ERROR LOADING HTML FROM SOURCE (http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu//design/skins/UFDC/html/header_item.html)

Athenian Leadership in Thucydides

Permanent Link: http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu/NCFE004481/00001

Material Information

Title: Athenian Leadership in Thucydides "History of the Peloponnesian War"
Physical Description: Book
Language: English
Creator: Buckingham, William
Publisher: New College of Florida
Place of Publication: Sarasota, Fla.
Creation Date: 2011
Publication Date: 2011

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords: Classics
Thucydides
Ancient Greece
Genre: bibliography   ( marcgt )
theses   ( marcgt )
government publication (state, provincial, terriorial, dependent)   ( marcgt )
born-digital   ( sobekcm )
Electronic Thesis or Dissertation

Notes

Abstract: In this thesis, I explore the arc of Athenian leadership in Thucydides� History of the Peloponnesian War. To achieve this goal, I rely on Thucydides� narrative technique of interrelating speech and narrative throughout his work. I examine closely the speeches of the characters themselves, their interaction with Thucydides� narrative, and their interaction with each other. I apply this method to the speeches of the four main Athenian generals in the history: Pericles, Cleon, Nicias, and Alcibiades. My analysis reveals the connection that Thucydides establishes between each of the leaders, and infers the judgments that Thucydides leads us to make through his narrative technique. The result is a complete portrait of Athenian leadership, in which Pericles represents optimal leadership, Cleon represents the beginning of its decline, and Nicias and Alcibiades represent its ultimate, complete failure.
Statement of Responsibility: by William Buckingham
Thesis: Thesis (B.A.) -- New College of Florida, 2011
Electronic Access: RESTRICTED TO NCF STUDENTS, STAFF, FACULTY, AND ON-CAMPUS USE
Bibliography: Includes bibliographical references.
Source of Description: This bibliographic record is available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication. The New College of Florida, as creator of this bibliographic record, has waived all rights to it worldwide under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights, to the extent allowed by law.
Local: Faculty Sponsor: Shaw, Carl

Record Information

Source Institution: New College of Florida
Holding Location: New College of Florida
Rights Management: Applicable rights reserved.
Classification: local - S.T. 2011 B92
System ID: NCFE004481:00001

Permanent Link: http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu/NCFE004481/00001

Material Information

Title: Athenian Leadership in Thucydides "History of the Peloponnesian War"
Physical Description: Book
Language: English
Creator: Buckingham, William
Publisher: New College of Florida
Place of Publication: Sarasota, Fla.
Creation Date: 2011
Publication Date: 2011

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords: Classics
Thucydides
Ancient Greece
Genre: bibliography   ( marcgt )
theses   ( marcgt )
government publication (state, provincial, terriorial, dependent)   ( marcgt )
born-digital   ( sobekcm )
Electronic Thesis or Dissertation

Notes

Abstract: In this thesis, I explore the arc of Athenian leadership in Thucydides� History of the Peloponnesian War. To achieve this goal, I rely on Thucydides� narrative technique of interrelating speech and narrative throughout his work. I examine closely the speeches of the characters themselves, their interaction with Thucydides� narrative, and their interaction with each other. I apply this method to the speeches of the four main Athenian generals in the history: Pericles, Cleon, Nicias, and Alcibiades. My analysis reveals the connection that Thucydides establishes between each of the leaders, and infers the judgments that Thucydides leads us to make through his narrative technique. The result is a complete portrait of Athenian leadership, in which Pericles represents optimal leadership, Cleon represents the beginning of its decline, and Nicias and Alcibiades represent its ultimate, complete failure.
Statement of Responsibility: by William Buckingham
Thesis: Thesis (B.A.) -- New College of Florida, 2011
Electronic Access: RESTRICTED TO NCF STUDENTS, STAFF, FACULTY, AND ON-CAMPUS USE
Bibliography: Includes bibliographical references.
Source of Description: This bibliographic record is available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication. The New College of Florida, as creator of this bibliographic record, has waived all rights to it worldwide under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights, to the extent allowed by law.
Local: Faculty Sponsor: Shaw, Carl

Record Information

Source Institution: New College of Florida
Holding Location: New College of Florida
Rights Management: Applicable rights reserved.
Classification: local - S.T. 2011 B92
System ID: NCFE004481:00001


This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

!"#$%&!%'($!)$*+#&,'&%'"#-./)&)$+0' !"#$%&'(%)($!*(+*,%+%--*#".-(/.& 12 3455467'189:4;<=67 ' ' !'"=>?4? ' +8@74AA>B'AC'A=>')4D4?4C;'CE'#876;4A4>? %>F'.C55><>'CE'G5CH4B6 &;'I6HA465'E85E4557>;A'CE'A=>'H>J84H>7>;A'ECH'A=>'B>> 169=>5CH'CE'!HA? -;B>H 'A=>'?IC;?CH?=4I'CE')HK'.6H5'+=6F ' ' +6H6?CA6L'G( M62L'NOPP ' ' '

PAGE 2

ii "6@5>?'CE'.C;A>;A? "6@5>'CE'.C;A>;A? 44 !@?AH69A 444 &;AHCB89A4C; P .=6IA>H'Q;> R ',>H495>? NO .=6IA>H'"FC R '.5>C; ST .=6IA>H '"=H>> R '%4946?'6;B'!594@46B>? UT .C;958?4C; VT 1 4@54C
PAGE 3

iii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

PAGE 4

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`abcd`e L' `abcd`fcg _L' 6;B'4A'4?'?C7>F=6A'B4EE4985A'AC'96A>< CH4h>'=4?'FCH:'4;'A>H7?'CE'A=>' <>;H>?'CE'A=>'A47>K #CH;@5CF>HL'PWVTL'TK N '' i6
PAGE 5

2 !A=>;46;L'6;B'F6?'@CH;'6HC8;B'SUO'1.$'4;AC'6'F>65A=2'6;B'6H4?AC9H6A49'E67452K [ ''#4?' F>65A='6;B'IH4D45><>'=6B'AFC'47ICHA6;A'H>?85A?L'E4H?AL'=>'A>;B>B'AC'E6DCH'6'7CH>' C54<6H9=49'H;7>;A'CD>H'6'B>7C9H6A49'C;>L'6;B'?>9C;BL'=>'=6B'A=>'H>?C8H9>?'6;B' A=>' CIICHA8;4A2'AC'FH4A>'=4?'=4?ACH2K S ''#>'ACC:'I6HA'4;'A=>'D>H2'F6H'A=6A'=>'H>9CHB?'4;' SNS'1.$L'F=>;'=>'F6?'>5>9A>B'6?'C;>'CE'A=>'A>;'6;;865'!A=>;46;'<>;>H65?K''#>'F6?' 8;?899>??E85'4;'=4?'6??4<;7>;A'AC'B>E>;B'!7I=4IC54?L'6;B'@>968?>'CE'A=4?L'A=>' !A=>;46;?'DCA >B'=47'4;AC'>X45>K''!EA>H'A=4?'IC4;AL'=6HB52'6;2A=4;<'9C;9H>A>'4?':;CF;' 6@C8A'=47L'@8A'=>'D>H2'54:>52'?I>;A'789='CE'=4?'H>764;4;<'2>6H?'AH6D>54;<'AC'9C55>9A' 4;ECH76A4C;L'6;B'FH4A4;<'=4?'=4?ACH2K''#>'B4>B'6HC8;B'SOO'1.$L'@8A'=4?'=4?ACH2'?ACI?' 6A'SPP'1.$L'?> D>;'2>6H?'@>ECH>'A=>'85A476A>'B>E>6A'CE'!A=>;?L'6;B'ECH'A=4?'H>6?C;L'4A' 4?'9C77C;52'6>B'A=6A'=4?'FCH:'4?'8;E4;4?=>BK j !A=>;?'6;B'+I6HA6 &;'"=892B4B>?^'A47>L'kH>>:?'F>H>'54D4;<'4;'4;B>I>;B>;A'94A2 R ?A6A>?'?96AA>H>B' 655'CD>H'764;56;B'kH>>9>L'6?'F>55'6?'C; 'A=>'?=CH>?'6;B'4?56;B?'CE'A=>'M>B4A>HH6;>6;K'' $69='94A2 R ?A6A>'4;958B>B'4A?'?8HHC8;B4;<'H8H65'56;B'6;B'4;=6@4A6;A?'6?'4A?'A>HH4ACH2' 6;B'ICI856A4C;K'')>?I4A>'@>4;<'lkH>>:mL'>69='94A2 R ?A6A>'?AHCD>'AC'764;A64;'4A?' 4;B>I>;B>;9>'EHC7'CA=>H'94A2 R ?A6A>?L'6;B'C;>' CE'A=>'76ZCH'4??8>?'CE'A=>' ,>5CIC;;>?46;'F6HL'6?'"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?'4AL'4?'A=>'!A=>;46;'>EECHA'AC'764;A64;' BC74;4C;'CD>H'4A?'?8@Z>9A'94A2 R ?A6A>?'6;B'>D>;'AC'?8@Z8<6A>'7CH>L'6<64;?A'A=>' +I6HA6;'>EECHA'AC'?8@D>HA'!A=>;46;'BC74;4C;K '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' [ Q.)L'PWWUL'PjPUK S i6
PAGE 6

3 !A=>;?'=6B'@>>;'6'B>7C9H 692'?4;9>'jPO'1.$L'F=>;'A=>'A2H6;;2'CE'A=>' ,>4?4?AH6A4B?'F6?'CD>HA=HCF;L'6;B'A=>';>F'5>6B>H L '.5>4?A=>;>? L '4;4A46A>B'B>7C9H6A49' H>ECH7?K U '')>7C9H6A49'4;?A4A8A4C;?'9C;A4;8>B'AC'B>D>5CI'4;'!A=>;?'A=HC8<=C8A'A=>' E4EA='9>;A8H2K''"=>'IH476H2'B>94?4C;'76:4;<'@CB2 '4;'!A=>;46;'H;7>;A'F6?'A=>' 6??>7@52L'4;'F=49='6;2'765>'94A4h>;'9C85B'?I>6:'4;'B>@6A>'6;B'DCA>K T ''"=>H>'F>H>' 65?C'6';87@>H'CE'H;7>;A'IC?A?L'4;958B4;<'6'9C8;945'CE'E4D>'=8;BH>BL'AH>6?8H>H?L' 6;B'Z8H4>?L'A=6A'F>H>'E455>B'@2'5CA V L'6;B'6'E>F'IC?A?L'4;95 8B4;<'A>;'<>;>H65?L'F=C'F>H>' >5>9A>BK W ''!55'CE'A=>?>'IC?A?'F>H>'699C8;A6@5>'AC'A=>'6??>7@52L'6;B'A=>H>ECH>'A=>' 94A4h>; R @CB2'CE'!A=>;?'4A?>5EK''"=4?'4;958B>?'A=>'<>;>H65?L'F=C'9C85B';CA'A6:>'6;2' 4;B>I>;B>;A'69A4C;'8;A45'A=>2'=6B'@>>;'<4D>;'A=>'68A=CH4A2'AC' BC'?C'@2'6'76ZCH4A2' DCA>'CE'A=>'6??>7@52K''"=>'!A=>;46;'B>7C9H692'F6?'>XAH>7>52';CD>5'6A'A=>'A47>L' 655CF4;<'94A4h>;?'AC'E8552'I6HA494I6A>'4;'A=>'B>94?4C;'76:4;<'IHC9>??'CE'H;7>;AL' 6;B'>D>;'6?9>;B'AC'HC5>?'CE'5>6B>H?=4IK &;'?A6H:'9C;AH6?A'AC'!A=>;?L'?A CCB'+I6HA6K''+I6HA6'F6?'H;>B'@2'6'?AH49A' C54<6H9=2'6;B'=6B'6'H4<4B'=4>H6H9=2'AC'4A?'?C94>A2K''"=>H>'F>H>'A=H>>'+I6HA6;'96?A>?' 4;AC'F=49='6'I>H?C;'9C85B'@>'@CH;K PO ''"=>'5CF>?A'96?A>L'A=>'=>5CA?L'F>H>'B>?9>;B>;A?' CE'>4A=>H'A=>'M>??>;46;?'CH'(69C;46;?L'F=C 7'A=>'+I6HA6;?'=6B'9C;J8>H>B'6;B' ECH9>B'4;AC'?>HEBC7K''"=>'?>9C;B'96?A>L'A=>'I>H4C4:C4L'F>H>';C74;6552'EH>>' 7>H9=6;A?'6;B'AH6B>?76;L'@8A'=6B';C'IC54A4965'H4<=A?K''"=>'=4<=>?A'956??'F>H>'A=>' +I6HA46A>?L'A=>'C;52'+I6HA6;'94A4h>;?L'F=C'F>H>'?>I6H6A>B'EHC7'A=> 4H'7CA=>H?'6A'A=>' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' U *C@4;?C;L'PWTTL'PNK''*C@4;?C;L'PWTTL'NVK T #6;?>;L'PWWPL'PNjK V !H4?ACA5>L' =3;1202>203;(36(.278;1 L NjK W G 4;5>2L'PWV[L'UTK PO i6
PAGE 7

4 6<>'CE'?>D>;'AC'8;B>HXA>;?4D>'7454A6H2'AH64;4;'6A>?A'4;E6;AH2' ECH9>'4;'655'CE'kH>>9>K''"=>'+I6HA6;?'9C85B'?I>6:'4;'6;'6??>7@52 PP L'@8A'A=>'B>94?4C;?' F>H>'85A476A>52'76B>'@2'6'9C8;?>5'CE'E4D>'>I=CH?L'6;B'6'I64H'CE'=>H>B 4A6H2':4;6B'A=>4H'6H74>?K "=>?>'AFC'94A4>?L'!A=>;?'6;B'+I6HA6L'C;'A=>'CIIC?4A>'>;B?'CE'A=>'6;94>;A' IC54A4965'?I>9AH87L'@CA='HC?>'AC'6?9>;B6;92'CD>H'A=>'CA=>H'kH>>:'94A2 R ?A6A>?'B8H4;<' A=>'E4EA='9>;A8H2'1.$K''1CA='69=4>D>B'A=>4H'ICF>H'F4A='A= >'64B'CE'A=>',>H?46;'36HL' EHC7'SWO'AC'STW'1.$K PN ''"=>'kH>>:?'B>E>;B>B',>H?46;'4;D6?4C;?'6<64;?A' CD>HF=>574;<';87>H4965'CBB?'@2'ECH74;<'6'9C654A4C;'CE'94A2 R ?A6A>?L'F4A='!A=>;?'6;B' +I6HA6'I5624;<'6'5>6B4;<'HC5>K''!EA>H'A=>',>H?46;?'F>H>'E4;6552'H>I85?>BL'!A=> ;?'6;B' +I6HA6'B4D4B>B'8I'9C;AHC5'CE'A=>'76;2'94A2 R ?A6A>?'F=C'=6B'6554>B'F4A='A=>7L'+I6HA6' 5>6B4;<'A=>',>5CIC;;>?46;'(>6<8>L'6;B'!A=>;?'5>6B4;<'A=>')>546;'(>6<8>K''Q;9>'A=>' ,>H?46;'A=H>6A'F6?';>8AH654h>BL'!A=>;?'6;B'+I6HA6'9C7I>A>B'ECH'9C;AHC5'CE'A=>'CA=>H' kH>>:'94A2 R ?A6A>?K''"=892B4B>?'C8A54;>?'A=>'B>D>5CI7>;A'CE'A=>'AFC'?A6A>?L' I6HA49856H52'!A=>;?L'5>6B4;<'8I'AC'A=>',>5CIC;;>?46;'36H'4;'=4?'E4H?A'@CC:L'6;B'A=>;' 9CD>H?'A=>'69A865'F6HL'@><4;;4;<'4;'S[P'1.$L'F=49='=>'95647?'F6?'968?>B'@2'l"=>' 'IC F>H'CE'!A=>;?L'6;B'A=>'656H7'F=49='A=4?'4;?I4H>B'4;'+I6HA6m'\PKN[Kj]K "=892B4B>?0'#4?ACH2 "=892B4B>?^' !012345(36(278(+893:3;;810<;(/ <4 '4?'?AH89A8H>B'6?'EC55CF?K''1CC:'&' C8A54;>?'A=>'2>6H?'@>ECH>'A=>'F6HL'@CA='A=>'H4?>'AC'>74;>;9>'6;B'A=>'H4D65H2'@>AF>>;' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' PP +I6HA6;?'6H>'CEA>;'9=6H69A>H4h>B'6?'A>H?>'6;B'@H4>E'F=>;'A=>2'?I>6:'@2'"=892B4B>?K''"=>2'F>H>' D>H2'?>9H>A4D>'F4A='H><6HB'AC'A=>4H'IC54A4965'6?'F>55'6?'A=>4H'7454A6H2'B>94?4C;?'6;B'69A4C;?L'6?'A=>2'=6B' AC'@>'9C;?A6;A5 2'C;'<86HB'6<64;?A';CA'C;52'A=>4H'>XA>H;65'>;>74>?L'@8A'6'IC??4@5>'=>5CA'H>DC5AL'F=C' C8A;87@>H>B'A=>4H'96IACH?'7CH>'A=6;'A>; R AC R C;>K'i6
PAGE 8

5 A=>;?'6;B'+I6HA6K''1CC:?'&& R &n'C8A54;>'=C?A454A4>?'@>AF>>;'+I6HA6'F4A='4A?'6554>?'6;B' !A=>;?'F4A='4A?'6554>?K''&;'1CC:'n'!A=>;?'6;B'+I6HA6'9C;958B>'6'I>69>'6;B'65546;9>' F4A='C;>'6;CA=>HL'A=C8<='A=HC8<=C8A'A=>'H>?A'CE'A=>'@CC:'D6H4C8?'94A2 R ?A6A>?'6H>'?A455' ECH9>B'AC'?=CF'5C265A2'AC'C;>'?4B>'CH'A=>'CA=>HK''1CC:'n&'C8A54;>?'A=>'I56;;4;<'6;B' >X>98A4C;'CE'6;'!A=>;46;'4;D6?4C;'CE'+49452K''1CC:'n&&'@><4;?'F4A='+I6HA6;' IH>I6H6A4C;?'AC'H>4<;4A>'A=>'F6H'F4A='!A=>;?L'6;B'9C;958B>?'F4A='A=>'B>E>6A'6;B' ?8HH>;B>H'CE'A=>' !A=>;46;'9C;A4;<>;A'6A'+49452K''1CC:'n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

PAGE 9

6 :; CF5>B<>'CE'A=>'85A476A>'C8A9C7>'AC'47I52'6'968?65'H>56A4C;?=4I'@>AF>>;'A=>' 9=6;<>?'4;'A=>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4I'A=HC8<=C8A'A=>'F6HL'6;B'A=>4H'E4;65'B>E>6AK''"=4?' H>?85A?'4;'6'@HC6B>H'I49A8H>'CE'!A=>;46;'?AH6A><2'6;B'5>6B>H?=4IL'6;B'655CF?' "=892B4B>?'AC'B>?9H 4@>'>69='!A=>;46;'5>6B>H'4;'A=>'9C;A>XA'CE'A=>'>;A4H>'AF>;A2' ?>D>;'2>6H'I>H4CBK''&;'A=4?'F62L'=>'5>6B?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'Z8B<>'A=>'>EE>9A4D>;>??'CE'>69=' CE'A=>'5>6B>H?'@2'9C;A>XA8654h4;<'>69='C;>'6<64;?A'A=>'@69:7ICH6H4>?K''"=>'>EE>9A'CE'"=8 92B4B>?0'@HC6B'I>H?I>9A4D>'4?'A=6A'!A=>;?0'E4;65' B>E>6A'6II>6H?'AC'@>'968?>B'@2'4A?'>6H54>H'74?A6:>?L'6;B'=>'4558?AH6A>?'A=>'74?A6:>?' 76B>'@2'!A=>;?'4;'A=>'E4H?A'AFC'F6H?'4;'?89='6'F62'6?'AC';6A8H6552'H>?85A'4;'4A?'B>E>6A' 4;'A=>'A=4HBK "=892B4B>?'6;B'A=>'# 4?ACH4965'"H6B4A4C; "=892B4B>?'F6?'4;'6'8;4J8>'IC?4A4C;'AC'H>9CHB'A=>'>D>;A?'CE'A=>' ,>5CIC;;>?46;'36HK''&;'A=>'E4H?A'2>6H?'=>'F6?'6'<>;>H65'C;'A=>'?4B>'CE'A=>'!A=>;46;?L' @8A'6EA>H'5C?4;<'A=>'94A2'CE'!7I=4IC54?'AC'6'+I6HA6;'6AA69:'4;'SN[L'"=892B4B>?'F6?' @5 67>B'@2'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>'ECH'A=>4H'B>E>6A'6;B'85A476A>52'F6?'>X45>BK''Q;9>'4;' >X45>L'=>'F>;A'CD>H'AC'A=>'+I6HA6;?'6;B'A=>4H'6554>?L'6@?A64;4;<'EHC7L'@8A'?A455' C@?>HD4;'F6HK''1>968?>'CE'=4?'>XI>H4>;9>?'C;'@CA='?4B>?L'=>'F6?'6@5>'AC'FH4A>'6' 9C7IH>=> ;?4D>'699C8;A'CE'A=>'>;A4H>'F6HL'65A=C8<='=4?'B>6A='IH>D>;A>B'=47'EHC7' 9C7I5>A4;<'A=>'E4;65'@CC:K''"=892B4B>?0'IC?4A4C;'6?'<>;>H65'655CF>B'=47'AC' 6998H6A>52'4;A>HIH>A'7454A6H2'69A4C;?'6;B'B>94?4C;?Y'=>'F6?'IH>?>;A'6A'76;2'CE'A=>' >D>;A?'=>'H>9CHB>BL'6;B'F=> H>'=>'F6?';CA'IH>?>;AL'=>'F6?'9C;;>9A>B'AC'?C8H9>?'C;' >4A=>H'?4B>'A=6A'9C85B'IHCD4B>'=47'F4A='4;ECH76A4C;K''"=>?>'6BD6;A6<>?'655CF>B'

PAGE 10

7 "=892B4B>?'AC'H>9CHB'=4?'F6H'F4A='7CH>'6998H692'A=6;'FC85B'CA=>HF4?>'=6D>'@>>;' IC??4@5>K PS ,H4CH'AC'"=892B4B>?L'A=>'76ZCH'l =4?ACH4965m'kH>>:'68A=CH?'F>H>'#C7>H'6;B' #>HCBCA8?K''!HC8;B'A=>'>4<=A='9>;A8H2'1.$L'#C7>H'FHCA>' $78("90I49'IC>7' 6@C8A'A=>'"HCZ6;'36HL'96K'A=>'AF>5EA='9>;A8H2'1.$L'F=49='9>;A>H>B'6HC8;B'A=>'kH>>:' =>HC L '!9=455>?K''"=>'5>6B4;<'=>HC>?'<4D>'EH>J8>;A'?I> >9=>?'A=HC8<=C8A'A=>'>I49L'6;B' A=>2'=6D>'?C7>'4;E58>;9>'CD>H'A=>'H>?85A'CE'A=>'E4<=A4;H'65?C'B>?9H4@>?'A=>' H>69A4C;?'CE'A=>'kCB?'AC'A=>'@6AA5>?L'6;B'>D>;'A=>4H'4;A>H69A4C;?'F4A='A=>'7CHA65?L'6?' A=>2'6AA>7IA'AC'=>5I'>4A=>H'?4B>K''#C7>H 'B>?9H4@>?'@6 AA5>?'4;'A=>'&546B '@2'B>?9H4@4;<'6' =C?A'CE'74;CH'=>HC>?'A=6 A'6H>'?564;'@2'A=>'6A>H'C;>? '6;B'EC98?>?'6A52'C;'A=>' AH487I='CE'4;B4D4B865?'4;'@6AA5>K''#CF>D>HL'699CHB4;<'AC'#C7>HL'A=>'85A476A>' C8A9C7>'4?';CA'B>A>H74;>B'@2'A=>'=>HC>?'A=>7?>5D>?'@8A'@2'i>8 ?K !EA>H'#C7>HL'#>HCBCA8?'4?'A=>';>XA'76ZCH'kH>>:'=4?ACH46;K PU ''#>HCBCA8?' FHCA>'A=>'=4?ACH2'CE'A=>',>H?46;'36HL'6;B'=4?';6HH6A4D>'?I6;?'EHC7'jSj'AC'SNO'1.K'' #>HCBCA8?^'?A6A>B'A>H74;>'F=2'A=>'kH>>:?'6;B',>H?46;?'F>;A'AC'F6HL' 6;B'AC'IH>?>HD>'A= >4H'?ACH4>?'ECH'E8A8H>'<>;>H6A4C;?K PT ''#>'FHCA>'=4?'=4?ACH2'EHC7'6' 9C55>9A4C;'CE'?C8H9>?L'7C?A52'CH65L'A=6A'=>'9C55>9A>B'6?'=>'AH6D>5>B'A=HC8<=C8A'kH>>9>' 6;B',>H?46K''#>'=47?>5E'?A6A>?'A=6A'=>'4?'C@54<>B'AC'H>ICHA'>D>H2A=4;<'A=6A'=>'4?'AC5BL' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' PS "=892B4B>?'CF;'I>H?C;65'@CC;?'F>H>'76<;4E4>B'@2'A=>'985A8H65'@CC;?'6EECHB>B'AC'=47'@2'54D4;<'4;' !A=>;?'B8H4;<'A=>'?C'9655>B'_kC5B>;'!<>_K''"=892B4B>?'FHCA>'B8H4;<'6'I>H4CB'CE'4;A>55>9A865' B>D>5CI7>; A'6;B'>XI5CH6A4C;L'9=6H69A>H4h>B'@2'6BD6;9>?'4;'785A4I5>'E4>5B?L'4;958B4;<'?CI=4?A49' H=>ACH49L'#4IIC9H6A49'7>B494;>'6;B'AH6<>B2K''"=>'4;A>55>9A865'7454>8'6A'A=>'A47>'B>E4;4A>52'4;E58>;9>B' "=892B4B>?'4;'=4?'FH4A4;HL'PWVTL'PPW K''"=C76?L'NOOUL'VT R POVK Pj Q.)L'PWWUL'TPV R TNOK PU GCH'7CH>'C;'A=>'H>56A4C;?=4I'@>AF>>;'"=892B4B>?'6;B'#>HCBCA8?L'?>>'#CH;@5CF>HL'PWVTL'P[ R [[K PT #>HCBCA8?L'PKPK

PAGE 11

8 @8A'4?';CA'C@54 <>B'AC'@>54>D>'4AL'6;B'=>'CEA>;'B4?@>54>D>?'CH'4?'8;6@5>'AC'B>94B>'C;'A=>' AH8A='CE'A=>'D>H2'?ACH4>?'=>'H>ICHA?K PV '' "=892B4B>?'95>6H52'BH6F?'EHC7'A=>'4;E58>;9>?'CE'A=>?>'IH>B>9>??CH?'4;'A=>' ?A25>'6;B'ECH7'CE'=4?'=4?ACH2K''o8?A'6?'#C7>HL'=>'EH>J8>;A52'4;?>H A?'?I>>9=>?'@2'A=>' 7C?A'47ICHA6;A'9=6H69A>H?'AC'=>5I'BH4D>'A=>';6HH6A4D>K''o8?A'6?'#>HCBCA8?L'=>'76:>?' 6;'4;J84H2'4;AC'A=>'968?>?'CE'A=>'F6H'4A?>5EK''(4:>'@CA='=>'F4?=>?'AC'IH>?>HD>'A=>' 6A'B>>B?'CE'7>;'ECH'E8A8H>'<>;>H6A4C;?K''%>D>HA=>5>??L'"=892B4B>?0' ?A25>'B4EE>H?' ;CA49>6@52'EHC7'A=6A'CE'#C7>H'6;B'#>HCBCA8?K''3=45>'#C7>H'6?9H4@>?'A=>'C8A9C7>' CE'76;2'CE'A=>'>D>;A?'4;'A=>'&546B'AC'A=>'4;E58>;9>'CE'6'?L'4;'=4?'CF;' FCH:L';>D>H'6?9H4@>?'6;2'>D>;A'AC'A=>'69A'CE'6'B>4A2K''3=45>'#>HCBCA8?'H>ICHA? '>D>H2' 699C8;A'A=6A'=>'9C55>9A?'B8H4;<'=4?'4;J84H4>?L'"=892B4B>?'4?'65F62?'9>HA64;'AC'B4?9>H;' 4;'=4?'=4?ACH2'@>AF>>;'F=49='H>ICHA?'6H>'AC'@>'A6:>;'6?'AH8>'6;B'F=49='6?'E65?>K''#4?' IH476H2'9CHB4;<'CE'>D>;A? PW '\PKNNKN]'6;B'=>'A6:>?'6'?: >IA4965' 6;B'9H4A4965'D4>F'CE'A=>'6998H692'CE'=4?'=4?ACH46;'IH>B>9>??CH?'\PKNP]K''#>'4?' B4?6IIC4;A>B'F4A='A=>'569:'CE'9H4A4965'4;J84H2L'6;B'6AA>7IA?'AC'A>69='=4?'CF;'H>6B>H' AC'4;J84H>'9H4A496552'A=HC8<='=4?'FCH:'\PKNNKS]K''&;'=4?'J8>?A'AC'8;B>H?A6;B'=4?'CF; F6H'6;B'?=6H>'=4?':;CF5>B<>'F4A='E8A8H>'<>;>H6A4C;?L'=>'H>E8?>?'AC'<4D>'A=>'H>6?C;' ECH'6;2'>D>;A'6?'B4D4;>'968?>'CH'H>AH4@8A4C;K''"=892B4B>?'E4H752'?A6A>?'A=6A'=4?ACH2'4?' B>A>H74;>B'@2'l bc epqdrs`cp m'\PKNNKS]L'F=49='74<=A'@>'AH6;?56A>B'D6H4C8?52'6?'lA=>' = 876;'9C;B4A4C;mL'l=876;';6A8H>mL'CH'l=876;'6EE64H?mK''"=892B4B>?'@>54>D>?'A=6A'A=>' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' PV '' #>HCBCA8?'TKPjNK[L'65?C'Q.)L'PWWUL'UWTL'*>;<6:C?L'NOOUL'NTW R [OOK PW '_ "=>H>'F6?'6'A47>'F=>;'4;A> HIH>A>H?'E>5A'A=6A'A=>'9C8H?>'CE'>D>;A?'6?'AC5B'@2'"=892B4B>?'9C;A64;?' ;CA'7CH>'A=6;'A=>'^;6:>B'E69A?^_K'+A6=5L'NOO[L'PT[K

PAGE 12

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h>'CH' >D>;'4;?>HA'IH>B49A4C;?'4;AC'A=>4H'?I>>9=>?K''"=>?>'?I>>9=>?'6H>'4;A>H?I>H?>B' A=HC8<=C8A'A=>'FCH:L'6;B'6H>'@6?>B'C;'H>65'?I>>9=>?'<4D>;'@2'?I>6:>H?L'6;B' 65A=C8<='"=892B4B>?'BC>?'95647'A=6A'=>'=C5B?'=47?>5E'AC'A=>'7>6;4;<' CE'F=6A'F6?' 69A86552'?64BL'=>'65?CL'6?'A=>'68A=CHL'B>A>H74;>?'>X69A52'=CF'>D>H2A=4;<'4?'?64BK _34A='H>E>H>;9>'AC'A=>'?I>>9=>?'4;'A=4?'=4?ACH2L'?C7>'F>H>'B>54D>H>B'@>ECH>' A=>' F6H'@><6;L'CA=>H?'F=45>'4A'F6?''&'=>6HB'72?>5EL'CA=>H?'&'H?t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h4;<'ECH7>H'=4?ACH46;?'ICH AH6265'CE'A=>'I6?AL'"=892B4B>?'=4<=54<=A?'A=>'47ICHA6;A'A=>7>?'4;'A=>' I6?A'A=6A'F455'@>'47ICHA6;A'4;'A=>',>5CIC;;>?46;'36HK''"=>'IH476H2'A=>7>?'6H>'_7C;>2_'6;B'_;6D65' ICF>H_K''kH>;>L'PWUjL'jUK

PAGE 13

10 "=>'>XA>;A'CE'"=892B4B>? 'CF;'9C;AH4@8A4C;'AC'=4?'?I>>9=>?'=6?'@>>;' A=CHC8<=52'B>@6A>B'@2'?9=C56H?K NP ''"=892B4B>?'=47?>5E'6B74A?'A=6AL'C;'A=>'C;>'=6;BL' =>'H>9CHB?'A=>'>D>;A?'6?'6998H6A>52'6?'IC??4@5>L'6;B'C;'A=>'CA=>H'=6;BL'=>'H>9CHB?' A=>'?I>> 9=>?'F4A='A=>'6H<87>;A?'A=6A'=>'9C;?4B>H>B'AC'@>'_B>76;B>B'CE'A=>7_' \PKNNKP]K''"=4?'7>6;?'A=6A'4;'A=>'=4?ACH4965';6HH6A4D>'>D>;A?'6H>'H>9CHB>B'IH>94?>52L' A=C8<='4;'A=>'?I>>9=>?'"=892B4B>?'=47?>5E'762'4;A>HD>;>'6;B'65A>H'F=6A'F6?'AH852' ?64B'AC'?84A'=4?'CF;' I8HIC?>K''o8?A'F=6A'"=892B4B>?'7>6;?'F=>;'=>'95647?'=>' 4;958B>?'F=6A'=>'9C;?4B>H?'_B>76;B>B_'4?'?C7>F=6A'8;95>6HK''+9=C56H?=4I'4?' B4D4B>B'@>AF>>;'A=C?>'F=C'H><6HB'A=>'?I>>9=>?'6?'7C?A52'E49A4C;65L'4;D>;A>B'@2' "=892B4B>?'=47?>5E NN L'6;B'A=C?>'F=C'9C;?4B>H'A=> 7'AC'@>'95C?>H'AC'A=>'FCHB?'CE'A=>' CH4<4;65'?I>6:>HK N[ ''&'9=CC?>'AC'4;A>HIH>A'_B>76;B>B_'6?'7>6;4;<'F=6A'"=892B4B>?' A=C8<=A'A=>'?I>6:>H'FC85B';>9>??6H452'?62L'@6?>B'C;'"=892B4B>?^'8;B>H?A6;B4;<'CE' A=>4H'4B>6?'6;B'7CA4D6A4C;?K''"=6A'4?'AC'?62L'"=892B4B>?'=6? '>69='?I>6:>H'?I>6:' 699CHB4;<'AC'=4?'CF;'47IH>??4C;'CE'A=6A'?I>6:>HK''#>'9H>6A>?'6;'476<>'CE'>69=' 9=6H69A>H'A=HC8<='A=>4H'?I>>9=>?L'CD>H'F=49='=>'=6?'?C7>'9C;AHC5L'6;B'A=HC8<='A=>4H' 69A4C;?L'CD>H'F=49='=>'=6?';C'9C;AHC5K'' "=892B4B>?'5>6B?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'B H6F'9C;958?4C;?'6@C8A'A=>'9=6H69A>H?' A=HC8<='9C7I6H4;<'A=>4H'FCHB?'F4A='A=>4H'69A4C;?'@2'47IC?4;<'=4?'CF;' 4;A>HIH>A6A4C;'CE'A=>'?I>>9=>?L'@8A'8?4;<'6'54A>H65'4;A>HIH>A6A4C;'CE'A=>'>D>;A?K''l34A=' H>E>H>;9>'AC'A=>';6HH6A4D>'CE'>D>;A?KKK'4A'H>?A?'I6HA52'C;'F= 6A'&'?6F'72?>5EL'I6HA52'C;' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' NP +4;9564H'>7I=6?4h>?'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'BC>?';CA'FH4A>'A=>'?I>>9= >?'6?'_?>74 R BH676A49'IHCB89A4C;?_L' @8A'A=6A'=>'AH852'_IH>?>HD>B'ECH'8?'?C7>'CE'A=>'IC54A4965'A=C8<=A'C E'A=>'IHC74;>;A'7>;'CE'=4?'A47> _' +4;9564HL'PWjPL'WWK NN _&A'4?'C;52'4;'7CH>'H>9>;A'A47>'A=6A'C;>'=6?'@><8;'AC'H>654h>'A=6A'A=>'6II6H>;A'=C7C<>;>4A2'CE'?A2 5>' 4;'"=892B4B>?^'?I>>9=>?L'F=49='C;'A=>'?8HE69>'76:>?'A=>7'?>>7'655'654:>L'6B74 A?'CE'B4EE>H>;9>?'CE' 9=6H69A>H? _'+A6=5L'NOO[L'PTSK N[ i6
PAGE 14

11 F=6A'CA=>H?'?6F'ECH'7>L'A=>'6998H692'CE'A=>'H>ICHA'@>4;<'65F62?'AH4>B'@2'A=>'7C?A' ?>D>H>'6;B'B>A645>B'A>?A?'IC??4@5>m'\PKNNKN]K''&;'A=4?'F62'"=892B4B>?'4?'6@5>'AC'6BZ8?A' >69='9=6H69A>H?0'?I>>9=>?'4;'6'F62'A=6A'6;A494I6A>?'A=>';6H H6A4D>L'F=45>'A=>';6HH6A4D>' H>764;?'>;A4H>52'E69A865K''"=4?'655CF?'=47'AC'>7I=6?4h>'A=>'H>56A4C;'@>AF>>;'6' 9=6H69A>H0?'FCHB?L'6;B'A=>'>D>;A?'4;'A=>'F6HK''#>'=6?'?AH89A8H>B'=4?'=4?ACH2'4;'?89='6' F62'A=6A'9=655>;<>?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'6;652h>'A=>'?47456H4A4>?'6;B 'B4EE>H>;9>?'@>AF>>;' F=6A'6'I>H?C;'?62?'6;B'BC>?K NS ''"=>'H>6B>H'4?'ECH9>B'AC'A=4;:'9H4A496552'6@C8A'A=>'A>XAL' 6;B'AC'BH6F'9C;958?4C;?'6@C8A'A=>'6@454A2'CE'9=6H69A>H?'AC'69A'6?'A=>2'?62'A=>2'F455L' 6;B'AC'IH>B49A'A=>'H>?85A?'CE'A=>4H'I56;?K''"=4?'H>?85A?'4;'6 '9>HA64;'ICHAH64A'CE'>69=' 4;B4D4B865'4;'"=892B4B>?^'FCH:'A=6A'4?'F>55'9C;AHC55>B'@2'=47'4;'CHB>H'AC'H>4;ECH9>' =4?'?'?62?'A=6A'=>'FHCA>'=4?'FCH:'_;CA'6?'6;'>??62'F=49='4?'AC'F4;'A=>' 6II568?>'CE'A=>'7C7>;AL'@8A'6?'6'IC??>??4C;'ECH'655'A47>_' \PKNNKS]K''#>'=6?';CA' FH4AA>;'=4?'=4?ACH2'AC'>;A>HA64;L'@8A'AC'>B896A>K''#>'>XI5494A52'?A6A>?'A=6A':;CF5>B<>' CE'A=>'I6?A'5>6B?'AC'8;B>H?A6;B4;<'CE'A=>'E8A8H>K NU ''"=4?'?A6A>7>;A'?8<<>?A?'A=6A' "=892B4B>?^'H>6B>H'F455'5>6H;';CA'C;52'AC'9C7I6H>'A=>'?I>>9=>?'6;B '69A4C;?'CE'6' 5>6B>H'4;'A=>',>5CIC;;>?46;'36HL'@8A'CE'6;2'=4?ACH4965'E4<8H>K''#>'699C7I54?=>?'=4?' 69=4;<'A=>'H>6B>H'A=HC8<='A=>'4;A>H69A4C;'CE'?I>>9='6;B';6HH6A4D>'4;'=4?' FCH:K'' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' NS MCHH4?C;L'NOOUL'NjNK Nj '''' GCH'7CH>'C;'"=892B 4B>?^'; 6HH6A4D>'A>9=;4J8>'6?'4A'6II54>?'AC'=4?'4;B4D4B865' 9=6H69A>H?L'?>>' kH4@@5>L'NOOUL'SST R SjPK NU '' "=>H>'=6?'@>>;'789='B>@6A>'CD>H'F=>A=>H'"=892B4B>?^'IHC95647>B'8A454A2'4?'?AH49A52'4;A>55>9A865L'CH' AH852'6II5496@5>K''GCH'7CH>'C;'A=4?'ACI49L'?>>'u655>AL'NOOUL'[[jK''''

PAGE 15

12 "=892B4B>?'8?>?'A=>'68A=CH4A2'6;B'CIICHA8;4A2'=>'=6?'6?'68A=CH'AC' FH4A>'A=>' ?I>>9=>?'4;'?89='6'F62'6?'AC'I8H?8>'=4?'B896A4;<'A=>'H>6B>H'\PKNNKS]K''#>' 4;9CHICH6A>?'H>E>H>;9>?'AC'E8A8H>'>D>;A?'6;B'CA=>H'?I>6:>H?'4;AC'A=>'?I>>9=>?'CE'=4?' 9=6H69A>H?L'F=49='?AH>;;'A=>'9C;;>9A4C;'@>AF>>;'A=>'9=6H69A>H^?'?I>>9='6;B '=4?' CF;';6HH6A4D>K''&;'A=4?'F62'=>'?AH89A8H>?'=4?'FCH:'?C'6?'AC'ECH9>'A=>'H>6B>H'AC' 9C7I6H>'A=>'4B>6?'4;'6'9=6H69A>H0?'?I>>9='F4A='=4?'69A4C;?'6;B'A=>'H>?85A?'CE'=4?' B>94?4C;?'4;'A=>';6HH6A4D>K''!'9=6H69A>H^?'?I>>9='F455'CEA>;'=4;A'6A'A=>'?899>??>?'CH' E64 58H>?'A=6A'6H>'2>A'AC'9C7>K''&;'A=>?>'96?>?L'"=892B4B>?'4?'6B6IA4;<'A=>'?I>>9='AC' =4?'CF;'8?>L'ECH'>D>;'4E'=>'B4B';CA'4;D>;A'A=>'4B>6'=4?'9=6H69A>H'IC?4A?'=>'?A455' I=H6?>?'4A'4;'?89='6'F62'6?'AC'6??C946A>'4A'F4A='4A?'H>?85A?'4;'A=>'=4?ACH2K''&;'6BB4A4C;L' =892B4B>?'=C5B?'>D>;'7CH>'ICF>H'@2'B>94B4;<'F=49='?I>>9=>?'6H>'FCHA=' H>ICHA4;<'4;'=4?'=4?ACH2'6;B'F=49='AC'C74AK''"=>H>'6H>'IC4;A?'A=6A'6'?I>>9='FC85B' 9>HA64;52'=6D>'@>>;'<4D>;'F=>H>'"=892B4B>?';><5>9A?'AC'IH>?>;A'4A'\SKNP]L'6;B'65?C' ?C7>'?I>>9=>?'A=6A'6H> '8;4J8>'AC'6'9>HA64;'?I>6:>H'\NK[j R SU]L'F=49='6H>' 8;>XI>9A>BK''$D>;'A=>?>'8;>XI>9A>B'C74??4C;?'6;B'6BB4A4C;?'6H>'?4<;4E496;AL' @>968?>'A=>2'H>D>65'F=C?>'?I>>9=>?'"=892B4B>?'9C;?4B>H>B'FCHA='7>;A4C;4;?>'H>6?C;?L'A=>?>'?I>>9=>?'6H>'6'I6HA49856H52'I CF>HE85'?C8H9>'CE'4;ECH76A4C;'4;' "=892B4B>?^'FCH:K''"=>2'6H>'A=>'764;'ACC5'A=HC8<='F=49='=>'9C;D>2?'=4?'5>??C;L'6;B' 6H>'7>6;4;4H'CF;'H4<=A'@8A'65?C'4;'A=>4H'4;A>H69A4C;'F4A='>69=' CA=>H'6;B'4;'A=>4H'4;A>H69A4C;'F4A='"=892B4B>?0';6HH6A4D> K''12'4;B894;<'A=>'H>6B>H'AC' 6;652h>'>69='9=6H69A>H0?'?I>>9=>?'4;'A=>'9C;A>XA'CE'A=>'>;A4H>'FCH:L'"=892B4B>?' A>69=>?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'A=4;:'9H4A496552L'BH6F'9C;958?4C;?'6@C8A'A=>'8;B>H524;<'968?>?'

PAGE 16

13 CE'>D>;A?L'6;B'4;A>HIH>A'A=>'H>56A4C;?=4I'@>AF>>;'6'5>6B>H^?'B >94?4C;?'6;B'H>?85A?'4;' =4?'CF;'A47>K "=>'?I>>9=>?'A=>7?>5D>?'4;A>H69A';CA'C;52'F4A='A=>';6HH6A4D>L'@8A'65?C'F4A=' >69='CA=>HK''!55'A=>'?I>6:>H?'6AA>7IA'AC'IH>B49A'6;B'4;E58>;9>'A=>'C8A9C7>'CE'A=>' F6HL'6;B'A=>H>ECH>'A=>'?I>>9=>?'H>56A>'AC'>69='CA=>H'4;'?89 ='6'F62'6?'AC'9C;D>2' @HC6B>H'A=>7>?'A=HC8<=C8A'A=>'F6HK''+C7>'7CB>H;'?9=C56H?'=6D>'94A>B'A=>' 9C;;>9A4C;'@>AF>>;'A=>'?I>>9=>?'6?'>D4B>;9>'6<64;?A'6'54A>H65'H>9CHB4;<'@2' "=892B4B>? NT L'6;B'&'FC85B'6>'F4A='A=4?'4;A>HIH>A6A4C;K''"=892B4B>?'FH4A>?'A=>' ?I>>9=>? 'F4A='7CH>'6@?AH69A'56;<86<>'A=6;'FC85B'54:>52'=6D>'CH4<4;6552'@>>;'8?>BL' F=49='>;9C8H6<>?'=4?'H>6B>H'AC'7CH>'>6?452'B>B89>'<>;>H654h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i6
PAGE 17

14 B>96B>?'CE'A=>'F6HK''#>'54;:?'A=>'B>94?4C;?'CE'A=>?>'9=6H69A>H?'F4A='A=>'C8A9C7>'CE' A=>'F6H'4A?>5EL'F=>;'=>'95647?'A=6A'@2'A=>'>;B'CE'A=>'F6H'_$69='7692L'A=>2'>;B>B'@2'9C774AA4;<'>D>;'A=>'9C;B89A'CE'? A6A>'6EE64H?'AC'A=>'F=47?' CE'A=>'785A4A8B>_'\NKUj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j'1.$L'6;B'F'8I'B8H4;<'A=>',>H?46;'F6HK''&;'=4?'>6H52'A>>;?'=>' >D6986A>B'!A=>;?'F4A='A=>'H>?A'CE'A=>'94A4h>;H2'AC'?>>'4A'?'EHC7'6E6 H'6?' 4A'F6?'H6h>B'@2'A=>'4;D6B4;<',>H?46;'6H72K'',>H495>?'6?9>;B>B'AC'76;=CCB'6;B'AC' ICF>H'6A'A=>'@><4;;4;<'CE'A=>'A8785A8C8?'A47>'477>B46A>52'6EA>H'A=>'kH>>:'D49ACH2' 4;'A=>'F6H'6<64;?A',>H?46K''GHC7'A=>'4;9>IA4C;'CE'=4?'96H>>HL'8;A45'=4?'B>6A='B8H4;<' A=>' ,>5CIC;;>?46;'36HL',>H495>?'76;>8D>H>B'AC'76:>'!A=>;?'A=>'BC74;6;A'94A2 R

PAGE 18

15 ?A6A>'4;'kH>>9>'6;B'?8II56;A'+I6HA6'EHC7'4A?'98HH>;A'IC?4A4C;'6?'?89=K''#>'4?' H>;CF;>B'ECH'=4?'699C7I54?=7>;A?'BC;>'AC'4;9H>6?>'A=>'<5CH2'CE'!A=>;?t'@CA=' I=2?496552'@2'@845B4;<'ECHA4E4 96A4C;?'6;B'A>7I5>?L'6?'F>55'6?'IC54A496552L'@2'>XI6;B4;<' B>7C9H692'6;B'76;>8D>H4;<'ECH'BC74;6;9>'CD>H'655'A=>'CA=>H'kH>>:'94A2 R ?A6A>?K ,>H495>?'F6?';>6H'A=>'>;B'CE'=4?'54E>'6A'A=>'C;?>A'CE'A=>',>5CIC;;>?46;'36HK'' #>'?>HD>B'6?'<>;>H65'ECH'C;52'6'E>F'2>6H? '@>ECH>'B24;<'4;'A=>'I56<8>'4;'SNWK'' %>D>HA=>5>??L'"=892B4B>?'<4D>?'=47'A=H>>'?8@?A6;A465'?I>>9=>?L'4;'F=49='=>'<4D>?'=4?' CI4;4C;?'C;'A=>'7454A6H2'6;B'IC54A4965'?A6A8?'CE'!A=>;?K''&A'4?'95>6H'4;'=4?'ICHAH6265'CE' ,>H495>?'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'6A52'H>?I>9A>B', >H495>?'6;B'=4?'4B>6?K''GCH'A=4?'H>6?C;L' ,>H495>?'4?'A=>'7C?A'47ICHA6;A'E4<8H>'4;'A=>'=4?ACH2'AC'?A8B2L'6;B'=>'F455'@>'A=>'E4H?A' A=6A'&'>X674;>K "=>';>XA'764;'!A=>;46;'9=6H69A>H'4;'A=>'=4?ACH2'6EA>H',>H495>?'4?'.5>C;L'6';>F' ?CHA'CE'IC54A4946;L'F=C?>'H4?>' AC'ICF>H'F6?'76B>'IC??4@5>'@2'A=>'B>7C9H6A49'H>ECH7?' 8;B>HA6:>;'@2',>H495>?K''#>'B4B';CA'69=4>D>'=4?'IC?4A4C;'A=HC8<='=C5B4;<'CEE49>'4;'A=>' AH6B4A4C;65'F62L'CH'A=HC8<='=4?'H>56A4C;?=4I'AC'A=>'6H4?AC9H692K''.5>C;'F6?'C;>'CE'A=>' E4H?A'!A=>;46;?'AC'69=4>D>'IC F>H'?AH49A52'A=HC8<='=4?'6@454A2'AC'I>H?86B>'A=>' !A=>;46;'I>CI5>'\[K[UKU]L'76:4;<'8?>'CE'A=>';>F'4;?A4A8A4C;'CE'B>7C9H692K'')8>'AC' A=>';6A8H>'CE'=4?'6?9>;?4C;'AC'ICF>HL'=>'F6?'B4?54:>B'@2'76;2'CE'A=>'7CH>' AH6B4A4C;65'7>7@>H?'CE'A=>'8II>H'956??L'4;958B4;<'" =892B4B>?K''.5>C;'F6?'65?C' H4B4985>B'@2'CA=>H'68A=CH?L'?89='6?'!H4?ACI=6;>?L'?AH49A52'C;'A=>'@6?4?'CE'=4?'IC54A4965' A69A49?'6;B'@H8A65'I>H?C;654A2K !EA>H'.5>C;'B4>?L'!A=>;?'6;B'+I6HA6'6>'AC'6'AH89>':;CF;'6?'A=>',>69>'CE' %4946?'4;'SNN'1.K''"=>'AH89>'4?' ?C';67>B'6EA>H'A=>'!A=>;46;'<>;>H65 L '%4946?L'F=C'F6?'

PAGE 19

16 7CH>'7CB>H6A>L'AH6B4A4C;65L'6;B'968A4C8?'A=6;'.5>C;K''#>'F6?'6'<>;>H65'6A'A=>'?67>' A47>'6?'.5>C;L'6;B'H>764;>B'6'<>;>H65'6EA>H'.5>C;^?'B>6A=K''%4946?'5>B'6';87@>H'CE' >XI>B4A4C;?'6<64;?A'A=>'+I6HA6;?L'F=4 9=L'B8>'AC'=4?'968A4C8?L'2>A'9C7I>A>;A';6A8H>L' FC;';C'>;CH7C8?'D49ACH4>?L'6;B'?8EE>H>B';C'A>HH4@5>'B>E>6A?K NV ''"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?' %4946?'6?'6;'6B=>H>;A'AC',>H495>?^'CH4<4;65'4B>6?'6;B'IC5492K''%>D>HA=>5>??L'%4946?'4?' 8;6@5>'AC'9C;D4;9>'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>' AC'BC'6?'=>'6BD4?>?L'6;B'4?'CEA>;'>D>;'6EH64B' AC'69A'6?'=>'AH852'F4?=>?'ECH'E>6H'CE'A=>'I>CI5>^?'Z8B<7>;A'\TKSV]K'')8H4;<'=4?'I>69>L' %4946?'6AA>7IA?'AC'B4??86B>'A=>'!A=>;46;?'EHC7'@><4;;4;<'6;CA=>H'F6H'6<64;?A'A=>' 94A2 R ?A6A>?'CE'+49452L'6;B'E645?K "=>'56? A'!A=>;46;'9=6H69A>H'&'>X674;>'4?'!594@46B>?K''#>'4?'6'E567@C26;A'6;B' 67@4A4C8?'6H4?AC9H6AL'F=C'9C7I>A>?'4;'A=>'IC54A4965'6H>;6'6?'6<??4D>52'6?'4;'A=>' 9=6H4CA'H69>?'\UKPU]K''"=892B4B>?'F455'54;:'!594@46B>?'I>H?C;6552'F4A='!A=>;?^' BCF;E655'\UKPj]K''"=4?' 4?'F>55'?8IICHA>B'@2'A=>';6HH6A4D>L'6?'!594@46B>?'9C;D4;9>?'A=>' !A=>;46;?'AC'?A6HA'6'B6;<>HC8?'6;B'>XI>;?4D>'F6H'ECH'=4?'CF;'@>;>E4A'4;'+49452K''!EA>H' A=>'!A=>;46;'ECH9>'?>A?'?645'ECH'+49452L'!594@46B>?'4?'H>9655>B'C;'9=6H<>?'CE'H>54<4C8?' ?96;B65'\UKNV]K'' #>'>D>;A86552'B>E>9A?L'6;B'IHCD4B>?'6BD49>'AC'A=>'+I6HA6;?'\UKVW R W[]L' 6;B'>D>;'B>65?'F4A='A=>',>H?46;?'\VKSj R ST]K''' "=>'!H9'CE'!A=>;46;'(>6B>H?=4I "=892B4B>?'?=CF?'A=6A'A=>'IC5492'CE',>H495>?'@>ECH>'6;B'B8H4;<'A=>'@><4;;4;<' CE'A=>'F6H'F6?'A=>'@>?A'\NKUj] L'@8A'A=6A'B8H4;<'A=>'9C8H?>'CE'A=>'F6HL'!A=>;?' >D>;A86552'B>D46A>B'EHC7'4A?'CH4<4;65'IC5492L'6;B'5C?AK''#>'76:>?'95>6H'4;'A=>' ;6HH6A4D>'A=6A'=>'8?>?',>H495>?'6?'6'7>6?8H4;<'?A49:'6<64;?A'F=49='AC'9C7I6H>'655' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' NV Q.)L'PWWUL'POSP

PAGE 20

17 E8A8H>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4IL';CA4;<'A=6A'l&;',>H 495>?0'A47>'!A=>;?0'6A;>??'F6?'6A' 4A?'=>4<=Am'\NKUjKj]K'',>H495>?0'?AH6A><2'=6?'4;E58>;9>B'655'CE'"=892B4B>?0'A=4;:4;<' 6@C8A'=4?ACH2L'@CA='@>ECH>'6;B'6EA>H',>H495>?L'6;B'"=892B4B>?'8?>?'=4?'IC5492'6?'A=>' IC5492'AC'@>'474A6A>B'@2'A=C?>'F=C'FC85B'H>6B'6;B '5>6H;'EHC7'=4?'=4?ACH2K''12' 9C;AH6?A4;<'A=>'B>94?4C;?'6;B'?I>>9=>?'CE',>H495>?'F4A='A=C?>'CE'56A>H'!A=>;46;?L'F>' 96;'B4?9>H;'F=49='?I>6:>H?'=>5B'AC',>H495>?^'?AH6A><2L'6;B'F=49='B4D>H<>BK''12'A=>' >9=C4;<'CE'4B>6?'E4H?A'I8A'ECHA='4;',>H495>?^'?I>>9=>?L'A=> '9C77C;'IC5492'4?'E5C8A>B' 7CH>'6;B'7CH>'A=HC8<=C8A'A=>'#4?ACH2L'6;B'A=>'9C;?>J8>;9>?'A=6A'H>?85A'EHC7' E6458H>'AC'EC55CF'A=4?'IC5492'6H>'B>7C;?AH6A>BK "=4?'A=>?4?'>X674;>?'A=>'IC5492'"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?'A=HC8<=',>H495>?L'6;B' =CF'9C;?>98A4D>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H ?'95>6D>B'AC'CH'B>D46A>B'EHC7'A=4?'IC5492K''"=>?>' 5>6B>H?'6H>'?=CF;'AC'6>'CH'B4?6>'F4A=',>H495>6;'IC5492';CA'C;52'@2'A=>4H' 69A4C;?L'@8A'65?C'@2'A=>4H'FCHB?L'6;B'F>'F455'>X674;>'=CF'"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?'>69=' 5>6B>H'AC'H>E5>9A'=4?'?A6;9>K''&;'.=6IA>H'Q; >L'&'C8A54;>'A=>'IC5492',>H495>?'E4H?A' B>D>5CI?L'6;B'B>7C;?AH6A>'=CF'"=892B4B>?'?=CF?'=4?'?8IICHA'CE',>H495>?'6;B'=4?' IC5492K''&'F455'>X674;>'>69='CE',>H495>?^'A=H>>'?I>>9=>?'4;'A8H;L'6;B'B>A>H74;>'F=49=' :>2'4B>6?'EHC7'>69='?=C85B'@>';CA>B'AC'9C7I6H>'F4A=' E8A8H>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?K''&' B>7C;?AH6A>'6'?AHC;<'6>7>;A'6;B'9C;;>9A4C;'@>AF>>;'"=892B4B>?0'6;B',>H495>?0' CF;'4B>6?L'F=49='4?'9H>6A>B'A=HC8<='A=>'?47456H4A4>?'@>AF>>;'A=>4H'?I>>9='6;B' ;6HH6A4D>L'A=HC8<='9C7I6H4?C;'CE',>H495>?0'?I>>9=>?'F4A='CA=>H'?I>>9=> ?'4;'A=>' 4;AHCB89A4C;L'6;B'A=HC8<='"=892B4B>?0'B>54@>H6A>'>;BCH?>7>;AK''"=>'9C;;>9A4C;' @>AF>>;'"=892B4B>?'6;B',>H495>?'4?'>XAH>7>52'47ICHA6;A'AC'A=>'FCH:'4A?>5EL'6;B'F455' @>'9>;AH65'AC'72'A=>?4?K''1CA='"=892B4B>?'6;B',>H495>?'<4D>'A=>4H'CF;'H>J84H>7>;A?'

PAGE 21

18 EC H'6'6B>HL'6;B'@>968?>'CE'A=>'?AHC;<'9C;;>9A4C;'6;B'?8IICHA'@>AF>>;' "=892B4B>?'6;B',>H495>?L'4A'@>9C7>?'95>6H'A=6A'A=>4H'9C7@4;>B'9H4A>H46'F455'@>'A=>' 7>AH49'@2'F=49='655'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?'F455'@>'7>6?8H>BK''&;'A=4?'F62L'&'?=CF' A=6A'"=892B4B>?' 4;B89>?'=4?'H>6B>H'AC'9C7I6H>'655'CA=>H'5>6B>H?'AC',>H495>?K &;'.=6IA>H'"FC'&'C8A54;>'A=>'IC5492'CE'.5>C;L'6;B'?=CF'=CF'=>'@><4;?'AC' B>D46A>'EHC7',>H495>?^'IC5492K''&'?=CF'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'H>IH>?>;A?'.5>C;'6?'A=>' @><4;;4;<'CE'A=>'B>954;>'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H ?=4IK''.5>C;'C;52'=6?'C;>'?I>>9='4;'A=>' =4?ACH2L'6;B'A=6A'?I>>9='4?'4;'6'B>@6A>'F4A='6;CA=>H'!A=>;46;'IC54A4946;K NW '12'<4D4;<' .5>C;'6'?I>>9='C;52'EHC7'6'B>@6A>L'"=892B4B>?'B4H>9A?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'B>A>H74;>' F=49='CE'.5>C;^?'4B>6?'6H>'H>6?C;6@5>L'6;B'F=49='6H>' 8;H>6?C;6@5>L'@2'9C7I6H4;<' A=>'IC4;A?'76B>'@2'.5>C;'F4A='A=C?>'CE'=4?'CIIC;>;AK''&'?=CF'A=6A'A=>';6HH6A4D>'65?C' H>D>65?'A=6A'.5>C;'E645?'AC'7>>A'A=>',>H495>6;'9H4A>H46'CE'5>6B>H?=4I'A=6A'=6D>'@>>;' >?A6@54?=>BK''"=>';6HH6A4D>'ICHAH62?'.5>C;'6?'4;E>H4CH'AC'C A=>H'<>;>H65?L'!A=>;46;' 6;B'+I6HA6;L'6;B'4;'?C'BC4;<'=4<=54<=A?'A=>'<6I'@>AF>>;'.5>C;0?'FCHB?'6;B'=4?' 69A4C;?K''&'?=CF'A=6A'.5>C;'?>HD>?'6?'6'@H4B<>'4;'A=>'6H9'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4IL'EHC7' A=>'@>?AL',>H495>?L'AC'A=>'FCH?AL'!594@46B>?K''"=892B4B>?'BC>?'A=4? '@2'8?4;<'A=>' B676<>'968?>B'@2'.5>C;^?'4;9C7I>A>;9>'6?'6'IH>98H?CH'AC'A=6A'968?>B'@2'!594@46B>?^' 67@4A4C;K &;'.=6IA>H'"=H>>'&'C8A54;>'A=>'IC5492'CE'!594@46B>?'4;'A=>'+494546;'$XI>B4A4C;L' 6;B'>X674;>'=CF'=>'=6?'9C7I5>A>52'H>D>H?>B'!A=>;46;'IC5492'EHC7',>H4 95>?^'CH4<4;65' I56;K''&'65?C'9C7I6H>'=47'F4A='=4?'9C;A>7ICH6H2'<>;>H65L'%4946?L'6;B'>XI564;'F=2' %4946?L'6H<84;<'ECH',>H495>6;'IC5492L'4?'8;6@5>'AC'I>H?86B>'=4?'!A=>;46;'68B4>;9>L'@8A' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' NW "=4 ?'IC54A4946;'4?';67>B')4CBCA8?L'6;B'=>'6II>6H?';CF=>H>'>5?>'4;'A=>'=4?ACH2L'CH'4;'6;2'CA=>H' >XA6;A'54A>H6A8H>K')>'*C74552L'PWU[L'PUO

PAGE 22

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lIC??>??4C;'ECH'655'A47>m'\PKNNKS]K'' M2'A=>?4?'9C;E4H7?'A=>'?4<;4E496;9>'CE'A=>'5>??C;'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'=6?'A68<=A'A=HC8<=' A=>?>'764;'9=6H69A>H?Y'A=6A'F>'E8A8H>'<>;>H6A4C;?'96;'5>6H;'EHC7'A=>'I6?AL'6;B'BC' ;CA';> >B'AC'5>6H;'EHC7'F6H'lGCH'F6H'4?'6'=6H?='A>69=>Hm'\[KVNKN]K '

PAGE 23

20 .=6IA>H'Q;> ,>H495>?'F6?'69A4D>'6?'6'<>;>H65'6;B'6'IC54A4946;'4;'A=>'2>6H?'5>6B4;<'8I'AC'A=>' ,>5CIC;;>?46;'F6HK [O '')8H4;<'A=4?'I>H4CB'=>'76B>'6A'699C7I54?=7>;A?'4;' E8HA=>H4;<'A=>'>XI6;?4C;' CE'>7I4H>'6;B'A=>'54@>H654h6A4C;'CE'B>7C9H692K [P ''#>' 6II>6H?'4;'"=892B4B>?0'=4?ACH2'6A'A=>'@><4;;4;<'CE'A=>'F6HL'@8A'6A'A=>'>;B'CE'=4?' 96H>>HK''#>'I562?'6'HC5>'4;'A=>'=4?ACH2'C;52'4;'A=>'A=H>>'?I>>9=>?'A=6A'=>'<4D>?L'@8A'=4?' IC5492'CE'6'B>E>;?4D>'F6H'6;B'=4 ?'?AH6A><2'CE';6D65'?8I>H4CH4A2'A=6A'=>'C8A54;>?'6H>' A=>'98574;6A4C;'CE'B>96B>?'CE'>XI>H4>;9>'4;'A47>?'CE'@CA='F6H'6;B'I>69>K'&'F455' B>7C;?AH6A>'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'9C;;>9A?',>H495>?^'IC5492'AC'=4?'CF;'6;652?4?'CE'A=>' F6HL'?8IICHA?',>H495>?^'IC5492'F4A='A=>'4B >6?'4;'=4?'CF;'4;AHCB89A4C;L'6;B'9C;958B>?' A=6A',>H495>?^'?AH6A><2'4?'?AHC;<>H'A=6;'A=>'?AH6A><2'CE'=4?'?899>??CH?K''3>'F455'@><4;' AC'?>>'EHC7',>H495>?^'E4H?A'6II>6H6;9>'A=6A'=4?'4B>6?'4;E58>;9>B'"=892B4B>?^'CF;'F62' CE'A=4;:4;<'6@C8A'5>6B>H?'4;'A=>'!A=>;46 ;'I6?AK''12'A=>'A47>',>H495>?'B4>?L'4A'4?'95>6H' A=6A'"=892B4B>?'F455'8?>',>H495>?^'4B>6?'4;'=4?'Z8B<7>;A'CE'5>6B>H?'4;'A=>'!A=>;46;' E8A8H>'6?'F>55K "=892B4B>?'<4D>?';C'CA=>H'!A=>;46;'6'?I>>9='F=45>',>H495>?'4?'654D>K''"=4?'4?' ?4<;4E496;AL'@>968?>'!A=>;?'4 ?'6'B>7C9H692L'6;B'CA=>H'IC54A4946;?L'4;958B4;<'.5>C;L' 6H>'69A4D>'4;'I8@549'54E>'F=45>',>H495>?'4?'?A455'654D>K''!;2'!A=>;46;'94A4h>;'9C85B'?I>6:' 4;'A=>'!A=>;46;'6??>7@52L'?C'4;'H>654A2L',>H495>?'FC85B'=6D>'@>>;'C;>'CE'76;2'AC' ?I>6:'C;'7C?A'C996?4C;?K''%>D >HA=>5>??L'4;'=4?'FCH:L'"=892B4B>?'IH>?>;A?'C;52' ,>H495>?0'?I>>9=>?'4;'A=>'6??>7@52K''12';><5>9A4;<'CA=>H'!A=>;46;'?I>6:>H?'4;' ,>H495>?^'A47>L'"=892B4B>?'H>4;ECH9>?'=4?'C@?>HD6A4C;'A=6A',>H495>?'4?'_A=>'E4H?A'76;' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' [O )>'*C74552L'PWU[L'PPOK [P "H692L'NOOWL'jK

PAGE 24

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vw`wpvbc bv xcwr yvp z{ycfdeb`e L' vdwr zv |sc bc| sdrbc| epzdcg ed}{ '\^ A=>' H>?85A'F6?'4;'A=>CH2'B >7C9H692'@8A'4;'E69A'H85>'@2'A=>'E4H?A'76;^'NKUjKW]K'"?6:76:4?L'PU[L'NOOUK [S )>'*C74552L'PWU[L'PP[K

PAGE 25

22 &;'A=4?'?>9A4C;L'&'F455'?=CF'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?',>H495>?'6?'A=>'4B>65' 5>6B>HK''M2'6;652?4?'F455'H>D>65'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'9C;;>9A?'=4?'CF;'4B>6?'4;'A=>' ;6HH6A4D>'F4A=',>H495>?^'4B>6?'4;'=4?'?I>>9=>?K''"=4?'4?'47ICHA6;A'@>968?>'"=8 92B4B>?' H6H>52'4;?>HA?'=4?'CF;'CI4;4C;'6;B'6;652?4?'4;AC'A=>'=4?ACH2K''&;?A>6BL'&'IHCD>'A=6A'=>' 8?>?',>H495>?'6?'6'9C;B84A'ECH'=4?'4B>6?K''"=4?'9H>6A>?'A=>'B865'>EE>9A'A=6A',>H495>?' 6>?'F4A='"=892B4B>?^';6HH6A4D>L'6;B'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'6>?'F4A=',>H495> ?^' CH4<4;65'4B>6?K''"=4?'655CF?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'6IIHC69='A=>'H>764;B>H'CE'A=>'=4?ACH2'F4A=' 6'B>E4;4A>'ICHAH64A'CE'"=892B4B>?^'CIA4765'5>6B>HK''34A='6'E4H7'4B>6'CE'F=6A' 9=6H69A>H4h>?'A=>'@>?A'5>6B>HL'A=>'H>6B>H'4?'>;9C8H6<>B'AC'9C7I6H>'?8@?>J8>;A' 5>6B>H?'AC', >H495>?L'AC'B>A>H74;>'=CF'6'5>6B>H'96;''IH>94?>' 9C;?>J8>;9>?'6H>K "=HC8<=',>H495>?^'?I>>9=>?L'6;B'=4?'CF;';6HH6A4D>L'"=892B4B>?'>?A6@54?=>?' A=>'?I>94E49'9H4A>H46'CE'5>6B>H?=4I'A=6A',>H495>?'IC??>??>?L'A=6A'CA=>H?'?=C85B' >7856A>L'6;B' @2'F=49='E8A8H>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?'F455'@>'Z8B<>BK'',>H495>?'54?A?'6;B' >XI564;?'?C7>'CE'A=>?>'9H4A>H46'=47?>5E'@8A'?C7>'CE'A=>'9H4A>H46'762'@>'B>B89>B'EHC7' A=>'IH>9>B>;A?'A=6A',>H495>?'?>A?K''#>'?>A?'6;'>X67I5>'4;'@CA='FCHB'6;B'B>>BL' B>54@>H6A>52'>XAC554;<'= 4?'CF;'@>=6D4CH?'A=6A'=>'B>>7?'7C?A'47ICHA6;AL'F=45>'6A'A=>' ?67>'A47>L'5>6D4;<'8;7>;A4C;>B'76;2'74;8A46>'A=6A'6H>'?A455'@>;>E49465K''!55'A=>?>' ECH7'6'54?A'CE'9H4A>H46'A=6A'FC85B'@2'4A?>5E'@>'?8EE494>;A'AC'BH6F'6'?A6H:'9C;AH6?A' @>AF>>;',>H495>?'6;B'E8A8H>'! A=>;46;'5>6B>H?K''&;'6BB4A4C;'AC'A=>?>'9H4A>H46'A=6A' ,>H495>?'B4H>9A52'CH'4;B4H>9A52'>?A6@54?=>?'A=HC8<='=4?'CF;'?I>>9=>?L'"=892B4B>?' 6BB?'=4?'CF;'9H4A>H46'A=HC8<='=4?';6HH6A4D>L'4;'A=>'>85C<2'A=6A'=>'<4D>?',>H495>?K

PAGE 26

23 "=892B4B>?'>XI5494A52'>;BCH?>?'A=>'IC5 492'A6:>;'@2',>H495>?'4;'=4?'>85C<2'AC' =47'_4;'=4?'A47>'~!A=>;?^'6A;>??'F6?'6A'4A?'=>4<=A_'\NKUjKj]L'6;B'9C;B>7;?'A=>' IC5492'A6:>;'@2'=4?'?899>??CH?'_34A='=4?'?899>??CH?'4A'F6?'B4EE>H>;AKKK'~"=>2' IHCB89>B'6'=C?A'CE'@58;B>H?_'\NKUjKPO R PP]K''"=892B4B>?' >XI5494A52'54;:?'A=>'E655'CE' !A=>;?'AC'A=>'!A=>;46;?^'E6458H>'AC'9C;A4;8>'EC55CF4;<',>H495>?^'6BD49>'6EA>H'=4?' B>6A=K''"=4?'>85C<2'4?'8;8?865L'4;'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'B4??>?'EHC7'=4?'8?865';6HH6A4D>' A>9=;4J8>'CE'5>6B4;<'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'BH6F'=4?'CF;'9C;958?4C;? K''"=>'>EE>9A'A=6A'A=4?' B4??4C;'9H>6A>?'4?';CA'?C'789='A=6A'A=>'H>6B>H'?8BB>;52'@>9C7>?'9C;D4;9>B'A=6A' ,>H495>?'4?'6'?AHC;<'5>6B>HL'?4;9>'A=4?'=6?'65H>6B2'@>>;'A=CHC8<=52'>?A6@54?=>B'@2'A=4?' IC4;AK''*6A=>HL'@2'B4??4;<'@>ECH>'=>'9C;A4;8>?'F4A='=4?'8?8 65';6HH6A4D>L' "=892B4B>?'H>4;ECH9>?'A=>'_<>;48?_'CE',>H495>?^'ECH>?4<=A'\NKUj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

PAGE 27

24 ?I>>9='AC'9C7I5>A>'A=>'ICHAH64A'CE'4B>65'5>6B>H?=4IK''"=HC8<=C8AL'&'B>7C;?AH6A>'A=>' 54A>H6H2'7>9=6;4?7?'@2'F=49='"=892B4B>?'?=CF?'=4?'6>7>;A'6;B'?8IICHA'CE' ,>H495>?'6;B'=4?'4B>6?K +>9A4C;'Q;> ,>H 495>?'E4H?A'6BBH>??>?'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>'4;'6'?I>>9='A=6A'8H<>?'A=>7'AC' @><4;'6'F6H'F4A='+I6HA6K''&;'A=4?'?I>>9=L',>H495>?'B>?9H4@>?'A=>'H>65'B6;<>H?'+I6HA6' IC?>?'AC'!A=>;?L'@8A'6A'A=>'?67>'A47>'=>'>XI564;?'6;'!A=>;46;'9C8;A>H R ?AH6A><2'F4A=' CIA474?A49'=CI >?K'',>H495>?'I=H6?>?'=4?'?AH6A><2'4;'CIA474?A49'A>H7?'@>968?>'=>' :;CF?'A=6A'F6H'4?'_;>9>??6H2_'\PKPSSK[]L'6;B'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'78?A'76:>' ?69H4E49>?'4;'CHB>H'AC'?A6;B'6'9=6;9>K''#>'76:>?'4A'95>6HL'A=C8<=L'A=6A'!A=>;46;' 9=6;9>?'6H>'9C;B4A4C;65Y''_&E'A=>2' 76H9='6<64;?A'C8H'9C8;AH2'F>'F455'?645'6<64;?A' A=>4H?_'\PKPS[KS]K'',>H495>?'?A6:>?'655'CE'A=>'!A=>;46;?^'9=6;9>?'4;'A=>'F6H'C;'A=>4H' ;6D65'6@454A4>?L'@8A'A=4?'4?';CA'A=>'C;52'H>J84H>7>;A'=>'<4D>?'ECH'D49ACH2K''#>'65?C' 95647?'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;?'F455'C;52'=6D>' 9=6;9>?'_4E'2C8'96;'9C;?>;A';CA'AC'9C7@4;>' ?9=>7>?'CE'EH>?='9C;J8>?A'F4A='A=>'9C;B89A'CE'A=>'F6HL'6;B'F455'6@?A64;'EHC7' F455E8552'4;DC5D4;<'2C8H?>5D>?'4;'CA=>H'B6;<>H?_'\PKPSSKP]K''"=4?'4?'A=>'BC74;6;A' A=>7>'CE',>H495>?^'E4H?A'?I>>9=K''"=>'!A=>;46;?'78?A'H >?I>9A'A=6A'A=>'+I6HA6;?'=6D>' >J865'9=6;9>?L'6;B'A=>H>ECH>'A=>'!A=>;46;?'78?A'9C774A'A=>7?>5D>?'AC'A=>'F6H' F=C5>=>6HA>B52L'6;B'@>9C7>';>4A=>H'B4?AH69A>B';CH'CD>H9C;E4B>;AK''"=4?'4?'A=>' 9H4A4965'H>J84H>7>;A'ECH'!A=>;46;'D49ACH2'A=HC8<=C8A'A=>'F6HL'6;B'"=892 B4B>?'H>E>H?' @69:'AC'A=4?'IC4;A'4;'76;2'CE'A=>'56A>H'?I>>9=>?K "=892B4B>?'IH>I6H>?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'?>>'6>7>;A'@>AF>>;',>H495>?^'4B>6?' 6;B'=4?'CF;'@2'=6D4;<',>H495>?'H>I>6A'@6?49'E69A?'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'=6?'65H>6B2'?A6A>B'

PAGE 28

25 4;'A=>';6HH6A4D>K'1>ECH>'A=>'F6HL'A =>'+I6HA6;?'?>;B'=>H65B?'AC'!A=>;?'F4A='?I>94E49' B>76;B?L'A=H>6A>;4;<'!A=>;?'F4A='F6H'4E'A=>2'H>E8?>'AC'9C7I52K [j ''G4H?AL'"=892B4B>?' =47?>5E'54?A?'A=>'+I6HA6;'B>76;B?'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'?ACI'A=>4H'?4><>'CE',CA4B6>6L' H>?I>9A'A=>'4;B>I>;B>;9>'CE'!><4;6L'H>DC: >'A=>4H'>7@6H<6H6L'6;B' E4;6552'I>;B>;9>'AC'A=>'#>55>;>?L'A=6A'4?L'655'CE'k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kH>>:?'=6D>'8?>B'AC'69=4>D>'ICF>H'\PKPj]K [U ''#>' 9 4A>?'A=>'6;94>;A':4;<'M4;C?'6?'A=>'E4H?A'H85>H'AC'>?A6@54?='6';6D2L'F=49='655CF?'=47' AC'9C;AHC5'A=>'>;A4H>'#>55>;49'?>6'\PKS]K''#>'95647?'A=6A'ECH'6'F=45>'I4H692'F6?' IH>D65>;A'6;B'>D>;'6'H>?I>9A>B'IHCE>??4C;'A=HC8<=C8A'kH>>9>'\PKj R T]K''#>'65?C' 95647?'A=6A' !<67>7;C;'F6?'6@5>'AC'H6552'A=>'kH>>:?'AC<>A=>H'4;'A=>'"HCZ6;'F6H';CA' @>968?>'CE'A=>'C6A=?'A=>4H'5>6B>H?'=6B'A6:>;L'6?'#C7>H'?64BL'@8A'@>968?>'CE'A=>' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' [j '_ "=>'ECH7'4;'F=49='A=>'B>76;B'F6?'A=HCF;'F6?'>D>;'FCH?>'A=6;'4A?'?8@?A6;9>K''"=>'+I6HA6;?' F>H>'4;';C'IC?4A4C;'AC'B49A6A>'AC'!A=>;?L'6;B'!A=>;?'9C85B';CA'6 99>IA'?89='CHB>H?'F4A=C8A'6B74AA4;<' A=>'95647'CE'+I6HA6'AC'69A'6?'6'?CD>H>4<;'94A2K_'!@@CAAL'PWTOL'NOSK [U \PKV R W]L'G4;5>2L'PSNL'PWU[K

PAGE 29

26 477>;?>'?AH>;?'95>6H52' >?A6@54?=>?'6'?AHC;<';6D2 '6?'A=>'7C?A'47ICHA6;A'6??>A'CE'6'k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

PAGE 30

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€''"=892B4B>?'4?'6@5>'AC'=6D>'A=>?>'?I>6:>H?'6;?F>H'C;>'6;CA=>H'4;' ?89='6'E6?=4C;'6?'A=>'?I>6:>H?'A=>7?>5D>?'9C85B';CA' =6D>'4;'A=>4H'69A865'?I>>9=>?K'' ,>H495>?L'A=C8<='=>'762'=6D>':;CF;'A=6A'A=>'.CH4;A=46;?'?>;A'6;'>7@6??2'AC'+I6HA6L' FC85B';CA'=6D>':;CF;'>X69A52'F=6A'A=>2'?64B'AC'A=>'+I6HA6;'6??>7@52L'6;B'E8HA=>HL' FC85B';CA'@>'6BBH>??4;<'A=>'?67>'68B4>;9>L'?C'A=>H>'4?';C'H >6?C;'ECH'=47'AC'6;?F>H' A=>'.CH4;A=46;'95647?'IC4;A'ECH'IC4;A'4;'A=>'F62'=>'BC>?'4;'=4?'?I>>9=K''3=6A'A=>;'4?' A=>'>EE>9A'CE',>H495>?'H>?IC;B4;<'AC'A=>'IC4;A?'H64?>B'@2'!H9=4B678?'6;B'A=>' .CH4;A=46;?'4;'6'+I6HA6;'6??>7@52L'F=>;',>H495>?'4?'?I>6:4;<'AC'6;'!A =>;46;' 68B4>;9>€ ,>H495>?'H>?IC;B?'AC'A=>'IC4;A?'76B>'4;'A=>'+I6HA6;'6??>7@52'F4A='A=>'H>?85A' A=6A'=>'I>H?86B>?';CA'C;52'=4?'CF;'68B4>;9>'@8A'65?C'"=892B4B>?^'68B4>;9>L'A=>' H>6B>HL'F=C'=6?'H>6B'@CA='?4B>?'CE'A=>'6H<87>;AK'',>H495>?'9C;958B>?'A=>'6H<87>;A'

PAGE 31

28 <> ;>H6A>B'4;'A=>'+I6HA6;'6??>7@52 'F4A=C8A'>XI5494A52'I6HA494I6A4;?' ICHAH62?',>H495>?'6?'9H>B4@5>'6;B'68A=CH4A6A4D>'@2'654<;4;<'=47'F4A='A=>'F4?>L'6;B' 7CB>H6A>'+I6HA6;'9C776;B>HL'!H9=4B678?K''#>'4?'6@5>'AC'6;?F>H'>69='CE'A=>' 6H<87>;A?'CE'A=>'.C H4;A=46;?'IC4;A'@2'IC4;AL'6;B'4;'A=4?'F62'B4?I>5?'655'A=>' H>6?C;6@5>'9C8;A>H6H<87>;A?'6<64;?A'=4?'CF;'?AH6A><2K''"=>'7C?A'ICF>HE85'>EE>9A' "=892B4B>?'9H>6A>?'@2'9C;958B4;<'A=>'B>@6A>'F4A=',>H495>?0' ?I>>9= '4?'A=6A',>H495>?' =6?'A=>'56?A'FCHB'@>ECH>'A=>'?A6HA' CE'A=>'F6H'\PKPSj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h>;?'A=6A'!A=>;?'C8<=A';CA''6H<87>;A?'CE'A=>?>'.CH4;A=46;?K''"=892B4B>?'BC>?';CA'IH>?>;A'6;2'6H<87>;A'@2'6;'!A=>;46;'A=6A' !A=>;?'?=C85B';CAL'968 ?>'CE'A=4?L'699CHB4;<'AC'@CA='"=892B4B>?'6;B' ,>H495>?L'A=6A'!A=>;?'?=C85B''9C;958?4C;K'')>'*C74552L'PP[L'PWU[K

PAGE 32

29 F=49='9C85B' @>'BC;>'F4A='E>F>HL'?47I5>H'FCHB?L'@8A'=>'65?C'4;B4H>9A52'H>E>H?'AC'A=>' B>94?4C; R 76:4;<'IHC9>??'4;'A=>'!A=>;46;'B>7C9H692'6;B'AC'=4?'CF;'?A6A8?'4;'!A=>;?K'' "=HC8<=',>H495>?L'"=892B4B>?'BH6F?'6'I6H655>5'@>AF>>;'6'?4;<5>'9C8;945' 9=67@>H'6;B'6'B49A6ACHL'6?' F>55'6?'6'9C;??'6;B'6'B>7C9H692K''34A='A=4?'4;'74;BL'4A' 4?'H>76H:6@5>'A=6A'A=>'9C;??'CE'+I6HA6'4?'9H4A494h>B'4;'6'?I>>9='<4D>;'AC'6' B>7C9H6A49'6??>7@52K'',>H495>?'47I54>?'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;'6??>7@52'4A?>5E'?8EE>H?' EHC7'A=>'E685A?'CE'6'9C;??L'6;B'=> '65?C'47I54>?'A=6A'C;>'76;'=6?'A=>'6BD6;A6<>?'CE' A=>'?4;<5>'9C8;945'9=67@>HK''&;'A=4?'F62',>H495>?'<4D>?'6;'6H<87>;A'6<64;?A' B>7C9H692'6;B'ECH'C54<6H9=2K''"=4?'?A6A>7>;A'Z8?A4E4>?'EC55CF4;<'C;>'B>94?4C; R 76:>HL' ;67>52',>H495>?L'H6A=>H'A=6;'6'56H<>L'B4D4B>BL 'B>94?4C; R 76:4;<'@CB2L'A=>'!A=>;46;' 6??>7@52K "=4?'47I5496A4C;'4?'H>4;ECH9>B'@2'"=892B4B>? '?A6A>7>;A?'@>ECH>'6;B'6EA>H' ,>H495>? '?I>>9=K'',>H495>?'4?'E4H?A'4;AHCB89>B'6?' "=>'E4H?A'76;'CE'=4?'A47>'6A'!A=>;?L' 6@5>?A'654:>'4;'9C8;?>5'6;B'4;'69A4C; '\PKP[WK S]K''!EA>H'=4?'?I>>9=L'F=>;'A=>' !A=>;46;?'E4;6552'B>94B>'F=49='9C8H?>'CE'69A4C;'AC'A6:>L'A=>2' DCA>B'6?'\,>H495>?]' B>?4H>BL'6;B'6;?F>H>B'A=>'+I6HA6;?'6?'=>'H>9C77>;B>BL'@CA='C;'A=>'?>I6H6A>' IC4;A?'6;B'4;'<>;>H65 '\PKPSj]K''"=>';6HH6A4D>'ICHAH62?',>H495>?'6 ?'=6D4;<'6A' 4;E58>;9>'CD>H'A=>'B>94?4C;?'CE'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>L'?C'789='?C'A=6A'A=>2'EC55CF'=4?' 6BD49>'>X69A52K''3=>;',>H495>?'95647?'A=6A'6'?4;<5>'9C8;945'4?'96I6@5>'CE'B>94B4;<' 7CH>'>XI>B4>;A52L'4A'74HHCH?'A=>'!A=>;46;? 'CF;'B>94?4C;'AC'EC55CF'=4?'CF ;'?4;<856H' 9C8;945K "=>'E4H?A'6;B'7C?A'C@D4C8?'I8HIC?>'CE'A=4?'?I>>9='4?'AC''!A=>;46;?'AC' F6HK''"=>'?>9C;B'I8HIC?>'4?'AC'9C;D>2'A=>''CE'A=6A'F6HK''

PAGE 33

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~!A=>;46;?'6?' 8@><91 '\PKPSPKj]K''#>'6B74A?' A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'F455'5C?>'789='CE'A=>4H'56;B?L'@>968?>'B4H>9A'@6AA5>'F4A='A=>' +I6HA6;?'FC85B'@>'A6;A67C8;A'AC'?8494B>K''3=6A'4?'7CH>L'>D> ;'4E'A=>'!A=>;46;?' ?=C85B'<64;'6'D49ACH2'CD>H'A=>'+I6HA6;?L'A=>2'FC85B'?A455'=6D>'AC'E69>'A=>'?67>' 7454A6H2'6;B';87>H4965'?8I>H4CH4A2'4;'A=>';>XA'@6AA5>L'F=>H>6?'?=C85B'A=>2'5C?>L'A=>2' ?A6;B'AC'5C?>'A=>'?8IICHA'CE'A=>4H'6554>?'\PKPS[Kj]K''&;'=4?'9C;958?4C; L'=>'9C7I6H>?'A=>'

PAGE 34

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t'6;B'A=>'?I>>9='4;'1CC:'&L'F=49=';C' C;>'4?'?=CF;'6?'9C;AH6 B49A4;<'6;B'>D>H2'94H987?A6;9>'?>HD>?'AC'9CHHC@CH6A>L'A=8?'C998I4>?'6'D>H2' >X9>IA4C;65'IC?4A4C;'4;'A=>'IH>5474;6H2'B4?98??4C;?Y'4A'?A6;B?'A=>H>'6?'6'95>6H'B>7C;?AH6A4C;'CE'A=>' 4B>6?'F=49='=>'9C;?4B>H>B'7C?A'47ICHA6;AK''&A'A=8?'IHCD4B>?'8?'F4A='6'E4H7'6;B'F >55 R >?A6@54?=>B'IC4;A' CE'B>I6HA8H>K_')>'*C74552L'PNOL'PWU[

PAGE 35

32 96I6@454A2'6;B'5474A?K SO ''#6D4;<'>?A6@54?=>B'A=>?>'5474A?'=>H>L'"=892B4B>?'?=CF?'4;' =4?'56A>H';6HH6A4D>'A=6A'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?'B4?H><6HB'A=>7K +>9A4C;'"FC "=>'?>9C;B'?I>>9=',>H495>?'<4D>?'4?'A=>'E67C8?'E8;>H 65'CH6A4C;'6A'!A=>;?' 6EA>H'A=>'E4H?A'2>6H'CE'A=>'F6HK''"=>'B>54D>H2'CE'6'E8;>H65'CH6A4C;'6A'A=>'9C;958?4C;'CE' A=>'2>6H'F6?'!A=>;46;'98?AC7L'6;B'"=892B4B>?'?A6A>?'A=6A'4A'4?'EC55CF>B'A=HC8<=C8A' A=>'F6HK''%>D>HA=>5>??L',>H495>? '?I>>9='4?'A=>'C;52'?89='>85C< 2'<4D>;'4;'A=>'>;A4H>' =4?ACH2K''3=6A'4?'A=>'>EE>9A'CE'"=892B4B>?'<4D4;<'C;52',>H495>? '?I>>9=L'6;B'5>6D4;<' C8A'>D>H2'CA=>H'E8;>H65'CH6A4C;'4;'?8@?>J8>;A'2>6H?'CE'A=>'F6H€''&A'4?'AH8>'A=6A'C;9>' "=892B4B>?'=6?'>?A6@54?=>B'A=>'E69A'A=6A'6'E8;>H65'CH6A4C;'4?'9 8?AC76H2'=>';>>B';CA' 4;958B>'C;>'ECH'>D>H2'2>6HK''"=4?'76:>?'?>;?>'F=>;'F>'9C;?4B>H'A=6A'?89='6'?I>>9=' FC85B';CA';>9>??6H452'6BB'6;2';>F'4;ECH76A4C;'AC'A=>';6HH6A4D>L'@8A',>H495>?' ?I>>9='BC>?'9H>6A>'6;'47ICHA6;A';6HH6A4D>'>EE>9AK''!'E8;>H65'CH6A4C;'98?AC7 6H452'4?' <4D>;'9C;9>H;4;<'A=>'B>>B?'CE'CA=>H'!A=>;46;'<>;>H6A4C;?'\NK[UKS]L'F=49='4?' 8;47ICHA6;A'AC'"=892B4B>?'\PKPKP]K'',>H495>?L'=CF>D>HL'@H>6:?'EHC7'>?A6@54?=>B' AH6B4A4C;'4;'=4?'CF;'E8;>H65'CH6A4C;K''#>'BC>?'4;B>>B'IH64?>'I6?A'<>;>H6A4C;?' 699CHB4;<'AC'9 8?AC7L'@8A'J849:52'J8654E4>?'A=4?'@2'956474;<'A=6A'I6?A'69=4>D>7>;A?' BC';CA'9C7I6H>'F4A='A=>'69=4>D>7>;A?'CE'A=>'IH>?>;A'<>;>H6A4C;'\NK[UK[]K''GHC7'A=4?' IC4;AL'=>'7CD>?'C;'AC'C8A54;>'A=>'6A;>??'CE'!A=>;?'4;'=4?'CF;'B62L'B8>'AC'H>9>;A' 9=6;<>?'4;'4A?' H;7>;A L '6'B>7C9H692'\NK[T]K''&A'4?'54:>52'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'4;958B>?' ,>H495>?^'E8;>H65'CH6A4C;'@>968?>'4A'@H>6:?'EHC7'AH6B4A4C;L'6;B'9C;?4B>H?'ACI49?';CA' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' SO _"=>'9C7@4;6A4C;'CE'@CA='B>E4;>?'6'D>H2'A=CHC8<='?2?A>7'6;B'6'95>6H'IC54A4965'6AA4A8B>K''&A'?>>7?L' 7CH>CD>HL'A=6A'A=4?'IC54A4965'6AA4A8B>'96;'@>'H>9C<;4h>B'@CA='6?'6;'68A=>;A49'4;B496A4C;'CE',>H4 95>?^' 4B>6?L'6;B'6?'A=>'>XIH>??4C;'CE'6'IC5492'F=49='"=892B4B>?'=47?>5E'9C;?4B>H>B'6'D654B'C;>K_')>' *C74552L'PPUL'PWU[

PAGE 36

33 ;CH76552'9CD>H>B'4;'6'I8@549'E8;>H65K''"=892B4B>?'4;958B>?'C;52',>H495>?^'CF;'?I>>9=' AC'I64;A'6'I49A8H>' CE'!A=>;?'@>ECH>'A=>',>5CIC;;>?46;'36HK SP ''"=4?'4?'6'I49A8H>'CE' 6A' IHC?I>H4A2 'A=6A'4?'8;H4D65>B'A=HC8<=C8A'A=>'6;94>;A'FCH5B'6;B'F455'@>' B>B'6;B'B>?AHC2>B'@2'A=>'F6HK "=>'IHC?I>H4A2'CE'!A=>;?'6A'A=>'?A6HA'CE'A=>'F6H'?>HD>?'6?'6;CA=>H'7>AH49'@2' F=49 ='AC'9C7I6H>'A=>'?899>??'CE'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?'6<64;?A',>H495>?K' "=892B4B>?L'4;',>H495>?0'E8;>H65'CH6A4C;L'IHCD>?'A=6A',>H495>?'4?'6A'A=>'I>6:'CE'A=>'6H9' CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4IL'@2'B>7C;?AH6A4;<'A=>'IC?4A4D>'9C;?>J8>;9>?'CE'=4?'H85>' @>ECH>'A=>'F6HL'6; B'>?A6@54?=4;<'A=>'IHC?I>H4A2'6;B'J8654A2'CE'54E>'6A'!A=>;?L'6<64;?A' F=49='!A=>;?'4;'A=>'E8A8H>';6HH6A4D>'96;'@>'9C7I6H>BK''"=892B4B>?'76:>?'8?>?'CE' ,>H495>?0'?I>>9='=>H>'AC'9C;A4;8>'?AH>;;4;<'A=>'9C;;>9A4C;'@>AF>>;'=47?>5E'6;B' ,>H495>?L'6;B'AC'B>7C;?A H6A>'A=6A',>H495>?L'6;B'!A=>;?'4;',>H495>?0'A47>L'6H>' l>B896ACH?m'\NKSPKP]'CE'"=892B4B>?0'68B4>;9>K ,>H495>?'@><4;?'=4?'G8;>H65'QH6A4C;'4;'A=>'98?AC76H2'76;;>HY'=>'IHC95647?' A=>'6A;>??'CE'!A=>;46;'6;9>?ACH?L'4;'F=C?>'F6:>'A=>'98HH>;A'?C5B4>H?'AH>6BK''' #>' J849:52'B>D46A>?'EHC7'AH6B4A4C;L'A=C8<=L'4;'A8H;4;<'=4?'IH64?>'EHC7'A=>'7>;'CE'A=>' B4?A6;A'I6?A'AC'A=>'7>;'CE'=4?'CF;'A47>L'>D>;'2'6H>' 7CH>'IH64?>FCHA=2K''"2I496552L'A=>'6A'7454A6H2'D49ACH4>?'CD>H'A=>',>H?46;?L'CH'>D>;' CE'A=>'D49ACH2'6<64;?A'6'?8IIC?>B'!76h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jSL'PWU[

PAGE 37

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kH>>:' 94A2 R ?A6A>L'=>'6H<8>?'A=6A'A=4?'6A;>??'7>6;?'A=6 A'!A=>;46;?'=6D>'7CH>'6A'?A6:>'4;' F6H'A=6;'A=>4H'>;>74>?K'',>H495>?'?62?'A=6A'4;B4D4B865'!A=>;46;'?C5B4>H?'78?A'H>?4?A' A>7IA6A4C;'AC'E5>>'@69:'AC'A=>4H'58X8H4>?'6A'=C7>L'@8A'7CH>'?8@A52L'6;B'7CH>' 47ICHA6;A52L'=>'47I54>?'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'6H>'H4?:4;<'7CH>' F=>;'A=>2'4H'>;>74>?K''+4;9>'A=>2'H4?:'6'5CA'F=>;>D>H'A=>2'2'78?A'6DC4B'F6H'8;5>??'A=>H>'4?'6'9>HA64;'<64;'AC'@>';'EHC7'E4<=A4;' A47>'CE',>H495>?L'A=>'F6H'4?'Z8?A4E4>B'@2'A=>'E69A'A=6A'A=>'+I6HA6 ;?'4;?A4<6A>B'4A'6;B' 4;D6B>B'A=>'A>HH4ACH2'CE'!A=>;?K''!EA>H',>H495>?'B4>?L'A=>'H>6?C;4;<'ECH'9C;A4;84;<'A=>' F6H'@>9C7>?'@58HH>BL'6;B'A=>'!A=>;46;?'>D>;'6AA>7IA'AC'@><4;'6';>F'F6H'6<64;?A' +49452K'''&;'A=4?'F62L'F=>;',>H495>?'8H<>?'C;'!A=>;46;?'AC';CA'?=H4; :'EHC7'A=>' ;>9>??6H2'F6H'4;'=4?'CF;'B62L'=>'47I54>?'A=6A'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;?'?=C85B'6DC4B'56A>HL' 8;;>9>??6H2'F6H?K Q;9>'=>'A8H;?'=4?'68B4>;9> ?'6AA>;A4C;'6F62'EHC7'A=>'7454A6H2'<5CH2'CE'I6?A' <>;>H6A4C;?L'=>'6H<8>?'A=6A'A=>'<5CH2'CE'A=>'7>;'F=C'B4>B'A=4?'2>6H '4?';CA'B8>'AC'6;2' IHCF>??'4;'@6AA5>L'@8A'H6A=>H'ECH'A=>'4B>65'ECH'F=49='A=>2'EC8<=AL'A=>'B>7C9H6A49'94A2' ECH'F=49='A=>2'EC8<=AL'!A=>;?K'',>H495>?'?A6A>?'A=6A'A=>'7454A6H2'D49ACH4>?'CE'=4?'CF;'

PAGE 38

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h>;?'CH'ECH>4<;>H?L'762'54?A>;'F4A='6BD6;A6<> L'"=892B4B>?'4;B496A>?'A=6A'A=>H>' 4?'6'5>??C;'AC'@>'A6:>;'EHC7',>H495>? '8I9C74;<'FCHB?L'6;B'A=>'H>6B>H'4?'IH>I6H>B'AC' <64;'F=6A>D>H' 6BD6;A6<> '=>'762'EHC7',>H495>? '?I>>9=K ,>H495>?L'4 77>B46A>52'6EA>H'956474;<'A=6A'A=>'6A;>??'CE'!A=>;?'4?'A=>' IHCI>H'?8@Z>9A'CE'=4?'?I>>9=L'?A6A>?'A=6A'!A=>;?'4?'C8A?A6;B4;<'@>968?>'4A'4?'6' B>7C9H692K'',>H495>?'95647?'A=6A';CA'C;52'4?'A=>';>F'6;B'98HH>;A'!A=>;?'6A>H'A=6;' 4A?'IH>B>9>??CHL'@8A'A=6A'4A' 4?'6A>H'A=6;'6;2'CA=>H'kH>>:'94A2 R ?A6A>K'',>H495>?'>X65A?' !A=>;?'CD>H'4A?'ECH7>H'=4?ACH2'6;B'CD>H'CA=>H'kH>>:'H;7>;A?'@2'94A4;<'A=>' >J8654A2'@>ECH>'A=>'56F'AC'655'94A4h>;?L'6;B'A=>'6@454A2'CE'4A?'I>CI5>'AC'6BD6;9>'@6?>B' C;'7>H4A'H6A=>H'A=6;'F>65A='C H'@4HA=K''#>'9C;A4;8>?'@2'956474;<'A=6A'B>7C9H692' ;46;?';CA'C;52'6A>H'>J8654A2'6;B'54@>HA2L'@8A'65?C'6'6A>H'?A6;B6HB'CE' 54D4;H495>?'65?C'>;87>H6A>?'A=>'?>9C;B6H2'@>;>E4A?'CE'A=>'B>7C9H692L' ;67>52L'A=6A'54E>'4?'?A455'D>H2'>;ZC26@ 5>'ECH'A=>'!A=>;46;'94A4h>;'B>?I4A>'A=>'?899>??'

PAGE 39

36 6;B'47ICHA6;9>'CE'!A=>;?K''!55'A=>?>'9C;?4B>H6A4C;?'762'@>'>6?452'A6:>;'ECH'B' @2'A=>'7CB>H;'H>6B>HL'2>A'6A'A=>'A47>'?89='CIICHA8;4A2'6;B'>J8654A2'F6?';CD>5'6;B' 8;:;CF;K''3>'74<=A';CF'?8H74?>'6;CA=>H'7CA 4D6A4C;'ECH'"=892B4B>?'AC'4;958B>'A=4?' ?I>>9='4;'=4?'#4?ACH2Y'4A'I64;A?'6'I49A8H>'CE'!A=>;46;'IHC?I>H4A2'@>ECH>'A=>'F6HK'' !A=>;?'4?'ICHAH62>BL'@>ECH>'A=>'?A6HA'CE'A=>'F6HL'6?'6'6A'94A2'@>968?>'CE'4A?' C8A?A6;B4;<'4;A>H;65'H;7>;AL';CA'@>968?>'CE'6;2'> XA>H;65'6<??4C;K SN '' ,>H495>?0'4B>6'CE'<5CH2'?A6;B?'4;'?A6H:'9C;AH6?A'AC'A=>'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?0' 9C;9>IA4C;'CE'<5CH2L'F=>H>@2'A=>2'F455'>XI5C4A'A=>'!A=>;46;'B>7C9H692'AC'I8H?8>' A=>4H'CF;'?AL'A=8?'?8@D>HA4;<'@CA='A=>',>H495>6;'4B>6?'CE' 6'?AHC;<' B>7C9H692'6;B'6'B>E>;?4D>'F6H'IC5492K ,>H495>?'9C;A4;8>?L'6EA>H'?=CF4;<'A=>'?8I>H4CH4A2'CE'!A=>;?'C8AH4<=AL'@2' 9C7I6H4;<'!A=>;?'F4A='+I6HA6K''+I6HA6;'94A4h>;?'6H>'@HC8<=A'8I'EHC7'@4HA='AC'@>' ?C5B4>H?L'6;B'6H>'655'H64?>B'8;B>H'A=>'9H8>5>?A'6;B'?AH 49A>?A'9C;B4A4C;?K''"=>'+I6HA6;' 54E>'4?'789='7CH>'6'54E>'ECH'+I6HA6'A=6;'6'54E>'ECH'C;>?>5EK'',>H495>?'6H<8>?'A=6A'F=45>' A=>'!A=>;46;?'A>;B'AC'5>6B'7CH>'>;ZC26@5>'6;B'I5>6?6;A'54E>'A=6;'A=>'+I6HA6;?L'A=>2' 6H>';CA';>9>??6H452'4;E>H4CH'F=>;'4A'9C7>?'AC'F6HK' '"=>'+I6HA6;? 54D>'6'=6H?='54E>' 9C;?A6;A52L'@8A'A=4?'C;52'H>?85A?'4;'A=>4H'>XI>H4>;94;<'A=>'=6HB?=4I?'CE'F6H'@>ECH>' A=>2'6H>';>9>??6H2K'',>H495>?'6H<8>?'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'BC';CA'?8EE>H'=6HB?=4I?' @>ECH>'A=>2';>>B'ACL'6;B'2>A'@>968?>'CE'A=>4H'5CD>'CE'!A=>;? L'6H>'?A455'Z8?A'6?'F4554;<'AC' E4<=A'F=>;'A=>'A47>'9C7>?'\NK[WKS]K''!;CA=>H'4;A>HIH>A6A4C;L'A=C8<=L'4?'A=6A'@>2C;B' A=>'9C7I6H4?C;'F4A='+I6HA6L',>H495>?'>7I=6?4h>?'AC'=4?'68B4>;9>'A=6A'A=>'<>;>H6A4C;' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' SN ,>H495>?'4?'96H>E85'AC';CA'?8<<>?A'A=6A'!A=>;?^'6A;>??'4?'6;'>X98?>'AC'Z8?A4E2'>XI6;?4C;4?7'CH' 47I>H4654?7K''#>'C;52'?=CF?'A=6 A'A=>'?CD>H>4<;'94A2'A=6A'H85>?'A=>'>7I4H>'4?'6AL';CA'A=6A'A=4?' 6A;>??'Z8?A4E4>?'9C;J8>?AK''GCH'6'B>A645>B'6;652?4?'CE'A=4?'4B>6L'?>>')>'*C74552L'P[O R PSOL'PWU[K

PAGE 40

37 CE'!A=>;46;?'F=C'54D>B'477>B46A>52'@>ECH>'A=>4H'CF;'6DC4B >B'A=>'=6HB?=4I?'CE' 8;;>9>??6H2'F6H?L'54D4;<'4;'I>69>'ECH'CD>H'6'B>96B>K''"=6A'4?L'!A=>;46;?'4;',>H495>? B62'B4B';CA'E>;B>B'A=>7?>5D>?'F=>;>D>H'B6;<>H' 6HC?>K''Q;9>'6<64;L',>H495>?'H>E>H?'AC'=4?'B>E>;?4D>'F6H'?AH6A><2L'6 ;B'H>4;ECH9>?'4A'@2' 9C;;>9A4;<'4A'AC'A=>'IC5492'CE'C5B>H'!A=>;46;'<>;>H6A4C;?K''#>'65?C'=4;A?'A=6A' !A=>;46;?'4;'A=>';>6H'E8A8H>'F455'?>I6H6A>'EHC7'A=>'B>E>;?4D>'!A=>;46;'AH6B4A4C;K ,>H495>?'?'C;'AC'9C7I6H>'!A=>;? '7>A=CB'CE'B>94?4C; R 76:4;<'F4A=' +I6HA6 ?K''#>'95647?'A=6AL'8;54:>'A=>4H'>;>74>?L'!A=>;46;?'B>54@>H6A>'6;B'B4?98??' @>ECH>'A=>2'69AK''%>D>HA=>5>??L'A=4?'B4?98??4C;'BC>?';CA'B474;4?='A=>'?I>>B'CH' B>A>H74;6A4C;'CE'A=>4H'69A4C;K'',>H495>?'65?CL'4;'A=4?'?>9A4C;L'95647?'A=6A'!A=>;?'655CF?' 4A?'94A4h>;? 'AC'B>D>5CI' :;CF5>B<>'F4A=C8A'>EE>74;692 L'6?'F>55'6?' F>65A='ECH'8?>' H6A=>H'A=6;'ECH'?=CF ''\NK[WKP]K''#>'65?C'95647?'A=6A'!A=>;?'<4D>?'AC'4A?'EH4>;B?' ;CA' EHC7'9659856A4C;'CE'>XI>B4>;92L'@8A'4;'A=>'9C;E4B>;9>'CE'54@>H654A2 '\NK[WKj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l"=>'G8;>H65'QH6A4C;'4;D4A>?'9C7I6H4?C;L'@CA='4;'?47456H4A2'6;B'9C;AH6?A'F4A=L'6;B'A=8? '?>HD>?'6?'6' IHC9>'ECHL'A=>' !012345 '6?'6'F=C5>K''&A?'IC?4A4D>'A>;CH'F455'@>'KKK'B4?76;A5>B'?2?A>76A496552' 4;'A=>'H>764;B>H'CE'A=>'FCH:Km'*66E568@L'PWNL'NOOUK

PAGE 41

38 A=>'E8A8H>L'=>'?87?'8I'=4?'CF;'6H<87>;A?Y' &;'?=CHAL'&'?62'A=6A'6?'6'94A2'F>'6H>'A=>' ?9=CC5'CE'#>556?t '\NKSPKP ] '"=4?'4?'A=>'IC4;A'AC'F=49 =',>H495>?'=6B'@>>;'5>6B4;<'8I' 6;B'@845B4;<'ACF6HB'A=HC8<=C8A'=4?'F=C5>'?I>>9=L'A=6A'!A=>;?'4?'A=>'>X67I5>'A=6A' A=>'H>?A'CE'kH>>9>'?=C85B'EC55CFL'6;B'6?'"=892B4B>?'47I54>?L'A=6A'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;?' ?=C85B'65?C'EC55CFK''"=4?'4?'6;'>XAH>7>52'?4<;4E496;A'?A6A>7> ;A'@>968?>'>D>;'@>2C;B' 9C;;>9A4;<',>H495>?'6;B'"=892B4B>?'F4A='H><6HB'AC'A=>4H'IC5492'6;B'4B>6?'CE' 5>6B>H?=4IL'4A'65?C'9C;;>9A?'A=>7'F4A='H><6HB'AC'A=>'4B>6'A=6A',>H495>?L'6;B'!A=>;?'4;' ,>H495>?0'A47>L'6H>'A>69=>H?'\PKNNKS]K'',>H495>?'6;B'!A=>;?'4;'=4?'B62 '6H>'>X67I5>?L' ;CA'Z8?A'ECH'A=>'H>?A'CE'kH>>9>L';CA'Z8?A'ECH'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;?L'@8A '65?C 'ECH'A=>'H>6B>HL' 6;B'ECH'655'A47>K ,>H495>?';CF'9C;958B>?'A=>'?>9A4C;'CE'=4?'?I>>9='A=6A'B>?9H4@>?'A=>'9=6H69A>H' CE'!A=>;?L'>XI564;4;<'A=6A'=4?'4;A>;A4C;'F6?'E4H?A' AC' ?=CF'A=6A'C8H'?A6:>'4;'A=>' ?AH8<<5>'4?';CA'A=>'?67>'6?'A=>4H?'F=C'=6D>';C'?89='@5>??4; \NKSNKP]L'6;B' ?>9C;B'AC'?>HD>'6?'6'>85C<2'CD>H'A=>'!A=>;46;'?C5B4>H?K'',>H495>?'4?'96H>E85'AC'76:>' A=>'IC4;A'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'=6D>'789='7CH>'6A'?A6:>L'789='7 CH>'AC'5C?>'A=6;'A=>4H' >;>74>?K''#>'A=>;'IH64?>?'A=>'E655>;'?C5B4>H?'D>=>7>;A52'ECH';CA'E54;9=4;<'EHC7'@6AA5>' 4;'A=>'=CI>'CE'>;ZC24;<'A=>'@>;>E4A?'CE'!A=>;?'?>5E4?=52K''#>'95647?'A=6A'A=>'<5CH2'CE' B24;<'4;'@6AA5>'AC'B>E>;B'?89='6'94A2'6?'!A=>;?'4?'6?'6A '6?'6;2K''&A'4?'D>H2'47ICHA6;A' AC';CA>'A=6A',>H495>?'C;52'IH64?>?'A=>'B>6B'?C5B4>H?L'A=>';CH765'85C<2L'6EA>H' =>'=6?'>?A6@54?=>B'A=6A'A=>'94A2'ECH'F=49='A=>2'B4>B'F6?'6AK'',>H495>?'76:>?'95>6H' A=6A'A=>'<5CH2'CE'E655>;'?C5B4>H?'4?'9C;B4A4C;65'8 IC;'A=>'968?>'ECH'F=49='A=>2'B4>K''&E' !A=>;?'?=C85B';CA'@>'B>7C9H6A49L'4E'!A=>;?'?=C85B'@>'8;Z8?AL'4E'!A=>;?'?=C85B'@>' >XI>B4>;A'F=>H>'4A'C8<=A'AC'@>'54@>H65L'A=>;'?C5B4>H?'F=C'E4<=A'6;B'B4>'ECH'!A=>;?'

PAGE 42

39 5>6D>'@>=4;B';C'<5CH2K''"=4?'C;9>'6<64;'6;A494I6A>?'6; B'ECH>?=6BCF?'A=>'69A?'CE' E8A8H>'5>6B>H?L'6;B'H>I>6A?'A=6A'A=>4H'9C;J8>?A?'F455';CA'4;9H>6?>'A=>'<5CH2'CE'!A=>;?K ,>H495>?'9C;958B>?'A=>'H>?A'CE'A=>'>85C<2'@2'H>74;B4;<'=4?'68B4>;9>'CE'A=>' 6A;>??'CE'!A=>;?L'H>I>6A4;<'A=6A'A=C?>'F=C'?69H4E49>B'A=>7?>5D> ?'B>?>HD>'6;B' H>9>4D>'A=>'6A>?A'<5CH2L'6;B'8H<4;<'=4?'68B4>;9>'AC'?AH4D>'AC'76A9='A=>4H'6A;>??K'' #>'CEE>H?'9C7ECHA'AC'A=>'@>H>6D>B'H>56A4D>?L'H>74;B?'A=>'68B4>;9>'A=6A'A=>'9=45BH>;' CE'A=>'E655>;'?C5B4>H?'F455'@>'@HC8<=A'8I'6A'I8@549'>XI>;?>L'6;B'A=>; 'A>55?'A=>' 68B4>;9>'A=6AL'=6D4;<'9C;958B>B'A=>4H'567>;A6A4C;L'A=>2'762'B>I6HA'\NKSU]K !?'F>'=6D>'?>>;L'A=>'?I>>9='I64;A?'6'I49A8H>'CE'!A=>;?'6;B'!A=>;46;'IC5492' @>ECH>'A=>'F6HK''"=892B4B>?'=6?',>H495>?'8?>'?I>94E49'56;<86<>'AC'ICHAH62'A=>' 9=6H69A>H'CE'!A= >;?'A=6A'=>'F455'8?>'6<64;'F=>;'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?'B>D46A>' EHC7'A=4?'?AH6A><2K''&;'.=6IA>H'"FC'&'>X674;>'=CF'A=>'!A=>;46;?'76:>'B>94?4C;?' @6?>B'C;' >XI>B4>;92 'H6A=>H'A=6;'6'?>;?>'CE' 54@>H654A2 K''&;'.=6IA>H'"=H>>'&' >X674;>'=CF'A=>'!A=>;46;?'69A'B6H4 ;<52'@8A'F4A=C8A'B>54@>H6A4C;K +>9A4C;'"=H>> ,>H495>?'76:>?'=4?'A=4HB'6;B'E4;65'?I>>9='AC'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>'4;'=4?'CF;' B>E>;?>K SS ''"=>'?8EE>H4;'!A=>;46;?'4;'A=>'E4H?A'2>6H?'CE'A=>'F6H'F>H>'>D>;' 6A>H'A=6;'A=C?>',>H495>?'=6B'IH>B49A>BK''&;'6BB4 A4C;'AC'5C?4;<'A=>4H'56;B?'C8A?4B>' CE'A=>'94A2'F655?'AC'A=>'4;D6B4;<'+I6HA6;?L'A=>'>;A4H>'ICI856A4C;L'=6D4;<'E5>B'4;AC'A=>' 94A2L'F6?'H6D6<>B'@2'6'I56<8>K''"=>'9C;B4A4C;?'4;'!A=>;?'B8>'AC'CD>H9HCFB4;<'6;B' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' SS &A'4?';CA>FCHA=2'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'4;958B>?',>H495>?^'?I>>9='=>H>L'ECH'AFC'H>6?C;?K'' G4H?AL'A=>'?I>>9=' F6?'8;?899>??E85'4;'9C;D4;94;<'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>';CA'AC'@567>',>H495>?L'6?'=>'F6?'E4;>B'6;B' H>7CD>B'EHC7'CEE49>K''+>9C;BL',>H495>?'H>?A6A>?'=4?'CH4<4;65';6D65'IC5492'A=6A'=>'=6?'65H>6B2'<4D>;'4;' =4?'E4H?A'?I>>9=K''!?'&'F455'?=CF'4;'A=4? '?>9A4C;L'"=892B4B>?L'A=HC8<='A=>'4;A>H69A4C;'CE'A=4?'?I>>9='F4A=' =4?'>85C<2L'C8A54;>?'A=>'H>J84H>7>;A?'ECH'6'6B>HK''_#>'?>>7?'AC'=6D>'@>>;'I6HA49856H52'6;X4C8?' AC'6AAH69A'=4?'H>6B>H?^'6AA>;A4C;'AC'9>HA64;'6?I>9A?'CE',>H495>?^'IC54A4965'4B>6?'9C;?4B >H>B'ECH'A=>4H'CF;' ?6:>K_')>'*C74552L'PNOL'PWU[

PAGE 43

40 B4?>6?>'F>H>'?C'A>HH4@5>L'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'F4?=>B' AC'?8>'A=>'+I6HA6;?'ECH'I>69>L' 6;B'@567>B',>H495>?'ECH'655'CE'A=>4H'AHC8@5>?K'',>H495>?L'A=C8<=';CA'ECH>?>>4;<'A=>' >XA>;A'CE'A=>'74?>H2'!A=>;?'FC85B'?8EE>H'EHC7'A=>'F6HL'=6?'ECH>?>>;'A=6A'A=>' ICI8569>'FC85B'=C5B'=47'699C8;A6@5>'ECH'F=6A>D>H'?8EE>H4;2 '>;B8H>B' \NKj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t'6;BL'?>9C;BL'!A=>;46;?'E69>'8;;>9 >??6H2'H4?:?' 4;'6;'6<??4D>'F6H'H><6HB5>??'CE'A=>'6??8H6;9>?'6;B'6BD6;A6<>?'A=>2'IC??>??K'' ,>H495>? '56?A'?I>>9='9C;958B>?'A=>'IC4;A?'B>D>5CI>B'4;'A=>'IH>D4C8?'AFCL'H>4A>H6A4;<' A=>'H>J84H>7>;A?'A=6A'6'5>6B>H'@>'7CB>H6A>'6;B'IH8B>;AL'6;B'6BB4;<'A=>' H>J84H >7>;A'A=6A'6'5>6B>H'@>'I>H?86?4D>K''"=4?'H>?85A?'4;'A=>'I49A8H>'CE'6;'4B>65' 5>6B>HL'6<64;?A'F=49='E8A8H>'!A=>;46;?'F455'@>'9C7I6H>B'4;'A=>'H>?A'CE'=4?'FCH:K "=>'E4H?A'IC4;A',>H495>?'76:>?'4?'A=>'47ICHA6;9>'CE'A=>'9C77C;F>65A='CD>H' 6;2'4;B4D4B865K''#>'6H<8 >?'A=6A';C'76AA>H'=CF'F>55'CEE'C;>'76;'4?L'4E'=4?'?A6A>'4?' H84;>B'A=>;'=>'=47?>5E'4?'6?'F>55K''3=6A'4?'7CH>L'=>'95647?' 6'?A6A>'96;'?8IICHA'A=>' 74?ECHA8;>?'CE'IH4D6A>'94A4h>;?L'F=45>'A=>2'96;;CA'?8IICHA'=>H? '\NKUOKS]K''#>'8H<>?'

PAGE 44

41 A=>'!A=>;46;?'AC';CA'@>'B4? 9C8H6<>B'@2'A=>4H'CF;'IH4D6A>'6;B'A>7ICH6H2' 74?ECHA8;>?L'6;B'5CC:'AC'A=>'9C77C;'?6E>A2'CE'A=>'94A2K''#>'65?C'H>IHC69=>?'A=>7'ECH' @>4;<'6;'H>6?C;?K''G4H?AL'A=>2'F>H>'A=>'C;>?'F=C'DCA>B'ECH' F6HL'6;B'?C'=>'B4B';CA=4;<'F4A=C8A'A=>4H'C F;'9C;?>;AK''+>9C;BL'=>'F6?'6;B'4?'A=>' 7C?A':;CF5>B<>6@5>'<>;>H65L'6;B'=>'F6?'9CHH>9A'4;'=4?'Z8?A4E496A4C;'CE'6;B'?AH6A><2' ECH'A=>'F6H'4;'A=>'@><4;;4;H>ECH>L'A=>H>'4?';C'H>6?C;'AC'A=4;:'A=6A'=4?'6BD49>'4?' FHC;<';CFL'?47I52'@>968?>'A=>2'=6D>'>;9C8;A> H>B'7CH>'B4EE4985A4>?'A=6;'A=C?>' >XI5494A52'IH>B49A>BK ,>H495>?'>XI564;?'AC'=4?'68B4>;9>'A=6A'6'5>6B>H'4;'<>;>H65'78?A':;CF'F=6A'4?' @>?A'ECH'=4?'I>CI5>L'6;B'78?A'I>H?86B>'A=>7'AC'69A'4;'A=>4H'@>?A'4;A>H>?A?K''&;'A=>' 477>B46A>'9C;A>XA'CE',>H495>?'Z8?A4E24; <'=4?'B>94?4C;?L',>H495>?0'?A6A>7>;A'=>H>'4?'6' B>E>;?>'CE'=4?'B>94?4C;?'@6?>B'C;'A=>'95647'A=6A'=>':;CF?'@>AA>H'A=6;'=4?'!A=>;46;' 68B4>;9>'F=6A'4?'4;'A=>4H'@>?A'4;A>H>?AK'',>H495>?'<>;>H654h>?'E8HA=>H'A=6;'4?';>9>??6H2' ECH'=4?'CF;'B>E>;?>L'A=C8<=L'>XI564;4 ;<'l!'76;'IC??>??4;<'A=6A':;CF5>B<>'F4A=C8A' A=6A'E6985A2'CE'>XIC?4A4C;'74<=A'6?'F>55'=6D>';C'4B>6'6A'655'C;'A=>'76AA>HY'4E'=>'=6B' @CA='A=>?>'<4EA?L'@8A';C'5CD>'ECH'=4?'9C8;AH2L'=>'FC85B'@>'@8A'6'9C5B'6BDC96A>'ECH'=>H' 4;A>H>?A?t'F=45>'F>H>'=4?'I6AH4CA4?7';C A'IHCCE'6<64;?A'@H4@>H2L'>D>H2A=4;<'FC85B'm'\NKUOKU]K''#>H>',>H495>?'>?A6@54?=>?'A=>'<>;>H65'9H4A>H46'ECH'5>6B>H?=4I'@2' F=49='AC'9C7I6H>'E8A8H>'5>6B>H?Y':;CF5>B<>L'I>H?86?4D4A2L'6;B'5C265A2K''"=892B4B>?' =47?>5E'>56@CH6A>?'C;'A=>?>'H>J84H>7>;A ?'4;'=4?'C@4A86H2'AC',>H495>?L'>XI564;4;<'A=6A' ,>H495>?'F6?'8;4J8>'67C;<'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?'4;'A=6A'=>'5>B'A=>'785A4A8B>L'H6A=>H' A=6;'F6?'5>B'@2'A=>7'\NKUjKV]K',>H495>?'9C85B'9C;D4;9>'A=>'!A=>;46;?'AC'?>>'H>6?C;' F=>;'A=>2'F>H>'>4A=>H'ACC'I>??474?A49'CH'AC'CI A474?A49'\NKUjKW]K''#>'F6?'65?C'?>98H>'

PAGE 45

42 4;'=4?'CF;'ICF>HL'8;54:>'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;?K''"=892B4B>?'H>D>65?'A=6A'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;' 5>6B>H?'F455L'4;'CHB>H'AC'4;9H>6?>'A=>4H'CF;'ICF>H'F4A=4;'A=>'!A=>;46;'?2?A>7L'96A>H' AC'A=>'47I85?4D>'F=47?'CE'A=>'785A4A8B>'\NKUjKPP ]K''MCH>'47ICHA6;A52L'"=892B4B>?' >XI5494A52'9C7I6H>?'6;B'9C;AH6?A?',>H495>?'F4A='E8A8H>'!A=>;46;'<>;>H65?'4;'?89='6' F62'6?'AC'ECH9>'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'7>6?8H>'>69='C;>'6<64;?A',>H495>?K''"=4?'9C7I6H4?C;L' 6;B'A=>?>'9H4A>H46'>?A6@54?=>?'@2',>H495>?'6;B'"=892B4B>? L'6H>'9H89465'AC' 8;B>H?A6;B4;<'A=>'H>56A4C;?=4I'@>AF>>;',>H495>?'6;B'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;?L'6;B'6H>'A=>' 7C?A'47ICHA6;A'ACC5'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'8?>?'4;'A>69=4;<'A=>'H>6B>HK 34A='H><6HB'AC'F6HL',>H495>?'H>4A>H6A>?'A=6A'A=>4H?'4?';>9>??6H2L'@8A';CF'=>' 76:>?'6;CA=>H' 95647'A=6A'F455'@>'>XAH>7>52'47ICHA6;A'56A>H'4;'A=>'=4?ACH2Y'' GCH' A=C?>'CE'9C8H?>'F=C'=6D>'6'EH>>'9=C49>'4;'A=>'76AA>H'6;B'F=C?>'ECHA8;>?'6H>';CA'6A' ?A6:>L'F6H'4?'A=>'6A>?A'CE'EC554>? '\NKUPKP]K''&;'A=4?'?I>>9=',>H495>?'?62?'C8AH4<=A' F=6A'=>'=6B'@>>;'= 4;A4;<'4;'=4?'E8;>H65'CH6A4C;Y'4E'!A=>;?'9C85B'6DC4B'F6HL'6;B'6DC4B' H4?:4;<'4A?'9C;?4B>H6@5>'H>?C8H9>?L'A=>;'4A'?=C85BK'',>H495>?'95647?'A=6A'7>;'F=C' F4554;<52'H4?:'F=6A'A=>2'=6D>'69J84H>B'6H>'?A8I4B'6;B'@567>FCHA=2K''&;'A=>4H'IH>?>;A' 96?>L'A=C8<=L'A=>2'78 ?A'H495>?'6H<8>?L'=>H>L'ECH'6'IC5492'CE'H>?AH64;A'4;' A47>?'CE'IHC?I>H4A2L'6;B'B>E46;9>'4;'A47>?'CE'=6HB?=4It'A=4?'4?'A=>'F62'A=6A'4?'@>?A'ECH' A=>'94A2L'6;B'4?'95>6H'AC'A=C?>'F=C'IC??>??'ECH>?4<=AK''3=>;',>H495>?'956H4E4>?'A=4?'4B>6' EHC7'=4?'? >9C;B'?I>>9=L'=>'A4>?'A=>'4B>6?'EHC7'655'CE'=4?'?I>>9=>?'AC<>A=>HL'6;B' ?A6A>?'A=6A'E8A8H>'!A=>;46;?'F=C'9C;A4;8>'AC'I8H?8>'F6H'F=>;'A=>2'9C85B'>?A6@54?=' I>69>'6H>'8;B>HA6:4;<'lA=>'6A>?A'CE'EC554>?m'\NKUPKP]K ,>H495>?'H>4A>H6A>?'A=>'IC4;A?'A=6A'=>'76B>' 9C;9>H;4;<'!A=>;46;'?AH6A><2'6;B' !A=>;46;'9=6;9>?'4;'=4?'E4H?A'?I>>9=K''!A=>;46;?'?=C85B'>XI>9A'D49ACH2'@6?>B'C;'A=>4H'

PAGE 46

43 9C;AHC5'CE'A=>'?>6L'?C'5C;<'6?'A=>2'H>764;'?A>6BE6?A'6;B'B>E>;?4D>'C;'56;BK''"=>'5C??' CE'A=>4H'E4>5B?'6;B'=C8?>?'C;'A=>'56;B'4?';CA'6?'?4 <;4E496;A'6?'A=>4H'9C;AHC5'CE'AH6B>' 6;B';6D4>?'C;'A=>'?>6K''#>'6BB?'6';>F'E69ACHL'A=C8<=L'F=>;'=>'95647?' AC'5C?>'F=6A' C;>'=6?''B4?E85'A=6;'AC'@>'A=F6HA>B'4;'<>AA4;< '\NKUNK[]K''"=4?' 9C7I6H4?C;'?>>7?'C8A'CE'I569>'6A'A=4?'IC4;At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j '''.C;?4B>H4;;L'A=6A',>H495>?'762';CA';>9>??6H452'=6D>' 6> B'F4A='A=>'69J84?4A4C; 'CE'A=>'> 7I4H>'4;'A=>'E4H?A'I569>L'4A'4?'H>6?C;6@5>'A=6A'=>' FC85B'9C;?4B>H'E8HA=>H'9C;J8>?A?'AC'@>' 455' 6BD4?>BL'4;'6BB4A4C;'AC'=4?'9C;?4B>H6A4C;' A=6A'A=>2'FC85B'@>'8;?6E>K''#>'H>4A>H6A>?'4;'2>A'6;CA=>H'ECH7'=4?'?8IICHA'CE'6' B>E>;?4D>' IC5492L'A=HC8<='=4?'B>?9H4IA4C;'CE'A=4?'9CHC556H2'AC'=4?'CD>H6H9=4;<'?9=>7>K'' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' Sj GCH'7CH>'C;'A=>'9=6H69A>H4h6A4C;'CE'!A=>;46;'>7I4H>'6?'6'A2H6;;2'=6A>B'@2'4A?'?8@Z>9A?L'?>>')>' *C74552'PNj R PNVL'PWU[K

PAGE 47

44 12'A=4?'IC4;AL'4A'4?'6@?C58A>52'95>6H'AC'A=>'H>6B>H'A=6A',>H495>?';>D>H'=6B'6;2' 4;A>;A4C;'CE'>XI6;B4;<'!A=>;46;'A>HH4ACH2'4;'A=>',>5CIC;;>?46;'F6HK ,>H495>?'9C;958B>?'=4?'?I>>9= '@2'H>4A>H6A4;<'!A=>;? '6A;>??L'6;B' H>4A>H6A4;<'A=6A'A=>2'?=C85B';CA'655CF'A=>4H'98HH>;A'74?ECHA8;>?'AC'B>A>H'A=>7'EHC7' F=6A'4?'@>?A'ECH'A=>'$7I4H>K''&A'4?'47ICHA6;A'AC';CA>'A=6A'=4?'IC4;A'H><6HB4;<' 74?ECHA8;>'CE'A=>'7C7>;A'65?C'6II54>?'AC'' CE'A=>'7C7>;AK''"=4?'4?'F=2' ,>H495>?'E4H752'>?A6@54?=>?'A=>'4B>6?'A=6A'C;52';>9> ??6H2'F6H?'@>'EC8<=AL'A=6A'A=>' > 7I4H>'4?';CA';>9>??6H452'Z8?AL'6;B'9>HA64;52'8;?6E>L'6;B'A=6A'H>A64;4;<'F=6A'A=>2' =6D>'4?'7CH>'47ICHA6;A'A=6A'<64;4;<'F=6A'A=>2'F6;AK'' "=892B4B> ?'=47?>5E'?8IICHA?' A =>?>'9C;958?4C;?'4;'=4?'>I45C<8>'AC',>H495>? '?I>>9='\NKUj]K "=892B4B>?'<4D>?'=4?'6A>?A'IH64?>'CE',>H495>?'6;B'=4?'IC5492'6EA>H'=4?'A=4HB' ?I>>9=K''"=892B4B>?'>XI564;?'A=6A'F=45> 'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>'E4;>B ',>H495>?' 477>B46A>52'6EA>H'= 4?'?I>>9=L'A=>2'F>H>'?A455'9C;D4;9>B'A=6A'=4?'IC5492'F6?'H4<=AL'6;B' A=>2'>5>9A>B'=47'6<64;'6?'<>;>H65'6A'A=>';>XA'>5>9A4C;L' 6;B'9C774AA>B'655'A=>4H' 6EE64H?'AC'=4?'=6;B?'KKK'8;B>H?A6;B4;<'A=6A'=>'F6?'A=>'@>?A'76;'CE'655'ECH'A=>';>>B?'CE' A=>'?A6A> ''\NKUjKS ]K''%CA'C;52'B4B'A=>'I>CI5>'CE'!A=>;?'AH8?A'4;',>H495>?'6;B'=4?' IC5492L'@8A'"=892B4B>?'=47?>5E'95647?'A=6A',>H495>?'F6?'65F62?'6998H6A>'4;'=4?' IH>B49A4C;?L'6;B'A=6A',>H495>?'F6?L'6A'5>6?A'4;'I6HAL'H>?IC;?4@5>'ECH'A=>'6A;>??'CE' !A=>;?K'' GCH'6?'5C;<'6?'= >'F6?'6A'A=>'=>6B'CE'A=>'?A6A>'B8H4;<'A=>'I>69>L'=>'I8H?8>B' 6'7CB>H6A>'6;B'9C;?>HD6A4D>'IC5492t'6;B'4;'=4?'A47>'4A?'6A;>??'F6?'6A'4A?'=>4<=AK'' 3=>;'A=>'F6H'@HC:>'C8AL'=>H>'65?C'=>'?>>7?'AC'=6D>'H4<=A52'<68<>B'A=>'ICF>H'CE'=4?'

PAGE 48

45 9C8;AH2 '\NKUjKj]K SU ''3=>;'= >'95647?'A=6A',>H495>?'65?C'<68<>B'!A=>;46;'ICF>H'6EA>H' A=>'F6H'@><6;L'"=892B4B>?'H>D>65?'=4?'CF;'CI4;4C;'CE'A=>'4B>65'!A=>;46;'7454A6H2' ?AH6A><2K "=892B4B>?'=47?>5E'?87?'8I'A=>'4B>6?'=>'9C;?4B>H>B'47ICHA6;A'EHC7' ,>H495>? '?AH6A><2K''"=>'!A=>;46;?'C8<=A'A C'F64A'I6A4>;A52L'>;<6<>'A=>'>;>72'C;52'4;' A=>'76H4;>'>5>7>;AL'6AA>7IA';C';>F'9C;J8>?A?L'6;B'>XIC?>'A=>'94A2'AC'6?'E>F'H4?:?' 6?'IC??4@5>'\NKUjKT]K'',>H495>?'=47?>5E'4?'6@5>'AC'9C;AHC5'A=>'!A=>;46;'785A4A8B>L'6;B' AC'9C;D4;9>'A=>7'AC'69A'4;'A=>4H'CF;'4;A>H>? A'\NKUjKV R W]K''"=892B4B>?'65?C'@567>?' E8A8H>'!A=>;46;?'ECH'69A4;<'9C;AH6H452'AC'A=>?>'IC4;A?K''!A=>;?'F455'@>'5>B'@2'?>5E4?=' 5>6B>H?'F=C'F455'5CC:'7CH>'AC'A=>4H'CF;'I>H?C;65'IHCE4A'A=6;'A=>''?A6A>' \NKUjKPO]K''"=892B4B>?'?I>94E496552'7>;A4C;?'A=> '+494546;'>XI>B4A4C;'A= 6A'F455'C998H'4;' =4?'?4XA='6;B'? >D>;A='@CC:?L'6?'6'9H89465'!A=>;46;'B>D46A4C;'EHC7',>H495>6;'IC5492' \NKUj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kH>>:?L';CA'4;AH6 R !A=>;46;' IC54A49?K''"=>H>ECH>L'"=892B4B>?'95>6H52'9C;?4B>H?',>H495>? 'ECH>4<;'IC5492'F6?'9C;?>HD6A4D>L'6;B'A=6A' A=4 ?'F6?'A=>'47ICHA6;A'E>6A8H>'CE'=4?'5>6B>H?=4IK'

PAGE 49

46 B>7C;?AH6A>L'A=HC8< ='=4?';6HH6A4D>'A>9=;4J8>'6;B'A=HC8<='9C7I6H4?C;'F4A=' ,>H495>?L'A=>'E6A65'B>D46A4C;?'CE'A=>'CA=>H'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?K''1>ECH>'F>'>X674;>'A=>' 9C7I5>A>'B>H495>6;',C5492'4;'A=>'+494546;'$XI>B4A4C;L'F>'F455'>X674;>' =CF'A=>'!A=>;46;?'B>D>5CI>B'CD>H 9C;E4B>;9>'8;B>H'A=>'B>76'F=C'<64;>B' 4;E58>;9>'6EA>H',>H495>? 'B>6A=Y'.5>C;K ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '

PAGE 50

47 .=6IA>H'"FC &;'A=>'IH>D4C8?'9=6IA>HL'&'C8A54;>B'A=>'9C;;>9A4C;'@>AF>>;'"=892B4B>?'6;B' ,>H495>?'6;B'>XI5CH>B'A=>'9H4A>H46'CE'5>6B>H?=4I'A=6A'6H>'>?A6@54 ?=>B'4;'A=6A' H>56A4C;?=4IK'' 1CA=',>H495>?'6;B'"=892B4B>?' >XI5494A52' 54?A'A=>?>'9H4A>H46' \NKUj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j]L'=>'CEE>H?';C'>XI5494A'>;BCH?>7>;A'CH' 9H4A494?7'CE'CA=>H'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?L'4;958B4;<'.5>C;K''&;?A>6BL'=>'5>6B?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC' B>B89>'A=>'IH>94?>'B4EE>H>;9>?'@>AF>>;'.5>C;0?'IC5492'6;B',>H495>?0'IC5492L'4;'6'F62' A=6A'H> D>65?'6?I>9A?'CE'.5>C;?'IC5492'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'FC85B'9H4A494h>K''&'F455'6;652h>' =CF'"=892B4B>?'8?>?'=4?';6HH6A4D>'A>9=;4J8>'AC'ICHAH62'.5>C;L'9C7I6H4;<'.5>C;^?' CF;'?I>>9=>? ST 'AC'=4?'69A4C;?'4;'A=>';6HH6A4D>'6;B'9C7I6H4;<'.5>C;^?'?I>>9=>?'AC' ,>H495>?^'?I>>9 =>?K''M2'6;652?4?'F455';CA'C;52'H>D>65'>X69A52'F=49='9H4A>H46'CE'6'6B>H'.5>C;'E645?'AC'7>>AL'@8A'65?C'A=>'?4<;4E496;9>'CE'=4?'E6458H>'6;B'A=>' 9C;?>J8>;9>?'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'6??C946A>?'F4A='4AK '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' ST .5>C;'=6?'C;52'C;>'?I>>9='4;'B4H>9A'B4?9C8H?>'A=6A'4?';CA'?AH49A52'6@C8A'7454A6H2'76AA>H?L'=4?'?I>>9=' 4;'A=>'M2A45>;6>6;'B>@6A>'\[K[T R SO]K''%>D>HA=>5>??L'=>'BC>?'?I>6:'4;'4;B4H>9A'B4?9C8H?>'B8H4;<'A=>' ,25C? '6EE64H'\SKNPK[]L'6;B'"=892B4B>?'BC>?'B>?9H4@>'A=>'>EE>9A'CE'.5>C;'?I>6:4;<'\SKNNK[]K''&'F455' B4?98??'A=>'?4<;4E496;9>'CE'.5>C;'?I>6:4;<'C;52'4;'4;B4H>9A'B4?9C8H?>'4;'A=>',25C?'6EE64H'6@CD>K

PAGE 51

48 "=892B4B>?'4;958B>?'4;'=4?'FCH:'?C7>'ACC5?'AC'64B>'8?'4;' C8H'6;652?4?K''&;'A=>' >85C<2'AC',>H495>?L'=>'?>5>9A?'I6HA49856H'IC4;A?'CE',>H495>?^'?AH6A><2'AC'IH64?>'6;B' C8A54;>?'>XI5494A52'9>HA64;'74?A6:>?'A=6A'=4?'?899>??CH?'F455'76:>'\NKUj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

PAGE 52

49 &;'A=>'A=4HB'?>9A4C;L'&'F455'?=CF'=CF'"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?'.5>C;'4;'A=>' ;6HH6A4D>'6A'"=H69>L'9C7I5>A4;<'A=>'=2IC9H4A4965L'B>76'CE' .5>C;'@><8;'@2'=4?'? I>>9='4;'A=>'M2A45>;6>6;'B>@6A>'6;B'9C;A4;8>B'@2'@CA='A=>' ?I>>9='6;B'A=>';6HH6A4D>'6A',25C?K''"=892B4B>?'=C5B?'.5>C;'699C8;A6@5>'4;'A=>' ;6HH6A4D>'ECH'=4?'CD>H6H9=4;<'E6458H>'AC'EC55CF',>H495>?0'?AH6A><2'CH'9C;ECH7'AC' ,>H495>?0';CA4C;'CE'6'6B>HK''.5> C;'E4;B?'=47?>5E'4;'6'?4A86A4C;'F=>H>'=>'78?A' ?899>>B'A=HC8<='?:455L'H6A=>H'A=6;'589:L'6;B'"=892B4B>?'9C;958?4D>52'?=CF?'A=6A' .5>C;'E645?'B8>'AC'6'569:'CE'?:455L'6'569:' A=6A '.5>C;'=6?'IC??>??>B'A=HC8<=C8A'=4?' 96H>>HK''"=4?'4?'?4<;4E496;AL'@>968?>'.5>C;0?'4 ;9C7I>A>;9>'4;'A=>'E4;65'@6AA5>'6A' !7I=4IC54?'>??>;A46552';8554E4>?'655'CE'.5>C;0?'6H<87>;A?'6;B'IHCIC?>B'?AH6A><4>?' >6H54>H'4;'A=>'F6HK''"=892B4B>?'9C;958B>?'=4?'I49A8H>'CE'.5>C;'6;B'IHCD>?'A=6A'=4?' ?AH6A><2'=6?'@>>;'4;E>H4CH'@2'?=CF4;<'A=6A'6'B>94?4D>'B> E>6A L '?89='6?'A=>'C;>'6A' !7I=4IC54? L '4?'A=>'4;>D4A6@5>'9C;?>J8>;9>'CE'.5>C;0?'B>94?4C;?K M2'6;652?4?'F455'H>D>65'?4<;4E496;A'B4EE>H>;9>?'@>AF>>;'.5>C;'6;B',>H495>?' A=6A'F455'@>'9>;AH65'AC'8;B>H?A6;B4;<'=CF'"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?'A=>'B>954;>'CE' !A=>;46;'5>6B> H?=4I'6;B'A=>'9C;?>J8>;9>?'A=6A'H>?85AK''"=4?'9C7I5>A>'I49A8H>'CE' .5>C;L'<>;>H6A>B'@2'6;'6;652?4?'CE'A=>'4;A>H69A4C;'CE'=4?'?I>>9='F4A='A=>';6HH6A4D>L' I562?'6;'47ICHA6;A'HC5>'4;'"=892B4B>?^'FCH:'6?'6'F=C5>K''&A'>XI564;?'=CF'6;' 8;?84A6@5>'5>6B>H'96;'69=4>D> '6A'4;E58>;9>'A=HC8<='6'9C7@4;6A4C;'CE' B>76H2'6;B'589:K''&A'65?C'?>A?'A=>'?A6<>'ECH'A=>'6HH4D65'CE'>D>;'FCH?>'5>6B>H?' 6EA>H'.5>C;^?'B>6A=K''"=892B4B>?'8?>?'.5>C;'6?'6'@H4B<>'@>AF>>;',>H495>?'6;B'%4946?' 6;B'!594@46B>?L'6?'.5>C;'IC4;A?'C8A'=CF'76;4I8 56A4D>'B>76?'74<=A'9C7>'AC' ICF>H'4;'6'B>7C9H692'@2'@CA='=4?'FCHB?'6;B'69A4C;?K'"=4?'>XI564;?'=CF'A=>'J8654A2'

PAGE 53

50 CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4I'9C85B'B><>;>H6A>'?C'9C7I5>A>52'@2'A=>'A47>'CE'%4946?'6;B' !594@46B>?K''&;'?=CHAL'.5>C;^?'69A4C;?'6;B'476<>'4;'A=>'=4?ACH 2'6H>'47ICHA6;A'@>968?>' A=>2'=>5I'A=>'H>6B>H'8;B>H?A6;B'A=>'B>954;>'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4I'CD>H'A=>'F=C5>' FCH:K''"=4?'F455'@>'47ICHA6;A'ECH'72'A=4HB'9=6IA>HL'4;'F=49='&'F455'>XI5CH>'=CF'>69=' <>;>H6A4C;'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?'6AA>7IA?'AC'E85E455'A=>'CH4<4;65'9 H4A>H46L'F4A=',>H495>?' ?899>>B4;C;'@><4;;4;<'AC'E645 SW L'6;B'%4946?'6;B'!594@46B>?'E6454;<'C8AH4<=AK "=>'M2A45>;6>6;')>@6A> &;'A=>'E4EA='2>6H'CE'A=>'F6H'A=>'94A2 R ?A6A>'M2A45>;>'H>@>55>B'6<64;?A'!A=>;?K'' !A=>;?L'F4A='A=>'=>5I'CE'A=>'B>7C9H6A49'E69A4C;' F4A=4;'M2A45>;>L'I8A'BCF;'A=>'H>DC5AL' 96IA8H>B'A=>'5>6B>H?'CE'A=>'H>DC5AL'6;B'?>;A'A=>7'@69:'AC'!A=>;?K''-IC;'A=>4H'6HH4D65' AC'A=>'94A2L'A=>'5>6B>H?'F>H>'655'I8A'AC'B>6A='C;'A=>'?ICAL'6;B'A=>'!A=>;46;?'F>H>'?C' 6;6H4;<'6@C8A'A=>'M2A45>;6>6;'H>DC5 A'A=6A'A=>2'CHB>H>B'A=>'>;A4H>'ACF;' @>'I8A'AC'B>6A='6?'F>55K''"=>'EC55CF4;<'B62L'A=>'!A=>;46;?'H>9C;?4B>H'A=>'=6H?=;>??' CE'A=>4H'B>9H>>L'F=49='FC85B'I8;4?='A=>'4;;C9>;A'6?'F>55'6?'A=>'<845A2L'6;B'=C5B' 6;CA=>H'6??>7@52'AC'B>@6A>'F=>A=>H'AC'H>9655'A=>'?=4I'9 6HH24;<'A=>'B>6A='?>;A>;9>' AC'M2A45>;>K''"=892B4B>?'IH>?>;A?'A=>'6H<87>;A?'CE'AFC'?I>6:>H?'6A'A=4?'B>@6A>Y' .5>C;'ECH'764;A64;4;<'A=>'CH4<4;65'B>9H>>L'6;B')4CBCA8?'ECH'H>?94;B4;<'4AK .5>C;'76:>?'=4?'B>@8A'4;'A=>'=4?ACH2'F4A='=4?'?I>>9='4;'A=4?L'A=>'M2A45>; 6>6;' B>@6A>K''#>'@><4;?'=4?'6H<87>;A'@2'956474;<'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'C8<=A'AC'54?A>;'AC' A=>4H'CF;'9C;?94>;9>L'H6A=>H'A=6;'AC'A=>'E6;92'6H<87>;A?'I8A'ECHA='@2'CH6ACH?K''#>' ?A6A>?'A=6AL'4;'<>;>H65L'6H<87>;A?'?=C85B'@>'FC;'@2'A=>'?AHC;<>H'96?>L';CA'A=>' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' SW G4;5>2'H>E>H?'AC'A=>'IHC??'CE'B>;'=>' FH4A>?' l.5>C;0?'FCHB?L'A=>H>ECH>L'?4<;4E2'A=>' @H8A654A2'CE'7CCB'AC'F=49='A=>'F6H'F6?'<4D4;<'H4?>'6;B'F=49='=>'F6?'I5624;<'8IC;'AC'@845B'8I'6' I>H?C;65 'EC55CF4;2L'PWU[L'PTjK''.5>C;'?>A?'A=>'IH>9>B>;A'CE'96A>H4;<'AC'A=>'D4C5>;A'F=47?'CE' A=>'76??>?'AC'?8IICHA'=4?'CF;'ICI856H4A2L'6?'"=892B4B>?'IH>D4C8?52'ECH>F6H;>B'\NKUjKPO]K

PAGE 54

51 ?AHC;<> H'?I>6:>HL'6;B'A=6A'6'B>7C9H6A49'68B4>;9>'78?A'@>'lE64H'Z8B<>?'H6A=>H'A=6;' 9C7I>A4ACH?m'\[K[TKS]K''.5>C;0?'?A6A>7>;A?'=>H>'6H>'95>6H52'4B>6?'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'=6?' 65H>6B2'H>IH>?>;A>B'6?'IC?4A4D>L'6;B'>D>;'6?'A=>'8;B>H524;<'I=45C?CI=2'CE'=4?'CF;' FCH:K''"=>'FC HB'ECH'9C7I>A4ACH?'=>H>'4?' ewrp`abe` L'F=49='BH6F?'6'I6H655>5'@>AF>>;' .5>C;0?'IC4;A'6;B'"=892B4B>?0'CH4<4;65'?A6A>7>;A'A=6A'=4?'FCH:'4?';CA'FH4AA>;'ECH'6' 9C7I>A4A4C;'\ ewrp`aye ]L'@8A'6?'6'56?A4;<'IC??>??4C;K j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h>B'4;'A=>'A47>'CE'%4946?'6;B' !594@46B>?K''.5>C;^?'D>H2'E4H?A'FCHB?Y'_&'=6D>'CEA>;'9C;?4B>H>B'B >7C9H692'AC'@>' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' jO "=>'56;<86<>'8?>B'=>H>'65?C'4;D4A>?'9C7I6H4?C;'F4A='A=>';6HH6A4D>'CE'A= >'94D45'F6H'4;'.CH92H6K'' "=892B4B>?'H>56A>?'A=6A'4;'A=>'94D45'F6HL';CH765';CA4C;?'CE'=C;>?A2L'7CH654A2L'6;B'>D>;'5><654A2L' B4?6II>6H>BK''3=6A'H>?85A>B'F6?'6'9C7I>A4A4C;'@>AF>>;'4A?'CF;'94A4h>;?'CD>H'l6':4;B'CE'IH4h>'ECH' 95>D>H;>??m'\ ‚|pvavrg ewrp`aye ]'\[KVNKT]L'F=>;'4;'E69A'A=>2'F>H>'@>AH624;<'6;B'78HB>H4;<'>69=' CA=>HK'"=C76?L'NOOUL'VWK

PAGE 55

52 4;96I6@5>'CE'>7I4H>_'\[K[T]'6H>'H>74;4?9>;A'CE'A=>'47I5496A4C;'B8H4;<',>H495>?^'E4H?A' ?I>>9='A=6A'6'B>7C9H692'4?';CA'6?'>EE494>;A'6'B>94?4C; R 76:>H'6?'6;'C54<6H9=2' \PKPSPKT]K''"=892B4B>?'=47?>5E'6>?'A=6A'A=>'B>94?4C;?'CE'!A=>;?'4;',>H495>? ^'A47>' F>H>'F4?>'@>968?>'A=>'!A=>;46;?'F>H>'lI>H?86B>B'@2'A=>'F4?BC7'CE'=4?'6BD49>m' \PKPSj]L'6;B'?C'EC55CF>B'=4?'6BD49>'>X69A52K''"=>'4B>6?'A=6A'.5>C;'IH>?>;A?'?=6HI>;' 6;B'EC98?'A=>?>'>6H54>H'4B>6?'>XIH>??>B'@2'"=892B4B>?'6;B',>H495>?K''"=892B4B>?'=6?' 65H> 6B2'9=6H69A>H4h>B',>H495>?'6?'lE4H?A'76;'CE'=4?'A47>'4;'!A=>;?L'6@5>?A'654:>'4;'@CA=' 9C8;?>5'6;B'69A4C;m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t '.5>C;'4?'?>5E4?='6;B' I>H?86?4D>K jP ''"=>'>EE>9A'CE'H>I>6A4;<',>H495>?0'H>J84H>7 >;A?'=>H>'4;'.5>C;0?'CF;' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' jP '_ .5>6H52L'"=892B4B>?'EC98?>?'J84A>'6'@4A'CE'6AA>;A4C;'C;'A=>'7CH65'6;B'4;A>55>9A865'9=6H69A>H'CE' 5>6B>H?KKK'kH>6A'?A6A>?7>;L'?89='6?',>H495>?L'F>H>' >?I>946552'<4EA>B'4;'9=6H69A>H'6?'F>55'6?'4;'H=>ACH4965' ?:455?K_'oC=;?C;L'PWW[L'PW[ R PWSK

PAGE 56

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jN '' ,>H495>?'=6?'65H>6B2'@>>;'ICHAH62>B'6? '6@5>'AC'9C;AHC5'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>'B8H4;<' A=>'?8BB>;'9=6;<>'CE'ECHA8;>'B8H4;<'A=>'I56<8>L'6;B'=>'76:>?'95>6H'4;'=4?'A=4HB' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' j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jKVW]K

PAGE 57

54 ?I>>9='A=6A'A=>'I56<8>'?=C85B';CA'B4?9C8H6<>'!A=>;?'EHC7'9C;A4;84;<'A=>'F6H' \NKUS]K''"=892B4B>?'6EE4H7?'4;'=4?'>85C<2'A=6A',>H495>?' ?899>>B>B'4;'H>?AH64;4;<'A=>' I>CI5>'4;'A=>4H'7C7>;A'CE'F>6:;>??'\NKUjKN]L'A=6A',>H495>?'=6?'9C;?4?A>;A52'@>>;' 6@5>'AC'H>?AH64;'A=>'I>CI5>'\NKUjKW]L'6;B'A=6A'56A>H'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?'F455';CA'H>?AH64;' A=>'I>CI5>'6?',>H495>?'B4B'\NKUjKPO]K !EA>H'.5>C;'?I>6:?L '6;CA=>H'!A=>;46;L')4CBCA8?L'F=C'6II>6H?'4;'A=>'#4?ACH2' C;52'4;'A=4?'>I4?CB>L'<4D>?'A=>'6;?F>H4;<'?I>>9='\[KSN R SV]K'')4CBCA8?^'?I>>9='4?'D>H2' 4;ECH76A4D>'?4;9>'=>'4?'H>?IC;B4;'4?'6@5>'AC'6;?F>H'>69='CE'A=>'IC4;A?'A=6A' .5>C;'=6?'76B>K j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j[ "=892B4B>?'76:>?'8?>'CE'A=>'B>@6A>'ECH76AL'6?'F>55'6?'=4?'?A6A>B'4;A>;A4C;'AC'H>ICHA'A=>'4B>6?'4 ;' ?I>>9=>?'l6?'4;'72'CI4;4C;'F6?'B>76;B>Bm'\PKNNKP]L'AC'IHCD4B>'E8552'@CA='?4B>?'CE'A=>'B>@6A>L'@8A' 95>6H52'ICHAH62')4CBCA8?0'?4B>'6?'F4?>HY''l"=>'AFC'?I>>9=>?'F>H>'A=8?'9C7IC?>B'@2'"=892B4B>?'4;' ?89='6'F62'A=6A'A=>'?2?A>76A49'9C;AH6?A'@>AF>>;'A=>7L'65A=C8 <='H6A=>H'47IHC@6@5>'4;'6;'69A865' B>@6A>L'@HC8<=A'C8A'A=>'F4?BC7'CE'C;>'?C58A4C;'9C7I6H>B'F4A='A=>'EC552'CE'A=>'CA=>HKm')>'*C74552L' PWU[L'PUOK

PAGE 58

55 ,25C?'\SK[ R N[L'SKNU R SP] .5>C;';>XA'6II>6H?'4;'A=>'>I4?CB>'6A',25C? K''&;'A=4?'>I4?CB>'6;'!A=>;46;'E 5>>A' 4?'ECH9>B'AC' 56;B'C;'A=>'3>?A>H;'?4B>'CE'A=>',>5CIC;;>?8?L'6;B'A=>H>'76:>?'6;'6B' =C9'ECHA4E496A4C;K''"=>'IH476H2'+I6HA6;'ECH9>'4?'?A455'4;'!AA496L'6;B'8IC;'=>6H4;<'CE'A=>' ;>F'!A=>;46;'ECHA4E496A4C;L'=8HH4>?'=C7>'4;'CHB>H'AC'6AA69:'A=>';>F'!A=>;46;'ECHAK'' M>6;F=45>')>7C ?A=>;>?L'A=>'5>6B>H'CE'A=>'!A=>;46;?L'=6?'?>;A'AFC'?=4I?'8;;CA49>B' @2'A=>'+I6HA6;?'AC'H>J8>?A'64B'EHC7'!A=>;?L'6;B'IH>I6H>?'=4?'7>;'AC'7>>A'A=>' +I6HA6;'6??685A'@2'@CA='56;B'6;B'?>6K''"=>'+I6HA6;?L'A=C8<='8;6F6H>'CE'A=>' !A=>;46;'H>J8>?A'ECH'64BL'76:>'IHCD4? 4C;?'AC'IHCA>9A'A=>4H'6??685A'EHC7'6;'67@8?=' EHC7'6;'4;9C74;<'!A=>;46;'E5>>AL'@2'>7I5C24;<'6'=CI54A>'<6HH4?C;'C;'A=>';>6H@2' 4?56;B'CE'+I=69A>H46L'6;B'@5C9:4;<'A=>'I6??6<>?'AC',25C?'F4A='?=4I?L'A=8?'<4D4;<'6;2' !A=>;46;'?=4I?';C'?84A6@5>'I569>'AC'56;B'AC'64B 'A=>4H'6554>?K "=>'!A=>;46;?'?899>>B'4;'H>I>554;<'A=>'+I6HA6;?'B8H4;<'A=>'E4H?A'B62'CE'A=>' E4<=A4;';>XA'B62'A=>'!A=>;46;'H>4;ECH9>7>;A?'6HH4D>'8;B>A>9A>BL'@8A'?>>'A=6A' A=>H>'6H>';C'?84A6@5>'56;B4;<'IC4;A?'6;B'?C'?I>;B'A=>';4<=A'C;'A=>';CA'E6H'CEE'B >?>HA' 4?56;B'CE',HCA>K''"=>'!A=>;46;?'6AA69:'6A'B6F;'A=>';>XA'B62L'F=>;'A=>'+I6HA6;' @5C9:6B>'=6?';CA'2>A'@>>;'I8A'8IL'6;B'EC55CF4;<'6'@H8A65'@6AA5>L'76;6<>'AC'96IA8H>' ?C7>'CE'A=>'+I6HA6;'?=4I?'6;B'4?C56A>'A=>'+I6HA6;'4;E6;AH2'ECH9>L'F=49='=6B'@>>;' B>I5C2>B 'C;'A=>'4?56;B'CE'+I=69A>H46K''&77>B46A>52'A=>'!A=>;46;?'>?A6@54?='6'I6AHC5' HC8A>'6HC8;B'+I=69A>H46'F4A='A=>4H'?=4I?L'AC'>;?8H>'A=6A';C;>'CE'A=C?>'C;'A=>'4?56;B' >?96I>'6;B'A=6A';C;>'CE'A=>'+I6HA6;?'EHC7'A=>'764;56;B'?>;B'?8II54>?'AC'A=>4H' @>?4><>B'9C7H6B>? 'C;'A=>'4?56;BK

PAGE 59

56 "=4?'=6?'655'@>>;'699C7I54?=>B'F4A=C8A'6;2'69A4C;'C;'.5>C;^?'I6HAK''Q;9>'655' CE'A=>?>'>D>;A?'=6D>'C998HH>BL'A=>'+I6HA6;?'?>;B'>;DC2?'AC'!A=>;?L'6?:4;<'ECH'@CA=' 6;'>;B'AC'A=>'F6HL'6;B'A=>'H>A8H;'CE'A=>4H'47IH4?C;>B'?C5B4>H?K jS ''.5>C;'H>?IC;B ?'AC' A=>'+I6HA6;?'6EA>H'A=>2'=6D>'76B>'A=>4H'?I>>9='4;'A=>'6??>7@52K''"=892B4B>?'BC>?' ;CA'<4D>'.5>C;'6'E855'?I>>9=L'6?'=>'B4B'AC'A=>'+I6HA6;?L'@8A'=6?'.5>C;'H>Z>9A'A=>'I>69>' CEE>H'C;52'A=HC8<='4;B4H>9A'B4?9C8H?>K jj ''"=4?'C74??4C;'CE'.5>C;0?'B4H>9A'?I>>9='4? >XAH>7>52'?4<;4E496;AK''.5>C;'=6?'65H>6B2'<4D>;'6'5>;>9='4;'F=49='=>' 9=6?A4?>?'A=>'!A=>;46;?'ECH'A=>4H'D85;>H6@454A2'AC'H=>ACH4965'I>H?86?4C;'\[K[T R SO] jU K''' 12'B>IH4D4;<'.5>C;'CE'6'?I>>9='6A'A=>'6??>7@52L'"=892B4B>?'4?'6@5>'AC'9C;D>2'A=>' >EE>9A'CE' .5>C;0?'CH6ACH2L'8?4;<'?89='56;<86<>'6?'_.5>C;'I>H?86B>B_L'_.5>C;'D4C5>;A52' 6??645>B_'\SKNP]K''#>'BC>?';CA'IH>?>;A'6;2'9C;D4;94;<'6H<87>;A'CH'Z8?A4E496A4C;L'6;B' 4?'ICHAH62>B'C;52'6?'I>H?86B4;<'=4?'68B4>;9>'6;B'6AA69:4;<'A=>'CA=>H?'?I>6:>H?K''12' C74AA4;<'.5 >C;0?'69A865'FCHB?'6;B'4B>6?L'"=892B4B>?'>7I=6?4h>?'=4?'69A4C;?L'F=49=' 9C;AH6B49A'=4?'>6H54>H'6BD49>K''.5>C;'BC>?';CA'?I>6:'AC'=4?'68B4>;9>L'@8A'H6A=>H' 76;4I856A>?'6;B'6AA69:?'A=>7L'4;'>X69A52'A=>'?67>'76;;>H'6?'=>'F6H;>B'6<64;?A'4;' =4?'?I>>9='B8H4;<'A=>'M 2A45>;6>6;'B>@6A>K''"=>'>EE>9A'CE'A=>';6HH6A4D>'4?'A=6A'.5>C;' 9C;AH6B49A?'=4?'>6H54>H'6BD49>'<4D>;'AC'A=>'!A=>;46;'6??>7@52L'76:4;<'=47?>5E'6' =2IC9H4A>'6;B'6II>6H4;'H>6B>HL'AC'D658>'=4?'CF;'ICI856H4A2'CD>H'A=>'AH8>' ;?K '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' jS GCH'6'A=CHC8<='6;652?4?'CE'=CF'"=892B4B>?'8?>?'A=4?'+I6HA6;'?I>>9='6?'6'9C;B84A'ECH'=4?'CF;' 6??>??7>;A'CE'A=>'? 4A86A4C;L'?>>')>'*C74552L'PWU[L'PTN R PTWK jj )>'*C74552'?A6A>?'A=6A'.5>C;0?'B>94?4C;'4;'A=>'B>@6A>L'9C;D>2>B'A=HC8<='4;B4H>9A'B4?9C8H?>L'l4?' IH>?>;A>B'J84A>'C@D4C8?52'6?'6;'69A'9C7I5>A>52'9C;AH6H2'AC'IC54A4965'F4?BC7Km')>'*C74552L'PWU[L'PTNK jU #CH;@5CF>H'54; :?'"=892B4B>?'C74??4C;'CE'6'?I>>9='@2'.5>C;'F4A='A=>'F>6:;>??'CE'A=>'+I6HA6;?' 6H<87>;A?K''l~.5>C;'4?';CA'655CF>B'@2'"=892B4B>?'AC'B>7C54?='A=>'?CI=4?AH2'6;B'>7IA2'CEE>H?'CE'A=>' +I6HA6;?Km''"=4?'7>6;?'A=6A'.5>C;'4?'Z8?A4E4>B'6;B'9CHH>9A'4;'H>E8?4;<'A=>'+ I6HA6;'I>69>'CEE>H4;'96?>K''#CH;@5CF>HL'PWVTL'jUK

PAGE 60

57 .5>C;^?'B>76;B? '6;B'@>=6D4CH'4;'A=>'6??>7@52'H>9655'A=>'?CHA'CE'?I>>9='6;B' 7CA4D6A4C;'CE'6;'CH6ACH'A=6A'.5>C;'=47?>5E'B>9H4>B'4;'A=>'M2A45>;6>6;'B>@6A>K''"=4?' 4?'H>4;ECH9>B'@2'A=>'?I>>9='A=>'+I6HA6;?'<4D>'@>ECH>'A=>'!A=>;46;'6??>7@52K''"=>4H' B>76;B?'6H>'<4D>;'6?'<>;>H654 h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h>?'A=6A'.5>C; 0?' FCHB?'6H>';CA'A=>'@>?A'>D4B>;9>'ECH'Z8B<4;<'.5>C;L'@8A'H6A=>H'=4?'B>>B?'6H>'@>?AL'6;B' A=>'Z8B<7>;A'CE'=4?'B>>B?'96;;CA'@>'BC8@A>BK''.5>C;0?'69A4C;?'=>H>'956H4E2'A=6A'=>' =6?'H>I>6A>B',>H495>6;'4B>6?'4;'A=>'M2A45>;6>6;'B>@6A>L'@8A'BC>?';CA'8;B>H?A6;B' A=>7 '4;'?89='6'F62'6?'AC'69A'699CHB4;<52K''!?'6'H>?85AL'=>'76:>?'6'76H:>B52' 6<??4D>'6;B'8; R ,>H495>6;'B>94?4C;K''#>'H>E8?>?'A=>4H'CEE>HL'B>76;B4;<';CA'C;52' A=6A'A=>'+I6HA6;?'C;'A=>'4?56;B'?8HH>;B>H'6;B'@>'A6:>;'6?'IH4?C;>H?'AC'!A=>;?L'@8A'

PAGE 61

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j]K''.5>C;0?'6BB4A4C;65' B>76;B?'AC'A=>'+I6HA6;?'B8H4;<'A=>'6??>7@52'H>D>65'A=6A'=>'4?'B4D>H<4;<'>D>;' E8HA=>H'EHC7',>H495>?0'IC5492 'H6A=>H 'A=6 ;'?47I52'?F4A9=4;<'AC'A=>'CEE>;?4D>K .5>C;'B>76;B?'A=6A'A=>'+I6HA6;?'9>B>'9C;AHC5'CE'%4?6>6L',><6>L'"HC>h>;L'6;B' !9=6>6'\SKNPK[]K''"=>?>'H><4C;?'6H>'655'C;'A=>'764;56;BL'6;B'F=45>'%4?6>6'6;B',><6>' 6H>'C;'A=>'4?A=78?'@>AF>>;'A=>',>5CIC;;>?8?'6;B'A=>'H>?A'C E'kH>>9>L'!9=6>6L'6;B' "HC>h>;'54>'95>6H52'C;'A=>',>5CIC;;>?8?K''"=>?>'I569>?'6H>'655'E4H752'8;B>H'A=>' 9C;AHC5'CE'A=>'9CH>'+I6HA6;'?L'6;B'=6D>'@>>;'4;'+I6HA6;'=6;B?'?4;9>'6' AH>6A2'F6?'>;69A>B'CD>H'6'B>96B>'@>ECH>'A=>'@><4;;4;<'CE'A=>',>5CIC;;>?4 6;'36HK'' "=>?>'5C96A4C;?'6H>'C;'A=>'56;B'6;BL'A=>H>ECH>L'@>2C;B'A=>'67@4A4C;'CE',>H495>?^' CH4<4;65'F6H'?AH6A><2K''G4;6552L'A=>'C;52'C;>'CE'A=>?>'I569>?'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'6H>'

PAGE 62

59 6@5>'AC'96IA8H>'4?'%4?6>6K jT ''!EA>H'=6D4;<'96IA8H>B'%4?6>6L'A=>'!A=>;46;?'6H>'?CC; I8A'C;'A=>'B>E>;?4D>'@2'6'9C7@4;6A4C;'CE'+I6HA6;'6AA69:?'6;B'4;?8HH>9A4C;?'CE'A=>4H' CF;'9C5C;4>?K jV ''.5>C;^?'B>76;B?L'A=>;L'6H>'4;9C;?4?A>;A'F4A='F=6A'!A=>;?'9C85B' AH852'69=4>D>'F4A='4A?'H>65'ICF>HL'6;B'4;B496A>'9C7I5>A>'B4?H><6HB'ECH',>H495>?^' IH>E>H>;9>' ECH'C;52';6D65'F6HE6H>K GC55CF4;<'.5>C;^?'H>E8?65'CE'A=>'I>69>'CEE>HL'A=>'!A =>;46;?'764;A64;'6' @5C9:6B>'6A' ,25C?K'"=>'@5C9:6B>'4?'B4EE4985AL'6;B'A=>2'6H>'8;6@5>'AC'H>B89>'A=>' +I6HA6;?L'F=C'9C;A4;8C8?52'76;6<>'AC'?78<<5>'4;'?8II54>?K''"=>'!A=>;46;?'B>94B>' AC'A6:>'B>94?4D>'69A4C;'@>ECH>'F4;A>H'9C7>?'6;B'A=>'?4><>'@>9C7>?'7CH>'B4EE4985AL' 762@>'>D>;'47IC??4@5>L'B8>'AC'A=>'B4EE4985A2'4;'?8II524;<'A=>'@5C9:6B4;<';6D2L'6;B' A=>'4;9H>6?>B'9=6;9>?'ECH'+I6HA6;?'AC'?8II52'A=>7?>5D>?'6;B'>D>;'>?96I>'4;'?=4I?' B8H4;<'4;9 5>7>;A'F>6A=>HK''"=>'+I6HA6;?'9>6?>'?>;B4;<'>;DC2?'AC'!A=>;?L'6;B'A=>' !A=>;46;?'@>9C7>'FCHH4>B'A=6A'A=>'+I6HA6;?'=6D>'EC8;B'?C7>'F62'AC'?C5D>'A=>4H' B45>776L'6;B'H>A';CA'699>IA4;<'A=>'I>69>'CEE>H4;<'4;'A=>'E4H?A'I569>'\SKNTKN]K''"=>' !A=>;46;?'@><4;'AC'C;'ECH'5>6B4;<'A=>7'AC'H>E8?>'A=>'+I6HA6;'I>69>' CEE>H4;C;L'4;'6;'>EECHA'AC'<64;'A=>4H'?'C;9>'7CH>L'?8<<>?A?'A=6A' A=>2'?>;B'7CH>'?=4I?'6;B'568;9='6;'6??685A'B4H>9A52'6<64;?A'A=>'?C5B4>H?'C;'A=>' @>?4><>B'4?56;BK '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' jT '' !594@46B>?'BC>?L'B8H4;<'A=>',>69>'CE'%4946?L'9C;B89A'6'?7655'ECH9>'CE'!A=>;46;?'6;B'6554>?'4;AC'A=>' ;CHA=>H;',>5CIC;;>?8?L'6;B'6AA>7IA?L'67C;<'CA=>H'A=4;6; R *=487L'C;' A=>'D>H2';CHA=>H;'IC4;A'CE'A=>',>5CIC;;>?8?K''"=4?'762'@>'>X958B>B'ECH'C8H'I8HIC?>?'@>968?>'4A'4?' B8H4;<'6'A47>'CE'I>69>L'@>968?>'A=>',>5CIC;;>?46;?'IH>D>;A'9C;?AH89A4C;'CE'6'I>H76;>;A'ECHAL'6;B' @>968?>'!594@46B>?^'IH476H2'AA5>'76AA>H?'9C;;>9A>B'F4A='A=>'65546;9>_L'6;B';CA'AC' I>H76;>;A52'C998I2'A=>'6H>6'\jKjNKN]K jV "=>'E69A'A=6A'!A=>;?'96IA8H>B'%4?6>6'B4B';CA'?5CF'A=>'+I6HA6;'9C8;A>H6AA69:?'CH'4;94A6A4C;'CE' 4;?8HH>9A4C;?'CE'!A=>;46;'6554>?K'''1H6?4B6?L'A=>'+I6HA 6;'<>;>H65L'?47I52'54>?'6@C8A'A=>'E6A>'CE'%4?6>6'AC' A=>'9C5C;4>?'=>'4;94A>?L'6;B'4?'6@5>'AC'I>H?86B>'76;2'AC'H>DC5A'?47I52'@2'764;A64;4;<'A=>'476<>'CE' +I6HA6;'?AH>;B<>'6;B')>@;6HL'NOOUL'jTSK

PAGE 63

60 &;'A=>'!A= >;46;'6??>7@52L'.5>C;'@567>?'A=>'CA=>H'!A=>;46;'<>;>H65?'ECH' @>4;<'8;6@5>'AC'ECH9>'A=>'+I6HA6;?'AC'?8HH>;B>HL'6;B'>D>;'95647?'A=6A'4E'=>'F>H>'4;' 9C776;BL'=>'FC85B'=6D>'65H>6B2'H>B89>B'A=>'?C5B4>H?'C;'A=>'4?56;BK''&;'H>?IC;?>'AC' A=4?L'A=>'<>;>H65'%4946?'F45 54;<52'H>?4<;?'=4?'9C776;BL'6;B'CEE>H?'.5>C;'AC'A6:>'=4?' I569>'6;B'5>6B'6;'>XI>B4A4C;'6<64;?A',25C?K''Q;9>'.5>C;'H>654h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j]K''&;'A=4?'F62L'=>'4?'H>D>65>B'AC'=6D>'E645>B' C;>'CE'"=892B4B>?0'CH4<4;65'9H4A>H46'ECH'6'?AHC;<'5>6B>H '\NKUjKPO]K GHC7'A=>'@><4;;4;<'CE'A=>'>I4?CB>'8;A45'4A?'9C;958?4C;L'"=892B4B>?'76:>?' 95>6H'4;'=4?';6HH6A4D>'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'?899>>B'6A'>D>H2'IC4;A'@2'6'74XA8H>'CE'';>H65?=4I'CE')>7C?A=>;>?K jW ''"=892B4B>?0'>7I=6?4?'C;' )>7C?A=>;>?' 6;B'6A>?'A=>'>EE>9A'A=6A'.5>C;'?>>7?'AC'=6D>';C' H>?IC;?4@454A2'ECH'A=>'IC?4A4D>'C8A9C7>'A=6A'>D>;A86552'C998H?'6A',25C?K'' )>7C?A=>;>?'F6?'C;>'CE'A=>'<>;>H65?'4;'9=6H<>'CE'A=>'CH4<4;65'E5>>A'F=49='=6B'@>>;' ECH9>B'AC'>;967I'6A',25C?K''1>ECH>'A=> 4H'ZC8H;>2L'=>'H>9C77>;B>B'A=6A'A=>' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' jW )>7C?A=>;>?'F6?'6'?AHC;<'<>;>H65L'?:455>B'4;'A69A49? '6;B'4;?I4H4;<'6?'6'5>6B>HL'F=C';>D>HA=>5>??' 6II>6H>B'AC'=6D>';C'IC54A4965'67@4A4C;?K''"=892B4B>?'BC>?';CA'ICHAH62'=47'6?'IC??>??4;<'6;2'IC54A4965' 4;E58>;9>L'6;B'7>;A4C;?'=47'C;52'6?'6'7454A6H2'5>6B>HK'Q.)L'PWWUL'SjUK

PAGE 64

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oCD>L'=>^?'?AC5>;'4AL'6;B'?>HD>B''4A' 8IK'ƒ'o8?A'6?'2C8'B4B'A=>'IH4?C;>H?'6A',25C?_K'!H4?ACI=6;>?L'u;4<=A?L'PNOO R PNOP

PAGE 65

62 .5>C;'4?'?899>??E85'@2'9=6;9>'4;'A=>'>I4?CB>'6A',25C?L'@8A'4;'A=>'EC55CF4;<' >;<6<>7>;A?'CE'A=>'F6HL'4A'@>9C7>?'95>6H'A=6A'A=>H>'4?';C'9=6;9>'AC'E85E455'=4?'CH4<4 ;65' B>76;B?K''"=>'+I6HA6;?'5>6B'>XI>B4A4C;?'AC'4;94A>'H>DC5A?'4;'D6H4C8?'!A=>;46; R 6554>B' 94A2 R ?A6A>?L'6;B'C;9>'6<64;'ECH9>'A=>'!A=>;46;?'C;'A=>'B>E>;?4D>L'B>?I4A>'A=>4H' IC??>??4C;'CE'+I6HA6;'=C?A6<>?K''$D>;A86552L'6EA>H'A=>'5C??'CE'A=>'76ZCH'94A2 R ?A6A>' !7I =4IC54?'4;'"=H69>L'A=>'!A=>;46;?'69J84>?9>'6;B'6>'AC'6'C;> R 2>6H'6H74?A49>' 6;B'A=>'H>A8H;'CE'A=>'+I6HA6;'IH4?C;>H?K''!EA>H'A=>'2>6H'6;B'A=>'AH89>'>;BL'.5>C;' <6A=>H?'6;B'5>6B?'6;'6H72'AC'"=H69>'4;'CHB>H'AC'H>95647'A=>'A>HH4ACH2'A=6A'!A=>;?' =6B'5C?AK UN ''"=4 ?'967I64<;'B>7C;?AH6A>?'A=6A'.5>C; ?'CH4<4;65'B>76;B?'F>H>'=C55CFt' 4A'C998H?'E6H'6F62'EHC7'A=>'I569>?'A=6A'=>'B>76;B>BL'6;B'4?'8;B>HA6:>;'AC'H><64;' 94A2 R ?A6A>?'A=6A'!A=>;?'=6?'5C?A'>D>;'6EA>H'.5>C;'76B>'A=>'B>76;B?K''"=892B4B>?' E4;4?=>?'=4?'ICHAH64A'CE'.5> C;'4;'A=>'"=H6946;'967I64<;L'@2'9C;D>24;<'4;'A=>';6HH6A4D>' 6'95>6H'9C;A>7IA'A=6A'.5>C; ?'EH4>;B?L'>;>74>?L'6;B'>D>;'"=892B4B>?'=47?>5E'=6B'ECH' =47K .5>C;'E4H?A'6AA69:?'A=>'A>HH4ACH2'CE'"CHC;>L'6;B'4?'?899>??E85'A=>H>L'6?'A=>' B>E>;B4;<'+I6HA6;'ECH9>'4?'?76 55'6;B'968<=A'@2'?8HIH4?>K''!EA>H'69=4>D4;<'A=4?'D49ACH2L' .5>C;'?645?'C;'ACF6HB?'!7I=4IC54?L'F=49='4?'B>E>;B>B'@2'A=>'764;'+I6HA6;'<>;>H65L' 1H6?4B6?K''-IC;'56;B4;C;'4?'8;6@5>'AC'76:>'IHC??L'6;B'?C'>;967I?'6;B' ?>;B?'>;DC2?'AC';>6H@2'!A=>;46;'6554>? '4;'CHB>H'AC'C@A64;'6BB4A4C;65'ECH9>?K''3=45>' =>'4?'BC4;<'A=>?>'A=4;6H;?'CE'.5>C; ?'IC?4A4C;'6;B'4;69A4D4A2L'6;B' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' UN "=>'94A2 R ?A6A>?'A=6A'=6D>'@>>;'A6:>;'EHC7'A=>'!A=>;46;'=6D>'@>>;'5C?A';CA'C;52'AC'A=>'+I6HA6; ?L'CH' AC'4;?8HH>9A4C;?L'@8A'65?C'AC'CA=>H'ECH9>?'?8 9='6?'A=>'M69>BC;46;? 'i6=H;AL 'NOOU L'jWU K''"=>' 4;DC5D>7>;A'CE'6H74>?'8;6EE4546A>B'F4A='>4A=>H'?4B>'4?'=4<=54<=A>B'@2'A=>'E69A'A=6A'F=>;'!A=>;?' B>76;B>B'A=>'H>A8H;'CE'!7I=4IC54?'EHC7'+I6HA6'4;'A=>'A>H7?'CE'A =>4H'I>69>'AH>6A2L'A=>'+I6HA6;?' 9C;E>??>B'A=6A'4A'F6?';CA'>D>;'8;B>H'A=>4H'9C;AHC5'\jK[jKN]'i6=H;AL'NOOUL'UPOK

PAGE 66

63 6HH6;<>?'=4?'ECH9>?'8IC;'A=>'=4<=>H'H'AC'?>>'6;2'7CD>7>;A?'A=6A' .5>C;'74<=A'76:>K "=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?'.5>C;'6?'I5 624;<'H4<=A'4;AC'1H6?4B6? '=6;B?'6A'>D>H2' ?A>IK''3=>;'.5>C; ?'6H72'E4;6552'4?'?>A'4;AC'7CA4C;L'"=892B4B>?'95647?'A=6A'.5>C;' F6?'ECH9>B'AC'69A'Z8?A'6?'1H6?4B6?'IH>B49A>BK''.5>C;' ;>D>H'BH>67>B'CE'6;2C;>' 9C74;<'C8A'AC'E4<=A'=47 '\jKTK[]'6?'=>'?>A'8I'=4?'6H72 'C;'6'H>9C;;64??6;9>'74??4C;K'' #>'H>654h>?'A=6A'1H6?4B6?'=6?'?>A'6'AH6I'ECH'=47'ACC'56A>L'6;B'477>B46A>52'6EA>H'=>' ?>>?'A=>'4;9C74;<'6AA69:'6;B'CHB>H?'=4?'ECH9>?'AC'H>AH>6AL'1H6?4B6?'568;9=>?'=4?' 6AA69:K''"=892B4B>?'>XI564;?'A=6A'A=>'C8A9C7>'CE'A=>'@6AA5>' F6?'B>A>H74;>B'@CA='@2' A=>'6A;>??'CE'A=>'+I6HA6;'9C776;B>H'6;B'A=>'F>6:;>??'CE'A=>'!A=>;46;' 9C776;B>HY' "=>'!A=>;46;?'~F>H>'I6;49 R ?AH49:>;'@2'A=>4H'CF;'B4?CHB>H'6;B' 6?AC8;B>B'6A'~1H6?4B6? '68B694A2 '\jKPOKU]K''&;'A=4?'F62'"=892B4B>?'76:>?'95>6H' A=HC8< ='=4?';6HH6A4D>'A>9=;4J8>'A=6A'.5>C;'4?'6;'4;E>H4CH'9C776;B>HK''"=892B4B>?' >D>;'?'?C'E6H'6?'AC'>XI5494A52'?A6A>'A=6A'.5>C;'=6?'@>>;'76B>'CD>H9C;E4B>;A'@2'=4?' D49ACH2'6A',25C?L'6;B'F6?'8;IH>I6H>B'AC'7>>A'6;'>;>72'6H72'4;'6;'69A865'@6AA5>' \jKTK[]K''"=4?'4 ?'A=>'98574;6A4C;'CE'"=892B4B>?0'I49A8H>'CE'.5>C;0?'=2IC9H4?2L'F=49='=>' B>D>5CI>B'4;'=4?'?I>>9='4;'A=>'M2A45>;6>6;'B>@6A>L'6;B'=4?'4;DC5D>7>;A'4;'A=>' >I4?CB>'6A',25C?K''"=892B4B>?'8?>?'.5>C;0?'B>E>6A'6A'!7I=4IC54?'6?'6;'>X67I5>'CE'A=>' 85A476A>'9C;?>J8>;9>? 'CE'I8H?84;<'6'ICCHL'8; R ,>H495>6;'F6H'IC5492K .5>C;'4?'65?C'ICHAH62>B'6?'CD>H9C;E4B>;A'6;B'4;9C7I>A>;A'4;'A=>'>2>?'CE'=4?' CF;'AHCCI?K''G4H?AL'4;'A=>'!A=>;46;'6??>7@52'F=>H>'.5>C;'4?'>5>9A>B'AC';>H65L'"=892B4B>?'H>56A>?'A=6A' ?>;?4@5>'7> ; 'F>H>'=6II2'A=6A'A=>2'74<=A'=6D>' 6'9=6;9>'AC'@>'H4B'CE'.5>C;'\SKNVKj]K''"=4?'9C;D>2?'@CA='A=6A'"=892B4B>?'=47?>5E'

PAGE 67

64 9C;?4B>H?'.5>C;'6'ICCH'5>6B>HL'6;B'A=6A'76;2'!A=>;46;?'9C;?4B>H'.5>C;'6'ICCH' 5>6B>HK''!'?47456H'!A=>;46;'CI4;4C;'CE'.5>C;'?8HE69>?'6<64;'B8H 4;<'=4?'967I64<;'4;' "=H69>K'')8H4;<'.5>C; ?'4B5>;>??'6;B'1H6?4B6? '8;?>>;'C@?>HD6A4C;'CE'A=>'!A=>;46;' 967IL'A=>'!A=>;46;'?C5B4>H?'IH>?>;A'@><4;'AC'B4?98??'67C;<'A=>7?>5D>?'.5>C; ?' F>6:;>??'6;B'4;9C7I>A>;9> L'6;B'=4?'H>56A4D>'4;E>H4CH4A2'AC'1H6?4B6?'\jKTKN ]K'' "=892B4B>?'65?C';CF'76:>?'>XI5494A'F=6A'=6B'@>ECH>'@>>;'47I5496A>B'4;'A=>' ;6HH6A4D>L'A=6A'A=>'?C5B4>H?'A=>7?>5D>?L';CA'Z8?A'A=>'9H4A49?'A=6A'H>764;>B'6A'!A=>;?L' B4B';CA'F6;A'AC'699C7I6;2'.5>C;'C;'A=>'>XI>B4A4C;K''"=8?'4;'A=>';6HH6A4D>'@>ECH>' .5>C; ?'B> 6A=L'4A'=6?'@>>;'H>D>65>B'A=6A'.5>C;'4?';CA'H>?I>9A>B'6?'6'9C776;B>H'@2' "=892B4B>?L'@2'A=>'+I6HA6;?L'6;B'>D>;'@2'=4?'CF;'I>CI5>L'A=>'!A=>;46;?K''&;'A=4?'F62' "=892B4B>?'9C;958B>?'=4?'ICHAH64A'CE'.5>C;L'EC98?4;<'A=>'Z8B<7>;A?'CE'>D>H2'IC??4@5>' 9H4A49'AC'B4?9 H>B4A'.5>C;'6;B'B>?AHC2'A=>'5><4A47692'CE'=4?'>6H54>H'?AH6A><2K .5>C;'6;B'1H6?4B6?'@CA='B4>'4;'A=>'@6AA5>'CE'!7I=4IC54?L'@8A'A=>'+I6HA6;?'F4;' A=>'@6AA5>'@2'6'56H<>'76H<4;K'&77>B46A>52'6EA>H'A=>'B>6A=?'CE'.5>C;'6;B'1H6?4B6?L' @CA='?4B>?'6>'AC'6'I>69>'AH> 6A2'\jKPS]K''1H6?4B6?'F6?'A=>'+I6HA6; ?'7C?A'96I6@5>' <>;>H65L'6;B'.5>C;'F6?'A=>'!A=>;46; ?'7C?A'F6H54:>K''"=892B4B>?'>XI564;?'A=6A'A=>' !A=>;46;?'6H>'7CA4D6A>B'@2'A=>4H'5C??'6A'!7I=4IC54?L'6;B'H>AA>B'A=>4H'H>E8?65'CE' A=>'>6H54>H'I>69>'CEE>H4;'C A=>H'=6;BL'A=>'+I6HA6;?'=6D>'EC8;B'A=6A'A=>4H' 6@454A2'AC'H6D6<>'A=>'!A=>;46;'56;B?'4?'4;?8EE494>;A'AC'?8@B8>'A=>'!A=>;46;?L'6;B'A=>4H' B>E>6A'6A',25C?'76B>'A=>7'6F6H>'A=6A'A=>2'F>H>'4;'E69A'D85;>H6@5>K''&;'?=CHAL'A=>' !A=>;46;?'H>654h>'A=6A'A=>2'=6B';CA=4;<' AC'<64;'@2'IHC5C;<>B'9C;E549AL'6;B'A=>' +I6HA6;?'H>654h>'A=6A'A=>2'9C85B';CA'76:>'E8HA=>H'IHC??'B8>'AC'!A=>;? ';6D65' ?8I>H4CH4A2K''1CA='CE'A=>?>'H>654h6A4C;?'F>H>'A=>'764;'IH>9>IA?'CE'A=>'?AH6A><2'

PAGE 68

65 C8A54;>B'@2',>H495>?K''!?'6'76AA>H'CE'E69AL'"=892B4B>?'>X I564;?'A=6A'A=>'+I6HA6;?'F>H>' 7CH>'>6<>H'ECH'I>69>'A=6;'A=>'!A=>;46;?'\jKPj]K''"=>'I>69>'AH>6A2'9C85B'A=>;'@>' ?>>;'6?'6'?4<;4E496;A'!A=>;46;'D49ACH2L'4;'A=6A'A=>2'=6D>'?899>>B>B'4;'?ACII4;<'A=>' CH4<4;65'+I6HA6;'6<??4C;L'6;B'FC85B'@>'?6E>L'6??874;<'A=6A' A=>2'FC85B'8;B>HA6:>' ;C';>F'9C;J8>?A?K "=892B4B>?'8?>?'.5>C;'4;'=4?';6HH6A4D>'AC'H>IH>?>;A'A=>'954;>'CE' !A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4IK''3=45>',>H495>?'4?'9C;D4;94;<'6;B'@H45546;AL'.5>C;'4?'9C;D4;94;<' 6;B'4<;CH6;AK''.5>C;^?'4<;CH6;9>L'65A=C8<='4A'4?'?8EE49 4>;A'AC'5C?>'A=>'56H<>'@6AA5>'6A' !7I=4IC54?'6;B'968?>'A=>'!A=>;46;?'AC'?8>'ECH'I>69>L'4?'4;?8EE494>;A'AC'@H4;<'6@C8A' A=>'9C7I5>A>'BCF;E655'CE'!A=>;?K'' '!594@46B>?'4?'A =>'7C?A'I>H?86?4 D>'!A=>;46;'6EA>H' .5>C;^?'B>6A= L'6;B'E6H'EHC7'4<;CH6;AL'=>'4?'>XAH>7>52'9 6I6@5>'6;B'4;A>554<>;AL'@8A' ?>5E4?=K''"=8?'.5>C;'4?'B>I49A>B'6?'74BF62'65C;<'A=>'6H9'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4IK'' 3=45>';CA'9C7I>A>;A'>;C8<='AC'699C7I54?='6;2A=4;<''4?';CA'765494C8?L'6;B' BC>?';CA'69A4D>52'?>>:'=4?'CF;'>;B?'CD>H'A=>';?K &;' A=>';>XA'9=6IA>HL'&'F455'>XI5CH>'=CF'"=892B4B>?'8?>?'A=>'9=6H69A>H?'%4946?' 6;B'!594@46B>?'AC'9C;958B>'A=>'B>954;>'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4I'@><8;'@2'.5>C;K''&;' 6BB4A4C;'AC'>X674;4;<'=CF'%4946?'6;B'!594@46B>?'B4EE>H'EHC7',>H495>?0'CH4<4;65' 9H4A>H46'CE'5>6B>H?= 4IL'&'F455'65?C'>X674;>'=CF'A=>2'E645'AC'6BBH>??'A=>'IHC@5>7?'6' B>7C9H692'E69>?'A=6A'.5>C;'C8A54;>?'4;'A=>'M2A45>;6>6;'B>@6A>K''"=>'?4<;4E496;9>'CE' "=892B4B>?0'ICHAH64A'CE'.5>C;'F455'@>'76B>'95>6H'@2'A=>'ICHAH64A'CE'%4946?'6;B' !594@46B>?K''!594@46B>?'F455' @>'Z8?A'6?'I>H?86?4D>'6?'.5>C;L'@8A'=>'F455'I>H?86B>'A=>' !A=>;46;?'AC'8;B>HA6:>'6;'>D>;'7CH>'B6;<>HC8?'6;B'H>9:5>??'9C8H?>'A=6;'.5>C;' =6?K''"=HC8<='.5>C;L'"=892B4B>?'?=CF?'=CF'6'I>H?86?4D>'CH6ACH'96;'69=4>D>'ICF>HL'

PAGE 69

66 6;B'A=HC8<='!594@46B>?L'"=892B4B>?'?=CF?' F=6A'A=>'85A476A>'9C;?>J8>;9>?'CE' H=>ACH4965'?:455'F4A=C8A'65AH84?7'6H>K ' ' ' ' '

PAGE 70

67 .=6IA>H'"=H>> &;'A=>'56?A'9=6IA>HL'&'?=CF>B'=CF'"=892B4B>?'BH6F?'6'9C7I6H4?C;'@>AF>>;' .5>C;'6;B',>H495>?L'ICHAH62?'.5>C;'6?';CA'E85E4554;<',>H495>?^'9H4A>H46'ECH'5>6B>H?=4IL' 6;B'A=>H>@2'H>IH>?>;A?'A=>'@><4;;4;<'CE'A=>'B>954;>'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4I'A=HC8< =' .5>C;K''&;'A=4?'9=6IA>HL'&'>XI5CH>'=CF'"=892B4B>?'BH6F ?'6'9C7I6H4?C;'@>AF>>;' ,>H495>? '6;B'%4946?'6;B'!594@46B>?K''&'65?C'@845B'8IC;'72'6;652?4?'CE'"=892B4B>?^' ICHAH6265'CE'.5>C;'AC'B>7C;?AH6A>'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'H>IH>?>;A?'%4946?'6;B'!594@46B>?' 6?'A=>'9C;95 8?4C;'CE'A=>'B>954;>'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4IK 1CC:?'n&'6;B'n&&'CE'"=892B4B>?^'#4?ACH2'9CD>H'A=>'7454A6H2'967I64<;'CE' !A=>;?'6<64;?A'+49452K''"=4?'I6HA'CE'=4?ACH2'F6?L'@>ECH>'"=892B4B>?L';CA'9C;?4B>H>B' A=>'?67>'F6H'6?'A=>'477>B46A>52'IH>D4C8?'F6H'@>AF>>;'!A =>;?'6;B'+I6HA6K U[ "=892B4B>?'9C;?4B>H?'A=>'+494546;'>XI>B4A4C;'AC'@>'6;'4;A>' ,>5CIC;;>?46;'36HK ''12'A>554;<'A=>'=4?ACH2'CE' A=>'A=H>>'?7655>H'F6H?'A=6A'76:>'8I' A=>',>5CIC;;>?46;'36HL'"=892B4B>?'4;D4A>?'9C7I6H4?C;'CE'A=>'968?>?'CE'!A=>;46;' B> E>6A'4 ;'A=>'56A>H'I6HA'CE'A=>'F6H 'F4A='A=>'H>J84H>7>;A?'CE'?899>??'4;'A=>'>6H54>H' I6HA'CE'A=>'F6HK''#>'>XI564;?'A=>'>D>;A865'!A=>;46;'B>E>6A'@2'B>?9H4@4;<'A=>'9=6;<>?' 4;'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4I'A=6A'=6D>'C998HH>B'CD>H'A=>'9C8H?>'CE'A=>'>;A4H>'F6HK "=892B4B>?' =47?>5E'?A6A>?'A=6A'A=>'+494546;'$XI>B4A4C;'4?'6'@58;B>H'\NKUjKPP]K'' &'6H<8>'A=6A'A=>'B4?6?A>H'CE'A=>'+494546;'$XI>B4A4C;'4?'B8>'AC'A=>'B>D46A4C;'CE'!A=>;46;' 5>6B>H?'EHC7',>H495>?0'?AH6A><2K''Q;'A=>'C;>'=6;BL'%4946?L'C;>'CE'A=>'IHC74;>;A' <>;>H65?'4;'A=4?'> I4?CB>L'IC??>??>?'4;A>?4<=A'9C7I6H6@5>'AC',>H495>?L' @8A'4?'C;52'7>B4C9H>'6?'6'<>;>H65'6;B'4?'4;96I6@5>'CE'I>H?86B4;<'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' U[ ,56ACL' F8;8G8;>1 L'NS[! K

PAGE 71

68 AC'69A'699CHB4;<'AC'=4?'I56;K''Q;'A=>'CA=>H'=6;BL'!594@46B>?L'6;CA=>H'47ICHA6;A'E4<8H>L' 569:?'4;A>?4<=AL'@8A'4?'?A455'6'?AHC;<'<>;>H65'6;B'4?' >6?452'6@5>'AC' I>H?86B>'A=>'!A=>;46;'I>CI5>'AC'EC55CF'=4?'I56;K''"=8?L'A=>'AFC'76ZCH'!A=>;46;' <>;>H65? L 'F=C7'"=892B4B>?'IH>?>;A?'6?'69ACH?'4;'A=>'+494546;'>XI>B4A4C;L'IC??>??' C ;52'=65E'CE'A=>'6AAH4@8A>?'A= 6A '"=892B4B>?'CH4<4;6552'IH64?>B'4;',>H495>?K''"=4?' 9=6IA>H'F455'>XI5CH>'=CF'"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?'A=>?>'AFC'9=6H69A>H?L'?=CF4;<'A=>' B4EE>H>;A'74?A6:>?'A=6A'6H>'76B>'6?'6'H>?85A'CE'C;52'I6HA465'E85E4557>;A'CE',>H495>6;' 6AAH4@8A>?K &;'A=>'@><4;;4;<'CE'1CC:'n &L'"=892B4B>?'IH>?>;A?'6;'6H9=6>C5C<2'CE'+49452'6;B' A=> 'D6H4C8?'AH4@>?'A=6A'54D>'A=>H> '6;B'A=>;'B>A645?'6'B4?98??4C;'4;'A=>'!A=>;46;' !??>7@52'CD>H'F=>A=>H'CH';CA'AC'568;9='6;'>XI>B4A4C;'AC'+49452K''"=>'6554>?'CE'!A=>;?' 4;'+49452'?>;B'>;DC2?'6?:4;<'ECH'!A=> ;46;'64B'4;'A=>4H'CF;'94D45'F6H?K''#CF>D>HL' "=892B4B>?'76:>?'95>6H L '@CA='B4H>9A52'4 ;'=4?'6H9=6>C5C<2'6;B';6HH6A4D> 6;B 4;B4H>9A52' 4;'A=>'?I>>9='CE'=4?'9=6H69A>H? 'A=6A'A=>'AH8>'647'CE'A=>'!A=>;46;' >XI>B4A4C ;'AC'+49452'4?';CA'AC'=>5I'A=> '6554>? 'CE'!A=>;? L'@ 8A'AC'A6:>'CD>H'A=>'>;A4H>' 4?56;BK US ''"=>'AFC'?I>6:>H?'4;'"=892B4B>?0'=4?ACH2 '6H>'A=>'764;'!A=>;46;'<>;>H65?Y %4946?L'A=>'96 8A4C8?L'6<>BL'?:>IA4965'D>A>H6; '6;B'!594@46B>?L'A=>'67@4A4C8?L'CIA474?A49' 2C8;<'<8;K &;'A=4?'9=6IA>H L '&'>5894B6A>'=CF'"=892B4B>?'?=C F?'%4946?^'?A H6A><2'AC'@>'A=>' IH>E>H6@5>'C;> '6;B'!594@46B>?^'?AH6A><2'AC'@>'A=>'455 R 6BD4?>B'C;>K''3=45>'"=892B4B>?' BC>?';CA';BCH?>'>4A=>H'?I>6:>H'6?'=>'B4B'F4A=',>H495>?L'=>'BC>?L' @>ECH>'>69='?I>>9=L'6>'CH'B4?6>'F4A='6'76ZCH'IC4;A'CE '>69='C;>^?'6H<87>;AK'' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' US '\ UKPKP]L'\UKVKS]L'\UKPVKS]K

PAGE 72

69 G8HA=>HL'"=892B4B>?'I56;A?'H=>ACH4965'B>D49>?'4;'>69='9=6H69A>H^?'?I>>9='A=6A' B>7C;?AH6A>'A=>'=2IC9H4 ?2'CE'A=>'?I>6:>H'=>'B4?I6H6<>? '6;B'A=>'<>;84;>;>??'CE'A=>' ?I>6:>H'=>'F6;A?'AC'IHC7CA>K''&'F455'>XI564;'A=>'476<>'CE'%4946?'6;B'!594 @46B>?' 9H>6A>B'@2'A=>4H'?I>>9=>?'6;B'=CF'A=4?'476<>'4?'6EE4H7>B'@2'A=>';6HH6A4D>K''&;' 6BB4A4C;'AC'C8A54;4;<'"=892B4B>?0'ICHAH64A?'CE'%4946?'6;B'!594@46B>?L'&' F455' 9C7I6H>' A=>4H'?I>>9=>?'F4A='@CA= ',>H495>?0'6;B'.5>C;^?'?I>>9=>? '6;B'B>A>H74;>'A=>'?I>94E49' F6 2?'4;'F=49='"=892B4B>?'B>D>5CI?'A=>'>DC58A4C;'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4IK G4H?A'F>'F455'>X674;>'%4946?0'?I>>9=K''"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?'%4946?'6?'A=>' >XI>H4>;9>BL'6;B'A=>' 6IIHCIH46A>52'968A4C8?L'?I>6:>H '6;B'B>?9H4@>?'=47'6?'6>4;<' F4A='A=>'6;652?4?'IH>D4C8?52' CEE>H>B'4;'A=>';6HH6A4D>K''"=892B4B>?'95647? L '4;'=4?' +494546;''6H9=6>C5C<2 L 'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?0'AH8>'67@4A4C;'F6?'AC'9C;J8>H'A=>'F=C5>'CE' +49452L';CA'7>H>52'AC'IHCA>9A'A=>4H'6554>?'\UKU]K''&;'A=4?'B>@6A> L'"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?' %4946? '6?'7CA4D6A>B'AC'?I>6:'@> 968?>'=>'A=C8<=A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'F6;A>B'AC'9C;J8>H' A=>'F=C5>'CE'+49452'\UKV]K''1>ECH>'F>'=>6H'6;2'FCHB?'CE'%4946?'=47?>5EL'F>'6H>' 4;ECH7>B'A=6A'=>'=>5B'A=>'D>H2'?67>'I>H?I>9A4D>'CE'A=>'>XI>B4A4C;'A=6A'"=892B4B>?' B4BK''"=4?'IH>I6H>?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'?>>'A=>'H>6? C;4;<' A=6A'%4946?'<4D>?'4;'=4?'?I>>9= 6;B'AC'699>IA'=4?'6H<87>;A?K''+4;9>'%4946?^'CF;'68B4>;9>'CE'!A=>;46;?'F6?';CA' 9C;D4;9>B'@2'=4?'6H<87>;A?L'A=>'H>6B>H'F455'65?C'5CC:'ECH'A=>'H>6?C;'A=6A'%4946?' E645>B'AC'9C;D4;9>'=4?'9C;A>7ICH6H4>?L'B>?I4A>'A=>'68A=CH4A 2'CE'=4?'6H<87>;A?K'' %4946?^'E6458H>'4;D4 A>?'6'9C7I6H4?C;'@>AF>>;'=47L ',>H495>? L '6;B'.5>C;K 3=>;'%4946?'@><4;?'AC'?I>6:L'=>'C8A54;>?'A=>'H>6 ?C;?'A=6A'=>'?=C85B'@>' @>54>D>B '6;B'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'?=C85B';CA'8;B>HA6:>'6;'>XI>B4A4C;'AC'+49452 K''G4H?AL' =>'?=C 85B'@>'@>54>D>B '@>968?>'=>'6?'6;'4;B4D4B865'FC85B'IHC?I>H'EHC7'A=>'

PAGE 73

70 >XI>B4A4C; Uj L '@8A'=>'?A455'6H<8>?'6<64;?A'4A '6;B'A=>H>ECH>'6<64;?A'=4?'CF;'I>H?C;65' <64;'\UKW]K''+>9C;BL'=>'6H<8>?'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'FC85B'5>6D>'A=>7?>5D>?'CI>;'AC' 6AA69:'6A'=C7>'C;9>'A=>2' =6D>'9C774AA>B'6'56H<>'ECH9>'AC''?A6A>?'A=6A'A= >'!A=>;46;?'=6D>'54AA5>'AC'<64; '6;B'789='AC'5C?>'\UKPP]K''GC8HA=L'6;B' E4;6552L'=>'6AA69:?'A=C?>'F=C'?8IICHA'A=>'>XI>B4A4C ;L'956474;<'A=6A'A=>2'6H>'2C8;< 6;BL'7C?A'47ICHA6;A52L'4;>X I>H4>;9>B'\UKP[]K''"=>'E4H?A'A=H>>'IC4;A?'6H>'H>74;4?9>;A' CE'A=>'6BD49>'CE',>H495>?L'F=C'6H<8>B'A=6A'A=>'?A6A>'?=C85B'IHC?I>H'@>ECH>'A=>' 4;B4D4B865'\NKUOKN]L'A=6A';>F'F6H?'?=C85B';CA'@>'8;B>HA6:>;'\PKPSS]L'6;B'A=6A'4A'4?' @>AA>H'AC';CA'5C?>'F=6A'C;>'=6?'A=6 ;'AC'<64;'F=6A'C;>'BC>?';CA'=6D>K'\NKUNK[]K''"=>' 4HC;2'4?'A=6A L 'F=45>'%4946?^'H>6?C;4;<'4?'Z8?A'6?'?C8;B'6?',>H495>?^L'=4?'CH6ACH2'4?';CA'6?' I>H?86?4D>K''GCH'A=4?'H>6?C;L'=>'6B74A?'A=HC8<=C8A'=4?'?I>>9='A=6A'=>'F455'@>'8;6@5>' AC'I>H?86B> 'A=>'!A=>;46;?'@2'= 4?'FCHB?L '?C '=> 'H>54>?'C;'=4?'E4;65'IC4;AL'A=>'4;D>9A4D>' 6<64;?A'!594@46B>?K''%4946?'4?'ICHAH62>B'6?'8;9C;D4;94;?I>946552'4;'A=4?'E4;65'IC4;AL' 6;B'A=4?'4?'F=>H>'=>'B4D>H<>?'?=6HI52'EHC7',>H495>?K GHC7'A=>'C8A?>AL'%4946?'6B74A?'A=6A'=>'FC85B'=C5B'!A=>; 46;?'AC'A=>'7CB>H6A>' 9C8H?>L'6?',>H495>?'B4BL'4E'=>'9C85B'9C;D4;9>'A=>7K''#>'477>B46A>52'H>Z>9A?'A=4?' IC??4@454A2L'?624;<'A=6A'=4?'FCHB?'6H>'ACC'F>6:'AC'9C;D4;9>'=4?'68B4>;9>'AC'6DC4B'H4?:' ECH'B8@4C8?'H>F6HB?L'@8A'A=6A'=>'9C85B'C;52'?=CF'A=>7'A=6A'A=>4H'67 @4A4C;'4?' B4EE4985A'AC'C@A64;'\UKW]K''"=4?'4?'54:>52'AC'@>'6'B4H>9A'H>E>H>;9>'AC',>H495>?^' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' Uj 3=45>'%4946?'762'=6D>'IHC?I>H>B'EHC7'A=>'>XI>B4A4C;L'=>'65?C'54:>52'FC85 B'=6D>'@>;>E4AA>B'EHC7' IH>D>;A4;<'A=>'>XI>B4A4C;K''#>'4?'9=6H69A>H4h>BL'B8H4;<'A=>',>69>'CE'%4946?L'6?'B>?4H4;<'I>69>'AC'6DC4B' 5C?4;<'=4?'F4;; 4;<'H>9CHB'6?'6'<>;>H65K'\jKPU] '&A'4?';CA'8;H>6?C;6@5>'AC'B>B89>'A=6A'=>'762'=6D>' ?47456H'7CA4D6A4C;?'B8H4;<'A=>' +494546;'B>@6A>K''%>D>HA=>5>??L'"=892B4B>?'BC>?'95>6H52'ICHAH62'%4946?' 6?'9CHH>9A'6@C8A'A=>'E65?>'7 >H4A'CE'A=>'+494546;'>XI>B4A4C; 'kH4@@5>L' NOOUL'SjW R SUNK UU !A=>;?'F6?';C74;6552'6A'I>69>'F4A='+I6HA6L'@8A'A=4?'I>69>'AH>6A2L'6?'%4946?'6H<8>?L'F6?';CA'?A6@5> K'' l"=>',>69>'CE'%4946?'KKK'F6?';>D>H'E8552'47I5>7>;A>BK''"=C8<='+I6HA6'B>?4H>B'I>69>'6;B';>>B>B'4A'AC' @H4;<'=>H'H>?A5>??'6554>?'8;B>H'9C;AHC5L'A=>'6554>?'A=>7?>5D>?'E>5A'A=6A'A=>2'=6B'@>>;'@>AH62>B'6;B' H>E8?>B'AC'C@?>HD>' A=>'9568?>?'A=6A'9C;9>H;>B'A=>7 m' 1CFH6L'PWTPL'NUSK

PAGE 74

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l6'?9=>7>'8;>X>98A>B'4?' F4A='~!A=>;46;?'6'IC?4A4D>'5C??m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

PAGE 75

72 A=>4H'ECH9>?L'F=49='BC>?'=6II>;K''#>'65?C'H>E >H?'AC'A=>'F6H;4;H495>?'6;B'A=>' 74?A6:>?'CE'.5>C; 'F=>;'=>'@>'!A=>;46;? ';CA'AC'H'>7I4H> 'F=45>' A=>4H'98HH>;A'C;>'4?'6A'H 4?:K''&;'=4?'?I>>9=L'%4946?'8?> ?'A=>'D>5 CI7>;A'CE' !A=>;46;'H>9:5>??;>?? '\EHC7'H>?AH64;>B'8;B>H',>H495>?L'AC';8HA8H>B'8;B>H'.5>C;L' 6;B'E4;6552 'AC C8A'CE'9C;AHC5'4;'=4?'CF;'A47>] 'AC'ECH>?=6BCF'A=>'4;>D4A6@5>' B>?AH89A4C ;'A=6A'@>E655?'!A=>;?K''12'IH>B49A4;<'A=>'H>65'9C;?>J8>;9>?'A=6A'F455'C998H' @>968?>'CE'A=>'+494546;'$XI>B4A4C;L'F=45>'H>E>HH4;<'AC'A=>'B>94?4C;?'4;'A=>'I6?A'A=6A' ?=6I>B'!A=>;46;'9=6H69A>HL'%4946?' BH6F?'B4H>9A'9C;;>9A4C;?'67C;< 'A=>'<>;>H65?L' F=49='B>7C;?AH6 A>'A=>'>DC58A4C;'6;B'B>954;>'CE'5>6B>H?=4I'4;'!A=>;?K'%4946?' 8;:;CF4;<52'47I54>?'6'95>6H'968?65'54;:'@>AF>>;'A=>'6H9'CE'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4I'6;B' A=>'4;>D4A6@5>'!A=>;46;'9C556I?>K G4;6552L'%4946?'6AA>7IA?'AC'I>H?86B>'A=>'6??>7@52'A C'H>764;'8;?F62>B'@2' !594@ 46B>? '6;B'76:>?'6'I>H?C;65'6AA69:'6<64;?A'=47'\UKPN]K''#>'BC>?';CA'7>;A4C;' !594@46B>?'@2'; 67>L'@8A'=>'95>6H52'47I5496A>?'=47 'F=>;'=>'6998?>? '6;2'!A=>;46;' A=>H>'F=C'AH4>?'AC'IHCE4A'EHC7'A=>'I8@549'>XI>B4A4C;'AC'?8IICHA'=4?'CF;'IH4D6A>' 4;A>H>?A?'\UKPNKN]K'' "=>'6AA69:? 'A=6A'%4946?'76:>?'6<64;?A'!594@46B>?'6H>'>9=C>B'4;' "=892B4B>?0'IH>E69>'AC'!594@46B>?0'CF;'?I>>9='6A'A=>'?67>'6??>7@52'\UKPj]K''&;'A=4?' F62 L 'F>'?>>'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'CEE>H?'47I5494A'6IIHCD65'6A'A=>'>;B'CE'%4946?0'?I>>9='6?' F>55'6?'4;'A=>'@><4;;4; D>HA=>5>??L'A=C8<='"=892B4B>?'95>6H52'@CC:>;B?'%4946?0' ?I>>9='F4A='=4?'CF;'?8@A5>'6IIHCD65'4;'A=>';6HH6A4D>L'A=6A'BC>?';CA'76:>'A=>'69A865' 6H<87>;A?'A=6A'%4946?'8?>?'6;2'7CH>'9C;D4;94;'I>H?C;65'6??685A'A=6A'%4946?' 76:>?'4?'8;4J8>'6;B'B4??47456 H'AC'6;2'6H<87>;A'<4D>;'@2',>H495>?K'',>H495>?'76:>?' 95>6H'4;'=4?'G8;>H65'QH6A4C;'A=6A'!A=>;?'4?'6A'@>968?>'4A'H>F6HB?'7>H4A'\NK[T]K''

PAGE 76

73 3=45>',>H495>?'BC>?'?A6A>'A=6A'7>6<>H'7>6;?'?=C85B';CA'IH>D>;A'6'96I6@5>'I>H?C;' EHC7'6?9>;B4;<'AC'CEE49>L'=>H>'%4946?'6 H<8>?'A=6A'6A'7>6;?'?=C85B'IH>D>;A'6' 96I6@5>'I>H?C;L'ECH'!594@46B>?'F6?'6'96I6@5>'<>;>H65K''%4946?'76:>?'6'95647'=>H>'A=6A' 4?';CA'C;52'8; R ,>H495>6;L'@8A'65?C'8; R #>55>;49 UV L'6;B'A=>H>ECH>'4?';CA'C;52' 8;?899>??E85L'@8A'762'>D>;'B4?9H>B4A'%4946?'=47?>5EK''+ 4;9>'A=4?'4?'%4946?0'56?A' ?A6A>7>;A'4;'A=4?'?I>>9=L' =>'>;B?'C;'6;'8;9C;D4;94;<';CA> '6;B'?>A?'A=>'?A6<>'ECH' !594@46B>?'AC'H>?IC;B'AC'= 4?'8;F6HH6;A>B'655><6A4C;?'4;'6BB4A4C;'AC '=4?'5><4A476A>' IC4;A?K !EA>H'%4946?'9C;958B>?'=4?'?I>>9=L'6?:4;<'ECH'6'H>9C;?4B> H6A4C;'CE'A=>'+494546;' $XI>B4A4C;L'"=892B4B>?'?A6A>?'A=6A'A=>H>'F>H>'7CH>'!A=>;46;?'F=C'967>'ECHF6HBL' 7C?A'6H<84;<'ECH'A=>'$XI>B4A4C;L'@8A'C;52'<4D>?'A=>'?I>>9='CE'!594@46B>?'=47?>5EK'' "=892B4B>?'>XI564;?'A=6A'!594@46B>?'F6?'A=>'7C?A'6 D4B'?8IICHA>H'CE'A=>' >XI>B4A4C; 6;B'A=6A'=>'F6?'7CA4D6A>B'AC'?I>6:'@>ECH>'A=>'6??>7@52'AC'A=F6HA'%4946?L'F=C'F6?' =4?'IC54A4965'CIIC;>;A'6;B'F=C'=6B'Z8?A'6AA69:>B' =47'4;'=4?'CF;'?I>>9=L'6;B' AC' I>H?C;6552'<64;'F>65A='6;B'E67>'EHC7'A=>'?899>??'CE'A=>'$XI>B4A4C;K''!A'A=4?'IC4;AL' =892B4B>?'5CC:?'6 =>6B '6;B'>XI5494A52'54;:?'!594@46B>?0'>X9>??4D>'I>H?C;65'54E>'F4A=' A=>'56A>H'BCF;E655'CE'!A=>;?K UW '"=4?'4?'C;>'CE'C;52'EC8H'I569>?'4;'A=>'F=C5>'#4?ACH2' F=>H>'"=892B4B>?'ECH>96?A?'A=>'47I69A'CE'6'IH>?>;A'94H987?A6;9>'C;'A=>'E8A8H>K TO '' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' UV "=>';CA4C;'A=6A' IH4D6A>'?899>??'?=C85B'H>?85A'4;'I8@549'ICF>H'4?'IH>D 65>;A'4;'6'?C94>A2'A=6A'EC98?>?' C;'6;B'H>F6HB?'9C7I>A4A4C;'6?'789='6?'A=>'kH>>:?'B4BK'',>H=6I?L'A=C8<=L'%4946?'=4;A?'6A'!594@46B>?' C54<6H9=49L'6;B';C; R B>7C9H6A49'?56;AK''#CF>D>HL'4E'A=4?'F6?'=4?'4;A>;B>B'>EE>9AL'4A'F6?';CA'H>654h>BK UW kH4@@5>'?62?'A=6A'A=4 ?'IH>B49A4C;'6A'UKPj'A6:>?'A=>'6;652?4?'CE'A=>'B>E>6A'CE'!A=>;?'6A'NKUj'_AC'6';>F' 5>D>5_L'@2'956474;<'6'B4H>9A'968?65'4;E58>;9>'@>AF>>;'A=>'E6454;'4;B4D4B865L'!594@46B>?L'6;B' !A=>;?^'B>E>6AK''!594@46B>?'=8HA'A=>'94A2'B4H>9A52'@2'E5C8A4;<'A=>',>H49 5>6;'4B>65'CE'6;'4;B4D4B865'@>4;<' 6A'C;52'6?'6'I6HA'CE'A=>'94A2L'@2'B>IH4D4;<'A=>'>XI>B4A4C;'CE'=4?'CF;'5>6B>H?=4IL'6;B'@2'B> E>9A4;<' 6;B'64B4;<'A=>'+I6HA6;? 'kH4@@5>L' NOOU L 'SUN R SUSLK TO "=>'A=H>>'CA=>H?'6H>L',>H495>?'C@4A86H2'6A'NKUjL'F=49='4?'>XA>;?4D>5 2'6;652h>B'4;'72'A=>?4?L'6?'F>55' 6?'A=>'9=6H69A>H4h6A4C;'CE'1H6?4B6?'6A'SKVPL'6;B'A=>'?>9C;B'IHCC>7487'6A'jKNUK''&A'4?';CA>FCHA=2'A=6A'

PAGE 77

74 "=>H>EC H>'4A'4?'477>;?>52'?4<;4E496;A'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'=47?>5E'>XI5494A52'@567>?' !594@46B>?'I>H ?C;6552K ''!?'6'76AA>H'CE'E69AL'!594@46B>?^'I8@549'54E>L'CH'=4?'I>HECH76;9>' 6?'<>;>H65L'F6?'6?'>X9>55>;A'6?'6;2t';>D>HA=>5>?? L '=>'F6?'?C'67@4A4C8?'6;B'>B2'4;' =4?'IH4D6 A>'54E> 'A=6A'=>'CEE>;B>B'>D>H2C;>L' ?C'A=>2'H>E8?>B'AC'655CF'=47'AC'9C;A4;8>' AC'9C776;B'\UKPj]K''&;'A=>'?I>>9= L '=>'4?'I>H?86?4D>L'@8A'A=>'6H<8 7>;A?'A=6A'=>'<4D>?' 6H>'B8@4C8? '6;B'B>94B>B52'8; R ,>H495>6;K !594@46B>?'E4H?A'6;?F>H?'%4946?^'6998 ?6A4C;'A=6A'=>'4? '8;E4A'AC'5>6B 'B8>'AC'=4?' 4;>XI>H4>;9>'6;B'>X9>??'4;'=4?'IH4D6A>'54E>K''#CF>D>HL'F=45>'%4946?^'CH4<4;65'6AA69:' 8IC;'!594@46B>?'4?'8; R ,>H495>6;L'!594@46B>?^'6;?F>H'4?'>J86552'8; R ,>H495>6;K''#>' 95647?'A=6A'=4?'>XAH6D6<6;A'?I>;B4;<'4?'Z8?A4E4>B L '6;B'>D>;'568B 6@5> L '@>968?>'4A'=6?' @HC8<=A'<5CH2'AC'@CA='=4?'6;9>?ACH?'6;B'AC'=4?'9C8;AH2K''3> L 'A=>'H>6B>H L ':;CF'A=6A' ,>H495>?^'D4>FIC4;A'=6?'@>>;'A=6A'A=>'6A;>??'CE'6;'4;B4D4B865'94A4h>;'I65>?'@>ECH>' A=>'?AH>;'9C8;AH2'4;'F=49='=>'54D>?'\N K UOKN]K''"=4?'IC4; A'4?'>7I=6?4h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

PAGE 78

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jKPP'74<=A'?>>7'AC'H>D>65'A=6A'"=892B4B>?'6>B'F4A='!594@46B>?^'6??>??7>;A' CE'A=>'7454A6H2'?AH>;D>HL'"=892B4B>?'?A6A>?'A=6A '!A=>;46;'B4?9CHB'6A'=C7> '6;B'A=> H>?85A6;A 'E6458H>'AC'H>?8II52'A=>'AHCCI? F>H>'A=>'AH8>'968?> ? K''1>968?>'CE'A=4?L'4E'"=892B4B>?'=>H>' 6>?'F4A='!594@46B>?^'6??>??7>;A'CE'ECH9>L'B>?I4A>'=4?'56A>H';6HH6A4D>'ICHAH6265L'=>'65?C'6>?'F4A=' %4946?^'6??>??7>; A'CE'!A=>;46;'?A6@454A2'6A'=C7> 'i6=H;AL' NOOU L'UNW K

PAGE 79

76 6 <64;?A'$I4B68H8?'8 ;B>H',>H495>? '6;B'6<64;?A',CA4B6>6'8;B>H'#6<;C;'\UK[PKN]K TN '' "=892B4B>?'>XI564;?'A=6A'A=>'@>?A'76H4;>?'6;B'?'F>H>'?>5>9A>B'AC'76;' A=>'>XI>B4A 4C; '6;B'A=6A'>69='H>9>4D>B'6'56H<>'67C8;A'CE'I627>;AK''"=>'47IH>??4C;'CE' A=4?'476<>L'699CHB4;<'AC'"=892B 4B>?L'4?'A=6A'4A'?>>7>B'AC';C; R !A=>;46;?'AC'@>'_7CH>' 6'B4?I562'CE'ICF>H'6;B'H>?C8H9>?'A=6;'6;'6H767>;A'6<64;?A'6;'>;>72_'\UK[PKS]K'' "=892B4B>?'>D>;'?'?C'E6H'6?'AC'>7I=6?4h>'!594@46B>?^';><5>9A'CE'E4;6;9>?'F=>;'=>' 8?>?'A=>'9C;B4A4C;65Y "6 '6;2C;>'=6B'9C 8;A>B'8I'A=>'I8@549'>XI>;B4A8H>'CE'A=>'?A6A>KKK'A=>'IH4D6A>' C8A562' CE'4;B4D4B865?KKK'A=>'?87?'96IA64;?'CE'AH4H>7>?'=6B'564B'C8A'6;B'F>H>'?A455'AC' 562' C8AKKK'A=>'ZC8H;>2'7C;>2'ECH'6'DC26<>'CE'?89='5>;'?C5B4>H?'ACC:' F4A=' A=>7KKK' 278; '4A'FC8 5B'=6D>'@>>;'EC8;B'A=6A'76;2'A65>;A?'=6B'@>>;'A6:>;'C8A' CE'A=>' 94A2_'\UK[PKj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j]K !594@46B>?'76:>?'6;CA=>H'6H<87>;A6A4D>'E56F'9C;9>H;4;<'A=>'7CA4D6A4C;'CE' A=>'>XI> B4A4C;K''"=>'CEE49465'!A=>;46;'7CA4D6A4C;'4?'AC'64B>'!A=>;46;'6554>?'4;'+49452L' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' TN %CH76552L'4A'4?'"=892B4 B>?^' H3?>1(3:84<;?0( AC'5>6D>'6;2'9C7I6H4?C;'CE'>D>;A?'4;'A=>'=4?ACH2'AC'A=>' H>6B>H'=47?>5EK''!?'7>;A4C;>B'4;'ECCA;CA>'6@CD>L'A=>H>'6H>'EC8H'_E56?= R ECHF6HB?_K''#>H>L'F>'=6D>'6' _E56?= R @69:F6HB_L'6;B'A=>H>'6H>'?>D>;'?89='4;'A=>'#4?ACH2K''"=6A'"=892B4B>?^'8?>? 'C;>'=>H>'4;B496A>?' A=>'6?I>9A'CE'A=>'$XI>B4A4C;'A=6A'!594@46B>?'B4B';CA'6BBH>??'4;'=4?'?I>>9=K''+4;9>'!594@46B>?'B4B';CA' 6BBH>??'A=4?'4??8>L'F>'A=>'H>6B>H'FC85B';CA'@>'4;ECH7>B'CE'4A'CA=>HF4?>K

PAGE 80

77 @8A'A=>'H>6B>H':;CF?'A=6A'A=4?'F6?';CA'A=>'AH8>'7CA4D6A4C;K''&;'E69AL'A=>'!A=>;46;?' =CI>'AC'69=4>D>'6A'F> 65A='A=HC8<='9C;J8>?A'CE'+49452 '6;B L 'D46'A=>'H>?C8H9>?'A=8?' <64;>BL' AC'>XI6;B'A=>4H'>7I4H>'>D>;'C;AC'CA=>H'I6HA?'CE'kH>>9>K T[ ''"=892B4B>?'?A6A>?' A=4?'4;'=4?';6HH6A4D>L'6;B'%4946?'F6H;?'6<64;?A'A=4?'4;'=4?'?I>>9=K''1CA='6H<8>'A=6A'A=4?' AH8>';?'AC'69A86552'69=4>D>K''!594@46B>?'E645?'AC'6BBH>??' A= 4?'6H<87>;AK''#>'6H<8>?'A=6A'!A=>;?'C8<=A'AC'?8IICHA'4A?'6554>?L'6II>654;<'AC'A=>' ?=67' Z8?A4E496A4C;K''#>'?8HIH4?>?'8? 'A=C8<=L'F=>;'=>'65?C'?A6A>?'A=6A'!A=> ;?'?=C85B' 9C;J8>H'655'CE'+49452 '6;B'A=>;'7CD>'C;'AC'9C;J8>H'A=>'H>?A'CE'kH>>9>K !594@46B>?'=>B<>? =4?'@>A?'@>AF>>;'A=>'AFC'B4?I6H6A>'Z8?A4E496A4C;?'C E'A=>' >XI>B4A4C; '6;B'@>968?>'CE'A=4?L'=4?'?I>>9='4?'?I54A'@>AF>>;'A=>'AFC'A=>7>?'CE' B>E>;B4 ;<'C;>?^'6554>?'F=C'6H>'4;';>>B '6;B'A=>';>>B'ECH'6;'>7I4H>'AC'8;9>6?4;<52' 6<??'6;B'>XI6;BK''"=4?'H>?85A?'4;'A=> 'H4B4985C8?'9C;E56A4C;'CE'A=>'AFC'4B>6?Y'l&A'4?' A=8?'A=6A'>7I4H>'=6?'@>>;'FC;KKK'@2'6'9C;?A6;A'H>6B4;>??'AC'?8IICHA'655KKK'A=6A'4;D4A>' 6??4?A6;9>m'\UKPVKN]K''#>'?'C;'AC'>XI5494A52'H>E8A>'CEE>H4;<'=>5I'AC'C;52'A=C ?>'F=C7' 4A'4?'I>HA4;>;A'AC'=>5I '6;B'76:4; <'C;52' 6' E>F';>F'9C;J8>?A?K''"=>'IC5492'A=6A' !594@46B>?'=>H>'>;BCH?>?Y'= >5I4;<'6;2'6552'8;9C;B4A4C;6552 '6;B'6 AA69:4;<'6;2'>;>72' CE'A=6A'6552L '4;'6BB4A4C;'AC'@>4;<'95>6H52'8;?C8;BL'4?'65?C'6<64;?A'A=>'?CHA'CE' 7CB>H6A4C;'A=6A',>H495>?'6BDC96A>B'4;'=4?'A=H>>' ?I>>9=>?L'6?'F>55'6?'6<64;?A'A=>'?CHA' CE'IC54A4965'9659858?'A=6A'CA=>H'!A=>;46;?'=6D>'6II54>B'4;'?47456H'?4A86A4C;?K TS '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' T[ 1>968?>'A=>'!A=>;46;?'?>;B'6'ECH9>'789='ACC'76??4D>'AC'69=4 >D>'A=>4H'?A6A>B'647L'A=>2'69A86552' 4;A474B6A>'76;2'CE'A=>4H'ECH7>H'6554>?'6A'+49452L'F=C'E>6H'!A=>;?^'H>65'647?'CE'ACA65'9C;J8>?AK''3=6A'4?' 7CH>L'=6D4;<'9C774AA>B'?89='6'56H<>'ECH9>L'A=>'!A=>;46;?'9C85B';CA'H>AH>6A'EHC7'+49452'F4A=C8A' ?8EE>H4;<'6'?>H4C8?' 5C??'CE'IH>?A4<>K'i6=H;AL' NOOU L 'USS K TS &;'I6HA49856H'A=>'B>94?4C;?'76B>'@2'A=>'!A=>;46;?'B8H4;<'A=>'.CH4;A= R .CH92H6'6EE64H'4;'" =892B4B>?0' 4;AHCB89A4C;K'\PKSj] '&;'B4?98??4C;'CE'A=4?'>D>;AL'6?'4;'6;2'CA=>HL'A=>'!A=>;46;?'B>@6A>B'A=>'IHC?'6;B' 9C;?'CE'=>5I4;< '>4A=>H'?4B>K''!A'E4H?AL'A=>2'?4B>B'F4A='A=>4H'ECH7>H'>;>74>?L'@8A'H>D 4?>B'A=>4H'B>94?4C;' 4;'6'?>9C;B '6??>7@52K''"=>'Z8?A4E496A4C;'4;'>69='96?>L'=CF>D>HL'4?'76B>'@2'A=>'>XI>B4>;9>'CE'A=>'

PAGE 81

78 !594@46B>?0'95647'A=6A'>7I4H>'4?'FC;'A=HC8<='9C;?A6;A'@6AA5>'4?'95>6H52' 9C;AH6B49A>B'@2'A=>'69A4C;?'CE'!A=>;?'B8H4;<'A=>',>H?46;'36H?Y'F= 45>'7C?A'CE'A=>' kH>>:?'8;4A>B'6<64;?A'A=>'9C77C;'EC>L'A=>2'B4B';CA'H>?4?A'A=>',>H?46;?'6A'>D>H2' IC4;A'CE'6AA69:L'@8A'C;52'F=>H>'4A'F6?'F4?>'AC'BC'?C'\PKPVKN]K''"=>H>ECH>L'F=>;'A=>' ,>H ?46;?'6BD6;9>B'AC'6AA69:'!A=>;? '6;B'A=>'94A2'F6?'8;A>;6@5>L'A=>'!A=>;46;? _76B>'8I'A=>4H'74;B ?'AC'6@6;BC;'A=>'94A2_'\PKPVKN] '6;B'655CF>B'4A'AC'@>'?69:>BK Tj '' $D>H2'!A=>;46;'4;'A=>'68B4>;9>'FC85B'=6D>'@>>;'F>55'6F6H>'CE'A=>?>'>D>;A?K''-?4;<' !594@46B>?0'5C<49L'A=>')>546;'5>6<8>'?=C85B'=6D>'B>E>;B>B'!A=>;?L'6?'F>55'6?'655'CE'A=>' CA= >H'94A4>?'A=6A'A=>',>H?46;?'H6;?6 9:>B'@>ECH>'A=>2'H>69=>B'!A=>;? 'B>?I4A>'A=>' B4EE4985A2L'4E';CA'C8AH4<=A'47IC??4@454A2L'4;DC5D>BK''!594@46B>?0'95647'65?C'E645?'AC' 9C4;94B>'F4A=',>H495>?0'6BD49>'B8H4;<'A=>'CH4<4;65'+I6HA6;'4;D6?4C;K'',>H495>?'6BD4?>B' !A=>;? 'AC'H>EH64;'EHC7'B>E>;B4;<'A=>4H' 56;B'4;'A=>'477>B46A>'6H>6'6HC8;B'A=>'94A2'4;' 6;'8;;>9>??6H2'56;B'@6AA5>'\NKNN]K''&E'?89='95C?>'6;B'477>B46A>'56;B'6?'764;56;B' !AA496'96;'@>'5>EA'8;B>E>;B>BL'?8H>52'6'H>7CA>'4?56;B'?89='6?'+49452L'A=6A'@>6H?';C' AH4@8A>' AC'!A=>;?L'9C85B'@>'5>EA'Z8?A'6?'8;B>E>;B>BK !594@46B>?'?I>>9=L'=CF> D>HL'F6?'I>H?86?4D>'6A'A=>'A47> '6;B'6@5>'AC'9C;D4;9>' =4?'!A=>;46;'68B4>;9>'AC'8;B>HA6:>'A=>'>XI>B4A4C;K''%>D>HA=>5>??L'"=892B4B>?' ICHAH62?'A=>'9CH>'CE'!594@46B>?0'6H<87>;A?'6?'8;9C;D4;94; <'AC'=4?'H>6B>HL'@2' 47I5494A52'9C7I6H4;<'=47'F4A=',>H495>?K''!594@46B>?^'7CA4D6A4C;L'=4?'D>H2'@6?4?'ECH' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' B>94?4C;'ECH'!A=>;?L';CA'B8>'AC'6;2'9C774A7>;A'E>5A'ECH'A=>'6554>B'? A6A>K''"=6A'=>H>L'4;'A=>'+494546;' B>@6A>L'=>5I4;<'C;>?'6554>?'4?';CA'?8EE494>;A'Z8?A4E496A4C;'4?'6;'4;?A6;9>'CE'A=>'8;B>H524;<'A=>7>'CE' H>6?C;4;<'IH>?>;A'4;'IC54A49?'CE'A=>'A47>L'6?'"=892B4B>?0'ICHAH62?'4AK''"=>'4B>6'A=6A'>A=49?'C8<=A'AC'@>' 7CH>'9C7I5496A> B'A=6;'?47I52'=>5I4;<'655'C;>0?'EH4>;B?'6;B'=6H74;<'655'C;>0?'>;>74>?'4?'6;94>;A' ?CI=4?7K''"=>'4B>6'A=6A'>XI>B4>;9>'6;B';CA'7CH654A2'7CA4D6A>?'?A6A>?'4?'9C;A>7ICH6H2'IC54A4965' H>654?7K Tj 3=45>'A=>'?69:'CE'!A=>;?'B8H4;<'A=>',>H?46;'F6H'4?';CA'4;958B>B'4;'"= 892B4B>?0'6H9=6>C5C<2L'4A'4?' 7>;A4C;>B'4;'#>HCBCA8?0'=4?ACH2K''G8HA=>HL'6;2'!A=>;46;'4;'A=>'68B4>;9>'CE'A=>'B>@6A>'FC85B'?8H>52' :;CF'CE'A=>'>D>;AK

PAGE 82

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

PAGE 83

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}der 'AC'B>?9H4@>'A=>'IH>I6H6A4C;?L' 47I524;<'AC'A=>'!A=>;46;?'A=6A'A=>2'78?A'8;B>HA6:>'A=>7Y'l csx`beg scxxc|g KKK' }d{pe` {yeg ewv`p m 5 4A>H6552Y'4A '4?';>9>??6H2'AC'?>;B'76;2'ECCA' ?C5B4>H?K''"=>'>EE>9A'4?' A=6A'A=>'!A=>; 46;?'=6D>'65H>6B2'6??87>B'A=6A'A=>2'F455'E85E455'A =>'H>J84H>7>;A?'CE' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' TT "=>'4;A>;A4C;'4?';>D>H'>XI5494A52'?A6A>B'@2'%4946?L'@8A'H6A=>H'7>;A4C;>B'@2'"=892B4B>?'4;'A=>' ;6HH6A4D>K' '&A'4?'47IC??4@5>'AC':;CF'ECH'9>HA64;'F=>A=>H'"=892B4B>?'B>B89>B'%4946?0'4;A>;A4C;L'CH' 5>6H;>B'6@C8A'A=>7'EHC7'6;'4;A>HD4>F'F4A='%4946?'CH'?C7>C;>'4;'F=C7'%4946?'FC85B'=6D>'9C;E4B>BK'' "=>'4;A>;A4C;L'=CF>D>HL'4?'9C;?4?A>;A'F4A='%4946?'CF;'?A6A>B'647?'4;'=4? 'E4H?A'?I>>9 ='4;'A=>'6??>7@52L' ?C'F=6A>D>H' "=892B4B>?0'?C8H9>L'A=>'4;A>;A4C;'4?'?A455'Z8?A4E4>B'@2'%4946?0'CF;'FCHB?K'\UKPWKN] TV "=>'?AHC;<>? A'9C;?AH89A4C;'%4946?'9C85B'8?> 'FC85B'@>'A=>'IH>?>;A'9C;AH6E69A865'9C;B4A4C;65Y'l &E'F>' F6;A'AC'@>'6@5>'AC'A6:>'CD>H'+49452'\@8A'F>' <48;I2 ]L'A=>;'F>';>>B'A=>?>'ECH9>?'\@8A'F>'BC;0A]mK''"=4?' 9C;?AH89A4C;'47I54>?'A=6A'A=>'IHCIC?>B'A6?:'4?'4;E>6?4@5>L'F4A=C8A'>XI5494A52'?A6A4;<'A=6A'4A'4?K''%4946?'4;' E69A'8?>?'6'E8A8H>'7CH>'D4D4B'9C;?AH89A 4C;Y'l {p vxqcyvp KKK' vacyvqe m\UKN[]'F=49='=6?'A=>'?AHC;<>?A' 968?65'54;:'CE'6;2'9C;B4A4C;65'9C;?AH89A4C;K

PAGE 84

81 A=>'6 ICBC?4? '6;B'A=8?'A=6A'A=>'I HCA6?4?'F455'EC55CFK''3=>;'=>'E4;6552'<4D>?'=4?' 9C;B4A4C;65'?A6A>7>;AL'=>'8?>?'A=>'?AHC;<>?A'9C;B4A4C;'IC??4@5>L'6'E8A8H>'7C?A'D4D4B' 9C;?AH89A4C;L'6;B'=>'B C>?';CA'?62'A=6A'A=>'IH>I6H6A4C;?'A=6A'=>'4;B496A>B'FC85B';CA' @>'>;C8 <=K''!55'=>'4?'6@5>'AC'IHC=4@4A '4?'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'F455'C;52'@6H>52'\ ycx`g ]'@>' 6@5>' AC'?899>>B'4;'9C;J8>H4;<'+49452 '6;B'IH>?>HD4;<'A=>7?>5D>?'\ c|brg c`c` bv vacyvqe brp yvp fdebv`p be zv fe` ze`arae` ]'\UKN[]K''&;'=4?'7C?A'ICF>HE85' ?>;A>;9>L'=>'6B74A?'A=6A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'9C85B'A6:> '+49452'F4A='>;C8<='IH>I6H6A4C;t '=>' 96;;CA'?6 2'l%ClK''&E'F>'H>7CD>'=4?'H>?AH64;4;<'\ ycx`a ]L'A=>;'=4?'9C;B4A4C;65'H8;?Y'l&E' F>'H>'IHCD4B>B'F4A='>J84I7>;A'CE'C8H'CF;KKK'>J865'AC'A=>4H?KKK'>D>;' ?8HI6??4;<'4AKKK'F>'F455'@>'6@5>'AC'9C;J8>H'A=>7L'6;B'>D>;'IH>?>HD>'C8H?>5D>?Km''3=C' 4?'A=4?'?8IIC?> B'AC'B4??86B>€ ,>H495>?'65?C'8?>?'9C;B4A4C;65'I=H6?>?'4;'=4?'CF;'?I>>9=>?'>6H54>H'4;'A=>' #4?ACH2L'@8A',>H495>?'4?'789='7CH>'9C;D4;94;<'4;'=4?'8?6<>K'',>H495>?'7C?A'ICF>HE85' 6;B'7C?A'E67C8?'9C;B4A4C;65'?A6A>7>;A'4?'=4?'9C;958?4C;'AC'=4?'E4H?A'?I>>9=K''#4?' 764;''?I>>9='4?'AC'I>H?86B>'A=>'!A=>;46;?'AC'>;<6<>'+I6HA6'4;'F6HL'@8A'=>' 4?'96H>E85'AC'7CB>H6A> 'A=>'67@4A4C;?'CE'A=>'!A=>;46;? '6;B'=4?'6BD49>'4?'F>55' ?8776H4h>B'@2'A=4?'9C;B4A4C;65'I=H6?>Y'_ scxxe zv fe` exxe v}r vg vxs`ze bc| svd`vaqe` L' {p vqvx{bv ed}{p bv y{ vs`fbeaqe` eye scxvyc|pbvg fe` f`pz|pc|g e|qe`dvbc|g y{ sdcab`qvaqe` _'\PKPSS]K'',>H495>?'8?>?'6'IH>?>;A'<>;>H65'9C;B4A4C;65Y' _&E'2C8'B>94B>'AC'H>?AH64;'2C8H?>5D>?'EHC7'\>D>H]'>XI6;B4;<'2 C8H'H85>'6A'A=>'?67>' A47>'6?'2C8'F6<>'F6HL'6;B'65?C'BC';CA'\>D>H]'I8A'2C8H?>5D>?'4;'CA=>H'B6;<>H?L'A=>;'&'

PAGE 85

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vxs`ze _L'_=CI>_L'H6A=>H'A=6;'C8AH4<=A'_ p`f{p _L'_D49ACH2_K %4946?'65?C'4;=4@4A?'=4?'CF;'4;A>;A4C;?'F4A='A=>'8?>'CE'I8HIC?>'9568?>?'AC' B>?9H4@>'A=>'?899>??E85'>EE>9A?'CE'=4?'>XAH6D6<6;A'H>9C77>;B6A4C;?'\UKNN]K''#4?' ICCH52'I56;;>B'8?>'CE'A=>?>'9C;?AH89A4C;?' 9H>6A>B'6'95>6H'Z8?A4E496A4C;'CE'A=> H>9C77>;B6A4C;?'=>'<4D>?L'6;B'6??8H>? '=4?'68B4>;9>'A=6A' A=>2'F455 '69=4>D>' 4;A>;A4C;65'H>?85A?'EHC7'A=>4H'IH>I6H6A4C;?K''#>'6H<8>?'A=6A'A=>2'?=C85B'6HH4D>'6A' +49452'F4A='76;2'74??45>'AHCCI?L'l 4;'CHB>H'A=6A' A=>2'762'F 4A=?A6;B'A=>'96D65H2'CE'A=>' >;>72m'\ csrg sdcg bc vfv`prp `ss`fcp epbv}ra` ]K''#>'6H<8>?'A=6A'A=>2'?=C85B' @H4;<'76;2'?=4I?L'l 4;'CHB>H'AC' @H4;<'4;'C8H'?8II54>?'7CH>'>6?452m'\ `pe fe` be vs`b{zv`e de`cp vafcy`„ryvqe ]K''G4;6552L'=>'F6H;?'A=>7'AC'@H4;<';CA'C;52'76;2' ECCB?A8EE?'F4A='A=>7L'@8A'65?C'@ 6:>H?'6;B'AH6B>?7>;L'l 4;'CHB>H'A=6A L'4E'I>H9=6;9>'F>' @>'B>A64;>B'@2'?AH>??'CE'F>6A =>HL'A=>'6H72'762'=6D>'?8II54>? m'\ `pe {p sc| |sc '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' TW '' "=>'FCHB?'_>D>H_'6;B'_65F62?_'6H>';CA'IHCD4B>B'54A>H6552'4;'A=>'kH>>:'4A?>5EL'@8A'6H>'47I54>B'@2'A=>' 9C;?AH89A4C;K''!'IH>?>;A'<>;>H65'9C;B4A4C;65'?A6A>7>;A '47I54>?'6;'6??87IA4C;'4;'A=>'IHCA6?4?L'6;B'6' <>;>H65'H85>'4;'A=>'6ICBC?4?' A=6A 'EC55CF?K''"=4?'4?';6A8H6552'47I54>B'4;'A=>'kH>>:L'6;B'4?'>7I=6?4h>B'4;' $;<54?='@2'4;958B4;<'A=>? >'6BD>H@?K'#6;?>;'6;B'…84;;L 'NOOS L'WjK

PAGE 86

83 esxc`eg escxey†epryvqe v}{ { abdeb`e be vs`b{zv`e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h>B'4;'A=>' +49454 6;'>XI>B4A4C;K

PAGE 87

84 "=892B4B>?'=6?'65?C'ECH>?=6BCF>B'A=>'E685A?'CE'%4946?'6;B'!594@46B>?' A=HC8<='.5>C;'6 ?'F>55'6?'A=HC8<=',>H495>?K''&;'A=>'M2A45>;6>6;')>@6A>L'.5>C;'F6H;?' 6<64;?A'A=>'H4?:?'!A=>;46;?'E69>'@2'76:4;<'A=>4H'B>94?4C;'@6?>B'C;'B>@6A>K''#>' F6H;?'=4?'68B4>;9>'A=6A'Z8?A'6?'>6?452'6?'6'?I>6:>H'74<=A'H>IH>?>;A'A=>'9C77C;' '74<=A'H>IH>?>;A'=4?'C F;'4;A>H>?A?'\[K[VKN]K''#>'ECH>96?A?'A=>'B>@6A>' @>AF>>;'%4946?'6;B'!594@4 6B>?'4;'A=>'+494546;'>I4?CB> 'F=>H>'%4946?'F45 5'?I>6:'AC' ?>HD>'!A=>;?'\UKWKN] '6;B'!594@46B>?'F455'?I>6:'AC'?>HD>'=47?>5E'\UKPU]K''.5>C;'F6H;?' A=>'!A=>;46;?' _&;'?89='9C;A>?A?'A=>'? A6A>'<4D>?'A=>'H>F6HB?'AC'CA=>H?L'6;B'A6:>?'A=>' B6;<>H?'ECH'=>H?>5E_'\[K[VK[]K''%4946?'F455'8?>'6'?47456H'6H<87>;A'F6H;4;<'A=>' !A=>;46;?' l BC';CA'655CF'=47'AC'764;A64;'=4?'IH4D6A>'?I5>;BCH'6A'=4?'9C8;AH2 0 ?'H4?:L' @8A'H>7>7@>H'A=6A'?89='I>H?C;?'4;Z8H>'A=>'I8@ 549'ECHA8;> m '\UKPNKN]K''"=>?>'F6H;4;C;'6;B'%4946?'6H>'H>I>A4A4C;?'CE'C;>'CE',>H495>? 0 'CF; 'CH4<4;65'9H4A>H46'ECH'6' 5>6B>H '6;B'9C;;>9A',>H495>?'AC'A=>'56A>H'5>6B>H?'A=HC8<='.5>C;'6?'6;'4;A>H7>B46H2K .5>C; 0 ?' 9=6H69A>H4h6A4C;'CE'M2A45>;> 0 ?'6HHC<6;9>'6;B'CD>H9C;E4B>;9>'4;'6' A47>'CE'IHC?I>H4A2'I6H655>5? 'A=>'?>;A47>;A'CE'!A=>;?'B8H4;<'A=>'I>69>'5>6B4;<'8I'AC' A=>'+494546;'>XI>B4A4C;'\UKPPKj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

PAGE 88

85 65H>6B2'@HC8 <=A'655'CE'A=>?>'9C;?4B>H6A4C;?'AC'A=>'H>6B>H^?'6AA>;A4C;'4;'=4?'?I>>9='4;' A=>'M2A45>;6>6;')>@6A>K''1>968?>'CE'A=>'6;A494I6A4C;'<4D>;'AC'A=>'+494546;'>XI>B4A4C;' A=HC8<=',>H495>?L'.5>C;L'6;B'"=892B4B>?^'CF;';6HH6A4D>L'A=>'H>6B>H'=6?';C'BC8@A'6?' AC'A=>'85A47 6A>'C8A9C7>'CE'A=>'>XI>B4A4C;K''(4:>F4?>L'B8>'AC'"=892B4B>?^';6HH6A4D>' A>9=;4J8>L'A=>'H>6B>H'=6?';C'BC8@A'A=6A'A=4?'B>E>6A'=6?'@>>;'968?>B'@2'A=>'B>954;>'CE' !A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4IK %4946?0'IH>B49A4C;?'6H>'6EE4H7>BL'6;B'!594@46B>?0'9C;AH6B49A>BL'@2'A=>'69A865 H>?85A?'CE'A=>'+494546;'$XI>B4A4C;K''3=45>'A=>'!A=>;46;?'6H>'>;<6<>B'4;'+49452L'A=>' +I6HA6;?'?>4h>'A=>'CIICHA8;4A2'AC'@CA= '?>;B'H>4;ECH9>7>;A?'AC'A=>'64B'CE'A=>' B>E>;B4;<'+494546;? '6;B'65?C'AC'?>;B'6;'CEE>;?4D>'ECH9>'AC'>H>9A'6'ECHA'4;'!AA496L'95C?>' AC'!A =>;?'\UKW[]K''!?'6'76AA>H'CE 'E69AL'A=>'+I6HA6;?'6H>'I>H?86B>B'AC'BC'?C'@2';C;>' CA=>H'A=6;'!594@46B>?L'F=C'F6?'>X45>B'EHC7'!A=>;?'ECH'9CHH8IA4C;'6;B'H>54<4C8?' ?96;B65K VP ''"=8? L 'A=>'+I6HA6;?'H>4<;4A>'=C?A454A4>?'F4A='!A=>;?'C;'A=>'764; 56;B '6;B' H>4;ECH9>'A=>' +494546;?L'Z8?A'6?'%4946?'IH>B49A>BL'6;B'!594@46B>?'B>;4>BK''!A'A=>'?67>' A47>L'A=>'!A=>;46;?'>;9C8;A>H'7CH>'H>?4?A6;9>'4 ;'+49452'A=6;'A=>2'96;'CD>H9C7> '6;B' ;>>B'AC'?>;B'=C7>'ECH'H>4;ECH9>7>;A?L'B>?I4A>'655'A=>'>XA>;?4D>'IH>I6H6A4C;?'A=6A' A=>2'8;B>HACC:'C;' 699C8;A'CE'A=>'6BD49>'CE'%4946?K''Q;9>'A=>'+I6HA6;?'6HH4D>'6A'+49452L' A=>'A6@5>?'6H>'A8H;>B'C;'A=>'!A=>;46;?K''*6A=>H'A=6;'@>?4><4;<'A=>'+494546;'94A4>?L'A=>' !A=>;46;?'6H>';CF'ECH9>B'AC'B>E>;B'A=>4H'CF;'IC?4A4C;L'6?'A=>2'6H>'CD>HICF>H>B' @CA='C;'56;B'6;B'?> 6K''!A=>;46;'H>4;ECH9>7>;A? L '5>B'@2')>7C?A=>;>? L '6HH4D>'6EA>H' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''' VP !594@46B>?'BC>?';CA'9C;D4;9>'A=>'+I6HA6;?'AC'4;A>HD>;>'6;B'H>4;ECH9>' +2H698?>L'ECH'A=>2'=6D>' 65H>6B2'@>>;'I56;;4;<'A=4?K''3=6A'!594@46B>?'699C7I54?=>?L'4?'AC'9C;D4;9>'A=>7'AC'?>;B'4A'7CH>' J849:52'A=6;'A=>2'FC85B'CA=>HF4?>K''&;'6BB4A4C;L'=>'6BD4?>?'A=>7'AC'4;D6B>'!AA496L'6;B'>?A6@54?='6' I>H76;>;A'ECHA4E496A4C;';>6H'!A=>;?L'A C'9=655>;<>'!A=>;46;'9C;AHC5'CE'A=>4H'CF;'A>HH4ACH2K''_&;?CE6H'6?' A=>?>'7>6?8H>?'IHCD>B'A8H;4;<'IC4;A?'4;'A=>'F6HL'~!594@46B>?'=47?>5E'96;'@>'9655>B'A=>'9=4>E' 6H9=4A>9A'CE'= 4?'9C8;AH2^?'BCC7 _'G4;5 >2L 'PWU[L'N[PK

PAGE 89

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

PAGE 90

87 .C;958?4C; "=892B4B>?'=6?'IH>?>;A>B'=4?'#4?ACH2'?C'A=6A'E8A8H>'<>;>H6A4C;?'9C85B' B4?9>H;'A=>4H'CF;'5>??C;?'F4A=C8A'789='CE'"=892B4B>? 0 'CF;'CI4;4C;K''12'H>EH64;4;<' EHC7'4;?>HA4;<'ACC'789='CE'=4?'CF;'6;652?4?L'"=892B4B>?'I8A?'A=>'@8HB >;'CE' 6;652h4;<'6;B'Z8B<4;<'A=>'H>56A4C;?=4I'@>AF>>;'B>94?4C;?'6;B'9C;?>J8>;9>?'C;'A=>' H>6B>HK''&;'A=4?'F62L'=>'A>69=>?'A=>'H>6B>H';CA'C;52'A=>'5>??C;?'EHC7'A=>' ,>5CIC;;>?46;'F6HL'@8A'65?C'=CF'AC'9H4A496552'6;652h>'A=>'FCHB?'6;B'B>>B?'CE' 5>6B>H?'4;'=4?'CF; 'B62K''1>968?>'A=>'H>6B>H'=47?>5E'85A476A>52'BH6F?'9C;958?4C;?L' 6;B';CA'"=892B4B>?L'A=>'H>6B>H'762'6II52'A=>'5>??C;?'5>6H;>B'B>?I4A>'B4EE>H>;9>?'4;' =4?'CF;'94H987?A6;9>?K &'=6D>'6;652h>B'"=892B4B>?^'=4?ACH2'F4A='H>?I>9A'AC'=4?'ICHAH6265'CE'!A=>;46;' 5>6B>H ?=4IK''M2'6;652?4?'=6?'H>D>65>B'A=6AL'A=HC8<='A=>'9=6H69A>H?L'"=892B4B>?'=6?' C8A54;>B'A=>'B4EE4985A4>?'A=6A'6'B>7C9H692'E69>?L'6;B'A=>'H>J84H>7>;A?'A=6A'4A?' 5>6B>H?';>>B'AC'7>>A'4;'CHB>H'AC'5>6B'?899>??E8552K''#>'=6?'65?C'IHCD4B>B'B>E4;4A>' >X67I5>?'CE'A=>' 9C;?>J8>;9>?'CE'E6454;<'AC'6BBH>??'A=>?>'B4EE4985A4>?'6;B'E6454;<'AC' 5>6B'?899>??E8552'A=HC8<='A=>'D>H2'>D>;A?'6;B'C8A9C7>'CE'A=>'F6H'4A?>5EK''&'=6D>' 6;652h>B'"=892B4B>?^'=4?ACH2'EHC7'A=>'I>H?I>9A4D>'CE'4;B4D4B865'5>6B>H?'@>968?>L'4;' 72'CI4;4C;L'4A'4?'A=>' ?47I5>?A'AC'5CC:'6A'A=>'ICHAH64A'CE'>69='4;B4D4B865'!A=>;46;' 5>6B>H'F4A=4;'A=>'477>B46A>'9C;A>XA'CE'A=>';6HH6A4D>L'6;B'C;52'6EA>H'6'E4H7'I49A8H>'CE' >69='4;B4D4B865'F4A=4;'>69='A47>'I>H4CB'4?'<>;>H6A>BL'AC'IHC9>>B'AC'A=>'6;652?4?'CE' A=>'@HC6B>H'I49A8H>K''M2 '6;652?4?'4?'9>HA64;52';CA'A=>'C;52'6IIHC69='AC'B>B894;<' "=892B4B>?^'5>??C;L'@8A'&'=CI>'A=6A'4A'F455'@>'6'?84A6@5>'@6?4?'ECH'E8HA=>H'>;J84H2K

PAGE 91

88 &'=6D>'?=CF;'=CF'"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4I'A=HC8<=C8A'A=>' F6H'@2'=4?';6HH6A4D>'A>9=;4J8>K''"=892B4B >?'=6?'BC;>'A=4?'A=HC8<='A=>'4;A>H69A4C;'CE' >69='9=6H69A>H?^'?I>>9=>?'F4A='A=>';6HH6A4D>L'6;B'A=>'4;A>H69A4C;'CE'B4EE>H>;A' 9=6H69A>H?^'?I>>9=>?K''"=892B4B>?'ICHAH62?',>H495>?'6?'A=>'I>6:L'.5>C;'6?'A=>'B>954;>L' 6;B'!594@46B>?'6;B'%4946?'6?'A=>'E6458H>'CE'!A =>;46;'5>6B>H?=4IK''&'=6D>'?=CF;'A=6A' A=>'9=6H69A>H'ICHAH64A?'CE'%4946?'6;B'!594@46B>?'6H>'I6HA49856H52'?AH4:4;968?>' @CA='95>6H52'E85E455'?C7>'CE'A=>'H>J84H>7>;A?'ECH'?AHC;<'5>6B>H?=4IL'6;B'@CA='95>6H52' E645'AC'E85E455'A=>'CIIC?4A>'H>J84H>7>;A?K''%>D> HA=>5>??L'F=45>'A=>4H'E85E4557>;A'CE' 5>6B>H?=4I'9H4A>H46'4?'4;9C7I5>A>L'A=>'9C;?>J8>;9>?'6H>'6A>?AL'6;B'?C'A=>4H'E6458H>' 4?'9C7I5>A>K''M2'9C;958?4C;?'6H>'?4<;4E496;A'6;B'4;A>H>?A4;<'@CA='4;'6;B'CE' A=>7?>5D>?L'6;B'65?C'6?'6'I6HA'CE'A=>'6A>H'F=C5>'CE'" =892B4B>?^'5>??C;?'F4A=4;'A=>' =4?ACH2K "=>'IHC74;>;A'5>??C;L'6?'9C;D>2>B'@2'"=892B4B>?^';6HH6A4D>'A>9=;4J8>L'A=6A'&' =6D>'EC98?>B'C;'=6?'@>>;'A=>'9C7I6H4?C;'CE'A=>'EC8H'764;'!A=>;46;'<>;>H65?' A=HC8<=C8A'A=>'=4?ACH2K''%>D>HA=>5>??'"=892B4B>?'B4B';CA'FH4A>'= 4?'=4?ACH2'>4A=>H'AC' 9C;D>2'A=4?'5>??C;'C;52'4;'A=>';6HHCF'9C;A>XA'CE'=4?'FCH:L'CH'AC'9C;D>2'C;52'A=4?' 5>??C;L'6;B';C'CA=>H?K''"=892B4B>?'5>6B?'8?'6?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC'9C7I6H>'A=>'!A=>;46;' 5>6B>H?'4;'CHB>H'AC'A>69='8?'=CF'AC'9C7I6H>'5>6B>H?'4;'<>;>H65K''"=4?'4 ?'F=6A'=>' 7>6;?'F=>;'=>'95647?'4;'=4?'7>A=CBC5C<2'A=6A'=>'FH4A>?'A=>'>D>;A?'CE'A=>'I6?A'_AC' 64B'4;'A=>'8;B>H?A6;B4;<'CE'A=>'E8A8H>_'\PKNNKS]K'"=892B4B>?'4;D4A>?'A=>'H>6B>H'AC' 9C7I6H>'6;2'5>6B>H'6A'655L';CA'Z8?A'A=>'!A=>;46;?'4;'=4?'CF;'B62L'@2'A=>'9H4A>H46 '=>' C8A54;>?'4;',>H495>?K''"=4?'4?'47ICHA6;AL'@>968?>'4A'76:>?'"=892B4B>?^'5>??C;'789=' B>>I>H'4;'?9CI>'A=6;'4A'FC85B'@>'CA=>HF4?>K

PAGE 92

89 "=892B4B>?'65?C'9CD>2?'5>??C;?'@HC6B>H'4;'?9CI>'A=6;'A=>'C;>'&'=6D>' >X674;>BL'@2'9C7I6H4;<'CA=>H'6?I>9A?'CE'A=>'!A=>;46;'B>9 4?4C; R 76:4;<'IHC9>??L' ?89='6?'A=>4H';6A8H65L'6<??4D>'9=6H69A>HL'H>654?A49'6IIHC69='AC'B4I5C7692L'CH' 47I>H4654?A49'A>;B>;94>?K''"=>?>'6?I>9A?'CE'!A=>;46;'IC5492L'F=49='6H>'?=CF;'AC'=6D>' B>E4;4A>'47I69A'C;'A=>'H>?85A?'CE'=4?ACH2L'762'@>'DC49>B'4;'?I>>9=>? '@2';67>5>??' B>5><6A4C;?'CH'7>??>;<>H?L'6;B'9C7I6H>B'AC'A=>';6HH6A4D>'CE'!A=>;46;'69A4C;'4;' <>;>H65K''M2'CF;'6;652?4?'4?'6;'47ICHA6;A'6;B'4;A>94I=>H4;<'A=>'ACA65' 7>??6<>'CH'5>??C;'"=892B4B>?'9C;D>2?'9C;9>H;4;<'A=>'H>56A4C;?=4I'@>AF>>;'5>6B>H ?' 6;B'A=>'?A6A>L'6;B'5>6B>H?'6;B'A=>'5>BK''%>D>HA=>5>??L'72'6;652?4?'BC>?';CA'9CD>H'A=>' >;A4H>'5>??C;L'F=49='FC85B'@>'4;9C7I5>A>'F4A=C8A'6;'8;B>H?A6;B4;<'CE'655'A=>' E69ACH?'A=6A'I562'6'HC5>'4;'A=>'B>94?4C; R 76:4;<'IHC9>??'CE'A=>'FCH5B^?'E4H?A' B>7C9H692K GC H'A=4?'H>6?C;L'72'6;652?4?'4;'A=4?'A=>?4?'FC85B'<64;'4;'7>6;4;<'6;B' ?4<;4E496;9>'@2'4;A>'CA=>H'5>??C;?'A=6A'"=892B4B>?' ICHAH62?'4;'=4?'FCH:L'4;'I6HA49856HL'A=>'6?I>9A?'CE'!A=>;46;'9=6H69A>H'A=6A'=>' ICHAH62?'6?'I6HA52'H>?IC;?4 @5>'ECH'A=>'B>94?4C;?'A=6A'5>B'AC'!A=>;?^'BCF;E655K''&;' 6BB4A4C;'AC'@>4;<'64B>B'4A?>5EL'72'A=>?4?'=>5I?'AC'@845B'?89='E8HA=>H'6;652?4?'@2' IHCD4B4;<'6'EC8;B6A4C;'6;B'EH67>FCH:'A=6A'=6?'65H>6B2'C8A54;>B'A=>'4;A>H69A4C;?'CE' ?I>94E49'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?'F4A='A=>' 785A4A8B>K''&'=6D>'>?A6@54?=>B'6'?C54B'@6?>'CE' B>B894@5>'4;ECH76A4C;'9C;9>H;4;<'"=892B4B>?^'H>IH>?>;A6A4C;'CE'A=4?'C;>'5>??C;' EHC7'=4?'=4?ACH2L'6;B'=6D>'65?C'C8A54;>B'6'?899>??E85'7>A=CB'CE'4;A>HIH>A4;<' "=892B4B>?^';6HH6A4D>'A>9=;4J8>'AC'B>A>H74;>'A=>'5>?? C;'9C;D>2>B'A=HC8<='6;2'CE' A=>'?I>>9=>?^'4;A>H69A4C;?'F4A='A=>';6HH6A4D>K

PAGE 93

90 !'5C<4965';>XA'?A>I'AC'@845B'8IC;'A=4?'A=>?4?'FC85B'@>'AC'6;652h>'A=>'?I>>9=>?' CE'!A=>;46;?'A=6A'&'=6D>';CA'9CD>H>B'4;'A=>'?67>'F62'6?'&'=6D>'BC;>'72?>5EY'@2' 95C?>52'9C7I6H4;<'A=>'? I>>9=>?'AC'A=>';6HH6A4D>L'6?'F>55'6?'AC'A=>'CA=>H'?I>>9=>?L' 4;958B4;<'A=C?>'F=49='&'=6D>'65H>6B2'6;652h>BK''"=4?'FC85B'BC'789='AC'9H>6A>'6' E855>H'I49A8H>'CE'"=892B4B>?^'5>??C;L'6;B'956H4E2'A=>'HC5>'A=6A'!A=>;46;'5>6B>H?=4I' I562?'4;'A=>'@4<<>H'9C;A>XA'CE'65 5'CE'A=>'=876;'968?>?'CE'!A=>;46;'B>E>6AK''"=>' ?I>>9=>?'A=6A'&'FC85B'H>9C77>;B'AC' 6;652h>'4;958B>'A=>'M>546;'B465C<8>'\jKVS R jKPPP]L'6;B'A=>'!A=>;46;'B>5><6A4C;'AC'+I6HA6'4;'1CC:'C;>'\PKT[ R TV]K ' ' ' '

PAGE 94

91 14@54C52;K' +840B981(<;?($78(J39?8;(.D8(36(.278;1 K'%>F'/CH:Y'.CCI>H'+J86H>' ,8@54?=>H?L'&;9K'PWTOK !H4?ACI=6;>?K' $78(C;0D721 K'SNS'1.K !H4?ACA5>K' =3;1202>203;(36(.278;1 K'96K'[Nj'1.K 1CFH6L'.K'MK' +840B98<;(.278;1 K'"HCF@H4B<>L'345A?=4H>Y'*>BFCCB',H>??'(474A>BL'PWTPK .6HA5>B<>L',685'6;B',6856')>@;6HK' l +I6HA6'6;B'A=>'+I6HA6;?'4;'"=892B4B>?K m K4099 I 1( ( =3H:<;03;(23($7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY'jjW R jVTK .C;;CHL'3K'*C@>HAK' $7>B5?0?81 K',H4;9>AC;Y',H4;9>AC;'-;4D>H?4A2',H>??L'PWVSK )>'*C74552L'o69J8>54;>K' $7>B5?0?81(<;?(.278;0<;("H:840<901H K'"H6;?56A>B'@2',=454I' "=CB2K 'QXECHBY'16?45'1569:F>55L'PWU[K G4;5>2L'oC=;'#K'oHK' $7>B5?0?81 K'!;;'!H@CHY'-;4D>H?4A2'CE'M49=4<6;',H>??L'PWU[K G4;5>2L'MK'&K' +39020B1(0;(278(.;B08;2(/349? K'.67@H4B<>L'(C;BC;L'%>F'/CH:L'%>F' *C9=>55>L'M>5@C8H;>L'+2B;>2Y'.67@H4B<>'-;4D>H?4A2',H>??L'PWV[K kH>;>L')6D4BK' J488L(+39020B<9($78345 K'.=496'-;4D>H?4A2'CE'.=496??L'PWUjK kH4@@5>L')6D4BK' l &;B4D4B865?'4;'"=892B4B>?K m K4099 I 1(=3H:<;03;(23($7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY' S[W R SUVK #6;?>;L'#6HB2'6;B'k>H65B'MK'…84;;K (J488LM(.;(";28;10N8(=3>418 K'% >F'/CH:Y'GCHB=67' -;4D>H?4A2',H>??L'NOOSK #6;?>;L'MC<>;?'#>H76;K' $78(.278;0<;(?8H3B4Y'1569:F>55L'PWWPK #CH;@5CF>HL'+47C;K' $7>B5?0?81 K'165A47CH>Y'oC=;'#CI:4;?'-;4D>H?4A2',H>??L'PWVTK #C?>L'M6HA4;K' l ,>5CIC ;;>?46;'36HY'+C8H9>?'QA=>H'"=6;'"=892B4B>?K m K4099 I 1( ( =3H:<;03;( 23($7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY'UUW R UWOK oC=;?C;L'(68H4>'MK' $7>B5?0?81P(!3QQ81P(<;?(278(";284:482<203;(36(&8<901H K')>u65@Y' %CHA=>H;'&554;C4?'-;4D>H?4A2',H>??L'PWW[K u655>AL'(4?6K' l "=892B4B>?^'3CH:?=CI 'CE'#4?ACH2'6;B'-A454A2K m K4099 I 1(=3H:<;03;(23( ( $7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY'[[j R [UVK

PAGE 95

92 MCHH4?C;L'o67>?'nK' l &;A>H69A4C;'CE'+I>>9='6;B'%6HH6A4D>'4;'"=892B4B>?K m K4099 I 1( ( =3H:<;03;(23($7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY''NjP R NTVK $78(%G634?(=9<110B<9(O0B203;<45 K'$B4A>B'@2'+47C;'#CH;@5CF >H'6;B'!;A=C;2' +I6FECHA=K'[HB'>BK'PWWUK ,56ACK' F8;8G8;>1 K'96K'SOO'1.K *66E568@L'u8HA'!K' l "=892B4B>?'C;')>7C9H692'6;B'Q54<6H9=2K m K4099 I 1(=3H:<;03;(23( ( $7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY'PVW R NNNK *>;<6:C?L'!;AC;4C?K' l "=892B4B>?^'%6HH6A4D>Y'"=>'$I49'6;B'#>HCBCA>6;'#>H4A6<>K m K4099 I 1( =3H:<;03;(23($7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY'NTW R [OOK *C@4;?C;L'.=6H5>?'!5>X6;B>H'oHK' .278;1(0;(278(.D8(36(+840B981 K'%CH76;Y'-;4D>H?4A2'CE' Q:56=C76',H>??L'PWTTK +4;9564HL'"K'!K' .(!012345(36(J488L(+390 20B<9($73>D72 K'(C;BC;Y'*C8A5>B<>'‡'u><6;',685' (ABK'PWjPK +A6=5L'#6;? R ,>A>HK' $7>B5?0?81M(F<; I 1(+9Y'"=>')6D4B'1HCF;' 1CC:'.CK'NOO[K "=C76?L'*C?654;BK' l "=892B4B>?^'&;A>55>9A865'M454>8'6;B'A=>',56<8>K m K4099 I 1( ( =3H:<;03;( 23($7>B5?0?8 1 L'NOOUY'VT R POVK "=892B4B>?L' $78(,<;?H<4L($7>B5?0?81P(.(=3H:4878;10N8(J>0?8(23(278(+893:3;;810<;( ( /<4 K''"H6;?56A>B'@2'*49=6HB'.H6F5>2K'$B4A>B'@2'*C@>HA'1K'+AH6??5>HK'%>F' /CH:L' (C;BC;L'"CHC;ACL'+2B;>2Y'GH>>',H>??L'PWWUK "H692L'+A>I=>;'nK' +840B981 K'1>H:5> 2L'(C?'!;<>5>?L'(C;BC;Y'-;4D>H?4A2'CE'.654ECH;46' ,H>??L'NOOWK "?6:76:4?L'!;AC;4?K' l (>6B>H?L'.HCFB?L'6;B'A=>',CF>H'CE'A=>'&76<>Y',C54A4965' .C778;496A4C;'4;'"=892B4B>?K m K4099 I 1(=3H:<;03;(23($7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY'PUP R PVVK 36H;>HL'*>XK' +840B981($78(.278;0<; K '1C?AC;L'"CHC;ACY'(4AA5>L'1HCF;'6;B'.C7I6;2L' PWU[K i6H>hK' $7>B5?0?81 K',H4;9>AC;'6;B'QXECHBY',H4;9>AC;'-;4D>H?4A2',H>??L'NOOjK i6=H;AL'M49=6>5K' l M69>BC;46'6;B'"=H69>'4;'"=892B4B>?K m K4099 I 1(=3H:<;03;(23( ( $7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY'jVW R UPSK

PAGE 96

93 i6=H;AL'M49=6> 5K' l +49452'6;B'+C8A=>H;'&A652'4;'"=892B4B>?K m K4099 I 1(=3H:<;03;(23( ( $7>B5?0?81 L'NOOUY'UNW R UjjK


ERROR LOADING HTML FROM SOURCE (http://ncf.sobek.ufl.edu//design/skins/UFDC/html/footer_item.html)