!:B!-JEB:97!+E!2F@I:?E!E9!G8FF!E9!:B!>78!4EI!@C!ReRP!ED>:A8FL!9GEL8?!>78! @J:B:@B 9!@C!<@>7!-8=:B@F89!EB?!.I88T9!\PQRR^dc]M!)B!ReRkO!*8B8IEF!SEDT9@B!E>>EDT8?! /8B9ED@FE!G78I8!>78!6I:>:97!G8I8!E>>8=J>:BH!>@!E=E99!E!C@ID8!>@!9G88J!>78! ,=8I:DEB9!@;>!@C!3@<:F8!EB?!;F>:=E>8FL!D;>!@CC!EW:9!>@!>78!*;FC!.@E9>M!"7:9!>F8O! DF8EIFL!EB!ED>!@C!>78! 4EI!@C!ReRPO!DEB!EF9@!<8!D@B9:?8I8?!E9!E!JI8K;8F!>@!>78!2:I9>! -8=:B@F8!4EIM "@!;B?8I9>EB?!G7L!>78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8!4EI!DEB!<8!;B?8I9>@@?!E9!E!D@I@FFEIL! >@!>78!4EI!@C!ReRPO!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!=;9>!<8!8WE=:B8?M!"78!<@I?8IFEB?9!@C!-JEB:97!+E! 2F@I:?E!:BDF;?8?O!$BHF: 97!D@F@B:89!EB?!>78!FE>8I!'B:>8?!->E>89!@C!,=8I:DE!>@!>78!B@I>7! EB?!8E9>!@C!+E!2F@I:?EO!EB?!>78!.I88T!.@BC8?8IEDL!>@!>78!B@I>7!EB?!G89>!@C!+E! 2F@I:?EM!"7898!J@G8IC;F!J@F:>:89!:B>8IED>8?!G:>7!@B8!EB@>78I!:B!E!CF;:?!9>E>8O!97:C>:BH! CI@=!@B8!JFEL8I!>@!>78!B8W >!E9!K;:DTFL!E9!>78!<@I?8I9!97:C>8?M!%E>7EB:8F!3:FF8>! \PQQi]!JI@A:?89!E!H@@?!?:9D;99:@B!@C!>78!<@I?8IFEB?9!D@BD8J>!:B!7:9!V&8C:B:BH! 2I88?@=!:B!>78!,>FEB>:D!6@I?8IFEB?9!@C!>78!(8A@F;>:@BEIL!-@;>78E9>XM!0B8!@C!>78!

PAGE 60

! dQ =EBL!I8E9@B9!>7E>!>78!'M-M!7E?!F@BH!<88B!D@B D8IB8?!G:>7!-JEB:97!+E!2F@I:?E!GE9! -JE:B!@J8B!J@F:DL!>@GEI?9!8=EBD:JE>:BH!I;BEGEL!9FEA89^ "78!'B:>8?!->E>89!{BEFFL!@C{D:EFFL!EB?!;B@C{D:EFFL!FE;BD78?!CI8K;8B>O! EHHI899:A8!8BDI@ED7=8B>9!EHE:B9>!>78!2F@I:?E9!:B!>78!7@J89!@C! EDK;:I:BH!EFF!@I!JEI>!@C!>78!>8II: >@ILg!>7898!E?AEBD89!G8I8!I8J8FF8?!78!)B?:EB!EB?!78!-JEB:97O!G7:D7!@BFL!JF;BH8?!>78!EI8E! :B>@!EB!8A8I!?88J8I!DLDF8!@C!?89>E<:F:N:BH!A:@F8BD8M!"78!8F8AE>8?!9>E>;9! @C!:A8!,=8I:DEB9!:B!>78!-JEB:97!2F@I:?E9!7E?!<@>78I8?! ,BHF@ 5 ,=8I:DE!G78B!>78!I8H:@B!GE9!<;>!E!J8I:J78IEF!D@BD8IB!EB?!>78! 9>E>;9!@C!9FEA8IL!EB?!9FEA89!GE9!>ET8B!C@I!HIEB>8?M!\3:FF8>!PQQi^hif] 4:>7!>78!89>E!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!:B!>78!RieQ9O!>78!>7I8E>!J@98?!78! D@BD8J>!@C!2I88!6FEDT9!:B!-JEB:97!+E!2F@I:?E!GE9!CI:H7>8B:BH!C@I!9FEA8!@GB8I9! <8DE;98!@C!>78!?89>E<:F:N:BH!E9J8D>!@C!9:=JF8O!7;=EB!7@J8M!"78!6I:>:97!TB8G!>7:9!EB?! 8BHEH8?!:B! ?89>E<:F:N:BH!>78:I!C@I=8I!D@F@B:89!@!EBL!J8I9@B!@C! ,CI:DEB!78I:>EH8!G7@!D@;F?!I8ED7!>78:I!!C@I!>78!6I:>:97M! ,9!E!I89;F>!@C!>7:9!@CC8IO!6I:>:97!.@F@B8F!$?GEI?!%:D7@FF9!78FJ8?!89>E78! %8HI@!2@I>!@B!>78!,JEFED7:D@F E!(:A8I!:B!ReRkO!G7:D7!GE9!?89>I@L8?!:B!ReRf!G78B!VE! 9:BHF8!7@>!97@>!?:I8D>8?!>@GEI?!>78!C@I>U9!J@G?8I!=EHEN:B8X!7:>O!DE;9:BH!>78! =;B:>:@B9!>@!8WJF@?8!\68FT@!PQRR^iR]M!"7;9O!G78B!>ET:BH!E!7@F:9>:D!A:8G!@C!>7:9! J78B@=8B@BO!>78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8!4EI!I8EFFL!7E9! :>9!@I:H:B9!:B!>78!RieQ9M!"7:9!>F8! :9!G78I8!)!<8F:8A8!:>!9EF:8B>!>@!98JEIE>8!>78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8!4EI!CI@=!H8B8IEF! 7@9>:F:>:89!CI@=!>78!4EI!@C!ReRPM! "78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8!4EI!GE9!C@D;98?!:B!>78!/EB7EB?F8!@C!2F@I:?E O!< 8DE;98!@C! :>9!<@I?8IFEB?!9>E>;9M!"78!'B :>8?!->E>;9!D@;F?!B@>!C8E9:78I!:B>@!+E! 2F@I:?E!G:>7@;>!:BA@T:BH!>78!:I8!@C!>78!-JEB:97!.I@GBM!0B8!@C!>78!=@9>!:=J@I>EB>! I8E9@B9!C@I!>78!4EI!GE9!>7E>!*8B8IEF!,B?I8G!SEDT9@B!GE9!F@@T:BH!>@!DEJ>;I8! = EI@@B9!EB?!98FF!>78=!:B>@!9FEA8IL!@I!I8>;IB >78=!>@!>78:I!@GB8I!E9!G8FF!E9!J;B:97!

PAGE 61

! dR >78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!>78!.I88T9M!&;I:BH!3EID7!@C!ReReO!*8B8IEF!SEDT9@B!9G8J>!:B>@! -JEB:97!2F@I:?E!>@!J;B:97!>78!7@9>:F8!-8=:B@F89!EB?!.I88T9!:B!>78!/EB7EB?F8M! SEDT9@B!=E?8!:>!E9!CEI!E9!>78!-;GEB88!(:A8I^ SEDT9@BU9!E=JF8! C@ID8!G@IT8?!:>9!GEL!?@GB!>78!,JEFED7:D@FE!(:A8IO! G:>7!>78!@:A8!@C!J;I9;:BH!>78!7E>8?!-8=:B@F8!)B?:EB9!?88J!:B>@! >78!:B>8I:@I!@C!$E9>!2F@I:?EM!0A8I!>78!B8W>!>7I88!=@B>79O!SEDT9@BU9! EI=L!?89>I@L8?!98A8IEF!=EZ@I!)B?:EB!>@GB9 q <;IB:BH!7@=89!EB?! D@BC:9DE>: BH!9;JJF:89!EB?!F:A89>@DTO!DEJ>;I:BH!=8BO!G@=8BO!EB?! D7:F?I8B!@C!)B?:EB!EB?!,CI:DEB!:BH!98A8IEF!)B?:EB! F8E?8I9O!EB?!;F>:=E>8FL!9DE>>8I:BH!>78!-8=:B@F8!?88J8I!:B>@!>78! /8B:B9;FE!@C!2F@I:?EM!)B!>78!JI@D899!@C!>8=J@IEI:FL!?89>I@L:BH! -8=:B@F8 I89:9>EBD8!>@!'M-M!8WJEB9:@B!:B!>78!I8H:@BO!SEDT9@B!EF9@! 98:N8?!98A8IEF!-JEB:97!98>>F8=8B>9!EB?!C@I>9!EB?!DEJ>;I8?!EB?! 8W8D;>8?!>G@!6I:>:97!D:>:N8B9 q A:8G8?!!,=8I:DEB9!E9!>78! :B9>:HE>@I9!@C!>7:9!)B?:EB!GEIM!\68FT@!PQRR^dk] "78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8!4EI!8B ?8?!FEIH8FL!:B!3EL!@C!ReReM!*8B8IEF!SEDT9@BU9!IE:?!CI@=! >78!,JEFED7:D@FE!EFF!>78!GEL!:B>@!>78!:B>8I:@I!@C!B@I>78E9>!2F@I:?E!D@BA:BD8?!>78! -JEB:97!>7E>!>78L!D@;F?!B@!F@BH8I!D@B>I@F!2F@I:?EM!)B!RePRO!2F@I:?E!>IEB9C8II8?! 7EB?9!CI@=!-JEB:97!D@B>I@F!>@!,=8I:DEB D@B>I@F!;B?8I!>78!,?E=9 5 0 B| 9!"I8E>LM! ,C>8I!>78!>IEB9C8I!:B!Re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ePk!GE9!9:HB8?!EB?!DI8E>8?!E!I898IAE>:@B!:B!.8B>IEF!2F@I:?EM!)B! Rehk!>78!"I8 E>L!@C!/ELB8U9!+EB?:BH!GE9!9:HB8?O!DI8E>:BH!>78!CIE=8G@IT!C@I!>78!

PAGE 62

! dP E>>8=J>8?!I8=@AEF!>@!>78!)B?:EB!"8II:>@IL!>7I@;H7!>78!*;FC!JE99EH8!@C!>78!"IE:F!@C! "8EI9M! -A6!91D>:3VB!'B:F\!-A6!.6W>5V!.6C35>D6!'B:! "78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EI!GE9!E!D@9>FL!GEI!:B!<@>7!>78!C :BEBD:EF!EB?!>78! 7;=EB!D@9> 9 M!)>!GE9!EBEF@H@;9!>@!>78!b:8>BE=!4EI!:B!:>9!7@J8F899!C;>:F:>LM!"78! C:BEBD:EF!D@9>!7E9!<88B!89>:=E>8?!>@!7EA8!<88B!<8>G88B!}PQOQQQOQQQ!\&8B7E=! RccR^hc]!>@!}kQOQQQOQQQ!\/@I>8I!Rcfk^kPi]!EB?!E9!7:H7! E9 }iQOQQQOQQQMQQ!\YB8>9D7! PQRR ^RdR]!78!8B?!@C!>78!GEI!:B!RekPM!2@I!D@=JEI:9@BO!>78!C8?8IEF!<;?H8>!:B! RekP!GE9!~}hQOQQQOQQQ!G78B!EDD@;B>:BH!C@I!>78!<;?H8>!8WJ8B?:>;I89!G7:D7!>@>EF8?! EI@;B?!}PdOPQfOQQQ!EB?!>78!?8C:D:>!C@I!>7E>!L8EI!G7:D7!>@>EF8?!EI@;B?!}dOPhQOQQQ! \'-!6;I8E ;!@C!>78!.8 B9;9!Rcif^RRQk]M!) B!>@?ELU9!?@FFEI9O!:>!G@;F?!D@9>!<8>G88B!E! 9>EHH8I:BH!}echOkReORcc R EB?!}ROfRQOQQQOQQQ P M!"7898!EI8!B;=<8I9!>7E>!@B8!G@;F?! C:B?!:B!E!FEIH8!:B>8IBE>:@BEF!D@BCF:D>!@C!>7E>!>:=8!9;D7!E9!>78!4EI!@C!ReRP!EB?! 38W:DEB 5 ,=8I:DEB!4EIO!B@>!C@I!I8=@A: BH!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!CI@=!>78:I!7@=8FEB?M 4E9!:>!>I;FL!E!-8=:B@F8!4EI _!,DD@I?:BH!>@!3EZ@I!*8B8IEF!"7@=E9!S89;JO!:B!E! FE>8I!?E>8?!&8D8=<8I!cO!RehfO!V"7:9!oGEIp!L@;!=EL!<8!E99;I8?O!:9!E!B8HI@O!B@>!EB! )B?:EB!GEIX!\6FE:I!EB?!(:A89!Rehc^Pfc]M!.8I>E:BFLO!>78!3EI @@B9!G7@!C@;H7>!G:>7!>78! -8=:B@F89!9;D7!E9!,@!F@98!:B!>78!8A8B>!@C! DEJ>;I8!>7EB!?:?!>78!-8=:B@F89M!)C!>78!-8=:B@F89!G8I8!DEJ>;I8?O!?8J@I>E>:@B!>@!>78! )B?:EB!"8II:>@IL!GE9!H;EIEB>88?O!<;>!E>!F8E9>!>78!-8=:B@F89!G@;F?!7EA8 >78:I! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! R 7>>J^uuGGGMG89>8HHMD@=u:BCFE>:@Bu:BCFMDH: O!EDD8998?!@B!RR uiuRR P 7>>J^uuGGGM=8E9;I:BHG@I>7MD@=u;9D@=JEI8u:B?8WMJ7J O!EDD8998?!@B!RRuiuRRO! ;98?!*&/!?8CFE>@IM

PAGE 63

! dh CI88?@=M!2@I!>78!3EI@@B9O!7:9!>:=8!TB@GB!E9!>78!6FEDT!-8=:B@F89O!DEJ>;I8! EF=@9>!D8I>E:BFL!=8EB>!<8:BH!98B>!>@!9FEA8ILM 478B!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EI!<8HEBO EDD@I?:BH >@!S@8!YB8>9D7O!>78!'B:>8?! ->E>89!7E?!<88B!?@GB9:N:BH!>78!=:F:>EIL!:B!EB!8CC@I> >@!9>@J!E!J8ID8:A8?!=:F:>EIL!8F:>8! CI@=!C@I=:BH!\YB8>9D7!PQRR^RhQ]M! 68DE;98!@C >7:9!EB?!<:DT8I:BH!E=@BH!=@9>!@C! G7E>!I8=E:B8?!@C!>78!=:F:>EILO!>78!'M-M!GE9!B@>!JI8JEI8?! C@I!GEI M!"78!GEI!<8HEB!Z;9>! <8C@I8!>78!>;IB!@C!>78!B8G!L8EI!@B!&8D8=<8I!Pe O! RehdO!G78B 09D8@FE!F8?!7:9!:@B!@C!>78!'M-M!)B?:EB!,H8B>!4:F8L!"7@=J9@B!EB?!,FF:HE>@I!F8?!>78! E=<;97!EB?!?89>I;D>:@B!@C!3EZ@I!2IEBD:9!+M!&E?8U9!C@ID8 =EID7:BH!CI@=!2@I>!6I@@T8! >@!2@I>!Y:BH M!"78!?89>I;D>:@B!@C!3EZ@I!&E?8U9!C@ID89!F8C>!*8B8IEF!&;BD EB!.F:BD7O!E>! >78!>:=8!:B!D7EIH8!@C!>78!'M-M!=:F:>EIL!:B!2F@I:?EO!G:>7!@B8 5 C:C>7!@C!7:9!D@==EB?! F@9>! :B!>F8 \PQRR^RhR]M!"78!?8C8E>!@C!3EZ@I!&E?8U9!8WJ8?:>:@B!GE9!@B8!@C!>78!G@I9>! ?8C8E>9!>78!'M-M!=:F:>EIL!7E9!8A8I!8WJ8I:8BD8?!J8I!DEJ:>E^!RQd!@;>!@C!RQe! =8B!G8I8! T:FF8?!>7E>!?ELM! b8IL!8EIFL!@BO!>78!2F@I:?E!=:F:>:E!JFEL8?!EB!:=J@I>EB>!I@F8!:B!>78!GEIM!*8B8IEF! .F:BD7!EB?!*8B8IEF!(:D7EI?!Y8:>7!.EFF!\G7@!GE9!:B!D7EIH8!@C!>78!2F@I:?E!=:F:>:E]! E>>8=J>8?!EB!E99E;F>!@B!>78!.@A8!@C!>78!4:>7FED@@D788!97@I>FL!EC>8I >78!=E99EDI8!@C! 3EZ@I!&E?8U9!C@ID8M!4:>7!EJJI@W:=E>8FL!kQQ!=:F:>:E!=8B!EB?!PQQ!=:F:>EIL!I8H;FEI9O! .F:BD7!EB?!.EFF!E>>8=J>8?!>@!E99E;F>!>78!.@A8O!G:>7!@BFL!@B8!@F?O!F8ETL!<@E>!>@!H8>! >78!8B>:I8!C@ID8!EDI@99!>78!I:A8IM!"78!-8=:B@F8!GEI!D7:8C!,FF:HE>@I!>:=8? 7:9!E99E;F>! G8FF!EB?!C:I8?!@B!>78!=8B!G78B!>78L!G8I8!7EFCGEL!EDI@99!>78!I:A8IM!,9!E!I89;F>!@C! ,FF:HE>@IU9!>ED>:D9O!G7:D7!:BA@FA8?!?:9EJJ8EI:BH!:B>@!>78!7E==@DT9!8ED7!>:=8!>78! =:F:>EIL!=8B!E>>8=J>8?!>@!?:9J8I98!>78!E>>EDT8I9O!:>!C@ID8?!*8B8IEF9!.F:BD7!EB?! .EFF!

PAGE 64

! dk :B>@!E!I8>I8E>M!"78!FEDT!@C!EBL!9;JJ@I>!CI@=!>78!2F@I:?E!=:F:>:E!:B!>7:9!>F8!GE9!>78! C:I9>!@C!=EBL!D@B>I@A8I9:89!:B!>ED>:D9!<8>G88B!>78!>IE:B8?!8BF:9>8?!=8B!EB?!>78! ;B>IE:B8?!=:F:>:E!\YB8>9D7!PQRR^RhP]M *8B8IEF!4:BC:8F?!-D@>>!EII:A8?!:B!2F@I:?E :B Rehf O!@BFL!>@!F8EA8!E!C8G!=@B>79! FE>8I!EC>8I!A8IL!F:>>F8!9;DD899M!2@FF@G:BH!*8B8IEF!-D@>>U9!?8JEI>;I8O!*8B8IEF!.EFF!@C!>78! 2F@I:?E!3:F:>:E!EB?!*8B8IEF!S89;JO!G7@!GE9!>78B!K;EI>8I=E9>8I!H8B8IEF!@C!>78!EI=LO! >@@T!@A8I!D@==EB?M!"78!4:>7FED@@D788!D@B>:B;8?!>@ <8!E!D8B>8I!@C!C@D;9! C@I! *8B8IEF9!S89;J!EB?!.EFF! @B!>78 2F@I:?E FEB?9DEJ8O!E9!G8FF!E9!>78!EI8E!@C!b@F;9:E!9@;>7! @C!+ET8!*8@IH8M!68DE;98!@C!>78!:BE<:F:>L!@C!>78!=:F:>EIL!EB?!=:F:>:E!>@!E?EJ>!>@! -8=:B@F8!H;8I:FFE!>ED>:D9O!*8B8IEF!S89;J!>@@T!@A8I!D@==EB?!@C! >78!8B>:I8!@J8IE>:@B! EB?!:==8?:E>8FL!97:C>8?!C@D;9!>@!E>>EDT:BH!Vj>78!9>I@BH7@F?9!@C!09D8@FEO!3:DEB@JLO! Y:BH!/7:F:JO!EB?!.@@J8I!:B!K;:DT!9;DD899:@B!>@!JI8A8B>!>78=!CI@=!D@BD8B>IE>:BH!EB?! ?8F:A8I:BH!E!D@;B>8I9D7!PQRR^Rhc]M!! ,C>8I!8=I@L:BH!>78!-8=:B@F89!A:FFEH89!EB?!HEI?8B9O! 9@=8!-8=:B@F89!<8HEB!>@!>:I8!@C!>78!GEIM!)B!-8J>8=<8I!RehiO!*8B8IEF!S@98J7! #8IBEB?8N!@C!>78!2F@I:?E!=:F:>:E!=EBEH8?!>@!DEJ>;I8!Y:BH!/7:F:J!EB?!'D788!6:FFLM! "78!DEJ>;I8!@C!Y:BH!/7:F:J!HEA8!>78!,=8I:DE B!=:F:>EIL!F8A8IEH8!@B!>78!-8=:B@F89M!0B! 0D>@<8I!PPO!RehiO!09D8@FE! EB?!98A8IEF!@C!7:9!C@FF@G8I9! G8I8 DEJ>;I8?!;B?8I!>78! H;:98!@C!>78!G7:>8! CFEH M!"78!-8=:B@F8!F8E?8I!.@8! # E?Z@O!G7@!7E?!7:9!>:=8!F@BH! 9:BD8!Z@:B8?!>78!,=8I:DEB!9:?8O!EDD@=JEB:8?!09D8@FE!>@ 7:9!EII89>M!09D8@FEO!EF@BH! G:>7!.@ED@@D788O!G8I8!DEJ>;I8?!EB?!98B>!>@!2@I>!3EI:@BO!>78!@F?!.E9>:FF@!?8!-EB! 3EID@9M!.@ED@@D788O!EF@BH!G:>7!98A8IEF!@>78I!-8=:B@F89!89DEJ8?O!<;>!09D8@FE!?:?! B@>!E>>8=J>!>@!EB?!8B?8?!;J!?L:BH!:B!E!JI:9@B!D8FF!:B!-@;>7!.EI@F:BE M

PAGE 65

! dd *8B8IEF!S89;J!EF9@!8BED>8?!E!B8G!BEAEF!J@F:DLO!J;> >:BH .@F@B8F!`ED7EIL! "ELF@I!:B!D7EIH8M! .@F@B8F!"ELF@I!VGE9!J;>!:B!D7EIH8!@C!=@B:>@I:BH!>78!-8=:B@F89! <8>G88B!>78!.EF@@9E7E>D788!(:A8I!B@I>7!>@!>78!4:>7FED@@D788!(:A8IX!\3D.EI>7L! Rceh^PQ]!:B!RehiM!"7:9!J@ F:DL!9@;H7>!>@!7EIE99!>78!-8=:B@F8!DE=J9!EB?!A:FFEH89!@B! =EBL!@C!>78!I:A8I9!EB?!>@!I89>I:D>!>78:I!E<:F:>L!>@!=@A8!@B!>78!FEB?9DEJ8M!.;I:@;9FLO! >78!3LETTE!(:A8I!GE9!@BFL!9;J8IC:D:EFFL!=@B:>@I8?M .@F@B8F!`ED7EIL!"ELF@I!I8JFED8?!S89;J!:B!>78!FE>>8I!JEI>!@C!Re heM!"ELF@I! 89>E@D@F!@C!DI8E>:BH!=:F:>EIL!?:9>I:D>9M!"7898!?:9>I:D>9!G8I8!FE:?!@;>!E>! PQ 5 =:F8!:B>8IAEF9!EGEL!CI@=!@B8!EB@>78I!:B!E!F:B8!;B?8I!>78!:?8E!>7E>!>78!JE>I@F9!C@I! 8ED7!?:9>I:D>!G@;F?!8A8B>;EFFL!C:B?!-8=:B@F89!GEB?8I:BH!E<@;>!EB?!DEJ>; I8! EB? 78=!>@!>78!)B?:EB!"8II:>@ILM!"ELF@I!E F9@!CE:F8?!9J8D>ED;FEIFL!<;>!78 ?8A8F@J8? @A8I!kOQQQ!C88>!@C!!ROQQQ!=:F89!@C!B8G!I@E?!\PQRR^Rki]M!"7:9! ?8A8F@J=8B>!G@;F?!78FJ!JEA8!>78!GEL!C@I!=@I8!:B>8B9:A8!98>>F8=8B>!@C!2F@I:?EM 6L!8E IFL!RekQO!"ELF@I!GE9!I8JFED8?!!6I:HE?:8I!*8B8IEF!4EFT8I!YM! ,I=:9>8E?M!,I=:9>8E?!EB?!7:9!9;<@I?:BE>89!<8HEB!>@!:B>8HIE>8!-8=:B@F8!EB?! 3EI@@B! H;8I:FFE!>8D7B:K;89M ,I=:9>8E?!8=IL:BH!>@!?89>I@L!>78! -8=:B@F89!DI@J9!I:H7 >!<8C@I8 >78!IE:BL!98E9@B!<8HEB M!"7:9!DE=JE:HB!GE9!=@?8IE>8FL! 9;DD899C;FM!"78!FE9>!,=8I:DEB!>@!E>>8=J>!>@!78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!>78!3EI@@B9! GE9!.@F@B8F!4:FF:E=!S8BT:B9!4@I>7 :B!RekR!;B>:F!>78!GEIU9!8B?!:BRekP M!4@I>7!GE9! >78!=@9>!9;DD899C;F!@C!EFF!>78!,=8I:DEB!=: F:>EIL!F8E?8I9!<8DE;98!78!GE9!G:FF:BH!>@!?@! G7E>!B@!@>78I!F8E?8I!?:?!<8C@I8^!J;I9;8!E!DE=JE:HB!I8HEI?F899!@C!>78!IE:BL!98E9@BM! 2@I>;BE>8FL!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89O!>7:9!DE=JE:HB!DE=8!>@@!F:>>F8!>@@!FE>8!E9!>78!,=8I:DEB! J;IE>:@B!>:I8?!@C!>78!GEIO F8EA:BH!ROkff!=:F:>EIL!=8B!T:FF8?!EB?!EB!

PAGE 66

! df ;BTB@GB!B;=<8I!@C!=:F:>:E!EB?!A@F;B>88I!C@ID89!F@9>!>@!?:98E98!EB?!>F8M!"78! -8=:B@F89O!>7@;H7!I8?;D8?!:B!B;=<8I!EB?!9>I8BH>7O!I8=E:B8?!E!A:!EB?! :B?8J8B?8B>!J8@JF8!EC>8I!98A8B!L8EI9!@C!I89:9>EBD8!EB?!,=8I:DE B!=:F:>EIL! 7EIE99=8B>M c:6B_354!/>357\!-A6!-A3:V!.6C35>D6!'B: "78I8!G@;F?!<8!EB!;B8E9L!J8ED8!>7E>!FE9>!>7:I>88B!L8EI9O!J8I:@?:DEFFL!9M!6L!>78!<8H:BB:BH!@C!>78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EIO!EDD@I?:BH!>@! SE=89!.@A:BH>@B!\Rcff^kf]O!V"78I8!G8I 8!EJJI@W:=E>8FL!kQQ!-8=:B@F89 q =8BO! G@=8BO!EB?!D7:F?I8B q >78B!F:A:BH!:B!-@;>78IB!2F@I:?EMX!"8B9:@B9!<8>G88B!>78! -8=:B@F89!EB?!G7:>8!J:@B88I!98>>F8I9!7E?!<88B!9F@GFL!9:==8I:BH!9:BD8!>78!8B?!@C! >78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EI!:B!RekPM!%@!=EZ@I!D@BCF:D>!7E?!O EF>7@;H7 >78! Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH!->@I8!=E99EDI8!:B!Rekc :9!9:HB:C:DEB>!C@I!>7:9!>789:9 M!)B!S;FL!@C! RekcO!C@;I!I@H;8!-8=:B@F89!EII:A8?!E>!>78!>IE?:BH!J@9>!@B!G7E>!:9!>@?EL!/ELB89! .I88T!E>>8=J>:BH!>@!>IE?8M!.@A:BH>@B!\RccQ^hQh 5 hQk]!H:A89!E!9;==EIL!@C!>78!8A 8B>9! @C!>78!=E99EDI8^ "78!s@;>9:?8I9s!8I!E!I89>!@C!98A8IEF!?EL9O!EF9@!E> 5 >EDT8?!>78! >IE?:BH!J@9>!E>!/ELB89!.I88TM!0B!S;FL!RiO!B8EI!B:H7>CEFFO!C@;I!)B?:EB9! EJJ8EI8?!E>!>78!9>@I8!DEIIL:BH!I:CF89!EB?!I8K;89>8?!>78!;98!@C!E!<@E>!>@! DEIIL!E!JEDT!@C! ?88I9T:B9!CI@=!>78!@>78I!9:?8!@C!/ELB8t9!.I88TM!/ELB8! EHI88?!>@!F8>!>78=!;98!7:9!<@E>!<;>!I8C;98?!>78:I!I8K;89>!>@!9F88J!:B! >78!9>@I8M!47:F8!>78!=8B!E>!>78!>IE?:BH!J@9>!G8I8!8E>:BH!>78:I!8A8B:BH! =8EFO!>78!)B?:EB9!9E>!@B!>78!J@ID7!B8EI!>78!?@@I!9=@T:BH!J:J8 9M!"78BO! G:>7@;>!GEIB:BHO!>78L!<8HEB!C:I:BH!>78:I!I:CF89O!T:FF:BH!47:??8B!EB?! /ELB8!EB?!G@;B?:BH!3D.;FF@;H7M!478B!>78!)B?:EB9!JE;98?!>@!I8F@E?O! 3D.;FF@;H7!HIE<<8?!E!I:CF8!CI@=!>78!GEFF!EB?!C@FF@G8?!7:9!G:C8!EB?! D7:F?!G7@!G8I8!I;BB:BH!>@!>78!7!3D .;FF@;H7!EB?!7:9!G:C8! G8I8!G@;B?8?O!<;>!>78L!G8I8!E@!89DEJ8!78! ;B?8I8?!>78!9>@I8!EB?!98>!C:I8!>@!>78!<;:F?:BH! EB?!7;>9M!"78!3D.;FF@;H79!=E?8!>78:I!GEL!9@=8!>G8B>L!=:F89!>@!>78! B8EI89>!G7:>8!98>>F8=8B>!@B!>78!,FEC:E (:A8IM

PAGE 67

! di "78!C8EI!98>!@CC!78!=E99EDI8!F8?!>@!>78!89>E!@C!2@I>!.7@T@B:TFEO!B@>!>@@! CEI!CI@=!>78!9:>8!@C!>78!=E99EDI8M!#@G8A8IO!-8=:B@F8!D7:8C9!6:FFL!6@GF8H9 \2:H;I8!f] O! -E=!S@B89O!EB?!,99:BGEI!=@A8?!K;:DTFL!>@!EA@:?!EFF 5 @;>!GEI!EB?!!=@9> @C! >78!J8IJ8>IE>@I9!>@!Z;9>:D8!\#@;98!@C!(8JI898B>E>:A89!Rekcg!-D78:B8!Rciig! .@A:BH>@B!RccQ]M %@>!EFF!:B>8IED>:@B9!<8>G88B!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!,BHF@ 5 ,=8I:DEB9!G8I8! B8HE>:A8O!7@G8A8IM!)B!CED>O!>78I8!EI8!K;:>8!E!C8G!9>@I:89!:B!>78!-EIE9@>E 5 6IE?8B>@B! EI8E!EF@B 8!>7E>!E>>89>!>@!>78!CED>!>7E>!I8FE>:@B9!<8>G88B!-8=:B@F89!EB?!J:@B88I9! G8I8!D@I?:EFO!<@I?8I:BH!@B!CI:8B?FLO!?;I:BH!>7:9!7E>!6:FFL!6@GF8H9!G@;F?!A:9:>!G:>7!>78!47:>ET8I!CE=:FL!I8H;FEIFL!B8EI! D@B>8=J@IEIL!?@GB>@GB!-E IE9@>EM!#@G8A8IO!EC>8I!>78!Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH!9>@I8! =E99EDI8O!E!>I:<;>EIL!@C!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IO!>8B9:@B9!<8HEB!>@!I8ED7!E!C8A8I!J:>D7M! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!S@8!YB8>9D7^ "78!)B?:EB!-DEI8!@C!Rekc!>@!RedQ!!=@I8!>I@@J9!:B>@!2F@I:?EO!>@! I8H;FE>8!>78!9:>;E>:@BM!)>!EF9@!!EB!:BDI8E98!:B!E>>EDT9!@B!>78! J@F:DL!@C!>78!H@A8IB=8B>M!$A8B!>78!G:?8FL!I89J8D>8?!)B?:EB!EH8B>O! .EJ>E:B!S@7B!.M!.E98LO!GE9!E>>EDT8?!78 JI899!C@I!ED>;EFFL! 8BD@;IEH:BH!>78!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9!>@!F8EA8!>78:I!E99:HB8?!EI8E!>@! >IE?8!EB?!D@==;B:DE>8!G:>7!>78!EH8B>M!*@A8IB@I!"7@=E9!6I@GBO!G7@! 9;DD88?8?!o*@A8IB@I!4:FF:E=p!3@98F8LO!GE9!Z;9>!E9!E?E=EB>!E9!7:9! JI8?8D899@I!:B!E>>8=J>:BH!>@!H8>!>78!J8B: B9;FE!I:?!@C!>78!V)B?:EB! =8BED8X!EB?!J;978?!7:9!A:8G9!;J@B!>78!GEI!?8JEI>=8B>M!"78!JEB:D! 7E?!EF9@!DE;98?!>78!9>E>8!>@!DEFF!;J!:>9!=:F:>:EO! 0*(,*2(/%#39-,$2%*()2 F36"%(6$2.#3-+2(/%32%*$2"6#$"912$R+63)(F$24(R%-#$2352"#41@2>/9("/)@2 )$%%6$#)@2"/92/302%*$24(6(%( j"7I@;H7@;>!>78!8EIFL!RedQ9O!o.EJ>E:B!@C! >78!2F@I:?E!=:F:>:E!,EI@Bp!S8IB:HEB!EB?!7:9!D@7@I>9!D@B9>EB>FL!G8I8!@B! 9D@;>9O!@I!I8D@BBE:99EBD8O!:B>@!>78!EI8E!Z;9>!B@I>7!@C!>78!)B?:EB!F:B8! F@@T:BH!C@I!A:@FE>@I9!EB?!V)B?:EB!9:HB9OX!G7:D7!>78L!98F?@=!CE:F8?!>@! C: B?M!"78!EI=L!EF9@!9>8JJ8?!;J!:>9!8WJF@IE>:@B9!:B>@!>78!%E>:A8! ,=8I:DEB!FEB?9O!:BDF;?:BH!>78!6:H!.LJI899M!"7898!JI899;I89!EB?!>78! D@B9>EB>!9D@;>:BH!78!EI=L!:B>@!>78!I898IA8?!FEB?9!<8HEB!>@!>ET8! >78:I!>@FF!@B!>78!-8=:B@F89M!\PQQh^RkcO!8=J7E9:9!E??8?]

PAGE 68

! de %@ >!@BFL!>7E>!<;>!V)B!RedkO!>78!?8J;>L!9;IA8L@I9!G8I8!@I?8I8?!:B>@!>78!@F?!F:=:>9!@C! >78!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB!<@;B?EIL!>@!89>E78!9>E>8!C@I!L8>!EB@>78I!GEI g!@BFL!E!9JEIT!GE9!B88?8?M 47E>!9 JEIT8?!>78!GEI!:9!;J!C@I!?88M!$ :>78I!:>!GE9!E!9;CC!IEAEH:BH!EB?!?89>I@L:BH!6:FFL!6@GF8H9!E>:@B! EI@;B?!&8D8=<8I!PQO!Redd!E9!: 9!I8D@;B>8?! EB! E>>EDT!8BEB>!#EI>9;CCU9!=8B!:B!&8D8=<8I!Redd_! )>!:9BU>!D8I>E:Bg!<;>!G7E>!:9!D8I>E:B!:9!>7E>!6:FFL!6@GF8H9!GE9!:BA@FA8?!EB?!>7E>!:>! <8HEB!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?EM!6:FFL!6@G F8H9O!E!?89D8B?EB>!@C!>78!.@GT88J8I! ?LBE9>L!@C!,FED7;EO!GE9!@B8!@C!>78!=@9>!G:?8FL!I89J8D>8?!-8=:B@F8!F8E?8I9M!,F@BH! G:>7!-E=!S@B89O!78!GE9!@B8!@C!>78!=@9>!:=J@I>EB>!C:H;I89!>@!F8E?!>78!-8=:B@F8! I89:9>EBD8M!/I89:?8B>!3:FFEI?!2:FF=@I8!7E?!6@GF8H9 \C:H;I8!f] D@=8!;J!>@! 134I:6!O!c3 DDY!c>@D64;?!"G:BABC!B5V!>7A6:!.6C35>D6!(6BV6:;!35!'B;A3547>5!*<#
PAGE 69

! dc 4E97:BH>@B!&M.M!:B!RedR!>@!B8H@>:E>8!>78!I89>!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!I8=@AEF!>@!>78!)B?:EB! "8II:>@ILO!E!>I:J!G7:D7!:BDF;?8?!>78!CE=@;9!6FEDT!-8= :B@F8! F8E?8I!,8I! B8EIFL >7I88!L8EI9!@C!>78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EIO!6:FFL!6 @GF8H9! 9;II8B?8I8?!EB?!F8C>!G:>7!7:9!@!>78!)B?:EB!"8II:>@ILM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!6I8B>! 48:9=EB^ )>!>@@T!>G@!L8EI9!C@I!>78!D@=<:B8?!EI=LO!=:F:>:EO!EB?!A@F;B>88I!C@ID8! >@!C:B?!6:FFL!6@GF8H9j0B!%@A8=<8I!RcO!RediO!>78!<@E>!>I@@J9!C@;B?! EB?!<;IB8?!6@GF8H9U!DE=JO D@B9:9>:BH!@C!9@=8!C:C>L!?G8FF:BH9O!>@ID78?! 7:9!C:8F?9O!EB?!>@@T!FEIH8!K;EB>:>:89!@C!D@IB!EB?!I:D8!EB?!9@=8!@W8BM! 6@GF8H9!TB8G!>7:9!GE9!>78!8B?!@C!7:9!GEL!@C!F:C8!EB?!?8D:?8?!>@!H@! G89>M!"8I=9!G8I8!I8ED78?O!EB?!@B!3EL!kO!RedeO!6:FFL!6@GF8H9!EB?!Rfk! -8=:B@ F89!9EG!2F@I:?E!C@I!>78!FE9>!>:=8!EB?!98>!9E:F!C@I!>78!B8G!>G@ 5 =:FF:@B 5 EDI8!-8=:B@F8!(898IAE>:@B!:B!)B?:EB!"8II:>@ILM!\Rccc^dc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h^RdQ] ? 89DI:<89!>78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EI!EJ>FL!V28G!GEI9!:B!'B:>8?!->E>89! #:9>@IL!7EA8!<88B!9@!D@B> I:A8?!E9!>78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EIMX "78!-8=:B@F89U!9 >IE>8HL! :B!>7:9!GEI!H8B8IEFFL!D@B9:9>8?!@C!9=EFF!H;8I:FFE 5 9>LF8!E99E;F>9! C@FF@G8?!@!>78!G:F?8IB899M!,!F:9>!@C!9T:I=:9789!:9!E9!C@FF@G9^ SEB;EIL!Redf! "78!-8=:B@F89!T:FF!/8>8I!S@7B9@B!EB?!$?GEI?!2EII8FFO! G7@!G8I8!G:>7:B!9:W!=:F89!@C!2@I>!&EFFE 9!G7:F8!7EIA89>:BH!D@@B>:8!

PAGE 70

! fQ I@@>9M!!-@@B!EC>8I!C:A8!9@F?:8I9!CI@=!2@I>!&8LBE;?!EI8!T:FF8?!HE>78I:BH! G@@?M 3EID7!Redf! "78!7@=8!@C!#E=F:B!bM!-B8FF!:9!E>>EDT8?!EB?!<;IB8?!Z;9>! B@I>7!@C!-EIE9@>E!6ELO!T:FF:BH!E!3IM!.;BB:BH7E=!G7@!GE9!F:A:BH!G:>7! -B8FF!E>!>78!> :=8M ,JI:F!Redf! -8=:B@F89!E99E;F>!>78!6IE?8B!JFEB>E>:@B!@B!,JI:F!fM 3EL!Redf! -8=:B@F89!E>>EDT!>78!7@=89>8E?!@C!.EJ>E:B!(@<8I>! 6IE?F8L!:B!G7E>!:9!>@?EL!/E9D@!.@;B>LM!"78!IE:?!:9!B@>!@BFL!>78!=@9>! B@I>78IB!E99E;F>!@C!>78!GEI!78!-8=:B@F89O!<;>!EF9@!>G @!@C!>78! .EJ>E:BU9!D7:F?I8B!EI8!T:FF8?M +E>8!:B!RedfO!>78!2F@I:?E!=:F:>:E!;B?8I!D@==EB?!@C!->I8E>L!/EIT8I!V9;IJI:98?! E!o-8=:B@F8p!JEI>L!B8EI!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!EB?!T:FF8?!E>!F8E9>!C@;I!@C!>78!8B8=LO! :BDF;?:BH!>78!?EI:BH!F8E?8I!09D8B!";9>8B;HH88M!S@8!YB8>9D7! \PQQh^Rdk]!D:>89!SE=89! .@A:BH>@B!\Rcch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ciP^Ri]M!"78!FE9>!=EZ@I!D7:8C9!F8C>!:B!>78!->E>8!@C! 2F@I:?E!G8I8!.7:JD@O!-E=!S@B89!\G7@!?:8?!EI@;B?!>78!EH8!@C!RQQ!9@=8>:=8!?;I:BH!

PAGE 71

! fR >78!.:A:F!4EI]O!EB?!0F?!":H8I>E:FM!.@A:BH>@B!=8B>:@B9!E!D7:8C!V";9>8B;HH88X!:B!Reic! E9!F :A:BH!G:>7!7:9!!.8B>8IM!"7:9!:9!F:T8FL!":H8I!";9>8B;HH88O!G7@!#EIIL! Y8I98LO!SIM!\Rcik^dR]!I8D@I?9!E9!<8:BH!>78!VFE9>!GEI!D7:8C!@C!>78!.@G!.I88T!:=8!@C!C8EI!EHE:B!>7E>!>78!-8=:B@F89!G@;F?! >ET8!E?AEB>EH8 @C!>78!@BH@:BH!,=8I:DEB!GEI!>@!9>EH8!E>>EDT9!@C!>78:I!@GBM!)B!3EID7! RefPO!2F@I:?E!*@A8IB@I!S@7B!3:F>@B!EJJ@:B>8?!S@7B!*I:CC:BO!E!G8FF!TB@GB!>IE?8I!EB?! E!J8I9@B!EJJEI8B>FL!78F?!:B!9@=8!89>88=!78!-8=:B@F89O!>@!988T!@;>!V-E=!S@B89! EB?!":H8I!"E:FO!EB?!E99 ;I8!>78=!@C!>78!CI:8B?97:J!@C!>78!9>E>8!EB?!>78!.@BC8?8IE>8! ->E>89X!\"ELF@I!RccR^hQP]M!"EF89!IEB!IE=JEB>!@B!>78!2F@I:?E!CI@B>:8I!>7E>!-E=! S@B89U9!ET:BH!>78!'B:@B!9:?8!EB?!T:FF:BH!:B?:9DI:=:BE>8FL!\RccR^hQh]M! "7898!D@=JF8>8FL!;E FFL!ECC8D>8?!>78!-8=:B@F89!>@@!G78B!*I:CC:B! I8J@I>8?^! #8!I8D8:A8?!CI897!:BC@I=E>:@B!CI@=!EB@>78I!)B?:EB!D@B>ED>!8?!E!=88>:BH!A:E!E!=8998BH8I!78! 98B>!>@!"E=JEM!)B!E!vHI8E>!8WD:>8=8B>U!-;==8IF:B!EB?!E!D@=JEB:@B! >IEA8F 8?!>@!>78!)B?:EBU9!I8=@>8!7EA8BO!>EFT8?!G:>7!>78!BE>:A89O!EB?! I8J@I>8?!EFF!K;:8>!:B!>78:I!DE=J9M!"78!-8=:B@F8!D7:8C! 5$"#$920*(%$)2 0$#$2+#$+"#(/.2%32"%%",=2*()2+$3+6$ 78!CEF98!9>@I:89!@C!EB! ;JI:9:BHM!#8!EF9@!8WJI8998?!D@BD8IB8?!E>!>78:I!B@>!<8:BH! E@! J;ID7E98!9;JJF:89!CI@=!B8EI>F8=8B>9M!\RccR^hQh O!8=J7E9:9! E??8? ] 2 8EI!@C!-8=:B@F8!:B9;II8D>:@B!EB?!>78:I!Z@:B:BH!>78!'B:@B!DE;98!D@B>: B;8?! >7I@;H7@;>! >78!.:A:F!4EIM!"ELF@I!B@>89!\RccR^hRk]O!V47:F8!>78!D@;I98!>78L!o>78! -8=:B@F89p!C@FF@G8?!>8B? 8?!>@GEI?!DE;>:@;9!B8;>IEF:>LO!>78L!9T:FFC;FFL!=E:B>E:B8?! >:89!>@!<@>7!9:?89!:B!>78!9>I;HHF8!:B!EB!8CC@I>!>@!9;IA:A8!>78!G7:>8!=EBU9!GEIXM )B!ReicO!+:8;>8BEB>!(@<8I>!/IE>>!D@B?;D>8?!E!I@;H7!D8B9;9!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89! I8=E:B:BH :B!2F@I:?EM!#8!:?8B>:C:8?!C@;I!< EB?9O!>78:I!F@DE>:@BO!>78:I!B;=<8I9O!EB?!

PAGE 72

! fP VJ@99:XM!#8!B@>89!Pf!=8=<8I9!@C!.7:JD@U9!!.F:BD7O!cQ! =8=<8I!@C!";9>8B;HH88U9!!.8B>8IO!eQ!=8=<8I9!@C!0F?!":H8I!"E:FU9! !-7EDTF8C@I?O!PQ!=8=<8I9!@C!1@;BH!":H8I!"E: FU9!\0F?!":H8I!"E:FU9!9@B]! :=E>8?!PQ!@I!9@!-8=:B@F89!E9!J@99:O!>@>EF:BH!PcP! -8=:B@F89!\.@A:BH>@B!RciP^Re]M "78!C8EI!@B!>78!CI@B>:8I!?:?!B@>!CE?8!G:>7!>78!8B?!@C!>78!.:A:F!4EIM!)B!ReefO! B8EI!2@I>!/:8ID8O!>78!-8=:B@F89!I8J@I>8?!> 7E>!DE>>F8!I;9>F8I9!7E?!9>@F8B!7@H9!EB?! DE>>F8!CI@=!>78=M!"78!>@GB9J8@JF8!G8I8!9@!ECIE:?!@C!I8>I:<;>:@B!CI@=!>78!-8=:B@F89! >7E>!>78L!CF8?!>@!>78!<8ED7!9:?8!@C!>78!68FF!CE=:FL!JI@J8I>LO!9>E>:BHO!V48!7EA8!D@=8! @A8I!78I8O!E9!>78!)B?:EB9!EI8!@B!>78!GEIJE>7O!>7 8:I!JE:B>9!@B!EB?!?EBD:BH!EI@;B?!>78! C:I8M!-EL!tY:FF;=!EFF!G7:>8!=EBO!t!9@!G8!DE=8!78I8!>@!988!:C!L@;!DEBt>!=ET8!E!>I8E>L! G:>7!>78=M!"78L!9E:?!G7:>8!=8B!7E?!9>@F8B!>78:I!7@H9!EB?!?I:A8B!EFF!>78:I!DE>>F8!@CC! EB?!9E:?!>78L!G@;F?!T:FF;=!EFFO!:B!>G@!9;B9X!\68F F!RcPe^kh]M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!#EIIL! Y8I98LO!SIMO!>78!CE=:FL!@C!$=:FL!+EH@G!68FF!IE:98?!=@B8L!>@!JEL!>78!-8=:B@F89! D@=J8B9E>:@B!C@I!>78:I!F@9989O!E!>@>EF!@C!>G@!7;B?I8?!?@FFEI9M!Y8I98L!9>E>89! \Rcik^dR]O!V"7:9!GE9!>78!FE9>!I8J@I>8?!DE98!:B!>78!ReQQU9!G78I8!-8=:B@ F8! I8>I:<;>:@B!GE9!>7@;H7>!>@!<8!9@!8=:B8B>!E9!>@!GEIIEB>!>ET:BH!JI@>8D>:A8!=8E9;I89MX ,>!>78!>;IB!@C!>78!>G8B>:8>7!D8B>;ILO!I8FE>:@B9!<8>G88B!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!>78! G7:>8!98>>F8I9!@C!2F@I:?E!7E?!I8ED78?!E!F8A8F!@C!DEF=!>7E>!@IHEB:NE>:@B9!9;D7!E9!V"78! 2I:8B ?9!@C!2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F89X!G8I8!C@;B?8?!>@!E?A@DE>8!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89!:B!2F@I:?E! J@F:>:D9M!#@G8A8IO!:B!RcQiO!>78!FE9>!=EZ@I!-8=:B@F8!D@BCF:D>!GE9!E<@;>!>@!8I;J>M! .EJ>E:B!"@=!":H8I!\3:DD@ 2 ";9>8B;HH88]O!E!G8FF!TB@GB!C:H;I8!:B!J@9> 5 (8D@B9>I;D>:@B! 2F@I:?EO!GE9!E -8=:B@F8!@C!>78!.@G!.I88T!!@C!E!D7:8CFL!CE=:FL!>7E>!

PAGE 73

! fh :BDF;?8?!7:9!78I!":H8I!";9>8B;HH88O!EB?!7:9!78I 5 :B 5 FEG!D7:8C!"EFFE7E9988! G7@!GE9!=EII:8?!>@!":H8I!EB?!3:DD@U9!9:9>8I!3EI>7EM!3:BB:8!3@@I8 5 4:FF9@B! \RcRk^Rke]!JI@A:?89!>7:9!I@=EB>:D!EB ?!H@IH8@;9!?89DI:J>:@B!@C!"@=!":H8I^ )>!:9!E!B;=<8I!@C!L8EI9!B@GO!>7E>!"@=!":H8IO!D7:8C>E:BO!I8ED78?! Y:99:==88!EC>8I!E!I:?8!@C!RfQ!=:F89M!"EFFO!9>IE:H7>!EB?!=;9D;FEIO!78! JI@A8?!7:=98FC!E!G@I>7L!?89D8B?EB>!@C!>78!I@LEF!";9>8B;HH88M! &I8998?!:B!>78!I8HEF:E!@C E!D7:8CO!EB?!=@;B>8?!@B!E!IEG!<@B8?!7@I98O! 78!=:H7>!7EA8!<88B!=:9>ET8B!C@I!E!978:T!@C!>78!,IE<:EB!?898I>M!#8!7E?! D@=8!@B!E!CI:8B?FL!A:9:>!:BD:?8B>EFFLO!<;>!>@!>8FF!7:9!G7:>8!CI:8B?!7:9! >I@;! JI8>8B 98O!8!>IE?8Ij>78!I89;F>!oGE9p!>7E>!.EJ>E:B!"@=! ":H8IjGE9!>78!C:I9>!2F@I:?E!)B?:EB!>7E>!8A8I!9>@@?!;J!:B!E!G7:>8!=EBU9! D@;I>j"78!>EFFO!=EHB:C:D8B>!F@@T:BH!9EAEH8O!G:>7!;JF:C>8?!7EB?O!>@@T! >78!@E>7!@B!>78!7@FL!6@@TO!G:>7!E!J8IC8D>!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!@C!: >9! =8EB:BHM! "@=!":H8IO!E!I@=EB>:D:N8?!EB?!EF=@9>!F8H8B?EIL!C:H;I8!@B!>78!2F@I:?E!2I@B>:8I!7E?!E! ?8E>7!?898IA:BH!@C!Z;9>!7@G!EF=@9>!=L>7 5 F:T8!>78!9>@I:89!9;II@;B?!7:=!EI8M! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!Y8I98L!\Rcik^dh]^! "78!?8E>7!@C!.EJ>E:B!"@=!":H8I!GE9!E9!;B;9;EF!E9!7: 9!F:C8M!0B8!?EL! G7:F8!78!GE9!G@IT:BH!@B!E!?;H@;>!DEB@8!B8EI!+ET8!0T88D7@<88O!E! 9>@I=!I;DT!B:BHM!478B!7:9!CE=:FL! I8>;IB8?!>@!>78!9J@>!EB?!C@;B?!>78!<@?LO!>78L!>;IB8?!>78!7EFC 5 C:B:978?! DEB@8!@A8I!>@!=ET8!E!<;I:EF!AE;F>!IE>78I!>7E B!<;:F?:BH!>78!>IE?:>:@BEF! -8=:B@F8!F@H 5 J8B!HIEA8M! "7:9!;B:K;8!HIEA8!9:>8!EB?!>78!@EBD8!@C!"@=!":H8IO!F8?!>@!>78! ?898DIE>:@B!@C!>78!<;I:EF!9:>8!EB?!>7:8A:BH!@C!7:9!<@B89!E9!G8FF!E9!HIEA8!H@@?9!F:T8! "@=!":H8IU9!J:J8!@!!>@!>78!-=:>79@B:EB! )B9>:>;>8!\Y8I98L!Rcik^dh]M! &898DIE>:@B !2F@I:?E!>@!>78!! TB@GB!>7E>!;BF899!>78!<@B89!G8I8!I8>;IB8?!>@!>78:I!@I:H:BEF!I89>:BH!JFED8O!>78L! G@;F?!8BED>!>78!>:=8!@C!>78!4EI!47@@J!EB ?!-DEFJ:BH!YB:C8O!>78!D8I8=@B:EF!

PAGE 74

! fk JI8I8K;:9:>8!>@!>78!-8=:B@F89!H@:BH!>@!GEIM!2I@B>:8I!D@==;B:>:89!G8I8!9@!9J@@T8?! 78!9J8D>8I!@C!E!C@;I>7!-8=:B@F8!GEI!>7E>!=EBL!:B>8I:@I!98>>F8I9!=@A8?!>@!>78! D@E9>!EB?!:B>@!FEIH8!>@GB9!EB?!D:>:89!C@I!JI@>8D>:@BM!!"78!-8 =:B@F89O!B;=<8I:BH!:B! >78!IEBH8!@C!dQQ!>@!fQQ!:FF!7E;B>8?!>78!=:9>9!@C!>78!CI@B>:8I! H7@9>! 9>@I:89!8B@;H7!>@!DE;98! 7L9>8I:EM!Y8I98LO!:B!7:9!D@BDF;9:@BO!B@>89!>78!C@FF@G:BH! \Rcik^df]^! 2:I9>O!:>!GE9!J8ID8:A8?!E9!E!I8EF!>7I8E>!7@98!CE= :F:89!F:A:BH!:B! JI@W:=:>L!>@!>78!)B?:EB!DE=J9M!)B!:B>8IA:8G9!>78L!>8FF!@C!EI=:BH!EB?! >ET:BH!9J8D:EF!JI8DE;>:@B9!9;D7!E9!98B?:BH!D7:F?I8B!>@!9EC8!EI8E9M! .8I>E:BFL!:>!=;9>!7EA8!<88B!F:>>F8!9@FED8!G78B!>78!-8=:B@F8!JI@=:98?! >7E>!>78:I!H@@?!CI:8B?9!G@;F?!<8!T: FF8?!G:>7!?:HB:>L!IE>78I!>7EB!<8! DE;H7>!;J!:B!E!=E99EDI8M #@G8A8IO!;BF:T8!>78!2:I9>O!-8D@B?O!EB?!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!GEI9O!GEI!GE9!B@>!>@!D@=8M! "78!<@B89!G8I8!I8>;IB8?!>@!>78:I!@I:H:BEF!<;I:EF!JFED8!EB?!Y8I98L!J@9:>9!>7E>!:>! J@>8B>:EFFL!78FJ8?!J;97!>78!->E>8! >@GEI?9!C:BEFFL!JI@A:?:BH!E!J8I=EB8B>!I898IAE>:@B! C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89!>7E>!E>!F8E9>!G@;F?!H:A8!9@=8!9@I>!@C!A8:F8?!JI@>8D>:@B!>@!>78! -8=:B@F89!\Rcik^df]M 06WDB3C354!X3;7>:Y\!-A6!f5W>5gI6:6V!/6>TD6!->VBY )B!E!7:9>@IL!CIE;H7>!G:>7!A:@F8BD8!EB?!;J78EAEFO!>78!9 >@IL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8! "I:<8!@C!2F@I:?E!EB?!>78!3:DD@9;T88!"I:<8! @C!)B?:EB9! @C!2F@I:?E!:9!E!I8=EITE89>E=8B>!>@!>78!F8BH>79!>7E>!J8@JF89!G:FF!H@!>@!F:A8!:B!>78:I!@GB!GEL9!E9!CI88!J8@JF8O! B8A8I!D@BK;8I8?M!"78!-8=:B@F89!I8D8:A8?!28?8IEF!I8D@HB:>:@B!:B!Rcdi EB?!>78! 3:DD@9;T889!C@FF@G8?!:B!97@I>!@I?8I!:B!RcfPM!6@>7!>I:<89O!89J8D:EFFL!>78!-8=:B@F89O! 7EA8!7E?!9;DD899!8D@B@=:DEFFLM!"78!9;DD899!>7E>!<@>7!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?! 3:DD@9;T889!7EA8!7E?!:B!DE9:B@9!7E9!78FJ8?!IE:98!>78:I!9>E>;9!EB?!J@F:>:DEF!DEJ:>EFM!

PAGE 75

! fd S899:DE .E>>8F:B@! \PQQe] 8WE=:B8?!>78!=8>8@I:D!8D@B@=:D!I:98!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!:B! 78I!<@@T! !(.*28%"=$)O2:63#(9"28$4(/36$2B"4(/.2"/9283F$#$(./%1 M! "78!>I:<8!7E9!<8D@=8!E!A8IL!J@G8IC;F!J@F:> :DEF!C@ID8!:B!>78!9>E>8g :B!RcePO!E! D@B9>I;D>:@B!D@=JEBL!DE=8!;J@B!E!D8=8>8I L!G7:F8!JI8JEI:BH!>@!<;:F?!E!JEIT:BH! HEIEH8!:B!"E=JEM!,ID7E8@F@H:9>9!?8>8I=:B8?!>7E>!>78!I8=E:B9!E>!>78!9:>8!G8I8! -8=:B@F8O!F:T8FL!>7@98!EGE:>:BH!?8J@I>E>:@B!E>!2@I>!6I@@T8!>@!>78!)B?:EB!"8II:>@ILM! "78B!.7:8C!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8!"I:<8!@C!2F@I:?E O SE=89!6:FF:8 O E9T8?!>7E>!:B!8WD7EBH8!C@I! EFF@G:BH!>78!JEIT:BH!HEIEH8!>@!<8!<;:F>O!>78!I8=E:B9!G@;F?!<8!I8:B>8II8?!E<@;>! 9:W! =:F89 EGELO!G78I8!>78L!G@;F?!<8!JI898IA8?!C@I!EFF!8>8IB:>L!78!D@B9>I;D>:@B!@C!E! -8=:B@F8!.;F>;IEF!.8B>8IM!47:F8!>78!D8B>8I!GE9!<8:BH!D@B9>I;D >8?O!>78!>I:<8!K;:DTFL! J@;BD8?!@B!>78!B8G!FEB?!@JJ@I>;B:>L!EB?!<8HEB!?8A8F@J=8B>!@C!E!<:BH@!7EFFM!478B! >78!H8B8IEF!J;!>78!=@A8O!.7:8C!6:FF:8!9>E>8?!V>7E>!:>! 988=8?!JI@A:?8B>:EF!>7E>!>78!<@B89!@C!>78!>I:<8U9!EBD89>@I9!I8ED78?!@;>! >7I@;H7@;>! >78!L8EI9!>@!F8B?!E!C:BEBD:EF!7EB?!>@!>78:I!F@BH 5 9;CC8I:BH!?89D8B?EB>9X!\K;@>8?!:B! .LJI899!Rcci^Rdc]M!'F>:=E>8FLO!>78!-8=:B@F89!8WJEB?8?!>78:I!@J8IE>:@B!EB?!>@?ELO! >78!<:BH@!7EFF!:9!B@G!E!DE9:B@!EB?!>I:<8U9!EBD89>@I9!?:?!:B?88?!F8B?!E!78FJ:BH!7E B?! E9!>78!-8=:B@F8U9!DE9:B@9!7EA8!!:==8B98!G8EF>7!>@!>78!>I:<8M! 18>O!;B>:F!I8D8B>FLO!B@B 5 -8=:B@F89!G7@!F:A8!:B!2F@I:?E!>@?EL!:=J@98?!>78! ?@=:BEB>!BEIIE>:A8!D@BD8IB:BH!>78!-8=:B@F89!\-:==9!Reheg!&IET8!Reedg!.@IL! Recfg!3@@I8 5 4:F9@B!Recfg!2E:I8!E9!>78!C:I9>!?8DE?8!@C!>78! >G8B>L 5 C:I9>!D8B>;ILO!>78!@BFL!-8=:B@F8!7:9>@IL!>E;H7>!78!9>@IL!@C! 09D8@FE!EB?!7:9!;9;IJE>:@B!E9!E!CEFF8B!,=8I:DEB!78I@!G:>7!7:9!<8>IELEF!;B?8I!>78! G7:>8!CFEHM!"7E>!:9!B@>!>@!9EL!>7E>!09D8@FE!:9 B @ > E!9:HB:C:DEB>!C:H;I8!:B!-8=:B@F8!

PAGE 76

! ff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hO!PQRR]M!.7E:I=EB! 3:>D78FF!.LJI899O!>78B!.7E:I=EB!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8!"I:< 8!@C!2F@I:?E!9>E>8?!>78! C@FF@G:BH!EC>8I!>78!EDDI8?:>E>:@B!:B!,JI:F!@C!PQQc^ )!E=!<@>7!7@B@I8?!EB?!JI@;?!>@!7EA8!9;D7!EB!ED7:8A8=8B>!<89>@G8?! ;J@B!@;I!,7 5 "E7 5 "7: 5 Y:!3;98;=M!478B!>78!"I:7:9!Z@;IB8L!:>!GE9!E<@;>!=@I8!>7EB!Z;9>!E!98E F!@C!EJJI@AEFM!)>! GE9!E<@;>!=ET:BH!9;I8!>7E>!@;I!>I::BH!;B?8I! >78!9>EB?EI?9!>7E>!G@;F?!:B9;I8!@;I!7:9>@IL!EB?!D;F>;I8!G@;F?!<8! JI898IA8?!C@I8A8IM!)>!7E9!<88B!E!F@BH!Z@;IB8LO!<;>!@B8!>7E>!GE9!G8FF! G@I>7!:>M!\%EJF89!&E:FL!%8G9O!,JI:F!cO! PQQc] %@>!@BFL!GE9!:>!>7E>! ,7 5 "E7 5 "7: 5 Y: G@;F?!98IA8!E9!E!7EFF!>@!JI898IA8!EB?!I8JI@?;D8! D;F>;IEF!=8=@ILO!<;>!>78!=@9>!:=J@I>EB>!>7:BH!GE9!>7E>!:>!G@;F?!<8!-8=:B@F89! F8E?:BH!>78!GELO!?8>8I=:B:BH!>78!CE>8!@C!>78:I!78I:>EH8M!$A8B!>7@;H7!=@9>!@C!>78! 8=JF@L889!@C!<@>7!>78!"#/0!EB?!>78!=;98;=!EI8!B@> -8=:B@F8O!>78L!EI8!8BHEH8?!:B! E!D@FFE<@IE>:A8!I898EID7!JEIE?:H=!>7E>!:9!C@D;98?!@B!G@IT:BH!G:>7!>78!-8=:B@F89!>@! 78FJ!JI@?;D8!E!?:9>:BD>FL!-8=:B@F8!>ET8!@B!>78:I!7:9>@IL!EB?!78I:>EH8M!478B!)!GE9!

PAGE 77

! fi :B>8IB:BH!:B!>78!"#/0!;B?8I!&IM!3EI:@B!-=:>7!:B!9;==8I!PQQc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c]M!)B!9;==8I!PQQc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

PAGE 78

! fe 89DEJ8?!>@!C I@=!,=8I:DEB!8BDI@ED7=8B>M!)B!=L!B8W>!D7EJ>8IO!)!G:FF!8WJF@I8!>7:9! FEB?9DEJ8!<8F@G!>78!9;ICED8!EB?!FEL@;>!98A8IEF!JFED89!@C!:=J@I>EBD8!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!7@G!>78!-8=:B@F89!DE=8!>@!<8!>78! -8=:B@F89O!;>:F:N:BH!>78!7:9>@I:D!EB?!EID7 E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?9!>@!FEL!@;>!G7L!>7898! 9:>89!EI8!:=J@I>EB>!EB?!;F>:=E>8FL!=@A:BH!>@GEI?9!>78!=@=8B>!@C!-8=:B@F8! 8>7B@H8B89:9M!

PAGE 79

! fc #X"/-)0!1&f0! 8 ":WAB6>D>43WBD!.376; "78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!:?8B>:>L!:9!?:CC:D;F>!EB?!D@=JF8WM!)BDI8E9:BHFLO! EID7E8@F@HL!:9!JFEL:BH!EB!:=J@I>EB>!I@F8!:B!B@>!@BFL!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!JE9>O!<;>!EF9@! :B!F8H:>:=E>:BH!:?8B>:>:89!:B!>78!JI898B>M! -:nB! S@B89!9>E>89!\Rcci^R]!V"78!I@F8!@C! EID7E8@F@HL!:B!>78! D@B9>I;D>:@B!EB?!F8H:>:=E>:@B!@C!D@FF8D>:A8!D;F>;IEF!:?8B>:>:89!:9! D@=:BH!>@!<8!J8ID8:A8?!E9!@B8!@C!>78!=@9>!:=J@I>EB>!:99;89!:B!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!>78@IL! EB?!JIED>:D8MX!18>O!>78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!:?8B>:>L!:9!B@>!@BFL!?:CC:D;F>O!<;>!:>!:9!@C>8B! JI@:DM!,DD@I ?:BH!>@!S@B89!\Rcci^RQf]O!Vj>78!:?8B>:C:DE>:@B!@C!JE9>!D;F>;I89! EB?!J8@JF89!:B!EID7E8@F@HL!7E9j<88B!?8J8B?8B>!@B!>78!E99;=J>:@B!>7E>!<@;B?8?O! =@B@F:>7:D!D;F>;IEF!8B>:>:89!\vEID7E8@F@H:DEF!D;F>;I89U]!D@II8FE>8!G:>7!JE9>!J8@JF89O! 8>7B:D!HI@;J9O!>I:<89O!EB?u@ I!IED89MX!,ID7E8@F@HL!:9!B8A8I!9>EITFL!8M! 'B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!?8A8F@J=8B>!@C!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!:B!2F@I:?E!>7I@;H7! EID7E8@F@HL!:9!E!?:CC:D;F>!JI@D899M!68DE;98!@C!>78!BE>;I8!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8!J8I:@?!:B! 2F@I:?EU9!7:9>@ILO!>78!IEG!C:B?9!:B!>78!EID7E 8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?!EI8!;9;EFFL!9DEB>!:C! EBL>7:BH!:9!C@;B?!E>!EFFM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!+@IBE!68EI?O!S8IIL!#:FF:EI?O!EB?!*F8B!,TI:?H8! \PQQQ^hPk]^! )B!$E9>8IB!%@I>7!,=8I:DEO!DF:=E>8!EB?!9@:F!D@B?:>:@B9!EI8!D@B9:?8I8?! JI:=EIL!CED>@I9!:B!J@@I!<@B8!EB?!EI>:CED>!JI898IAE> :@Bj#:9>@I:D! HIEA89!@C!8B9FEA8?!,CI:DEB 5 ,=8I:DEB9O!:B?:H8B>9O!>F8!DE9;EF>:89O! >IEA8F8I9O!:BCEB>9O!EB?!D7:F?I8B!EI8!8WE=JF89!@C!:B>8I=8B>9!>7E>!EI8! F:T8FL!>@!<8!J@@IFL!JI898IA8?!:B!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?M!%E>;IEF! 8BA:I@B=8B>EF!JI@D89989!E9!G8FF!E9!7;= EB!CED>@I9O!9;D7!E9!IEJ:?! ;I!EB?!=@?8IBO!=8D7EB:N8?!CEI=:BHO!DEB!?89>I@L! JIED>:DEFFL!EFF!8A:?8BD8!o<@B89!EB?!<;I:EF!H@@?9p!@C!J@@IFL!=EIT8?! HIEA89M $A8B!>7@;H7!68EI? O!8>!EFM!\PQQQ]O! EI8!D@BD8IB8?!G:>7!<;I:EF9O!>78!9E=8!CED>@I9!EF9@! F8E?!>@! J@@I!JI898IAE>:@B!@C! EI>:CED>9 O!89J8D:EFFL!:B!9:>;E>:@B9!G78I8!>78!I8D@I?!=EL!

PAGE 80

! iQ D@B9:9>!@C!Z;9>!E!C8G! @9 M!2F@I:?E!E9!E!9;< 5 >I@J:DEF!DF:=E>8O!7E9!>@!?8EF!G:>7!7:H7! F8A8F9!@C!9@:F!ED:?:>L!EB?!?89>I;D>:@B!@C!E<@A8!HI@;B?!9:>89!?;8!>@!7;II:DEB89M! ,DD@I?:BH! >@!-7:BZ:I@!-E>@U9!\PQQh^RR]!?@D>@IEF!?:998I>E>:@B O >I@J:DEF!9@:F9!EI8! B@>@I:@;9!C@I >78:I!7:H7!ED:?:>LM!"78!ED:? D@B>8B>!@C!=@9>!2F@I:?E!9@:F9!F8B?9!:>98FC!>@! J@@I!EI>:CED>!JI898IAE>:@B!\-:FA8:IEO!8>!EFM!PQQig!-7@<8IO!8>!EFM!PQQe]M "@!;B?8I9>EB?!>78!EID7 E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?!@C!J8@JF8!CF88:BHO!SE=89!-D@>>! \PQQc^hPc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e >7 EB?!8EIFL!Rc >7 D8B>;I:89O!EB?!>78!-8=:B@F89!?;I:BH!>78!I89>!@C!>78!Rc >7 D8B>;ILM! 68C@I8!>78!-8=:B@F8!4EI9!J8I:@?O!>78! EID7E8@F@H:DEF! I8D@I?!:9!E!F@>!=@I8!8W>8B9:A8! :B!D@=JEI:9@B!>@!>78!-8=:B@F8!4EI9!J8I:@?!\48:9=EB!RcecO!Rccc]M ,!D@==@B!EI>:CED>!C@;B?!E=@BH!-8=:B@F8!9:>89!>7I@;H7@;>!2F@I:?E!:9! .7E>>E7@@D788 5 6I;978?!J@>>8ILM! ,DD@I?:BH! >@!4:FF:E=!#M!-8EI9O!>78!.7E>>E7@@D788!

PAGE 81

! iR 6I;978?!GE9!@I:H:BEFFL!C@;B?!E=@BH9>!>78!.I88TM!,??:>:@BEFFLO!78!K;@>89!CI@=!S@7B! *@HH:B!>7E>!>7:9!9>LF8!E9!G8FF!E9!>G@!@>78I!=EZ@I!9>LF89!@C!>78!Ri>7!>7I@;H7!Rc>7! D8B>;I:89!\0D=;FH88!2:8F?9!)BD:98?!J@>>8IL!EB?!YE9:>E (8?!2:F=8?!J@>>8IL]!GE9! C@; B?!E=@BH9>!V>78!AEI:@;9!.I88T 5 ?8I:A8?!-8=:B@F8!HI@;J9!\*@HH:B!Rckc^!hi]X! \-8EI9!Rcdd^Rkh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cie^hcP] ,B!8WE=J F8!@C!8ED7!A8998 F DEB!<8!988B :B!C:H;I89! i EB?! e M )B!>7:9!D7EJ>8IO!)!:B>I@?;D8!EB?!8WE=:B8!C@;I!-8=:B@F8!9:>89!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF! 2F@I:?EM!)B!-@;>78IB!-EIE9@>E!.@;B>LO!>78I8!:9!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!3@;B?!-:>8O!G7:D7! 134I:6!P!#AB77BA>>WA66!c:I;A6V!/>7!W>I:76;Y!>H! +6>:43B!U5V3B5!/>776:Y!'6G;376?!f53Z6:;37Y!>H! +6> :43B< 134I:6!Q!&WCID466!136DV;!U5W3;6V!G>@D!W>I:76;Y!>H! +6>:43B!U5V3B5!/>776:Y!'6G;376?!f53Z6:;37Y!>H! +6>:43B

PAGE 82

! iP GE9!E!FEIH8!=@;B?!EB?!=:??8B!9:>8!G:>7!@B8!@C!>78!=@I8!I8=EITE:CED>9!C@;B?! :B!-8=:B@F8!EID7E8@F@HLM!"7:9!9:>8!:9!B@>! C:I=FL! ?E>8?g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

PAGE 83

! ih 3LETTE7E>D788M! +:>>F8!-EF>!-JI:BHU9!DI88T!C88?9!>78!GE>8I9!@C!3LETTE7E>D788M!"78! JI898BD8!@C!>G@!9:HB:C:DEB>O!F@BH 5 >8I=!9:>89!@C!DE=J!EB?!7E<:>E>:@B!G:>7:B!E! 97@I>! ?:9>EBD8!CI@=!@B8!EB@>78I!:9!:B?:DE>:A8!@C!E!D@B>:B;:BH!D@BB8D>:@B!>@!>78! 3LETTE7E>D788 C@I!@A8I!RQOQQQ!L8EI9M! "78!:=J@I>EBD8!@C!>78!F@DE>:@B!@C!>78! 3LETTE7E> D788!9:>8!DEBB@>!<8!;B?8I9>E>8?M!) >9!F@DE>:@B!GE9!7EI?!>@!I8ED7O!8A8B!C@I! >78!=@9>!:B>I8J:?! @C!>I8TT8I9!EB?!>78!8E9:89>!GEL!>@!EDD899!>78!F@DE>:@B!GE9!>7I@;H7! DEB@8 5 IEB9J@I>E>:@B!;B>:F!>78!,=8I:DEB!J:@B88I!J8I:@?M! ,B@>78I!A:9:;I8!@B!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!:9!>78!8W:9>8BD8!@C!DE>>F8!>IE:F9!EB?!G:F?!@IEBH89!:B!>78!EI8EM! ,!TB@GB!7:9>@I:D!>IE:F D;>!>7I@; H7!>78!3LETTE7E>D788O!>IEA8I989 >78!>8IIE:B!@C!>78! 3LETTE7E>D788!3@;B?!\*8@IH8!+;8I!PQRRO!J8I9@BEF!D@==;B:DE>:@B]M! "@?ELO! >78!9:>8 :9!F@DE>8?!E<@;>! Ri!=:F89 8E9>!@C!=@?8IB 5 ?EL!b8B:D8O!2F@I:?EO! :B!>78!D:>L!@C!%@I>7!/@I>M!"78!3LETTE7E>D788!=88>9!> 78!3LETTE! B8EI!>78 =@;>7!@C! >78!I:A8I!:B!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IO!>7;9!JI@A:?:BH!:>!I8FE>:A8FL!8E9L!EDD 899!:B>@!>78!7EI<@I! A:E!DEB@8M! "78!3LETTE7E>D788 GE9!JEI>:EFFL!I89>@I8? G78B!>78!2F@I:?E!&8JEI>=8B>! @C!$BA:I@B=8B>EF!/I@>8D>:@B!I87E<:F:>E>8?!JEI>!@C!>78!9F@;H7 EB?!I89>@ I8?!9@=8!@C! >78!G8>FEB?9!:B!PQQP!\,;9>:B!PQQP ]M!"@?ELO!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!78E?GE>8I9!EI8! G:>7:B!>78!D@BC:B89!@C!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!.I88T!$BA:I@B=8B>EF!/EITO!E!D@;B>L! @J8IE>8?!JEIT!G:>7!7@I98!EB?!<:T:BH!>IE:F9M )!7EA8!A:9:>8?!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!9:>8! 98A8IEF!>:=89!\SEB;EIL!PQRQO!3EL!PQRQO!SEB;EIL!PQRR]M!"78!I8=BEB>!@C!>78!=@;B?! :9!9>:FF!8W>EB>!EB?!>78!7:9>@I:D!@IEBH8!>I889!>7E>!*8@IH8!+;8I!I8D@I?8?!:B!7:9!B@>89O! 9JEBB:BH!CI@=!>78!RceQ9!>@!>78!JI898B>O!EI8!9>:FF!A:9::@ B]M!.;II8B>FLO!>78!@GB8I!@C!>78!JI@J8I>L!EJJ8EI9!>@!;98!>78!8B>:I8! JEID8F!@C!FEB?!C@I!@CC 5 I@E?!A87:DF8!ED>:A:>:89

PAGE 84

! ik "78!3LETTE7E>D788!-:>8!GE9!7@=8!>@!=EBL!?:CC8I8B>!J8@JF89M! "78!9:>8!GE9! ?:9D@A8I8?!:B!RceP!8;I!C@99:F!EB?!J@>7;B>8I9M!&8A8F@J=8B>! E>! >78!9:>8!<8HEB! :B!97@I>!@I?8I!EB?!E!>8E=!@C!EID7E8@F@H:9>9!:BDF;?:BH!3EI:@B!,F=LO!*8@IH8!+;8IO!EB?! 6@@!9EFAEH8!EB?!?@D;=8B>!E9!=;D7!E9!J@99:8!D@B>E:B9! 98A8B!D@=J@B8B>9!E9!:?8B>:C:8?!8B9:A8!EI8E!@C!F:>7:D ?88B9:A8!=:??8B!EI8Eg!h]!E!<;I:EF!EI8Eg!k]!E!D;I8?!8EI>7G@IT!@C!9EB?g! d]!E!9EB?!<;I:EF!=@;B?g!f]!E!J@99:7:D!?88B?8?!;B?8I!>78!9:>8!CI@=!"I@J:DE:I8!6@;F8AEI?!>@!>78 9@;>7!>@!E!97@I>!?:9>EBD8!B@I>7! @C!>78!:B>8I98D>:@B!@C!(8:9>8I> @ G B!(@E?!EB?!.@F?! -JI:BH!+EB8M!3@9>!@C!>78!F:>7:D!=E>8I:EF!GE9!C@;B?!@B!7:H7!HI@;B?O!89J8D:EFFL!B8EI! >78!I:=!@C!>78!@F?!J@B?!C8E>;I8M!"78!=:??8B!D@A8I8?!EB!EI8E!@C!E>!F8E9>!PQOQQQ! 9K;EI8! =8>8I9!<8C@I8!:>9!?89>I;D>:@B!\+;8I!Rcei^Rkh]M!3@9>!@C!>78!=:??8B!D@B>E:B8?! CE;BEF!I8=E:B9!EB?!F:>7:D!=E>8I:EF9O!E9!G8FF!E9!E!J@I>:@B!@C!>78!=:??8B!>7E>!GE9! D8IE=:D9 5 :B>8B9:A8M!"78!=:??8B!GE9!F@DE>8?!@B!>78!8E9>8IB 5 7EFC!@C!>78!9:>8M!,!<;I:EF! 9:>8!GE9!F@DE> 8?!:B!>78!9@;>78IB!J@I>:@B!@C!>78!=:??8BO!?E>:BH!>@!>78!J@9> 5 ID7E:D! J8I:@?M "78!D:IDF8!=@;B?!:9!F@DE>8?!:B!>78!DE<78! B@I>7G89>8IB!J@I>:@B!@C!>78!9:>8M!)>!:9!@AEF 5 97EJ8?!EB?!7E9!E!' 5 97EJ8?!8=M! )>!GE9!E99@D:E>8?!G:>7!>78!9EB?!<;I:EF!=@;B?!E>!>78!9:>8M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!+;8IO!:>!=EL! 7EA8!<88B!Vj>78!FE9>!I8=E: B:BH!8WE=JF8!@C!EB!;B;9;EF!9:>8!EIIEBH8=8B>!>7E>! @DD;II8?!:B!:B>8I:@I!EI8E9!@C!G89> 5 D8B>IEF!2F@I:?EX!\Rcei^Rkk]M!!'BC@I>;BE>8FLO! <8C@I8!:>!D@;F?!<8!?@D;=8B>8?!C;FFLO!>78!=@;B?!GE9!EF=@9>!D@=JF8>8FL!?89>I@L8?!
PAGE 85

! id ?8A8F@J=8B>M!,99@D:E>8?!J@>8B>:EFFL!G:>7!>78! D:IDF8!=@;B?!GE9!E!J@99::C:8?!@!+;8I!\Rcei^Rkf]O!V)>!=8E9;I89!Rd!8I9! EB?!=:H7>!7EA8!JI@A:?8?!9EB?!C@I!>78!.:IDF8!3@;B?MX!2:BEFFLO!>78I8!GE9!E!9=EFF!9EB?! =@;B?!>7E>!GE9BU>!ECC8D>8?!O!<;>!=EL!7E A8!7E?! 9@=8@B8 ?:H!>7I@;H7! :>!F@@T:BH!C@I!EI>:CED>9M ,9!)!=8B>:@B8?!:B!D7EJ>8I!>G@O!>78!7:9>@IL!@C!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IU9!7;=EB! 7E<:>E>:@B!?E>89!@!@A8I!RQOQQQ!L8EI9!EH@M!"78!7:9>@IL!@C!>78!3LETTE7E>D788! 9:>8!<8H:B9!:B!>78!/EF8@ 5 )B?:EBu$EIFL!,ID7E:D!J8I:@ ?9M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!+;8I!\Rcei^Rkf]O! E!!EB?!EB!;B!G8I8!I8D@A8I8?!CI@=! >78!<;FF?@N8?!9J@:FM!,??:>:@BEFFLO!E!6@F8B!J@:B> O E!2F@I:?E!-J:T8 O EB?!>7I88!2F@I:?E! 3@II@G!3@;B>E:B!TB:A89 G8I8! I 8J@I>8?!CI@=!>78!9:>8 M!"78!B8W> J8I:@?!@C!B@>8!:9!>78! 3:??F8!,ID7E:D!J8I:@?!G78I8!E>!F8E9>!dQ!2F@I:?E!,ID7E:D!->8==8?!JI@Z8D>:F8!J@:B>9! G8I8!I8D@A8I8?M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!+;8IO!98A8IEF!@C!>78!9J8D:=8B9!C@;B?!G8I8!EF=@9>! :?8B>:DEF!>@!D@B>8=J@IEIL!3:??F8!,ID7E:D!9:>89!:B!9@;>7G89>!EB?!G89> 5 D8B> IEF! 2F@I:?E!9;D7!E9!+:>>F8!-EF>!-JI:BH O! 6EL!489>O!EB?!(8J;< F :D!*I@A89!\Rcei^Rkf]M!0>78I! F:>7:D9O!:BDF;?:BH!%8GBEB!J@:B>9O!G8I8!I8D@A8I8?!CI@=!>78!9:>8M!"78!C:I9>!D8IE=:D9! <8HEB!>@!EJJ8EI!:B!>78!.8IE=:D 5 ,ID7E:D!2F@I:?E 5 "IEB9:>:@BEF!J8I:@?M!"78!E998=7!J@:B>9!EB?!E!.FEL!J@:B>j,F9@!D@FF8D>8?!G8I8!Ri!9EB? 5 EB?!C:<8I 5 >8=J8I8?!978I?9!\Rd!<@?LO!P!I:=]jRk!978I?9!\Rh!<@?LO!R! I:=]!@C!A8IL!>7:DT 5 GEFF8?!\Rk!==]!->M!S@7BU9!/FE:B!J@>>8IL!GE9! I8D@A8I8?MMMM"78!9J@:F!EF9@!L:8F?8?!E!9:N8EO!CE97:@B8?!CI@=! >78!78EAL!978FF!F:J!@C!E!K;88B!D@BD7jz;88B!D@BD7!D8F>9!G8I8!@<>E:B8?! CI@=!9@;>78E9>!2F@I:?E!EB?!>78!2F@I:?E!Y8L9M!\Rcei^Rkf] 2@;I!#8IBEB?@!J@:B>9!EB?!98A8IEF!9EB? 5 >8=J8I8?!978I?9!C@;B?!D@II89J@B?! >@!>78!$EIFL!3EBE9@>E!/8I:@?!\Rcei^Rki ]M!"78!B8W>!EI>:CED>!E998=
PAGE 86

! if >@!>78!+E>8!3EBE9@>E!J8I:@?!>7I@;H7!>78!488?8B!)9FEB?!J8I:@?!EB?!>78!-EC8>L! #EI<@I!J8I:@?M!"78!D8IE=:D9!E998=8?O!9EB? 5 >8=J8I8?!978I?9!\kfc!<@?LO!dc!I:=]jh!9EB? 5 EB?!HI@H 5 >8=J8I8?!JFE: B!978I?9!\R!<@?LO!P!I:=]jf!>7:B!->M!S@7B9!/FE:B! <@?L!978I?9!EB?!Rh!68FF8!*FE?8!/FE:B!978I?9!\RQ!<@?LO!h!I:=]M! \Rcei^Rki] ,DD@I?:BH!>@!+;8IO!98A8IEF!<@B8!EB?!978FF!>@@F9!G8I8!I8D@A8I8?!E9!G8FF!E9!98A8IEF! /:B8FFE9!J@:B>9!!\>7898!J@:B>9!F:T8FL!?E>8!>@!>78!-E C8>L!#EI<@I!J8I:@?]!EB?!VE!FEIH8! 9DIEJ8I!=E?8!CI@=!>78!F8C>!AEFA8!@C!E!K;E7@HX!\Rcei^Rki]M!&E>:BH!>@!>78!-EC8>L! #EI<@I!J8I:@?!G8I8!CIEH=8B>9!@C!VF8C> 5 7EB?8?!G78FT!978FF!?I:BT:BH!D;J9!EB?!7;=EB! <@B8!E9!G8FF!E9!J@>!978I?9X!\Rcei^Rki]M!"78!J@>978I?9!:BDF;?8?! V9:W>L 5 >G@! ;B?8D@IE>8?O!9EB? 5 >8=J8I8?!978I?9!\dk!<@?LO!e!I:=]X!>7E>!G8I8!9:=JF8!<@GF9! EDD@I?:BH!>@!+;8IO!E9!G8FF!E9!X>G@!I:=!978I?9!@C!-EIE9@>E!)BD:98?!J@>>8ILX! \Rcei^Rki]M!,B! ;B:?8B>:C:8?! =EB!G7@!?;H!:B!E!J@>7@F8!VC@;B?!E!9>EDT!@C!C:A8!B89>8?! 978I?9!EDD@= JEB:8?!G@!G8E>78I8?!F8C> 5 7EB?8?!G78FT!D@F;=8FFE!!>78!9:>8!:B!>78!9;==8I!@C!RceP!\Rcei^Rki]M! "78! 7 :9>@I:D!J8I:@?!@DD;JE>:@B!@C!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!9:>8!:BDF;?89!>G@! 98JEIE>8!@DD;JE>:@B9M!"78!C:I9>!@DD;JE>:@B!GE9!$EIFL!-8=:B@F8M!"78!C:BEF @DD;JE>:@B! E>!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!9:>8!:9!>78!8EIFL!PQ >7 D8B>;IL! 7 :9>@I:D!J8I:@?M!,I>:CED>9! I8D@A8I8?!E>!>78!9:>8!G8I8!C@;B?!@B!>78!9;ICED8!@C!>78!9EB?!<;I:EF!=@;B?!EB?! VD@B9:9>8?!@C!98A8IEF!J:8D89!@C!HFE99!EB?!:I@B9>@B8!EB?!E!J:8D8!@C!HI88BO!>IEB9C8I 5 JI:B> 8?!GEI8X!?E>:BH!>@!E<@;>!RcRQX!\Rcei^Rkc]M!2IEH=8B>9!@C!!>78!9:>8M!2:BEFFLO!@IEBH8!>I889!D@B>:B;8!>@!HI@G!VG:F?X!:B!>78!EI8E!E9!E! I89;F>!@C!>78!7:9>@I:D!J8I:@?M!

PAGE 87

! ii ,DD@I?:BH!>@!+;8I!\Rcei]O!/7:F!47:9F8I!J8IC@I=8?!E!CE;BEF!EBEFL9:9 @C!>78! >7@;9EB?9!@C!<@B89!C@;B?!:B!>78!=:??8B!EF@BH!(8:9>8I>@GB!(@E?!\I8C8I!>@!"E!:B>8I89>:BH! I8=E:B9 ?:9D@A8I8?!:B!>78!EBEFL9:9!GE9!>78! ?:9D@A8IL!@C!>78!I8=E:B9!@C!9EF>GE>8I!C:97M!"78!B8EI89>!9@;ID8!C@I!>7898!C:97!G@;F?! 7EA8!<88 B!E<@;>! c!=:F89 ?@GB9>I8E=!G78I8!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!CF@G9!:B>@!>78! 3LETTE!(:A8IM!"78!JI898BD8!@C!9EF>GE>8I!C:97!I8=E:B9!:B!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?!:9! D8I>E:BFL!:B?:DE>:A8!@C!=@A8=8B>!;J 5 EB? 5 ?@GB!>78!DI88T!CI@=!>78!(:A8IM!/8I7EJ9O!:>! :9!8A8B!:B?:DE>:A8!@C! >IE?8!<8>G88B!>78!D@E9>EF!98>>F8=8B>9!EB?!>78!:BFEB?! 98>>F8=8B>9M! )B!E??:>:@BO!>78!V3LETTE7E>D788!-:>8!I8A8EF9!:B>8B9:A8!;>:F:ENE>:@B!@C! >78!EI8EU9!@BD8!?:A8I98!G8>FEB?!CE;BEX!\Rcei^RdQ]M!!,!C:BEF!B@>8!E<@;>!>78!EI>:CED>! EBEFL9:9 g &EBE!->8M!.FE:I8!EB?!(@<8 I>!,;9>:B!EBEFLN8?!>78!?8<:>EH8!@C!>78! 3LETTE7E>D788!-:>8M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78:I!EBEFL9:9!VF:>7:D!=E>8I:EF!7E?!>@!7EA8!<88B! !>@!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!-:>8O!EB?!G78B!:>!GE9O!:>!GE9!EFI8E?L!:B!9@=8! JI8JEI8?!C@I=j!"78!G:?8!IEBH8!@C!>E9T9!8A:?8BD8?!7! >78!7;B>:BHuHE>78I:BH!ED>:A:>:89!G7:D7!>@@T!JFED8!E>!>78!-:>8X!\Rcei^RdR]M! ,9!)!I8C8II8?!>@!8EIF:8I!:B!D7EJ>8I!>G@O >78!FEB?9DEJ8!@C!>78!3LETTE7E>D788! 7E9!D7EBH8?!9:HB:C:DEB>FLM!!&;I:BH!>78!-8=:B@F8!0DD;JE>:@B!J8I:@?O!>78!=@;B?! D@=JF8W G@;F? 7EA8!8W:9>8?!EF@BH9:?8!>78!B@I>7!9:?8!@C!E!FET8!@I!J@B?!\J@99:7E>!98IA8?!E9!>78!9@;ID8!C@I!>78!3LETTE7E>D788M!&;I:BH!9EFAEH:BH!@C!>78! =@;B?!EC>8I!?8A8F@J=8B>!;B8WJ8D>8?FL!@DD;II8?O!@BFL!@B8!EI>:CED>!GE9!C@;B?^ 'B8EI>78?!GE9!EB!:B>ED>! J@>>8IL!A8998FO!D@B>E:B:BH!F8E?!97@>O!G7:D7! GE9!DEJJ8?!8?!=8>EF!T8>>F8M!)B!C@I=O!>78!A8998F!GE9!EF=@9>! :?8B>:DEF!>@!E!A8998F!@C!.7E>>E7@@D788!6I;978?!C@;B?!!>78!Y:99:==88!(:A8I!\*@HH:B!Rcfk^2:HMRe^$O!/FM!c^,]!\+;8I! Rcei^R ke]M

PAGE 88

! ie "78!A8998F!C@;B?!E>!3LETTE7E>D788!?:CC8I8?!CI@=!.7E>>E7@@D788!6I;978?!9>LF8!:B! 9;<>F8!GEL9O!EDD@I?:BH!>@!+;8I^ #@G8A8IO!>78!9;ICED8!>I8E>=8B>!@C!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!A8998F!GE9! ?:CC8I8B>M!"78!8W>8I:@I!9;ICED8!@C!:>9!<@?L!7E?!<88B!9>E=J8?!G:>7 F:B8EI!=EI T9!EB?!>78B!I@;H7FL!9=@@>78?!<8C@I8!C:I:BH!\JI@?;D:BH!EB! 8CC8D>!I898=7E>!J:D>;I8?!D788!A8998F!GE9!E<@;>!hQ!>@!hd!D=!:B!78:H7>O!@C!E!A8IL!?EIT! @!<8!>8=J8I8?!G:>7!E!9=EFF!E=@;B>!@C!C:B 8! 9EB?!\+;8I!Rcei^Rke]M "78!A8998F!+;8I!=8B>:@B9!>7E>!*@I?@B!4:FF8L!C@;B?!DE=8!CI@=!B8EI:C:8?!E9!6:9DELB8!(@;H78B8?!EB? GE9 C@;B?!E>!>78!$BHF8G@@?! =@;B?M!"78!8W>8I:@I!@C!>78!A8998F!:9!=EIT8?FL!I@;H78I!>7EB!>78!@>78I!A8998F9!>7E>! 4:FF8L!J:D>;I8?!CI@=!>78!$BHF8G@@?!=@;B?!@B!JFE>8!kf \988!EJJ8B?:W!$] M!!)>!7E9!E! G:?8!=@;>7!EB?!J:BD78?!I:=9M!"78I8!EJJ8EI9!>@!<8!?8D@IE>:A8!F:B89!@B! >78!A8998FO! <;>!:>!:9!?:CC:D;F>!>@! >8FF CI@=!>78!:=EH8M 78!A8998F! CI@=!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!=@;B?! D@B>E:B8?!VEJJI@W:=E>8FL!RQQ! F8E?!G@!@I!>7I88!9:N89X!\Rcei^Rke]M!)B>8I89>:BHFLO!98A8IEF!@C!>78!F8E?9!:FF!Z@:B8?!>@!@B8!EB@>78I!E9! >78L!G@;F?!7EA8!<88B!@B!F8EA:BH!>78!=@F?! :B!G7:D7!>78L!G8I8!=E?8X!\Rcei^Rke]M!,!9:=:FEI!=8>EFO!J@99:>F8!>@!>78! @B8!C@;B?!E>@J!>78!A8998F!I898=LO!2F@I:?E!\*@HH:BO!8>!EFM!Rckc]M!)B!D @B>8W>O!>78!A8998F!EB?! EDD@=JEBL:BH!T8>>F8!EJJ8EI!>@!7EA8!<88B!EB!:B>I;9:A8!C8E>;I8!:B!>78!9EB?!=@;B?g! 7@G8A8IO!:>!?@89!B@>!EJJ8EI!>@!7EA8!<88B!E99@D:E>8?!G:>7!E!<;I:EF!E9!B@B8!@C!>78! <8E?9!;9;EFFL!C@;B?!G:>7!-8=:B@F8!<;I:EF9!G8I8!C@;B?!EF@BH!G:>7!>78!A899 8FM 4:>7@;>!>78!8A:?8BD8!@C!E!<;I:EFO!G7E>!D@;F?!>7:9!:B>I;9:A8!C8E>;I8! <8 _!+;8I! DE;>:@;9FL!EJJI@ED789!>78!>@J:D!E<@;>!>78!J@99:<:F:>L!C@I!G7E>!>78!A8998F!=8EB9!C@I!

PAGE 89

! ic >78!-8=:B@F89^ )>!:9!>8=J>:BH!>@!9J8D;FE>8!>7E>!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!C:B?!I8JI898B>9!E! 7@EI?! @C!AEF;8?!97@>!<;I:8?!7!>78!:B>8B>!@C!JI@>8D>:BH!:>! C@I!FE>8I!;98M!"78!9EB?!=@;B?!E>!>78!9:>8!GE9!EB!8E9:FL!:?8B>:C:E;I8!EF@BH!>78!8E9:FL!>IEA8FF8?!9F@;H7M!)>!G@;F?!7EA8!JI@A:?8?!E! H@@?!AEB>EH8!J@:B>!@A8I!E!FEIH8!EI8E!EB?!G@;F?!7EA8!< 88B!EB! E>>IED>:A8!DE=J:BH!9J@>M!\Rcei^Rke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

PAGE 90

! eQ "78I8!EI8!>G@!9:>89!:=J@I>EB>!>@!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!-8=:B@F89!?;I:BH!>78! Re >7 EB?!Rc >7 D8B>;I:8 9M!&;I:BH!>78!RekQ9O!S@7B!&EIF:BH!EB?!"7@=E9!/M!Y8BB8?LO!>G@! EI=L!9;>F8I9!\E!9;>F8I!:9!E!D:A:F:EB!=8ID7EB>!G7@!98FF9!H@@?9!>@!=:F:>EIL!=8B!EB?! G@=8B!@I!G7@!98FF9!H@@?9!:B!E!=:F:>EIL!D@B>8W>]!@;>!@C!2@I>!6I@@T8!\B@G!"E=JE]O! G8I8!H:A8B!J8I=:99:@B!>@!@J8B!E!> IE?:BH!J@9>!:B!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IM!"78!>IE?:BH!J@9>! GE9!9>ECC8?!E:B!*8@IH8!/ELB8 M 6:FFL!6@GF8H9!EB?!7:9!@!CI8K;8B>!>78!J@9>M!6:FFL!6@GF8H9!GE9!E!G8FF 5 TB@GB! -8=:B@F8!GEI!D7:8CM!#8!CI8K;8B>8?!>78!489> 5 .8B>IEF! 2F@I:?E!I8H:@B!EB?!GE9!>78!FE9>! =EZ@I!-8=:B@F8!F8E?8I!>@!DEJ:>;FE>8!>@!I8=@AEF!C@FF@G:BH!>78!<;IB:BH!@C!7:9!DE=J!:B! >78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EIM!-E=!S@B89!GE9!E!G8FF 5 TB@GB!-8=:B@F8!=8?:D:BEF!=EB!EB?! JI@J78>M!'B?8I!7:9!F8E?8I97:JO!7:9!E78=98FA89 :B!>78!$A8IHFE?89! B8EI!>@?ELU9!6:H!.LJI899!I898IAE>:@B!EB?!GE9!E@!EA@:?!DEJ>;I8M!-E=!S@B89!EB?! 7:9!9!=ET8!;J!>78!=EBL!-8=:B@F89!EB?!3:DD@9;T889!>@?ELM ,DD@I?:BH!>@!.:BBE=@B!6E:I!@C!>78! +ET8FEB?!+8?H8I O!:B!EB!EI>:DF8!CI@=!3EID7! Pe O! PQQdO!V,!98A8I8!7;II:DEB8!:B!Rekej98I:@;9FL!?E=EH8?!>78!<;:F?:BHX!\PQQd^& 5 R]M! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!SE=89!.@A:BH>@BO!7@G8A8IO!>78!9>@I8!<;IB8?!?@GB!\RccQ^hQf]M!$:>78I! GELO!C@FF@G:BH!>78!?89>I;D>:@B!@C!>78!9>@I8O!Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH!=@A8?!>78:I!9>@I8! CI@=!.7EIF@>>8! #EI<@I!>@! !"%)$2H3%=" O!E!>I:<;>EIL!@C!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IM!"78!9>@I8!F:T8FL! D@B>E:B8?!D@B9;=E9O!C:9789O!EB?!JI@?;D8M!)B!RekcO!E9!)! ?89DI:<8!:B!D7EJ>8I!>7I88O!>7:9!98D@B?!Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH!9>@I8!GE9!>78!9:>8!@C!E! =E99EDI8!@C!>78!9>@I8U9! DF8IT9!7:9!98D@B?!9>@I8! FE>8I!:B!>7:9!D7EJ>8IM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!EB!ECC:?EA:>!CI@=!,;H;9>!RRO!Rekc!@C!4:FF:E=! 3D.;FF@;H7O!E!9;IA:A@I!@C!>78!E>>EDT!@B!>78!Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH!9>@I8!B8EI!>78!

PAGE 91

! eR /8ED8!(:A8IO!I8J@I>8?!>7E>!9>@I8!D@B >E:B8?!>78!C@FF@G:BH^! "78I8!G8I8!978FA89!@B!>G@!9:?89!@C!>78!9>@I8 5 I@@=!G7:D7!GE9!E<@;>! PP!C88>!9K;EI8O!EB?!@B!>78!978FA89O!G7:D7!G8I8!JI8>>L!G8FF!C:FF8?O! \>78I8!G8I8!C:A8!>:8I9!@C!978FA89]!G8I8!I:CF89O!>F89O!<8E?9O! 9O!>:B 5 GEI8O!?@=89>:D!H @@?9!@C!8A8IL!?89DI:J>:@BO!J@G?8IO!F8E?O! CF:B>9O!>@7O!9J;I9O!9O!E! 9E??F89O!F@@T:BH 5 HFE9989O!C:F89O!E!C;FF!>@@F 5 D789>!@C!>@@F9O!)B?:EB!97EGF9! EB?!7EB?T8ID7:8C9O!7@89!EB?!7E>D78>9O!HI:B?9>@B89O!D@=<9O!<:B?:BHO!E! FE IH8!K;EB>:>L!@C!9EF>!EB?!G7:9TLO!D@IB!EB?!JI@A:9:@B9O!EB?!E!K;EB>:>L! @C!?88I 5 9T:B9!:B!7E:IO!EF9@!<8EI 5 9T:B9!EB?!=@DDE9:B9O!T:>D78B!EB?!=899! C;IB:>;I8O!E!FEIH8!DEB@8O!€DM!\'-!-8BE>8O!b@FM!R!RedQ^RfP 5 Rfh] )B!E!F8>>8I!?E>8?!S;FL!PPO!RekcO!Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH I8J@I> 8? @B!>78!H;B!H@@?9!T8J>! E>!>78!B8G!9>@I8!@B!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!EB?!E>!>78!C@I=8I!>IE?:BH!J@9>!:B!.7EIF@>>8! #EI<@I^ jG8!7EA8!>@!9>E>8!>7E>!>78!)B?:EB!9>@I8!E>!.7EIF@>>8!7EI<@I!EB?!@B! /8E9!.I88TO!7E9!<88B!9;JJF:8?!9:BD8!>78!HEF8!@C!-8J>8=<8I!FE9>!G:>7! C :A8!T8H9!@C!I:CF8!EB?!@B8!EB?!E!7EFC!T8H9!@C!DEB:9>8I!J@G?8IO!EB?!>7I88! 7;B?I8?!EB?!C:C>88B!J@;B?9!@C!F8E?M!0C!>7:9!K;EB>:>L!>78I8!I8=E:B8?! @B!7EB?!;B9@F?!E>!>78!9>@I8!@B!/8E9!.I88TO!@B!>78!Rf >7 :B9>EB>O!>G@!7EFC! T8H9!@C!I:CF8!EB?!@B8!T8H!@C!DEB:9>8I!J@G?8 I!;B!9:W! J@;B?9!:B!@;I!I8>E:F!DEB:9>8IO!EB?!>7I88!DEB:9>8I9 q >78!T8H9!@C!I:CF8!EI8! >G8B>L 5 C:A8!J@;B?9!8ED7 q >78!DEB:9>8I9!EI8!@B8!J@;B?O!E!T8H! D@B>E:B:BH!>G8B>L 5 C:A8!DEB:9>8I9M!\RedQ^hk] )>!:9!I8E9@BE@!<8F:8A8!>78B!>7E>!<@>7!9>@I89!G8I8!DF @98!:B!9:N8!EB?!DEII:8?!>78! 9E=8!H@@?9M!"78!9>@I8!:B!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!GE9!JI@I;D>;I8!EB?!E! FEIH8 9:N8M!)B!RedcO!>78!'-*-!9;IA8L@I9!I8J@I>8?!>7E>!JEI>!@C!>78!@F?!Y8BB8?L!€! &EIF:BH!9>@I8!GE9!9>:FF!9>EB?:BHO!@B!E!T8L!Z;9>!>@!>78!8E9>!@C!B@I >78IB!/:B8!)9FEB?! \-G:DT!RcRh^ih]M! 0CC!>78!8E9> 5 D8B>IEF!D@E9>!@C!/:B8!)9FEB?O!:9!9:>8!e++hcO!TB@GB!E9!0F? )B?:EB! 2:8F?M!,I@;B?!RcdQ O!>78!FEB?@GB8I9!@C!)B?:EB!2:8F?O!#8I=EB!EB?!,BBE!/:8JF@GO! <8HEB!D@B9>I;D>:@B!@C!E!7@;98!E>!>78!7:H789>!J@:B>!@C!>78!:9FEB? G78B!>78L! ;BD@A8I8?!EB!;B=EIT8?!7;=EB!<;I:EFM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!*8@IH8!+;8I!\Rcec^RhR]O!V)B!

PAGE 92

! eP 3EID7!RcdPO!EID7E8@F@H:9>!S@7B!3M!*@HH:B!EB?!98A8IEF!9>;?8B>9!>IEA8F8?!>@!)B?:EB! 2:8F?MX!"78I8!>78L!C@;B?!VjE!H;BO!<8E?9O!TB:C8O!=:II@IO!H;B!CF:B>9O!8>DM!\*@HH:B! RcdP^P c 5 hQ]MX!*8@IH8!+;8I!\Rcec^RhR]!D:>89!S8CCI8L!3M!3:>D78=!?:9D;99:BH!>78!<8E?9! >7E>!*@HH:B!EB?!7:9!9>;?8B>9!C@;B?^ j!Rc!@C!>7898!G8I8!CED8>8?!LJ:DEF!@C!-8=:B@F8!9:>89M! "78I8!G8I8!EF9@!PP!CED8>8?!7I88!CED8>8?!VDIL9>EFX! < 8E?9!\:>!:9!;BDF8EI!G78>78I!>7898!G8I8!2F@I:?E!.;>!.IL9>EF!@I!CED8>8?! D@F@IF899!HFE99]O!>G@!CED8>8?!L8FF@G!@I!F:H7>!D78=!Rcec^Pfk 5 Pff]M "7:9!C:B?!I8JI898B>9!@B8!@C!>78!C8G!-8=:B@F8!<;I:EF9! C@;B?!:B!489>!2F@I:?EM!,9!)! J@:B>8?!@;>!8EIF:8IO!H;B 5 I8FE>8?!EI>:CED>9!EI8!:=J@I>EB>!>@!-8=:B@F8!<;I:EF9!EB?!>78L! =EIT!9:HB:C:DEBD8M!"78!)B?:EB!2:8F?!<;I:EF!:9!9@!DF@98!>@!>78!F:T8FL!F@DE>:@B!@C! Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH!->@I8!:B!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!>7E>!:>!97@G9!> 78!9:HB:C:DEBD8!@C!>78! JFED8M!-8=:B@F8!<;I:EF9!9;D7!E9!>7:9!?:?!B@>!@DD;I!:B!JFED89!@C!B@B 5 9:HB:C:DEBD8M! 2:BEFFLO!>78I8!:9!E!>7:I?!9:>8!@B!*E9JEI:FFE!)9FEB?!\e++ek]!G78I8!<8E?9!EB?!D8IE=:D9! G8I8!I8D@A8I8?!\+;8I!Rcec^RhR]M $6556VY!B5V!*B:D354!.7>:6!>5!7A6!/ 6BW6!03Z6: )B!>7:9!>789:9O!>78!Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH!9>@I8!@B!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!:9!D@B9:?8I8?! E9!98JEIE>8!CI@=!>78!8EIF:8I!9>@I8!:B!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IM!,9!?89DI:<8?!8EIF:8IO!>78! Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH!9>@I8!@B!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!GE9!E!CE:IFL!9:NEG@!9:?89!@C!>78!9>@I8 5 I@@=!G7:D7!GE9!E<@;>!PP!C88>!9K;EI8O!EB?!@B! >78!978FA89O!G7:D7!G8I8!JI8>>L!G8FF!C:FF8?O!\>78I8!G8I8!C:A8!>:8I9!@C!978FA89]jX!\'-! -8BE>8O!b@FM!R!RedQ^RfP]M!!)B!S;FL!RekcO!EB@>78I!-8=:B@F8!GEI!EF=@9>!M! 3:D7E8 F!-D78:B8!?89DI:<89!:>!E9!7EJJ8B8?^ "78!DI:9:9!GE9!JI8D:J:>E>8?!F8?!)B?:EB9! @B8!@C!G7@=! 7E?!I8D8B>FL!<88B!@;>FEG8?!78!>I:<8! G7@!E>>EDT8?!E!9=EFF!
PAGE 93

! eh @C!98>>F8I9!F:A:BH!B8EI!2@I>!/:8ID8M!4:>7!>78!G7:>89!DFE=@I:BH!C@I! I8A8BH8!EB?!>78 -8=:B@F89!:BDI8E9:BHFL!G@II:8?!E<@;>!>78! ?8>8I:@IE>:BH!9:>;E>:@BO!>78!9;< 5 D7:8C!,99:BGEI!GE9!98B>!>@!DEJ>;I8!>78! >I@;78=O!7@G8A8IO!>78! I8B8HE?89!7E?!DI@998?!>78!J8B:B9;FE!EB?!J8IJ8>IE>8?!EB@>78I! ?8JI8?E>:@BM!\Rcii^P P]! )B!E!F8>>8I!?E>8?!-8J>8=<8I!fO!RekcO!.EJ>E:B!S@7B!.M!.E98L O )B?:EB!,H8B>!>@!>78! -8=:B@F89!CI@=!>78!6;I8E;!@C!)B?:EB!,CCE:I9 O I8J@I>8?!>7E>!>78!=EZ@I!D7:8C9!@C!>78! -8=:B@F8!78!=;I?8I9!EB?!G@IT8?!>@!78=!>@!Z;9>:D8!:B! @I?8I!>@!JI8 98IA8!>78!J8ED8!>7E>!7E?!<88B!89>E8I!>78!8B?!@C!>78!-8D@B?! -8=:B@F8!4EI M )B!EB!8IE!@C!GEI!EB?!?:9>I;9>O!.E98L!JI@A:?8?!>I;9>G@I>7:B899!>7E>! >78!-8=:B@F89!AEF;8?!EB?!EJJI8D:E>8?!\4EFFED8!RcfP]M!#:9!7@B89>L!EB?!>78! I8FE>:@B97:J!78!7E?!G:>7!>78!-8= :B@F89!78FJ8?!EA8I>!GEI!:B!RedQ!C@FF@G:BH!>78! =E99EDI8!E>!>78!Y8BB8?L!EB?!&EIF:BH!9>@I8!@B!/ELB89!.I88TM!2;I>78I=@I8O!78! I8D@I?8?!>78!C@FF@G:BH^! "78L!9E:?!6:FFL!o6@GF8H9p!7E?!78EI?!G:>7!I8HI8>!@C!>78!FE>8!=;I?8I9g! EB?!>@F?!>78=!>@!9EL!>7E>O!:C!)!G@;F?!=88 >!7:=O!78!G@;F?!<8!E@! 98>>F8!>78!?:CC:D;F>:89jEB?!>7E>!-E=!S@B89!7E?!98B>!E!I;BB8I!>@!6:FFL! G:>7!>78!C:I9>!B8G9O!EB?!;IH:BH!7:=!>@!E:?!:B!JI898IA:BH!J8ED8M!"78! =;I?8I!@B!)B?:EB!I:A8IO!@B!>78!RP >7 @C!S;FLO!GE9!D@==:>>8?!FEGO!EB?!G7@!?89:I8?!>@!=ET8! GEI!C@I!>78!J;IJ@98!@C!9EA:BH!7:=98FC!CI@=!>78!)B?:EB!FEGM!"78L! I8=E:B8?!@B!>7E>!9:?8!@C!>78!>8II:>@IL!;B>:F!>78!Rd >7g! EB?O!:B!F899!>7EB! >G@!?EL9O!>78L!DI@998?!@A8I!>@!>78!/8E!I:A8I!EB?!D@==:>>8?!>78! =;I?8I9!>78I8M!, 99;BGE7!GE9!?89JE>D78?!o )(, pO!!EC>8I!>78!C:I9>!=;I?8IO! >@!EII89>!>78=O!<;>!I8ED78?!/8E!I:A8I!@BFL!>78!?EL!EC>8I!>78!=;I?8I!E>! >78!9>@I8M!)==8?:E>8FL!>78I8EC>8I!>78!C:A8!=;I?8I8I9!G8I8!@A8I>ET8B! EB?!DEJ>;I8?!78L!G8I8!@B!>78:I!GEL!>@!>78! 9 8>>F8=8B>9M!\#@;98!@C!(8JI898B>E>:A89!Rekc^RPR] )B!E!F8>>8I!?E>8?!0D>@<8I!RcO!RekcO!3EZ@I!*8B8IEF!&EA:?!$M!"G:HH9!GI@>8!E!J8D;F:EI! 9>E>8=8B>!>7E>!:9!:B?:DE>:A8!@C!>78!?;I899!EB?!D@B?:>:@B9!>7E>!>78!,=8I:DEB! 98>>F8=8B>!@C!2F@I:?E!JFED8?!@B!>78!-8=:B@F89^!V "7:9!ECCE:I!GE9!B@G!D@=JF8>8?!>@!

PAGE 94

! ek @;I!9E>:9CED>:@BM!"78!)B?:EB9!7E?!I8?88=8?!>78:I!JI@=:989O!EB?O!)!<8F:8A8!C@I!>78! C:I9>!>:=8!:B!>78:I!7:9>@ILO!L:8F?8?!@B8!@C!>78:I!B;=<8IO!!@C!>78!BE>:@BO! >@!>78!Z;9>:D8!@C!>78!G7:>89X!\Rekc^Rhk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xTyO!1E=E9988O!1;D7:O!"8K;89>EO!,JEFED7:D@FEO!.7@D>EGO!EB?!0D@B88X!E9!>78! -8=:B@F8!"I:<8!@C!2F@I:?E!J;>9!:>O!:B>@!>78!'BD@BK;8I8?!/8@JF89O!>78!-8=:B@F8!EB?! 3:DD@9;T88!"I:<89!@C!2F@I:? EM

PAGE 95

! ed #X"/-)0!1U2)! 8 9"!@3DV!A>:;6?!B!H:66 CB5h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g!?89DI:<8?!>78!H8@HIEJ7L!EB?!CF@IE!EB?!CE;BE!@C!>7I88!@C!>78!=E:B! GE>8IGEL9!@C! 489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?Eg!FE:?!@;>!E!7:9>@IL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89g!EB?! ?89DI:<8?!E!98I:89!@C!9:HB:C:DEB>!9:>89!@C!-8=:B@F8!EID7E8@F@HL!EB?!7:9>@IL!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?EM!"78!H@EF!@C!>7:9!D7EJ>8I!:9!>@!8BHEH8!G:>7!>78!J@J;FEI!EB?!9D7@FE9>:D! EIH;=8B>9!EB?!JI@A:?8! EB!EF>8IBE>:A8!GEL!>@!;B?8I9>EB?!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9! !:B!>78!EID7:AEF!I8D@I?M!68C@I8!)!D@B>:B;8O!E!97@I>!?:9D;99:@B!@C!>78! >8I=!8>7B@H8B89:9!:9!:B!@I?8IM! "78!D@BD8J>!@C!8>7B@H8B89:9!EI@98!@;>!@C!-@A:8>!J@F:>:DEF!:?8@F@HL! \-7B:I8F=EB!Rccd]M!!,DD@I?:BH!>@!6EI7B@H8B89:9!I8C8I9!>@! >78!<:I>7:BH!@C!B8G!D;F>;IEF!:?8B>:>:89j3@=8B>9!@C!8>7B@H8B89:9!9:HBEF!>78! G@IT:BH9!@C!7:9>@I:DEF!EB?!D;F>;IE F!97:C>9!>7E>!=ET8!JI8A:@;9!T:B?9!@C!:?8B>:C:DE>:@B!

PAGE 96

! ef F899!I8F8AEB>O!H:A:BH!I:98!>@!B8G!C@I=9!@C!:?8B>:>LMX!S@BE>7EB!#:FF!9>E>89!V.;F>;IEF! EB>7I@J@F@H:9>9!7EA8!H8B8IEFFL!;98?!>78!>8I=! $%*/3.$/$)() >@!?89DI:<8!>78!7:9>@I:DEF! 8=8IH8BD8!@C!E!J8@JF8!G7@!?8C:B8!> 78=98FA89!:B!I8FE>:@B!>@!E!9@D:@D;F>;IEF!EB?! F:BH;:9>:D!78I:>EH8X!\#:FF!Rccf^RO!:>EF:D9!:B!@I:H:BEF]M!6@>7!EI8!9:=:FEI!?8C:B:>:@B9O!@B8! CI@=!EB!EID7E8@F@H:9>!EB?!@B8!CI@=!E!D;F>;IEF!EB>7I@J@F@H:9>M!#:FF!C;I>78I!8WJ@;B?9! @B!>78!J@G8I!@C!8>7B@H8B89:9!:B!CF89 7:BH!@;>!>78!B;EBD8!@C!=;>E:>:89^! j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ccf^RO!8=J7E9:9!E??8?]M "78!9>I;HHF8!>@!DI8E>8!8B?;I:BH!:?8B>:>L!:9!@B8!>7E>!7E9!@C>8B!<88B!@A8IF@@T8?!:B!>78! EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?!EDD@I?:BH!>@!b@99!\PQQe^RP]M!-78!JI898B >9!78I!=8>7@?@F@H:DEF! CIE=8G@IT!E9!>78!VI898EID7!JI898B>8?!78I8!:9!B@>!E:=8?!E>!?:9D@A8I:BH!>78!vDE;98U!@C! 8>7B@H8B89:9!<;>!IE>78I!E>!;9:BH!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!8A:?8BD8O!7:9>@I:DEF!?@D;=8B>9O!EB?! @IEF!7:9>@IL!>@!>IED8!>78!G8<9!@C!9@D:EF!?:9D@;I98!EB?!=E>8I:EF!J IED>:D89!>7E>! JEI>:D:JE>8?!:B!>78!8=8IH8BD8!EB?!D@B9@F:?E>:@B!@C!.EF:C@IB:@!:?8 B>:>LX!\PQQe^d]M!!)B! >7898!B8W>!D7EJ>8I9 O!)!G:FF!;>:F:N8!E!CIE=8G@IT!@C!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!EBEFL9:9O!@IEF!I8D@I?! JI898IA8?!>7I@;H7!>78!GI:>>8B!I8D@I?O!EB?!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!I8D@I?!:B!@ I?8I!>@!EIH;8!C@I! 489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!EB?!:>9!GE>8IGEL9!E9!<8:BH!D8B>IEF!>@!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9M! &I:!":WAB6>D>43WBD!"5W6;7>:; "78!J@J;FEI!A:8G! :B!>78!JI8CED8! H:A89!;9!E!98B98!@C!G7E>!>78!8A8IL!?EL! J8I9@B!=:H7>!TB@G!E<@;>!>78!-8=:B@F89!@C!2F@I:?EM!)B!> 7:9!98D>:@BO!)!G:FF!FEL!@;>!>78!

PAGE 97

! ei 9D7@FEI97:J!@C!6I8B>!48:9=EB!EB?!D@=JEI8!:>!>@!.7I:9>@J78I!->@ZEB@G9T:U9!I8D8B>! G@IT!\PQQc]!@B!>78!<:@EID7E8@F@HL!@C!J@9> 5 D@B>ED>!J8@JF89!:B!>78!-@;>78E9>M! 48:9=EB!:9!>78!F8E?:BH!9D7@FEI!@B!-8=:B@F8!EID7E8@F@HL!>@?ELM!#:9!G@ IT!:9! :=JI899:A8!:B!:>9!?8J>7!EB?!:B!:>9!=EZ@I!D@B>I:<;>:@B!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78! -8=:B@F89!:B!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?M!)B!RcecO!78!J;!=EZ@I!G@IT! @B!>78!-8=:B@F89O! H(=$2G$"9)23/2"28%#(/.O2C2<-6%-#$2!()%3#12352%*$28$4(/36$2>/9("/)2(/2 X3#%*$#/2M$/(/)-6"#2:63#(9" \Rcec]M!)B!>7:9!G@ITO!78! @;>F:B89 8EIFL!-8=:B@F8!7:9>@IL! :B!2F@I:?E!CI@=!>78!Re >7 D8B>;IL!>7I@;H7!>@!>78!D@BDF;9:@B!@C!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8! 4EIM!#8! 8WJ@;B?9 ;J@B 7:9!:?8E9!@C -8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L O ?:9D;99:BH!>78!:=J@I>EBD8!@C! 8BHEH8=8B>!G:>7!HF@!EB?!9;:>:89M!#8!C@D;989! @B!>78!.I88T!EBD89>IEF!JE>>8IB!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89O!;>:F:N:BH!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!EB?! 7:9>@I:DEF!I8D@I?9!>@!EIH;8!C@I!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!E 9!E!.I88T 5 I8F E>8?!J78B@=8B@BM!!)B! 7 :9!98D@B?!=EZ@I!G@IT!@B!>78!-8=:B@F89O! N/,3/K-$#$92M$3+6$ O!48:9=EB 2 \Rccc]! GI:>89 >78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!:B!E!J@J;FEIFL! EDD899:EB?:BH!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9O!7:9!=@9>! :=J@I> EB>!D@B>I:<;>:@B!:9!7:9!EI>:DF8 2 V%E>:A:9=O!(89:9>EBD8O!EB?!$>7B@H8B89:9!@C!>78! 2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F8!)B?:EB!:?8B>:>LX!\PQQi]M!!,9!7:9!PQQi!EI>:DF8!:9!7:9!=@9>!D@=JF8>8! G@IT!@B!8>7B@H8B89:9!@C!>78!2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F89O!)!G:FF!?89DI:<8!:>9!?8>E:F9!EB?! EIH;=8B> 9 M 48 :9=EB!;B?8I9>EB?9!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!>@!<8!E!FEIH8FL!VBE>:A:9>:D! J78B@=8B@B!:BCF;8BD8?!9>I@BHFL!EBD8!>@!,=8I:DEB!?@=:BE>:@BX! \PQQi^Rce]M!,9!)!FE:?!@;>!:B!D7EJ>8I!C@;IO!2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F8!7:9>@IL!:9!JI8?:DE>8?!@B! >78:I!I8C;9EF!>@!EFF@G!,=8I:DEB9 >@!D@=JF8>8FL!?@=:BE>8!EB?!D@BK;8I!>78!HI@;JM!

PAGE 98

! ee ,DD@I?:BH!>@!48:9=EBO!I89:9>EBD8!DEB!<8!?8>8I=:B8?!CI@=!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?! >7I@;H7!>78!E<98BD8!@C!$;I@J8EB!D8IE=:D9!EB?!>78!D@B>:B;8?!EJJ8EIEB D8!@C!BE>:A8! J@>>8IL!\PQQi^Rce] M!/8>8I!%E<@T@A!\Rccf]!GI:>89 @B!7@G!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB!J8@JF89! ;B?8I9>EB?!7:9>@IL!EB?!7@G!?:CC8I8B>!:>!:9!CI@=!489>8IB!F:B8EI!;B?8I9>EB?:BH9!@C! 7:9>@ILM!#8!CIE=89!7:9!?:9D;99:@B!@C!=E>8I:EF!D;F>;I8!\:M8M!GE=J;=!<8E?9!C@I!>78! )I@K;@:9]!EB?!7@G!:>!I8JI898B>9!I89:9>EBD8!>@!7:9>@ILM!,DD@I?: BH!>@!%E<@T@A! \Rccf^kh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ccf^kk]O!Vj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

PAGE 99

! ec >78 /E LB89>@GB 9:>8 O!78!B@>89!>7E>!<@>7!-8=:B@F8!EB?!$;I@J8EB!D8IE=:D9! G8I8! C@;B? :B!>78!EI>:CED>!E998=LJ:DEF!@C!=EBL!-8=:B@F8!9:>89!JI8 5 -8D@B?! -8=:B@F8!4EI!\PQQi^PQh]M!6;>!G:>7!9:>89!?E>8?!>@!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EIO!>78I8!:9! E!J8D;F:EI!FEDT!@C EBL!$;I@J8EB!D8IE=:D9M!48:9=EB!@CC8I9!E!J@99:7:9! @DD;II8?^!V&;8!>@!>78!D@B9>IE:B>9!@C!GEIO!:>!:9!J@99:7E>!>78!9;JJFL!@C!D8IE=:D9! 9:=JFL!?I:8?!;JjX!\PQQi^PQk]M!#@G8A8IO!>78!7:9>@I:D!I8D@I?O!E9!78!J@:B>9!@;>O!97@G9! >7E>!>7:9!9:=JFL!GE9! B@>!>78!DE98!E9!Vj>78!!GE9!T8J>!A8IL!=;D7!EF:A8!IE?8I9!EB?!8B>I8JI8B8;I9!78?H:BH!>78:I!<8>9!@B!>78!GEIU9!@;>D@=8X!\PQQi^PQk]M! 48:9=EB!EF9@! GI:>89!E<@;> >78!;98!@C!,=8I:DEB!=:F:>EIL!DF@>7:BH!>I:<;>89!E!H@@?!?8EF!@C!9L=<@ F:D!J@G8I!>@!>78!;9EH8!@C!>78!;B:C@I=9! 78!J@G8I!@C!BE>:A:9=!@A8I!>78!G7:>8!=EBM!#@G8A8IO!)!?@! B@>!>7:BT!>7:9!:9!>78!DE98!E9!F@@T:BH!F:T8!>78!8B8=L!:B!E!>:=8!@C!GEI!7E9!F@BH!<88B!E! >ED>:D!;98?!:B!GEICEI8O!89J8D:EFFL!E9L==8>I:DEFO! H;8I:FFE!GEICEI8M!)>!:9!EF9@!:=J@I>EB>! >@!I8=8=<8I!>7E>!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EIO!=@I8!>7EB!E!-8=:B@F8!4EIO!DEB!<8! ;B?8I9>@@?!>@!<8!E!3EI@@B!GEI!G:>7!-8=:B@F89!C:H7>:BH!EF@BH9:?8!\ 6FE:I!EB?!(:A89! Rehc^Pfcg! /@I>8I!Rcfkg!.FEA:B!PQRR]M 48:9=EB \PQQi^Rce] J@9:> 9!>7E>!>78!DE>EFL9>!C@I!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!:9!>78! -8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EIM!#@G!DEB!E!J8@JF8!<8D@=8!-8=:B@F8!EF=@9>!>G@!?8DE?89!EC>8I! >78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8!4EI!_!"78!EB9G8I!:9!>7E>!>78!G@I?!-8=:B@F8!7E?! D@F@B:EF:9>!:=JF:DE>:@B9M!)B!E!$;I@J8EB!D@B>8W>O! >78!G@I?!-8=:B@F8!I8C8II8?!>@! J8@JF8!@J8IE>:BH!@;>9:?8!@C!>78!I8EF=!@C!E!$;I@J8EB 5 ?@=:BE>8?!I8H:@B!E9!8EIFL!E9! >78!Ri >7 D8B>;ILM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!S@7B!4@I>7O!":=;D;EB9!G7@!CF8?!-JEB:97!=:99:@B9! G8I8!TB@GB!E9! ,(4"##3/$) \Rcce^PO!RPR]M!$A8B!>7@;H7!)!K;@>8?!8EIF: 8I!:B!D7EJ>8I!

PAGE 100

! cQ >7I88!EB!EB8D?@>8!CI@=!S8EB!(8B@!E<@;>!78EI:BH!>78!=8EB:BH!@C!-8=:B@F8!CI@=!E! 3:DD@9;T88!E9!B@>!<8:BH!I8FE>8?!>@!D:=EII@B89O!>78!=8EB:BH!@C!.:=EII@Bu-8=:B@F8! :B!>78!$;I@J8EB!D@B>8W>!I8C8II8?!>@!>7898!I;BEGEL9M!"78I8C@I8O!>78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8! 4E I!:B!CED>!GE9!JEI>!@C!E!B@=8BDFE>;I8!>IE?:>:@B!@C!I8C8II:BH!>@!J8@JF8!:B!2F@I:?E! G7@!G8I8!B@>!E99:=:FE>:BH!EB?!G8I8!I89:9>:BH!$;I@J8EB!:BD;I9:@B9M! $A8B!>7@;H7!48:9=EB!H:A89!E!?8C:B:>:A8!>:=8!CIE=8!C@I!>78!DE>EFL9>!C@I! -8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!E9!>78!-8D@B?!8=:B@F8!4EIO!78!I:H7>FL!9>E>89O $>7B@H8B89:9j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i^PQPO!8=J7E9:9!E??8?]M "78!:=J@I>EBD8!@C!D8I8=@B:EF!:B>8IED>:@B!EB?!>IE?8!I@;>89!>@GEI?9!<8D@=:BH! -8=:B@F8!:9!A:>EF!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!8>7B@H8B89:9M!&IM!48:9=EB!JI@A:?89!9>I@BH! 8A:? 8BD8!@C!>78!78H8=@BL!@C!3;9T@H88!D8I8=@B:EF!JIED>:D8!:B!7:9!JI8A:@;9!G@IT! \48:9=EB!Rcecg!Rccc]!:B!>78!F@G8I!-@;>78E9>M!"78!6;9T!D8I8=@BL!G@;F?!HI@G!:B! :=J@I>EBD8!EB?!;F>:=E>8FL!<8D@=8!EB!:=J@I>EB>!D8B>8I:BH!J@:B>!@C!-8=:B@F8! :?8B>:>L!8A8B!:B>@!>78!JI898B>O I8HEI?F899!@C!D@BA8I9:@B!>@!.7I:9>:EB:>L!E9!=EBL! -8=:B@F89!EB?!3:DD@9;T889!7EA8!?@B8M 68D@=:BH!-8=:B@F8!GE9!>78!I89;F>!@C!H8B8IE>:@B9!@C!9@D:@ 5 J@F:>:DEF! :B>8IED>:@B9!>IL:BH!>@!I8?8C:B8!>78!IEJ:?FL!D7EBH:BH!G@IF?!@C!>78!9@;>78E9>!I8H:@B!@C! %@I>7!,=8I:DEM!/ @G8IC;F!J@F:>:89!:B!-JEB:97! H"2:63#(9" ?:9:B>8HIE>8?!E9!?:98E98!EB?! GEICEI8!?8D:=E>8?!>78!J@J;FE>:@B9!@C!>78!J8@JF89!@C!2F@I:?E!EB?!>78!3;9T@H88!

PAGE 101

! cR .I88T9!I@98!:B!J@G8I!E9!$;I@J8EB!T:BH?@=9!GEII8?!@A8I!FEB?!DFE:=9!EB?! =@BEID7EF!9;DD899:@BM!48:9=EB!\RcecO!Rccc O!PQQi]!E??9!T8L!:B9:H7>9!:B>@!G78B!>78! -8=:B@F89!<8HEB!>@!;B?8I9>EB?!>78=98FA89!E9!-8=:B@F8!EB?!B@>!(8?!->:DT!@I!0D@B88! @I!3:TE9;T:!@I!,JEFED7:!@I!E9!?:9JEIE>8!HI@;J9!@C!J8@JF8!B@=:BEFFL!EFF:8?!>@!JI@>8D>! >78:I!I:H7>9!>@!F:A8!E9!J8@JF89!@;>9:?8!@C!$;I@J8E B!78H8=@BLM!"78!B8>G@IT9!@C! D8I8=@BL!EB?!>IE?8!>7E>!78FJ8?!FEL!>78!C@;B?E>:@B9!C@I!D@B>8=J@IEIL!-8=:B@F8! :?8B>:>LO!78FJ8?!>@!9;9>E:B!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!E9!>78:I!B;=<8I9!G8I8!I8?;D8?!>@!Z;9>!E! C8G!7;B?I8?!9DE>>8I8?!EDI@99!>78!9GE=J9!EB?!7:B>8IFEB?9!@C!>78!9@ ;>78IB!2F@I:?E! J8B:B9;FEM 478I8E9!48:9=EB!JI898B>9!EB!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!EB?!8>7B@HIEJ7:D!J8I9J8D>:A8! @B!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9O!.7I:9>@J78I!->@ZEB@G9T:!:9!D@BD8IB8?!G:>7!D@B>I:<;>:BH! E!<:@EID7E8@F@H:DEF!J8I9J8D>:A8!@B!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9M!)B9>8E?!@C!988:BH! 8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!E9!E!I89J@B98!>@!+@G8I!.I88T!9@D:@ 5 J@F:>:D9!E9!48:9=EB!EB?! @>78I9!\->;I>8A8EB>!RciRg!.IE:H!EB?!/88@ZEB@G9T:!D@=<:B89!Vj<:@?:9>EBD8!?E>E!G:>7!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!EB?!7:9>@I:DEF! :BC@I=E>:@B!>@!EIH;8!>7E>!>7 8!-8=:B@F8O!H8B8IEFFL!D@B9:?8I8?!8:H7>88B>7 5 D8B>;IL! =:HIEB>9!>@!2F@I:?EO!EI8O!:B!JEI>O!<:@F@H:DEF!?89D8B?EB>9!@C!>78!/I8 5 .@F;=<:EB! J@J;FE>:@B!@C!>78!9>E>8!G7@98!EBD89>IEF!D@BB8D>:@B9!>@!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!G8I8!8IE98?! 78!AEHEI:89!@C!D@F@B:EF!8>7B@BL=LX!\->@Z EB@G9T:!PQQc^fQ]M!$>7B@H8B89:9!:9!B@>!E! 9:=JF8!JI@D899!<;>!IE>78I!E!98I:89!@C!=@=8B>9!EB?!J@99:<:F:>:89!@B!>78!7:9>@I:D!EB?! D@B>8=J@IEIL!FEB?9DEJ89M!48:9=EB!\PQQi]!JI@A:?89!>78!:B9:H7>!:B>@!>78!GE>8I978?! =@=8B>!EB?!>78!78H8=@BL!@C!.I88T!D8I8=@B:EF!JIED>:D8 g ->@ZEB@G9T:!EIH;89!>7E>! >78!-8=:B@F89!EI8!B@>!E!JI:=EI:FL!.I88T!J78B@=8B@B!<;>!IE>78I!>7E>!>78L!EI8!>78!

PAGE 102

! cP I89;F>!@C!I8C;H889!@C!2F@I:?E!J8@JF89!I8>;IB:BH!>@!>78:I!7@=8FEB?9!>@!I889>E78=98FA89!\PQQc^ff]M ->@ZEB@G9T:!?8I:A89!7:9!<:@EID7E8@F@H:DEF!?E>E C@I!JI8 5 -8=:B@F8O!J@9> 5 D@B>ED>!2F@I:?E!CI@=!JI:=EI:FL!>7I88!JI@A:BD89^!>78!,JEFED7:O!>78!*;EF8O!EB?!>78! ":=;D;E!JI@A:BD89!@C!J@9> 5 .@B>ED>!-JEB:97!+E!2F@I:?EM!68C@I8!-JEB:97!98>>F8=8B>!@C! 2F@I:?EO!2F@I:?E!GE9!:BDI8?::DEFFL!EB?!D@B>E:B8? E!?:A8I98!EIIEL! @C!J8@JF89M!->@ZEB@G9T:!9>E>89!V,JJI@W:=E>8FL!Pd!FEBH;EH89!@I!?:EF8D>9!G8I8!9J@T8B! E=@BH!J8I7EJ9!dQ!?:CC8I8B>!D7:8C?@=9O!G7:D7!AEI:8?!:B!J@J;FE>:@B!?8B9:>LO!=E>8I:EF! D;F>;I8O!9;<9:9>8BD8!E?EJ>E>:@BO!EB?!98>>F8=8B>!9>I;D>;I8X!\PQQc^fh]!:B!2 F@I:?EM!)B! 7:9!EBEFL9:9!@C!H8B8>:D!?:9>EBD8!@I?:BE>:@B9!?;I:BH!>78!FE>8!Rf >7 D8B>;IL!EB?!C:I9>!7EFC! @C!>78!Ri >7 D8B>;IL!78!C@;B?!>7E>!V"78!JE>>8IB!@C!H8B8>:D!?:9>EBD89!E=@BH!9E=JF89! ?;I:BH!>78!8EIFL!=:99:@B!J8I:@?!:B?:DE>89!:9@FE>:@B!EBD8O!G7:D7!I8C F8D>9! F:=:>8?!F@BH 5 ?:9>EBD8!H8B8!CF@G!EB?!9;HH89>9!>7E>!>78!JE>>8IB!@C!=E>8!8WD7EBH8!?:?! B@>!D7EBH8!G:>7!>78!>IEB9:>:@B!>@!98>>F8?!=:99:@B!F:C8X!\PQQc^fe]M!47E>!:9!=@9>! 9>I:T:BH!:9!>78!I89;F>9!C@;B?!C@I!>78!FE>8!=:99:@B!J8I:@?O!G7:D7!EDD@I?:BH!>@! ->@ZEB@G9 T:!?E>89!<8>G88B!RfdQ!EB?!RiQkM!->@ZEB@G9T:!C@;B?!>7E>!>78!H8B8>:D! ?:9>EBD8!GE9!9:HB:C:DEB>FL!9=EFF8I!>7EB!>78!8EIFL!=:99:@B!J8I:@?O!E!9;IJI:9:BH!I89;F>M! #8!9>E>89O!V)C!J@J;FE>:@B!9:N8!EF@B8!G8I8!?I:A:BH!>78!H8B8>:D!AEI:EBD89O!FE>8!=:99:@B! J8I:@?!I8H:@BEF! H8B8>:D!?:A8I9:>L! 03-692?$24"R(4(&$9 X!\PQQc^fc]M!68DE;98!@C!>7:9! I89;F>!78!JI@J@989!>7E>!>78!DE;98!@C!>7:9!I8?;D>:@B!:B!AEI:E<:F:>L!:9!DE;98?!8B9:A8!F@BH 5 ?:9>EBD8!=:HIE>:@B!EB?!H8B8!CF@G!E=@BH!=:99:@B:N8?!D@==;B:>:89! :B!>78!GET8!@C!B8EI 5 D@=JF8>8!?8= @HIEJ7:D!D@FFEJ98X!\PQQc^fc]M!"78!8A:?8BD8!@C!>7:9!

PAGE 103

! ch 9:HB:C:DEB>!?8=@HIEJ7:D!D7EBH8!:B?:DE>89!9@D:EF!I8@IHEB:NE>:@B!:B!2F@I:?EO!G7:D7!:9! 8B>:I8FL!D@B9:9>8B>!G:>7!>78!TB@GB!7:9>@I:DEF!EB?!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?9M! #@G!?@89!>7:9!:BC@I=E>:@B!C:>!:B>@!E!=@?8F!@C! -8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9_!"78! >G@!=EZ@I!EI8E9!@C!8EIFL!JI@>@ 5 -8=:B@F8!98>>F8=8B>!G8I8!>78!,FED7;E!/IE:I:8!\>78! C@I=8I!JI@A:BD8!@C!>78!489>8IB!":=;D;E]!EB?!>78!"EFFE7E9988!(8?!#:FF9!\>78!C@I=8I! JI@A:BD8!@C!>78!,JEFED788]M!,9!->@ZEB@G9T:!9>E>89 \PQQc^ih 5 ik] O!C@ I! ;BTB@GB I8E9@B 9 >7898!>G@!EI8E9!89DEJ8?!=@9>!@C!>78!8CC8D>9!@C!?8=@HIEJ7:D!D@FFEJ98!;B>:F! A8IL!FE>8M!#8!?@89!B@>!H@!:B>@!=;D7!?8>E:F!D@BD8IB:BH!>78!,FED7;E!-8=:B@F89O!<;>! IE>78I!C@D;989!@B!>78!"EFFE7E9988!-8=:B@F89^ "78I8C@I8O 2 >78!=@A8!@!,JEFED788! >8II:>@IL!@ 5 -8=:B@F8u+@G8I!.I88T!J@J;FE>:@B9!:9!:B!=L!@J:B:@B! )(4+612"2#$%-#/2%32 %*$2*34$6"/923529()+6",$92+$3+6$@2#$/"4$92?12,3/%$4+3#"#12Q-#3+$"/)2 %*"%25"(6$92%32-/9$#)%"/92%*$2/-"/,$)2352,363/("62%#(?"62)3,($%1; \PQQc^ikO!8=J7E9:9!E??8?] "78! -8=:B@F89!E9!I8>;IB:BH!J8@JF89!IE>78I!>7EB!=:HIEB>9!:9!E!J@G8IC;F!EB?! 9;:@B!>7E>!;B?8ID;>9!$;I@J8EB 5 ,=8I:DEB!7:9>@I:89!@C!>78!-@;>78E9>M! "78!?:CC8I8BD8!<8>G88B!B8G!=:HIEB>9!EB?!J8@JF89!I8>;IB:BH!>@!E!7@=8FEB?!:9! JI@C@;B?M!)>!8A8B!7E9!JI@C@;B?!: =JF:DE>:@B9!C@I!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!.I88T! .@BC8?8IEDLM!!,9!->@ZEB@G9T:!9>E>89!\PQQc^id 5 if]^ (8D@HB:N:BH!<:@F@H:DEF!EB?!9@D:EF!D@BB8D>:@B9!:B!>78!D@B>8W>!@C!E! D@78I8B>!7:9>@I:DEF!>IEZ8D>@IL!8A:?8B>!CI@=!>78!JI8 5 .I88T!>7I@;H7! .I88T!EB?!>78B!-8=:B@F8!J8I:@?9!7E 9!:=J@I>EB>!:=JF:DE>:@B9!C@I!>78! JEI9:BH!@C!D;F>;IEF!JE>I:=@BL!:B!>78!9@;>78E9>8IB!'B:>8?!->E>89M! +E<8F:BH!>78!-8=:B@F8!E9!8:H7>88B>7!D8B>;IL!=:HIEB>9!>@!2F@I:?E! ?:=:B:9789!>78:I!JE>I:=@BLO!7:9>@ILO!EB?!78I:>EH8M!S;9>!E9!>78!.I88T! EI8!E!DE98!9>;?L!:B!D@F@B :EF!8>7B@BL=LO!9@!>@@!EI8!>78!-8=:B@F8M! V-8=:B@F8X!:9!E!D@II;J>8?!C@I=!@C!D:=EII@BO!E!D@B?:>:@B!>7E>!?8C:B8?! -8=:B@F8!I89:9>EBD8!>7I@;H7@;>!>78:I!I8D@HB:N8?!7:9>@ILM!)!JI@J@98! >7E>!>7:9!9E=8!JE99:@B!C@I!I89:9>EBD8!C;I>78I!F:BT9!>78!=@?8IB! -8=:B@F8!>@!2F@I: ?EU9!JI8D@B>ED>!:B?:H8B@;9!J@J;FE>:@B9g!>7@98!>7E>! VK;:>X!>78!-JEB:97!<8DE=8!.I88T!EB?!;F>:=E>8FL!BEA:HE>8?!>78!D@F@B:EF!

PAGE 104

! ck J8I:@?O!FE>8I!?8CL:BH!>78!$BHF:97!EB?!>78B!>78!,=8I:DEB9M!"7:9!7:9>@IL! @C!?8C:EBD8O!G7:D7!C:H;I89!9@!JI@=:B8B>FL!:B!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!> @?ELO! :BDF;?89!9;IA:A:BH!>7I88!GEI9!G:>7!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!EB?!J@J;FE>:@B! I8?;D>:@B9!>@!PQQ!J8@JF8M!&8C:EBD8!98IA8?!>78!-8=:B@F8!G8FF! >7I@;H7@;>!>78:I!7:9>@IL q EB?!E!F@BH!7:9>@IL!:>!7E9!<88BM "7:9O!;F>:=E>8FL!9;ET8!@B!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!:9!E! =EZ@I!D@B>I:<;>:@B! EB?!E??9!E!?:CC8I8B>!J8I9J8D>:A8!>@!>7E>!@C!48:9=EB! \Rcecg!PQQi]! G7@!C@D;989!=@I8! @B!.I88T!:BCF;8BD89!@B!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9M!->@ZEB@G9T:! \PQQc]! 8=J7E9:N89!>7E>! >78!-8=:B@F89!<8D@=8!-8=:B@F8!EC>8I!I8>;IB:BH!>@!>78:I!7@=8FEB?!EC>8I!<8:B H!8W:F8?! EB?!>7E>!>78!>8I=9!$;I@J8EB9!EJJF:8?!>@!>78!J8@JF89!I89;F>8?!CI@=!>78:I! =:9;B?8I9>EB?:BH!EB?!D@BC;9:@B!@C!>78!9@D:EF!EB?!J7L9:DEF!FEB?9DEJ8!@C!>78!%E>:A8! J8@JF89!@C!>78!-@;>78E9>M f5W>5gI6:6V!/6>TD6 @?ELU9!-8=:B@F89! EI8!<@;B?!>@H8>78I!G:>7!>78:I 3:DD@9;T88!D@;9:B9!EB?! >78:I!:B?8J8B?8B>!78I9!EB?!9:9>8I9!E9!>78!;BD@BK;8I8?!J8@JF8M!"78!9>E>8 @C! 2F@I:?E :9!TB@GB!C@I!:>9!B;=8I@;9!G8>FEB?9O!9GE=J9O!EB?!7E==@DT9!>7E>!I8=E:B! ;BD@BK;8I8?!>@!>7:9!?EL!E9!=;D7!E9!:>!:9!TB@GB!C@I :>9!<8ED789O C@@>8?!8EIF:8I!:B!D7EJ>8I!>7I88O!>78!-8=:B@F8!"I:<8!@C!2F@I:?E!\-"02]! @CC:D:EFFL!I8D@HB:N89!>78:I!@I:H:B9!E9!9;D7^ .I88TO!#:>D7:>:O!,JEFED788O!3:T:9xTyO!1E=E9988O!1;D7:O!"8K;89>EO! ,JEFED7:D@FEO!.7@D>EGO!EB?!0D@B88!G8I8!Z@:B8?!78I9!:B!>78!J;I9;:>!@C!<8>>8I!F:A89!E=@BH!>78!>7:DT!A:IH:B!C@I89>9O! G:?8!HIE99!JIE:I:89!EB?!9JI:BH 5 C8?!I:A8I9!@C!:B>8I:@I!2F@I:?EM!"78L! 97EI8?!EB!:B9>:BD>!C@I!9;IA:AEF!EB?!E!D@==@BEF>L!@C!J;IJ@98^! #$5-)"62 %32?$2934(/"%$92?12%*$20*(%$24"/S o8 =J7E9:9!E??8?pM!\-"02!PQRR] "78!=;F>:CED8>8?O!D@9=@J@F:>EB!:?8B>:>L!@C!78I:>EH8!:9!:=J@I>EB>!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89! G7@!9>:FF!9J8ET!3:TE9;T:!EB?!3;9T@H88!EB?!D@=JI:98!E!D@=JF8W!=:W!@C!J8@JF89!EB?! :?8B>:>:89M!,9!)!=8B>:@B8?!:B!D7EJ>8I!>7I88O!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!> 78!3:DD@9;T88!

PAGE 105

! cd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e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h )>!:9!EF9@!:=J@I>EB>!>@!B@>8!G7E>!>78!-8=:B@F8!%E>:@B!@C!0TFE7@=E!7E9!>@!9EL! I8HEI?:BH!>78:I!@I:H:B9M!$A8B!>7@;H7!>78!-8=: B@F8!%E>:@B!?@89!B@>!CEFF!;B?8I!>78! :?8B>:>L!@C!'BD@BK;8I8?!/8@JF8!>7E>!:9!9@!A:>EF!>@!2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F8!EB?!3:DD@9;T88! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! h &;8!>@!>78!9DEB>!EI>:DF89!EAE:FE7!:B>8IA:8G9!CI@=!>7:9!HI@;JO!)!I89J8D>C;FFL! 9;<=: >!>@!>78!G:9789!8WJI8998?!:B!>78!EI>:DF89!78!J8@JF8!>@!B@>!GI:>8!EBL>7:BH! E<@;>!>78!HI@;JU9!7:9>@IL!<8L@B?!>78!97EI8?!@I:H:B9!G:>7!>78!-8=:B@F8!"I:<8!@C! 2F@I:?EO!>78!-8=:B@F8!%E>:@B!@C!0TFE7@=EO!EB?!>78!3:DD@9;T88!"I:<8!@C!2F@I:?EM

PAGE 106

! cf :?8B>:>LO!>78L!EI8!EB!:=J@I>EB>!JEI>!@C!>78!J;NNF8M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!-8=:B@F8!%E>:@B! @C!0TFE7@=EO!>7:9!:9!>78:I! 9>@IL ^ "78!7:9>@IL!@C!>78 -8=:B@F8!%E>:@B!@C!0TFE7@=E!<8HEB!G78B!-JE:B! C:I9>!@DD;J:8?!>78!J8B:B9;FE!TB@GB!E9!2F@I:?EM 478B!/8?I@!38BaB?8N! ?8!,A:Fa9!C@;B?8?!->M!,;H;9>:B8!:B!RdfdO!>78!C:I9>!J8I=EB8B>! 98>>F8=8B>!:B!2F@I:?E!EC>8I!E>!F8E9>!fQ!L8EI9!@C!9J@IE?:D!-JEB:97! A:9:>E>:@BO!78! ?:9D@A8I8?!D@=JF8W!D;F>;I89!9;9>E:B8?!:BHO! C:97:BHO!CEI=:BH!EB?!IE:9:BH!9>@DTM!"I:<89!CI@=!>7I88!?:CC8I8B>!78!":=;K;EBO!.EF;9EB!EB?!3;9T7@H8EB!@DD;J:8?! 2F@I:?E!EB?!F:A8?!:B!9=EFF!EB?!G8FF 5 @IHEB:N8?!A:FFEH89M ,F>7@;H7!>@?EL!> 78!>8I=!-8=:B@F8!:9!;98?O!>7:9!BE=8!@I:H:BE>8?!?;8!>@! E!$;I@J8EB!=:9B@=8IO!G7:D7!DE>8H@I:N8?!E!?:A8I98!HI@;J!@C! E;>@B@=@;9!>I:<89!>@H8>78I!;B?8I!>78!BE=8!-8=:B@F8M!"78!-JEB:97! C:I9>!I8D@HB:N8?!>78!:B?@=:>E:@B!@C!>78!9J8ET8I9!@C! >78!sD@I8! FEBH;EH8X! 'F)=3=$ O!EB?!DEFF8?!>78= ,(4"##3/$) O!@I!sCI88! J8@JF8s!\-8=:B@F8]M!"IEB9FE>8?!>7I@;H7!98A8IEF!FEBH;EH89!>@!$BHF:97O! >7:9!>8I=!DE=8!>@!EJJFL!>@!EFF!@C!2F@I:?EU9!:B:>:EF!:B7E<:>EB>9O!EB?!>78:I! B8:H7<@I9!G7@!FE>8I!CF8?!>@!Z@:B!>78=!G78B!?8JI:A8?!@C! >78:I!@GB! 7@=8FEB?9M!"78!-8=:B@F89!E<9@I<8?!I8=BEB>9!@C!@>78I!2F@I:?E!>I:<89! :B>@!>78:I!@GBM!"78!0D@B88!G8I8!>78!@I:H:BEF!s-8=:B@F8Os!EB?!FE>8I! :BDF;?8?!>78!#8D8>8O!$;CE;FEO!3:TE9;T:O!#@II8GE7F8O!"EFE7E9988O! .7:E7EO!EB?!,JJEFED7:D@FEM! ,??:>:@BEFFLO!>7I@; H7!:B>8I=EII:EH8O! >IE?:>:@BEF!D;F>;IEF!E?@J>:@B!JIED>:D89!EB?!>I8E>L!@:@B9O! I;BEGEL!EB?!VCI88?X!9FEA89!G8I8!E<9@I<8?!EF9@M "78!>8I=! VD:=EII@B89X!9J@T8B!78!-JEB:97!GE9!:B:>:EFFL!>IEB9F:>8IE>8?!78! .I88T!E9!V98=AF@BMX V!-8=AF@B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i]!9889!E! BE>:A:9>:D!=@A8=8B>!EI:9:BH!@;>!@C!E!.I88T!J78B@=8B@Bg!->@ZEB@G9T:!\PQQc]! EJJF:89!<:@EID7E8@F@HL!EB?!EIH;89!>7E>!J7L9:DEF!8>7B@H8B89:9!@DD;I9!:B!>78!

PAGE 107

! ci 98A8B>88B>7!D8B>;IL!G:>7!>78!JI899;I89!@C!?8=@HIEJ7:D!D @FFEJ98!EB?!9@D:EF! I8@IH:BENE>:@B!:B!-JEB:97!+E!2F@I:?Eg!>78!-8=:B@F89!988!>78:I!@I:H:B9!:B!E! D@9=@J@F:>EB!F:H7>O!I8CF8D>:BH!>78:I!:?8B>:>L!E9!E!J8@JF8!I8>;IB:BHO!B@>!EB!:==:HIEB>! J8@JF8g!EB?!>78!3:DD@9;T88!988:BH!>78=98FA89!E9!.I88T!?89D8B?EB>9M!(:D7EI?! E>>F8IO!:B!7:9!EI>:DF8!V(8=BEB>9O!(8B8HE?89O!EB?!(;BEGEL9^!-8=:B@F8!$>7B@H8B89:9! ( 8D@B9:?8I8?X!\Rccf]!>EDTF89!>78!:99;8!@C!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9! ;9:BH! EB! 8>7B@7:9>@I:DEF!EJJI@ED7M +:T8!48:9=EB \Rcecg!PQQi] O!-E>>F8I \Rccf] 9889!>78!@I:H:B9!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89 E9!<8:BH!I8FE>8?!>@!>78!.I88TM!'BF:T8!48:9=EBO!:>!:9!E!9>@IL!@C!I8C;H889!EB?!98D899:@BO! IE>78I!>7EB!.I88T9!=@A:BH!:B>@!2F@I:?EM!-E>>F8I!C@D;989!@B!>78!F@G8I!.I88T!D7:8C?@=! @C!>78!YEG:>EM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!-E>>F8IO!V)>9!D@=JF8W!7:9>@IL!EB?!H8>8I@H8B@;9! D@=J@9:> :@B!JI@=@>8?!<@>7!:B9>E<:F:>L!EB?!98D899:@BX!\Rccf^kP]M!6L!RiRdO!>78! YEG:>E!D@B>I@FF8?!3;9T@H88O!,JEFED7:D@FEO!,JEFED7:O!1E=E9:O!EB?!1;D7:!J8@JF89M!"78! I8E9@B!C@I!>78!EJJ8EIEBD8!@C!.I88T!D8I8=@B:EF!78H8=@BL!EB?!>78!I:98!@C!3;9T@H88! EB?!#:>D7:>:!:B!>78!C;>; I8!-8=:B@F89!:9!<8DE;98!@C!>78!78H8=@B:D!BE>;I8!@C!>78! YEG:>E!J@F:>LM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!-E>>F8I!\Rccf^kP]!V"78!YEG:>E!EJJEI8B>FL!:=J@98?! I8F:H:@;9!EB?!F:BH;:9>:D!78H8=@BLO!E9!G8FF!E9!J@F:>:DEF!D@B>I@FM!(:>;EF!JIED>:D89!EB?! <8F:8C9!:B!EFF!@C!>78!+@G8I!.I88T! (%"6 0")2 H8B8IEFFL!D@BA8IH8?!?;I:BH!>78!8:H7>88B>7! D8B>;IL M X!%@>!@BFL!?:?!>78L!:=J@98!I:>;EF!EB?!J@F:>:DEF!D@B>I@FO!<;>!>78L!E F9@!:=J@98?! F:BH;:9>:D!78H8=@BL M!3;9T@H88!<8DE=8!>78!?@=:BEB>!FEBH;EH8!:B!>78!.I88T! .@BC8?8IEDL!EB?!#:D7:>:!8=8IH8?!E9!>78!D@==@B!FEBH; EH8!@C!>78!,JEFED7:D@FEO! 1E=E9:O!EB?!,JEFED7:!>@GB9!\-GEB>@B!RcPe^!Pke 5 Pkc]M!

PAGE 108

! ce $A8B!>7@;H7!>78!YEG:>E!EI8!E!.I88T!J78B@=8B@BO! 6I:=O >78!JEIE=@;B>!D7:8C! :B!>78!8EIFL!8:H7>88B>7!D8B>;ILO!GE9!=EII:8?!>@!EB!,JEFED7:!G@=EB!E9!->@ZEB@G9T: \PQQc] EB?!-E>>F8I!9>E> 8!\Rccf^kh]M!68DE;98!@C!>78!:=J@I>EBD8!@C!=E>I:F:B8EF!F:B8EH8O! 7:9!9@B9!G8I8!,JEFED7:!EB?!7:9!9@B9!-:=J;TE9:!\>78!8EIF:8I!BE=8?!-8D@CC88]!EB?! .7:F@T:F:D7:!F8?!?:99:?8B>!=@A8=8B>9!78:I!9>E>;9!E9!JI@ 5 -JEB:97!EFF:EBD8! EB?!E9!E!9;<@I?:BE>8?!J8@JF8!:B >78!YEG:>E!J@F:>L!?;8!>@!>78:I!,JEFED7:!F:B8EH8M! 0B8!@C!:B>I:H;:BH!J:8D89!@C!8A:?8BD8!>7E>!-E>>F8I \Rccf] @!>78!C@I8!:9! >78!7:9>@I:D!I8D@I?!@C!>@GB!BE=89!:B!Re >7 D8B>;IL!-JEB:97!+E!2F@I:?EM!-J8D:C:DEFFLO!E>! >78!78E?!@C!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IO!>78I8!GE9!E!A:FFEH8!TB@GB!E9!"EFETD7EJT@M!"78!CED>!>7E>! >7E>!BE=8!D@B>:B;8?!>@!7EA8!:=J@I>EBD8!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89!E9!E!=EIT8I!@C!JFED8!:9! :B?:DE>:A8!@C!TB@GF8?H8!@C!JFED8O!:9!EB@>78I J:8D8!@C!8A:?8BD8!>7E>!9;JJ@I>9!>78! EIH;=8B>!EHE:B9>!>78!:?8E!>7E>!>78!-8=:B@F89!EI8!:==:HIEB>9!EB?!.I88TM!,B@>78I! J:8D8!@C!>78!J;NNF8!:9!>7E>!>78!,FED7;E!-8=:B@F89!EI8!EB!0D@B88!HI@;JM!-E>>F8I! I8J@I>9O!V"78I8!:9!E!I8E9@BEL!>7E>!4TEJ;D7E9:U9 o.@GT88J8Ip!0T@B:! G8I8!:?8B>:DEF!G:>7!>78!0D;>8!@C!8EIFL!-JEB:97!EDD@;B>9X!\Rccf^ke]M!!"78!0D;>8!G8I8! :B!9@;>78E9>8IB!*8@IH:E!EB?!-E>>F8I!<8F:8A89!>78I8!:9!E!D@BB8D>:@B!<8>G88B!>78!>G@! <8DE;98!>78!VH8=:BE>8! / :B!3;9T@H88!:9!@C>8B!78EI?!E9!E! 92 @I!E! %2 7:9O!>78!=@A8=8B>!@C!0D@B88! ?@GBGEI?!:B>@!2F@I:?E!:9!I8JI898B>E>:A8!@C!E!HI@G:BH!?:99:?8B>!=@A8=8B>!988T:BH! >@!=@A8!@;>!@C!.I88TuYEG:>E!78H8=@BL!EB?!I8?8C:B8!>78=98FA89!@B!>78:I!@GB! >8I=9!:B!2F@I:?EM 2@I -E>>F8I!\Rccf]O!@B8!@C!>78!=EZ@I!=@=8B>9!@C!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L! C@;B?E>:@B!@DD;I9!<8>G88B!RieQ!EB?!RePPO!E!>:=8!@C!HI8E>!;J78EAEF!C@I!>78!.I88T!

PAGE 109

! cc .@BC8?8IEDLM!"78!;9;IJE>:@B!@C!J@G8I!78!.I88T! .@BC8?8IEDL!;F>:=E>8FL!F8?!>@!>78!98A8 I:BH!@C!>:89!:FF!B@=:BEFFL!D@BB8D>8?!>@!>78!.I88T!.@BC8?8IEDLM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!-E>>F8IO!>78!,FED7;E! -8=:B@F89!G8I8!>78!C:I9>!>@!98A8I!>:89!>@!>78!.I88T!.@BC8?8IEDL!C@FF@G:BH!>78!I:98!@C! 3D*:FF:AIEL^ "78!,FED7;E!-8=:B@F8!G8I8!>7 8!C:I9>!>@!98A8I!>:89M!68DE;98!>78L!G8I8! ?:9>EB>!CI@=!>78!D8B>8I9!@C!.I88T!J@G8IO!YEG:>EU9!9;N8IE:B>L!7E?! EFGEL9!<88B!B@=:BEF!>78I8M!&;I:BH!>78!,=8I:DEB!(8A@F;>:@B!>7:9! HI@;J!ED>:A8FL!JEI>:D:JE>8?!G:>7!>78!6I:>:97!:B!E>>EDT9!EHE:B9>!>78! ,=8I:DEB9O!:B!A:@FE >:@B!@C!@CC:D:EF!.I88T!B8;>IEF:>L!\6@L?!EB?!+E>@II8! Rcdh^!RRhg!-8EIDL!Rced^!PQO!iPO!RQeO!Rdk]M!6L!>78!RicQ9O!>78!,FED7;E! ED>:A8FL!J;I9;8?!EB!:B?8J8B?8B>!D@;I98O!=@9>FL!7?IEG:BH!CI@=! JEI>:D:JE>:@B!:B!+@G8I!.I88T!EB?!D@BC8?8IEDL!ECCE:I9M!\Rccf^dR]M "7 8!,FED7;E!-8=:B@F8!G8I8!=E?8!;J!@C!0D@B88O!1E=E9:O!EB?!F:T8FL!I8C;H88!2F@I:?E! J@J;FE>:@B9!9;D7!E9!>78!"@D@<@HEO!G7@!G8I8!EFI8E?L!8CC8D>:A8FL!:B?8J8B?8B>!EB? ?@=:BE>8?!>78!,FED7;E!-EAEBBE7 M "78!,JEFED788!-8=:B@F89!:B!>78!C@I=8I!,JEFED788!JI@A:BD8!C@FF@G8?! >78! ,FED7;E!-8=:B@F89!:B!LM!3D*:FF:AIEL!GE9!7:H7FL! ;BJ@J;FEI!E=@BH!>78!,JEFED788!-8=:B@F89!E9!>78L!9;JJ@I>8?!4:FF:E=!,;H;9>;9! 6@GF89!:B!>78!J@G8I!9>I;HHF8!\Rccf^dP]M!6L!ReQkO!>78!.I88T!.@BC8?8IEDL! EDTB@GF8?H8?!>78!E;>@B@=L @C!>7:9!HI@;J!EB?!>78!HI@;J9!7E?!<8D@=8!C;FFL! :B?8J8B?8B>!@C!.I88T!78H8=@BLM!'BF:T8!>78!,FED7;E!-8=:B@F8O!>78!,JEFED788! -8=:B@F8O!89J8D:EFFL!>78!3:T:9xTyO!G8I8!EB!,JEFED7:!HI@;JM!$A8B!>7@;H7!>78L!G8I8! ,JEFED7:!F:A:BH!:B!>78:I!7@=8FEB?O!E;>@B@=L!EB?!:B?8J8 B?8BD8!?:?!B@>!D@=8!;B>:F! >78!J@G8I!:B!>78!HI@;J!97:C>8?!CI@=!"EFE7E99:!>@!3:T:9xTyM!-E>>F8I!9>E>89^ "78!:BDI8E9:BH!:B?8J8B?8BD8!JI@8?!EB@>78I!:=J@I>EB>! D7EBH8!E=@BH!>78!-8=:B@F8!@C!>7:9!I8H:@BM!"@BEJ:!@C!"EFE7E99:! EJJEI8B>FL!?:8?!97@I>FL!EC>8 I!RiiiM!#8!GE9!9;DD88?8?!E9!9J@T89=EB!

PAGE 110

! RQQ EB?!F8E?8I!!@BFL!7E?!E!B8G!F8E?8I!8=8IH8?O!<;>!JI88=:B8BD8!7E?! 97:C>8?M!"78!BE>;I8!EB?!DE;989!@C!>7:9!97:C>!EI8!;BTB@GBO!<;>!>78! 8CC8D>9!G8I8!9:HB:C:DE B>M!\Rccf^dP] -E>>F8IU9!DE;>:@;9B899!:9!;B?8I9>EB?E!>7:9!J@99:<:F:>L!C@I!:BDI8E9:BH! E;>@B@=Lg!7@G8A8IO!>78!CED>!:9!>7E>!H@:BH!@!-8D@CC88!EB?!7:9!78I! .7:F@T:F:D7:!:B!>78!C:I9>!?8DE?89!@C!>78!Re >7 D8B>;ILO!>78I8!7E?!<88B!E!?:99:?8 B>! =@A8=8B>!@C!,JEFED788!EB?!@>78I!9;<@I?:BE>8?!I8C;H88!HI@;J9!;B?8I!YEG:>E!EB?! .I88T!78H8=@BLM!"78!=@A8=8B>!@C!J@G8I!>@!E!D8B>8I!@C!,JEFED7:!F:C8!C@I!>78! ,JEFED788!-8=:B@F8!:9!E!I889>E!@C!J@G8I!C@I!E!2F@I:?E!J8@JF8O! G7@!7EA8! I8>;IB8?!>@!>78:I!7@= 8 FEB? M "G@!@>78I!8A8B>9!EI8!:=J@I>EB>!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!D@9=@J@F:>EB! EB?!?:A8I98!=ET8;J!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89M!2F@I:?E!7E?!F@BH!<88B!E!JFED8!@C!I8C;H8!C@I! 9FEA89!89DEJ:BH!>@!CI88?@=M!#@G8A8IO!<8C@I8!RifhO!Vj>78I8!:9!B@!8A:?8BD8!>7E>!>78L! o3EI@@B9p!C@I= 8?!EBL!D@BB8D>:@B!G:>7!>78!-8=:B@F8!@I!>7E>!>78L!C@I=8?!E!JEI>!@C! >78!FE>8I!-8=:B@F8!3EI@@B9M!"78!EAE:FE89!>7E>!>78!8EIF:8I! 3EI@@B9!:B!CED>!F8C>!G:>7!>78!-JEB:97!:B!RifhX!\-E>>F8I!Rccf^fi]M!!4:>7!>78!6I:>:97! >ET8@A8I!@C!2F@I:?EO!EB?!97: C>:BH!H8@J@F:>:D9!E9!>78!BE9D8B>!,=8I:DEB!(8A@F;>:@BEIL! =@A8=8B>!>@@T!7@F?O!:>!<8DE=8!E!J@F:>:DEF!EB?!8D@B@=:D!G8EJ@B!@C!>78!6I:>:97!>@! :BA:>8!9FEA89!>@!89DEJ8!>@!2F@I:?E!EB?!F:A8!CI88FL!:B!8WD7EBH8!C@I!?8C8B98!@C!>78:I! D@F@B:EF!:B>8I89>M!$A8B!>7@;H7!>78!6 I:>:97!F@9>!>78!4EIO!>78!=@A8=8B>!@C!89DEJ8?! 9FEA89!:B>@!2F@I:?E!D@B>:B;8?M!"78!4EI!@C!ReRP!:BDI8E98?!>78!CF@G!@C!9FEA89!988T:BH! CI88?@=!:B!2F@I:?EO!89J8D:EFFL!G:>7!>78!89>E!@C!>78!%8HI@!2@I>!@B!>78! ,JEFED7:D@FE!(:A8I!\6EIE=!PQQeg!'978IG@@?!PQRRg! -E;B>!PQRP]M!"78!3EI@@B!

PAGE 111

! RQR D@==;B:>:89!DI8E>8?!:B!2F@I:?E!8B?8?!;J!JI@A:?:BH!>78!-8=:B@F89!G:>7!9@=8!@C! >78:I!=@9>!:=J@I>EB>!EB?!AEF;E8IJI8>8I9M "78!98D@B?!8A8B>!GE9!>78!?8C8E>!@C!>78!(8?!->:DT!.I88T9!:B!>78!.I88T!4EI!@C! ReRh 5 ReRkM!"78!.I 88T!4EI!GE9!@I:H:BEFFL!E!D:A:F!GEIO!<;>!8B?8?!;J!8BD@=JE99:BH! >78!@BH@:BH!4EI!@C!ReRP!E9!E!JI@WL!GEIM!"78!+@G8I!.I88T9!G8I8!EFF:8?!E>!>78!>:=8! G:>7!,=8I:DEB!C@ID89!EB?!:B>8HIE>8?!:B>@!EB!:BDI8E9:BHFL!HF@M!"78! (8?!->:DT!.I88T!\>78!'JJ8I!.I88T] G8I8!?:99:?8B>9!:B9J:I8?!78!BE>:A:9>! =@A8=8B>!@C!"8D;=987M!"78!?8C8E>!@C!>78!(8?!->:DT!.I88T!EB?!>78:I!EFF:89!E=@BH!>78! .I88T!F8?!>@!E!=E99!:BCF;W!@C!(8?!->:DT!EB?!'JJ8I!.I88T!I8C;H889!:B>@!2F@I:?EM!"7898! .I88T!!>78: I!BE>:A:9>!=@A8=8B>!G:>7!>78 =! >@!2F@I:?EM! 6L!RePPO!>78!?:9JEIE>8!2F@I:?E!HI@;J9!G8I8!:B!DI:9:9!=@?8M!"78!2:I9>! -8=:B@F8!4EI!7E?!Z;9>!D@BDF;?8?O!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!7E?!>ET8B!D@B>I@F!@C!2F@I:?E! CI@=!>78!-JEB:97O!EB?!>78!,JEFED7:D@FE!-8=:B@F8!7E?!HE:B8?!E;>@B@=L!EB?! :B?8J8B?8BD8!CI@=! >78!+@G8I!.I88TM!"7:9!F8?!>@!>78!C@I=E>:@B!@C!E!D@;BD:F!:B!@I?8I! >@!?8EF!G:>7!>78!,=8I:DEB9M!,DD@I?:BH!>@!-E>>F8I^ )B!I89J@B98!>@!,=8I:DEB!?8=EB?9O!>78!?:9JEIE>8!-8=:B@F8!HI@;J9! C@I=8?!E!;B:C:8?!D@;BD:F!>@!?8EF!G:>7!>78=M!"7:9!D@;BD:F!:BDF;?8?!EFF! >78!(8?9 >:DT!>@GB9O!>78!,FED7;EO!>78!,JEFED788!-8=:B@F8O!EB?!>78! ,JEFED7:D@FE!-8=:B@F8M!0B8!#:>D7:>:!>@GBO!"@>>@F@9:!"EF@CEO! JEI>:D:JE>8?!E9!G8FFM!"78!D@;BD:F!8W:9>8?O!:B:>:EFFLO!9:=JFL!>@!?8EF!G:>7! >78!,=8I:DEB9!EB?!>@!B8H@>:E>8!E!B8G!>I8E>!G:>7!>78=M!)>!7E?!B@! 8 BC@ID8=8B>!J@G8I9O!EB?!:>9!@BFL!@CC:D:EF!GE9!E!9J8ET8IM!\Rccf^di] "7:9!D@;BD:FO!D@=<:B8?!G:>7!>78!"I8E>L!@C!3@;F>I:8!.I88T!JI@A:?8?!>78!C@;B?E>:@B! C@I!>78!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!>@!@DD;I!EDD@I?:BH!>@!-E>>F8IM!68DE;98!@C!D@BCF:D>!@A8I! >78!I898IAE>:@B!JI@D89 9O!>78!D@;BD:F!>@@T!@B!:BDI8E9:BH!:=J@I>EBD8!E9!E!F:=:BEF! 9JED8!C@I!BE9D8B>!;B:C:8?!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!>@!<8H:B!>@!>ET8!97EJ8M!)B!RePdO!>78!C:I9>!

PAGE 112

! RQP 8F8D>:@B!C@I!JEIE=@;B>!D7:8C!GE9!78F?O!G:>7!"ET@9E!)=E‚E!@C!>78!3:T:9xTy!<8:BH! 98F8D>8?!JEIE=@;B>!D7:8C!EB?!78! VJF8?H8?!>@!8BC@ID 8!>78!FEG9!EB?!J;B:97!A:@FE>@I9 @C!8:>78I!>I:<8X!\Rccf^de]M!6L!RehdO!>7:9!D@;BD:F!E>>E:B8?!E!F8A8F!@C!J@G8I!@A8I!>78! ?:9JEIE>8!-8=:B@F8!HI@;J9!7E>!:>!D@;F?!:99;8!Z;?H=8B>9!EB?!7EA8!>78=!DEII:8?! @;>^ "78!J@G8I9!@C!>78!D7:8C!EB?!;B:>L!@ C!>78!D@;BD:F!G8I8!G8FF!:FF;9>IE>8?! 78!8W8D;>:@B!@C!.7EIF8L!,=EI>7FE!\.EF:E!)=E‚E]!EB?!ED>:@B9!8EIFL! :B!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EI!:B!&8D8=<8I!RehdM!"78!D@;BD:F!@I?8I8?! .7EIF8L!,=EI>7FEU9!8W8D;>:@B!C@I!D@@J8IE>:BH!G:>7!>78!,=8I:DEB! I8=@AEF!8CC@I>M!,!JEI>L @C!GEII:@I9!CI@=!98A8IEF!?:CC8I8B>!>@GB9!;B?8I! >78!D@==EB?!@C!09D8@FE!\,9:!1E7@FE]O!GEI!D7:8C!@C!>78!"EF9:O!DEII:8?! @;>!>78!98B>8BD8M!\Rccf^de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

PAGE 113

! RQh E9!>@! 0*$#$ 8>7B@H8B89:9!=EL!7EA8!@DD;II8?M!48:9=EB!\PQQi^PQk]!?:9D;9 989!>78! .@A8!@C!>78!4:>7FED@@D788!(:A8I!E9!E!9:>8!@C!:=J@I>EBD8!>@GEI?9!-8=:B@F8! 8>7B@H8B89:9!E9!:>!978F>8I8?!>78!-8=:B@F8!I89:9>EBD8!?;I:BH!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8! 4EIM!)B!>7:9!98D>:@B!)!G:FF!EIH;8!C@I!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!E9!E!JFED8!@C!9:HB:C:DEBD8! >@GEI?9!8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9M!)!G:FF!FEL!@;>!>7I88!CED>@I9!>@GEI?9!-8=:B@F8! 8>7B@H8B89:9^!>78!3LETTE!BE=8g!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!E9!E!9:HB:C:DEB>!JFED8!G:>7!>78! "I8E>L!@C!3@;F>I:8!.I88T!:B!RePhg!EB?!C:BEFFLO!)!G:FF!I8>;IB!>@!>78!J@>!C@;B?!E>!>78! 3LETTE7E>D788!3@;B? >7E>!)!?:9D;998?!:B!D7EJ>8I!C@;IM 'AB7d;!35!B!5BC6E!-A6!,YB__B!03Z6: 47L!:9!>78!BE=8!3LETTE!9:HB:C:DEB>!@B!>78!2F@I:?E!FEB?9DEJ8_!"78!BE=8! 3LETTE!EB?!:>9!AEI:EB>9!3:EIDEO!3:EDDEO!3EDED@O!EB?!3ELED@!7EA8!<88B!C@;B?! >7I@;H7@;>!2F@I:?EM!S@7B!+88!4:FF:E=9!GI: >89^ 478B!28I?:BEB?!o )(, p!?8!-@>@!:BAE?8?!2F@I:?EO!78!C@;B?!EB!)B?:EB! .7:8C!BE=8?!3EDED@!:B!>78!B8:H7<@I7@@?!@C!"E=JE!6ELO!EB?!7:9! JI@A:BD8!<@I8!>78!9E=8!BE=8M!478B!)!A:9:>8?!.7EIF@>>8!6ELO!:B!RePeO!)! C@;B?!98A8IEF!BE>:A8!)B?:EB9O!E<@;>!>78!-JEB:97!C:978I: 89O!G7@!DEFF8?! .7EIF@>>8!(:A8IO!78!BE=8!@C!3EDED@M!\Rehi^fR] "7 8!I:A8I!>7E>!4:FF:E=9!=:9>ET8BFL!I8C8I9!>@!E9!>78!3EDED@!(:A8I!:9!ED>;EFFL!>78! /8ED8!(:A8IO!EB?!>78!I:A8I!78!I8D@I?9!E9!>78!/8ED8!(:A8I!:9!ED>;EFFL!>78!3LETTE! (:A8IM!)B!RfckO!,F8W:9!#;<8I>!SEFF:@>!?I8G!E!=EJ!8B>:>F8?! C4$#(,"2)$+%$/%#(3/"6()2(/2 )-")2+#"$,(+ -")2+"#%$29(F()"@2"92-)-42)$#$/())(4(2G-#.-/9("$29-,() M!0B!>7:9!=EJO!78! I8D@I?9!>78!BE=8!@C!E!>@GB!:B!<8>G88B!"E=JE!6EL!EB?!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!BE=8?! 3;D@D@ \C:H;I8!c] M! )!7EA8!;B?8IF:B8?!>78!BE=8!3;D@D@!@B!>78!=EJ M

PAGE 114

! RQk "7 8!BE=8!3LETTE!7E9!EF9@!<88B!EJJF:8?!>@!98A8IEF!<@?:89!@C!GE>8I!>7I@;H7@;>!>78! 9>E>8M!0B!SEDK;89!%:D@FE9!68FF:BU9!Rikk!=EJ! <"#%$29$26"2H3-()("/$2,3-#)29-2'())())(+(2 $%2+"()2F3()(/) O!78! I8D@I?9!>78!BE=8!@C!E!FET8!B8EI!.EJ8!.EBEA8IEF!DEFF8?!3EZED@ \C:H;I8!RQ] M! )!7EA8!;B?8IF:B8? >78!BE=8!3EZED@! @B!>78!=EJ M 3@9>!CE=@;9FLO!+ET8! 0T88D7@<88!GE9!TB@GB!G@!@>78I!BE=89!:B!I8D@I?8?!7:9>@IL^!+ET8!3ELE:=:!\C@I! >78!3ELE:=:!J8@JF8!G7@!F:A8?!EF@BH!:> 9!97@I89]!EB?!+ET8!3ELED@M!48FF!:B>@!>78! B:B8>88B>7!D8B>;ILO!>7:9!BE=8!GE9!EJJF:8?!>@!>78!FET8M!&EB:8F!*M!6I:B>@B!I8D@I?9O! V478B!>IEA8FF:BH!:B!2F@I:?E!)!C@;B?!E!9=EFF!<@?L!@C!GE>8I!B8EI!3EBE>88!DEFF8?!FET8! 3ELED@O!EB?!@B!>78!8E9>8IB!97@I8!o@C!2F@I:?Ep!>78! I:A8I!3:E=:!JI898IA89!>78!@>78I! C@I=!@C!>78!BE=8!o@C!+ET8!0T88D7@<88pX!\Redc^RRd]M! 134I:6!R! ,-.)*/"$0.#1.21)*%2"(*0$*2$03"0 $ #)"./*#3"0$#")1.$+*4*0"5$"+$303-$0.).2*00*-*$63)732+*".$ +3/*0 ?!JORM

PAGE 115

! RQd 478B!:>!D@=89!>@!>78!BE=8!3LETTE!:B!I8FE>:@B!>@!>78!I:A8IO!:>!:9!H8B8IEFFL! EDD8J>8?!>7E>!>78!BE=8!:9!E!FE>8I!DI8E>:@B!@C!-8=:B@F89!G7@!DE=8!:B>@!>78!9>E>8! \3D.EI>7L!Rceh]M!#:9>@I:EB!S@7B!3D.EI>7L!GI:>89!V"78!/;ID8FF!=EJ!o@C!RicPp!=EL! <8!>78!C:I9>!>@!I8D@I? >78!BE=8!3:ED@!(:A8I!8A8B!>7@;H7!:>!?:?!B@>!EJJFL!>@!>78!I:A8I! @C!>78!BE=8!>@?ELX!\Rceh^Rk]M!3D.EI>7L!F8C>!>78!J@99:<:F:>L!@J8B!>7E>!>78!BE=8! 3LETTE!=EL!<8!@F?8IM!"7@;H7O!>78!:=JF:DE>:@B!>7E>!>78!BE=8!3LETTE!:9!E!-8=:B@F8! DI8E>:@B!:=JF:89!B@!JI:@I!D@BB8D> :@B!>@!>78!EI8E!EB?!CEFF9!:B>@!>78!:?8E!@C!-8=:B@F8! E9!E!.I88T!J78B@=8B@BM! 47E>!)!7EA8!?@B8!9@!CEI!:9!97@G!98A8IEF!I8D@I?8?!8WE=JF89!@C!>78!BE=8! 3LETTE!>7I@;H7@;>!>78!9>E>8!@C!2F@I:?E!?E>:BH!@!>78!Rf >7 D8B>;IL :B!>78! EID7:AEF!I8D@I?!\(EBH8F!Rcch]!E B?!@B!>78!=EJ9!@C!2F@I:?E M!#@G!>78B!?@89!>78!BE=8! 3LETTE!I8FE>8!>@!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9O!:C!E>!EFF_!47:F8!I898EID7:BH!>78!7:9>@I:D! =EJ9!?E>E78!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!2F@I:?E!EB?!>78!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!-@;>7! 2F@I:?EO!)!8WE=:B8?!,F8WEB?I8!?8!6E>NU9!Rik i!=EJ \C:H;I8!RR] C#%$2.$/$#"629$2%3-%$2 6"2,I%$29$26"2H3-()("//$2J-)K-L"26"2G"1$28%;2G$#/"#9@2,3)%$29$26"2:63#(9$@2G"1$29$26"2 134I:6!JS! 8")1.$+.$("$9%3*0*"2.$/%3)0$+3$!*00*00*#*$.1$#"*0$4%*0*20 ?!JPMM

PAGE 116

! RQf '3?(66$@2G$;29$2M"/)",36$@2G"1$29$28%;2>3)$+*@28%;2'"#,29$)2C+"6",*$);29"/)26LC4$#(K-$2 )$+%$/%6$ M!0B!>78!B@I>7!9:?8!@C!G7E>!:9!.7E IF@>>8!#EI<@ IO!78!I8D@I?9!>78!BE=8! 3ELEDE9!\ ;B?8IF:B8?!:B! C:H;I8!RR]M "78!:=JF:DE>:@B9!@C!>7:9!=EJ!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!F@BH9>EB?:BH! D@BB8D>:@B9!@B!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!EI8!=EBLM!&8!6E>NU9! =EJ!:9!E!C;FF!kd!L8EI9!@F?8I!>7E B! G7E>!GE9!JI8A:@;9FL!TB@GB!C@I!>78!BE=8!3LETTEM!)C!>78!/;ID8F F!=EJ!7E?!<88B!>78! C:I9>!@B8!>@!E9DI:<8!>78!BE=8!3LETTE!>@!E!I:A8I!:B!>78!I8H:@BO!>78B!:>!G@;F?!<8! I8E9@BE@!D@BDF;?8!>7E>!>78!BE=8!3LETTE!GE9! F:T8FL!E!BE=8!H:A8B!@!>78!I:A8IM!,9!)!97@G8?!:B!=L!JI8A:@;9!D7EJ>8I9O!:B!RikiO!E BL! D@BB8D>:@B9!>@!>78!.I88T9!:B!>7:9!EI8E!@C!2F@I:?E!G8I8!8J78=8IEF!E>!<89>M!"78! 134I:6!JJ! ,)1.$7.2.)"($+.$1%31.$("$/:1.$+.$("$9%3*0*"22.$;30<3="$("$6">.$?1@$6.)2")+5$/%01.$+.$("$'(%)*+.5$ 6">.$+.$("$!%A*((.5$6.@$+.$B"20"/%(.5$6">.$+.$?1@$C%0.#D5$?1@$!")/$+.0$ ,#"("/D.0@$+"20$(=,-.)*<3.$ 0.#1.21(. ?!JPMP

PAGE 117

! RQi I8=BEB>9!@C!>78!.EF;9E!G8I8!9>:FF!F:A:BH!:B!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IM!"7:9!>789:9!EIH;89!>7E>! >78!BE=8!D@B>:B;8?!>@!<8!EJJF:8?!78!J8@JF8!G7@!<8DE=8!>78!-8=:B@F89!:9! :B?:DE>:A8!@C! D@B>:B;:>L!:B!>78!I8H:@B!EB?!>7E>!>78!-8=:B@F89!G8I8!B@>!:==:HIEB>9!>@! 8=J>L!FEB?!<;>!E!J8@JF8!G:>7!E!I8C;H88!78I:>EH8!I8>;IB:BH!>@!>78!FEB?9!>78L!F:A8?!@B! JI8A:@;9FLM ,B@>78I!:=J@I>EB>!E9J8D>!@C!-8=:B@F8!F:C8!@B!>78!3LETTE!:9!>78!J8D;F:EI! =:F:>EIL!J@F:DL! @C!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EIM!68C@I8!>78!GEIO!>78!-8=:B@F89!G8I8! TB@GB!>@!<8!F:A:BH!:B!>78!3LETTE!I8H:@BM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!3D.EI>7LO!V4:FF:E=9U9!=EJ!@C! Rehi!97@G9!E!>IE:F!>7E>!F8?!B@I>7!CI@=!>78!=@;>7!@C!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IO!EF@BH!>78!8E9>! 9:?8!@C!G7E>!GE9!>78B!>78! ,9>8IBEF!(:A8IO!>@!>78!+:>>F8!3EBE>88!(:A8I!EB?!>78B!>@! 2@I>!,FE!@C!"E=JEX!\3D.EI>7L!Rceh^Rc]M!"7:9!>IE:F!>7E>!4:FF:E=9!=EJJ8?! GE9!=@9>!D8I>E:BFL!E!G8FF 5 ;98?!-8=:B@F8!>IE:FM!4:>7!>78!>IE:F!EF@BH9:?8!>78!3LETTE! (:A8IO!3D.EI>7L!C88F9!>7E>!:>!V:FF;9 >IE>89!>78!JI898BD8!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!:B!>78!I8H:@BX! \Rceh^Rc]M!4:>7!>78!@B98>!@C!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EI!:B!RehdO!>78!=:F:>EIL! 7EIE998?!EB?!C@ID8?!>78!-8=:B@F89!C;I>78I!9@;>7!:B!>78!9>E>8M!)B!*8@IH8!$M!6;T8IU9! <@@T! 80"4+28"(63#)@2U(F$#(/$2P"#5"#$2(/2%*$2QF $#.6"9$)2DE\] ^ DE_[ O!78!?89DI:<89! 9@=8!@C!>78!=:F:>EILU9!ED>:A:>:89!:B!>78!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!I8H:@B^ "7I88!?EL9!FE>8I!>78! P")*(/.%3/ I8>;IB8?!CI@=!:>9!:B9J8D>:@B!@C! .7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IO!EB?!.EJ>E:B!o$N8T:8Fp!S@B89!I8J@I>8?!>7E>!@B!3EID7! Pe!EB?!Pc!+:8;>8BEB>!-=: >7!7E?!9:H7>8?!EB!)B?:EB!8BDE=J=8B>!E>!>78! =@;>7!@C!>78!3LEDDE!(:A8IM!-=:>7!D@;F?!D@;B>!>G8B>L 5 >G@!-8=:B@F89! E>!>7:9!DE=JO!EB?!78!D@;F?!988!=EBL!C:I89!B8EI!GE9!@7E>!>78!8B8=L!@;>B;=<8I8?!7:9!9=EFF!JEI>LO!78!?8D:?8?!>@!98B?!7:9! >G@!)B?:E B!H;:?89!>@!EIIEBH8!E!JEIF8LM!,9!9@@B!E9!>78!>G@!FEB?8?!>78L! G8I8!=8>!78I8!GE9!E!>8B98!=@=8B>!;B>:F!E! 78!H;:?89M!,C>8I!>7E>!>78!>G@!JEI>:89!>EFT8?M! "78!7@9>:F89!9E:?!>78L!G@;F?!7EA8!97@>!G7:>8!=8BO!EB?!> 78L!G8I8!A8IL! I8F;D>EB>!>@!JE99!@B!EBL!:BC@I=E>:@B!>@!)B?:EB9!G@IT:BH!C@I!>78! ,=8I:DEB9M!"78!H;:?89!D@;F?!@BFL!I8J@I>!>7E>!>78!GEII:@I9!G8I8!

PAGE 118

! RQe <8FF:H8I8B>O!?8>8I=:B8?O!EB?!=@I8!B;=8I@;9!>7EB!-=:>7U9!C@ID8M! "78I8!G8I8!B@!C;I>78I!8BD@;B>8I9!G:>7!>78!-8=:B@F89! ?;I:BH!>78! P")*(/.%3/ U9!DI;:98M!\6;T8I!Rcid^PP 5 Ph]! 47E>!:9!8W>IE@I?:BEI:FL!J8D;F:EI!E<@;>!>7:9!8BD@;B>8I!:9!>7E>!:>!:9!@B8!@C!>78!C8G! >:=89!>78!=:F:>EIL!8A8B!9D@;>8?!JEI>!@C!>78!I:A8I!?;I:BH!>78!GEIM! ,9!)!9>E>8?!8EIF:8I!:B! >7:9!D7EJ>8IO! .@F@B8F!`ED7EIL!" ELF@I!VGE9!J;>!:B!D7EIH8!@C!=@B:>@I:BH!>78!-8=:B@F89! <8>G88B!>78!.EF@@9E7E>D788!(:A8I!B@I>7!>@!>78!4:>7FED@@D788!(:A8IX!:B!Rehi! \3D.EI>7L!Rceh^PQ]M!"78!=:F:>EIL!7EIE998?!>78!-8=:B@F89!@B!EFF!@C!>78!I:A8I9!G:>7:B! >7:9!EI8E!EB?!L8>O!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!GE9!F8C> EF@B8M!"78I8!EI8!98A8IEF!=:F:>EIL!=EJ9! CI@=!>78!>:=8!J8I:@?!>7E>!97@G!>78!3LETTE!E9!E>!<89>!E!C8G!=:F89!F@BHM! 68DE;98 >78! -8=:B@F89!G8I8!F8C>!I8FE>:A8FL!;B?:9>;I<8?!:B!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!EI8E O!:> D@;F?!7EA8! JI@A:?8?!>78=!G:>7!JI@>8D>:@B!CI@=!,=8I:DEB!=:F:>E IL!:BD;I9:@B9!EB?!EB!8E9L! B8>G@IT!>@!>IEA8F!EF@BH!CI@=!>78!/8ED8!(:A8IO!?@GB!>78!3LETTE!:>98FCO!EB?!EF9@! .7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IM 489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!:9!B@>!Z;9>!9:HB:C:DEB>!<8DE;98!@C!>78!3LETTEM!"78!"I8E>L! @C!3@;F>I:8!.I88T!89>E78!C:I9>!-8=:B@F8! I898IAE>:@B!:B!>78!EI8E \C:H;I8!RP] M! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!,I>:DF8!P!@C!>78!>I8E>L^ "78!2F@I:?E!"I:<89!@C!)B?:EB9!G:FF!78I8EC>8I!<8!D@BD8B>IE>8?!EB?! D@BC:B8?!>@!>78!C@FF@G:BH!38>89!EB?!6@;B?EI:89g!D@==8BD:BH!C:A8! =:F89!%@I>7!@C!0T8Z;=T8O!I;BB:BH!:B!E!?:I8D>!F:B8!>@ E!J@:B>O!C:A8!=:F89! 489>!@C!-8>EITLU9!98>>F8=8B>O!@B!>78!GE>8I9!@C!>78!,=EN;IE!@I! 0;:>7FED@@D788!o )(, p! (:A8IO!F8EA:BH!9E:?!98>>F8=8B>!>G@!=:F89!-@;>7!@C! >78!F:B8O!CI@=!>78BD8!:B!E!?:I8D>!F:B8!>@!>78!-@;>7!8B?!@C!>78!6:H! #E==@DTO!>@!:BDF;?8!.7:TT;D7E>>:g!D @B>:B;:BH!@B!:B!>78!9E=8! ?:I8D>:@B!C@I!C:A8!=:F89!<8L@B?!9E:?!#E==@DTg!JI@A:?8?!9E:?!J@:B>! ?@89!B@>!EJJI@ED7!B8EI8I!>7EB!C:C>88B!=:F89!>78!98E!.@E9>!@C!>78!*;FJ7! o )(, p @C!38W:D@g!:C!:>!?@89O!>78!9E:?!F:B8!G:FF!>8I=:BE>8!E>!>7E>!?:9>EBD8! CI@=!>78!98E!.@E9>g >78BD8!-@;>7!>G8FA8!=:F89O!>78BD8!:B!E!-@;>7!hQƒ! $E9>!?:I8D>:@BO!;B>:F!>78!9E=8!97EFF!9>I:T8!G:>7:B!C:A8!=:F89!@C!>78!=E:B! 78!.7EIF@>>8!o/8ED8p!(:A8IO!>78BD8!:B!E!?;8!$E9>!?:I8D>:@B!>@!

PAGE 119

! RQc G:>7:B!>G8B>L!=:F89!@C!>78!,>FEB>:D!.@E9>g!>78BD8!%@I>7!C:C >88BO!489>! C@I!C:C>L!=:F89 q EB?!CI@=!>7:9!FE9>!>@!>78!<8H:BB:BH!J@:B>M!\48FD7! RekR^PQf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kO!)!?89DI:<8?!-8=:B@F89!9:>89!:B!>78!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!I8H:@B!TB@GB! CI@=!>78!7:9>@I:D!I8D@I?!EB?!CI@=!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?M!"78!7:9>@I:D!I8D@I?! :B?:DE>89!>78!JI898BD8!@C!>78! -8=:B@F89!:B!>7:9!I8H:@BM!)B!>7:9!D7EJ>8IO!)!8WE=:B8?!>78! 9D7@FEI97:J!@C!48:9=EBO!->@ZEB@G9T:O!EB?!-E>>F8I!@B!>78!8>7B@H8B89:9!@C!>78! -8=:B@F89!EB?!JI@A:?8?!8A:?8BD8!:B!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!I8D@I?!C@I!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E! E9!E!9:HB:C:DEB>!FEB?9DEJ8!>@GEI?9!;B?8I 9>EB?:BH!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>LM!)B!D7EJ>8I!9:WO!)! 134I:6!JK! 1:>C $ ED.$F*01%)>$"2+$E%#%7)"#D>$%&$1D.$ G2*1.+$?1"1.0 $ ](>5V>5?!\!X357>5?!U5!3;!CB:_6V!35!7A6!GDI6! B 5V!Y6DD>@!:643>5;!>H!7A6!.7B76<

PAGE 120

! RRQ G:FF!?:9D;99!7@G!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?!:B?:DE>89!>78!97:C>:BH!:?8B>:>L!@C!>78! -8=:B@F89!EB?!;F>:=E>8FLO!>78!8>7B@H8B89:9!@C!-8=:B@F8!)?8B>:>LM!)!G:FF!C@D;9!@B! >7I88!JEI>9^!>78!3LETTE7E>D788!3@;B?!J@>g!>78!) B?:EB!2:8F?!<;I:EFg!EB?!C:BEFFLO!>78! FEDT!@C!EI>:CED>9M!

PAGE 121

! RRR #X"/-)0!.Ui! 8 -A6!":WAB6>D>4Y!>H!.6C35>D6!)7A5>4656;3; "78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!:9!F:H7>!EB?!9DE>>8I8?!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF! 2F@I:?EM!,9!E!J8@JF8!@B!>78!I;BO!B@!9:HB:C:DEB>!9>I;D>;I89!G8I8!IE:98? @B!>78! FEB?9DEJ8g!IE>78IO!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?!D@B9:9>9!@C!JI@89!EB?! <;I:EF9M!,9!)!?89DI:<8?!:B!D7EJ>8I!C@;IO!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89! 78I8!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!:9!H8B8IEFFL!J@>>8ILO!<8E?9O!EB?!<;>>@B9M!,9!EF9@! ?:9D; 998?!:B!D7EJ>8I!C@;IO!>78!I8E9@B!>78I8!:9!B@>!=@I8!:9!<8DE;98!>78!9@:F9!:B!>7:9! I8H:@B!EI8!ED:?:D!E9!E!9;< 5 >I@J:DEF!DF:=E>8!EB?!:B!H8B8IEFO!?@!B@>!JI898IA8!=@9>!@C! >78!EI>:CED>!I8D@I?!C@I!>7E>!F@BHM!)B!>7:9!D7EJ>8IO!)!G:FF!EIH;8!C@I!>78!9:HB:C:DEBD8!@C! V >78!<@B89!@C!>78!EBD89>@I9X!\.LJI899!Rcci]!EB?!G7E>!:B!>78!I8D@I?!:B?:DE>89! 8>7B@H8B89:9M 6I8B>!48:9=EBO!:B! H(=$2G$"9)23/2"28%#(/.O2C2<-6%-#$2!()%3#12352%*$28$4(/36$2 >/9("/)2(/2X3#%*2M$/(/)-6"#2:63#(9" \Rcec]O!FEL9!>78!C@;B?E>:@B!C@I!7:9!FE>8I!7:9>@I:DEF! E ID7E8@F@H:DEF!G@IT!@B!>78!-8=:B@F89M!48:9=EB!?8EF9!G:>7!:99;89!@C! =;F>:D;F>;IEF:9=O!DI8@F:NE>:@BO!EB?!7LL!\:M8M!(;<8I>@B8!PQQQ^khi 5 khc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

PAGE 122

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cec^Rfh 5 Rfk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cdPg!+;8I!RceiO!Rcec]M!)B!>7:9!I8H:@B!@C!2F@I:?EO!E9! ?89DI:<8?!:B!D7EJ>8I!C@;IO!G8!7EA8!E>!F8E9>!>G@!9;D7!9:>89!@C!H;B 5 I8FE>8?!@9!E>! >78!3LETTE7E>D788!3@;B?!9:>8!:B! 9 @;>78IB!-EIE9@>E!D@; B>L!EB?!E>!)B?:EB!2:8F?!:B! 3E>FED7E!/E99!I:H7>!@CC!@C!/:B8!)9FEB?!:B!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IM

PAGE 123

! RRh "78!7:9>@I:DEF!I8D@I?!DEB!78FJ!C:FF!:B!>78!;B?8I9>EB?:BH9!@C!>78!EID7E8@F@HL!@C! >78!-8=:B@F89!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?EM!,!H@@?!8WE=JF8!@C!G7E>!DEB!7EJJ8B!>@!:>!:9! C@;B?! :B!SEB8>!-BL?8I!3E>>78G9U! 7*$2Q9.$2352P(69$#/$)) \Rceh^PPf]O!G78B!978! I8FE>89!@B8!@C!>78!C8G!>:=89!EB!,=8I:DEB!GEI!JEI>L!GE9!:B!>78!EI8E!@C!>78!3LETTE! (:A8I!?;I:BH!>78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EI^!V2I@=!E!?:CC8I8B>!?:I8D>:@B!=@I8!>7EB!>G8B>L! =:F89!EGELO!.EJ>E:B!+89 F8L!C@;B?!E!CI897!)B?:EB!DE=J!@B!EB!:9FEB?!:B!>78!3LETTEM! 6;>!78!7E?!B8:>78I!7@I989!B@I!9;JJF:89!>@!J;I9;8!>78!>IE:FMX!"7:9!JE>>8IB!:9! 9L=J>@=E>:D!@C!>78!89DEJ8!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!CI@=!>78!,=8I:DEB!=:F:>EILO!F8EA:BH! <87:B?!DE=J!9:>89!B8EI!EDD899:89!9;D7!E9!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IM"78! 7:9>@I:DEF!I8D@I?!DEB!EF9@!78FJ!>@!H:A8!E!98B98!@C!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!:B!G7:D7!>78!:?8B>:>L! @C!>78!-8=:B@F89!:9!DI8E>8?M!$A8B!>7@;H7O!E9!/E>I:D:E!(;<8I>@B8!\PQQQ]!D@II8D>FL! E998I>9O!>7:9!>ET89!:B>@!EDD@;B>!>78!A:8GJ@:B>!@C!>78 D@F@B:N8IO!:>!ED>;EFFL!78FJ9!=ET8! >78!EIH;=8B>!C@I!>78!8>7B@H8B89:9!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89O!JI@A:?:BH!E!98B98!@C!>78! D;F>;IEF!FEB?9DEJ8!?;I:BH!-JEB:97!EB?!6I:>:97!8BD@;B>8I9!EB?!FE>8I!,=8I:DEB! 8BD@;B>8I9O!G:>7!>78!JI@>@ 5 -8=:B@F89M!#@G8A8IO!:>!:9!:=J@I>EB>!>@!B@ >8O!;BF:T8!:B!>78! A8:B!@C!7:9>@I:D!9:>89!EID7E8@F@HLO!>78!7:9>@I:D!I8D@I?!:9!<8:BH!;98?!>@!:?8B>:CL!>78! =@A8=8B>!@C!J8@JF8!EB?!@9!:B!2F@I:?E!?;I:BH!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9M! ,9!E!J8@JF8!<@IB!@;>!@C!I89:9>EBD8O!>78!-8=:B@F89!EI8!E!?:I8D>!I89J@B98! >@GEI?9 >78!$;I@J8EB!8BD@;B>8IM!)>!:9!:=J@I>EB>!>@!B@>8O!E9!(;<8I>@B8!?@89O!>7E>!E9! >IE;=E>:D!>78!$;I@J8EB!8BD@;B>8I!GE9O!>78!J8@JF89!@C!J@9> 5 D@B>ED>!%E>:A8!,=8I:DE! G8I8!I8=EITE:BH!EB?!DI8E>:BH!B8G!:?8B>:>:89^ jo'9:BH!>78!D@F@B:EF!8BD@;B>8I!E9!> 78!=@=8B>!@C!D;F>;I8!D7EBH8O! IE>78I!>7EB!>ET:BH!:B>@!EDD@;B>!>78!@BH@:BH!CF;:?:>L!@C!J8@JF89! :?8B>:>:89p!J@989!>78!I:9T!@C!8BD@;IEH:BH!8WJFEBE>:@B9!>7E>!8=J7E9:N8! D@F@B:EF!8BD@;B>8I9!E9!>78!9:BHF8!>IEB9C@I=:BHO!:C!B@>!>IE;=E>:DO!8A8B>!

PAGE 124

! RRk :B!%E>:A8!J8@JF89t!F: A89O!IE>78I!>7EB!EDTB@GF8?H:BH!>78:I!E<:F:>L!>@! G:>79>EB?!EB?!9@=8>:=89!I89:9>!>7898!:BAE9:@B9!EB?!>78!:BD;I9:@B9! >7E>!C@FF@G8?M!"78!s7:9>@I:Ds!>I:<89!@C!>78!-@;>78E9>!EI8!B@>!=8I8FL! J@9>D@B>ED>!J78B@=8BE!G7@98!A8IL!8W:9>8BD8!GE9!>78!F8HEDL!@C! -JEB:97!D@B> ED>M!(E>78I!>7EB!A:8G:BH!>7898!s>I:9!@C!J@J;FE>:@B!?8DF:B8O!9@D:EF!>;I=@:FO!EB?!8D@B@=:D! ?:9I;J>:@B9 5 G7:D7!=EBL!:B?88?!8WJ8I:8BD8?!>@!AEIL:BH!?8HI889O!:>! =:H7>!<8!=@I8!;98C;F!>@!D@B9:?8I!>78:I!8=8IH8BD8!E9!8A:?8BD8!@C! 9;IA:AEF!9T:FF9j \PQQQ^khk 5 khd] S;9>!>@!K;:DTFL!>@;D7!@B!>7:9!J@:B>O!@B8!@C!>78!EBD89>IEF!J8@JF89!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89O!>78! ,JEFED788O!G8I8!;B?8IH@:BH!9@D:EF!>IEB9C@I=E>:@B!E>!>78!>:=8!@C!D@B>ED>O!9@!>78! 8BA:I@B=8B>!DI8E>8?!ED>!GE9!Z;9>!@B8!CED>@I!:B!>78!9@D:EF I8:=EH:B:BH!@C!>78!,JEFED788!FEB?9DEJ8M!!68C@I8!>78!-JEB:97!EII:A8?O!>78!,JEFED788! G8I8!:B!>78!JI@D899!@C!I8:=EH:B:BH!>78=98FA89!<@>7!J@F:>:DEFFL!EB?!I8F:H:@;9FLM!"78! -@;>78E9>8IB!.8I8=@B:EF!.@=JF8W!7E?!<8D@=8!D@B>89>8?!HI@;B?M!478B!>78!-JEB:97! EII:A8!@B! >78!9D8B8!G:>7!.7I:9>:EB:>LO!E!FEIH8!J8ID8B>EH8!@C!>78!,JEFED788!BE>:@B! G:FF:BHFL!:N8?!EB?!<8DE=8!.E>7@F:D!;B?8I!JI@>8D>:@B!@C!>78!-JEB:97!DI@GBM!"78! ,JEFED788!?:?!B@>!<8D@=8!-JEB:97O!<;>!IE>78IO!>@@T!.E>7@F:D:9=!EB?!>IEB9C@I=8?!:>! :B>@!EB!,JEFED788!;B ?8I9>EB?:BH \3D$GEB!RccR g!6F@D7!PQRR] M -A6!":WAB6>D>4Y!>H!7A6!f5W>5gI6:6V!/6>TD6 ,9!?89DI:<8?!:B!D7EJ>8I!C@;IO!.7E>>E7@@D788!6I;978?!J@>>8IL!GE9!@I:H:BEFFL! C@;B?!E=@BH9>!>78!.I88T9!EB?!>78!I8C;H88!J8@JF89!CI@=!>78!-@;>78E9>!;B?8I!>78! .I88T!9;N8IE:B>L!:B!>7 8!FE>8!Ri>7!D8B>;IL!>7I@;H7!>78!Rc>7!D8B>;ILM!$A:?8BD8!@C! .7E>>E7@@D788!6I;978?!J@>>8IL!:B!2F@I:?E!JI@A:?89!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!8A:?8BD8!>7E>! D@BC:I=9!>78!GI:>>8B!I8D@I?!>7E>!>78I8!G8I8!.I88T!7!E9! -EIE9@>E!7L! Rceh]M!"78!9;<>F8!D7EBH89!:B!>78! D@B9>I;D>:@B!@C!>78!A8998F!:B?:DE>8!>78!<8H:BB:BH!@C!8>7B@ 5 >IEB9C@I=E>:@B!CI@=!E!

PAGE 125

! RRd .I88T!:?8B>:>L!>@!E!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>LM!"78!9>E=J:BH!@C!F:B8EI!=EIT9!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8! A8998F!9>EB?9!:B!D@B>IE9>!>@!>78!.I88T!.7E>>E7@@D788!6I;97 8?!A8998F9!G7:D7O!:C!>78L! G8I8!8A8B!?8D@IE>8?O!D@B>E:B8?!VF:H7>FL!9DIE>D78?!@I!J:BD78?!:=JI899:@B9!EI@;B?! >78!@;>9:?8!@C!>78!I:=X!\&:DT8B9!EB?!.7EJ=EB!Rcie^hcP]M!47L!>78B!G@;F?!9;D7!E! ;>:F:>EI:EB!A8998F!<8!?8D@IE>8?!=@I8!8W>8B9:A8FL!:B!>78!-8=:B@F8!D@B>8W> )>!:9!?:CC:D;F>!>@!=ET8!E!>7@I@;H7!EBEFL9:9!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8!J@>!CI@=!>78! 3LETTE7E>D788!3@;B?!9:>8!G:>7@;>!EDD899!>@!>78!A8998F!@I!J7@>@9!@C!:>O!<;>!:>!F:T8FL! :B?:DE>89!EB!:=J@I>EB>!97:C>M!"78!CED>!>7E>!9;D7 E!;>:F:>EI:EB!A8998F!G@;F?!I8D8:A8! =@I8!?8D@IE> :@B!:B!>78!-8=:B@F8!D@B>8W>!E9!@JJ@98?!>@!>78!.I88T!EBD89>IEF!D@B>8W>! EB?!>78!CED>!:>!:9!E99@D:E>8?!G:>7!E!DED78!@C!E==;B:>:@B!D@;F?!:B?:DE>8!>78! :=J@I>EBD8!@C!>7:9!DED78!>@!>78!-8=:B@F89!G7@!<;I:8?!:>M!,9!E!J8@JF8!@B!>78!I;BO! F8EA:BH!<87:B?!E!FEIH8!E=@;B> @C!E==;B:>:@B!:9!E!FEIH8!I:9T!<8DE;98!EI=9!EB?! E==;B:>:@B!G8I8!B@>!E9!8E9:FL!@<>E:BE78!-8=:B@F89O!89J8D:EFFL!?;I:BH! GEI>:=8M!'BC@I>;BE>8FLO!<8DE;98!@C!>78!GEL!>78!EI>:CED>!GE9!?:9D@A8I8?O!>78I8!:9!B@! H@@?!>8=J@IEF!D@B>8W>!?;8!>@!?89>I;D>:@B!7!?8A8F@J=8B>!EB?! 5 7;B>8I9M! "78!F8EA:BH!@C!>78!E==;B:>:@B!:>98FC!F:T8FL!:B?:DE>89!E!9>I@BH!E>>ED7=8B>!>@!>78!FEB?M! "@!>I;9>!>7E>!DED78!G@;F?!<8!>78I8!;J@B!I8>;IB!>@!>78!9:>8!:9!E!VF8EJ!@C!CE:>7X!=@=8B>! C@I!>78!8A@FA:BH!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>LM 4:>7@;>!H@@ ?!>8=J@IEF!D@B>8W>!?;8!>@!>78!?89>I;D>:@B!@C!>78!=@;B?!9:>8O!:>!:9! ?:CC:D;F>!>@!?8>8I=:B8!G78>78I!>78!EI>:CED>!?E>89!>@!JI8 5 -8D@B? 5 -8=:B@F8!4EIO!>@! ?;I:BH!>78!-8D@B?5-8=:B@F8!GEIO!@I!J@9> 5 -8D@B? 5 -8=:B@F8!4EIM!,9!9>E>8?!E<@A8!:B! >7:9!D7EJ>8IO!48:9=EB!\PQQi] EIH;89!>7E>!>78!DIL9>EFF:NE>:@B!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8! :?8B>:>L!@DD;I9!?;I:BH!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EI!J8I:@?M!"78!DI;W!@C!>78!EIH;=8B>!:9!

PAGE 126

! RRf >7E>!>78!DIL9>EFF:NE>:@B!@C!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!<8H:B9!?;I:BH!>7:9!GEI!G:>7!>78!I:98!@C! BE>:A:9>!=@A8=8B>9!E=@BH9>!>78!EBD89>I EF!-8=:B@F89!F8?!78!(8?!.I88T!6EB?]!EB?!>78!JI@J78>!0>8FT8 5 >7F@D@M!'9:BH!48:9=EBU9!=@?8FO!:>!:9! J@99:@!:BC8I!>78!>8=J@IEF!D@B>8W>M!)CO!E9!48:9=EB!9>E>89 \PQQi^PQk 5 d] ^ "78!E<98BD8!@C!$;I@J8EB!,=8I:DEB!D8IE=:D9!o:B!>78!EID 7E8@F@H:DEF! I8D@I?pMMM:9!<89>!EDD@;B>8?!C@I!78!8W:9>8BD8!@C!EB! ;B?@D;=8B>8?!BE>:A:9>:D!=@A8=8B>!E=@BH!>78!-8=:B@F89O!E! =@A8=8B>!C@I=8?!:B!?:I8D>!I89J@B98!>@!>78!B88?!>@!=@<:F:N8!C8IA@I! C@I!E!?:CC:D;F>!9>I;HHF8!EB?!D8B>8I8?!EI@;B?!@B8!@C!>78!= @I8!@9>8B9:78!G7:>8!=EBU9!GEL9M! >78B!>78!FEDT!@C!EBL!@>78I!EI>:CED>9!CI@=!>78!-8=:B@F89!D@;F?!:B?:DE>8!>7E>!>78! EI>:CED>!D@;F?!<8!?E>8?!>@!9@=8>:=8!?;I:BH!@I!J@9> 5 -8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!GEIM!)>!:9! :B>8I89>:BH!>@!B@>8O!7@G8A8IO!>7E>!>78!JI898BD8! @C!E!=8>EF!T8>>F8!:B?:DE>89!EB! EJJI@JI:E>:@B!@C!$;I@J8EB!,=8I:DEB!:?8E9!78!-8=:B@F89M!)>!:9!;98?!:B!E!-8=:B@F8! D@B>8W>O!FL:BH!:BA8I>8?!E>@J!>78!A8998FO!G7:D7!C;I>78I!9J8ET9!>@!>78!<:I>7!@C!-8=:B@F8! :?8B>:>LM "@!EB9G8I!>78!98D@B?!K;89>:@B!>7E>!)!J@98?O! >78!FEDT!@C!EI>:CED>9!:9!B@>! :B?:DE>:A8!@C!EB!8=J>LO!;B:B7E<:>8?!FEB?M!(E>78IO!:>!:9!:B?:DE>:A8!@C!>78!9>I89989! JFED8?!@B!>78!-8=:B@F89M!)B?88?O!:>!:9!A8IL!;98C;F!>@!:BD@IJ@IE>8!48:9=EBU9!=@?8F! C@I!8WE=:B:BH!>78!FEDT!@C!EI>:CED>9M!4:>7!@BFL!@B8!A8998F!C@;B ?!E>!>78!3LETTE7E>D788! -:>8O!:>!D@;F?!<8!>7E>!V?;8!>@!>78!D@B9>IE:B>9!@C!GEIO!:>!:9!J@99:7E>!>78!9;JJFL!@C! D8IE=:D9!9:=JFL!?I:8?!;JO!<;>!?@D;=8B>EIL!8A:?8BD8!:B?:DE>89!>@!>78!D@B>IEILX! \PQQi^PQk]M!%@>!@BFL!:9!48:9=EB!;98C;FO!<;>!EF9@!SE=89!-D@>>U9!\PQ Qc]!=@?8F9 2 JI@A:?8!>78!B8D899EIL!>78@I8>:DEF!7B@ 5 H8B89:9M!#:9!=@9>! 9EF:8B>!:B9:H7>9!:B>@!J8@JF89!89DEJ:BH!EI8!8>7B@H8B89:9!DE;98?!:@B! 78!->E>8!EB?!7@G!H8@HIEJ7L!JFEL9!:B>@!:?8B>:>LM!(8>;IB:BH!>@!48:9=EBU9!:?8E! @C!

PAGE 127

! RRi E!BE>:A:9>!=@A8=8B>O!:>!:9!F:T8FL!EB!:B?:DE>@I!@C!:?8B>:>L!C@I=E>:@B!E9!E!I89;F>!@C! J8I:J78IEF:NE>:@B!78!->E>8M!"78!I8Z8D>:@B!@C!$;I@J8EB 5 ,=8I:DEB!D8IE=:D9!:B! CEA@I!@C!V=@I8!JI:=:>:A8X!BE>:A8!D8IE=:D9!:9!E!DF8EI!I8Z8D>:@B!@C!>78!?@=:BEB>! :?8@F@HLM!# @G8A8IO!G78B!$;I@J8EB 5 ,=8I:DEB!EI>:CED>9!?@!97@G!;J!:B!D@B>8W>!G:>7! -8=:B@F8!EI>:CED>9O!>78!-8=:B@F89!7EA8!EF=@9>!:BAEI:E8?!>78=O! 89J8D:EFFL!E9!?89DI:<8?!E<@A8!G:>7!>78!T8>>F8!EB?!J@>!D@=<:BE>:@B!C@;B?!E>!>78! 3LETTE7E>D788!3@;B?!EB?!EF9@!:B ,FED7;E!.@;B>LM -8=:B@F8!<;I:EF9!EI8!:=J@I>EB>!>@GEI?9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!>78!97:C>:BH!:?8B>:>L! @C!>78!-8=:B@F89M!-8=:B@F8!<;I:EF9!EI8!9EDI8?!HI@;B?M ) >!:9!>E<@@!8A8B!>@?EL!E=@BH! >78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!3:DD@9;T889!>@!8B>8I!E!<;I:EF!9:>8M!68DE;98!@C!>78!JI898BD8!@C! E! <;I:EF!9@!DF@98!>@!TB@GB!7:9>@I:D!9:>89!@C!-8=:B@F8!:=J@I>EBD8!\>78!Y8BB8?L!EB?! &EIF:BH!9>@I8!:B!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I]!EB?!>78!EI>:CED>9!E99@D:E>8?!G:>7!>78!<;I:EFO!>7:9! JEI>!@C!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!GE9!F:T8FL!E!9:HB:C:DEB>!F@DE>:@B!C@I!>78!-8=:B@F89M!)B!CED>O! > 78!BE=8!@C!>78!JE99O!3E>FED7EO!E9!9>E>8?!:B!D7EJ>8I!C@;IO!:9!>7@;H7>!>@!<8!E!-8=:B@F8! G@I?!@C!;BTB@GB!@I:H:BM!"78!7:9>@I:D!EB?!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?!@CC8I9!>EB>EF:N:BH! DF;89!@C!7@G!9:HB:C:DEB>!>7:9!EI8E!=EL!7EA8!<88BM! %@>!@BFL!GE9!>78I8!E!<;I:EF!C@;B?!:B! .7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IO!<;>!>78!GI:>>8B!I8D@I?! I8D@I?9!E!>IE?:>:@B!:B!>78!3LETTE!@C!-8=:B@F8!<;I:EF9M!)B!*8@IH8!-7:8F?9!<@@T! !-/%(/.2(/2%*$2B#$"%2P$)%2`U-)%6(/.)2(/2%*$2U3,=($)a \Reee]O!78!I8FE>89!E!9>@IL!@C! 7;B>:BH!@B!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IO!B8EI!EB!@F?!-8=:B@F8!DE=J :BH!HI@;B?^ ,>!E!7EFC 5 JE9>!@B8!@UDF@DT!G8!EII:A8?!E>!>78!9D8B8!@C!@B8!@C!6:FFL! 6@GF8HU9!@F?!DE=J:BH!HI@;B?9!?;I:BH!7:9!GEI!G:>7!>78!'M!-M!>I@@J9M!#8! HEA8!:>!>78!J@8>:DEF!BE=8!@C!.@;H7J8BB9F@;H7g!EB?!:>!:9!9E:?!>7E>!@B8! @C!7:9!CEA@I:>8!GEII:@I9!F:89!<;I:8?! B@>!CEI!CI@=!78I8O!G7@!GE9!D@;I> 5 =EI>:EF8?!EDD@I?:BH!>@!>78!)B?:EB!D;9>@=!EB?!97@>!@B!EDD@;B>!@C!9@=8! @CC8B9:A8!I8=EIT!=E?8!:B!>78!D7:8CU9!JI898BD8!D@BD8IB:BH!>78!BE=8!

PAGE 128

! RRe H:A8B!>@!>7:9!DE=JM!\Reee^PRc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t9!sI;B!EGELMs!6;>!)!E9T8?!#@GEI?!09D8@FE!@BD8^! s47E>!?@89!-8=:B@F8!38EB_s!,B?!78!9E:?^!s48FFO!=L!?E??L!>@F?!=8! >7E>!78L!G8I8!D7E9:BH!>78=!EFFO!G78B!>78L!G8I8! D7E9:BH!EFF!>78!)B?:EB9O!9@=8!G7:>8!9@F?:8I9!9E :?!>@!@B8!@C!@;I!C8FFE9O! @B8!@C!>78!3:DD@9;T889O!s47@!EI8!>7@98!)B?:EB9!G8!988!@;>!>78I8!GEL! EGELO!@;>!@B!>78!7@I:N@B_!48!DEB!B8A8I!DE>D7!;J!G:>7!>78=O!>78!@B89! >7E>!EI8!EFGEL9!I;BB:BH!EGELO!47@!EI8!>78L_s!s,B?!@;I!C8FF@G!9E:?! L8$4(/36"1YL2 )>t9!E!G@I?!@C!@ ;I!FEBH;EH8O!>78!3:DD@9;T88!FEBH;EH8O!>7E>! =8EB9!G:F?O!E!98=:B@FEL!J:HO!E!98=:B@FEL!7@I98O!G:F?O!B@>!C8BD8?!:BO! C8IEFM!)>!I8EFFL!?@89Bt>!=8EB!I;B!EGELO!:>!=8 EB9!E!G:F?!7@HO!E!G:F?! 7@I98! E!CI88!=EB[s!\"78! !$662P(%*2M36(%(,)@2 SEB8!(8B@!Rcck^RQe] ,FGEL9!?:9EJJ8EI:BH!Z;9>!<8L@B?!>78!7@I:N@Bg!>7:9!=8>EJ7@I!?89DI:<89!7@G!>78! 9GE=J9!EB?!I:A8I9!E:?8?!>78!-8=:B@F8!J8@JF89!89DEJ8!>78!I8ED7!@C!>78!->E>8M! 68DE;98!>78!-8=:B@F89!G8I8!I;BB:BH!EGELO!>78!=E>8I:EF!I8D@I?!>78L!F8C>!<87:B?!:9! EF=@9>!EF GEL9!9DEB>M!"78I8C@I8O!>78!FEDT!@C!EI>:CED>9!:B!>78!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E! I8H:@BO!D@=<:B8?!G:>7!>78!EI>:CED>9!>7E>!?@!8W:9>O!9>I@BHFL!D@B>I:<;>89!>@!>78!:?8E!

PAGE 129

! RRc >7E>!>78!:?8B>:>L!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!GE9!DIL9>EFF:N8?!>7I@;H7!BE>:A:9>!=@A8=8B>9! ?;I:BH!>78!-8D@B?5-8 =:B@F8!4EI!EB?!J@9> 5 -8D@B? 5 -8=:B@F8!4EIM

PAGE 130

! RPQ #X"/-)0!.)2)%! 8 -A6!f5W>5gI6:6V!/6>TD6 0A8I!>78!D@;I98!@C!>7:9!>789:9O!)!7EA8!I8A:8G8?!>78!7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HL!@C! %E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9O!?89DI:<8?!>78!H8@HIEJ7L!@C!>78!GE>8IGEL9!@C!489> 5 .8B>IEF! 2F@I:?EO!8WE=:B8?!>78! 7:9>@IL!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89O!JI898B>8?!98A8IEF!7:9>@I:D!EB?! EID7E8@F@H:DEF!9:>89!D@BB8D>8?!G:>7!>78!-8=:B@F89!:B!>78!I8H:@BO!EB?!JI898B>8?!>78! AEI:8>L!@C!A:8G9!@B!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!EB?!:?8B>:>LO!EB?!JI898B>8?!8A:?8BD8!C@I! -8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!:B!489> 5 .8B >IEF!2F@I:?E!>7I@;H7!>78!7:9>@I:D!EB?! EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?M!)B!>7:9!D7EJ>8IO!)!G:FF!D@BDF;?8!=L!JI8D8?:BH!>G@!D7EJ>8I9! EB?!>ET8!E!I8CF8W:A8!F@@T!E>!=L!D@BDF;9:@BM "78I8!EI8!>7I88!I8E9@B9!C@I!>78!EIH;=8B>!@C!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?E^! >78!BE=89!I8D@I?8?!@B!=EJ9O!>78!"I8E>L!@C!3@;F>I:8!.I88TO!EB?!E! DI:>:DEF!8WE=:BE>:@B!@C!>78!8J78=8IEF!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?!:B!489> 5 .8B>IEF!2F@I:?EO! 9:>;E>8?!EHE:B9>!>78!7:9>@I:D!I8D@I?M!)B!D7EJ>8I!C:A8O!)!FE:?!@;>!>78!8A:?8BD8!C@I!>78! 9:HB:C:DEBD8!@C!BE=8 9!I8D@I?8?!@B!>78!=EJM!68DE;98!>78!BE=8!3LETTE!EB?!:>9! AEI:EB>9!:9!<@>7!C@;B?!EI@;B?!>78!9>E>8! "/9 <8DE;98!:>!:9!I8D@I?8?!:B!>78!EI8E!@C!>78! 3LETTE!(:A8I!>@?EL!H@:BH!@!E>!F8E9>!>78!=:??F8!@C!>78!8:H7>88B>7!D8B>;ILO!:>!:9! B@!D@:BD:?8BD8M!"78!8W:9>8BD8 @C!>78!BE=8!3LETTE!:B! 489> 5 .8B>IEF 2F@I:?E!97@G9!E! D@B>:B;:>L!@C!TB@GF8?H8!@C!JFED8M!(;<8I>@B8!\PQQQ^khd]!JI@A:?89!E!9>I@BH!EIH;=8B>! C@I!G7L!>78!FEB?9DEJ8!:9!:=J@I>EB>!C@I!;B?8I9>EB?:BH!D@BB8D>:@B!>@!>78!FEB?O! 9>E>:BHO!V (E>78I!>7EB!:B9:9>:BH!>7E>!=EBL! %E>:A8!,=8I:DEB!HI@;J9!@C!>78!J@9>D@B>ED>! J8I:@?!EI8!7:9>@I:DEFFL!8=8IH8B>!J78B@=8BE!G7@98!D;F>;IEF!E;>78B>:D:>L!:9! K;89>:@BEEBD89!EI8!>78!D@B98K;8BD8!@C!$;I@J8EB! D@B>ED>!EB?!D@F@B:EF:9=!:B9>8E?!@C!?88J!7:9>@I:DEF!I@@>9O!>78L!=: H7>!<8!=@I8!

PAGE 131

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d^cd]M!"78! BE=89!3LETTE! EB?!"EFETD7@JT@!78FJ!>@!:FF;=:BE>8!>78!7:??8B!7:9>@I:89!@C!2F@I:?E!EB?!>78!8B?;I:BH! D@BB8D>:@B9!>@!>78!FEB?!>78!-8=:B@F89!7E?!EB?!D@B>:B;8!>@!7@F?M! 478B!>ET8B!7@F:9>:DEFFLO!>78!JI898BD8!@C!>78!BE=8!3LETTE!8W:9>:BH!<@>7! EI@;B?!>78!9>E>8!E9!G8F F!E9!<8:BH!>:8?!>@!>78!I8H:@B!9>I8BH>78B9!>78!9JE>:EF! D@BB8D>:@B9!>@!EBD89>IEF!7@=8FEB?9M!!"78!G@I?!3LETTE!D@B>:B;:BH!>@!8W:9>!CI@=!E>! F8E9>!>78!C:I9>!7EFC!@C!>78!Re >7 D8B>;IL!97@G9!E!F:BH;:9>:D!D@B>:B;:>LM!$A8B!:C!:>!:9!E! D@=JF8>8!D@:BD:?8BD8!>7E>!>78!3LE TTE!(:A8I!>@?EL!7E9!>7E>!BE=8O!>78!BE=8!3LETTE! :9!EJJF:8?!>@!FEIH8!FET89!EB?!I:A8I9!:B!>78!J8B:B9;FEM!*@:BH!@!C:H;I8!>G@!:B! D7EJ>8I!C:A8O!>78!BE=8!V3EZED@X!:9!EJJF:8?!>@!E!FEIH8!FET8!B8EI!.EJ8! .EBEA8IEFM!" 78I8! GE9!EF9@!E!>@GB!B8EI!>7:9!EI8E!BE=8?!3EL EIDE!E9!I8D@I?8?!@B!+ET8!0T88D7@<88!GE9!

PAGE 132

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khd]O!:>!:9! GEL!>@@!9:=JF:9>:D >@!>I8E>!JFED8!BE=89!E9!D@:BD:?8BD89!EB?!>7;9FL! J@9> 5 D@B>ED>!J8@JF89!E9! <8:BH! G:>7@;>!JI:@I!D@BB8D>:@B!>@!>78!FEB?!<8L@B?!E!?:9>EB>! EBD89> IEF!@B8O!IE>78I!>7EB!E!F:A:BHO!7:BH!D@B>:B;:>L M "78!3LETTE!(:A8I!B@>!@BFL!9;9>E:B8?!>78!BE=8!EB?!>78!D@BB8D>:@B!>@!>78! FEB?9DEJ8O!<;>!>78!J8@JF89!G7@!=E?8!:>!>78:I!7@=8M!,9!)!GI@>8!:B! E! 2F@I:?E! ,B>7I@J@F@H:DEF!-@D:8>L!JEJ8I!V"78!'BD@BK;8I8?!/8@JF8^!" 78!.E98!C@I!-8=:B@F8! $>7B@ 5 H8B89:9!:B!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!b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

PAGE 133

! RPh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ccf^di 5 de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

PAGE 134

! RPk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nB! S@B89!9>E>89!\Rcci^RPP]O!V"7;9O!>78!I8FE>:@B97:J!<8>G88B!=E>8I:EF! D;F>;I8!9>LF89!EB?!>78!8WJI899:@B!@C!8>7B:D:>L!=EL!<8!D@B9>EB>FL!97:C>:BH!EDD@I?:BH! >@!>:=8!EB?!JFED8M!3E>8I:EF!9>LF89!G7:D7!:B!9@=8!9@D:EF!EB?!7:9>@I:DEF!D@B>8W>9!EI8! ED>:A8FL!>ET8B!;J!:B!> 78!9:HB:C:DE>:@B!EB?!B8H@>:E>:@B!@C!8>7B:D:>L!=ELO!:B!@>78I! D@B>8W>9O!@BFL!C@I=!JEI>!@C!>78!=8EB:BHC;F!8BA:I@B=8B>!:B!G7:D7!8>7B:D:>L!:9! H8B8IE>8?XM!"7:9!EI>:CED>!:9!DF8EIFL!JEI>!@C!>78!8BA:I@B=8B>!;B?8I!G7:D7!>78!JI@D899! @C!8>7B@H8B89:9!GE9!<8H:BB:BH!>@!9 @F:?:CL!:>98FC!E=@BH!>78!EBD89>IEF!-8=:B@F89O!:C!B@>!

PAGE 135

! RPd EB!ED>;EF!:B?:DE>:@B!@C!>78!97:C>:BH!:?8B>:>L!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89M! ,??:>:@BEFFLO!S@B89!JI@A:?89!E!=@?8F!C@I!7@G!>@!;B?8I9>EB?!8>7B:D:>L!@I! 8>7B:D!D7EBH8!CI@=!>78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?^ "7;9O!E!EB?:BH!@C!JE9>!D;F>;IEF!D@B>8W>9!?8I:A8?!CI@=!E! AEI:8>L!@C!9@;ID89!EB?!DFE9989!@C!?E>E!:9!EB!8998B>:EF!JEI>!@C!EBL! EBEFL9:9!@C!8>7B:D:>L!:B!EID7E8@F@HLM!)B!JEI>:D;FEIO!:>!:9!B8D899EIL!>@! 8WE=:B8!=@?89!@C!9@D:EF!:B>8IED>:@B!EB?!>78!?:9>I:<;>:@B!@C!=E>8I:E F! EB?!9L=<@F:D!J@G8I!<8>G88B!HI@;J9!@C!J8@JF8O!<8DE;98O!E9!EIH;8?! E<@A8O!8>7B:D:>L!:9!E!JI@?;D>!@C!>78!:B>8I98D>:@B!@C!9:=:FEI:>:89!EB?! ?:CC8I8BD89!:B!J8@JF8U9! *"?(%-) EB?!>78!D@B?:>:@B9!D7EIED>8I:N:BH!EBL! H:A8B!7:9>@I:DEF!9:>;E>:@BM!,B!E?8K;E>8!TB@GF8?H8! @C!JE9>!9@D:EF! @IHEB:NE>:@B!:9!EF9@!:=J@I>EB>O!E9!8>7B:D:>L!:9!<@>7!E!>IEB9:8B>! D@B9>I;D>!@C!I8J8E>8?!ED>9!@C!:B>8IED>:@B!EB?!D@==;B:DE>:@BO!EB?!EB! E9J8D>!@C!9@D:EF!@IHEB:NE>:@B!G7:D7!<8D@=89!:B9>:>;>:@BEF:N8?!>@! ?:CC8I8B>!?8HI889O!EB?!:B!?:CC8I8B>!C@I=9O! :B!E!?:CC8I8B>!9@D:8>:89O! \S@B89!Rcci^RPd 5 RPf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

PAGE 136

! RPf <;I:EF!:9!9:HB:C:DEB>!9@!DF@98!>@!<@>7M!%@>!@BFL!>7E>O!<;>!>@!I8>;IB!>@!>78!:?8E!@C!BE=89! @B!>78!FEB?9DEJ8O!<@>7!3E>FED7E!EB?!>78!BE=8!@C!)B?:EB!2:8F?!EI8!>7@;H7>!>@!<8!CI@=! >78!-8=:B @F89!\+;8I!Rcec]M!"78!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!I8D@I?O!D@=<:B8?!G:>7!>78!7:9>@I:D! I8D@I?!@CC8I9!9>I@BH!8A:?8BD8!@C!>78!J@99:<:F:>L!>7E>!>78!8>7B@H8B89:9!@C!>78! -8=:B@F89!@DD;I9!:B!>7:9!I8H:@B!@C!G89> 5 D8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!EB?O!E9!48:9=EB!\PQQi]! J@9:>9O!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8 4EI!:9!>78!GE>8I978?!=@=8B>!C@I!>78!H8B89:9!@C!E! D@78I8B>!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>LM .>C6!#>5WDIV354!-A>I4A7; "7:9!>789:9!7E9!EIH;8?!C@I!>78!8>7B@H8B89:9!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!CI@=!E! D@FF8D>:@B!@C!EBD89>IEF!2F@I:?E!J8@JF89!EB?!@>78I!I8C;H88!J8@JF89!>@!E!D@FF8D>:A8! -8 =:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!@DD;I:BH!:B!G89> 5 D8B>IEF!2F@I:?EM!"7:9!>789:9!@CC8I9!E!IE?:DEF! J8I9J8D>:A8!@B!>78!-8=:B@F89!EB?!>78:I!8>7B@H8B89:9M!"7E>!>7:9!>789:9!EIH;89!C@I!>78! -8=:B@F89!E9!?89D8B?EB>9!@C!>78!EBD89>IEF!2F@I:?E!J8@JF89!EB?!E9!>78!?@=:BEB>! I8E9@B!>@GEI?9 -8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!:9!E!FEIH8!78!JI8A:@;9!;B?8I9>EB?:BH9! :B!>78!EDE?8=:D!D@==;B:>LM!,IH;:BH!C@I!>78!8>7B@H8B89:9!@C!EB!8B>:I8!J8@JF8!!=E>8I:EF!I8=E:B9!EF@B8!G@;F?!<8!JI@:DM!6;>!;9:BH!>78!9>I;D>;I8!@C! 7:9>@I:DEF!EID7E8@F@HLO! <@>7!>78!E<98BD8!@C!EID7E8@F@HL!EB?!>78!8W:9>:BH!EID7E8@F@HL! EI8!:B!CED>O!9>I@BH!:B?:DE>@I9!>@GEI?9!-8=:B@F8!8>7B@H8B89:9M! 6I;D8!"I:HH8I!\Rcec^kRR]!GEIB9O!VjEID7E8@F@H:9>9!=;9>!9>I:A8j>@!988!>78! JE9>!E9!:>!GE9O!B@>!E9!>78L!G:97!:>!>@!7EA8!<8 8BMX!!,9!EDE?8=:D9O!G8!=;9>!I8D@HB:N8! >7E>!>78!-8=:B@F89!7@F?!?88J!D@BB8D>:@B9!>@!>78!FEB?!:B!2F@I:?EO!?E>:BH!@!G8FF! <8C@I8!D@B>ED>M!)C!G8!:B!>78!EDE?8=:D!D@==;B:>L!DEBB@>!988!>7:9O!7@G!DEB!G8!8WJ8D>! >78!D:>:N8B9!@C!2F@I:?E!>@!;B?8I9>EB?!>7E>!>78!-8= :B@F89!EI8!B@>!EF:8B!>@!2F@I:?EO!<;>!

PAGE 137

! RPi IE>78I!>78!=@?8IB!=EB:C89>E>:@B!@C!BE>:A8!2F@I:?E!:?8B>:>L_!!"78!-8=:B@F89U! 8>7B@H8B89:9!D@=89!E<@;>!?;8!>@!E!F@BH!98I:89!@C!CED>@I9^!>78!9@D:EF!D7EBH89!@BH@:BH! :B!>78!J@9> 5 3:99:99:JJ:EB!-@;>78E9>O!?8=@HIEJ7:D!I8@IHEB:N E>:@B!EB?!:?8@F@H:DEF! 97:C>9!C@FF@G:BH!-JEB:97!D@B>ED>!EB?!:B>8IED>:@BO!EB?!JI899;I89!CI@=!>78!,=8I:DEB! =:F:>EIL!EB?!,=8I:DEB!98>>F8=8B>!@C!2F@I:?EM!489> 5 D8B>IEF!2F@I:?E!:9!>78!F:=:BEF! 9JED8!:B!G7:D7!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!<8HEB!>@!D@EF89D8!EB?!>78!J8@JF89!<8HE B!>@! ;B?8I9>EB?!>78=98FA89!E9!-8=:B@F8M

PAGE 138

! RPe "TT65V3b!"! 8 ,BT; 134I:6!J! ,-.)*/".$0*4.$<4")1".$%)A*0$#")1*0$2%4"$.1$.H"/1*00*-"$ +.0/)*#1*%2 ?!JNOK?!*364>!+I736::6j

PAGE 139

! RPc 134I:6!KB '(%)*+".$,-.)*/".$B)%4*2/*". ?!JNRJ!`JNOMa?!=BWgI6;!(6!,>Y56!V6!,>:4I6;?! ?*230$C%"2$2*0$ B%2/.

PAGE 140

! RhQ 134I:6!KG! '(%)*+".$,-.)*/".$B)%4*2/*". ?!JNRJ!`JNOMa?!=BWgI6;!(6!,>Y56!V6!,>:4I6; ?!23DDB46!>H! ,BYB:WB

PAGE 141

! RhR 134I:6! M 9"$'(%)*+"@$,3/1%).$F*.)%2I$8D*"4.0I5$ JNQM?!+6:>53C> V6!#ABZ6j !

PAGE 142

! RhP 134I:6! N '9JKCL,$.1$,B,98FM ?!JNRP?!#>:563DD6!'Y7HD367

PAGE 143

! Rhh 134I:6! O '(%)*+"$.1$K.7*%2.0$N*/*2". ?!JOLS?!=>B556;!V6!(B67

PAGE 144

! Rhk 134I:6! P ,-.)*/"$ 0.#1.21)*%2"(*0$*2$03"0$#)"./*#3"0$#")1.$+*4*0"5$"+$303-$0.).2*00*-*$63)732+*".$+3/*0 ?! JORM?!"D6b3;!XIG6:7!=B3DD>7

PAGE 145

! Rhd 134I:6! Q ,)1.$7.2.)"($+.$1%31.$("$/:1.$+.$("$9%3*0*"22.$;30<3="$("$6">.$?1@$6.)2")+5$/%01.$+.$("$'(%)*+.5$6">.$ +.$ ("$!%A*((.5$6.@$+.$B"20"/%(.5$6">.$+.$?1@$C%0.#D5$?1@$!")/$+.0$,#"("/D.0@$+"20$(=,-.)*<3.$0.#1.21(. ?!JPMP?! "D6bB5V:6!V6!cB7jH!9(B!1D>:3V6F

PAGE 146

! Rhf 134I:6! R ED.$8%"01$%&$O.01$'(%)*+"$"2+$9%3*0*"2"@$ED.$B.2*203(" $ "2+$P3(&$%&$'( %)*+"$%)$8D"22.($%&$6"D"-"$ Q*1D$1D.$6"D"-"$C0("2+0 CB;!=6HH:6Y;?!V67B3D!>H!#AB:D>776!XB:G>:
PAGE 147

! Rhi 134I:6! JS !"#$%&$'(%)*+" ?!JQKL?!!X65:Y!.WA65W_!-B556:<

PAGE 148

! Rhe "TT65V3b!c! 8 -:6B7Y!>H!,>ID7:36!#:66_ .>I:W6\! YEJJF8IO! .7EIF89!SM RcQk!)B?:EB!,CCE:I9^!+EG9!EB?!"I8E>:89O!b@FM!))O!"I8E>:89M!*@A8IB=8B>! /I:B>:BH!0CC:D8^!4E97:BH>@BM "0-U#()!J< "#$ ;B?8I9:HB8?!D7:8C9!EB?!GEII:@I9O!C@I!>78=98FA89!EB?!>78:I!>I:<89O!7EA8! EJJ8EF8?!>@!>78!7;=EB:>Lg!EB?!>7I@GB!>78=98FA89!@BO!EB?!7E A8!JI@=:98?!>@! D@B>:B;8!;B?8IO!>78!JI@>8D>:@B!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89O!EB?!@C!B@!@>78I!BE>:@BO! J@G8IO!@I!9@A8I8:HBg!EB?O!:B!D@B9:?8IE>:@B!@C!>78!JI@=:989!EB?!9>:J;FE>:@B9! 78I8:BEC>8I!=E?8O!?@!D8?8!EB?!I8F:BK;:97!EFF!DFE:=!@I!>:>F8!G7:D7!>78L!=EL! 7EA8!>@!>78!G 7@F8!>8II:>@IL!@C!2F@I:?EO!G:>7!>78!8WD8J>:@B!@C!9;D7!?:9>I:D>!@C! D@;B>IL!E9!97EFF!78I8:B!<8!EFF@>>8?!>@!>78=M "0-U#()!K< "78!2F@I:?E!>I:<89!@C!)B?:EB9!G:FF!78I8EC>8I!<8!D@BD8B>IE>8?!EB?!D@BC:B8?!>@! >78!C@FF@G:BH!=8>89!EB?!<@;B?EI:89^!D@==8BD:BH!C:A8!=:F89 B@I>7!@C! 0T87;=T8O!I;BB:BH!:B!E!?:I8D>!F:B8!>@!E!J@:B>!C:A8!=:F89!G89>!@C!-8>EITLt9! 98>>F8=8B>O!@B!>78!GE>8I9!@C!,=EN;IEO!\@I!4:>7FE7;D7:8!I:A8IO!]!F8EA:BH!9E:?! 98>>F8=8B>!>G@!=:F89!9@;>7!@C!>78!F:B8g!CI@=!>78BD8O!:B!E!?:I8D>!F:B8O!>@!>78! 9@;>7!8B?!@C!>78 6:H!#E==@DTO!>@!:BDF;?8!.7:DT;D7E>8g!D@B>:B;:BHO!:B!>78! 9E=8!?:I8D>:@BO!C@I!C:A8!=:F89!<8L@B?!>78!9E:?!#E==@DT q JI@A:?8?!9E:?!J@:B>! ?@89!B@>!EJJI@ED7!B8EI8I!>7EB!C:C>88B!=:F89!>78!98E!D@E9>!@C!>78!*;FC!@C!38W:D@g! :C!:>!?@89O!>78!9E:?!F:B8!G:FF!>8I=:BE>8!E> >7E>!?:9>EBD8!CI@=!>78!98E!D@E9>g! >78BD8O!9@;>7O!>G8FA8!=:F89g!>78BD8!:B!E!9@;>7!hQ„!8E9>!?:I8D>:@BO!;B>:F!>78!9E=8! 97EFF!9>I:T8!G:>7:B!C:A8!=:F89!@C!>78!=E:B!>8!I:A8Ig!>78BD8O!:B!E! ?;8!8E9>!?:I8D>:@BO!>@!G:>7:B!>G8B>L!=:F89!@C!>78!,>FEB> :D!D@E9>g!>78BD8O!B@I>7O! C:C>88B!G89>O!C@I!C:C>L!=:F89!EB?!CI@=!>7:9!FE9>O!>@!>78!<8H:BB:BH!J@:B>M "0-U#()!L< "78 'B:>8?!->E>89!G:FF!>ET8!>78!2F@I:?E!)B?:EB9!;B?8I!>78:I!DEI8!EB?!JE>I@BEH8O! EB?!G:FF!ECC@I?!>78=!JI@>8D>:@B!EHE:B9>!EFF!J8I9@B9!G7E>9@8A8Ig!JI @A:?8?!>78L! D@BC@I=!>@!>78!FEG9!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89O!EB?!I8CIE:B!CI@=!=ET:BH!GEIO!@I! H:A:BH!EBL!:B9;F>!>@!EBL!C@I8:HB!BE>:@BO!G:>7@;>!7EA:BH!C:I9>!@<>E:B8?!>78! J8I=:99:@B!EB?!D@B98B>!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89^!,B?O!:B!D@B9:?8IE>:@B!@C!>78! EJJ8EF!EB?!D899:@B!=E ?8!:B!>78!C:I9>!EI>:DF8!@C!>7:9!>I8E>LO!78!EC@I89E:?! D7:8C9!EB?!GEII:@I9O!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!JI@=:98!>@!?:9>I:<;>8!E=@BH!>78!>I:<89O! E9!9@@B!E9!D@BD8B>IE>8?O!;B?8I!>78!?:I8D>:@B!@C!>78:I!EH8B>O!:=JF8=8B>9!@C!

PAGE 149

! Rhc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g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g!EB?!>78L!C;I>78I!EHI88! >@!D@=J8B9E>8!>7@98!:B?:A:?;E F9!G7@!7EA8!<88B!D@=J8FF8?!>@!E9!@B!FEB?9O!B@>!8=7:B!>78!F:=:>9!EFF@>>8?O!>@!>78! E=@;B>!@C!C@;I!>7@;9EB?!C:A8!7;B?I8?!?@FFEI9O!>@!<8!?:9>I:<;>8?!E=@BH!>78! 9;CC8I8I9O!:B!E!IE>:@!>@!8ED7O!JI@J@I>:@BEF!>@!>78!AEF;8!@C!>78!:=JI@A8=8 B>9! E8?!->E>89!C;I>78I!EHI88!>@!C;IB:97!E!9;=O!B@>!8WD88?:BH! >G@!>7@;9EB?!?@FFEI9O!>@!<8!8WJ8B?8?!78:I!EH8B>O!>@!CED:F:>E>8!>78! >IEB9J@I>E>:@B!@C!>78!?:CC8I8B>!>I:<89!>@!>78!J@:B>!@C!D@BD8B>IE>:@B!?89:HBE>8?M "0-U#()!O< ,B!EH8B>O 9;< 5 EH8B>O!EB?!:B>8IJI8>8IO!97EFF!<8!EJJ@:B>8?O!>@!I89:?8!G:>7:B!>78! )B?:EB!<@;B?EIL!EC@I89E:?O!>@!GE>D7!@A8I!>78!:B>8I89>9!@C!9E:?!>I:<89g!EB?!>78! 'B:>8?!->E>89!C;I>78I!9>:J;FE>8O!E9!EB!8A:?8BD8!@C!>78:I!7;=EB8!J@F:DL!>@GEI?9! 9E:?!>I:<89O!G7@!7EA8!EJJ8EF8?!>@ >78:I!F:<8IEF:>LO!>@!EFF@G!C@I!>78! 89>E!@C!E!9D7@@F!E>!>78!EH8BDLO!@B8!>7@;9EB?!?@FFEI9!J8I!L8EI!C@I! >G8B>L!9;DD899:A8!L8EI9g!EB?!@B8!>7@;9EB?!?@FFEI9!J8I!L8EIO!C@I!>78!9E=8! J8I:@?O!C@I!>78!9;JJ@I>!@C!E!H;B!EB?!7O!G:>7!>78!8WJ8B989!:BD:? 8B>EF! >@!7:9!97@JM "0-U#()!P< "78!D7:8C9 EB?!GEII:@I9!EC@I89E:?O!C@I!>78=98FA89!EB?!>I:<89O!9>:J;FE>8!>@!<8! ED>:A8!EB?!A:H:FEB>!:B!>78!JI8A8B>:BH!>78!I8>I8E>:BH!>@O!@I!JE99:BH!>7I@;H7O!@C!

PAGE 150

! RkQ >78!?:9>I:D>!@C!D@;B>IL!E99:HB8?!>78=O!@C!EBL!E<9D@B?:BH!9FEA89O!@I! C;H:>:A89! CI@=!Z;9>:D8g!EB?!C;I>78I!EHI88O!>@!;98!EFF!B8D899EIL!8W8I>:@B9!>@!EJJI878B?! EB?!?8F:A8I!>78!9E=8!>@!>78!EH8B>O!G7@!97EFF!I8D8:A8!@I?8I9!>@!D@=J8B9E>8! >78=!EHI88E@!>78!>I@;7!E!9;IA8L@IO!97EFF!<8!EJJ@:B>8?O!78! /I89:?8B>!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89O!>@!I;B!EB?!=EITO!\!>78!>I889]! >78!F:B8!E9!?8C:B8?!:B!>78!98D@B?!EI>:DF8!@C!>7:9!>I8E>LO!G7@!97EFF!<8!E>>8B?8?!@!<8!?89:HBE>8?!78:I!@GB!>I:<89O!EB?!G7@! 97EFF!I8D8:A8O!G7:F8!9@!8=JF@L8?O!E!?E:FL!D@=J8B9E>:@B!@C!>7I88!?@FFEI9M "0-U#()!R< "78!;B?8I9:HB8? D7:8C9!EB?!GEII:@I9O!C@I!>78=98FA89!EB?!>I:<89O!7EA:BH! @8?!>@!>78:I!D@BD8B>IE>:@B!G:>7:B!>78!F:=:>9!?89DI:<8?!:B!>78 98D@B?! EI>:DF8!@C!>7:9!>I8E>LO!;B?8I!>78!:=JI899:@B!>7E>!>78!9E:?!F:=:>9!?:?!B@>!D@B>E:B! E!9;CC:D:8B>!K;EB>:>L!@C!H@@?!FEB?!>@!9;<9:9>!>78=O!EB?!C@I!B@!@>78I!I8E9@B^!:>!:9O! >78I8C@I8O!8WJI899FL!;B?8I9>@@?O!<8>G88B!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!EB?!>78!EC@I89E:?! D7:8C 9!EB?!GEII:@I9O!>7E>O!97@;F?!>78!D@;B>IL!8=78!9E:?!F:=:>9O!;J@B! 8WE=:BE>:@B!78!)B?:EB!EH8B>!EB?!>78!D@==:99:@B8IO!@I!D@==:99:@B8I9O!>@! <8!EJJ@:B>8?!;B?8I!>78!e>7!EI>:DF8!@C!>7:9!>I8E>LO!<8!78=!D@B9:?8I8?! :B9;CC:D:8B>!C@I!>78!9;JJ@I>!@C!> 78!9E:?!)B?:EB!>I:<89g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q ,B?!>78L!C;I>78I!I8K;89>O!>7E>!@B8!=:F8!9K;EI8O!E >!>78!0D78988! 6F;CC9O!8=8J78B!(:D7EI?t9!C:8F?!@B!9E:?!!>@!9E:?!->8J78B!(:D7EI?9M!"78!D@==:99:@B8I9!EDD@I?!:B! 98B>:=8B>!G:>7!>78!;B?8I9:HB8?!D7:8C9!EB?!GEII:@I9O!EB?!I8D@==8B?!E! D@=JF:EBD8!G:>7!>78:I! G:9789!>@!>78!/I89:?8B>!EB?!-8BE>8!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89g! <;>!>78!?:9EJJI@AEFO!@B!>78!JEI>!@C!>78!9E:?!E;>7@I:>:89O!@C!>7:9!EI>:DF8O!97EFFO!:B! B@!G:98O!ECC8D>!>78!@>78I!EI>:DF89!EB?!9>:J;FE>:@B9!D@BDF;?8?!@B!:B!>7:9!>I8E>LM )B!>89>:=@BL!G78I8@CO!>78!D@==:99 :@B8I9O!4:FF:E=!/M!&;AEFO!SE=89!*E?9?8BO! EB?!68IBEI?!-8H;:O!EB?!>78!;B?8I9:HB8?!D7:8C9!EB?!GEII:@I9O!7EA8!78I8;B>@!

PAGE 151

! RkR 9;<9DI:<8?!>78:I!BE=89!EB?!ECC:W8?!>78:I!98EF9M!&@B8!E>!DE=J!@B!3@;F>I:8! DI88TO!:B!>78!>8II:>@IL!@C!2F@I:?EO!>7:9!8:H7>88B>7!?EL!@C!-8J>8=<8I O!@B8! >7@;9EB?!8:H7>!7;B?I8?!EB?!>G8B>L 5 >7I88O!EB?!@C!>78!:B?8J8B?8BD8!@C!>78! 'B:>8?!->E>89!>78!C@I>L 5 8:H7>7M P(66("42M;2V-F"6@2bH;28;c d"4$)2B"9)9$/@2bH;28;c G$#/"#928$.-(@2bH;28;c X$"2'"%*6"@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c 73=3)$2'"%*6"@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c X(//$$2 !34"%"27-)%$/-=1@2*()24"#=@2bH;28;c '(,3/3+$@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c X3,3)$$2C*36"@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c d3*/2G6-/%@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c T%6$4"%"@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c 7-)=$$/$*"@2*()2R24"#=@bH;28;c 7-)=(2!"J3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c Q,3/,*"%(4(,3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH; 2 8;c Q43%$6$1@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c '-6"%%32e(/.@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c <*3,*363*"/3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c Q4"%63,*$$@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c P3=)$2!36"%"@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c C4"%*6"2!3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c !36"%$5(),(,3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c <*$5(),32!"J3@2*()2R 2 4"#=@2bH;28;c

PAGE 152

! RkP H"%*63"2'"%*6"@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c 8$/-5=1@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c C6"=2!"J3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c :"*$6-)%$$2!"J3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c T,%"*"4(,3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c 7-)%$/$,=2!"J3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c T=3)=$$2C4"%*6"@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c T,*$$/127-)%$/-=1@2*()2R24"#=2bH;28;c M*(66(+@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c <*"#6$12C4"%*6"@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c d3*/2!3+3/$1@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c U"%2!$"9@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c !36"%%"2C4"%*6"@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c :3)*"%,*(4(,3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c -:HB8?O!98EF8?O! EB?!?8F:A8I8?!:B!>78!JI898BD8!@C q B$3#.$2'-##"1@2)$,#$%"#12%32%*$2,344())(3/@ B;2!-4+*#$1)@2>/9("/2".$/%@ 8%$+*$/2U(,*"#9)@2(/%$#+#$%$#@ >)"",2X;2<3R@ d;2Q#F(/.@2,"+%"(/@2:3-#%*2C#%(66$#1@ !"#F$12G#30/@26($-%$/"/%@2:3-#%*2C#%(66$#1@ <;2VLQ)+(/F(66$@26($-%$ /"/%@2:3-#%*2C#%(66$#1@ d/3;2G;28,3%%@26($-%$/"/%@2:3-#%*2C#%(66$#1@

PAGE 153

! Rkh P(66("427#"F$#)@ !3#"%(328;2V$R%$#; "**U-U&%"(!"0-U#()< .6T77FEO!S@7B!6F;B>O!";9T:!#EZ@O!3;FE>>@!Y:BHO!$=E>7F@D788O!EB?! $D@BD7E>:=:D@O!9:W!@C! >78!JI:BD:JEF!.7:8C9!@C!>78!2F@I:?E!)B?:EB9O!EB?!JEI>:89!>@! >78!>I8E>L!>@!G7:D7!>7:9!EI>:DF8!7E9!<88B!EBB8W8?O!7EA8!GEI=FL!EJJ8EF8?!>@!>78! .@==:99:@B8I9!C@I!J8I=:99:@B!>@!I8=E:B!:B!>78!?:9>I:D>!@C!D@;B>IL!B@G! :B7E<:>8?!78=g!EB?O!:B!D@B9:?8IE>:@B!@C!>78 :I!CI:8B?FL!?:9J@9:>:@BO!EB?!JE9>! 98IA:D89!>@!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89O!:>!:9O!>78I8C@I8O!9>:J;FE>8?O!<8>G88B!>78!'B:>8?! ->E>89!EB?!>78!EC@I89E:?!.7:8C9O!>7E>!>78!C@FF@G:BH!I898IAE>:@B9!97EFF!<8! 9;IA8L8?O!EB?!=EIT8?!78!.@==:99:@B8IO!@I!.@==:99:@B8I9O!>@!<8! EJ J@:B>8?!;B?8I!>78!e>7!EI>:DF8!@C!>7:9!"I8E>L^!2@I!>78!;98!@C!%8E!3E>7FE!EB?! 7:9!D@BB8D>:@B9O!>G@!=:F89!9K;EI8O!8=78!";J7;FHE!A:FFEH8O!@B!>78! GE>8I9!@C!(@DTL!.@=C@I>!.I88TM!2@I!6F;B>!EB?!";9T:!#EZ@O!E!I898IAE>:@BO! D@==8BD:BH!@B!>78!,JEFED7:D@FEO!@B 8!=:F8!<8F@G!";9T:!#EZ@t9!:=JI@A8=8B>9O! I;BB:BH!;J!9E:?!I:A8I!C@;I!=:F89g!>78BD8O!G89>O!>G@!=:F89g!>78BD8!9@;>78IFLO!>@! E!J@:B>!>G@!=:F89!?;8!G89>!@C!>78!<8H:BB:BHg!>78BD8!8E9>O!>@!>78!<8H:BB:BH! J@:B>M!2@I!3;FE>>@!Y:BH!EB?!$=E>7F@D788O!E!I898IAE>:@BO!D@==8 BD:BH!@B!>78! ,JEFED7:D@FEO!E>!E!J@:B>!>@!:BDF;?8!18FF@G!#E:I9!:=JI@A8=8B>9g!>78BD8O!;J!9E:?! I:A8IO!C@I!C@;I!=:F89g!>78BD8O!G89>O!@B8!=:F8g!>78BD8O!9@;>78IFLO!>@!E!J@:B>!@B8! =:F8!G89>!@C!>78!<8H:BB:BHg!EB?!>78BD8O!8E9>O!>@!>78!<8H:BB:BH!J@:B>M!2@I! $D@BD7E>: =:D@O!E!I898IAE>:@BO!D@==8BD:BH!@B!>78!.7E>E7@@D7:8O!@B8!=:F8! <8F@G!$D@BD7E>:=:D@t9!7@;98g!>78BD8O!;J!9E:?!I:A8IO!C@I!C@;I!=:F89g!>78BD8O!@B8! =:F8O!G89>g!>78BD8O!9@;>78IFLO!>@!E!J@:B>!@B8!=:F8!G89>!@C!>78!<8H:BB:BHg!>78BD8O! 8E9>O!>@!>78!<8H:BB:BH!J@:B>M!"7 8!'B:>8?!->E>89!JI@=:98!>@!H;EIEB>L!>78! J8ED8E78!9E:?!I898IAE>:@B9O!E9!?8C:B8?O!>@!>78!EC@I89E:?! D7:8C9!EB?!>78:I!?89D8B?EB>9!@BFLO!9@!F@BH!E9!>78L!97EFF!D@B>:B;8!>@!@DD;JLO! :=JI@A8O!@I!D;F>:AE>8O!>78!9E=8g!<;>!:B!>78!8A8B>!@C!>78!E!@C!EFFO!@I! 8:>78I!@C!>78!I898IAE>:@B9O!78!D7:8C!@I!D7:8C9O!>@!G7@=!>78L!7EA8!<88B! EFF@>>8?O!>78!I898IAE>:@BO!@I!I898IAE>:@B9O!9@!E!>@!>78! 'B:>8?!->E>89O!E9!:BDF;?8?!:B!>78!D899:@B!=E?8!:B!>78!C:I9>!EI>:DF8!@C!>7:9!>I8E>LM! )> :9!C;I>78I!;B?8I9>@@?O!>7E>!>78!BE=89!@C!>78!:B?:A:?;EF9!I8=E:B:BH!@B!>78! I898IAE>:@B9!EC@I89E:?O!97EFF!<8!C;IB:978?O!78!D7:8C9!:B!G7@98!CEA@I!>78! I898IAE>:@B9!7EA8!<88B!=E?8O!>@!>78!-;J8I:B>8B?8B>!@I!EH8B>!@C!)B?:EB!,CCE:I9O! :B!>78!>8II:>@IL!@C!2F@I: ?Eg!EB?!>7E>!B@!@>78I!:B?:A:?;EF9!97EFF!<8!I8D8:A8?!@I! J8I=:>>8?!>@!I8=E:B!G:>7:B!9E:?!I898IAE>:@B9O!G:>7@;>!>78!JI8A:@;9!D@B98B>!@C! >78!-;J8I:B>8B?8B>!@I!,H8B>!EC@I89E:?g!,B?O!E9!>78!EC@I89E:?!.7:8C9!EI8! E;>7@I:N8?!>@!98F8D>!>78!:B?:A:?;EF9!I8=E:B:BH!G:>7 >78=O!9@!>78L!97EFF!8ED7!<8! 98JEIE>8FL!78F?!I89J@B9:78!J8ED8E!@C!>78:I!>@GB9O!@I!>78! :B?:A:?;EF9!I89:?:BH!@B!>78!I898IAE>:@B9!EFF@>>8?!>78=M!)>!:9!C;I>78I! ;B?8I9>@@?O!<8>G88B!>78!JEI>:89O!>7E>!>7:9!EHI88=8B>!:9!B@>!:B>8B?8?!>@! JI@7:<:> >78!A@F;B>EIL!I8=@AEFO!E>!EBL!C;>;I8!J8I:@?O!@C!EFF!@I!8:>78I!@C!>78!

PAGE 154

! Rkk EC@I89E:?!.7:8C9!EB?!>78:I!D@BB8D>:@B9O!>@!>78!?:9>I:D>!@C!D@;B>IL!9@;>7O!EFF@>>8?! >@!>78!2F@I:?E!)B?:EB9O!78!98D@B?!EI>:DF8!@C!>7:9!"I8E>LO!G78B8A8I!8:>78IO!@I! EFF!=EL!>7:BT!JI@J8I! >@!=ET8!9;D7!EB!8F8D>:@Bg!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!I898IA:BH!>78! I:H7>!@C!@I?8I:BHO!C@I!EBL!@;>IEH8!@I!=:9D@B?;D>O!>78!EC@I89E:?!.7:8C9O!@I!8:>78I! @C!>78=O!G:>7!>78:I!D@BB8D>:@B9O!G:>7:B!>78!?:9>I:D>!@C!D@;B>IL!9@;>7O!EC@I89E:?M! )>!:9!C;I>78I!9>:J;FE>8?O!78!' B:>8?!->E>89O!>7E>O!@C!>78!9:W!>7@;9EB?!?@FFEI9O! EJJI@JI:E>8?!C@I!:=JF8=8B>9!@C!7;9@DTO!€DM!:B!>78!>7:I?!EI>:DF8!@C! >7:9!"I8E>LO!8:H7>!7;B?I8?!?@FFEI9!97EFF!<8!?:9>I:<;>8?O!:B!>78!9E=8!=EBB8IO! E=@BH!>78!EC@I89E:?!D7:8C9!EB?!>78:I!>@GB9g!EB?!:>!:9 ;B?8I9>@@?O!>7E>O!@C!>78! EBB;EF!9;=!@C!C:A8!>7@;9EB?!?@FFEI9!>@!<8!?:9>I:<;>8?!78!/I89:?8B>!@C!>78! 'B:>8?!->E>89O!>78L!G:FF!I8D8:A8!>78:I!JI@J@I>:@BM!)>!:9!C;I>78I!9>:J;FE>8?O!>7E>O! @C!>78!C@;I!>7@;9EB?!C:A8!7;B?I8?!?@FFEI9O!EB?!>G@!>7@;9EB?!?@FFEI9O! JI@A:?8?! C@I!78!d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bH;28;c d"4$)2B" 9)9$/@2bH;28;c G$#/"#928$.-(@2bH;28;c X$"2'"%*6";2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c d3*/2G6-/%@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c 7-)=(2!"J3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c '-6"%%32e(/.@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c Q4"%*63,*$$@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c Q,3/,*"%(4(,3@2*()2R24"#=@2bH;28;c -:HB8?O!98EF8?O!?8F: A8I8?O!:B!JI898BD8!@C q B$3#.$2'-##"1@2)$,#$%"#12%32%*$2,344())(3/

PAGE 155

! Rkd d";2P;2U(+6$1@ B;2!-4+*#$1)@2>/9("/2".$/%@ 8%$+*$/2U(,*"#9)@2(/%$#+#$%$#; "78!C@FF@G:BH!9>E>8=8B>!97@G9!>78!B;=<8I!@C!=8B!I8>E:B8?!78!.7:8C9O!G7@! 7EA8!I898IAE>:@B9!=E?8!>78=O!E>!>78:I!I8 9J8D>:A8!A:FFEH89M %;=<8I!@C!38BM 6F@;B>!M!M!kh .@D7IEB!M!M!kd 3;FE>>@!Y:BH!M!M!hQ $=E>7F@D788!M!M!Pe!$D@BD7E>:=:D@!M!M!he %8@!3E>7:E!M!M hQ "@>EF!M!M!PRk !

PAGE 156

! Rkf "TT65V3b!#! 8 &;W6>DB!B5V!A3;!A3;7>:Y "78!=;F>:FEL8I8?!78I:>EH8!@C!>78!-8=:B@F89!DEB!<8!<89>!988B!:B!>78!CE=:FL!@C! 09D8@FEM! 09D8@FEO!>78!(8?!->:DT!.I88T!!8WE=JF8!@C!>78!?LBE=:D!8F;D:?E>8?!@B8!:B!78I!98D>:@B!@B! V.I8@F:NE>:@BO!3;F>:D; F>;IEF:9=O!EB?!.@=JF8W:>LX!\(;<8I>@B8!PQQQ^khi 5 khc]!M!#:9! CE>78I!GE9!EB!$BHF:97!>IE?8I!BE=8?!4:FF:E=!/@G8FFO!7:9!=@>78I!GE9!E!"EFFE9988! G@=EB!BE=8?!/@FFL!.@J:BH8IO!G7@!GE9!>78!HIEB??E;H7>8I!@C!EB!:BCF;8B>:EF! -D@>9=EB!E=@BH!>78!"EFFE988!BE=8?!SE=89!3Dz;88BO EB?!7:9!HIEB?9@B!GE9! I8J@I>8?FL!6:FFL!6@GF8H9!)))O!GE9!>78!9@B!@C!EB!,CI:DEB!-8=:B@F8M! !! /E>I:D:E!4:DT=EB!?:9D;9989!09D8@FE!>78!=EB!A8I9;9!09D8@FE!>78!=L>7! \PQQf^fi 5 RQf]M! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!/E>I:D:E!4:DT=EB!\PQQf^f]^ 6L!>78!>:=8!@C!6:FFLU9!o09D8@FEp!<:I>7O!=EB L!@C!>78!"EFFE9988! >@GB9J8@JF8!G8I8!=:W8? 5 >:97O!EB?!9@=8! C8G!=EL!7EA8!7E?!,CI:DEB!7898j)>!:9!@7E>O!@?ELU9!H8B8>:D!9>EB?EI?9!:=J@98?! ;J@B!)B?:EB9!:B!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!>@ ?ELO!6:FFL!/@G8FF!o09D8@FEp!GE9! 8IBEF!HIEB?=@>78IO!%EBDLO!GE9!E!V7EFC! 78IU9!;=!GE9!@B8 5 K;EI>8IM!#:9!@GB! K;EB>;=O!>78I8C@I8O!G@;F?!7EA8!<88B!@BFL!@B8 5 8:H7> 555 8B@;H7!C@I! D:>:N8B97:J!:B!>78!\I8=@A8?]!-8=:B@F8 %E>:@B!@C!0TFE7@=EO!<;>!F899! >7EB!>78!=:B:=;=!I8K;:I8?!78!-8=:B@F8!"I:<8!@C!2F@I:?Eg!EB?! 8B@;H7!>@!<8!F:9>8?!@B!>78!"I:!B@>!8B@;H7!>@!7@F?!@CC:D8!:B! >78!\I8=@A8?]!3;9D@H88!\.I88T]!%E>:@B!@C!0TFE7@=EO!EFF!@C!G7:D7! >I:<89!EI8!7@=89!>@!7:9!? 89D8B?8B>9!>@!>7:9!?ELM 09D8@FE!GE9!E!I89J8D>8?!A@:D8!E=@BH!>78!-8=:B@F89!8A8B!>7@;H7!78!?:?!B@>! 7EA8!>78!EIL!F8E?8IM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!4:DT=EB!\PQQf^fe]O! Vjo09D8@FEp!?:?!8W8ID:98!E!C@I=!@C!J@G8I!EB?!:BCF;8BD8!<;:F>!;J@B!>78!DI:>:DEF!>G: B! 8F8=8B>9!@C!E?78I8BD8!>@!>IE?:>:@B!EB?!I8D:JI@DEF!DEI:BHM!"7898!G8I8!>78!9E=8! K;EF:>:89!>7E>!>78!J8@JF8!F@@T8?!C@I!:B!E!3:DD@ q E!J8I9@B!G7@!G@;F?!JI898IA8!>78!

PAGE 157

! Rki @F?!GEL9!EB?!T88J!>78!G@IF?!:B!ET:BH!DEI8!@C!>78=!8A8B!E9!>78L!>@@T! DEI8!@C!7:=MX!,> >78!9E=8!>:=8!>7E>!78!GE9!E!I89J8D>8?!A@:D8!EHE:B9>!8=:HIE>:@BO!>78! -8=:B@F89!G8I8!B@>!;B:>8?!E9!7@G!>@!<89>!?8EF!G:>7!>78!D@BCF:D>M!-8A8IEF!-8=:B@F8! F8E?8I9!9EG!09D8@FE!E9!E!>7I8E>!>@!8B?:BH!>78!D@BCF:D>!:BH!>78!@CC8I!>@!<8! I8=@A8?!>@!>78!)B?:EB "8II:>@ILM!0B8!9;D7!F8E?8IO!.7EIF8L!,=EI>7FE!GE9!ED>;EFFL! T:FF8?!78!>I::@B!C@I!D@@J8IE>:BH!G:>7! ,=8I:DEB!I8=@AEF!8CC@I>9M!,B@>78I!F8E?8I!G7@!7E?!?8D:?8?!>@!8=:HIE>8O!.@8!7E?Z@O! 9EG!09D8@FE!E9!E!>7I8E>!EB?!GE9 EF@BH9:?8!09D8@FE!E9!78!GE9!DEJ>;I8?!:B!0D>@<8I!@C! Rehi!\PQQf^fe]M!09D8@FEU9!JI89>:H8!8?!8IJI8>E>:@B9!@C!-8=:B@F8!:B>8IED>:@B9O!GE9!9@F:?:C:8?!E=@BH!>78!-8=:B@F89! C@FF@G:BH!7:9!T:FF:BH!@C!>78!7E>8?!)B?:EB!,H8B>!4 :F8L!"7@=J9@B!@B!&8D8=<8I!Pe >7 O! RehdM! ,9!E!D7:F?!@C!CF;:?!8>7B:D!:?8B>:>L!EB?!=:W8?!78I:>EH8O!09D8@FE!Vj9J8B>!E>!F8E9>! >78!FE9>!L8EI!EB?!E!7EFC!@C!7:9!F:C8O!CI@=!SEB;EIL!Rehf!>7I@;H7!=:? 5 RehiO!>IL:BH!>@! JI@A8!>@!G7:>89!>7E>!78!G@;F?!B@>O!;B?8I!EBL!D:ID;=9 >EBD89O!<8!C@ID8?!@;>!@C!>78! 7@=8!>7E>!78!DFE:=8?!:B!2F@I:?E!EB?O!E>!>78!9E=8!>:=8O!>IL:BH!>@!97@G!>7E>!78!D@;F?! F:A8!:B!J8ED8!G:>7!G7:>89X!\PQQf^cd]M!"78!GEI9!G8I8!B@>!B8D899EI:FL!EHE:B9>!,BHF@ 5 ,=8I:DEB9!E9!J8@JF8!<;>!IE>78I!@C!>78!:?8E!@C!C@ID8?!?:9J@998 99:@BM!$A8B!E9!09D8@FE! GE9!DEJ>;I8?!;B?8I!>78!G7:>8!CFEH!\*8B8IEF!S89;JO!>78!=E9>8I=:B?!@C!>7:9!JFEBO! G@;F?!7EA8!>@!9J8B?!>78!I89>!@C!7:9!F:C8!?8C8B?:BH!7:9!?8D:9:@B!>@!>78!,=8I:DEB! J;E>;I8O!09D8@FE! I8J;>8?FL! 78FJ8?!7:9!C@FF@G8I9!89DEJ8!:BH!>78!=8?:D:B8!<;B?F8!G:>7!G7:D7!>78L!D@;F?! D@B>I@F!>78!G@IF?!EI@;B?!>78=!>@!EFF@G!>78:I!89DEJ8M!09D8@FE!?:?!B@>!H@!G:>7!>78=!

PAGE 158

! Rke EB?!G@;F?!?:8!Z;9>!E!C8G!=@B>79!FE>8IO!<;>!7:9!DEJ>;I8!EB?!>78!89DEJ8!78!F8H8B?EI: FL! 8BH:B88I8?!9@F:?:C:8?!7:9!9>E>;9!E9!B@>!Z;9>!E!-8=:B@F8!F8E?8IO!<;>!E9!EB!,=8I:DEB! C@FT!78I@M!'BC@I>;BE>8FLO!>78!,=8I:DEB!F8H8B?!@C!09D8@FE!G@;F?!98IA8!E9!>78!GEL! ,=8I:DEB9!G@;F?!;B?8I9>EB?!>78!-8=:B@F89M!"78!EJJI@JI:E>:@B!@C!7:9!9>@IL!>@!98IA8! >78!HI8E >8I!=L>7@F@HL!@C!,=8I:DE!CED>@I8?!:B>@!>78!?:9J@99899:@B!@C!B@>!@BFL!>78! -8=:B@F89!CI@=!>78:I!7@=8FEB?!<;>!EF9@!CI@=!>78:I!78I:>EH8M .F8EIFLO!09D8@FE!GE9!I8JI898B>E>:A8!@C!>78!?LBE=:D!:B!>78!9@;>78E9>!E9!8>7B:D! <@;B?EI:89!G8I8!CF;:?!EB?!>7E>!78!G@;F?!@BFL! <8!@!<8!E!>I:@?EL!?;8!>@!>78!,=8I:DEB!;=!J@F:DL!:9!E!I8=EITEE>:9>:DO! 89J8D:EFFL!D@B9:?8I:BH!7:9!F8H8B?EIL!C@FT!78I@!9>E>;9!:B!>78!-@;>78E9>!>@?ELM!"78! H8B8>:D!E?=:W>;I8!>7E>!->@ZEB@G9T:!\PQQc]!D@BA8L9!:B!-JEB:9 7!+E!2F@I:?E!?:?!B@>! Z;9>!9>@J!C@FF@G:BH!>78!89>E!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89g!:>!D@B>:B;89!>@?EL!E9!>78! CF;:?:>L!@C!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L!D@B>:B;89!>@!8WJEB?!EB?!HI@GM! "78! @B8!>I;FL! ;B:CL:BH! CED>@I!@C!-8=:B@F8!:?8B>:>L O!G7:D7!7:9!I:D7FLO!=;F>:FEL8I8 ?!D@9=@J@F:>EB! 78I:>EH8!EFF!>@H8>78IO :9!>78! D@BD8J> @C!>78!'BD@BK;8I8?!/8@JF8M

PAGE 159

! Rkc "TT65V3b!*78!(:A8IO!F:T8!>78!CF@IEO!:9!I:D7!EB?!AEI:8?M!,!C;FF!F:9>!@C!CE;BE! TB@GB!>@!:B7E<:>!>78!EI8E!DEB!<8!C@;B?!:B!EJJ8B?:W!.!@C! >78! '1"=="2P(692"/928,$/(,2 U(F$#2'"/".$4$/%2M6"/ M!)B9>8E?!@C!F:9>:BH!EFF!>78!CE;BE!@C!>78!I:A8IO!)!G:FF!C@FF@G!>78! CIE=8G@IT!JI@A:?8?!78!3(3..!EB?!?:A:?8!:>!E>!EB?!H:A8!8WE=JF89M!"78! 7EI?G@@?9!:B!>78!=89:D!7E==@DT9!@C!>78!3LETTE!GE>8I978?!VJI@A :?8!D@A8I!EB?u@I! =E9>!C@I!B;=8I@;9!=E==EF!EB?!<:I?!9J8D:89!9;D7!E9!>78!HIEL!9K;:II8FO!C@W!9K;:II8FO! D@>>@B!=@;98O!G@@?!?;DTO!8E9>8IB!=@F8O!IEDD@@BO!HI88B!>I88CI@HO! 9K;:II8F!>I88CI@HO! L8FF@G!IE>!9BET8O!DI@GO!HIEDTF8O! EB?!I8? 5 8L8?!A:I8@X!\3(3..!PQRR^Re]M! ,?? :>:@BEFFLO!V,!=LI:E?!@C!GEI!@B!7E==@DT9! ?;I:BH!=:HIE>:@BjoEB?!>78Lp!EI8!EF9@!;>:F:N8?!:DE>8?!@I!C8IEF!EB:=EF9!9;D7! E9!DE>>F8!EB?!7@H9X!\PQRR^Re 5 Rc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ccQ^P 5 kk 5 kd]M!"78!CE;BE!:B!W8I:D!7E==@DT9!:BDF;?8!VHFE99 F:NEI?9O!9T:BT9O!D@IB!9BET89O!?GEIC!

PAGE 160

! RdQ 9EFE=EB?8I9O!$E9>8IB!BEII@G 5 =@;>78?!>@E?O!9J@>>8?!9T;BTO!A;F>;I89O!G:F?!>;IT8LO! L8FF@G 5 <:FF8?!D;DT@@O!8!GEIEBEH8IX!\RccQ^P 5 kd]M /:B8!CFE>G@@?9!EB?!J:B8!JIE:I:89!EI8!C@;B?!>7I@;H7@;>!>78!3 LETTE!(:A8I! GE>8I978?M!2@GF!:BDF;?8!V@9JI8LO!9!9;D7!E9!>78!8E9>8IB!L8FF@G!!EB?!8A8B:BH!X!\3(3..!PQRR^Rc]M!+EB?! =E==EF9!:BDF;?8!V@J@99;=O!EI=E?:FF@O!<@O!HIEL!C@WO!IEDD@@BO!C@W!9K;:II8F!EB?! G7:>8 5 >E :F8?!?88IX!E9!G8FF!E9!C8IEF!7@H9!EB?!DE>>F8!\PQRR^Rc]M!)B!E??:>:@BO!>78!3(3..! I8J@I>9!\PQRR^Rc]O!V0>78I!D@==@B!I89:?8B>9!@C!J:B8G@@?9!7E<:>E>9!:BDF;?8!>78! 8E9>8IB!>@G788O!D@>>@B!IE>O!D@>>@B!=@;98O!7E>D7O!B@I>78IB! DEI?:BEFO!<@W!>;I>F8O!EB?!J :B8!GEIE>!C@I!=EBL! C@99@I:EF!EB:=EF9M!"78!CE;BE!@C!>7:9!8BA:I@B=8B>!:BDF;?8!VH@J78I!>@I>@:98O!H@J78I! CI@Hj<;II@G:BH!@GFj$E9>8IB!?:E=@B?>F89BET8O!$E9>8IB!:B?:H@! 9BET8MMM9EB?7:FF!DIEB8O!7EGTO!E B?!DI89>8?!DEIEDEIEX! \3(3..!RccQ^P 5 kd]M!#@G8A8IO!9:BD8!RccQ!7E<:>E>!F@99!7E9!F8?!>@!>78!?:9EJJ8EIEBD8! @C!CE;BE!9;D7!E9!>78!<;II@G:BH!@GF!EB?!DI89>8?!DEIEDEIE!CI@=!>7:9!7E<:>E>!\3(3..! PQRR^Rc]M!2;I>78I=@I8O!V*@J78I!>@I>@:989!?:H!<;II@G9!>7E>!JI@A:?8!978F>8I CI@=! C:I89!EB?!?89:DDE>:@B!C@I!B;=8I@;9!D@==8B9EF9!9;D7!E9!>78!2F@I:?E!=@;98!\G7:D7! =EL!J@>8B>:EFFL!@DD;I!G:>7:B!W8I:D!7E<:>E>9!EF@BH!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!D@II:?@I]O! 8E9>8IB!?:E=@B?>F89BET8O!8E9>8IB!:B?:H@!9BET8O!EB?!H@J78I!CI@HX!\PQRR^Pd]M! "78!9DI;<< L!CFE>G@@?9!EB?!@ET!9DI;@F8IEBD8!@C!7EI97! D@B?:>:@B9!EB>9X!<8DE;98!@C!:>9!W8I:D!D7EIED>8I!\PQRR^Rc]M!+:T8!>78! ?IL!JIE:I:8O!>78!CFE>G@@?9!EB?!9DI;@!<;II@G:BH!CE;BE!EB?!>78:I! D@==8B9EF9!E9!G8FF!E9!>78!>7I8E >8B8?!2F@I:?E!9DI;
PAGE 161

! RdR "78!3(3..!JI@A:?89!E!H8B8IEF!F:9>!@C!CE;BE!D@B>E:B8?!G:>7:B!>78!CI897GE>8I! G8>FEB?9O!G7:D7!>78L!9>E>8!>7E>!>78!VG8>FEB?9!JI@A:?8!>78!=@9>!?:A8I98!9L9>8=9! G:>7:B!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!D@II:?@IO!E9!>78L!D@B>I:<;>8!>@!>78!9;IA:AEF!@C!<@>7! D7EIED>8I:9>:D!G8>FEB?!9J8D:89!E9!G8FF!E9!7E<:>E>!H8B8IEF:9>9X!\RccQ^P 5 kf]M!"78! G8>FEB?9!D@B9:9>!@C!>78!C@FF@G:BH^!V48>FEB?9!:BDF;?8!7L?I:D!7E==@DTO!<@>>@=FEB?! C@I89>O!G8>!JIE:I:8O!CF@@?JFE:B!=EI97O!8I!9>I8E=O!=EBHI@A8!9GE=JO!EB?! 9EF>GE>8I!=EI97X!\ PQRR^Re]M!"78!CE;BE!:BDF;?8!V2:97O!>@E?9!EB?!CI@H9O!E=J7:<:EB9O! 9EFE=EB?8I9O!EFF:HE>@I9O!EK;E>:D!>;I>F89!EB?!9BET89O!489>!)B?:EB!=EBE>88O!EB?!<:I?9! 9;D7!E9!F@@B9O!HI8<89O!?;DTO!J8F:DEB9O!78I@B9O!8HI8>9O!:<:989O!EB?!@9JI8L9MX!\RccQ^P 5 kf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c >7 D8B>;IL!EB?!D@B>:B;:BH!>@!>78!JI898B>!7E9!DI8E>8?!E!B8G!7 E<:>E>O!G7:D7! CEA@I9!9J8D:89!>7E>!8E9:FL!E?EJ>M!-@=8!@C!>7898!9J8D:89!:BDF;?8!VF@HH8I78E?!97I:T8O! IEDD@@BO!EIF:BHO!DE>>F8!8HI8>O!3;9D@AL!?;DTO!I@DT!?@A8O!7@;98! 9JEII@G!EB?!B@I>78IB!=@DT:BH<:I?X!\PQRR^PP]M!&@=89>:DE>8?!EB?!C8IEF!EB:=EF9 EF9@!

PAGE 162

! RdP JI898B>!B8G!9>IE:B9!@B!>78!GE>8I978?!EB?!>7898!:BDF;?8!>78!CE=@;9!3LETTE!DE>>F8O! C8IEF!J:H9O!VDE>9O!?@H9O!7@I989O!F:BH!?;DTO!=;9D@AL!?;DT9O!I88CI@H9O!%:F8!J8ID7O!GEFT:BH!DE>C:97O!EB?!-@;>7!,=8I:DEB!EI=@I8?! DE>C :97MX!\PQRR^Pk]M ,!FEIH8!E=@;B>!@C!>78!CE;BE!@C!>78!I8H:@BO!?;8!>@!PQ >7 D8B>;IL!?8A8F@J=8B>O!:9! @B!AEI:@;9!>7I8E>8B8?!F:9>9M!"78I8!EI8!>8B!?:CC8I8B>!9J8D:89!@C!E=J7:<:EB!EB?!I8J>:F8O! G7:D7!;98!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IU9!GE>8I978?!\PQRR^Pk]M!"7898!:BDF;?8!>78!C:A8! 98E!>;I>F8! 9J8D:89!+@HH8I78E?O!#EGT9<:FFO!*I88BO!+8E>78I>8!#EI<@Ig!>78!,=8I:DEB!EFF:HE>@Ig!>78!$E9>8IB!:B?:H@!9BET8g!EB?!H@J78I! >@I>@:989M!%@>!@BFL!EI8!I8J>:F89!EB?!E=J7:<:EB9!>7I8E>8B8?!<;>!8:H7>!9J8D:89!@C! =E==EF! EI8!EF9@!>7I8E>8B8?M!"78L!:BDF;?8!>78!g!I:A8I! @>>8Ig!489>!)B?:EB!=EBE>88g!I@;B? 5 >E:F8?!=;9TIE>9g!2F@I:?E!=@;98!2F@I:?E!=:BTg! 2F@I:?E!F@BH 5 >E:F8?!G8E98Fg!EB?!2F@I:?E!/EB>78IM!,9!@C!RccQO!:>!GE9!B@>!TB@GB! G78>78I!>78!/EB>78I!9>:FF!DE FF8?!>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!I8H:@B!7@=8!\3(3..!RccQ^P 5 ke 5 dQ]M!#@G8A8IO!7!E!J8I9@BEF!8BD@;B>8I!:B!SEB;EIL!@C!PQRQ!B8EI!>78! +@G8I!+ET8!>7E>!>78!E;>7@I!7E?!E9!G8FF!E9!E!D@BA8I9E>:@B!7E?!G:>7!-EIE9@>E!.@;B>L! EID7E8@F@H:9>!S@?:!/IED7>!\PQRQ!J8I9@BEF!D@==; B:DE>:@B]O!2F@I:?E!/EB>78I9!7EA8! I8>;IB8?!>@!>78!3LETTE!GE>8I978?M! ,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!3(3..O!V'J!>@!hc!F:9>8?!<:I?9!EI8!?:I8D>FL!?8J8B?8B>!@B!:>9! o>78!3LETTE!(:A8I!GE>8I978?p!7E<:>E>9!C@I!9;IA:AEFM!,>!F8E9>!RP!=:W8?!@I!9:BHF8 5 9J8D:89!GE?:BH!<:I?!D@F@B:89!7E A8!<88B!89>E78!3LETTE!(:A8I!D@II:?@I! \24.O!PQQc]X!\3(3..!PQRR^Pi]M!+@DEF!GE?:BH!<:I?9!:BDF;?8!>78!C@FF@G:BH^ %E>:A8!GE?:BH!<:I?9!:BDF;?:BH!>78!F:>>F8!I:D@F@I8?!78I@BO! I8??:97!8HI8>O!9B@GL!8HI8>O!!78I@BO!L8FF@G 5

PAGE 163

! Rdh DI @GB8?!B:H7>!78I@BO!HI88B!78I@BO!G7:>8!:<:9O!G@@?!9>@ITO!F:=JT:B! EB?!I@98E>8!9J@@B<:FF!EI8!EFF!F:9>8?!G:>7:B!>78!9>E>8!@C!2F@I:?E!?;8!>@! >78!JI8D:J:>@;9!F@99!@C!G8>FEB?!7E<:>E>!:B!2F@I:?EM \PQRR^Pi]M "78!=;?!EB?!>:?EF!CFE>9!@C!>78!GE>8I978?!78FJ!9;JJ@I>! C@GF!9;D7!E9!>78!,=8I:DEB! @L9>8IDE>D78IO!,=8I:DEB!EA@D8>O!J:J:BH!JF@A8IO!EB?!9@;>78E9>8IB!9B@GL!JF@A8I!E9! G8FF!E9!D@E9>EF!C@GF!9;D7!E9!H;FF9!EB?!>8IB9O!9;D7!E9!I@LEF!>8IBO!9EB?G:D7!>8IBO! I@98E>8!>8IBO!F8E9>!>8IBO!EB?!.E9J:EB!>8IBO!E9!G8FF!E9!@>78I!D@E9>EF! C@GF!9;D7!E9!>78! !CI:HE>8<:I?M!6@>7!>78!J:J:BH!JF@A8I! EB?!>78!I@LEF!>8IB!EI8!F:9>8?!E9!>7I8E>8B8?!9J8D:89!\PQRR^Pe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t9!7EGTO! 97EIJ97:BB8?!7EGTO!I8? 5 >E:F8?!7EGTO!I8? 5 97@;F?8I!7EGTO!78IB!7EII:8IO!@9JI8LO!EB?!DI89>8?!DEIEDEIEMX!\PQRR^Pe]M!"78!J:B8FEB?9!@C!>78! GE>8I978?!JI@A:?8!H@@?!7E<:>E>!C@I!G@@?J8DT8I9!:BDF;?8!>78!9@;>78IB!7E:IL! G@@?J8DT8I!EB?!I8? 5 D@DTE?8?!G@@?J8DT8I!\PQRR^Pe]M ,K;E>:D!CE;BE!9;D7!E9!C:97!EB?!CI897GE>8I!<8B>7:D!:BA8I>889!J@J;FE>8!>78! I:A8I!EB?!:>9!>I:<;>EI:89M!68B>7:D!:BA8I>889!:BDF;?8!=@FF;9T9O!CI897GE>8I! =;998F9O!>78!8W@>:D!,9:E>:D!DFE=O!IEBH:E!DFE=9O!@F:A8!B8I:>8!9BE:F9O! EB?!
PAGE 164

! Rdk ,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!3(3..O!V2@I>L 5 C@;I!9J8D:89!@C!CI897GE>8I!C:97!7EA8!<88B!I8D@I?8?! CI@=!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IX!\PQRR^hR]M!,=@BH!>7898!9J8D:89!:BDF;?8!FEIH8!E=@;B>9!@C! 9;BC:9789O!>@J!=:BB@G9O!E9!G8FF!E9!C@;I!?:CC8I8B>!9J8D:89!@C!97:B8I9O!:BDF;?:BH >78! 9E:FC:B!97:B8IM!,DD@I?:BH!>@!>78!3(3..O!V"7898!C:9789!EI8!H8B8IEFFL!E99@D:E>8?!G:>7! CF@G:BH!DF8EI!7:H7 5 K;EF:>L!GE>8IX!\PQRR^hR]M!3EI:B8!C:9789!EF9@!@DD;I!G:>7:B!>78! I:A8IO!EB?!=@9>!:B>8I89>:BHFL!:B!>78!'JJ8I!EB?!>78!+@G8I!3LETTE!+ET89M!"78L! :BDF;?8^!V >EIJ@BO!9B@@TO!9J@>C:B!=@ZEIIEO!9>I:J8?!=;FF8>O!EB?!7@HD7@T8IjoE9!G8FF!E9p! DE>E?I@=@;9!,=8I:DEB!88FX!\RccQ^P 5 df]M!)>!:9!:=J@I>EB>!>@!B@>8!>7E>!V-J8D:89! I:D7B899!H8B8IEFFL!:BDI8E98?!:B!E!?@GB9>I8E=!?:I8D>:@BXO!89J8D:EFFL!:B!>78!F@G8I! 3LETTE!(:A8IO!G7:D7!I89 8=7EB!E!I:A8I!=@;>7!\PQRR^hP]M

PAGE 165

! Rdd "TT65V3b!)C!+>:V>5!'3DD6Yd;! $ ,)/D".%(%7>$%&$1D.$'(%)*+"$P3(&$8%"01 ]JRMR^:46! (I6:!V6;W:3G6;!B;!;3C3DB:!35!BTT6B:B5W6!7>!7A6!#AB77BA>>WA66!c:I;A6V!Z6;;6D!H>I5V!B7!7A6! ,YB__BAB7WA66!,>I5V!.376< ! !

PAGE 166

! Rdf "TT65V3b!1! 8 c3GD3>4:BTAY ,;9>:BO!(@<8I>!SM PQQP!.;F>;IEF!(89@;ID8!,99899=8B>!-;IA8L!@C!>7 8!3LETTE7E>D788!.I88T! $BA:I@B=8B>EF!/EIT!/7E98!))!(89>@IE>:@B!/I@Z8D>O!-EIE9@>E!.@;B>LO!2F@I:?EM!4@IT! 9;<=:>>8?!C@I!J;:@B!PQQPO!2F@I:?E!->E>8!#:9>@I:D!/I898IAE>:@B!0CC:D8M 6EIE=O!'N:! PQQe s,!#EA8B!CI@=!-FEA8IL!@B!2F@I:?Et9!*;FC!.@E9>^!+@@T:BH!C@I!$ A:?8BD8!@C! ,BH@FE!@B!>78!3EBE>88!(:A8Is C5#(,"/2V(")+3#"2C#,*"$363.12X$%03#=2 X$0)6$%%$# 2 S;B8!PQQeM!,AE:FE 7>>J^uuGGGM?:E9J@IEM;:;DM8?;uB8G9QfQeuB8G9QfQeM7>=F M PQRP .@9=@J @F:>EB!38EB:BH9!@C!0F?!-JEB:97!2:8F?9^!#:9>@I:DEF!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!E! 3EI@@B!.@==;B:>L!:B!-@;>7G89>!2F@I:?EM !()%3#(,"62C#,*"$363.1 kf\R]^RQe 5 RPPM 6EI>IE=O!4:FF:E= RicR! "IEA8F9!"7I@;H7!%@I>7!EB?!-@;>7!.EI@F:BE \ *8@IH:EO!$E9>!EB?!489>!2F@I:?EO! >78!.78I@T88! .@;B>ILO!>78!$W>8B9:A8!"8II:>@I:89!@C!>78!3;9D@H;FH89!0I!.I88T! .@BC8?8IEDLO!EB?!>78!.@;B>IL!@C!>78!.7ED>EG9 M!SE=89!EB?!S@7B9@B^!/7:FE?8FJ7:E 68EI?O!+@IBEO!S8IIL!#:FF:EI?O!EB?!*F8B!,TI:?H8 PQQQ!#:9>@I:DEF!EB?!.78=:DEF!"IED89!@C!EB!0NEIT!.8=8>8IL!C@I!$B9FE A8?!,CI:DEB 5 ,=8I:DEB9^!,!->;?L!@C!-:F7@;8>>8!6;I:EF9!:B!68B>@B!.@;B>LO!,ITEB9E9M!)B! X3#%*2 C4$#(,"/2C#,*"$363.()% PR\k]^hPh 5 hkcM 68FT@O!4:FF:E=!-M PQRR!$J:F@H;8!>@!>78!4EI!@C!ReRP^!"78!3@BI@8!,?=:B:9>IE>:@BO!,=8I:DEB! ,BHF@J7@<:EO!EB?!>78!2:I9>!-8=:B@F8!4E IM )B! C4$#(,"A)2!-/9#$92f$"#)A2P"#O2N;8;2 QR+"/)(3/2%32%*$2B-652<3")%2"/92%*$2:"%$2352%*$28$4(/36$@2Dgh\ ^ DE]E; !! $?M!4:FF:E=!-M! 68FT@M!'B:A8I9:>L!/I899!@C!2F@I:?E^!*E:B89A:FF8M 6:ID7C:8F?O!&M!+M PQQh!-8=:B@F8M!*EI8>7!->8A8B9!/;A:FF8O!%1M 6F@D7O!+88 PQRR!,B!,B>7I@J@F@HL!@C!(8=8=<8I:BH^!z;88I!"78@ILO!.@FFE<@IE>:A8! ,ID7E8@F@HLO!EB?!>78!,JEFED788!/E9>M!6M!,M!>789:9M!&:A:9:@B!@C!-@D:EF!-D:8BD89O!%8G! .@FF8H8!@C!2F@I:?EM 6I:B>@BO!&EB:8F!*M Redc!%@>89!@B!>78!2F@I:?:EB!/8B:B9;FEO!:>9!+:>8IEIL!# :9>@ILO!)B?:EB!"I:<89!EB?! ,B>:K;:>:89M!S@98J7!-E<:B^!/7:FE?8FJ7:EM .EB@AEO!,B?I8G!/M RcQf!+:C8!EB?!,?A8B>;I89!:B!-@;>7!2F@I:?EM!"I:<;B8!/I:B>:BH!.@M^!"E=JEM

PAGE 167

! Rdi .E>>8F:B@O!S899:DE!(M PQQe!#:H7!->ET89^!2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F8!*E=:BH!EB?!-@A8I8:HB>LM!&;I7E=^!&;T8!!! 'B:A8I9:>L!/I899M .FEA:BO!3E>>78G PQRR!V)>!:9!E!B8HI@O!B@>!EB!)B?:EB!GEIX^!-@;>7E=J>@BO!->M!&@=:BH@O!EB?!>78!-8D@B?! -8=:B@F8!4EIM! )B! C4$#(,"A)2!-/9#$92f$"#)A2P"#O2N;8;2QR+"/)(3/2%32%*$2B-652<3")%2 "/92%*$2:"%$2352%*$28$4(/36$@2Dgh\ ^ DE]E; !! $?M!4:FF:E=!-M!6 8FT@M!'B:A8I9:>L!/I899!@C! 2F@I:?E^!*E:B89A:FF8M .FE;98BO!.EIF!SMO!#M!YM!6I@@T9O!EB?!,F!6M!489@F@G9TL Rcid!"78!$EIFL!3EB!-:>8!E>!4EI=!3:B8IEF!-JI:BH9O!2F@I:?EM!S@;IBEF!@C!2:8F?! ,ID7E8@F@HL!P\h]^!RcR 5 PRhM .@ILO!.7EIF89!6M Recf!#;B>:BH!EB?!C:97:BH!:B! 2F@I:?EM!$9>89!€!+E;I:E>^!6@9>@BM .@A:BH>@BO!SE=89!4M Rcff!,B!$J:9@?8!:B!>78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EIM!)B! 7*$2:63#(9"2!()%3#(,"62i-"#%$#61 kd\R]^kd 5 dcM RciP! 28?8IEF!,B?!->E>8!(8FE>:@B9 4:>7!"78!2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F89 Reid 5 RcQR M!)B! 7$K-$)%" hP^Ri 5 PiM RccQ!6:FFL!6@GF8 H9O!-E=!S@B89O!EB?!>78!.I:9:9!@C!RekcM!)B! 7*$2:63#(9"2!()%3#(,"62 i-"#%$#61 fe\h]^Pcc 5 hRR Rcch!"78!-8=:B@F89!@C!2F@I:?EM!*E:B89A:FF8^!'B:A8I9:>L!/I899!@C!2F@I:?EM!! .IEB8O!b8IB8I!4M RcRe "78!0I:H:B!@C!>78!%E=8!@C!>78!.I88T!)B?:EB9 M!)B! 7*$2'())())(++(2W"66 $12 !()%3#(,"62U$F($0 d\h]^hhc 5 hkPM .I;:T97EBTO!S;F:8M PQQd!&@!*FED:8I9!+:9>8B_!!'6.!/I899O!bEBD@;A8IO!6.M .LJI899O!6:FFL!+M Rcci!"78!(@F8!@C!,ID7E8@F@HL!:B!>78!-8=:B@F8!"I:<8!@C!2F@I:?EM! >/ %E>:A8! ,=8I:DEB9!EB?!,ID7E8@F@H:9>9^!->8JJ:BH!->@B89!>@!.@==@B!*I@;B?M!%:BE!-G:?F8IO! Y;I>!$M!&@BH@9T8O!(@H8I!,BL@BO!EB?!,FFEB!-M!&@GB8IO!8?9M!/JM!Rdf 5 RfQM!4EFB;>! .I88T^!,F>E3:IE!/I899M &88>NO!SE=89 Rccf! )B!-=EFF!"7:BH9!2@IH@>>8B^!,B!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!$EIFL ,=8I:DEB!+:C8 M!%8G! 1@IT^!,BD7@I!6@@T9M &8B7E=O!SE=89!3M

PAGE 168

! Rde RccR! s-@=8!/I8C8I!>78!-8=:B@F89s^!b:@F8BD8!EB?!&:9@I?8I!E=@BH!-@F?:8I9!EB?! -8>>F8I9!:B!>78!-8D@B? -8=:B@F8!4EIO!Rehd 5 RekP M!)B! 7*$2:63#(9"2!()%3#(,"62 i-"#%$#612 iQ\R]^he 5 dkM &:DT8B9O!SIMO!(@L!-M!EB? SE=89!#M!.7EJ=EB Rcie!.8IE=:D!/E>>8IB:BH!EB?!-@D:EF!->I;D>;I8!E>!"G@!+E>8!#:9>@I:D!.I88T!-:>89!:B! ,FE@IL!C@I!1@;BH!2@FT9M!#EIJ8I!€!6I@>78I9^!%8G!1@ITM &;T8O!-8L=@;I!(M Rehe!09 D8@FEg!@IO!2ED>!EB?!2:D>:@BO!,!"EF8!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8!4EIM!#EIJ8I!€!6I@>78I9^! %8G!1@ITM $>7I:?H8O!(@<<:8 PQQh!.I88T!.@;B>IL^!"78!.I88T!)B?:EB9!EB?!>78:I!4@IF?M!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!%@I>7! .EI@F:BE!/I899^!.7EJ8F!#:FFM 2E:I7B@ 5 ,ID7E8@F @HL!@C!>78!2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F8M!)B! 7",",*"6$O2Q))"1)23/2%*$2 >/9("/)2352:63#(9"2"/9283-%*$")%2B$3#.("29-#(/.2%*$2!()%3#(,2M$#(39 M!S8IEF?!"M! 3:FEB:D7!EB?!-E=;8F!/I@D>@IO!8?9M!/JM!Rfh 5 RchM!'B:A8I9:>L!/I899!@C!2F@I:?E^! *E:B89A:FF8M 2F@I:?E!&8JEI>=8B>!@C!$BA:I@B= 8B>EF!/I@>8D>:@B PQQi!/8ED8!(:A8I!6E9:B!(89@;ID8!3EBEH8=8B>!/FEBM PQRR!6EDTHI@;B?!)BC@I=E>:@B!"78!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@I!$9>;EILM!$F8D>I@B:D! ?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uuGGGMD7B8JMGE>8IE>FE9M;9CM8?;u;JF@E?u?@D;=8B>9u$9>;EIL->;?L.;II:D;F; =*;:?8l#EI?88MJ?C O!FE9>!EDD8998?!duRPuRPM 2F@I:?E!&8JEI>=8B>!@C!3:F:>EIL!,CCE:I9 PQRP!"78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EIO!Rehd 5 RekPM!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uu?=EM=LCF@I:?EMD@=u_JEH8l:?…kPR O!FE9>!EDD8998?!duRPuRPM 2F@I:?E!0;>?@@I9 PQRP!/8ED8!(:A8IM!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uuGGGMCF@I:?E 5 @ ;>?@@I9MD@=uJ8ED8lI:A8IM7>= O!FE9>!EDD8998?!kueuRP *E>9D78>O!,F<8I>!-M Reek!,!3:HIE>:@B!+8H8B?!@C!>78!.I88T!)B?:EB9M!&M!*M!6I:B>@B^!/7:FE?8FJ7:EM #EB?9=EBO!(;998FF!*M!EB?!"I;?:8!+E=:BH!.@F@B:EF:9=^!"78!3E7:DEB!EB?!-D7EH7>:D@T8!/8 @JF89!EB?!'9M!)B! '"=(/.2C6%$#/"%(F$2!()%3#($)O2 7*$2M#",%(,$2352C#,*"$363.12"/92!()%3#12(/2X3/ ^

PAGE 169

! Rdc P$)%$#/28$%%(/.) M!/8>8I!(!M-D7=:?>!EB?!"7@=E9!.M!/E>>89@BO!8?9M!-EB>8!28^!-,(! /I899O!/JM!ei 5 RRiM #8B97EFFO!SE=89!,M Reek!.E=J:BH!EB?!.I;:9:BH!:B!2F@I:?EM!(@<8I> .FEIT8!€!.@M^!.:BD:BBE>:M #:FFO!S@BE>7EB!&M Rccf!)B>I@?;D>:@B^!$>7B@H8B89:9!:B!>78!,=8I:DE9O!RkcP 5 RccPM!)B! !()%3#1@2M30$#@2 "/92>9$/%(%1O2Q%*/3.$/$)()2(/2%*$2C4$#(,")@2D_j[ ^ Djj[ M!S@BE>7EB!&M!#:FFO!8?M! 'B:A8I9:>L!@C!)@GE!/I899^!)@GE!.:>LM #:9>@IL3:E=: P QRR!z;89>:@B!@C!>78!488TM!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uuGGGM7:9>@IL=:E=:M@IHuI898EID7 5 =:E=:u=ET8 5 =:E=: 5 7:9>@IL 5 B@GuK;89>:@B 5 @C 5 >78 5 G88T u?8>E:F9uPQRR 5 QP 5 Peu O!FE9>!EDD8998?!duRQuRPM S8BT:B9O!.7I:9!.M PQQc!,7 5 "E7 5 "7: 5 Y:!68D@=89!2:I9>!"I:8?!3;98;=M!"78! -8=:B@F8!"I:<;B8O!,JI:F!Pk^!R,O!P,M S89;JO!"7@=E9 Rehc!oRehfp!+8>>8I!CI@=!*8B8IEF!S89;J!>@!>78!-8DI8>EIL!@C!4EIO!?E>8?!&8D8=<8I!cO! RehfM!)B! 7*$2<3/.#$))(3/"62B63?$@2,3/%"(/(/.28=$%,*$)2352%*$2V$?"%$)2"/92 M#3,$$9(/.)2352%*$270$/%1 ^ :(5%*2<3/.#$))@27*(#928$))(3/ k W36-4$2W>> M!2IEBD:9!/M! 6FE:I!EB?!S@7B!.M!(:A89 O!8?9M!*F@<8!0CC:D8^!4E97:BH>@BM S@B89O! -:nB Rcci!"78!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!$>7B:D:>L^!.@B9>I;D>:BH!:?8B>:>:89!:B!>78!JE9>!EB?!JI898B>M! (@;>F8?H8^!+@B?@BM Y8I98LO!SIMO!#EIIL!,M Rcih /8F>9O!/F;=89O!EB?!#:?89^!47:>8!"IE?8I9!E=@BH!>78!-8=:B@F8!)B?:EB9O!RecQ 5 RchQ M!)B! 7*$2:63#(9"2!()%3#(,"62i-"#%$#61 dR\h]^PdQ 5 PffM Rcik!"78!-8=:B@F8!V'JI:9:BHX!@C!RcQiM! 7*$2:63#(9"2C/%*#3+363.()% Pi\P]^!kc 5 deM RceR!2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F89!EB?!>78!.8B9;9!@C!RcQQM!)B! 7*$2:63#(9"2!()%3#(,"62i-"#%$#612 fQ\P]^Rkd 5 RfQM Rcei!"78!-8=:B@F8!EB?! 3:DD@9;T88!"I:<89^!,!.I:>:DEF!6:@B^! )B?:EBE!'B:A8I9:>L!/I899M Y:JC8IO!6EIU9!2:8F?G@IT!.@=JEB:@BM!3EF?8BO!3,O!6FEDTG8FF! /;?M YB8>9D7O!S@8 PQQh!2F@I:?EU9!-8=:B@F8!4EI9!ReRi 5 RedeM!,IDE?:E!/;< F:97:BH^!.7:DEH@M

PAGE 170

! RfQ PQRR!->IE>8HLM!0J8IE>:@B9O!EB?!"ED>:D9!:B!>78!-8D@B?!-8=:B@F8!4EIO!Rehd 5 RekPM!)B! C4$#(,"A)2!-/9#$92f$"#)A2P"#O2N;8;2QR+"/)(3/2%32%*$2B-652<3")%2"/92%*$2:"%$2352%*$2 8$4(/36$@2Dgh\ ^ DE]E; !! $?M!4:FF:E=!-M!68FT@M!'B:A8I9:>L!/I899!@C!2F@I:?E^! *E:B89A:FF8M +8@B8O!3EIT PQQd!"78!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!+:<8I>L!:B!EB!,=8I:DEB!.EJ:>EF^!$WDEAE>:@B9!:B!,BBEJ@F:9M! 68IT8F8L^!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!.EF:C@IB:E!/I899M +:>>F8O!6EI@I:DEF!,ID7E8@F@HL^!47L!>78!/E9>!3E>>8I9M!4EFB;>!.I88TO!.EF:C@IB:E^!+8C>! .@E9>!/I899O!)BDM +;8IO!*8@IH8O!3EI:@B!,F=LO!&EBE!->8M!.FE:I8O!EB?!(@<8I>!,;9>:B "78!3LETTE7E>D788!-:>8!\e-0hci]O!,!+EIH8!3;F>: 5 /8I:@?!)BFEB?!2I@=!>78!-7@I8! -:>8!:B!-EIE9@>E!.@;B>LO!2F@I:?EM!"78!2F@I:?E!EB>7I@J@F@H:9>!kQ\P]^!Rhi 5 RdhM +;8IO!*8@IH8O!8?M PQQP!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!'JJ8I!.7EIF@>>8!#EI<@IO!2F@I:?EM!2F@I:?E!,B>7I@J@F@H:DEF! -@D:8>L!/;:@BO!RdM!"EFFE7E9988^!2F@I:?E!,B>7I@J@F@H:DEF!-@D:8>LO!)BDM 3EI>7O!&8F!EB?!3EI>L!3EI>7 RccQ!"78!(:A8I9!@C!2F@I:?EM!/:B8EJJF8!/I899^!-EIE9@>EM 3E>>78G9O!SEB8>!-B L?8I Rceh!$?H8!@C!4:F?8IB899^!,!-8>>F8=8B>!#:9>@IL!@C!3EBE>88!(:A8I!EB?!-EIE9@>E!6EL! RdPe 5 ReedM!";F9EO!.EJI:B8!/I899 3D.EI>7LO!S@7B!2M!EB?!*F8BE!3M!&E=8 Rceh!,!#:9>@IL!@C!>78!3LETTE!(:A8IM!-EIE9@>E!.@;B>L!#:9>@I:DEF!,ID7:A89O!-EIE9@>EO! 2+M! 3D$GEBO!6@B B:8!*M RccR!-EB!+;:9!?8!"EF:=EF:^!"78!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!-JEB:97 5 )B?:EB!(8FE>:@B9!E>!E! 2F@I:?E!3:99:@BM!)B! !()%3#(,"62C#,*"$363.1 Pd\h]^hf 5 fQM 3:DD@9;T88!"I:<8!@C!)B?:EB9!@C!2F@I:?E PQRP!#:9>@ILM!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uuGGGM=:DD@9;T88MD@=u>I:<8 O!EDD8998?! duRkuRPM 3:FF8>O!%E>7EB:8F PQQi!&8C:B:BH!2I88?@=!:B!>78!,>FEB>:D!6@I?8IFEB?9!@C!>78!(8A@F;>:@BEIL! -@;>78E9>M!)B! Q"#612C4$#(,"/28%-9($) d\P]^hfi 5 hckM 3:FI@LO!+89F8L!EB?!SE=89!3:FI@L RccR!-J@T8B!EB?!GI:>>8B!B@I=9M!2I@=! C-%*3#(%12(/2H"/.-".$ M!(@;>F8?H8! ^!+@B?@BM

PAGE 171

! RfR 3@@I8 5 4:FF9@BO!3:BB:8 Recf!"78!-8=:B@F89!@C!2F@I:?EM!,=8I:DEB!/I:B>:BH!#@;98^!/7:FE?8FJ7:EM 3LETTE!(:A8I!3EBEH8=8B>!.@@I?:BE>:BH!.@;BD:F RccR!3LETTE!4:F?!!EB?!-D8B:D (:A8I! 3EBEH8=8B>!/FEBO! 9#"5% M!$F8D>I@B:D! ?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uu=LETTEI:A8I=EBEH8=8B>M@IHu3(4-3/M7>=F O!EDD8998?!cufuRR PQRR!3LETTE!4:F?!EB?!-D8B:D (:A8I!3EBEH8=8B>!/FEBO! 5(/"62,3+1 M!$F8D>I@B:D! ?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uu=LETTEI:A8I=EBEH8=8B>M@IHu3(4-3/M7>=F O!EDD8998?! duRRuRPM %E<@T@AO!/8>8I Rccf!%E>:A8!b:8G9!@C!#:9>@ILM!)B! 7*$2<"4?#(9.$2!()%3#12352%*$2X"%(F$2M$3+6$)2352%*$2 C4$#(,")O2W36-4$2>@2X3#%*2C4$#(," @2M"#%2D M!$?9M!6I;D8!*M!"I:HH8I!EB?!4:FD@=L!/I899^!.E=:@BEF!EDDI8?:>E>:@BM!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uuGGGMBEJF89B8G9MD@=uB8G9uPQQcuEJIuQcu98=:B@F8 5 >I:<8 5 =;98;= 5 8EIB9 5 BE>:@BEF 5 EDDI8?:>E>:@Bu O!EDD8998?!kueuPQRPM 0I98IO!.7EIF89!$M PQQi!"78!,I D7E8@F@HL!@C!(ED8!EB?!(ED:EF:NE>:@B!:B!#:9>@I:D!,=8I:DEM!'B:A8I9:>L! /I899!@C!2F@I:?E^!*E:B89A:FF8M /@I>8IO!Y8BB8>7!4M! RcdP!"78!.@GT88J8I!&LBE9>L!@C!>78!-8=:B@F8!%E>:@BM!)B! 7*$2:63#(9"2!()%3#(,"62 i-"#%$#61 hQ\k]^hkR 5 hkcM Rcfk!%8HI@89!EB?!>78!-8=:B@F8!4E IO!Rehd 5 RekPM!)B! 7*$2d3-#/"6235283-%*$#/2 !()%3#1 hQ\k]^kPi 5 kdQM /I89:?8B>!`ED7EIL!"ELF@I Rekc!3899EH8!CI@=!>78!/I89:?8B>!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89!>@!>78!"G@!#@;989!@C! .@BHI899!E>!>78!.@==8BD8=8B>!@C!>78!2:I9>!-899:@B!@C!>78!"7:I>L 5 2:I9>!.@BHI899M! 47:>8!#@;98 ^!4E97:BH>@B!&M.MO!'B:>8?!->E>89!.@BHI899M (EBH8FO!(@?I:H@ Rcch!,DD@;B>!@C!>78!%@I>78IB!.@BK;89>!EB?!&:9D@A8IL!@C!#8IBEB?@!?8!-@>@M!S@7B! $M!4@I>7O!>IEB9M!)B! 7*$2V$283%32<*#3/(,6$)O27*$2QR+$9(%(3/2352!$#/"/9329$283%32%32 X3#%*2C4$#(,"2(/2D]\j ^ D]_\@2W36-4$2 > M!+EGI8BD8!,M!.FEL>@BO!b8IB@B!SE=89!YB:H7>! SIMO!EB?!$?GEI?!.M!3@@I8O!8?9M!/J^Pki 5 hQfM!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!,FE7!/@F:>:D9^!"78!+:C8!EB?!4I:>:BH!@C!SEB8!4@@?!(8B@M!,>FEB>E^! /8ED7>I88!/;?M

PAGE 172

! RfP (@=E B9O!68IBEI? Riif!,!.@BD:98!%E>;IEF!#:9>@IL!@C!$E9>!EB?!489> 5 2F@I:?EM!(M!,:>T8B^!%8G!1@ITM (;<8I>@B8O!/E>I:D:E!$M PQQQ!"78!#:9>@I:DEF!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!%E>:A8!,=8I:DEB9M!)B! C//-"62U$F($02352 C/%*#3+363.1 \Pc]^kPd 5 kkf -E>@O!-7:BZ:I@ PQQh! /7@9J7@I;9!9@IJ>:@B! EB?!?89@IJ>:@B!:B!E!6IEN:F:EB!;F>:9@F!^!8CC8D>9!@C!J#!EB?! @IHEB:D!EB:@B9!@B!J7@9J7@I;9!<:@EAE:FE<:F:>L M!/7M!&M!?:998I>E>:@BO!&8JEI>=8B>!@C! -@:F!EB?!4E>8I!-D:8BD8O!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!2F@I:?EM! -E>>F8IO!(:D7EI?!,M Rccf!(8=EB>9O!(8B8HE?89O!EB?!(;BEGEL9^!-8=:B@F8 $>7B@H8B89:9!(8D@B9:?8I8?M! )B! !()%3#1@2M30$#@2"/92>9$/%(%1O2Q%*/3.$/$)()2(/2%*$2C4$#(,")@2D_j[ ^ Djj[ M!S@BE>7EB! &M!#:FFO!8?M!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!)@GE!/I899^!)@GE!.:>LM -D78B8O!3:D7E8F!*M Rcii!%@>!E!-7@>!2:I8?^!2@I>!.@T@B:TFE!EB?!>78!V)B?:EB!4EIX!@C!Rekc 5 RedQM!) B 2 7$K-$)%" hi^Rc 5 hiM 2 -D@>>O!SE=89!.M PQQc!"78!,I>!@C!%@>!68:BH!*@A8IB8?^!,B!,BEID7:9>!#:9>@IL!@C!'JFEB?!-@;>78E9>! ,9:EM!1EF8!'B:A8I9:>L!/I899^!%8G!#EA8BM -8EI9O!4:FF:E=!#M Rcdd!.I88T!EB?!.78I@T88!.;F>;I8!:B!>78!Re >7 .8B>;ILM! C4$#(,"/2C/%(K-(%1 PR\P]^! Rkh 5 RkcM -8=:B@F8!%E>:@B!@C!0TFE7@=E PQRP!,<@;>!>78!-8=:B@F8!%E>:@B!@C!0TFE7@=EM!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uu9B@ 5 B9BMH@Au:B?8WMJ7JuD;F>;I8uE<@;> 5 98=:B@F8 5 BE>:@B O!EDD8998?! duRkuRPM -8=:B@F8!"I:<8!@C!2F@I:?E PQRR!#:9>@ILO!G78I8!G8!DE=8!CI@=^!)B>I@?;D>:@BM!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uuGGGM98=>I:<8MD@=u#:9>@ILu)B>I@?;D>:@BME9JW O!EDD8998?!duRkuRPM -7B:I8F=EBO!b: D>@I!,M Rccd!2I@=!:B>8IBE>:@BEF:9=!>@!BE>:@BEF:9=^!C@IH@>>8B!JEH89!@C!-@A:8>!EID7E8@F@HL! :B!>78!RchQ9!EB?!RckQ9M!)B! X"%(3/"6()4@2M36(%(,)@2"/92%*$2M#",%(,$2352C#,*"$363.1 M! $?9!/7:F:J!+M!Y@7F!EB?!.FEI8!2EGD8>>O!JJM!RPQ 5 RheM!.E=L!/I899^! .E=< I:?H8M -7@<8IO!,=L!+MO!.7I:9>:B8!4:898O!EB?!*8@CCI8L!.M!&8BBL PQRR!-@:F!J#!EB?!>78!#@=8!+EB?9DEJ8!@I!*EI?8BM!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uu8?:9M:CE9M;CFM8?;uJ?CC:F89u--u--keQQQMJ?C O!EDD8998?! kueuRPM

PAGE 173

! Rfh -:FA8:IEO!3MO!SM!b8B?IE=:B:O!SM!$M!(8D7D:HFO!EB?!3M!6M!,?Z8: PQQc!-@:F!J#!EB?!+:=:BH!)99;89!,CC8D>:BH!6E7:EHIE99!/E9>;I8M!$F8D>I@B:D! ?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uu8?:9M:CE9M;CFM8?;uJ?CC:F89u--u-dQdQQMJ?C O!EDD8998?!kueuRPM -:FF:=EBO!->8J78B!4M PQQd!.;F>;I8!.@B>ED>!@I!.@F@B:EF:9=_!.7EFF8BH89!:B!>78!,ID7E8@F@HL!@C!%E>:A8! %@I>7!,=8I:DEM!)B! C4$#(,"/2C/%(K-(%12 iQ\R]^dd 5 ikM -:==9O!4:FF:E=!*:F=@I8 Rehe!-FEA8IL!:B!,=8I:DEO!<8:BH!6I:8C!(8A:8G!@C!3:99!3 EI>:B8E;!@B!>7E>!-;M! "7@=E9!4M!47:>8^!(:D7=@B?M -=:>7O!3EIT!&M PQRQ!-EIE9@>E!*@89!2I@=!6@@=!>@!6;9>!:B!>78!RcPQ9M!$F8D>I@B:D!&@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uuGGGM9EIE9@>E7:9>@ILEF:A8MD@=u9>@I:89uZ@;IBEF9 5 @C 5 L89>8IL8EIu9EIE9@>E 5 H@89 5 CI@= 5 <@@= 5 >@ 5 <;9> 5 :B 5 >78 5 RcPQ9u O!FE9>!EDD8998?!k uduRQM! -@;>78IB!.;F>:AE>@I RefQ!"78!/8B:B9;FE!@C!2F@I:?EM!)B! 83-%*$#/2<-6%(F"%3#2 Re\R]^!Pfc 5 PiQM -@;>7G89>!2F@I:?E!4E>8I!3EBEH8=8B>!&:9>I:D> PQRQ!3LETTE!(:A8I!4E>8I978?!)B:>:E>:A8M!$F8D>I@B:D!&@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uuGGGM9GCG=?M9>E>8MCFM;9uJI@Z8D>9u=LETTEu O!FE9>!EDD8998?!huRQuRQM ->@ZEB@G9T:O!.7I:9>@J78I!3M PQQc!6I:?H:BH!#:9>@I:89^!"78!6:@EID7E8@F@HL!@C!)?8B>:>L!:B!/@9>D@B>ED>!2F@I:?EM!)B! G(3"#,*"$36 3.12"/92>9$/%(%12(/2%*$2C4$#(,");2 Y8FFL!SM!YB;?9@B!EB?!.7I:9>@J78I!3M! ->@ZEB@G9T:O!8?9M!'B:A8I9:>L!/I899!@C!2F@I:?E^!*E:B89A:FF8M ->@F>8O!3EIH8 PQQc!#:9>@IL!@C!b8B:D8O!2F@I:?EM!$F8D>I@B:D!&@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uuGGGMH;FCD@E9>F:A:BH@BF:B8MB8>uA7:9>@IL=LETTEM7>=F O!FE9>!EDD8998?!kuduRQM -GEB>@BO!S@7B!(88? RcPP!$EIFL!#:9>@IL!@C!>78!.I88T!)B?:EB9!EB?!"78:I!%8:H7<@I9M!-=:>79@B:EB! )B9>:>;>8!6;I8E;!@C!,=8I:DEB!$>7B@F@HL!ihM!'M!-M!*@A8IB=8B>!/I:B> :BH!0CC:D8^! 4E97:BH>@B!&M!.M -G:DTO!.FEI8BD8!#M RcRh!"I:EBH;FE>:@B!,F@BH!>78!489>!.@E9>!@C!2F@I:?EM!*@A8IB=8B>!/I:B>:BH!0CC:D8^! 4E97:BH>@B!&M!.M "ELF@IO!(@<8I>!,M RccR 'BC@IH@>>8B!"7I8E>^!2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F89!:B!>78!.:A:F!4EI M!)B! 7*$2:63#(9"2 !()%3#(,"62i"#%$#61 fc\h]^hQQ 5 hRkM "I:HH8IO!6I;D8!*M

PAGE 174

! Rfk RceQ!,ID7E8@F@HL!EB?!>78!)=EH8!@C!>78!,=8I:DEB!)B?:EBM!)B! C4$#(,"/2C/%(K-(%1 kd\k]^ffP 5 fifM Rcec!,!7:9>@IL!@C!EID7E8@F@H:DEF!>7@;H7>M!.E=L!/I899^!.E=8?!->E>89!.@BHI899 RedQ!$W8D;>:A8!& @D;=8B>9!JI:B>8?!78!-8BE>8!@C!>78!'B:>8?!->E>89! ?;I:BH!>78!2:I9>!-899:@B!@C!>78!"7:I>L 5 2:I9>!.@BHI899M!4=M!3M!68F>^!4E97:BH>@BM 'B:A8I9:>L!@C!3:E=: PQRP!0F?!2F@I:?E!3EJ9M!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7>>J^uu9D7@FEIMF:L!@C!-@;>7!2F@I:?E PQRP!$WJF@I:BH!2F@I:?E!3EJ9M!$F8D>I@B:D!?@D;=8B>O! 7> >J^uuCD:>M;9CM8?;uCF@I:?Eu=EJ9u O!EDD8998?!duRuRPM '978IG@@?O!$F:NE<8>7!,BB PQRR! ,!(8EBEFL9:9!@C!>78!%8HI@!2@I>!\ReRk 5 ReRf]^!,!68ED@B!@C!#@J8!@B!>78! 2F@I:?E!2I@B>:8I M!/EJ8I!JI898B>8?!E>!>78!,BB;EF!388>:BH!@C!>78!2F@I:?E! ,B>7I@J@F@H:DEF!-@D:8>LO!0IFEB?@O!3 EL!f 5 eM b@99O!6EI7B@H8B89:9^!IED8!EB?!98W;EF:>L!:B!D@F@B:EF!-EB! 2IEBD:9D@M!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!.EF:C@IB:E!/I899^!68IT8F8LM 4EFFED8O!2I8?!4M RcfP!"78!->@IL!@C!.EJ>E:B!S@7B!.M!.E98LM!)B! 7*$2:63#(9"2!()%3#(,"62i-"#%$#612 kR\P]^R Pi 5 RkkM 4E>T:B9O!S@8 PQRQ!68D@=:BH!0B8!@C!V"78=X!M!M!M!M)B! ?$(/.2"/92?$,34(/.2(/9(.$/3-)2"#,*"$363.()% M! $?M!*8@IH8!%:D7@FE9M!+8C>D@E9>!/I899O!)BDM^!4EFB;>!.I88TO!.EF:C@IB:EM 48:9=EBO!6I8B>!(M Rcec!+:T8!68E?9!@B!E!->I:BH^!,!.;F>;I8!#:9>@IL!@C!>78! -8=:B@F8!)B?:EB9!:B! %@I>78IB!/8B:B9;FEI!2F@I:?EM!"78!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!,FEL! /I899!@C!2F@I:?E^!*E:B89A:FF8M PQQi!%E>:A:9=O!(89:9>EBD8O!EB?!$>7B@H8B89:9!@C!>78! 2F@I:?E!-8=:B@F8!)B?:EB! )?8B>:>LM! !()%3#(,"62C#,*"$363.1 kR\k]^!Rce 5 PRPM 4:DT=EBO!/E>I:DE!(M Rced! s,!"I:CF:BH!,CCE:I^s!+@@=:9!+L=EB!+EBH?@B!EB?!>78!"7:I?!-8=:B@F8!4EI M!)B! 7*$2:63#(9"2!()%3#(,"62i-"#%$#612 fh\h]^hQh 5 hRi PQQf! 09D8@FEU9!+8HEDL M!"78!'B:A8I9: >L!@C!,FE
PAGE 175

! Rfd Rehi!"8II:>@IL!@C!2F@I:?E^!@I!-T8>D789!@C!>78!"@JHIEJ7LO!.:A:F!EB?!%E>;IEF!#:9>@ILO! @C!>78!.@;B>ILO!>78!.F:=E>8O!EB?!>78!)B?:EB!"I:<89O!CI@=!>78!2:I9>!&:9D@A8IL!>@!>78! /I898B>!":=8O!G:>7!E!=EJO!A:8G9O!€ DM!,M!"M!*@@?I:D7^!%8G!1@ITM 4@FCO!$I:D RcciM!$;I@J8!EB?!>78!/8@JF8!4:>7@;>!#:9>@ILM!'B:A8I9:>L!@C!.EF:C@IB:E!/I899^!+@9! ,BH8F89M!


ERROR LOADING HTML FROM SOURCE (http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu//design/skins/UFDC/html/footer_item.html)